diff --git a/zheln/Appraisal_Log.md b/zheln/Appraisal_Log.md index ac8c25894..ab107b6be 100644 --- a/zheln/Appraisal_Log.md +++ b/zheln/Appraisal_Log.md @@ -111,3 +111,4 @@ | Dec 18, 2020 | 643 | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | | Dec 19, 2020 | 300 | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | | Dec 20, 2020 | 126 | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | +| Dec 21, 2020 | 696 | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | diff --git a/zheln/Worked_Time_Log.md b/zheln/Worked_Time_Log.md index 4c65c59a9..56ec4f160 100644 --- a/zheln/Worked_Time_Log.md +++ b/zheln/Worked_Time_Log.md @@ -7,4 +7,4 @@ | Wk 49, 2020 | 43h 2m | 48h | | Wk 50, 2020 | 15h 20m | 48h | | Wk 51, 2020 | 26h 26m | 48h | -| Wk 52, 2020 | 0h 22m | 48h | +| Wk 52, 2020 | 3h 37m | 48h | diff --git a/zheln/general-makeposti.sh b/zheln/general-makeposti.sh index d0b463166..ab1056606 100755 --- a/zheln/general-makeposti.sh +++ b/zheln/general-makeposti.sh @@ -1,10 +1,10 @@ #!/bin/bash v='3.1.1' edit=true -date='2020-12-20' -count=126 +date='2020-12-21' +count=696 -coreutils=false +coreutils=true rm_record_set=true summary_set='summary-systematic-set' diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0001-2020-12-21-392.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0001-2020-12-21-392.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..785486708 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0001-2020-12-21-392.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hu H, Feng C, Jiang Z, Wang L, Shrestha S, Yan J, Shu Y, Ge L, Lai W, Hua F, Long H. Effectiveness of remineralizing agents in the prevention and reversal of orthodontically induced white spot lesions: a systematic review and network meta-analysis. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Dec;24(12):4153-4167. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03610-z](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-020-03610-z). Epub 2020 Oct 15. [PMID: 33057826](https://pubmed.gov/33057826)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r392d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0002-2020-12-21-110.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0002-2020-12-21-110.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8ed69fefc --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0002-2020-12-21-110.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Herman JP, Nawreen N, Smail MA, Cotella EM. Brain mechanisms of HPA axis regulation: neurocircuitry and feedback in context Richard Kvetnansky lecture. Stress. 2020 Dec 21:1-16. [doi: 10.1080/10253890.2020.1859475](https://doi.org/10.1080/10253890.2020.1859475). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345670](https://pubmed.gov/33345670)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r110d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0003-2020-12-21-343.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0003-2020-12-21-343.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1932ba1c4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0003-2020-12-21-343.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhang J, He Y, Huang X, Liu Y, Yu H. The effects of acupuncture versus sham/placebo acupuncture for insomnia: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101253. [doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101253](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101253). Epub 2020 Nov 1. [PMID: 33186824](https://pubmed.gov/33186824)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r343d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0004-2020-12-21-221.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0004-2020-12-21-221.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cc59bd23c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0004-2020-12-21-221.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Conte F, Morava E, Bakar NA, Wortmann SB, Poerink AJ, Grunewald S, Crushell E, Al-Gazali L, de Vries MC, Mørkrid L, Hertecant J, Brocke Holmefjord KS, Kronn D, Feigenbaum A, Fingerhut R, Wong SY, van Scherpenzeel M, Voermans NC, Lefeber DJ. Phosphoglucomutase-1 deficiency: Early presentation, metabolic management and detection in neonatal blood spots. Mol Genet Metab. 2020 Sep- Oct;131(1-2):135-146. [doi: 10.1016/j.ymgme.2020.08.003](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ymgme.2020.08.003). Epub 2020 Sep 17. [PMID: 33342467](https://pubmed.gov/33342467)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r221d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0005-2020-12-21-18.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0005-2020-12-21-18.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b0dd2e05d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0005-2020-12-21-18.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Khaing K, Nair BR. Melatonin for delirium prevention in hospitalized patients: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Psychiatr Res. 2020 Dec 13;133:181-190. [doi: 10.1016/j.jpsychires.2020.12.020](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpsychires.2020.12.020). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348252](https://pubmed.gov/33348252)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r18d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0006-2020-12-21-625.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0006-2020-12-21-625.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a81b222f1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0006-2020-12-21-625.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Cavanagh N, Cockett G, Heinrich C, Doig L, Fiest K, Guichon JR, Page S, Mitchell I, Doig CJ. Compassion fatigue in healthcare providers: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Nurs Ethics. 2020 May;27(3):639-665. [doi: 10.1177/0969733019889400](https://doi.org/10.1177/0969733019889400). Epub 2019 Dec 12. [PMID: 31829113](https://pubmed.gov/31829113)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r625d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0007-2020-12-21-514.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0007-2020-12-21-514.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..60e5506f5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0007-2020-12-21-514.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Rogers AM, Brammer JE. Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation and Adoptive Cell Therapy in Peripheral T Cell Lymphoma. Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Aug;15(4):316-332. [doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00590-5](https://doi.org/10.1007/s11899-020-00590-5). [PMID: 32529515](https://pubmed.gov/32529515); [PMCID: PMC7415649](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7415649)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r514d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0008-2020-12-21-342.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0008-2020-12-21-342.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..989322897 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0008-2020-12-21-342.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Shinohara H, Kodera S, Kiyosue A, Ando J, Morita H, Komuro I. Efficacy of Fractional Flow Reserve-Guided Percutaneous Cornary Intervention for Patients with Angina Pectoris. Int Heart J. 2020 Nov 28;61(6):1097-1106. [doi: 10.1536/ihj.20-023](https://doi.org/10.1536/ihj.20-023). Epub 2020 Nov 13. [PMID: 33191337](https://pubmed.gov/33191337)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r342d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0009-2020-12-21-98.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0009-2020-12-21-98.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..62ec2be97 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0009-2020-12-21-98.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Villani LA, Pavalagantharajah S, D'Souza R. Variations in reported outcomes in studies on vasa previa: a systematic review. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 Aug;2(3):100116. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100116](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100116). Epub 2020 Apr 16. [PMID: 33345867](https://pubmed.gov/33345867)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r98d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0010-2020-12-21-281.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0010-2020-12-21-281.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2074e2d87 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0010-2020-12-21-281.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Menon S, Rossi R, Dusabimana A, Zdraveska N, Bhattacharyya S, Francis J. The epidemiology of tuberculosis-associated hyperglycemia in individuals newly screened for type 2 diabetes mellitus: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Infect Dis. 2020 Dec 9;20(1):937. [doi: 10.1186/s12879-020-05512-7](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12879-020-05512-7). [PMID: 33297969](https://pubmed.gov/33297969); [PMCID: PMC7724718](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7724718)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r281d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0011-2020-12-21-537.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0011-2020-12-21-537.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6ba6070ce --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0011-2020-12-21-537.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Toth S, Flohr TR, Schubart J, Knehans A, Castello MC, Aziz F. A meta- analysis and systematic review of venous thromboembolism prophylaxis in patients undergoing vascular surgery procedures. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2020 Sep;8(5):869-881.e2. [doi: 10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.03.017](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.03.017). Epub 2020 Apr 21. [PMID: 32330639](https://pubmed.gov/32330639)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r537d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0012-2020-12-21-621.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0012-2020-12-21-621.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7a000c9e7 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0012-2020-12-21-621.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sulpizio S, Del Maschio N, Fedeli D, Abutalebi J. Bilingual language processing: A meta-analysis of functional neuroimaging studies. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:834-853. [doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.014](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.014). Epub 2019 Dec 12. [PMID: 31838193](https://pubmed.gov/31838193)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r621d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0013-2020-12-21-632.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0013-2020-12-21-632.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d0f3e68ec --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0013-2020-12-21-632.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ding R, Ren J, Li S, Zhu X, Zhang K, Luo W. Domain-general and domain- preferential neural correlates underlying empathy towards physical pain, emotional situation and emotional faces: An ALE meta-analysis. Neuropsychologia. 2020 Feb 3;137:107286. [doi: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2019.107286](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2019.107286). Epub 2019 Nov 28. [PMID: 31786222](https://pubmed.gov/31786222)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r632d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0014-2020-12-21-661.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0014-2020-12-21-661.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..de9e2875d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0014-2020-12-21-661.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘European Association for the Study of the Liver. Electronic address: easloffice@easloffice.eu; Clinical Practice Guideline Panel: Chair:; Panel members:; EASL Governing Board representative:. EASL Clinical Practice Guideline: Occupational liver diseases. J Hepatol. 2019 Nov;71(5):1022-1037. [doi: 10.1016/j.jhep.2019.08.008](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhep.2019.08.008). Epub 2019 Sep 17. [PMID: 31540728](https://pubmed.gov/31540728)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r661d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0015-2020-12-21-511.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0015-2020-12-21-511.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..453ba3807 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0015-2020-12-21-511.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chinna Meyyappan A, Forth E, Wallace CJK, Milev R. Effect of fecal microbiota transplant on symptoms of psychiatric disorders: a systematic review. BMC Psychiatry. 2020 Jun 15;20(1):299. [doi: 10.1186/s12888-020-02654-5](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12888-020-02654-5). [PMID: 32539741](https://pubmed.gov/32539741); [PMCID: PMC7294648](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7294648)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r511d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0016-2020-12-21-368.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0016-2020-12-21-368.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..22d9496e4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0016-2020-12-21-368.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘McNerney NA, Losensky MJ, Lash MM, Rozaieski KR, Ortiz D, Garcia AN, Rethorn ZD. Low theoretical fidelity hinders the research on health coaching for opioid reduction: A systematic review of randomized controlled trials. PLoS One. 2020 Oct 29;15(10):e0241434. [doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0241434](https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0241434). [PMID: 33119705](https://pubmed.gov/33119705); [PMCID: PMC7595321](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7595321)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r368d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0017-2020-12-21-560.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0017-2020-12-21-560.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..26e3d9755 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0017-2020-12-21-560.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ontario Health (Quality). Cell-Free Circulating Tumour DNA Blood Testing to Detect EGFR T790M Mutation in People With Advanced Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer: A Health Technology Assessment. Ont Health Technol Assess Ser. 2020 Mar 6;20(5):1-176. [PMID: 32206157](https://pubmed.gov/32206157); [PMCID: PMC7082730](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7082730)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r560d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0018-2020-12-21-505.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0018-2020-12-21-505.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6787a3663 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0018-2020-12-21-505.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Furness K, Sarkies MN, Huggins CE, Croagh D, Haines TP. Impact of the Method of Delivering Electronic Health Behavior Change Interventions in Survivors of Cancer on Engagement, Health Behaviors, and Health Outcomes: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Med Internet Res. 2020 Jun 23;22(6):e16112. [doi: 10.2196/16112](https://doi.org/10.2196/16112). [PMID: 32574147](https://pubmed.gov/32574147); [PMCID: PMC7381039](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7381039)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r505d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0019-2020-12-21-382.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0019-2020-12-21-382.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..46f0df2d8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0019-2020-12-21-382.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Newland P, Bettencourt BA. Effectiveness of mindfulness-based art therapy for symptoms of anxiety, depression, and fatigue: A systematic review and meta- analysis. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101246. [doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101246](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101246). Epub 2020 Oct 13. [PMID: 33075726](https://pubmed.gov/33075726)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r382d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0020-2020-12-21-479.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0020-2020-12-21-479.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e6a316763 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0020-2020-12-21-479.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kocsis T, Molnár B, Németh D, Hegyi P, Szakács Z, Bálint A, Garami A, Soós A, Márta K, Solymár M. Probiotics have beneficial metabolic effects in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus: a meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials. Sci Rep. 2020 Jul 16;10(1):11787. [doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-68440-1](https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-68440-1). [PMID: 32678128](https://pubmed.gov/32678128); [PMCID: PMC7366719](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7366719)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r479d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0021-2020-12-21-423.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0021-2020-12-21-423.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..14df12f12 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0021-2020-12-21-423.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chisini LA, Cademartori MG, Conde MCM, Tovo-Rodrigues L, Correa MB. Genes in the pathway of tooth mineral tissues and dental caries risk: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3723-3738. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-019-03146-x](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-019-03146-x). Epub 2020 Sep 18. [PMID: 32945961](https://pubmed.gov/32945961)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r423d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0022-2020-12-21-132.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0022-2020-12-21-132.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..83d6aac75 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0022-2020-12-21-132.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Altan E, Seide S, Bayram I, Gizzi L, Ertan H, Röhrle O. A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis on the Longitudinal Effects of Unilateral Knee Extension Exercise on Muscle Strength. Front Sports Act Living. 2020 Nov 16;2:518148. [doi: 10.3389/fspor.2020.518148](https://doi.org/10.3389/fspor.2020.518148). [PMID: 33345109](https://pubmed.gov/33345109); [PMCID: PMC7739592](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7739592)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r132d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0023-2020-12-21-272.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0023-2020-12-21-272.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..af2a30d7a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0023-2020-12-21-272.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Fernández-Jané C, Solà-Madurell M, Yu M, Liang C, Fei Y, Sitjà-Rabert M, Úrrutia G. Completeness of reporting acupuncture interventions for chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: Review of adherence to the STRICTA statement. F1000Res. 2020 Apr 2;9:226. [doi: 10.12688/f1000research.22843.3](https://doi.org/10.12688/f1000research.22843.3). [PMID: 33335712](https://pubmed.gov/33335712); [PMCID: PMC7713895](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7713895)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r272d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0024-2020-12-21-530.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0024-2020-12-21-530.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b82cf7e9c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0024-2020-12-21-530.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Cook J, Muchtar E, Warsame R. Updates in the Diagnosis and Management of AL Amyloidosis. Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Jun;15(3):155-167. [doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00574-5](https://doi.org/10.1007/s11899-020-00574-5). [PMID: 32394186](https://pubmed.gov/32394186)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r530d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0025-2020-12-21-159.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0025-2020-12-21-159.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c28e80e5e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0025-2020-12-21-159.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Demrozi F, Pravadelli G, Bihorac A, Rashidi P. Human Activity Recognition using Inertial, Physiological and Environmental Sensors: A Comprehensive Survey. IEEE Access. 2020;8:210816-210836. [doi: 10.1109/access.2020.3037715](https://doi.org/10.1109/access.2020.3037715). Epub 2020 Nov 16. [PMID: 33344100](https://pubmed.gov/33344100); [PMCID: PMC7748247](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7748247)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r159d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0026-2020-12-21-145.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0026-2020-12-21-145.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e44824492 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0026-2020-12-21-145.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chinen K. Sudden death caused by Clostridium perfringens sepsis presenting as massive intravascular hemolysis. Autops Case Rep. 2020 Jul 30;10(3):e2020185. [doi: 10.4322/acr.2020.185](https://doi.org/10.4322/acr.2020.185). [PMID: 33344302](https://pubmed.gov/33344302); [PMCID: PMC7703123](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7703123)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r145d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0027-2020-12-21-286.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0027-2020-12-21-286.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..716a3e44b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0027-2020-12-21-286.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘De Silva S, Ball AS, Indrapala DV, Reichman SM. Review of the interactions between vehicular emitted potentially toxic elements, roadside soils, and associated biota. Chemosphere. 2021 Jan;263:128135. [doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128135](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128135). Epub 2020 Aug 31. [PMID: 33297123](https://pubmed.gov/33297123)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r286d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0028-2020-12-21-641.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0028-2020-12-21-641.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d4100064b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0028-2020-12-21-641.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Prompahakul C, Epstein EG. Moral distress experienced by non-Western nurses: An integrative review. Nurs Ethics. 2020 May;27(3):778-795. [doi: 10.1177/0969733019880241](https://doi.org/10.1177/0969733019880241). Epub 2019 Nov 21. [PMID: 31750780](https://pubmed.gov/31750780)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r641d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0029-2020-12-21-591.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0029-2020-12-21-591.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..228f4f496 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0029-2020-12-21-591.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Janmohamed A, Sohani N, Lassi ZS, Bhutta ZA. The Effects of Community Home Visit and Peer Group Nutrition Intervention Delivery Platforms on Nutrition Outcomes in Low and Middle-Income Countries: A Systematic Review and Meta- Analysis. Nutrients. 