🐛 Inaccurate Validation and UI Issues in Constitution Type Proposal Form

[kneerose]

Area

Proposal Pillar

Domain

https://govtool.cardanoapi.io/

Which wallet were you using?

No response

Context

While testing the validation and submission process for the constitution type proposal form, I encountered several issues:

1. Save Draft and Continue Button Visibility:

• The "Save Draft and Continue" button is visible even when the New Constitution URL field is empty, despite it being a required field for this type of proposal.

• Additionally, clicking "Save Draft" or "Submit Proposal" with an empty New Constitution URL field throws an error on the backend-triggered

2. Hide log for production

• log is visible for New Constitution URL, Guardrails Script URL, Guardrails Script Hash
  

3. URL Format Discrepancy:

• URLs without https:// or www. are accepted on the frontend but are rejected by the backend.

4. Save Draft and Continue Button Visibility for Guardrails Script:

• The "Save Draft and Continue" button is visible when the guardrails script data is enabled and the Guardrails Script URL and Guardrails Script hash fields are empty.

Clicking "Save Draft" or "Submit Proposal" with empty guardrails script URL and hash fields throws an error on the backend-triggered

Steps to reproduce

1. Connect to the wallet
2. Navigate to proposals page
3. Open the proposal creation form and select Updates to the Constitution
4. Follow the scenarios mentioned above.

Actual behavior

• Validation on the frontend is inaccurate.
• The UI does not update correctly based on the field values.

Expected behavior

• Proper validation should be enforced for all required fields.
• The UI should reflect the validation states accurately.

[kneerose]

@nebojsact I have updated the PDF version to 0.6.2 locally and verified whether the above changes were applied. However, points 3 and 4 are still reproducible.

3. URL Format Discrepancy:

• The frontend accepts URLs without https:// or www., but the backend rejects them.

4. "Save Draft and Continue" Button Visibility for Guardrails Script:

• The "Save Draft and Continue" button remains visible when the guardrails script data is enabled, even if the Guardrails Script URL and Guardrails Script Hash fields are empty.

CC: @bosko-m

[nebojsact]

It is strange, but I'll check again, I'm pretty sure that I correct this and URL must have protocol (http s or ipfs), for second, Do you like to make both fields mandatory if the box checked?

[bosko-m]

If the checkbox is selected I think both field need to be mandatory @nebojsact .
CC @Ryun1