Help with channel stucked in Opening - thanks in advance #8294

fotongit · 2023-12-19T19:06:36Z

fotongit
Dec 19, 2023

Hello folks, I think I have a similar issue as described in here
#6048

I am worried as I have a very large channel (1btc) opening, it is not progressing (as nothing has been broadcasted) and I fear losing funds if I don't properly manage this.

Your environment
version of lnd - v0.16.4
which operating system (uname -a on *Nix) - Debian - x86_64 GNU/Linux- 8Gb. Mynode
version of btcd, bitcoind, or other backend - Bitcoin Core 25.0

The issue appeared as I tried to open a channel but I had some channels closing unconfirmed, I didn't have enough bitcoin available, hence the channel did not open.

Now all my channels are ok, all the pending transactions are confirmed in the blockchain, but I still have this channel opening as pending:

lncli pendingchannels

{
    "total_limbo_balance": "0",
    "pending_open_channels": [
        {
            "channel": {
                "remote_node_pub": "033d8656219478701227199cbd6f670335c8d408a92ae88b962c49d4dc0e83e025",
                "channel_point": "4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93:1",
                "capacity": "100000000",
                "local_balance": "99996530",
                "remote_balance": "0",
                "local_chan_reserve_sat": "1000000",
                "remote_chan_reserve_sat": "1000000",
                "initiator": "INITIATOR_LOCAL",
                "commitment_type": "ANCHORS",
                "num_forwarding_packages": "0",
                "chan_status_flags": "",
                "private": false
            },
            "commit_fee": "2810",
            "commit_weight": "772",
            "fee_per_kw": "2500"
        }
    ],
    "pending_closing_channels": [
    ],
    "pending_force_closing_channels": [
    ],
    "waiting_close_channels": [
    ]
}

Similar to what was described in issue #6048, but I don't have any limbo balance.

In that issue the user rescanned opening LND and then used abandonchannel to get to a good status.

Would I need to run the reset-wallet-transactions on LND? My channels are now OK, I don't have limbo balance, but I don't know if this needs to be run before the abandonchannel.

Then, he used (from issue 6048): lncli abandonchannel --funding_txid --output_index

what would be my own syntax, would it be

lncli abandonchannel --funding_txid 4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93 --output_index 1

Sorry but as this is 1BTC, I prefer to double check with someone more experienced!

thanks in advance for your help team.

Long live Satoshi

Answered by guggero

Dec 19, 2023

Thanks. Looks like some inputs to the funding transaction also cannot be found... So to make sure they can never be confirmed either, can you please repeat the process (probably just grepping then posting the transaction dump here, no extra restart of lnd required as those probably already have been logged) for those transaction IDs:
08d397514cf3b445229153be843291cf86c811a6459d847aed0fb422b20f5085
74d4efb036c2c63a1e43a94ec7608f73242d3e53eead30bf74d5cbbb8d58c9d3
b3f476b16861b6b7894a4746b0ef459d01022ed7c72947643f45d96aa09c0461

I know it's tedious, but you really want to make sure the transaction can never confirm before abandoning it. Otherwise it gets reeeally complicated to rescue.

View full answer

guggero · 2023-12-19T19:17:21Z

guggero
Dec 19, 2023
Maintainer

Do not abandon! That's dangerous (going to remove the flag from your text to avoid anyone copy/pasting it).

How long ago did you open the channel? If it's been less than two weeks, please see https://docs.lightning.engineering/lightning-network-tools/lnd/unconfirmed-bitcoin-transactions#docs-internal-guid-d7a5497d-7fff-d4c9-e294-cb0cec6c9e86 (section "Channel opening" as well as "Rebroadcast transactions").

11 replies

fotongit Dec 19, 2023
Author

Thanks again for your support.

Tx does NOT appear in lncli listchaintxns.

