Door / window contact naming convention not uniform

[ai-xyz]

Hi,

i thought about adding to the rtl_433_mqtt_hass.py the ability to send auto discovery also for door / window contacts. As far as i can see the naming of the state if the contact is open or closed is different for all the sensors:

honeywell.c -> contact_open
dsc.c-> closed
kerui.c -> opened
simplisafe.c -> state
interlogix.c -> switch1 (i guess)

Is this somehow intended because some sensors are sending additional data or could we add there a naming convention in order to homgenize this type of devices and add the possibility for auto discovery?

[zuckschwerdt]

It's just that so far nobody came forward with a general scheme. There are some quirks to consider with each different device. I guess most users integrating these are interested in a specific sensor only.

[gdt]

I'm calling this is a bug; it seems obvious that naming should be regularized.