Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Nested Folders for Archives, Drafts, and Trash. #197

Open
uli-on opened this issue Jun 5, 2023 · 6 comments
Open

Nested Folders for Archives, Drafts, and Trash. #197

uli-on opened this issue Jun 5, 2023 · 6 comments
Labels
discussion enhancement New feature or request

Comments

@uli-on
Copy link

uli-on commented Jun 5, 2023

I can't open archived notes, only select. I believe I remember I could before v2.3.0-beta1. Am I wrong?

@alialbaali
Copy link
Owner

Nope, you're not. If you'd like to modify the note, or read it, you have to unarchive first.

This is part of marking archives simpler, as discussed here #182.

@uli-on
Copy link
Author

uli-on commented Jun 10, 2023

I'd like to outline my deliberations and will come to something a tad off topic.


  • In order to read my archived notes I need to unarchive them.
  • Will I find them in a folder of now 60+ notes? Will have to put them back into the archive.
  • I should have labelled them "archive" before archiving them. Or have them moved into a subfolder of my topic's folder so I could unarchive EDIT: read and edit them without any hassle.
  • And call that folder "Archive".
  • Actually, if I did that I would not have to archive/unarchive them and had all options available to do with them whatever I want.
  • What if every top level folder would be created containing a nested "Archive" folder already?
  • What if it also contained a folder called "Trash"? And one "Drafts"?
  • What if the users could set up a template for the folder set s/he wants created for every top level folder?

Do we need the action-restricted current archives or could nested folders be the solution?

@alialbaali
Copy link
Owner

alialbaali commented Jun 11, 2023

In order to read my archived notes I need to unarchive them.
Will I find them in a folder of now 60+ notes? Will have to put them back into the archive.

Do you need to read & edit archived notes, or just read them? I can implement a way to read the archived notes only, and not edit. Since, I believe it would defeat the purpose of an "Archive".

Regarding your other suggestions, it's a nice concept. However, it needs more studying to be implemented correctly.

@uli-on
Copy link
Author

uli-on commented Jun 20, 2023

Do you need to read & edit archived notes, or just read them?

Well currently I can't do anything with an archived note, so reading would be a step forward. Optimally, we could do with archived notes what we can do with normal ones. But the next step forward would maybe allow to add (and remove) labels to/from notes inside the archive, at least give them a label that allows identification when they're unarchived in their home folder, in order to put them back into the archive after editing them in some way that's possible only outside the archive at that point in time.

Desirable would also be to copy/move them to folders other than their home folder. Generally, everything we can do in real life will be great, and I don't feel adding an annotation to an archived note in real life would be against the idea of an archive.

@uli-on
Copy link
Author

uli-on commented Jun 20, 2023

I don't know what brings more programming effort, whether it happens when a) extending the possibilities of archives or b) when extending the possibilities of nested folders (plus wiring the archive FAB buttons with a folder declared as archive) . Because b) is already possible for the most part, it just needs the possibility to move notes into completely arbitrary folders, which is currently only possible with intermediate steps, as well as the mentioned new wiring (could be assigned to the respective folder's prefs).

@alialbaali alialbaali changed the title Reading in Archives? Nested Folders for Archives, Drafts, and Trash. Jun 26, 2023
@alialbaali alialbaali added enhancement New feature or request discussion labels Jun 26, 2023
@uli-on
Copy link
Author

uli-on commented Jul 15, 2023

Regarding your other suggestions, it's a nice concept. However, it needs more studying to be implemented correctly.

The most important thing it needed right now, in my innocent thinking, is being able to move notes freely around in nested folders: From a surrounding folder "PARENT" into the nested folder "CHILD"/Archive which isn't possible right now! This can only be achieved with a workaround, with the help of an interim folder "PARENT'S SIBLING" and from there into the CHILD/Archive folder, and I think this redundant extra step out of PARENT needed fixing.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
discussion enhancement New feature or request
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants