diff --git a/backends/functional/smtlib.cc b/backends/functional/smtlib.cc index 55efc83c1c2..c496b537591 100644 --- a/backends/functional/smtlib.cc +++ b/backends/functional/smtlib.cc @@ -23,264 +23,379 @@ USING_YOSYS_NAMESPACE PRIVATE_NAMESPACE_BEGIN -const char illegal_characters[] = "$\\"; +const char illegal_characters[] = "#:\\"; const char *reserved_keywords[] = {}; struct SmtScope { - pool used_names; - dict name_map; - FunctionalTools::Scope scope; - SmtScope() : scope(illegal_characters, reserved_keywords) {} - - void reserve(const std::string &name) { used_names.insert(name); } - - std::string insert(IdString id) - { - std::string name = RTLIL::unescape_id(id); - if (used_names.count(name) == 0) { - used_names.insert(name); - name_map[id] = name; - return name; - } - for (int idx = 0;; ++idx) { - std::string new_name = name + "_" + std::to_string(idx); - if (used_names.count(new_name) == 0) { - used_names.insert(new_name); - name_map[id] = new_name; - return new_name; - } - } - } - - std::string operator[](IdString id) - { - if (name_map.count(id)) { - return name_map[id]; - } else { - return insert(id); - } - } + pool used_names; + dict name_map; + FunctionalTools::Scope scope; + SmtScope() : scope(illegal_characters, reserved_keywords) {} + + void reserve(const std::string &name) { used_names.insert(name); } + + std::string insert(IdString id) + { + + std::string name = scope(id); + if (used_names.count(name) == 0) { + used_names.insert(name); + name_map[id] = name; + return name; + } + for (int idx = 0;; ++idx) { + std::string new_name = name + "_" + std::to_string(idx); + if (used_names.count(new_name) == 0) { + used_names.insert(new_name); + name_map[id] = new_name; + return new_name; + } + } + } + + std::string operator[](IdString id) + { + if (name_map.count(id)) { + return name_map[id]; + } else { + return insert(id); + } + } }; struct SmtWriter { - std::ostream &stream; + std::ostream &stream; - SmtWriter(std::ostream &out) : stream(out) {} + SmtWriter(std::ostream &out) : stream(out) {} - void print(const char *fmt, ...) - { - va_list args; - va_start(args, fmt); - stream << vstringf(fmt, args); - va_end(args); - } + void print(const char *fmt, ...) + { + va_list args; + va_start(args, fmt); + stream << vstringf(fmt, args); + va_end(args); + } }; template struct SmtPrintVisitor { - using Node = FunctionalIR::Node; - NodeNames np; - SmtScope &scope; + using Node = FunctionalIR::Node; + NodeNames np; + SmtScope &scope; - SmtPrintVisitor(NodeNames np, SmtScope &scope) : np(np), scope(scope) {} + SmtPrintVisitor(NodeNames np, SmtScope &scope) : np(np), scope(scope) {} - template std::string arg_to_string(T n) { return std::to_string(n); } + template std::string arg_to_string(T n) { return std::to_string(n); } - std::string arg_to_string(std::string n) { return n; } + std::string arg_to_string(std::string n) { return n; } - std::string arg_to_string(Node n) { return np(n); } - - template std::string format(std::string fmt, Args &&...args) - { - std::vector arg_strings = {arg_to_string(std::forward(args))...}; - for (size_t i = 0; i < arg_strings.size(); ++i) { - std::string placeholder = "%" + std::to_string(i); - size_t pos = 0; - while ((pos = fmt.find(placeholder, pos)) != std::string::npos) { - fmt.replace(pos, placeholder.length(), arg_strings[i]); - pos += arg_strings[i].length(); - } - } - return fmt; - } - std::string buf(Node, Node n) { return np(n); } - - std::string slice(Node, Node a, int, int offset, int out_width) - { - return format("(_ extract %1 %2 %0)", np(a), offset, offset + out_width - 1); - } - - std::string zero_extend(Node, Node a, int, int out_width) { return format("((_ zero_extend %1) %0)", np(a), out_width - a.width()); } - - std::string sign_extend(Node, Node a, int, int out_width) { return format("((_ sign_extend %1) %0)", np(a), out_width - a.width()); } - - std::string concat(Node, Node a, int, Node b, int) { return format("(concat %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string add(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvadd %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string sub(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvsub %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string mul(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvmul %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string unsigned_div(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvudiv %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string unsigned_mod(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvurem %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string bitwise_and(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvand %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string bitwise_or(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvor %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string bitwise_xor(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvxor %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string bitwise_not(Node, Node a, int) { return format("(bvnot %0)", np(a)); } - - std::string unary_minus(Node, Node a, int) { return format("(bvneg %0)", np(a)); } - - std::string reduce_and(Node, Node a, int) { return format("(= %0 #b1)", np(a)); } - - std::string reduce_or(Node, Node a, int) - { - std::stringstream ss; - // We use ite to set the result to bit vector, to ensure appropriate type - ss << "(ite (= " << np(a) << " #b" << std::string(a.width(), '0') << ") #b0 #b1)"; - return ss.str(); - } - - std::string reduce_xor(Node, Node a, int) { return format("(bvxor_reduce %0)", np(a)); } - - std::string equal(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(= %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string not_equal(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(distinct %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string signed_greater_than(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvsgt %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string signed_greater_equal(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvsge %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string unsigned_greater_than(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvugt %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string unsigned_greater_equal(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvuge %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string logical_shift_left(Node, Node a, Node b, int, int) { return format("(bvshl %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string logical_shift_right(Node, Node a, Node b, int, int) { return format("(bvlshr %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string arithmetic_shift_right(Node, Node a, Node b, int, int) { return format("(bvashr %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } - - std::string mux(Node, Node a, Node b, Node s, int) { return format("(ite %2 %0 %1)", np(a), np(b), np(s)); } - - std::string pmux(Node, Node a, Node b, Node s, int, int) - { - // Assume s is a bit vector, combine a and b based on the selection bits - return format("(pmux %0 %1 %2)", np(a), np(b), np(s)); - } - - std::string constant(Node, RTLIL::Const value) { return format("#b%1", value.as_string()); } - - std::string input(Node, IdString name) { return format("%0", scope[name]); } - - std::string state(Node, IdString name) { return format("%0", scope[name]); } - - std::string memory_read(Node, Node mem, Node addr, int, int) { return format("(select %0 %1)", np(mem), np(addr)); } - - std::string memory_write(Node, Node mem, Node addr, Node data, int, int) { return format("(store %0 %1 %2)", np(mem), np(addr), np(data)); } - - std::string undriven(Node, int width) { return format("#b%0", std::string(width, '0')); } + std::string arg_to_string(Node n) { return np(n); } + + template std::string format(std::string fmt, Args &&...args) + { + std::vector arg_strings = {arg_to_string(std::forward(args))...