I restarted LND and this is what I get if I grep on 4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93

sudo more lndlog |grep 4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93
Dec 19 13:36:07 mynode lnd[26385]: 2023-12-19 13:36:07.472 [ERR] FNDG: Unable to advance pending state of ChannelPoint(4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93:1): error waiting for funding confirmation for ChannelPoint(4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93:1): funding manager shutting down
Dec 19 13:36:07 mynode lnd[26385]: 2023-12-19 13:36:07.472 [WRN] FNDG: fundingManager shutting down, stopping funding flow for ChannelPoint(4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93:1)
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.237 [INF] LNWL: Inserting unconfirmed transaction 4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.256 [INF] LNWL: 4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93: broadcast failed because of: double spend: -25: bad-txns-inputs-missingorspent
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.261 [ERR] FNDG: Unable to rebroadcast funding tx 0200000"OFUSCATED"00000000 for ChannelPoint(4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93:1): transaction rejected: output already spent
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.261 [INF] NTFN: New confirmation subscription: conf_id=2, txid=4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93, num_confs=6 height_hint=821988
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.270 [INF] FNDG: Waiting for funding tx (4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93) to reach 6 confirmations
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.320 [INF] NTFN: New spend subscription: spend_id=82, outpoint=4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93:1, script=0 45e710d878153506bd7d1144f7f844a777dbd613b9bd69b889bb4c7c2066d7ba, height_hint=821988
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.320 [INF] NTFN: Dispatching historical spend rescan for outpoint=4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93:1, script=0 45e710d878153506bd7d1144f7f844a777dbd613b9bd69b889bb4c7c2066d7ba, start=821988, end=821990
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.371 [INF] CNCT: Close observer for ChannelPoint(4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93:1) active
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.774 [INF] NTFN: Historical spend dispatch finished for request outpoint=4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93:1, script=0 45e710d878153506bd7d1144f7f844a777dbd613b9bd69b889bb4c7c2066d7ba (start=821988 end=821990) with details:
Dec 19 13:43:21 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:21.546 [INF] CNCT: ChannelArbitrator(4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93:1): starting state=StateDefault, trigger=chainTrigger, triggerHeight=821990
Dec 19 13:43:22 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:22.184 [WRN] CHBU: Replacing disk backup for ChannelPoint(4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93:1) w/ newer version
Dec 19 13:43:22 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:22.861 [INF] PEER: Peer(033d8656219478701227199cbd6f670335c8d408a92ae88b962c49d4dc0e83e025): Loading ChannelPoint(4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93:1), isPending=true
Dec 19 13:43:22 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:22.861 [WRN] PEER: Peer(033d8656219478701227199cbd6f670335c8d408a92ae88b962c49d4dc0e83e025): Unable to find our forwarding policy for channel 4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93:1, using default values

guggero Dec 19, 2023
Maintainer

Can you post the lines directly following Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.237 [INF] LNWL: Inserting unconfirmed transaction 4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93? There should be a whole serialized transaction there. We need to know what inputs it used.

fotongit Dec 19, 2023
Author

There you go; If I am posting something I shouldn't, please delete it!

Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.237 [INF] LNWL: Inserting unconfirmed transaction 4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.256 [INF] LNWL: 4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93: broadcast failed because of: double spend: -25: bad-txns-inputs-missingorspent
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.261 [INF] LNWL: Removed invalid transaction: (*wire.MsgTx)(0xc0059f0f00)({
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Version: (int32) 2,
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: TxIn: ([]*wire.TxIn) (len=11 cap=11) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: (wire.TxIn)(0xc005f8ad80)({
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: PreviousOutPoint: (wire.OutPoint) 08d397514cf3b445229153be843291cf86c811a6459d847aed0fb422b20f5085:0,
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: SignatureScript: ([]uint8) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Witness: (wire.TxWitness) (len=1 cap=1) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: ([]uint8) (len=64 cap=64) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000000 0f 3a 0e bc 26 61 4e 37 f2 88 cc a8 6a 36 e3 9f |.:..&aN7....j6..|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000010 5a c4 bb 94 27 f4 1f a9 fd 39 f6 3e df e9 67 5c |Z...'....9.>..g|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000020 4b fc ac 94 63 13 8a 80 63 32 4e 3d cc 62 1a 3c |K...c...c2N=.b.<|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000030 01 70 72 9f b0 8a 1d ae e7 da 58 2d b5 f4 2a 87 |.pr.......X-...|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Sequence: (uint32) 0
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }),
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: (*wire.TxIn)(0xc005f8ade0)({
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: PreviousOutPoint: (wire.OutPoint) 1262c9f1ddaec548b8536e9664adba194ac6f1ea8e958b6e2c707396ff9da6f8:1,
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: SignatureScript: ([]uint8) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Witness: (wire.TxWitness) (len=1 cap=1) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: ([]uint8) (len=64 cap=64) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000000 23 a0 f8 64 4b 4f 88 09 d0 36 0b ea 6b 9b 9b 7d |#..dKO...6..k..}|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000010 e9 ee e3 58 95 9d c4 26 87 37 4b 9f 93 2c 48 61 |...X...&.7K..,Ha|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000020 64 71 38 fd b0 31 b0 4d 1d e9 27 35 38 16 97 51 |dq8..1.M..'58..Q|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000030 40 65 a9 0f 7a 8b 6f 97 f0 ef a9 72 ab 78 bb 79 |@e..z.o....r.x.y|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Sequence: (uint32) 0
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }),
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: (*wire.TxIn)(0xc005f8ae40)({
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: PreviousOutPoint: (wire.OutPoint) 3b222e20bc9d4d3175242bddf322c7eba95da6be1a996a4617303f030d26209a:27,
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: SignatureScript: ([]uint8) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Witness: (wire.TxWitness) (len=2 cap=2) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: ([]uint8) (len=71 cap=71) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000000 30 44 02 20 68 3b f7 27 e2 28 11 aa 74 a6 39 7f |0D. h;.'.(..t.9.|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000010 1a 9d bc a1 dd 00 d4 53 bf fa c5 93 66 1a 4a 51 |.......S....f.JQ|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000020 23 f8 1c 41 02 20 75 21 d0 fb dc 28 d0 20 34 66 |#..A. u!...(. 4f|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000030 95 fb 55 a5 38 7c 7b 8f 9c 01 6c 07 0a 62 69 5a |..U.8|{...l..biZ|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000040 9b 83 fa 74 1f 71 01 |...t.q.|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: ([]uint8) (len=33 cap=33) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000000 03 d2 c2 f4 48 17 75 46 a0 b4 3b eb d4 94 01 1a |....H.uF..;.....|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000010 53 00 10 f6 b0 1f 75 dc ec 23 21 fa 34 be be 45 |S.....u..#!.4..E|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000020 d7 |.|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Sequence: (uint32) 0
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }),
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: (*wire.TxIn)(0xc005f8aea0)({
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: PreviousOutPoint: (wire.OutPoint) 4b16f0a7522bc909ae3e81dbd2dfad70902d7dff9b55eaa4efe79454c5848a3a:1,
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: SignatureScript: ([]uint8) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Witness: (wire.TxWitness) (len=1 cap=1) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: ([]uint8) (len=64 cap=64) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000000 b5 25 f3 75 f9 67 91 3d 1c ea 9a 54 93 fa 08 8c |.%.u.g.=...T....|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000010 e6 94 55 4d 49 5f ba 5a bf 6e ff dc c5 a9 fb 3f |..UMI_.Z.n.....?|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000020 55 7b 7f 00 18 33 0a bb fb 9b fb f8 54 3a 39 63 |U{...3......T:9c|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000030 89 0c 4c 2b a0 f2 46 af 0a 64 c4 ef 6b cc 3d a5 |..L+..F..d..k.=.|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Sequence: (uint32) 0
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }),
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: (wire.TxIn)(0xc005f8af00)({
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: PreviousOutPoint: (wire.OutPoint) 690e43eda4b797869a9ede50a65bd2aaa67ce824c88de53c9d999296ee370f5c:1,
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: SignatureScript: ([]uint8) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Witness: (wire.TxWitness) (len=1 cap=1) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: ([]uint8) (len=64 cap=64) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000000 30 41 5a eb 38 7d c1 ec 27 2b 9e af 53 d7 39 c9 |0AZ.8}..'+..S.9.|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000010 d8 6e 2a 5e 7e e7 73 8b 80 9d 1c 3b 88 04 1c ae |.n^~.s....;....|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000020 08 ca bb b3 18 db b1 d4 00 ce 35 bf 0e 7b 0a 31 |..........5..{.1|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000030 36 eb c8 86 1f e1 cf f4 4e e0 d1 27 94 2d 84 fa |6.......N..'.-..|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Sequence: (uint32) 0
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }),
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: (*wire.TxIn)(0xc005f8af60)({
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: PreviousOutPoint: (wire.OutPoint) 74d4efb036c2c63a1e43a94ec7608f73242d3e53eead30bf74d5cbbb8d58c9d3:0,
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: SignatureScript: ([]uint8) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Witness: (wire.TxWitness) (len=1 cap=1) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: ([]uint8) (len=64 cap=64) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000000 f6 7d a2 31 ff 72 76 1d dd 5f 57 24 ce da 4e 91 |.}.1.rv..W$..N.|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000010 67 a9 dd e8 50 56 58 97 bc 49 d4 05 68 82 e4 43 |g...PVX..I..h..C|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000020 a7 ab f6 2d 48 01 c9 12 b9 2c d7 11 f5 21 c7 1d |...-H....,...!..|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000030 cd 72 03 6f c5 22 d0 1a c8 0d a6 ba ff 57 ba d4 |.r.o.".......W..|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Sequence: (uint32) 0
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }),
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: (*wire.TxIn)(0xc005f8afc0)({
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: PreviousOutPoint: (wire.OutPoint) 7b0d86f564b4e8f6c7017139bc9fead9a22f8047312f83a4a3343145250559e4:0,
