diff --git a/modular_skyrat/modules/reagent_forging/code/forge_weapons.dm b/modular_skyrat/modules/reagent_forging/code/forge_weapons.dm
index 1b056d2e160..cdc6a96ef00 100644
--- a/modular_skyrat/modules/reagent_forging/code/forge_weapons.dm
+++ b/modular_skyrat/modules/reagent_forging/code/forge_weapons.dm
@@ -239,22 +239,29 @@
 	. = ..()
 	AddComponent(/datum/component/reagent_weapon)
 
-/obj/item/ammo_casing/arrow/forged
-	desc = "An arrow made of wood, typically fired from a bow. It can be reinforced with sinew."
-	projectile_type = /obj/projectile/bullet/arrow/forged
-
-/obj/item/ammo_casing/arrow/forged/attackby(obj/item/attacking_item, mob/user, params)
+/obj/item/ammo_casing/arrow/attackby(obj/item/attacking_item, mob/user, params)
+	var/spawned_item
 	if(istype(attacking_item, /obj/item/stack/sheet/sinew))
-		var/obj/item/stack/stack_item = attacking_item
-		if(!stack_item.use(1))
-			return
-		new /obj/item/ammo_casing/arrow/ash(get_turf(src))
-		qdel(src)
+		spawned_item = /obj/item/ammo_casing/arrow/ash
+
+	if(istype(attacking_item, /obj/item/stack/sheet/bone))
+		spawned_item = /obj/item/ammo_casing/arrow/bone
+
+	if(istype(attacking_item, /obj/item/stack/tile/bronze))
+		spawned_item = /obj/item/ammo_casing/arrow/bronze
+
+	if(!spawned_item)
+		return ..()
+
+	var/obj/item/stack/stack_item = attacking_item
+	if(!stack_item.use(1))
 		return
-	return ..()
 
-/obj/projectile/bullet/arrow/forged
-	projectile_type = /obj/item/ammo_casing/arrow/forged
+	var/obj/item/ammo_casing/arrow/converted_arrow = new spawned_item(get_turf(src))
+	transfer_fingerprints_to(converted_arrow)
+	remove_item_from_storage(user)
+	user.put_in_hands(converted_arrow)
+	qdel(src)
 
 #define INCREASE_BLOCK_CHANGE 2