2020 Feb 10;12(2):440. [doi: 10.3390/nu12020440](https://doi.org/10.3390/nu12020440). [PMID: 32050577](https://pubmed.gov/32050577); [PMCID: PMC7071285](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7071285)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r591d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0030-2020-12-21-73.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0030-2020-12-21-73.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e33ca7de3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0030-2020-12-21-73.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Shi M, Gette JA, Gissandaner TD, Cooke JT, Littlefield AK. E-cigarette use among Asian Americans: a systematic review. J Ethn Subst Abuse. 2020 Dec 21:1-34. [doi: 10.1080/15332640.2020.1861495](https://doi.org/10.1080/15332640.2020.1861495). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346722](https://pubmed.gov/33346722)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r73d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0031-2020-12-21-357.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0031-2020-12-21-357.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c4dc06358 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0031-2020-12-21-357.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kashbour W, Gupta P, Worthington HV, Boyers D. Pit and fissure sealants versus fluoride varnishes for preventing dental decay in the permanent teeth of children and adolescents. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 4;11:CD003067. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003067.pub5](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD003067.pub5). [PMID: 33142363](https://pubmed.gov/33142363)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r357d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0032-2020-12-21-358.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0032-2020-12-21-358.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cc5a635b8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0032-2020-12-21-358.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Baugh JJ, White BA, Biddinger PD, Raja AS, Wittbold KA, Sonis JD, Yun BJ. To solve our new emergency care crisis, let's start with the old one. Am J Emerg Med. 2020 Oct;38(10):2000-2001. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajem.2020.06.036](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajem.2020.06.036). Epub 2020 Jun 25. [PMID: 33142164](https://pubmed.gov/33142164); [PMCID: PMC7315955](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7315955)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r358d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0033-2020-12-21-546.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0033-2020-12-21-546.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8b82a03f1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0033-2020-12-21-546.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘d'Alessandro E, Becker C, Bergmeier W, Bode C, Bourne JH, Brown H, Buller HR, Ten Cate-Hoek AJ, Ten Cate V, van Cauteren YJM, Cheung YFH, Cleuren A, Coenen D, Crijns HJGM, de Simone I, Dolleman SC, Klein CE, Fernandez DI, Granneman L, van T Hof A, Henke P, Henskens YMC, Huang J, Jennings LK, Jooss N, Karel M, van den Kerkhof D, Klok FA, Kremers B, Lämmle B, Leader A, Lundstrom A, Mackman N, Mannucci PM, Maqsood Z, van der Meijden PEJ, van Moorsel M, Moran LA, Morser J, van Mourik M, Navarro S, Neagoe RAI, Olie RH, van Paridon P, Posma J, Provenzale I, Reitsma PH, Scaf B, Schurgers L, Seelig J, Siegbahn A, Siegerink B, Soehnlein O, Soriano EM, Sowa MA, Spronk HMH, Storey RF, Tantiwong C, Veninga A, Wang X, Watson SP, Weitz J, Zeerleder SS, Ten Cate H; Scientific Reviewer Committee. Thrombo-Inflammation in Cardiovascular Disease: An Expert Consensus Document from the Third Maastricht Consensus Conference on Thrombosis. Thromb Haemost. 2020 Apr;120(4):538-564. [doi: 10.1055/s-0040-1708035](https://doi.org/10.1055/s-0040-1708035). Epub 2020 Apr 14. [PMID: 32289858](https://pubmed.gov/32289858)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r546d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0034-2020-12-21-81.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0034-2020-12-21-81.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..91034dd6e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0034-2020-12-21-81.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Parmeshwar N, Sultan SM, Kim EA, Piper ML. A Systematic Review of the Utility of Indocyanine Angiography in Autologous Breast Reconstruction. Ann Plast Surg. 2020 Dec 15;Publish Ahead of Print. [doi: 10.1097/SAP.0000000000002576](https://doi.org/10.1097/SAP.0000000000002576). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346549](https://pubmed.gov/33346549)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r81d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0035-2020-12-21-628.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0035-2020-12-21-628.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..41b412092 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0035-2020-12-21-628.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Marzuki AA, Pereira de Souza AMFL, Sahakian BJ, Robbins TW. Are candidate neurocognitive endophenotypes of OCD present in paediatric patients? A systematic review. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:617-645. [doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.010](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.010). Epub 2019 Dec 9. [PMID: 31821834](https://pubmed.gov/31821834)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r628d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0036-2020-12-21-137.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0036-2020-12-21-137.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d5afa6f18 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0036-2020-12-21-137.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hughes RC, Kitsao-Wekulo P, Bhopal S, Kimani-Murage EW, Hill Z, Kirkwood BR. Nairobi Early Childcare in Slums (NECS) Study Protocol: a mixed-methods exploration of paid early childcare in Mukuru slum, Nairobi. BMJ Paediatr Open. 2020 Dec 3;4(1):e000822. [doi: 10.1136/bmjpo-2020-000822](https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjpo-2020-000822). [PMID: 33344785](https://pubmed.gov/33344785); [PMCID: PMC7716665](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7716665)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r137d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0037-2020-12-21-256.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0037-2020-12-21-256.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0deb5992f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0037-2020-12-21-256.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘DelRosso LM, Picchietti DL, Spruyt K, Bruni O, Garcia-Borreguero D, Kotagal S, Owens JA, Simakajornboon N, Ferri R; International Restless Legs Syndrome Study Group (IRLSSG). Restless sleep in children: A systematic review. Sleep Med Rev. 2020 Dec 1;56:101406. [doi: 10.1016/j.smrv.2020.101406](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.smrv.2020.101406). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341437](https://pubmed.gov/33341437)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r256d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0038-2020-12-21-504.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0038-2020-12-21-504.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..602b5af9c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0038-2020-12-21-504.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Rezende Oliveira S, Fernandes Araújo Almeida T, Aparecida da Silva T, Alves Mesquita R, Guimarães Abreu L. Comparison of tissue artifacts in punch and scalpel biopsies of oral and maxillofacial lesions: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Stomatol Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 Dec;121(6):704-712. [doi: 10.1016/j.jormas.2020.06.005](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jormas.2020.06.005). Epub 2020 Jun 20. [PMID: 32574868](https://pubmed.gov/32574868)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r504d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0039-2020-12-21-188.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0039-2020-12-21-188.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..59b1b884c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0039-2020-12-21-188.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kong W, Deng H, Wan J, Zhou Y, Zhou Y, Song B, Wang X. Comparative Remission Rates and Tolerability of Drugs for Generalised Anxiety Disorder: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-analysis of Double-Blind Randomized Controlled Trials. Front Pharmacol. 2020 Nov 11;11:580858. [doi: 10.3389/fphar.2020.580858](https://doi.org/10.3389/fphar.2020.580858). [PMID: 33343351](https://pubmed.gov/33343351); [PMCID: PMC7741609](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7741609)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r188d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0040-2020-12-21-485.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0040-2020-12-21-485.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1ae11b4fa --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0040-2020-12-21-485.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Arca KN, Smith JH, Chiang CC, Starling AJ, Robertson CE, Halker Singh RB, Schwedt TJ, Kissoon NR, Garza I, Rozen TD, Boes CJ, Whealy MA, VanderPluym JH. COVID-19 and Headache Medicine: A Narrative Review of Non-Steroidal Anti- Inflammatory Drug (NSAID) and Corticosteroid Use. Headache. 2020 Sep;60(8):1558-1568. [doi: 10.1111/head.13903](https://doi.org/10.1111/head.13903). Epub 2020 Jul 10. [PMID: 32648592](https://pubmed.gov/32648592); [PMCID: PMC7404408](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7404408)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r485d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0041-2020-12-21-564.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0041-2020-12-21-564.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9d34b9b43 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0041-2020-12-21-564.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ontario Health (Quality). 5-Aminolevulinic Acid Hydrochloride (5-ALA)-Guided Surgical Resection of High-Grade Gliomas: A Health Technology Assessment. Ont Health Technol Assess Ser. 2020 Mar 6;20(9):1-92. [PMID: 32194883](https://pubmed.gov/32194883); [PMCID: PMC7077938](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7077938)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r564d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0042-2020-12-21-660.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0042-2020-12-21-660.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cfad07670 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0042-2020-12-21-660.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Halmai LA, Neilson AR, Kilonzo M. Economic evaluation of interventions for the treatment of asthma in children: A systematic review. Pediatr Allergy Immunol. 2020 Feb;31(2):150-157. [doi: 10.1111/pai.13129](https://doi.org/10.1111/pai.13129). Epub 2019 Dec 3. [PMID: 31571263](https://pubmed.gov/31571263)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r660d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0043-2020-12-21-318.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0043-2020-12-21-318.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f0d540045 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0043-2020-12-21-318.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘de Sévaux JL, Venekamp RP, Lutje V, Hak E, Schilder AG, Sanders EA, Damoiseaux RA. Pneumococcal conjugate vaccines for preventing acute otitis media in children. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 24;11:CD001480. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001480.pub6](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD001480.pub6). [PMID: 33231293](https://pubmed.gov/33231293)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r318d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0044-2020-12-21-402.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0044-2020-12-21-402.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d1cae46b4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0044-2020-12-21-402.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Santiago-Colón A, Daniels R, Reissman D, Anderson K, Calvert G, Caplan A, Carreón T, Katruska A, Kubale T, Liu R, Nembhard R, Robison WA, Yiin J, Howard J. World Trade Center Health Program: First Decade of Research. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020 Oct 6;17(19):7290. [doi: 10.3390/ijerph17197290](https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph17197290). [PMID: 33036199](https://pubmed.gov/33036199); [PMCID: PMC7579473](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7579473)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r402d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0045-2020-12-21-251.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0045-2020-12-21-251.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..33fee0a2b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0045-2020-12-21-251.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Siow I, Lee KS, Zhang JJY, Saffari SE, Ng A, Young B. Stroke as a Neurological Complication of COVID-19: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Incidence, Outcomes and Predictors. J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis. 2020 Dec 15;30(3):105549. [doi: 10.1016/j.jstrokecerebrovasdis.2020.105549](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jstrokecerebrovasdis.2020.105549). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341565](https://pubmed.gov/33341565)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r251d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0046-2020-12-21-329.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0046-2020-12-21-329.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3249e953a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0046-2020-12-21-329.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ipsen EØ, Madsen KS, Chi Y, Pedersen-Bjergaard U, Richter B, Metzendorf MI, Hemmingsen B. Pioglitazone for prevention or delay of type 2 diabetes mellitus and its associated complications in people at risk for the development of type 2 diabetes mellitus. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 19;11:CD013516. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013516.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD013516.pub2). [PMID: 33210751](https://pubmed.gov/33210751)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r329d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0047-2020-12-21-567.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0047-2020-12-21-567.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bb417513b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0047-2020-12-21-567.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Guzdar A, Costello C. Supportive Care in Multiple Myeloma. Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Apr;15(2):56-61. [doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00570-9](https://doi.org/10.1007/s11899-020-00570-9). [PMID: 32172361](https://pubmed.gov/32172361)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r567d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0048-2020-12-21-648.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0048-2020-12-21-648.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..39eadf09c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0048-2020-12-21-648.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Jerger L, Hyams JS. Special considerations for biologic medications in pediatric ulcerative colitis. Expert Opin Biol Ther. 2020 Apr;20(4):429-435. [doi: 10.1080/14712598.2020.1685492](https://doi.org/10.1080/14712598.2020.1685492). Epub 2019 Oct 29. [PMID: 31652087](https://pubmed.gov/31652087)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r648d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0049-2020-12-21-609.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0049-2020-12-21-609.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..eea6b1732 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0049-2020-12-21-609.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Puciło M, Lipski M, Sroczyk-Jaszczyńska M, Puciło A, Nowicka A. The anatomical relationship between the roots of erupted permanent teeth and the mandibular canal: a systematic review. Surg Radiol Anat. 2020 May;42(5):529-542. [doi: 10.1007/s00276-019-02404-7](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00276-019-02404-7). Epub 2020 Jan 3. [PMID: 31900577](https://pubmed.gov/31900577)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r609d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0050-2020-12-21-11.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0050-2020-12-21-11.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7008de971 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0050-2020-12-21-11.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Huang J, Yue N, Wu J, Shi N, Wang Q, Cui T, Zheng M, Sun S, Jin H. Screening rate and influential factors of lung cancer with low-dose computed tomography in Asian population: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Public Health (Oxf). 2020 Dec 22:fdaa225. [doi: 10.1093/pubmed/fdaa225](https://doi.org/10.1093/pubmed/fdaa225). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348356](https://pubmed.gov/33348356)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r11d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0051-2020-12-21-144.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0051-2020-12-21-144.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..15604a8cb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0051-2020-12-21-144.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘He R, Wang L, Li J, Ma L, Wang F, Wang Y. Integrated Analysis of a Competing Endogenous RNA Network Reveals a Prognostic Signature in Kidney Renal Papillary Cell Carcinoma. Front Cell Dev Biol. 2020 Dec 3;8:612924. [doi: 10.3389/fcell.2020.612924](https://doi.org/10.3389/fcell.2020.612924). [PMID: 33344459](https://pubmed.gov/33344459); [PMCID: PMC7744790](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7744790)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r144d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0052-2020-12-21-542.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0052-2020-12-21-542.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..39d8faa16 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0052-2020-12-21-542.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Golden CE, Mishra A. Prevalence of Salmonella and Campylobacter spp. in Alternative and Conventionally Produced Chicken in the United States: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Food Prot. 2020 Jul 1;83(7):1181-1197. [doi: 10.4315/JFP-19-538](https://doi.org/10.4315/JFP-19-538). [PMID: 32294168](https://pubmed.gov/32294168)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r542d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0053-2020-12-21-9.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0053-2020-12-21-9.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..36b75d729 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0053-2020-12-21-9.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Welle R, Seufferlein T, Kratzer W. Die Forschungssituation der Abdomensonografie an den deutschen Universitätskliniken. Eine Längsschnittstudie über 20 Jahre [Current state of research in abdominal ultrasonography at German university hospitals. A panel study over 20 years]. Z Gastroenterol. 2020 Dec 21. German. [doi: 10.1055/a-1332-2589](https://doi.org/10.1055/a-1332-2589). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348406](https://pubmed.gov/33348406)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r9d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0054-2020-12-21-153.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0054-2020-12-21-153.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d92b8c223 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0054-2020-12-21-153.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Patil S, Hedad IA, Jafer AA, Abutaleb GK, Arishi TM, Arishi SA, Arishi HA, Jafer M, Gujar AN, Khan S, Raj AT. Effectiveness of mobile phone applications in improving oral hygiene care and outcomes in orthodontic patients. J Oral Biol Craniofac Res. 2021 Jan-Mar;11(1):26-32. [doi: 10.1016/j.jobcr.2020.11.004](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jobcr.2020.11.004). Epub 2020 Nov 17. [PMID: 33344158](https://pubmed.gov/33344158); [PMCID: PMC7736984](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7736984)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r153d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0055-2020-12-21-355.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0055-2020-12-21-355.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5122bb130 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0055-2020-12-21-355.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Benstoem C, Kalvelage C, Breuer T, Heussen N, Marx G, Stoppe C, Brandenburg V. Ivabradine as adjuvant treatment for chronic heart failure. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 4;11:CD013004. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013004.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD013004.pub2). [PMID: 33147368](https://pubmed.gov/33147368)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r355d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0056-2020-12-21-178.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0056-2020-12-21-178.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1966406eb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0056-2020-12-21-178.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Shen LS, Liu LM, Zheng LH, Hu F, Hu ZC, Liu SY, Guo JR, Bhagat KK, Yao Y. Ablation strategies for arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Geriatr Cardiol. 2020 Nov 28;17(11):694-703. [doi: 10.11909/j.issn.1671-5411.2020.11.001](https://doi.org/10.11909/j.issn.1671-5411.2020.11.001). [PMID: 33343648](https://pubmed.gov/33343648); [PMCID: PMC7729178](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7729178)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r178d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0057-2020-12-21-583.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0057-2020-12-21-583.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8ce6ca4ac --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0057-2020-12-21-583.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bodendorfer BM, Wang DX, McCormick BP, Looney AM, Conroy CM, Fryar CM, Kotler JA, Ferris WJ, Postma WF, Chang ES. Treatment of Pectoralis Major Tendon Tears: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Repair Timing and Fixation Methods. Am J Sports Med. 2020 Nov;48(13):3376-3385. [doi: 10.1177/0363546520904402](https://doi.org/10.1177/0363546520904402). Epub 2020 Feb 28. [PMID: 32109153](https://pubmed.gov/32109153)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r583d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0058-2020-12-21-20.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0058-2020-12-21-20.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4db4b5536 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0058-2020-12-21-20.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Omraninava M, Mehranfar S, Vahedi P, Razi B, Imani D, Aslani S, Feyzinia S. Association between IL7 Receptor Alpha (Il7ra) gene rs6897932 polymorphism and the risk of Multiple Sclerosis: A meta-regression and meta-analysis. Mult Scler Relat Disord. 2020 Dec 15;48:102687. [doi: 10.1016/j.msard.2020.102687](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msard.2020.102687). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348212](https://pubmed.gov/33348212)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r20d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0059-2020-12-21-252.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0059-2020-12-21-252.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ae37a865b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0059-2020-12-21-252.