Termination status of pod is not shown

[gunpuz]

Describe the bug

When pod is being deleted and in kubernetes dashboard it shows that Terminating state, then ListNamespacedPodAsync does not represent this state

Pod Status is not Terminating and its not clear where this terminating state is shown in returned data structure from kubernetes c# client

Kubernetes C# SDK Client Version
e.g. 11.0.44

Server Kubernetes Version
e.g. 1.26.6

Dotnet Runtime Version
e.g. net7

To Reproduce
Delete pod from kubernetes dashboard

Expected behavior
Some indication in returned data, that pod is terminating

[tg123]

see https://kubernetes.io/docs/concepts/workloads/pods/pod-lifecycle/#pod-phase

Note: When a Pod is being deleted, it is shown as Terminating by some kubectl commands. This Terminating status is not one of the Pod phases. A Pod is granted a term to terminate gracefully, which defaults to 30 seconds. You can use the flag --force to terminate a Pod by force.

[gunpuz]

I did not see this info in API, that's why this issue was created, but maybe you can guide me where to look.

[tg123]

here is why you see terminating

https://github.com/kubernetes/kubernetes/blob/d3b7391dc2f1040083ee2a8bfcb02edf7b0ded4b/staging/src/k8s.io/kubectl/pkg/describe/describe.go#L811

[gunpuz]

@tg123 I mean in this kubernetes library, because via Kubernetes dashboard there clearly indication that pod is in process of deletion.

This library:

I serialized k8s.Models.V1Pod. There is deletionTimestamp, but no sign of any Termination state / status....

Kubernetes dashboard (web):

It uses this request:

[tg123]

Terminating is not a real state
sdk will NOT support it

some client shows status = Terminating when pod deletetimestap is set

you can do the same in your own code

[gunpuz]

Ok, thanks for the support. It would be better if there was some aggregated "state / status", but if there is not, then I could make use of deletionTimestamp for now. Thanks 👍!

[tg123]

you can check kubeui's impl
IvanJosipovic/KubeUI@bef4cdb