}; + for (size_t i = 0; i < arg_strings.size(); ++i) { + std::string placeholder = "%" + std::to_string(i); + size_t pos = 0; + while ((pos = fmt.find(placeholder, pos)) != std::string::npos) { + fmt.replace(pos, placeholder.length(), arg_strings[i]); + pos += arg_strings[i].length(); + } + } + return fmt; + } + std::string buf(Node, Node n) { return np(n); } + + std::string slice(Node, Node a, int, int offset, int out_width) + { + return format("((_ extract %2 %1) %0)", np(a), offset, offset + out_width - 1); + } + + std::string zero_extend(Node, Node a, int, int out_width) { return format("((_ zero_extend %1) %0)", np(a), out_width - a.width()); } + + std::string sign_extend(Node, Node a, int, int out_width) { return format("((_ sign_extend %1) %0)", np(a), out_width - a.width()); } + + std::string concat(Node, Node a, int, Node b, int) { return format("(concat %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } + + std::string add(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvadd %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } + + std::string sub(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvsub %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } + + std::string mul(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvmul %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } + + std::string unsigned_div(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvudiv %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } + + std::string unsigned_mod(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvurem %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } + + std::string bitwise_and(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvand %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } + + std::string bitwise_or(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvor %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } + + std::string bitwise_xor(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { return format("(bvxor %0 %1)", np(a), np(b)); } + + std::string bitwise_not(Node, Node a, int) { return format("(bvnot %0)", np(a)); } + + std::string unary_minus(Node, Node a, int) { return format("(bvneg %0)", np(a)); } + + std::string reduce_and(Node, Node a, int) { + std::stringstream ss; + // We use ite to set the result to bit vector, to ensure appropriate type + ss << "(ite (= " << np(a) << " #b" << std::string(a.width(), '1') << ") #b1 #b0)"; + return ss.str(); + } + + std::string reduce_or(Node, Node a, int) + { + std::stringstream ss; + // We use ite to set the result to bit vector, to ensure appropriate type + ss << "(ite (= " << np(a) << " #b" << std::string(a.width(), '0') << ") #b0 #b1)"; + return ss.str(); + } + + std::string reduce_xor(Node, Node a, int) { + std::stringstream ss; + ss << "(bvxor "; + for (int i = 0; i < a.width(); ++i) { + if (i > 0) ss << " "; + ss << "((_ extract " << i << " " << i << ") " << np(a) << ")"; + } + ss << ")"; + return ss.str(); + } + + std::string equal(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { + return format("(ite (= %0 %1) #b1 #b0)", np(a), np(b)); + } + + std::string not_equal(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { + return format("(ite (distinct %0 %1) #b1 #b0)", np(a), np(b)); + } + + std::string signed_greater_than(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { + return format("(ite (bvsgt %0 %1) #b1 #b0)", np(a), np(b)); + } + + std::string signed_greater_equal(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { + return format("(ite (bvsge %0 %1) #b1 #b0)", np(a), np(b)); + } + + std::string unsigned_greater_than(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { + return format("(ite (bvugt %0 %1) #b1 #b0)", np(a), np(b)); + } + + std::string unsigned_greater_equal(Node, Node a, Node b, int) { + return format("(ite (bvuge %0 %1) #b1 #b0)", np(a), np(b)); + } + + std::string logical_shift_left(Node, Node a, Node b, int, int) { + // Get the bit-widths of a and b + int bit_width_a = a.width(); + int bit_width_b = b.width(); + + // Extend b to match the bit-width of a if necessary + std::ostringstream oss; + if (bit_width_a > bit_width_b) { + oss << "((_ zero_extend " << (bit_width_a - bit_width_b) << ") " << np(b) << ")"; + } else { + oss << np(b); // No extension needed if b's width is already sufficient + } + std::string b_extended = oss.str(); + + // Format the bvshl operation with the extended b + oss.str(""); // Clear the stringstream + oss << "(bvshl " << np(a) << " " << b_extended << ")"; + return oss.str(); + } + + std::string logical_shift_right(Node, Node a, Node b, int, int) { + // Get the bit-widths of a and b + int bit_width_a = a.width(); + int bit_width_b = b.width(); + + // Extend b to match the bit-width of a if necessary + std::ostringstream oss; + if (bit_width_a > bit_width_b) { + oss << "((_ zero_extend " << (bit_width_a - bit_width_b) << ") " << np(b) << ")"; + } else { + oss << np(b); // No extension needed if b's width is already sufficient + } + std::string b_extended = oss.str(); + + // Format the bvlshr operation with the extended b + oss.str(""); // Clear the stringstream + oss << "(bvlshr " << np(a) << " " << b_extended << ")"; + return oss.str(); + } + + std::string arithmetic_shift_right(Node, Node a, Node b, int, int) { + // Get the bit-widths of a and b + int bit_width_a = a.width(); + int bit_width_b = b.width(); + + // Extend b to match the bit-width of a if necessary + std::ostringstream oss; + if (bit_width_a > bit_width_b) { + oss << "((_ zero_extend " << (bit_width_a - bit_width_b) << ") " << np(b) << ")"; + } else { + oss << np(b); // No extension needed if b's width is already sufficient + } + std::string b_extended = oss.str(); + + // Format the bvashr operation with the extended b + oss.str(""); // Clear the stringstream + oss << "(bvashr " << np(a) << " " << b_extended << ")"; + return oss.str(); + } + + std::string mux(Node, Node a, Node b, Node s, int) { + return format("(ite (= %2 #b1) %0 %1)", np(a), np(b), np(s)); + } + + std::string pmux(Node, Node a, Node b, Node s, int, int) + { + // Assume s is a bit vector, combine a and b based on the selection bits + return format("(pmux %0 %1 %2)", np(a), np(b), np(s)); + } + + std::string constant(Node, RTLIL::Const value) { return format("#b%0", value.as_string()); } + + std::string input(Node, IdString name) { return format("%0", scope[name]); } + + std::string state(Node, IdString name) { return format("(%0 current_state)", scope[name]); } + + std::string memory_read(Node, Node mem, Node addr, int, int) { return format("(select %0 %1)", np(mem), np(addr)); } + + std::string memory_write(Node, Node mem, Node addr, Node data, int, int) { return format("(store %0 %1 %2)", np(mem), np(addr), np(data)); } + + std::string undriven(Node, int width) { return format("#b%0", std::string(width, '0')); } }; struct SmtModule { - std::string name; - SmtScope scope; - FunctionalIR ir; - - SmtModule(const std::string &module_name, FunctionalIR ir) : name(module_name), ir(std::move(ir)) {} - - void write(std::ostream &out) - { - SmtWriter writer(out); - - writer.print("(declare-fun %s () Bool)\n", name.c_str()); - writer.print("(declare-datatypes () ((Inputs (mk_inputs"); - for (const auto &input : ir.inputs()) { - std::string input_name = scope[input.first]; - writer.print(" (%s (_ BitVec %d))", input_name.c_str(), input.second.width()); - } - writer.print("))))\n"); - - writer.print("(declare-datatypes () ((Outputs (mk_outputs"); - for (const auto &output : ir.outputs()) { - std::string output_name = scope[output.first]; - writer.print(" (%s (_ BitVec %d))", output_name.c_str(), output.second.width()); - } - writer.print("))))\n"); - - writer.print("(declare-fun state () (_ BitVec 1))\n"); - - writer.print("(define-fun %s_step ((state (_ BitVec 1)) (inputs Inputs)) Outputs", name.c_str()); - writer.print(" (let ("); - for (const auto &input : ir.inputs()) { - std::string input_name = scope[input.first]; - writer.print(" (%s (%s