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Alfattni G, Peek N, Nenadic G. Corrigendum to "Extraction of temporal relations from clinical free text: A systematic review of current approaches" [J. Biomed. Inf. 108 (2020) 103488]. J Biomed Inform. 2020 Dec 18;113:103663. [doi: 10.1016/j.jbi.2020.103663](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbi.2020.103663). Epub ahead of print. Erratum for: J Biomed Inform. 2020 Aug;108:103488. [PMID: 33341543](https://pubmed.gov/33341543)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r252d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0060-2020-12-21-336.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0060-2020-12-21-336.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..47affe4b1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0060-2020-12-21-336.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Li H, Hu Y, Tang H, Li S, Ding H, Zhai S, Zhao R. The Potential of Glycyrrhizinate in the Management of COVID-19: A Systematic Review of the Efficacy and Safety of Glycyrrhizin Preparations in the Treatment of SARS and MERS. Am J Chin Med. 2020;48(7):1539-1552. [doi: 10.1142/S0192415X20500767](https://doi.org/10.1142/S0192415X20500767). Epub 2020 Nov 13. [PMID: 33202150](https://pubmed.gov/33202150)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r336d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0061-2020-12-21-206.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0061-2020-12-21-206.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2262463d3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0061-2020-12-21-206.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Siag K, Mazzawi S, Paker M, Biener R, Ghanayim R, Lumelsky D. Acute longus colli tendinitis and otolaryngology. Braz J Otorhinolaryngol. 2020 Dec 5:S1808-8694(20)30214-7. [doi: 10.1016/j.bjorl.2020.10.018](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjorl.2020.10.018). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342696](https://pubmed.gov/33342696)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r206d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0062-2020-12-21-466.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0062-2020-12-21-466.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a3a9687d6 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0062-2020-12-21-466.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Veronese V, Ryan KE, Hughes C, Lim MS, Pedrana A, Stoové M. Using Digital Communication Technology to Increase HIV Testing Among Men Who Have Sex With Men and Transgender Women: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Med Internet Res. 2020 Jul 28;22(7):e14230. [doi: 10.2196/14230](https://doi.org/10.2196/14230). [PMID: 32720902](https://pubmed.gov/32720902); [PMCID: PMC7420634](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7420634)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r466d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0063-2020-12-21-389.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0063-2020-12-21-389.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f6d7fdea2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0063-2020-12-21-389.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Cantini F, Goletti D, Petrone L, Najafi Fard S, Niccoli L, Foti R. Immune Therapy, or Antiviral Therapy, or Both for COVID-19: A Systematic Review. Drugs. 2020 Dec;80(18):1929-1946. [doi: 10.1007/s40265-020-01421-w](https://doi.org/10.1007/s40265-020-01421-w). [PMID: 33068263](https://pubmed.gov/33068263); [PMCID: PMC7568461](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7568461)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r389d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0064-2020-12-21-238.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0064-2020-12-21-238.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9341bfb49 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0064-2020-12-21-238.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Urabe F. Editorial Comment from Dr Urabe to Diagnostic performance of prostate cancer antigen 3 and the Prostate Health Index in detecting overall and clinically significant prostate cancer in men at first biopsy: A meta-analysis. Int J Urol. 2020 Dec 19. [doi: 10.1111/iju.14467](https://doi.org/10.1111/iju.14467). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341976](https://pubmed.gov/33341976)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r238d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0065-2020-12-21-275.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0065-2020-12-21-275.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..68107b103 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0065-2020-12-21-275.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Shevchenko IL, Stoĭko IM, Gudymovich VG, Cherniago TI. Glikokaliks – opredeliaiushchiĭ faktor v razvitii éndotelial'noĭ venoznoĭ disfunktsii i vozmozhnosti ee korrektsii [Glycocalyx as a determining factor in development of endothelial venous dysfunction and possibilities of correction thereof]. Angiol Sosud Khir. 2020;26(4):71-77. Russian. [doi: 10.33529/ANGIO2020404](https://doi.org/10.33529/ANGIO2020404). [PMID: 33332308](https://pubmed.gov/33332308)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r275d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0066-2020-12-21-54.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0066-2020-12-21-54.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..984cad1d2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0066-2020-12-21-54.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bédard A, Lamarche PO, Grégoire LM, Trudel-Guy C, Provencher V, Desroches S, Lemieux S. Can eating pleasure be a lever for healthy eating? A systematic scoping review of eating pleasure and its links with dietary behaviors and health. PLoS One. 2020 Dec 21;15(12):e0244292. [doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0244292](https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0244292). [PMID: 33347469](https://pubmed.gov/33347469)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r54d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0067-2020-12-21-335.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0067-2020-12-21-335.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..eb8629273 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0067-2020-12-21-335.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chiu HC, Ada L, Bania TA. Mechanically assisted walking training for walking, participation, and quality of life in children with cerebral palsy. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 18;11:CD013114. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013114.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD013114.pub2). [PMID: 33202482](https://pubmed.gov/33202482)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r335d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0068-2020-12-21-274.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0068-2020-12-21-274.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0e621d103 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0068-2020-12-21-274.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Deng FC, Wang C, Gu W, Chen YY, Han JJ, Du HM, Peng H, Tang S. [Research advances in the adverse effects of azo dyes]. Zhonghua Yu Fang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2020 Dec 6;54(12):1478-1483. Chinese. [doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn112150-20200114-00020](https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.cn112150-20200114-00020). [PMID: 33333672](https://pubmed.gov/33333672)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r274d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0069-2020-12-21-525.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0069-2020-12-21-525.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..11c2357b1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0069-2020-12-21-525.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Davide M, Hagay S, Michela B, Claudia D, Elisabetta C. The effectiveness of ultrasound examination to assess the healing process of bone lesions of the jaws: a systematic review. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3739-3747. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03339-9](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-020-03339-9). Epub 2020 May 16. Erratum in: Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Dec;24(12):4663. [PMID: 32418014](https://pubmed.gov/32418014)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r525d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0070-2020-12-21-607.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0070-2020-12-21-607.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7001348c7 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0070-2020-12-21-607.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Magri MC, Nunes AKDS, Dantas BP, Manchiero C, Prata TVG, Alves GM, Tengan FM. Meta-Analysis of the Prevalence of HBV Infection Among Alcohol Users Worldwide. Alcohol Alcohol. 2020 Mar 19;55(2):136-143. [doi: 10.1093/alcalc/agz102](https://doi.org/10.1093/alcalc/agz102). [PMID: 31912149](https://pubmed.gov/31912149)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r607d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0071-2020-12-21-317.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0071-2020-12-21-317.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c395fb5eb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0071-2020-12-21-317.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Parry Smith WR, Papadopoulou A, Thomas E, Tobias A, Price MJ, Meher S, Alfirevic Z, Weeks AD, Hofmeyr GJ, Gülmezoglu AM, Widmer M, Oladapo OT, Vogel JP, Althabe F, Coomarasamy A, Gallos ID. Uterotonic agents for first-line treatment of postpartum haemorrhage: a network meta-analysis. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 24;11:CD012754. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012754.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD012754.pub2). [PMID: 33232518](https://pubmed.gov/33232518)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r317d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0072-2020-12-21-106.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0072-2020-12-21-106.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8f7f248c6 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0072-2020-12-21-106.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Green JE, Davis JA, Berk M, Hair C, Loughman A, Castle D, Athan E, Nierenberg AA, Cryan JF, Jacka F, Marx W. Efficacy and safety of fecal microbiota transplantation for the treatment of diseases other than Clostridium difficile infection: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Gut Microbes. 2020 Nov 9;12(1):1-25. [doi: 10.1080/19490976.2020.1854640](https://doi.org/10.1080/19490976.2020.1854640). [PMID: 33345703](https://pubmed.gov/33345703)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r106d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0073-2020-12-21-205.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0073-2020-12-21-205.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..31fac116a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0073-2020-12-21-205.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Borges ALF, Duarte PLES, Almeida RBS, Ledesma ALL, Azevedo YJ, Pereira LV, Bahmad F Jr. Cochlear implant and tinnitus-a meta-analysis. Braz J Otorhinolaryngol. 2020 Dec 8:S1808-8694(20)30215-9. [doi: 10.1016/j.bjorl.2020.11.006](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjorl.2020.11.006). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342697](https://pubmed.gov/33342697)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r205d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0074-2020-12-21-555.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0074-2020-12-21-555.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4bd188c38 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0074-2020-12-21-555.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Regmi K, Jones L. A systematic review of the factors - enablers and barriers - affecting e-learning in health sciences education. BMC Med Educ. 2020 Mar 30;20(1):91. [doi: 10.1186/s12909-020-02007-6](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-020-02007-6). [PMID: 32228560](https://pubmed.gov/32228560); [PMCID: PMC7106784](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7106784)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r555d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0075-2020-12-21-193.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0075-2020-12-21-193.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6b6096a8a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0075-2020-12-21-193.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Weinmann A, Galle PR. Role of immunotherapy in the management of hepatocellular carcinoma: current standards and future directions. Curr Oncol. 2020 Nov;27(Suppl 3):S152-S164. [doi: 10.3747/co.27.7315](https://doi.org/10.3747/co.27.7315). Epub 2020 Nov 1. [PMID: 33343209](https://pubmed.gov/33343209); [PMCID: PMC7739523](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7739523)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r193d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0076-2020-12-21-124.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0076-2020-12-21-124.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..abfc5e62b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0076-2020-12-21-124.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kostopoulou E, Dastamani A, Güemes M, Clement E, Caiulo S, Shanmugananda P, Dattani M, Gilbert C, Hurst JA, Shah P. Syndromic Forms of Hyperinsulinaemic Hypoglycaemia A 15-year follow-up Study. Clin Endocrinol (Oxf). 2020 Dec 20. [doi: 10.1111/cen.14393](https://doi.org/10.1111/cen.14393). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345357](https://pubmed.gov/33345357)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r124d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0077-2020-12-21-362.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0077-2020-12-21-362.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0afb56119 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0077-2020-12-21-362.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bardac OD, Baciu AB, Bogdan-Duică IS. Anal Metastasis from Lung Cancer: Report of a Case and Systematic Review of the Literature. Chirurgia (Bucur). 2020 Sept-Oct;115(5):681-689. [doi: 10.21614/chirurgia.115.5.681](https://doi.org/10.21614/chirurgia.115.5.681). [PMID: 33138907](https://pubmed.gov/33138907)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r362d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0078-2020-12-21-484.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0078-2020-12-21-484.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e3d074cfd --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0078-2020-12-21-484.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Smith TO, Sreekanta A, Walkeden S, Penhale B, Hanson S. Interventions for reducing hospital-associated deconditioning: A systematic review and meta- analysis. Arch Gerontol Geriatr. 2020 Sep-Oct;90:104176. [doi: 10.1016/j.archger.2020.104176](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.archger.2020.104176). Epub 2020 Jul 6. [PMID: 32652367](https://pubmed.gov/32652367)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r484d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0079-2020-12-21-195.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0079-2020-12-21-195.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..68766894a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0079-2020-12-21-195.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Smith SL, Langen WH. A Systematic Review of Mindfulness Practices for Improving Outcomes in Chronic Low Back Pain. Int J Yoga. 2020 Sep- Dec;13(3):177-182. [doi: 10.4103/ijoy.IJOY_4_20](https://doi.org/10.4103/ijoy.IJOY_4_20). Epub 2020 Sep 13. [PMID: 33343146](https://pubmed.gov/33343146); [PMCID: PMC7735497](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7735497)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r195d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0080-2020-12-21-177.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0080-2020-12-21-177.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..86831dfec --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0080-2020-12-21-177.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Senbekov M, Saliev T, Bukeyeva Z, Almabayeva A, Zhanaliyeva M, Aitenova N, Toishibekov Y, Fakhradiyev I. The Recent Progress and Applications of Digital Technologies in Healthcare: A Review. Int J Telemed Appl. 2020 Dec 3;2020:8830200. [doi: 10.1155/2020/8830200](https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/8830200). [PMID: 33343657](https://pubmed.gov/33343657); [PMCID: PMC7732404](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7732404)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r177d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0081-2020-12-21-561.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0081-2020-12-21-561.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..896061d54 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0081-2020-12-21-561.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Muraraneza C, Mtshali N, Bvumbwe T. Challenges in postgraduate research supervision in nursing education: Integrative review. Nurse Educ Today. 2020 Jun;89:104376. [doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2020.104376](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2020.104376). Epub 2020 Feb 21. [PMID: 32203748](https://pubmed.gov/32203748)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r561d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0082-2020-12-21-202.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0082-2020-12-21-202.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..112a71882 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0082-2020-12-21-202.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kiely J, Kumar M, Wade RG. The accuracy of different modalities of perforator mapping for unilateral DIEP flap breast reconstruction: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2020 Dec 10:S1748-6815(20)30670-7. [doi: 10.1016/j.bjps.2020.12.005](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjps.2020.12.005). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342741](https://pubmed.gov/33342741)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r202d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0083-2020-12-21-141.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0083-2020-12-21-141.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..af7d0af0b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0083-2020-12-21-141.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Pang QL, He WC, Li JX, Huang L. Symptomatic and optimal supportive care of critical COVID-19: A case report and literature review. World J Clin Cases. 2020 Dec 6;8(23):6181-6189. [doi: 10.12998/wjcc.v8.i23.6181](https://doi.org/10.12998/wjcc.v8.i23.6181). [PMID: 33344621](https://pubmed.gov/33344621); [PMCID: PMC7723689](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7723689)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r141d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0084-2020-12-21-584.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0084-2020-12-21-584.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..27281bbdb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0084-2020-12-21-584.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lee JC, Lamanna N. Is There a Role for Chemotherapy in the Era of Targeted Therapies? Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Apr;15(2):72-82. [doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00563-8](https://doi.org/10.1007/s11899-020-00563-8). [PMID: 32107713](https://pubmed.gov/32107713)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r584d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0085-2020-12-21-489.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0085-2020-12-21-489.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f095ef2f7 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0085-2020-12-21-489.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Morales J, Shubrook JH, Skolnik N. Practical guidance for use of oral semaglutide in primary care: a narrative review. Postgrad Med. 2020 Nov;132(8):687-696. [doi: 10.1080/00325481.2020.1788340](https://doi.org/10.1080/00325481.2020.1788340). Epub 2020 Jul 9. [PMID: 32643514](https://pubmed.gov/32643514)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r489d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0086-2020-12-21-233.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0086-2020-12-21-233.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f6e160361 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0086-2020-12-21-233.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhou YP, Yang M, Yao PT, Ge YB, Tang W, Wen Y, Lyu ZY, Tan FW, Sun X, Li F, Li J, Li N. [Quality assessment of guidelines and consensus in lung cancer chemotherapy]. Zhonghua Zhong Liu Za Zhi. 2020 Dec 23;42(12):1025-1033. Chinese. [doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn112152-20190508-00293](https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.cn112152-20190508-00293). [PMID: 33342159](https://pubmed.gov/33342159)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r233d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0087-2020-12-21-190.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0087-2020-12-21-190.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..781610261 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0087-2020-12-21-190.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Xiang X, He Q, Ou Y, Wang W, Wu Y. Efficacy and Safety of CAR-Modified T Cell Therapy in Patients with Relapsed or Refractory Multiple Myeloma: A Meta- Analysis of Prospective Clinical Trials. Front Pharmacol. 2020 Dec 3;11:544754. [doi: 10.3389/fphar.2020.544754](https://doi.org/10.3389/fphar.2020.544754). [PMID: 33343342](https://pubmed.gov/33343342); [PMCID: PMC7744881](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7744881)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r190d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0088-2020-12-21-283.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0088-2020-12-21-283.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..72ad5dd0f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0088-2020-12-21-283.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lai SY, Ng KH, Cheng CK, Nur H, Nurhadi M, Arumugam M. Photocatalytic remediation of organic waste over Keggin-based polyoxometalate materials: A review. Chemosphere. 2021 Jan;263:128244. [doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128244](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128244). Epub 2020 Sep 6. [PMID: 33297191](https://pubmed.gov/33297191)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r283d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0089-2020-12-21-483.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0089-2020-12-21-483.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f0b92d5c3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0089-2020-12-21-483.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Rodriguez Socarrás M, Loeb S, Teoh JY, Ribal MJ, Bloemberg J, Catto J, N'Dow J, Van Poppel H, Gómez Rivas J. Telemedicine and Smart Working: Recommendations of the European Association of Urology. Eur Urol. 2020 Dec;78(6):812-819. [doi: 10.1016/j.eururo.2020.06.031](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eururo.2020.06.031). Epub 2020 Jul 10. [PMID: 32654801](https://pubmed.gov/32654801); [PMCID: PMC7347487](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7347487)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r483d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0090-2020-12-21-276.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0090-2020-12-21-276.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9f09ad987 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0090-2020-12-21-276.