diff --git a/Common/src/main/java/mezz/jei/common/input/IInternalKeyMappings.java b/Common/src/main/java/mezz/jei/common/input/IInternalKeyMappings.java
index aa3c55778..303312a0d 100644
--- a/Common/src/main/java/mezz/jei/common/input/IInternalKeyMappings.java
+++ b/Common/src/main/java/mezz/jei/common/input/IInternalKeyMappings.java
@@ -23,6 +23,7 @@ public interface IInternalKeyMappings extends IJeiKeyMappings {
 	IJeiKeyMapping getCloseRecipeGui();
 
 	IJeiKeyMapping getBookmark();
+	IJeiKeyMapping getForceBookmark();
 	IJeiKeyMapping getToggleBookmarkOverlay();
 
 	@Override
diff --git a/Common/src/main/resources/assets/jei/lang/en_us.json b/Common/src/main/resources/assets/jei/lang/en_us.json
index a67ae678f..b603243ff 100644
--- a/Common/src/main/resources/assets/jei/lang/en_us.json
+++ b/Common/src/main/resources/assets/jei/lang/en_us.json
@@ -84,6 +84,7 @@
 
   "jei.key.category.mouse.hover": "JEI (Hovering With Mouse)",
   "key.jei.bookmark": "Add/Remove Bookmark",
+  "key.jei.forceBookmark": "Replace Bookmark",
   "key.jei.showRecipe": "Show Recipe",
   "key.jei.showRecipe2": "Show Recipe",
   "key.jei.showUses": "Show Uses",
diff --git a/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/bookmarks/BookmarkList.java b/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/bookmarks/BookmarkList.java
index f5a63f945..5a7f02499 100644
--- a/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/bookmarks/BookmarkList.java
+++ b/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/bookmarks/BookmarkList.java
@@ -54,8 +54,8 @@ public BookmarkList(
 		this.codecHelper = codecHelper;
 	}
 
-	public boolean add(IBookmark value) {
-		if (!addToListWithoutNotifying(value, clientConfig.isAddingBookmarksToFrontEnabled())) {
+	public boolean add(IBookmark value, boolean shouldForce) {
+		if (!addToListWithoutNotifying(value, clientConfig.isAddingBookmarksToFrontEnabled(), shouldForce)) {
 			return false;
 		}
 		notifyListenersOfChange();
@@ -90,21 +90,26 @@ public boolean contains(IBookmark value) {
 		return this.bookmarksSet.contains(value);
 	}
 
-	public <T> boolean onElementBookmarked(IElement<T> element) {
-		return element.getBookmark()
-			.map(this::remove)
-			.orElseGet(() -> {
-				ITypedIngredient<T> ingredient = element.getTypedIngredient();
-				IBookmark bookmark = IngredientBookmark.create(ingredient, ingredientManager);
-				return add(bookmark);
-			});
+	public <T> boolean onElementBookmarked(IElement<T> element, boolean shouldForceAdd) {
+		boolean didExist = element.getBookmark()
+					.map(this::remove)
+					.orElse(false);
+
+		if(shouldForceAdd || !didExist) {
+			ITypedIngredient<T> ingredient = element.getTypedIngredient();
+			IBookmark bookmark = IngredientBookmark.create(ingredient, ingredientManager);
+			return add(bookmark, shouldForceAdd);
+		}
+		return true;
 	}
 
-	public void toggleBookmark(IBookmark bookmark) {
+	public void toggleBookmark(IBookmark bookmark, boolean shouldAddBack) {
 		if (remove(bookmark)) {
-			return;
+			if(!shouldAddBack) {
+				return;
+			}
 		}
-		add(bookmark);
+		add(bookmark, false);
 	}
 
 	public boolean remove(IBookmark ingredient) {
@@ -131,9 +136,12 @@ public void setFromConfigFile(List<IBookmark> bookmarks) {
 		notifyListenersOfChange();
 	}
 