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: SignatureScript: ([]uint8) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Witness: (wire.TxWitness) (len=1 cap=1) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: ([]uint8) (len=64 cap=64) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000000 0a bf 0f b2 3a 28 8e 27 d8 34 ae 82 c9 7a aa 92 |....:(.'.4...z..|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000010 c3 ea f7 b8 00 7d 2f c7 48 71 18 38 e9 76 e8 0d |.....}/.Hq.8.v..|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000020 8e f2 5b a7 c8 6d 17 ae 08 03 63 23 4e 77 43 1b |..[..m....c#NwC.|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000030 0a 35 26 c2 06 79 0d 65 a6 42 65 2b d6 80 67 3d |.5&..y.e.Be+..g=|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Sequence: (uint32) 0
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }),
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: (*wire.TxIn)(0xc005f8b020)({
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: PreviousOutPoint: (wire.OutPoint) 7ea9cbb08129051a72f4e4c82ab0b41b2f4e8ff8b22cb4302217eb2ecd94d772:0,
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: SignatureScript: ([]uint8) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Witness: (wire.TxWitness) (len=1 cap=1) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: ([]uint8) (len=64 cap=64) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000000 60 1f ea 19 ea c9 2c 88 1f 7f 54 a0 b3 ba 8f 4d |.....,...T....M| Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000010 29 67 e7 4d 4d 58 ea 7a d2 ef 3d 9c 7c e7 af c4 |)g.MMX.z..=.|...| Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000020 64 92 3d d2 dc fa 19 63 b5 fa fc 08 00 93 26 b2 |d.=....c......&.| Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000030 36 e0 5c 32 85 a7 7a 93 65 61 bc 16 f1 0c 29 1e |6.\2..z.ea....).| Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: } Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }, Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Sequence: (uint32) 0 Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }), Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: (*wire.TxIn)(0xc005f8b080)({ Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: PreviousOutPoint: (wire.OutPoint) 91f6e542702a2b15c21bc62f9f94a30f63cac81664087fcee5a3f0e058d61159:1, Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: SignatureScript: ([]uint8) { Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }, Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Witness: (wire.TxWitness) (len=1 cap=1) { Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: ([]uint8) (len=64 cap=64) { Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000000 d5 b2 3c da fd 6a 4d 85 a9 8e 67 5a b0 9a 1e 60 |..<..jM...gZ...|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000010 44 da 51 26 ce 42 1c 12 fd 43 82 18 b5 da ce d8 |D.Q&.B...C......|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000020 f0 3b ab 47 ff df 6c f9 d0 24 a0 bc 17 51 af 6d |.;.G..l..$...Q.m|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000030 45 1c b4 55 84 6c 4b be 62 da fa 38 32 18 40 a4 |E..U.lK.b..82.@.|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Sequence: (uint32) 0
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }),
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: (*wire.TxIn)(0xc005f8b0e0)({
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: PreviousOutPoint: (wire.OutPoint) a659d8fd01b47e0248ac87c80eab26fda73264c666314103de958f081d40d2af:0,
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: SignatureScript: ([]uint8) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Witness: (wire.TxWitness) (len=1 cap=1) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: ([]uint8) (len=64 cap=64) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000000 3a ff ca f0 96 21 6a 99 f4 93 aa 19 73 7d c6 1a |:....!j.....s}..|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000010 a2 6a 6e 0d aa d8 ff b8 f8 75 dc fe eb e4 a2 73 |.jn......u.....s|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000020 2e 25 a5 c4 51 e6 4a 3f eb ce 1c 0b 52 6f 30 ee |.%..Q.J?....Ro0.|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000030 5f 8e 70 72 78 83 6d 8e 44 51 62 54 31 6a 02 c3 |.prx.m.DQbT1j..|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Sequence: (uint32) 0
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }),
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: (*wire.TxIn)(0xc005f8b140)({
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: PreviousOutPoint: (wire.OutPoint) b3f476b16861b6b7894a4746b0ef459d01022ed7c72947643f45d96aa09c0461:0,
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: SignatureScript: ([]uint8) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Witness: (wire.TxWitness) (len=1 cap=1) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: ([]uint8) (len=64 cap=64) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000000 f2 c3 b9 36 eb 9c 4d fb 5e f3 b2 24 4b 04 b1 14 |...6..M.^..$K...|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000010 ad 25 fa ec e1 11 d5 e8 b9 3f 63 bb ef 42 72 7d |.%.......?c..Br}|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000020 f0 06 24 4f e8 f0 73 cc 8c 93 1f a6 43 b9 2c a4 |..$O..s.....C.,.|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000030 48 5b 71 83 5e a4 52 47 83 1f 41 74 93 7a 85 32 |H[q.^.RG..At.z.2|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Sequence: (uint32) 0
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: })
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: TxOut: ([]*wire.TxOut) (len=2 cap=2) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: (wire.TxOut)(0xc0059f0f40)({
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Value: (int64) 158350,
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: PkScript: ([]uint8) (len=34 cap=34) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000000 51 20 7a 94 c8 59 ee 4b 5a 32 f7 2a 3f 7e 7a 05 |Q z..Y.KZ2.?~z.|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000010 ca ce e4 9b 03 8c 22 c8 1d a9 2c 18 02 0f 95 7d |......"...,....}|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000020 68 6b |hk|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }),
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: (*wire.TxOut)(0xc0059f0f60)({
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: Value: (int64) 100000000,
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: PkScript: ([]uint8) (len=34 cap=34) {
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000000 00 20 45 e7 10 d8 78 15 35 06 bd 7d 11 44 f7 f8 |. E...x.5..}.D..|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000010 44 a7 77 db d6 13 b9 bd 69 b8 89 bb 4c 7c 20 66 |D.w.....i...L| f|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 00000020 d7 ba |..|
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: }
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: })
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: },
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: LockTime: (uint32) 0
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: })
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.261 [INF] LNWL: Removed invalid transaction: 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
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.261 [ERR] FNDG: Unable to rebroadcast funding tx 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 for ChannelPoint(4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93:1): transaction rejected: output already spent
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.261 [INF] HSWC: HTLC Switch starting
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.261 [INF] NTFN: New confirmation subscription: conf_id=2, txid=4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93, num_confs=6 height_hint=821988
Dec 19 13:43:18 mynode lnd[20433]: 2023-12-19 13:43:18.270 [INF] NTFN: New block epoch subscription