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Melo CFCAE, Vasconcelos PFDC, Alcantara LCJ, Araujo WN. The obscurance of the greatest sylvatic yellow fever epidemic and the cooperation of the Pan American Health Organization during the COVID-19 pandemic. Rev Soc Bras Med Trop. 2020 Dec 11;53:e20200787. [doi: 10.1590/0037-8682-0787-2020](https://doi.org/10.1590/0037-8682-0787-2020). [PMID: 33331614](https://pubmed.gov/33331614); [PMCID: PMC7747828](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7747828)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r276d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0091-2020-12-21-596.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0091-2020-12-21-596.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..728cef5e8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0091-2020-12-21-596.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hunter BD, Chen YB. Current Approaches to Transplantation for FLT3-ITD AML. Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Feb;15(1):1-8. [doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00558-5](https://doi.org/10.1007/s11899-020-00558-5). [PMID: 32034660](https://pubmed.gov/32034660)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r596d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0092-2020-12-21-603.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0092-2020-12-21-603.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..07bbf56a8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0092-2020-12-21-603.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sarris J, Sinclair J, Karamacoska D, Davidson M, Firth J. Medicinal cannabis for psychiatric disorders: a clinically-focused systematic review. BMC Psychiatry. 2020 Jan 16;20(1):24. [doi: 10.1186/s12888-019-2409-8](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12888-019-2409-8). [PMID: 31948424](https://pubmed.gov/31948424); [PMCID: PMC6966847](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC6966847)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r603d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0093-2020-12-21-352.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0093-2020-12-21-352.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..94a02d2ed --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0093-2020-12-21-352.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Uhlig K, Efremov L, Tongers J, Frantz S, Mikolajczyk R, Sedding D, Schumann J. Inotropic agents and vasodilator strategies for the treatment of cardiogenic shock or low cardiac output syndrome. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 5;11:CD009669. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009669.pub4](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD009669.pub4). [PMID: 33152122](https://pubmed.gov/33152122)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r352d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0094-2020-12-21-630.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0094-2020-12-21-630.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..59c401d0c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0094-2020-12-21-630.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Cotelli M, Manenti R, Ferrari C, Gobbi E, Macis A, Cappa SF. Effectiveness of language training and non-invasive brain stimulation on oral and written naming performance in Primary Progressive Aphasia: A meta-analysis and systematic review. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:498-525. [doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.003](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.003). Epub 2019 Dec 4. [PMID: 31811834](https://pubmed.gov/31811834)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r630d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0095-2020-12-21-70.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0095-2020-12-21-70.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..792789de2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0095-2020-12-21-70.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Wirries N, Budde S. Der Oberflächenteilersatz an der Hüfte – eine kritische Analyse [Partial hip resurfacing-a critical analysis]. Orthopade. 2020 Dec 21. German. [doi: 10.1007/s00132-020-04056-7](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00132-020-04056-7). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346866](https://pubmed.gov/33346866)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r70d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0096-2020-12-21-610.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0096-2020-12-21-610.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..21c948a74 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0096-2020-12-21-610.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Acharya P, Mathur MC. Oxidative stress in alopecia areata: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Dermatol. 2020 Apr;59(4):434-440. [doi: 10.1111/ijd.14753](https://doi.org/10.1111/ijd.14753). Epub 2019 Dec 26. [PMID: 31875951](https://pubmed.gov/31875951)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r610d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0097-2020-12-21-456.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0097-2020-12-21-456.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8027ecbb9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0097-2020-12-21-456.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Davies A, Mueller J, Moulton G. Core competencies for clinical informaticians: A systematic review. Int J Med Inform. 2020 Sep;141:104237. [doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104237](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104237). Epub 2020 Jul 24. [PMID: 32771960](https://pubmed.gov/32771960)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r456d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0098-2020-12-21-339.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0098-2020-12-21-339.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e89cbf5a4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0098-2020-12-21-339.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lazarus JV, Palayew A, Rasmussen LN, Andersen TH, Nicholson J, Norgaard O. Searching PubMed to Retrieve Publications on the COVID-19 Pandemic: Comparative Analysis of Search Strings. J Med Internet Res. 2020 Nov 26;22(11):e23449. [doi: 10.2196/23449](https://doi.org/10.2196/23449). [PMID: 33197230](https://pubmed.gov/33197230); [PMCID: PMC7695541](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7695541)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r339d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0099-2020-12-21-457.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0099-2020-12-21-457.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..737acbb1a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0099-2020-12-21-457.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Conover ZR, Talai A, Klockau KS, Ing RJ, Chatterjee D. Perioperative Management of Children on Ketogenic Dietary Therapies. Anesth Analg. 2020 Dec;131(6):1872-1882. [doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000005018](https://doi.org/10.1213/ANE.0000000000005018). [PMID: 32769381](https://pubmed.gov/32769381)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r457d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0100-2020-12-21-239.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0100-2020-12-21-239.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0535280b3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0100-2020-12-21-239.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lobo EH, Frølich A, Kensing F, Rasmussen LJ, Livingston PM, Grundy J, Abdelrazek M. mHealth applications to support caregiver needs and engagement during stroke recovery: A content review. Res Nurs Health. 2020 Dec 20. [doi: 10.1002/nur.22096](https://doi.org/10.1002/nur.22096). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341958](https://pubmed.gov/33341958)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r239d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0101-2020-12-21-313.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0101-2020-12-21-313.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..505addd1b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0101-2020-12-21-313.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Olowoyeye A, Okwundu CI. Gene therapy for sickle cell disease. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 30;11:CD007652. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007652.pub7](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD007652.pub7). [PMID: 33251574](https://pubmed.gov/33251574)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r313d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0102-2020-12-21-228.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0102-2020-12-21-228.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a5e092280 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0102-2020-12-21-228.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Schizas D, Mastoraki A, Giannakodimos I, Giannakodimos A, Ziogou A, Katsaros I, Frountzas M, Koutelidakis I, Vassiliu P, Pikoulis E. Primary Angiosarcoma of the Gastrointestinal Tract: A Systematic Review of the Literature. J Invest Surg. 2020 Dec 21:1-9. [doi: 10.1080/08941939.2020.1853283](https://doi.org/10.1080/08941939.2020.1853283). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342318](https://pubmed.gov/33342318)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r228d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0103-2020-12-21-482.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0103-2020-12-21-482.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d9c2e9ee3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0103-2020-12-21-482.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sumida K, Nadkarni GN, Grams ME, Sang Y, Ballew SH, Coresh J, Matsushita K, Surapaneni A, Brunskill N, Chadban SJ, Chang AR, Cirillo M, Daratha KB, Gansevoort RT, Garg AX, Iacoviello L, Kayama T, Konta T, Kovesdy CP, Lash J, Lee BJ, Major RW, Metzger M, Miura K, Naimark DMJ, Nelson RG, Sawhney S, Stempniewicz N, Tang M, Townsend RR, Traynor JP, Valdivielso JM, Wetzels J, Polkinghorne KR, Heerspink HJL; Chronic Kidney Disease Prognosis Consortium. Conversion of Urine Protein-Creatinine Ratio or Urine Dipstick Protein to Urine Albumin-Creatinine Ratio for Use in Chronic Kidney Disease Screening and Prognosis : An Individual Participant-Based Meta-analysis. Ann Intern Med. 2020 Sep 15;173(6):426-435. [doi: 10.7326/M20-0529](https://doi.org/10.7326/M20-0529). Epub 2020 Jul 14. [PMID: 32658569](https://pubmed.gov/32658569)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r482d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0104-2020-12-21-572.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0104-2020-12-21-572.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..29e8781ad --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0104-2020-12-21-572.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Klimova B, Novotny M, Valis M. The Impact of Nutrition and Intestinal Microbiome on Elderly Depression-A Systematic Review. Nutrients. 2020 Mar 7;12(3):710. [doi: 10.3390/nu12030710](https://doi.org/10.3390/nu12030710). [PMID: 32156003](https://pubmed.gov/32156003); [PMCID: PMC7146624](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7146624)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r572d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0105-2020-12-21-244.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0105-2020-12-21-244.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..73f3ff89f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0105-2020-12-21-244.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Asghar A, Talha KM, Amanullah M, Shahabuddin S. Comparison of figure of eight and traditional simple wire closure method to prevent dehiscence after sternal closure. J Pak Med Assoc. 2020 Nov;70(11):2001-2006. [doi: 10.5455/JPMA.20135](https://doi.org/10.5455/JPMA.20135). [PMID: 33341848](https://pubmed.gov/33341848)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r244d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0106-2020-12-21-436.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0106-2020-12-21-436.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6d8934c4e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0106-2020-12-21-436.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Godinho MA, Jonnagaddala J, Gudi N, Islam R, Narasimhan P, Liaw ST. mHealth for Integrated People-Centred Health Services in the Western Pacific: A Systematic Review. Int J Med Inform. 2020 Oct;142:104259. [doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104259](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104259). Epub 2020 Aug 19. [PMID: 32858339](https://pubmed.gov/32858339)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r436d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0107-2020-12-21-255.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0107-2020-12-21-255.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9cfb3b53b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0107-2020-12-21-255.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Keshavarz P, Rafiee F, Kavandi H, Goudarzi S, Heidari F, Gholamrezanezhad A. Ischemic gastrointestinal complications of COVID-19: a systematic review on imaging presentation. Clin Imaging. 2020 Dec 8;73:86-95. [doi: 10.1016/j.clinimag.2020.11.054](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clinimag.2020.11.054). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341452](https://pubmed.gov/33341452)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r255d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0108-2020-12-21-35.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0108-2020-12-21-35.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e6f2eb0dc --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0108-2020-12-21-35.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Luo H, Xiao X, Li S, Sun W, Yi Z, Wang P, Zhang Q. Spectrum-frequency and genotype-phenotype analysis of rhodopsin variants. Exp Eye Res. 2020 Dec 18:108405. [doi: 10.1016/j.exer.2020.108405](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.exer.2020.108405). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33347869](https://pubmed.gov/33347869)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r35d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0109-2020-12-21-148.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0109-2020-12-21-148.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8035ac9e5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0109-2020-12-21-148.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Peng L, Li J, Meng C, Li J, Tang D, Guan F, Xu P, Wei T, Li Y. Diagnostic Value of Telomerase Activity in Patients With Bladder Cancer: A Meta-Analysis of Diagnostic Test. Front Oncol. 2020 Dec 3;10:570127. [doi: 10.3389/fonc.2020.570127](https://doi.org/10.3389/fonc.2020.570127). [PMID: 33344230](https://pubmed.gov/33344230); [PMCID: PMC7744937](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7744937)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r148d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0110-2020-12-21-208.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0110-2020-12-21-208.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7f10b8f1f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0110-2020-12-21-208.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Celdrán-Vivancos D, Noval-Martín S, González-Manrique M, Negoita A, Porto- Castro S. Eye oscilations with neurological implications in pediatric age. Arch Soc Esp Oftalmol. 2020 Dec 17:S0365-6691(20)30416-0. English, Spanish. [doi: 10.1016/j.oftal.2020.09.015](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oftal.2020.09.015). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342629](https://pubmed.gov/33342629)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r208d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0111-2020-12-21-74.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0111-2020-12-21-74.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0d3216683 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0111-2020-12-21-74.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘González-Castro TB, Tovilla-Zárate CA, López-Narvaez ML, Juárez-Rojop IE, Calderón-Colmenero J, Sandoval JP, García-Montes JA, Blachman-Braun R, Castillo- Avila RG, García-Flores E, Cazarín-Santos BG, Borgonio-Cuadra VM, Posadas- Sánchez R, Vargas-Alarcón G, Rodríguez-Pérez JM, Pérez-Hernández N. Association between congenital heart disease and NKX2.5 gene polymorphisms: systematic review and meta-analysis. Biomark Med. 2020 Dec;14(18):1747-1757. [doi: 10.2217/bmm-2020-0190](https://doi.org/10.2217/bmm-2020-0190). [PMID: 33346701](https://pubmed.gov/33346701)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r74d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0112-2020-12-21-694.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0112-2020-12-21-694.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..af570aaea --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0112-2020-12-21-694.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Khan MS, Siddiqi TJ, Khan SU, Shah SJ, VanWagner LB, Khan SS. Association of liver stiffness and cardiovascular outcomes in patients with heart failure: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur J Prev Cardiol. 2020 Feb;27(3):331-334. [doi: 10.1177/2047487318810013](https://doi.org/10.1177/2047487318810013). Epub 2018 Oct 30. [PMID: 30376368](https://pubmed.gov/30376368); [PMCID: PMC7319230](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7319230)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r694d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0113-2020-12-21-408.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0113-2020-12-21-408.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9ea2b29c9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0113-2020-12-21-408.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Luo L, Fu M, Li Y, Hu S, Luo J, Chen Z, Yu J, Li W, Dong R, Yang Y, Tu L, Xu X. The potential association between common comorbidities and severity and mortality of coronavirus disease 2019: A pooled analysis. Clin Cardiol. 2020 Dec;43(12):1478-1493. [doi: 10.1002/clc.23465](https://doi.org/10.1002/clc.23465). Epub 2020 Oct 7. [PMID: 33026120](https://pubmed.gov/33026120); [PMCID: PMC7675427](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7675427)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r408d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0114-2020-12-21-40.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0114-2020-12-21-40.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9e9694920 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0114-2020-12-21-40.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Rausa E, Manfredi R, Kelly ME, Bianco F, Aiolfi A, Bonitta G, Lucianetti A, Zappa MA. Magnetic Sphincter Augmentation Placement for Recalcitrant Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease Following Bariatric Procedures: A Systematic Review and Bayesian Meta-Analysis. J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A. 2020 Dec 21. [doi: 10.1089/lap.2020.0763](https://doi.org/10.1089/lap.2020.0763). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33347784](https://pubmed.gov/33347784)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r40d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0115-2020-12-21-534.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0115-2020-12-21-534.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..167bdf234 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0115-2020-12-21-534.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘French HP, Deasy M, Gallagher R, O'Grady A, Doyle F. Prevalence of Hip or Groin Pain in Adolescents: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Pain Pract. 2020 Sep;20(7):792-811. [doi: 10.1111/papr.12907](https://doi.org/10.1111/papr.12907). Epub 2020 Jun 15. [PMID: 32362057](https://pubmed.gov/32362057)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r534d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0116-2020-12-21-614.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0116-2020-12-21-614.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..110240189 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0116-2020-12-21-614.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chahal CAA, Salloum MN, Alahdab F, Gottwald JA, Tester DJ, Anwer LA, So EL, Murad MH, St Louis EK, Ackerman MJ, Somers VK. Systematic Review of the Genetics of Sudden Unexpected Death in Epilepsy: Potential Overlap With Sudden Cardiac Death and Arrhythmia-Related Genes. J Am Heart Assoc. 2020 Jan 7;9(1):e012264. [doi: 10.1161/JAHA.119.012264](https://doi.org/10.1161/JAHA.119.012264). Epub 2019 Dec 21. [PMID: 31865891](https://pubmed.gov/31865891); [PMCID: PMC6988156](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC6988156)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r614d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0117-2020-12-21-372.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0117-2020-12-21-372.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c3727ca74 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0117-2020-12-21-372.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Captieux M, Prigge R, Wild S, Guthrie B. Defining remission of type 2 diabetes in research studies: A systematic scoping review. PLoS Med. 2020 Oct 28;17(10):e1003396. [doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1003396](https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1003396). [PMID: 33112845](https://pubmed.gov/33112845); [PMCID: PMC7592769](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7592769)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r372d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0118-2020-12-21-394.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0118-2020-12-21-394.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b4f54dc6b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0118-2020-12-21-394.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Moraitis AA, Shreeve N, Sovio U, Brocklehurst P, Heazell AEP, Thornton JG, Robson SC, Papageorghiou A, Smith GC. Universal third-trimester ultrasonic screening using fetal macrosomia in the prediction of adverse perinatal outcome: A systematic review and meta-analysis of diagnostic test accuracy. PLoS Med. 2020 Oct 13;17(10):e1003190. [doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1003190](https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1003190). [PMID: 33048935](https://pubmed.gov/33048935); [PMCID: PMC7553291](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7553291)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r394d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0119-2020-12-21-229.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0119-2020-12-21-229.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e96a5c051 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0119-2020-12-21-229.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ishøi L, Nielsen MF, Hölmich P, Thorborg K. Now you see it - Now you don't: A letter to the editor concerning "Surgery is no more effective than conservative treatment for femoroacetabular impingement syndrome: Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials". Clin Rehabil. 2020 Dec 21:269215520981695. [doi: 10.1177/0269215520981695](https://doi.org/10.1177/0269215520981695). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342271](https://pubmed.gov/33342271)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r229d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0120-2020-12-21-63.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0120-2020-12-21-63.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..77082b978 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0120-2020-12-21-63.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sadowski A, Dunlap C, Lacombe A, Hanes D. Alterations in Heart Rate Variability Associated With Irritable Bowel Syndrome or Inflammatory Bowel Disease: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Clin Transl Gastroenterol. 