-	private boolean addToListWithoutNotifying(IBookmark value, boolean addToFront) {
+	private boolean addToListWithoutNotifying(IBookmark value, boolean addToFront, boolean shouldForce) {
 		if (contains(value)) {
-			return false;
+			if(!shouldForce) {
+				return false;
+			}
+			remove(value);
 		}
 		if (addToFront) {
 			bookmarksList.addFirst(value);
diff --git a/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/config/InternalKeyMappings.java b/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/config/InternalKeyMappings.java
index 712baefd9..3d6e59907 100644
--- a/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/config/InternalKeyMappings.java
+++ b/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/config/InternalKeyMappings.java
@@ -32,6 +32,7 @@ public final class InternalKeyMappings implements IInternalKeyMappings {
 	private final IJeiKeyMapping nextPage;
 
 	private final IJeiKeyMapping bookmark;
+	private final IJeiKeyMapping forceBookmark;
 	private final IJeiKeyMapping toggleBookmarkOverlay;
 	private final IJeiKeyMapping transferRecipeBookmark;
 	private final IJeiKeyMapping maxTransferRecipeBookmark;
@@ -128,6 +129,12 @@ public InternalKeyMappings(Consumer<KeyMapping> registerMethod) {
 			.setContext(JeiKeyConflictContext.JEI_GUI_HOVER)
 			.buildKeyboardKey(GLFW.GLFW_KEY_A)
 			.register(registerMethod);
+		// Mouse Hover
+		forceBookmark = mouseHover.createMapping("key.jei.forceBookmark")
+			.setContext(JeiKeyConflictContext.JEI_GUI_HOVER)
+			.setModifier(JeiKeyModifier.SHIFT)
+			.buildKeyboardKey(GLFW.GLFW_KEY_A)
+			.register(registerMethod);
 
 		showRecipe1 = mouseHover.createMapping("key.jei.showRecipe")
 			.setContext(JeiKeyConflictContext.JEI_GUI_HOVER)
@@ -369,6 +376,11 @@ public IJeiKeyMapping getBookmark() {
 		return bookmark;
 	}
 
+	@Override
+	public IJeiKeyMapping getForceBookmark() {
+		return forceBookmark;
+	}
+
 	@Override
 	public IJeiKeyMapping getToggleBookmarkOverlay() {
 		return toggleBookmarkOverlay;
diff --git a/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/input/handlers/BookmarkInputHandler.java b/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/input/handlers/BookmarkInputHandler.java
index 4ece53bdb..d70dcfc1d 100644
--- a/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/input/handlers/BookmarkInputHandler.java
+++ b/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/input/handlers/BookmarkInputHandler.java
@@ -20,18 +20,21 @@ public BookmarkInputHandler(CombinedRecipeFocusSource focusSource, BookmarkList
 
 	@Override
 	public Optional<IUserInputHandler> handleUserInput(Screen screen, UserInput input, IInternalKeyMappings keyBindings) {
-		if (input.is(keyBindings.getBookmark())) {
-			return handleBookmark(input, keyBindings);
+		if (input.is(keyBindings.getForceBookmark())) {
+			return handleBookmark(input, keyBindings, true);
+		}
+		else if (input.is(keyBindings.getBookmark())) {
+			return handleBookmark(input, keyBindings, false);
 		}
 		return Optional.empty();
 	}
 
-	private Optional<IUserInputHandler> handleBookmark(UserInput input, IInternalKeyMappings keyBindings) {
+	private Optional<IUserInputHandler> handleBookmark(UserInput input, IInternalKeyMappings keyBindings, boolean shouldForce) {
 		return focusSource.getIngredientUnderMouse(input, keyBindings)
 			.findFirst()
 			.flatMap(clicked -> {
 				if (input.isSimulate() ||
-					bookmarkList.onElementBookmarked(clicked.getElement())
+					bookmarkList.onElementBookmarked(clicked.getElement(), shouldForce)
 				) {
 					IUserInputHandler handler = new SameElementInputHandler(this, clicked::isMouseOver);
 					return Optional.of(handler);
diff --git a/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/recipes/RecipeBookmarkButton.java b/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/recipes/RecipeBookmarkButton.java
index a66da24c4..23bdd0967 100644
--- a/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/recipes/RecipeBookmarkButton.java
+++ b/Gui/src/main/java/mezz/jei/gui/recipes/RecipeBookmarkButton.java
@@ -87,7 +87,7 @@ protected boolean isIconToggledOn() {
 	protected boolean onMouseClicked(UserInput input) {
 		if (recipeBookmark != null) {
 			if (!input.isSimulate()) {
-				bookmarks.toggleBookmark(recipeBookmark);
+				bookmarks.toggleBookmark(recipeBookmark, false);
 			}
 			return true;
 		}