guggero Dec 19, 2023
Maintainer

Thanks. Looks like some inputs to the funding transaction also cannot be found... So to make sure they can never be confirmed either, can you please repeat the process (probably just grepping then posting the transaction dump here, no extra restart of lnd required as those probably already have been logged) for those transaction IDs:
08d397514cf3b445229153be843291cf86c811a6459d847aed0fb422b20f5085
74d4efb036c2c63a1e43a94ec7608f73242d3e53eead30bf74d5cbbb8d58c9d3
b3f476b16861b6b7894a4746b0ef459d01022ed7c72947643f45d96aa09c0461

I know it's tedious, but you really want to make sure the transaction can never confirm before abandoning it. Otherwise it gets reeeally complicated to rescue.

Answer selected by fotongit

fotongit Dec 19, 2023
Author

Hello. Sorry for my late reply I was driving. The only thing I can find in the log about those transactions are the lines that you already saw, there is nothing else in the log with those IDs

fotongit Dec 19, 2023
Author

Also, why did you pick those three? I see there are others (like 1262c9f1ddaec548b8536e9664adba194ac6f1ea8e958b6e2c707396ff9da6f8) also in the log related to 4e27d78c4e4afd967a0cba5dc741a7afa108dce73ee5bfae6a7338646ca8bd93, what makes these three special? (Sorry if this is such a basic question, still learning..)

guggero Dec 19, 2023
Maintainer

Those three transactions also can't be found in public mempools, so they never made it on chain. Not sure how you got into that situation. Are you using a pruned or Neutrino chain backend? Or often use unconfirmed inputs when sending on-chain?