2020 Dec 18;12(1):e00275. [doi: 10.14309/ctg.0000000000000275](https://doi.org/10.14309/ctg.0000000000000275). [PMID: 33346998](https://pubmed.gov/33346998); [PMCID: PMC7752679](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7752679)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r63d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0121-2020-12-21-523.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0121-2020-12-21-523.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b6a34c9d5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0121-2020-12-21-523.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Liverpool S, Mota CP, Sales CMD, Čuš A, Carletto S, Hancheva C, Sousa S, Cerón SC, Moreno-Peral P, Pietrabissa G, Moltrecht B, Ulberg R, Ferreira N, Edbrooke-Childs J. Engaging Children and Young People in Digital Mental Health Interventions: Systematic Review of Modes of Delivery, Facilitators, and Barriers. J Med Internet Res. 2020 Jun 23;22(6):e16317. [doi: 10.2196/16317](https://doi.org/10.2196/16317). [PMID: 32442160](https://pubmed.gov/32442160); [PMCID: PMC7381028](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7381028)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r523d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0122-2020-12-21-653.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0122-2020-12-21-653.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..af780cbf6 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0122-2020-12-21-653.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bahls M, Lorenz MW, Dörr M, Gao L, Kitagawa K, Tuomainen TP, Agewall S, Berenson G, Catapano AL, Norata GD, Bots ML, van Gilst W, Asselbergs FW, Brouwers FP, Uthoff H, Sander D, Poppert H, Hecht Olsen M, Empana JP, Schminke U, Baldassarre D, Veglia F, Franco OH, Kavousi M, de Groot E, Mathiesen EB, Grigore L, Polak JF, Rundek T, Stehouwer CD, Skilton MR, Hatzitolios AI, Savopoulos C, Ntaios G, Plichart M, McLachlan S, Lind L, Willeit P, Steinmetz H, Desvarieux M, Ikram MA, Johnsen SH, Schmidt C, Willeit J, Ducimetiere P, Price JF, Bergström G, Kauhanen J, Kiechl S, Sitzer M, Bickel H, Sacco RL, Hofman A, Völzke H, Thompson SG; PROG-IMT Study Group. Progression of conventional cardiovascular risk factors and vascular disease risk in individuals: insights from the PROG-IMT consortium. Eur J Prev Cardiol. 2020 Feb;27(3):234-243. [doi: 10.1177/2047487319877078](https://doi.org/10.1177/2047487319877078). Epub 2019 Oct 16. [PMID: 31619084](https://pubmed.gov/31619084); [PMCID: PMC7008553](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7008553)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r653d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0123-2020-12-21-375.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0123-2020-12-21-375.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bfeccfa4a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0123-2020-12-21-375.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Tiseo C, Vacca A, Felbush A, Filimonova T, Gai A, Glazyrina T, Hubalek IA, Marchenko Y, Overeem LH, Piroso S, Tkachev A, Martelletti P, Sacco S; European Headache Federation School of Advanced Studies (EHF-SAS). Migraine and sleep disorders: a systematic review. J Headache Pain. 2020 Oct 27;21(1):126. [doi: 10.1186/s10194-020-01192-5](https://doi.org/10.1186/s10194-020-01192-5). [PMID: 33109076](https://pubmed.gov/33109076); [PMCID: PMC7590682](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7590682)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r375d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0124-2020-12-21-155.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0124-2020-12-21-155.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f5bb74802 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0124-2020-12-21-155.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Almeida GJ, Khoja SS, Zelle BA. Effect of prehabilitation in older adults undergoing total joint replacement: An Overview of Systematic Reviews. Curr Geriatr Rep. 2020 Dec;9(4):280-287. [doi: 10.1007/s13670-020-00342-6](https://doi.org/10.1007/s13670-020-00342-6). Epub 2020 Nov 24. [PMID: 33344110](https://pubmed.gov/33344110); [PMCID: PMC7745772](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7745772)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r155d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0125-2020-12-21-338.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0125-2020-12-21-338.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..641bf2b4d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0125-2020-12-21-338.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Khattri S, Kumbargere Nagraj S, Arora A, Eachempati P, Kusum CK, Bhat KG, Johnson TM, Lodi G. Adjunctive systemic antimicrobials for the non-surgical treatment of periodontitis. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 16;11:CD012568. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012568.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD012568.pub2). [PMID: 33197289](https://pubmed.gov/33197289)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r338d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0126-2020-12-21-646.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0126-2020-12-21-646.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5c8eef17e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0126-2020-12-21-646.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Figueiredo PR, Tolomeo S, Steele JD, Baldacchino A. Neurocognitive consequences of chronic cannabis use: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:358-369. [doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.10.014](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.10.014). Epub 2019 Nov 9. [PMID: 31715191](https://pubmed.gov/31715191)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r646d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0127-2020-12-21-265.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0127-2020-12-21-265.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b99e25e37 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0127-2020-12-21-265.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ma C, Peng Y, Li H, Chen W. Organ-on-a-Chip: A New Paradigm for Drug Development. Trends Pharmacol Sci. 2020 Dec 16:S0165-6147(20)30264-9. [doi: 10.1016/j.tips.2020.11.009](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tips.2020.11.009). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341248](https://pubmed.gov/33341248)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r265d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0128-2020-12-21-102.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0128-2020-12-21-102.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..36a7a66ec --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0128-2020-12-21-102.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Higgins MF, Pollard L, McGuinness SK, Kingdom JC. Fetal heart rate monitoring in nonobstetric surgery: a systematic review of the evidence. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2019 Nov;1(4):100048. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2019.100048](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajogmf.2019.100048). Epub 2019 Sep 27. [PMID: 33345838](https://pubmed.gov/33345838)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r102d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0129-2020-12-21-125.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0129-2020-12-21-125.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e1ac8043d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0129-2020-12-21-125.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Yang Y, Liu J, Yang K, Ma Y, Fu S, Tang X, Wang Y, Zhou L. Endocrine Adverse Events Caused By Different Types and Different Doses of Immune Checkpoint Inhibitors in the Treatment of solid Tumors: A Meta-Analysis and Systematic Review. J Clin Pharmacol. 2020 Dec 20. [doi: 10.1002/jcph.1804](https://doi.org/10.1002/jcph.1804). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345342](https://pubmed.gov/33345342)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r125d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0130-2020-12-21-412.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0130-2020-12-21-412.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..633e21813 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0130-2020-12-21-412.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Guercio V, Pojum IC, Leonardi GS, Shrubsole C, Gowers AM, Dimitroulopoulou S, Exley KS. Exposure to indoor and outdoor air pollution from solid fuel combustion and respiratory outcomes in children in developed countries: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sci Total Environ. 2021 Feb 10;755(Pt 1):142187. [doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142187](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142187). Epub 2020 Sep 12. [PMID: 33017761](https://pubmed.gov/33017761)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r412d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0131-2020-12-21-78.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0131-2020-12-21-78.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1cf41ca50 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0131-2020-12-21-78.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Uhlig HH, Charbit-Henrion F, Kotlarz D, Shouval DS, Schwerd T, Strisciuglio C, de Ridder L, van Limbergen J, Macchi M, Snapper SB, Ruemmele FM, Wilson DC, Travis SPL, Griffiths AM, Turner D, Klein C, Muise AM, Russell RK; Paediatric IBD Porto group of ESPGHAN. Clinical Genomics for the Diagnosis of Monogenic forms of Inflammatory Bowel Disease: A Position Paper from The Paediatric IBD Porto Group of ESPGHAN. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr. 2020 Dec 16;Publish Ahead of Print. [doi: 10.1097/MPG.0000000000003017](https://doi.org/10.1097/MPG.0000000000003017). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346580](https://pubmed.gov/33346580)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r78d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0132-2020-12-21-538.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0132-2020-12-21-538.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3136eae65 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0132-2020-12-21-538.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Drakos P, Ford BC, Labropoulos N. A systematic review on internal jugular vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2020 Jul;8(4):662-666. [doi: 10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.03.003](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.03.003). Epub 2020 Apr 19. [PMID: 32321692](https://pubmed.gov/32321692)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r538d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0133-2020-12-21-90.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0133-2020-12-21-90.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f61a32bf3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0133-2020-12-21-90.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Michener CM, Lampert E, Yao M, Harnegie MP, Chalif J, Chambers LM. Meta- analysis of laparo-endoscopic single site and vaginal natural orifice transluminal endoscopic hysterectomy compared to multi-port hysterectomy: real benefits or diminishing returns? J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2020 Dec 17:S1553-4650(20)31189-4. [doi: 10.1016/j.jmig.2020.11.029](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmig.2020.11.029). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346073](https://pubmed.gov/33346073)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r90d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0134-2020-12-21-119.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0134-2020-12-21-119.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ee08cce69 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0134-2020-12-21-119.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lee YC, Fang TJ, Kuo IC, Tsai YT, Hsin LJ. Stapler Closure versus Manual Closure in Total Laryngectomy for Laryngeal Cancer: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Clin Otolaryngol. 2020 Dec 21. [doi: 10.1111/coa.13702](https://doi.org/10.1111/coa.13702). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345446](https://pubmed.gov/33345446)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r119d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0135-2020-12-21-139.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0135-2020-12-21-139.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..32cf3a8fe --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0135-2020-12-21-139.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ma F, Fan Y, Zhang L, Zhao Z, Nie Y, Chen M, Wang C. Roux-en-Y and Billroth II Reconstruction after Pancreaticoduodenectomy: A Meta-Analysis of Complications. Biomed Res Int. 2020 Dec 3;2020:6131968. [doi: 10.1155/2020/6131968](https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/6131968). [PMID: 33344644](https://pubmed.gov/33344644); [PMCID: PMC7732384](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7732384)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r139d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0136-2020-12-21-666.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0136-2020-12-21-666.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..780abf7bc --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0136-2020-12-21-666.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Caldeira PC, Soto AML, de Aguiar MCF, Martins CC. Tumor depth of invasion and prognosis of early-stage oral squamous cell carcinoma: A meta-analysis. Oral Dis. 2020 Oct;26(7):1357-1365. [doi: 10.1111/odi.13194](https://doi.org/10.1111/odi.13194). Epub 2019 Oct 9. [PMID: 31520552](https://pubmed.gov/31520552)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r666d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0137-2020-12-21-218.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0137-2020-12-21-218.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a5d4ec65f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0137-2020-12-21-218.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Smith CH, Mahil SK, Yiu ZZN, Bale T, Burden AD, Coates LC, McGuire A, Murphy R, Owen CM, Parslew R, Uthman OA, Woolf RT, Manounah L, Ezejimofor MC, Exton LS, Mohd Mustapa MF. Quantitative Evaluation of Biologic Therapy Options for Psoriasis: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis-Correction. J Invest Dermatol. 2021 Jan;141(1):177-181. [doi: 10.1016/j.jid.2020.02.048](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jid.2020.02.048). [PMID: 33342507](https://pubmed.gov/33342507)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r218d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0138-2020-12-21-566.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0138-2020-12-21-566.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c312a2da5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0138-2020-12-21-566.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Radin M, Foddai SG, Cecchi I, Rubini E, Schreiber K, Roccatello D, Bertolaccini ML, Sciascia S. Antiphosphatidylserine/Prothrombin Antibodies: An Update on Their Association with Clinical Manifestations of Antiphospholipid Syndrome. Thromb Haemost. 2020 Apr;120(4):592-598. [doi: 10.1055/s-0040-1705115](https://doi.org/10.1055/s-0040-1705115). Epub 2020 Mar 17. [PMID: 32185783](https://pubmed.gov/32185783)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r566d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0139-2020-12-21-433.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0139-2020-12-21-433.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e3a507651 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0139-2020-12-21-433.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Wang Q, Jiang X, Shen Y, Yao P, Chen J, Zhou Y, Gu Y, Qian Z, Cao X. Effectiveness of exercise intervention on fall-related fractures in older adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Sep 4;20(1):322. [doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01721-6](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-020-01721-6). [PMID: 32887571](https://pubmed.gov/32887571); [PMCID: PMC7650290](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7650290)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r433d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0140-2020-12-21-494.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0140-2020-12-21-494.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..17901ed08 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0140-2020-12-21-494.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kraiss JT, Ten Klooster PM, Moskowitz JT, Bohlmeijer ET. The relationship between emotion regulation and well-being in patients with mental disorders: A meta-analysis. Compr Psychiatry. 2020 Oct;102:152189. [doi: 10.1016/j.comppsych.2020.152189](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.comppsych.2020.152189). Epub 2020 Jun 18. [PMID: 32629064](https://pubmed.gov/32629064)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r494d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0141-2020-12-21-622.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0141-2020-12-21-622.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..25469569a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0141-2020-12-21-622.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Palandi J, Bobinski F, de Oliveira GM, Ilha J. Neuropathic pain after spinal cord injury and physical exercise in animal models: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:781-795. [doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.016](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.016). Epub 2019 Dec 16. [PMID: 31837360](https://pubmed.gov/31837360)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r622d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0142-2020-12-21-495.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0142-2020-12-21-495.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..920899986 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0142-2020-12-21-495.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Carvalho LC, Nogueira HS, Minussi ART, Lima MB, Munari DP, Peruzzi NJ, Silva EP. Genetic growth potential characterization in the Japanese quail: a meta-analysis. Animal. 2020 Aug;14(S2):s341-s347. [doi: 10.1017/S1751731120001202](https://doi.org/10.1017/S1751731120001202). Epub 2020 Jun 22. [PMID: 32624080](https://pubmed.gov/32624080)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r495d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0143-2020-12-21-25.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0143-2020-12-21-25.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8f679ed6b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0143-2020-12-21-25.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Aghdam ZN, Rahmani AM, Hosseinzadeh M. The Role of the Internet of Things in Healthcare: Future Trends and Challenges. Comput Methods Programs Biomed. 2020 Dec 13;199:105903. [doi: 10.1016/j.cmpb.2020.105903](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cmpb.2020.105903). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348073](https://pubmed.gov/33348073)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r25d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0144-2020-12-21-513.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0144-2020-12-21-513.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9c7ff7cce --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0144-2020-12-21-513.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘de Oliveira Gondim ITG, de Souza CCB, Rodrigues MAB, Azevedo IM, de Sales Coriolano MDGW, Lins OG. Portable accelerometers for the evaluation of spatio- temporal gait parameters in people with Parkinson's disease: an integrative review. Arch Gerontol Geriatr. 2020 Sep-Oct;90:104097. [doi: 10.1016/j.archger.2020.104097](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.archger.2020.104097). Epub 2020 May 13. [PMID: 32531644](https://pubmed.gov/32531644)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r513d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0145-2020-12-21-219.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0145-2020-12-21-219.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..89f3f269e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0145-2020-12-21-219.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Nesami MB, Moosazadeh M, Goudarzian AH, Jafari-Koulaee A. Erratum to: "Effect of Cryotherapy on Arteriovenous Fistula Puncture-Related Pain in Hemodialysis Patients: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis" [Complementary Therapies in Medicine 49C (2020) 102326]. Complement Ther Med. 2020 Mar;49:102363. [doi: 10.1016/j.ctim.2020.102363](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctim.2020.102363). Epub 2020 Mar 5. Erratum for: Complement Ther Med. 2020 Mar;49:102326. [PMID: 33342485](https://pubmed.gov/33342485)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r219d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0146-2020-12-21-480.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0146-2020-12-21-480.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e9598fab6 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0146-2020-12-21-480.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ebrahimpour-Koujan S, Milajerdi A, Larijani B, Esmaillzadeh A. Effects of probiotics on salivary cytokines and immunoglobulines: a systematic review and meta-analysis on clinical trials. Sci Rep. 2020 Jul 16;10(1):11800. [doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-67037-y](https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-67037-y). [PMID: 32678117](https://pubmed.gov/32678117); [PMCID: PMC7366729](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7366729)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r480d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0147-2020-12-21-658.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0147-2020-12-21-658.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..52c58b2de --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0147-2020-12-21-658.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Tessier JM, Sanders J, Sartelli M, Ulrych J, De Simone B, Grabowski J, Buckman S, Duane TM. Necrotizing Soft Tissue Infections: A Focused Review of Pathophysiology, Diagnosis, Operative Management, Antimicrobial Therapy, and Pediatrics. Surg Infect (Larchmt). 2020 Mar;21(2):81-93. [doi: 10.1089/sur.2019.219](https://doi.org/10.1089/sur.2019.219). Epub 2019 Oct 4. [PMID: 31584343](https://pubmed.gov/31584343)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r658d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0148-2020-12-21-400.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0148-2020-12-21-400.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..de2a6db1f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0148-2020-12-21-400.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bansal A, Singh AD, Jain V, Aggarwal M, Gupta S, Padappayil RP, Nadeem M, Joshi S, Mian A, Greathouse T, Wells D, Gupta M, Khan MZ. The association of D-dimers with mortality, intensive care unit admission or acute respiratory distress syndrome in patients hospitalized with coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19): A systematic review and meta-analysis. Heart Lung. 2021 Jan- Feb;50(1):9-12. [doi: 10.1016/j.hrtlng.2020.08.024](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hrtlng.2020.08.024). Epub 2020 Sep 18. [PMID: 33041057](https://pubmed.gov/33041057); [PMCID: PMC7500895](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7500895)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r400d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0149-2020-12-21-232.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0149-2020-12-21-232.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..145280f3a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0149-2020-12-21-232.