Toboggan not rendered

[manfredbrandl]

At http://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=17/46.91400/13.86941
there is a toboggan http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/55284714 in the database

and it is not rendered. I think it should be rendered.

There is another one which has the extra tag "highway=raceway" and I suppose that is why its rendered:

See http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/40454225
According to https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Tag:sport=toboggan the extra tag should maybe not be there.

[kocio-pl]

How should it look like in your opinion? It's not obvious to me. We don't render many other sports because of that - golf is an exception.

[HolgerJeromin]

No sport=* and iirc no attraction=* is rendered on its own.
We have no "main" tag here. I would suggest adding tourism=attraction or a leisure tag.
The german wiki suggests adding leisure=track.

raceway is for motor vehicles and is clearly wrong here.

[polarbearing]

leisure=track sounds plausible, so it was a bit short-sighted from the editor of the way cited in the first picture to remove the physical tag from the feature without providing a better one.

[polarbearing]

Tagging has been improved in both cases - but now we depend on Rendering leisure=track on lines #2632 :-(

[manfredbrandl]

@kocio-pl Rendering of a summer toboggan could be a medium dark grey line with dots. It may be be a bit broader than an aerial cableway and the dots (round, not squared?) could be less visible as those of an aerial cableway. But I am not an expert in map designing!

[manfredbrandl]

@kocio-pl I think the rendering should be based on the attraction=summer_toboggan attribute not on sport=toboggan. As sport=* is an non-physical tag it is probably okay not to be rendered. The summer_toboggan is a big and good visible structure.

[manfredbrandl]

@HolgerJeromin leisure=track did not help. Do you think that should be rendered?

[HolgerJeromin]

leisure=track did not help. Do you think that should be rendered?

We have #2632 for that

[manfredbrandl]

So I close my own issue. Thanks.