fotongit · 2023-12-19T22:25:02Z

fotongit
Dec 19, 2023
Author

I got into here because one of my peers mutually closed a channel, with a low fee. I had all liquidity on my side, so it was important to me. He then bumped the transaction, but the fee was again small as the fees were going up. When I tried to bump it myself, it failed. So this is when I tried to open a channel, using all my available funds (thinking I was going to spend as well the output of the closing transaction) and this got me in the state I'm currently. The closing transaction eventually was mined, so onchain I am now ok, but the opening transaction remains stuck as you saw. I should have just waited, I know. What would you suggest now? El mar, 19 dic 2023, 23:00, Oliver Gugger ***@***.***> escribió:

…

Those three transactions also can't be found in public mempools, so they never made it on chain. Not sure how you got into that situation. Are you using a pruned or Neutrino chain backend? Or often use unconfirmed inputs when sending on-chain? — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#8294 (reply in thread)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/A3QVQEDHVNCIEO2STMKY6SLYKIFAFAVCNFSM6AAAAABA3VCPHSVHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43SRDJONRXK43TNFXW4Q3PNVWWK3TUHM3TSMBSGI4TK> . You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: ***@***.***>

0 replies

guggero · 2023-12-20T08:42:52Z

guggero
Dec 20, 2023
Maintainer

Okay, so given that lnd isn't attempting to re-publish the "missing" three transactions, I guess you can be reasonably safe that the funding TX will never confirm. So you can run the command you posted originally, the syntax looks correct.

If all funds are accounted for in your wallet balance after that, I think you're fine to continue. If not, you probably need to run with reset-wallet-transactions=true to "find" all your spendable outputs again.

I would suggest to then spend all your coins into a new address (either a new channel with enough fees or just consolidate everything into a new wallet address using lncli sendcoins --sweepall, just to be on the paranoid side), though with fees going crazy again maybe you wait for an opportune moment.

3 replies

fotongit Dec 20, 2023
Author

Thank you so much Guggero. I'll try to fix it all and I'll post here the outcome.

THANK YOU SO MUCH!! Amazing support for the community, really appreciated!

guggero Dec 20, 2023
Maintainer

You're welcome!

fotongit Dec 20, 2023
Author

Ok, so just in case someone goes into a similar issue as I described, after all the checks that @guggero so nicely described, I felt confident to abandon the pending channel. It worked without issue, showing since then no pending channel.

Although my balance looked right, I did a reset-wallet-transactions adding reset-wallet-transactions=true in lnd.conf.

It took close to three hours to rescan the transactions (powerful miniPC with 16gb) but it just finished succesfully.

After that, I paid an incredible :( fee to consolidate all my balance an open a channel sweeping my old UTXOs.

So now everything working as expected!

Thanks again to @guggero for such an amazing support to the community.

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Help with channel stucked in Opening - thanks in advance #8294

{{title}}

{{editor}}'s edit

{{editor}}'s edit

Replies: 3 comments 14 replies

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

Select a reply

Help with channel stucked in Opening - thanks in advance #8294

fotongit Dec 19, 2023

Replies: 3 comments · 14 replies

guggero Dec 19, 2023 Maintainer

fotongit Dec 19, 2023 Author

guggero Dec 19, 2023 Maintainer

fotongit Dec 19, 2023 Author

guggero Dec 19, 2023 Maintainer

fotongit Dec 19, 2023 Author

fotongit Dec 19, 2023 Author

guggero Dec 19, 2023 Maintainer

fotongit Dec 19, 2023 Author

guggero Dec 20, 2023 Maintainer

fotongit Dec 20, 2023 Author

guggero Dec 20, 2023 Maintainer

fotongit Dec 20, 2023 Author

fotongit
Dec 19, 2023

Replies: 3 comments 14 replies

guggero
Dec 19, 2023
Maintainer

fotongit Dec 19, 2023
Author

guggero Dec 19, 2023
Maintainer

fotongit Dec 19, 2023
Author

guggero Dec 19, 2023
Maintainer

fotongit Dec 19, 2023
Author

fotongit Dec 19, 2023
Author

guggero Dec 19, 2023
Maintainer

fotongit
Dec 19, 2023
Author

guggero
Dec 20, 2023
Maintainer

fotongit Dec 20, 2023
Author

guggero Dec 20, 2023
Maintainer

fotongit Dec 20, 2023
Author