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Clark CE, Warren FC, Boddy K, McDonagh STJ, Moore SF, Goddard J, Reed N, Turner M, Alzamora MT, Ramos Blanes R, Chuang SY, Criqui M, Dahl M, Engström G, Erbel R, Espeland M, Ferrucci L, Guerchet M, Hattersley A, Lahoz C, McClelland RL, McDermott MM, Price J, Stoffers HE, Wang JG, Westerink J, White J, Cloutier L, Taylor RS, Shore AC, McManus RJ, Aboyans V, Campbell JL. Associations Between Systolic Interarm Differences in Blood Pressure and Cardiovascular Disease Outcomes and Mortality: Individual Participant Data Meta-Analysis, Development and Validation of a Prognostic Algorithm: The INTERPRESS-IPD Collaboration. Hypertension. 2020 Dec 21:HYPERTENSIONAHA12015997. [doi: 10.1161/HYPERTENSIONAHA.120.15997](https://doi.org/10.1161/HYPERTENSIONAHA.120.15997). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342236](https://pubmed.gov/33342236)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r232d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0150-2020-12-21-332.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0150-2020-12-21-332.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2299ab6b6 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0150-2020-12-21-332.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bugge C, Adams EJ, Gopinath D, Stewart F, Dembinsky M, Sobiesuo P, Kearney R. Pessaries (mechanical devices) for managing pelvic organ prolapse in women. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 18;11:CD004010. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004010.pub4](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD004010.pub4). [PMID: 33207004](https://pubmed.gov/33207004)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r332d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0151-2020-12-21-354.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0151-2020-12-21-354.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..517b7a521 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0151-2020-12-21-354.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Liang N, Li H, Wang J, Jiao L, Ma Y, Wang X, Liu B, Luo X, Zhao S, Lv M, Cao J, Hu W, Zhang H, Xiong Y, Tian Y, Chen Y, Wang Y, Shi N. Development of Rapid Advice Guidelines for the Treatment of Coronavirus Disease 2019 with Traditional Chinese Medicine. Am J Chin Med. 2020;48(7):1511-1521. [doi: 10.1142/S0192415X20500743](https://doi.org/10.1142/S0192415X20500743). Epub 2020 Nov 5. [PMID: 33148006](https://pubmed.gov/33148006)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r354d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0152-2020-12-21-599.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0152-2020-12-21-599.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5ac84a1f8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0152-2020-12-21-599.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘de Medeiros MMD, Carletti TM, Magno MB, Maia LC, Cavalcanti YW, Rodrigues- Garcia RCM. Does the institutionalization influence elderly's quality of life? A systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Feb 5;20(1):44. [doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-1452-0](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-020-1452-0). [PMID: 32024479](https://pubmed.gov/32024479); [PMCID: PMC7003363](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7003363)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r599d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0153-2020-12-21-330.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0153-2020-12-21-330.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..26c206c53 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0153-2020-12-21-330.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Tomita Y, Moldovan M, Chang Lee R, Hsieh AH, Townsend A, Price T. Salvage systemic therapy for advanced gastric and oesophago-gastric junction adenocarcinoma. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 19;11:CD012078. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012078.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD012078.pub2). [PMID: 33210731](https://pubmed.gov/33210731)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r330d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0154-2020-12-21-273.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0154-2020-12-21-273.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c3a30ba1b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0154-2020-12-21-273.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Yuan X, Xue N, Han Z. A meta-analysis of heavy metals pollution in farmland and urban soils in China over the past 20 years. J Environ Sci (China). 2021 Mar;101:217-226. [doi: 10.1016/j.jes.2020.08.013](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jes.2020.08.013). Epub 2020 Sep 3. [PMID: 33334517](https://pubmed.gov/33334517)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r273d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0155-2020-12-21-109.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0155-2020-12-21-109.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..420105717 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0155-2020-12-21-109.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zelig R, Goldstein S, Touger-Decker R, Firestone E, Golden A, Johnson Z, Kaseta A, Sackey J, Tomesko J, Parrott JS. Tooth Loss and Nutritional Status in Older Adults: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. JDR Clin Trans Res. 2020 Dec 21:2380084420981016. [doi: 10.1177/2380084420981016](https://doi.org/10.1177/2380084420981016). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345687](https://pubmed.gov/33345687)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r109d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0156-2020-12-21-650.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0156-2020-12-21-650.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2e8bfaa61 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0156-2020-12-21-650.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhao E, Lowres N, Woolaston A, Naismith SL, Gallagher R. Prevalence and patterns of cognitive impairment in acute coronary syndrome patients: A systematic review. Eur J Prev Cardiol. 2020 Feb;27(3):284-293. [doi: 10.1177/2047487319878945](https://doi.org/10.1177/2047487319878945). Epub 2019 Oct 24. [PMID: 31645116](https://pubmed.gov/31645116)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r650d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0157-2020-12-21-519.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0157-2020-12-21-519.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..06e26f9dd --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0157-2020-12-21-519.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Harteveld LM, Blom NA, Hazekamp MG, Ten Harkel ADJ. Treatment and outcome of plastic bronchitis in single ventricle patients: a systematic review. Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg. 2020 Jun 1;30(6):846-853. [doi: 10.1093/icvts/ivaa032](https://doi.org/10.1093/icvts/ivaa032). [PMID: 32451550](https://pubmed.gov/32451550)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r519d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0158-2020-12-21-571.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0158-2020-12-21-571.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6e4a582bd --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0158-2020-12-21-571.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Dvoretskiy S, Lieblein-Boff JC, Jonnalagadda S, Atherton PJ, Phillips BE, Pereira SL. Exploring the Association between Vascular Dysfunction and Skeletal Muscle Mass, Strength and Function in Healthy Adults: A Systematic Review. Nutrients. 2020 Mar 7;12(3):715. [doi: 10.3390/nu12030715](https://doi.org/10.3390/nu12030715). [PMID: 32156061](https://pubmed.gov/32156061); [PMCID: PMC7146456](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7146456)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r571d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0159-2020-12-21-674.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0159-2020-12-21-674.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1a3955684 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0159-2020-12-21-674.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bahraini S, Gifford W, Graham ID, Wazni L, Brémault-Phillips S, Hackbusch R, Demers C, Egan M. The accuracy of measures in screening adults for spiritual suffering in health care settings: A systematic review. Palliat Support Care. 2020 Feb;18(1):89-102. [doi: 10.1017/S1478951519000506](https://doi.org/10.1017/S1478951519000506). [PMID: 31387655](https://pubmed.gov/31387655)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r674d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0160-2020-12-21-168.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0160-2020-12-21-168.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c5ef228a5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0160-2020-12-21-168.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Velickovic VM, McIlwaine E, Zhang R, Spelman T. Adverse events in second- and third-line treatments for acute and chronic graft-versus-host disease: systematic review. Ther Adv Hematol. 2020 Dec 8;11:2040620720977039. [doi: 10.1177/2040620720977039](https://doi.org/10.1177/2040620720977039). [PMID: 33343855](https://pubmed.gov/33343855); [PMCID: PMC7727084](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7727084)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r168d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0161-2020-12-21-14.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0161-2020-12-21-14.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..37ddbc740 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0161-2020-12-21-14.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Wei XY, Gong QL, Zeng A, Wang W, Wang Q, Zhang XX. Seroprevalence and risk factors of Toxoplasma gondii infection in goats in China from 2010 to 2020: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Prev Vet Med. 2020 Dec 5;186:105230. [doi: 10.1016/j.prevetmed.2020.105230](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.prevetmed.2020.105230). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348304](https://pubmed.gov/33348304)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r14d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0162-2020-12-21-515.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0162-2020-12-21-515.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..96d48f892 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0162-2020-12-21-515.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Côté-Léger P, Rowland DL. Estimations of Typical, Ideal, Premature Ejaculation, and Actual Latencies by Men and Female Sexual Partners of Men During Partnered Sex. J Sex Med. 2020 Aug;17(8):1448-1456. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.04.317](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.04.317). Epub 2020 Jun 5. [PMID: 32507609](https://pubmed.gov/32507609)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r515d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0163-2020-12-21-150.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0163-2020-12-21-150.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e72acff0f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0163-2020-12-21-150.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Saeid Y, Salaree MM, Ebadi A, Moradian ST. Family Intensive Care Unit Syndrome: An Integrative Review. Iran J Nurs Midwifery Res. 2020 Sep 1;25(5):361-368. [doi: 10.4103/ijnmr.IJNMR_243_19](https://doi.org/10.4103/ijnmr.IJNMR_243_19). [PMID: 33344205](https://pubmed.gov/33344205); [PMCID: PMC7737832](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7737832)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r150d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0164-2020-12-21-47.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0164-2020-12-21-47.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ed01aa075 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0164-2020-12-21-47.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Romero-Franco N, Ortego-Mate MDC, Molina-Mula J. Knee Kinematics During Landing: Is It Really a Predictor of Acute Noncontact Knee Injuries in Athletes? A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Orthop J Sports Med. 2020 Dec 9;8(12):2325967120966952. [doi: 10.1177/2325967120966952](https://doi.org/10.1177/2325967120966952). [PMID: 33344669](https://pubmed.gov/33344669); [PMCID: PMC7731707](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7731707)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r47d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0165-2020-12-21-43.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0165-2020-12-21-43.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4196f0f18 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0165-2020-12-21-43.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Matar RN, Shah NS, Gardner TJ, Grawe BM. Return to sport after surgical treatment for posterior shoulder instability: a systematic review. JSES Int. 2020 Sep 11;4(4):797-802. [doi: 10.1016/j.jseint.2020.08.002](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jseint.2020.08.002). [PMID: 33345218](https://pubmed.gov/33345218); [PMCID: PMC7738578](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7738578)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r43d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0166-2020-12-21-39.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0166-2020-12-21-39.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f3679b264 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0166-2020-12-21-39.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Morice PM, Leary A, Dolladille C, Chrétien B, Poulain L, González-Martín A, Moore K, O'Reilly EM, Ray-Coquard I, Alexandre J. Myelodysplastic syndrome and acute myeloid leukaemia in patients treated with PARP inhibitors: a safety meta- analysis of randomised controlled trials and a retrospective study of the WHO pharmacovigilance database. Lancet Haematol. 2020 Dec 18:S2352-3026(20)30360-4. [doi: 10.1016/S2352-3026(20)30360-4](https://doi.org/10.1016/S2352-3026(20)30360-4). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33347814](https://pubmed.gov/33347814)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r39d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0167-2020-12-21-161.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0167-2020-12-21-161.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3060c04ee --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0167-2020-12-21-161.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Huang Q, Xiong H, Shuai T, Zhang M, Zhang C, Wang Y, Zhu L, Lu J, Liu J. Risk factors for new-onset atrial fibrillation in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PeerJ. 2020 Dec 2;8:e10376. [doi: 10.7717/peerj.10376](https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.10376). [PMID: 33344074](https://pubmed.gov/33344074); [PMCID: PMC7718784](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7718784)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r161d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0168-2020-12-21-315.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0168-2020-12-21-315.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..102243db5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0168-2020-12-21-315.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Guay J, Kopp S. Peripheral nerve blocks for hip fractures in adults. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 25;11:CD001159. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001159.pub3](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD001159.pub3). [PMID: 33238043](https://pubmed.gov/33238043)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r315d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0169-2020-12-21-201.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0169-2020-12-21-201.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..11aa90f36 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0169-2020-12-21-201.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kim D, Ki Y, Kim W, Park D, Joo J, Jeon H, Nam J. Comparison of local recurrence after mastectomy for pure ductal carcinoma in situ with close or positive margins: A meta-analysis. J Cancer Res Ther. 2020 Oct- Dec;16(6):1197-1202. [doi: 10.4103/jcrt.JCRT_160_19](https://doi.org/10.4103/jcrt.JCRT_160_19). [PMID: 33342773](https://pubmed.gov/33342773)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r201d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0170-2020-12-21-36.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0170-2020-12-21-36.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5b3cfd3df --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0170-2020-12-21-36.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sadeghi AH, Mathari SE, Abjigitova D, Maat APWM, Taverne YJHJ, Bogers AJJC, Mahtab EAF. Current and Future Applications of Virtual, Augmented, and Mixed Reality in Cardiothoracic Surgery. Ann Thorac Surg. 2020 Dec 18:S0003-4975(20)32127-5. [doi: 10.1016/j.athoracsur.2020.11.030](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.athoracsur.2020.11.030). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33347848](https://pubmed.gov/33347848)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r36d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0171-2020-12-21-680.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0171-2020-12-21-680.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..77cbe6c2d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0171-2020-12-21-680.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Di Tella S, Pagliari C, Blasi V, Mendozzi L, Rovaris M, Baglio F. Integrated telerehabilitation approach in multiple sclerosis: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Telemed Telecare. 2020 Aug-Sep;26(7-8):385-399. [doi: 10.1177/1357633X19850381](https://doi.org/10.1177/1357633X19850381). Epub 2019 May 27. [PMID: 31132909](https://pubmed.gov/31132909)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r680d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0172-2020-12-21-601.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0172-2020-12-21-601.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..95103951b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0172-2020-12-21-601.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Arnott C, Li Q, Kang A, Neuen BL, Bompoint S, Lam CSP, Rodgers A, Mahaffey KW, Cannon CP, Perkovic V, Jardine MJ, Neal B. Sodium-Glucose Cotransporter 2 Inhibition for the Prevention of Cardiovascular Events in Patients With Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Am Heart Assoc. 2020 Feb 4;9(3):e014908. [doi: 10.1161/JAHA.119.014908](https://doi.org/10.1161/JAHA.119.014908). Epub 2020 Jan 29. [PMID: 31992158](https://pubmed.gov/31992158); [PMCID: PMC7033896](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7033896)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r601d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0173-2020-12-21-89.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0173-2020-12-21-89.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..84678e098 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0173-2020-12-21-89.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Varkaneh HK, Rinaldi G, Hekmatdoost A, Fatahi S, Tan SC, Shadnoush M, Khni V, Mousavi SM, Zarezadeh M, Salamat S, Bawadi H, Rahmani J. Reply to "Double- counting of effect sizes and inappropriate exclusion of studies in "The influence of vitamin D supplementation on IGF-1 levels in humans: A systematic review and meta_analysis". Ageing Res Rev. 2020 Dec 17:101239. [doi: 10.1016/j.arr.2020.101239](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.arr.2020.101239). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346153](https://pubmed.gov/33346153)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r89d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0174-2020-12-21-654.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0174-2020-12-21-654.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a005974fb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0174-2020-12-21-654.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Noone C, Leahy J, Morrissey EC, Newell J, Newell M, Dwyer CP, Murphy J, Doyle F, Murphy AW, Molloy GJ. Comparative efficacy of exercise and anti- hypertensive pharmacological interventions in reducing blood pressure in people with hypertension: A network meta-analysis. Eur J Prev Cardiol. 2020 Feb;27(3):247-255. [doi: 10.1177/2047487319879786](https://doi.org/10.1177/2047487319879786). Epub 2019 Oct 15. [PMID: 31615283](https://pubmed.gov/31615283)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r654d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0175-2020-12-21-101.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0175-2020-12-21-101.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..21e4a9bab --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0175-2020-12-21-101.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kim SW, Nasioudis D, Levine LD. Role of early amniotomy with induced labor: a systematic review of literature and meta-analysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2019 Nov;1(4):100052. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2019.100052](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajogmf.2019.100052). Epub 2019 Sep 28. [PMID: 33345842](https://pubmed.gov/33345842)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r101d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0176-2020-12-21-301.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0176-2020-12-21-301.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7b3e79000 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0176-2020-12-21-301.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sousa PP, O'sullivan GJ. Iliocaval Endovascular Reconstruction - Clinical Cases Presentation And Systematic Review Publication. Rev Port Cir Cardiotorac Vasc. 2020 Oct-Dec;27(4):288. [PMID: 33280314](https://pubmed.gov/33280314)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r301d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0177-2020-12-21-509.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0177-2020-12-21-509.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..196fb5436 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0177-2020-12-21-509.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Carpenter CR, Mudd PA, West CP, Wilber E, Wilber ST. Diagnosing COVID-19 in the Emergency Department: A Scoping Review of Clinical Examinations, Laboratory Tests, Imaging Accuracy, and Biases. Acad Emerg Med. 2020 Aug;27(8):653-670. [doi: 10.1111/acem.14048](https://doi.org/10.1111/acem.14048). Epub 2020 Jul 26. [PMID: 32542934](https://pubmed.gov/32542934); [PMCID: PMC7323136](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7323136)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r509d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0178-2020-12-21-31.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0178-2020-12-21-31.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..357a531f0 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0178-2020-12-21-31.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Göbölös L, Rácz I, Hogan M, Remsey-Semmelweis E, Atallah B, AlMahmeed W, AlSindi F, Suri RM, Bhatnagar G, Tuzcu EM. The role of renin-angiotensin system activated phagocytes in the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus infection. J Vasc Surg. 2020 Dec 18:S0741-5214(20)32605-7. [doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2020.12.056](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvs.2020.12.056). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348007](https://pubmed.gov/33348007); [PMCID: PMC7748976](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7748976)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r31d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0179-2020-12-21-278.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0179-2020-12-21-278.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ad78718a7 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0179-2020-12-21-278.