inputs))", input_name.c_str(), input_name.c_str()); - } - writer.print(" )"); - - auto node_to_string = [&](FunctionalIR::Node n) { return scope[n.name()]; }; - SmtPrintVisitor visitor(node_to_string, scope); - - for (auto it = ir.begin(); it != ir.end(); ++it) { - const FunctionalIR::Node &node = *it; - - if (ir.inputs().count(node.name()) > 0) - continue; - - std::string node_name = scope[node.name()]; - std::string node_expr = node.visit(visitor); - - writer.print(" (let ( (%s %s))", node_name.c_str(), node_expr.c_str()); - } - - writer.print(" (let ("); - for (const auto &output : ir.outputs()) { - std::string output_name = scope[output.first]; - const std::string output_assignment = ir.get_output_node(output.first).name().c_str(); - writer.print(" (%s %s)", output_name.c_str(), output_assignment.substr(1).c_str()); - } - writer.print(" )"); - writer.print(" (mk_outputs"); - for (const auto &output : ir.outputs()) { - std::string output_name = scope[output.first]; - writer.print(" %s", output_name.c_str()); - } - writer.print(" )"); - writer.print(" )"); - - // Close the nested lets - for (size_t i = 0; i < ir.size() - ir.inputs().size(); ++i) { - writer.print(" )"); - } - - writer.print(" )"); - writer.print(")\n"); - } + std::string name; + SmtScope scope; + FunctionalIR ir; + + SmtModule(const std::string &module_name, FunctionalIR ir) : name(module_name), ir(std::move(ir)) {} + + void write(std::ostream &out) + { + const bool stateful = ir.state().size() != 0; + SmtWriter writer(out); + + writer.print("(declare-fun %s () Bool)\n\n", name.c_str()); + + writer.print("(declare-datatypes () ((Inputs (mk_inputs"); + for (const auto &input : ir.inputs()) { + std::string input_name = scope[input.first]; + writer.print(" (%s (_ BitVec %d))", input_name.c_str(), input.second.width()); + } + writer.print("))))\n\n"); + + writer.print("(declare-datatypes () ((Outputs (mk_outputs"); + for (const auto &output : ir.outputs()) { + std::string output_name = scope[output.first]; + writer.print(" (%s (_ BitVec %d))", output_name.c_str(), output.second.width()); + } + writer.print("))))\n"); + + if (stateful) { + writer.print("(declare-datatypes () ((State (mk_state"); + for (const auto &state : ir.state()) { + std::string state_name = scope[state.first]; + writer.print(" (%s (_ BitVec %d))", state_name.c_str(), state.second.width()); + } + writer.print("))))\n"); + + writer.print("(declare-datatypes () ((Pair (mk-pair (outputs Outputs) (next_state State)))))\n"); + } + + if (stateful) + writer.print("(define-fun %s_step ((current_state State) (inputs Inputs)) Pair", name.c_str()); + else + writer.print("(define-fun %s_step ((inputs Inputs)) Outputs", name.c_str()); + + writer.print(" (let ("); + for (const auto &input : ir.inputs()) { + std::string input_name = scope[input.first]; + writer.print(" (%s (%s inputs))", input_name.c_str(), input_name.c_str()); + } + writer.print(" )"); + + auto node_to_string = [&](FunctionalIR::Node n) { return scope[n.name()]; }; + SmtPrintVisitor visitor(node_to_string, scope); + + for (auto it = ir.begin(); it != ir.end(); ++it) { + const FunctionalIR::Node &node = *it; + + if (ir.inputs().count(node.name()) > 0) + continue; + + std::string node_name = scope[node.name()]; + std::string node_expr = node.visit(visitor); + + writer.print(" (let ( (%s %s))", node_name.c_str(), node_expr.c_str()); + } + + if (stateful) { + writer.print(" (let ( (next_state (mk_state "); + for (const auto &state : ir.state()) { + std::string state_name = scope[state.first]; + const std::string state_assignment = ir.get_state_next_node(state.first).name().c_str(); + writer.print(" %s", state_assignment.substr(1).c_str()); + } + writer.print(" )))"); + } + + if (stateful) { + writer.print(" (let ( (outputs (mk_outputs "); + for (const auto &output : ir.outputs()) { + std::string output_name = scope[output.first]; + writer.print(" %s", output_name.c_str()); + } + writer.print(" )))"); + + writer.print("(mk-pair outputs next_state)"); + } + else { + writer.print(" (mk_outputs "); + for (const auto &output : ir.outputs()) { + std::string output_name = scope[output.first]; + writer.print(" %s", output_name.c_str()); + } + writer.print(" )"); // Closing mk_outputs + } + if (stateful) { + writer.print(" )"); // Closing outputs let statement + writer.print(" )"); // Closing next_state let statement + } + // Close the nested lets + for (size_t i = 0; i < ir.size() - ir.inputs().size(); ++i) { + writer.print(" )"); // Closing each node + } + + writer.print(" )"); // Closing inputs let statement + writer.print(")\n"); // Closing step function + } }; struct FunctionalSmtBackend : public Backend { - FunctionalSmtBackend() : Backend("functional_smt2", "Generate SMT-LIB from Functional IR") {} + FunctionalSmtBackend() : Backend("functional_smt2", "Generate SMT-LIB from Functional IR") {} - void help() override { log("\nFunctional SMT Backend.\n\n"); } + void help() override { log("\nFunctional SMT Backend.\n\n"); } - void execute(std::ostream *&f, std::string filename, std::vector args, RTLIL::Design *design) override - { - log_header(design, "Executing Functional SMT Backend.\n"); + void execute(std::ostream *&f, std::string filename, std::vector args, RTLIL::Design *design) override + { + log_header(design, "Executing Functional SMT Backend.\n"); - size_t argidx = 1; - extra_args(f, filename, args, argidx, design); + size_t argidx = 1; + extra_args(f, filename, args, argidx, design); - for (auto module : design->selected_modules()) { - log("Processing module `%s`.\n", module->name.c_str()); - auto ir = FunctionalIR::from_module(module); - SmtModule smt(RTLIL::unescape_id(module->name), ir); - smt.write(*f); - } - } + for (auto module : design->selected_modules()) { + log("Processing module `%s`.\n", module->name.c_str()); + auto ir = FunctionalIR::from_module(module); + SmtModule smt(RTLIL::unescape_id(module->name), ir); + smt.write(*f); + } + } } FunctionalSmtBackend; PRIVATE_NAMESPACE_END diff --git a/tests/functional/.gitignore b/tests/functional/.gitignore index 8b20fbedf55..1ffe9926ef6 100644 --- a/tests/functional/.gitignore +++ b/tests/functional/.gitignore @@ -2,4 +2,4 @@ my_module_cxxrtl.cc my_module_functional_cxx.cc vcd_harness *.vcd -*.smt2 \ No newline at end of file +*.smt2 diff --git a/tests/functional/single_cells/run-test.sh b/tests/functional/single_cells/run-test.sh index 11ff1b5ce0b..cc6bcf16086 100755 --- a/tests/functional/single_cells/run-test.sh +++ b/tests/functional/single_cells/run-test.sh @@ -87,6 +87,10 @@ run_smt_test() { run_all_tests() { + declare -A cxx_failing_files + declare -A smt_failing_files + declare -A cxx_successful_files + declare -A smt_successful_files return_code=0 for rtlil_file in rtlil/*.il; do run_cxx_test "$rtlil_file" @@ -134,6 +138,8 @@ run_all_tests() { } run_smt_tests() { + declare -A smt_failing_files + declare -A smt_successful_files return_code=0 for rtlil_file in rtlil/*.il; do run_smt_test "$rtlil_file" diff --git a/tests/functional/single_cells/vcd_harness_smt.py b/tests/functional/single_cells/vcd_harness_smt.py index fd5e94f7e2f..88973eae0d1 100644 --- a/tests/functional/single_cells/vcd_harness_smt.py +++ b/tests/functional/single_cells/vcd_harness_smt.py @@ -76,6 +76,8 @@ declarations = datatype_group[1][1:] # Skip the first item (e.g., 'mk_inputs') if datatype_name == 'Inputs': for declaration in declarations: + print("My declaration") + print(declaration) input_name = declaration[0] bitvec_size = declaration[1][2] inputs[input_name] = int(bitvec_size) @@ -103,7 +105,7 @@ def set_step(inputs, step): define_inputs = f"(define-const test_inputs_step_n{step} Inputs ({mk_inputs_call}))\n" # Create the output definition by calling the gold_step function - define_output = f"(define-const test_outputs_step_n{step} Outputs (gold_step #b0 test_inputs_step_n{step}))\n" + define_output = f"(define-const test_outputs_step_n{step} Outputs (gold_step test_inputs_step_n{step}))\n" smt_commands = [] smt_commands.append(define_inputs) smt_commands.append(define_output)