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Moisset X, Pereira B, Ciampi de Andrade D, Fontaine D, Lantéri-Minet M, Mawet J. Neuromodulation techniques for acute and preventive migraine treatment: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. J Headache Pain. 2020 Dec 10;21(1):142. [doi: 10.1186/s10194-020-01204-4](https://doi.org/10.1186/s10194-020-01204-4). [PMID: 33302882](https://pubmed.gov/33302882); [PMCID: PMC7726868](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7726868)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r278d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0180-2020-12-21-424.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0180-2020-12-21-424.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..48045f300 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0180-2020-12-21-424.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bai L, Gao S, Burstein F, Kerr D, Buntine P, Law N. A systematic literature review on unnecessary diagnostic testing: The role of ICT use. Int J Med Inform. 2020 Nov;143:104269. [doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104269](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104269). Epub 2020 Sep 8. [PMID: 32927268](https://pubmed.gov/32927268)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r424d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0181-2020-12-21-577.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0181-2020-12-21-577.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6d8961298 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0181-2020-12-21-577.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Gutsmiedl K, Krause M, Bighelli I, Schneider-Thoma J, Leucht S. How well do elderly patients with major depressive disorder respond to antidepressants: a systematic review and single-group meta-analysis. BMC Psychiatry. 2020 Mar 4;20(1):102. [doi: 10.1186/s12888-020-02514-2](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12888-020-02514-2). [PMID: 32131786](https://pubmed.gov/32131786); [PMCID: PMC7057600](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7057600)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r577d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0182-2020-12-21-114.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0182-2020-12-21-114.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cd4ab3968 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0182-2020-12-21-114.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Nussbaum ES, Mikoff N, Paranjape GS. Cognitive deficits among patients surviving aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage. A contemporary systematic review. Br J Neurosurg. 2020 Dec 21:1-18. [doi: 10.1080/02688697.2020.1859462](https://doi.org/10.1080/02688697.2020.1859462). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345644](https://pubmed.gov/33345644)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r114d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0183-2020-12-21-367.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0183-2020-12-21-367.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7cce8ca2f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0183-2020-12-21-367.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Talebi F, Malchi F, Abedi P, Jahanfar S. Effect of dill (Anethum Graveolens Linn) seed on the duration of labor: A systematic review. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101251. [doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101251](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101251). Epub 2020 Oct 28. [PMID: 33130423](https://pubmed.gov/33130423)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r367d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0184-2020-12-21-474.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0184-2020-12-21-474.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..29e505637 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0184-2020-12-21-474.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Vargas KG, Jäger B, Kaufmann CC, Biagioli A, Watremez S, Gatto F, Özbek C, Razouk A, Geppert A, Huber K. Impella in cardiogenic shock following acute myocardial infarction: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Wien Klin Wochenschr. 2020 Dec;132(23-24):716-725. [doi: 10.1007/s00508-020-01712-y](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00508-020-01712-y). Epub 2020 Jul 20. [PMID: 32691215](https://pubmed.gov/32691215)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r474d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0185-2020-12-21-684.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0185-2020-12-21-684.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8d4ad2c84 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0185-2020-12-21-684.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Matterne U, Baumeister SE, Apfelbacher CJ. Suicidality and risk of suicidality in psoriasis: a critical appraisal of two systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Br J Dermatol. 2019 Oct;181(4):717-721. [doi: 10.1111/bjd.18108](https://doi.org/10.1111/bjd.18108). Epub 2019 Aug 1. [PMID: 31074832](https://pubmed.gov/31074832)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r684d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0186-2020-12-21-249.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0186-2020-12-21-249.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0108a9daa --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0186-2020-12-21-249.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hu Y, Kattan C, Kontos D, Zhu W, Hernandez ME. Benefits of tai ji quan practice on neuromuscular functions in older adults: A Systematic Review and meta-analysis. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Dec 16;42:101295. [doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101295](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101295). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341582](https://pubmed.gov/33341582)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r249d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0187-2020-12-21-696.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0187-2020-12-21-696.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d726cfb64 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0187-2020-12-21-696.md @@ -0,0 +1,248 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Droege JR, Robinson WL, Jason LA. Suicidality Protective Factors for African American Adolescents: A Systematic Review of the Research Literature. SOJ Nurs Health Care. 2017;3(2):10.15226/2471-6529/3/2/00130. [doi: 10.15226/2471-6529/3/2/00130](https://doi.org/10.15226/2471-6529/3/2/00130). Epub 2017 May 31. [PMID: 33344874](https://pubmed.gov/33344874); [PMCID: PMC7747935](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7747935)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r696d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0188-2020-12-21-173.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0188-2020-12-21-173.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..50ce8400e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0188-2020-12-21-173.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Mei M, Chen YH, Meng T, Qu LH, Zhang ZY, Zhang X. Comparative efficacy and safety of radiotherapy/cetuximab versus radiotherapy/chemotherapy for locally advanced head and neck squamous cell carcinoma patients: a systematic review of published, primarily non-randomized, data. Ther Adv Med Oncol. 2020 Dec 8;12:1758835920975355. [doi: 10.1177/1758835920975355](https://doi.org/10.1177/1758835920975355). [PMID: 33343720](https://pubmed.gov/33343720); [PMCID: PMC7727048](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7727048)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r173d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0189-2020-12-21-435.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0189-2020-12-21-435.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b4869b026 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0189-2020-12-21-435.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chadalawada S, Sillau S, Archuleta S, Mundo W, Bandali M, Parra-Henao G, Rodriguez-Morales AJ, Villamil-Gomez WE, Suárez JA, Shapiro L, Hotez PJ, Woc- Colburn L, DeSanto K, Rassi A Jr, Franco-Paredes C, Henao-Martínez AF. Risk of Chronic Cardiomyopathy Among Patients With the Acute Phase or Indeterminate Form of Chagas Disease: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. JAMA Netw Open. 2020 Aug 3;3(8):e2015072. [doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.15072](https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.15072). [PMID: 32865573](https://pubmed.gov/32865573); [PMCID: PMC7489816](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7489816)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r435d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0190-2020-12-21-184.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0190-2020-12-21-184.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8ef8d6df3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0190-2020-12-21-184.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Qian H, Shao F, Lenahan C, Shao A, Li Y. Efficacy and Safety of Botulinum Toxin vs. Placebo in Depression: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Front Psychiatry. 2020 Dec 4;11:603087. [doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2020.603087](https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2020.603087). [PMID: 33343429](https://pubmed.gov/33343429); [PMCID: PMC7746677](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7746677)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r184d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0191-2020-12-21-113.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0191-2020-12-21-113.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b243f5ffb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0191-2020-12-21-113.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bellera CL, Llanos M, Gantner ME, Rodriguez S, Gavernet L, Comini M, Talevi A. Can drug repurposing strategies be the solution to the COVID-19 crisis? Expert Opin Drug Discov. 2020 Dec 23:1-8. [doi: 10.1080/17460441.2021.1863943](https://doi.org/10.1080/17460441.2021.1863943). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345645](https://pubmed.gov/33345645)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r113d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0192-2020-12-21-91.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0192-2020-12-21-91.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bd28317bc --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0192-2020-12-21-91.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Loggini A, Tangonan R, El Ammar F, Mansour A, Kramer CL, Lazaridis C, Goldenberg FD. Neuroendocrine dysfunction in the acute setting of penetrating brain injury: a systematic review. World Neurosurg. 2020 Dec 17:S1878-8750(20)32624-3. [doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2020.12.058](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wneu.2020.12.058). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346052](https://pubmed.gov/33346052)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r91d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0193-2020-12-21-605.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0193-2020-12-21-605.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b5b8ef204 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0193-2020-12-21-605.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘British Orthopaedic Association Trauma Committee. Electronic address: william.eardley@nhs.net. British Orthopaedic Association Standard for Trauma (BOAST): Open fracture management. Injury. 2020 Feb;51(2):174-177. [doi: 10.1016/j.injury.2019.12.034](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.injury.2019.12.034). Epub 2019 Dec 24. [PMID: 31926613](https://pubmed.gov/31926613)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r605d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0194-2020-12-21-267.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0194-2020-12-21-267.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0e9b958f8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0194-2020-12-21-267.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Dunn CG, Wilcox S, Saunders RP, Kaczynski AT, Blake CE, Turner-McGrievy GM. Healthy Eating and Physical Activity Interventions in Faith-Based Settings: A Systematic Review Using the Reach, Effectiveness/Efficacy, Adoption, Implementation, Maintenance Framework. Am J Prev Med. 2021 Jan;60(1):127-135. [doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2020.05.014](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amepre.2020.05.014). [PMID: 33341177](https://pubmed.gov/33341177)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r267d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0195-2020-12-21-4.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0195-2020-12-21-4.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a9e59bcc8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0195-2020-12-21-4.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Romero SA, Young K, Hickey M, Su HI. Levonorgestrel intrauterine system for endometrial protection in women with breast cancer on adjuvant tamoxifen. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Dec 21;12:CD007245. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007245.pub4](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD007245.pub4). [PMID: 33348436](https://pubmed.gov/33348436)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r4d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0196-2020-12-21-470.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0196-2020-12-21-470.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c6b92f2f6 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0196-2020-12-21-470.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Al-Samarraie H, Ghazal S, Alzahrani AI, Moody L. Telemedicine in Middle Eastern countries: Progress, barriers, and policy recommendations. Int J Med Inform. 2020 Sep;141:104232. [doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104232](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104232). Epub 2020 Jul 15. [PMID: 32707430](https://pubmed.gov/32707430)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r470d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0197-2020-12-21-616.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0197-2020-12-21-616.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..52ecb5a66 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0197-2020-12-21-616.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Wang Z, Liu BS, Wang XY, Peng JL, Huang XQ, Tian H, Wei QH, Wang LQ. Effects of fixed-time artificial insemination using triptorelin on the reproductive performance of pigs: a meta-analysis. Animal. 2020 Jul;14(7):1481-1492. [doi: 10.1017/S1751731119003008](https://doi.org/10.1017/S1751731119003008). Epub 2019 Dec 20. [PMID: 31858952](https://pubmed.gov/31858952)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r616d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0198-2020-12-21-612.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0198-2020-12-21-612.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3341ba6d3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0198-2020-12-21-612.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Mergenhagen KA, Wattengel BA, Skelly MK, Clark CM, Russo TA. Fact versus Fiction: a Review of the Evidence behind Alcohol and Antibiotic Interactions. Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 2020 Feb 21;64(3):e02167-19. [doi: 10.1128/AAC.02167-19](https://doi.org/10.1128/AAC.02167-19). [PMID: 31871085](https://pubmed.gov/31871085); [PMCID: PMC7038249](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7038249)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r612d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0199-2020-12-21-347.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0199-2020-12-21-347.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e68a40ee2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0199-2020-12-21-347.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Moresco L, Bruschettini M, Calevo MG, Siri L. Pharmacological treatment for continuous spike-wave during slow wave sleep syndrome and Landau-Kleffner Syndrome. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 6;11:CD013132. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013132.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD013132.pub2). [PMID: 33174224](https://pubmed.gov/33174224)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r347d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0200-2020-12-21-693.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0200-2020-12-21-693.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8b9778ff3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0200-2020-12-21-693.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Romero-Martínez Á, Hidalgo-Moreno G, Moya-Albiol L. Neuropsychological consequences of chronic stress: the case of informal caregivers. Aging Ment Health. 2020 Feb;24(2):259-271. [doi: 10.1080/13607863.2018.1537360](https://doi.org/10.1080/13607863.2018.1537360). Epub 2018 Nov 18. [PMID: 30450952](https://pubmed.gov/30450952)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r693d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0201-2020-12-21-97.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0201-2020-12-21-97.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d3d4e9aaf --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0201-2020-12-21-97.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Pavalagantharajah S, Villani LA, D'Souza R. Vasa previa and associated risk factors: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 Aug;2(3):100117. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100117](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100117). Epub 2020 Apr 15. [PMID: 33345868](https://pubmed.gov/33345868)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r97d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0202-2020-12-21-111.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0202-2020-12-21-111.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..34880624e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0202-2020-12-21-111.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Di Tucci C, Galati G, Mattei G, Bonanni V, Capri O, D'Amelio R, Muzii L, Benedetti Panici P. The role of alpha lipoic acid in female and male infertility: a systematic review. Gynecol Endocrinol. 2020 Dec 21:1-9. [doi: 10.1080/09513590.2020.1843619](https://doi.org/10.1080/09513590.2020.1843619). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345661](https://pubmed.gov/33345661)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r111d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0203-2020-12-21-216.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0203-2020-12-21-216.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c92b73649 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0203-2020-12-21-216.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chojnacki GJ, Gothro AG, Gleason PM, Forrestal SG. A Randomized Controlled Trial Measuring Effects of Extra Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) Benefits on Child Food Security in Low-Income Families in Rural Kentucky. J Acad Nutr Diet. 2021 Jan;121(1S):S9-S21. [doi: 10.1016/j.jand.2020.05.017](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jand.2020.05.017). [PMID: 33342530](https://pubmed.gov/33342530)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r216d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0204-2020-12-21-220.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0204-2020-12-21-220.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a4bccdf1f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0204-2020-12-21-220.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Mack SA. Eliminating the stigma: A systematic review of the health effects of low-dose radiation within the diagnostic imaging department and its implications for the future of medical radiation. J Med Imaging Radiat Sci. 2020 Dec;51(4):662-670. [doi: 10.1016/j.jmir.2020.07.052](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmir.2020.07.052). Epub 2020 Oct 21. [PMID: 33342484](https://pubmed.gov/33342484)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r220d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0205-2020-12-21-586.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0205-2020-12-21-586.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..83f4cdfd8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0205-2020-12-21-586.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ma F, Zhi C, Wang M, Li T, Khan SA, Ma Z, Jing Z, Bo C, Zhou Q, Xia S, Huang S, Huang S, Zhang Z, Jia H, Cui X, Yao M, Ji T. Dysregulated NF-κB signal promotes the hub gene PCLAF expression to facilitate nasopharyngeal carcinoma proliferation and metastasis. Biomed Pharmacother. 2020 May;125:109905. [doi: 10.1016/j.biopha.2020.109905](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopha.2020.109905). Epub 2020 Feb 25. [PMID: 32070873](https://pubmed.gov/32070873)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r586d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0206-2020-12-21-143.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0206-2020-12-21-143.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..07e568e45 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0206-2020-12-21-143.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Fausak ED. A Mapping Study of Veterinary Literature on Perceptions and Attitudes of Female Canine Spaying. Front Vet Sci. 2020 Dec 4;7:559659. [doi: 10.3389/fvets.2020.559659](https://doi.org/10.3389/fvets.2020.559659). [PMID: 33344522](https://pubmed.gov/33344522); [PMCID: PMC7746841](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7746841)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r143d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0207-2020-12-21-581.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0207-2020-12-21-581.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..016f1d7ac --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0207-2020-12-21-581.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Wan Y, Wu X, Kou Y. The Impact of Text Message On Self-Management for Coronary Heart Disease: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Heart Surg Forum. 2020 Feb 10;23(1):E018-E024. [doi: 10.1532/hsf.2519](https://doi.org/10.1532/hsf.2519). [PMID: 32118537](https://pubmed.gov/32118537)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r581d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0208-2020-12-21-611.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0208-2020-12-21-611.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..43cc59f23 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0208-2020-12-21-611.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kim SH, Djaja YP, Park YB, Park JG, Ko YB, Ha CW. Intra-articular Injection of Culture-Expanded Mesenchymal Stem Cells Without Adjuvant Surgery in Knee Osteoarthritis: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2020 Sep;48(11):2839-2849. [doi: 10.1177/0363546519892278](https://doi.org/10.1177/0363546519892278). Epub 2019 Dec 24. [PMID: 31874044](https://pubmed.gov/31874044)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r611d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0209-2020-12-21-226.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0209-2020-12-21-226.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..02982a061 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0209-2020-12-21-226.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bills SE, Johnston JD, Shi D, Bradshaw J. Social-environmental moderators of neurodevelopmental outcomes in youth born preterm: A systematic review. Child Neuropsychol. 2020 Dec 21:1-20. [doi: 10.1080/09297049.2020.1861229](https://doi.org/10.1080/09297049.2020.1861229). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342364](https://pubmed.gov/33342364)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r226d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0210-2020-12-21-391.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0210-2020-12-21-391.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..39b74ebf7 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0210-2020-12-21-391.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Heckwolf MJ, Peterson A, Jänes H, Horne P, Künne J, Liversage K, Sajeva M, Reusch TBH, Kotta J. From ecosystems to socio-economic benefits: A systematic review of coastal ecosystem services in the Baltic Sea. Sci Total Environ. 2021 Feb 10;755(Pt 2):142565. [doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142565](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142565). Epub 2020 Sep 30. [PMID: 33059139](https://pubmed.gov/33059139)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r391d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0211-2020-12-21-323.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0211-2020-12-21-323.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3eb4a7db2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0211-2020-12-21-323.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘You YN, Hardiman KM, Bafford A, Poylin V, Francone TD, Davis K, Paquette IM, Steele SR, Feingold DL; Clinical Practice Guidelines Committee of the American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons. The American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons Clinical Practice Guidelines for the Management of Rectal Cancer. Dis Colon Rectum. 2020 Sep;63(9):1191-1222. [doi: 10.1097/DCR.0000000000001762](https://doi.org/10.1097/DCR.0000000000001762). [PMID: 33216491](https://pubmed.gov/33216491)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r323d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0212-2020-12-21-245.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0212-2020-12-21-245.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a0f9acc96 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0212-2020-12-21-245.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ribeiro RAB, Soeiro CBBM. Analysing criminal profiling validity: Underlying problems and future directions. Int J Law Psychiatry. 2020 Dec 17;74:101670. [doi: 10.1016/j.ijlp.2020.101670](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijlp.2020.101670). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341721](https://pubmed.gov/33341721)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r245d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0213-2020-12-21-120.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0213-2020-12-21-120.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..53c545785 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0213-2020-12-21-120.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Melazzini L, Vitali P, Olivieri E, Bolchini M, Zanardo M, Savoldi F, Di Leo G, Griffanti L, Baselli G, Sardanelli F, Codari M. White Matter Hyperintensities Quantification in Healthy Adults: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2020 Dec 20. [doi: 10.1002/jmri.27479](https://doi.org/10.1002/jmri.27479). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345393](https://pubmed.gov/33345393)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r120d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0214-2020-12-21-465.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0214-2020-12-21-465.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..127487f67 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0214-2020-12-21-465.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ostaszkiewicz J, Dickson-Swift V, Hutchinson A, Wagg A. A concept analysis of dignity-protective continence care for care dependent older people in long- term care settings. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Jul 29;20(1):266. [doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01673-x](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-020-01673-x). [PMID: 32727481](https://pubmed.gov/32727481); [PMCID: PMC7392826](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7392826)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r465d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0215-2020-12-21-404.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0215-2020-12-21-404.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fe1b24847 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0215-2020-12-21-404.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Gissi E, Manea E, Mazaris AD, Fraschetti S, Almpanidou V, Bevilacqua S, Coll M, Guarnieri G, Lloret-Lloret E, Pascual M, Petza D, Rilov G, Schonwald M, Stelzenmüller V, Katsanevakis S. A review of the combined effects of climate change and other local human stressors on the marine environment. Sci Total Environ. 2021 Feb 10;755(Pt 1):142564. [doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142564](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142564). Epub 2020 Sep 29. [PMID: 33035971](https://pubmed.gov/33035971)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r404d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0216-2020-12-21-211.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0216-2020-12-21-211.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3bd4dd697 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0216-2020-12-21-211.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘van Ommen-Nijhof A, Steenbruggen TG, Schats W, Wiersma T, Horlings HM, Mann R, Koppert L, van Werkhoven E, Sonke GS, Jager A. Erratum to "Prognostic factors in patients with oligometastatic breast cancer - A systematic review". [Cancer treatment Rev. 91 (2020) 102114]. Cancer Treat Rev. 2020 Dec 17:102138. [doi: 10.1016/j.ctrv.2020.102138](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctrv.2020.102138). Epub ahead of print. Erratum for: Cancer Treat Rev. 2020 Dec;91:102114. [PMID: 33342599](https://pubmed.gov/33342599)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r211d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0217-2020-12-21-458.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0217-2020-12-21-458.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4be8e1ca5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0217-2020-12-21-458.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Barochiner J, Martínez R. Use of inhibitors of the renin-angiotensin system in hypertensive patients and COVID-19 severity: A systematic review and meta- analysis. J Clin Pharm Ther. 2020 Dec;45(6):1244-1252. [doi: 10.1111/jcpt.13246](https://doi.org/10.1111/jcpt.13246). Epub 2020 Aug 7. [PMID: 32767823](https://pubmed.gov/32767823); [PMCID: PMC7436708](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7436708)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r458d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0218-2020-12-21-325.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0218-2020-12-21-325.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7b880d98f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0218-2020-12-21-325.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Du Y, Li WP, Xiong H, Zhang S, Zhou ZY, Deng JP, Zhang JN. [Efficacy and safety of pylorus-preserving gastrectomy for early gastric cancer located in the middle third of the stomach: a meta-analysis]. Zhonghua Wei Chang Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2020 Nov 25;23(11):1088-1096. Chinese. [doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn.441530-20200228-00098](https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.cn.441530-20200228-00098). [PMID: 33212558](https://pubmed.gov/33212558)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r325d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0219-2020-12-21-633.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0219-2020-12-21-633.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a26fdc637 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0219-2020-12-21-633.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Babiker A, Hassan M, Muhammed S, Taylor G, Poonia B, Shah A, Bagchi S. Inflammatory and cardiovascular diseases biomarkers in chronic hepatitis C virus infection: A review. Clin Cardiol. 2020 Mar;43(3):222-234. [doi: 10.1002/clc.23299](https://doi.org/10.1002/clc.23299). Epub 2019 Nov 30. [PMID: 31785111](https://pubmed.gov/31785111); [PMCID: PMC7068107](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7068107)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r633d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0220-2020-12-21-683.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0220-2020-12-21-683.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a07393c2a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0220-2020-12-21-683.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Drosatos G, Kaldoudi E. A probabilistic semantic analysis of eHealth scientific literature. J Telemed Telecare. 2020 Aug-Sep;26(7-8):414-432. [doi: 10.1177/1357633X19846252](https://doi.org/10.1177/1357633X19846252). Epub 2019 May 12. Erratum in: J Telemed Telecare. 2020 Apr;26(3):NP1. [PMID: 31081450](https://pubmed.gov/31081450)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r683d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0221-2020-12-21-449.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0221-2020-12-21-449.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..950443adc --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0221-2020-12-21-449.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Pitros P, O'Connor N, Tryfonos A, Lopes V. A systematic review of the complications of high-risk third molar removal and coronectomy: development of a decision tree model and preliminary health economic analysis to assist in treatment planning. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 Nov;58(9):e16-e24. [doi: 10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.07.015](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.07.015). Epub 2020 Aug 14. [PMID: 32800608](https://pubmed.gov/32800608)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r449d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0222-2020-12-21-665.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0222-2020-12-21-665.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..be2ba5a38 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0222-2020-12-21-665.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Andrade-González N, Hernández-Gómez A, Álvarez-Sesmero S, Gutiérrez-Rojas L, Vieta E, Reinares M, Lahera G. The influence of the working alliance on the treatment and outcomes of patients with bipolar disorder: A systematic review. J Affect Disord. 2020 Jan 1;260:263-271. [doi: 10.1016/j.jad.2019.09.014](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2019.09.014). Epub 2019 Sep 3. [PMID: 31521862](https://pubmed.gov/31521862)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r665d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0223-2020-12-21-473.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0223-2020-12-21-473.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fb89c7160 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0223-2020-12-21-473.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Pool J, Akhlaghpour S, Fatehi F. Towards a contextual theory of Mobile Health Data Protection (MHDP): A realist perspective. Int J Med Inform. 2020 Sep;141:104229. [doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104229](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104229). Epub 2020 Jul 11. [PMID: 32693246](https://pubmed.gov/32693246)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r473d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0224-2020-12-21-341.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0224-2020-12-21-341.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..31f53beaf --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0224-2020-12-21-341.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhao J, Chen M, Zhuo C, Huang Y, Zheng L, Wang Q. The Effect of Renin- Angiotensin System Inhibitors on the Recurrence of Atrial Fibrillation After Catheter Ablation. Int Heart J. 2020 Nov 28;61(6):1174-1182. [doi: 10.1536/ihj.20-346](https://doi.org/10.1536/ihj.20-346). Epub 2020 Nov 13. [PMID: 33191354](https://pubmed.gov/33191354)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r341d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0225-2020-12-21-250.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0225-2020-12-21-250.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..49a17ee97 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0225-2020-12-21-250.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Adam MG, Tran PTM, Bolan N, Balasubramanian R. Biomass burning-derived airborne particulate matter in Southeast Asia: A critical review. J Hazard Mater. 2020 Dec 3;407:124760. [doi: 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2020.124760](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2020.124760). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341572](https://pubmed.gov/33341572)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r250d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0226-2020-12-21-440.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0226-2020-12-21-440.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2891b5882 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0226-2020-12-21-440.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Davis SP, Bolin LP, Crane PB, Wei H, Crandell J. Non-pharmacological interventions to manage fatigue in adults with inflammatory bowel disease: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101229. [doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101229](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101229). Epub 2020 Aug 13. [PMID: 32836107](https://pubmed.gov/32836107)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r440d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0227-2020-12-21-306.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0227-2020-12-21-306.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..66e2063aa --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0227-2020-12-21-306.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Radcliffe C, Lier A, Doilicho N, Parikh S, Kaddouh F. Bordetella bronchiseptica: a rare cause of meningitis. BMC Infect Dis. 2020 Dec 3;20(1):922. [doi: 10.1186/s12879-020-05668-2](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12879-020-05668-2). [PMID: 33272197](https://pubmed.gov/33272197); [PMCID: PMC7713019](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7713019)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r306d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0228-2020-12-21-131.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0228-2020-12-21-131.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..007cbc1a1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0228-2020-12-21-131.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Geurin AN, Naraine ML. 20 Years of Olympic Media Research: Trends and Future Directions. Front Sports Act Living. 2020 Sep 29;2:572495. [doi: 10.3389/fspor.2020.572495](https://doi.org/10.3389/fspor.2020.572495). [PMID: 33345133](https://pubmed.gov/33345133); [PMCID: PMC7739588](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7739588)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r131d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0229-2020-12-21-246.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0229-2020-12-21-246.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..67ee2b03e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0229-2020-12-21-246.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Varghese J, Gohari SS, Rizki H, Faheem I, Langridge B, Kümmel S, Johnson L, Schmid P. A systematic review and meta-analysis on the effect of neoadjuvant chemotherapy on complications following immediate breast reconstruction. Breast. 2020 Dec 3;55:55-62. [doi: 10.1016/j.breast.2020.11.023](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.breast.2020.11.023). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341706](https://pubmed.gov/33341706)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r246d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0230-2020-12-21-344.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0230-2020-12-21-344.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ea96a2093 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0230-2020-12-21-344.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ball L, Almondo C, Pelosi P. Perioperative Lung Protection: General Mechanisms and Protective Approaches. Anesth Analg. 2020 Dec;131(6):1789-1798. [doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000005246](https://doi.org/10.1213/ANE.0000000000005246). [PMID: 33186165](https://pubmed.gov/33186165)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r344d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0231-2020-12-21-460.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0231-2020-12-21-460.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..477fb3445 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0231-2020-12-21-460.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Crick M, Devey-Burry R, Hu J, Angus DE, Backman C. The role of regulation in the care of older people with depression living in long-term care: a systematic scoping review. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Aug 5;20(1):273. [doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01675-9](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-020-01675-9). [PMID: 32758157](https://pubmed.gov/32758157); [PMCID: PMC7409447](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7409447)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r460d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0232-2020-12-21-134.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0232-2020-12-21-134.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f95ee055d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0232-2020-12-21-134.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Conforti F, Pala L, Bagnardi V, Specchia C, Oriecuia C, Marra A, Zagami P, Morganti S, Tarantino P, Catania C, De Marinis F, Queirolo P, De Pas T. EGFR-TKI Plus Anti-Angiogenic Drugs in EGFR-Mutated Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer: A Meta- Analysis of Randomized Clinical Trials. JNCI Cancer Spectr. 2020 Jul 29;4(6):pkaa064. [doi: 10.1093/jncics/pkaa064](https://doi.org/10.1093/jncics/pkaa064). [PMID: 33344882](https://pubmed.gov/33344882); [PMCID: PMC7737478](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7737478)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r134d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0233-2020-12-21-310.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0233-2020-12-21-310.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b48f58cfc --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0233-2020-12-21-310.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhang L, Silva TC, Young JI, Gomez L, Schmidt MA, Hamilton-Nelson KL, Kunkle BW, Chen X, Martin ER, Wang L. Epigenome-wide meta-analysis of DNA methylation differences in prefrontal cortex implicates the immune processes in Alzheimer's disease. Nat Commun. 2020 Nov 30;11(1):6114. [doi: 10.1038/s41467-020-19791-w](https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-020-19791-w). [PMID: 33257653](https://pubmed.gov/33257653); [PMCID: PMC7704686](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7704686)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r310d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0234-2020-12-21-197.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0234-2020-12-21-197.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..186fcb503 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0234-2020-12-21-197.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chen CX, Liu ML, Cao K, Yusufu M, Wang JD. Diagnostic value of optical coherence tomography angiography for choroidal neovascularization in age-related macular degeneration: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Ophthalmic Res. 2020 Dec 16. [doi: 10.1159/000511265](https://doi.org/10.1159/000511265). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342974](https://pubmed.gov/33342974)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r197d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0235-2020-12-21-174.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0235-2020-12-21-174.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..99bdafd28 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0235-2020-12-21-174.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Tsivgoulis G, Palaiodimou L, Zand R, Lioutas VA, Krogias C, Katsanos AH, Shoamanesh A, Sharma VK, Shahjouei S, Baracchini C, Vlachopoulos C, Gournellis R, Sfikakis PP, Sandset EC, Alexandrov AV, Tsiodras S. COVID-19 and cerebrovascular diseases: a comprehensive overview. Ther Adv Neurol Disord. 2020 Dec 8;13:1756286420978004. [doi: 10.1177/1756286420978004](https://doi.org/10.1177/1756286420978004). [PMID: 33343709](https://pubmed.gov/33343709); [PMCID: PMC7727052](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7727052)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r174d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0236-2020-12-21-162.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0236-2020-12-21-162.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..63645cf1f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0236-2020-12-21-162.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Charles D, White R, Reyes C, Palmer D. A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF THE EFFECTS OF BLOOD FLOW RESTRICTION TRAINING ON QUADRICEPS MUSCLE ATROPHY AND CIRCUMFERENCE POST ACL RECONSTRUCTION. Int J Sports Phys Ther. 2020 Dec;15(6):882-891. [doi: 10.26603/ijspt20200882](https://doi.org/10.26603/ijspt20200882). [PMID: 33344004](https://pubmed.gov/33344004); [PMCID: PMC7727417](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7727417)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r162d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0237-2020-12-21-316.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0237-2020-12-21-316.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6aad67e6b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0237-2020-12-21-316.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Van der Loo LE, Aquarius R, Teernstra O, Klijn K, Menovsky T, van Dijk JMC, Bartels R, Boogaarts HD. Iron chelators for acute stroke. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 24;11:CD009280. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009280.pub3](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD009280.pub3). [PMID: 33236783](https://pubmed.gov/33236783)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r316d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0238-2020-12-21-282.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0238-2020-12-21-282.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..44462a628 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0238-2020-12-21-282.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Holford P, Carr AC, Jovic TH, Ali SR, Whitaker IS, Marik PE, Smith AD. Vitamin C-An Adjunctive Therapy for Respiratory Infection, Sepsis and COVID-19. Nutrients. 2020 Dec 7;12(12):E3760. [doi: 10.3390/nu12123760](https://doi.org/10.3390/nu12123760). [PMID: 33297491](https://pubmed.gov/33297491)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r282d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0239-2020-12-21-381.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0239-2020-12-21-381.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4eaeb0c9d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0239-2020-12-21-381.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lopes LCP, Terada RSS, Tsuzuki FM, Giannini M, Hirata R. Heating and preheating of dental restorative materials-a systematic review. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Dec;24(12):4225-4235. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03637-2](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-020-03637-2). Epub 2020 Oct 20. [PMID: 33083851](https://pubmed.gov/33083851)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r381d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0240-2020-12-21-151.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0240-2020-12-21-151.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9534a711d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0240-2020-12-21-151.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Caruso G, Scopelliti A, Scaramuzzino S, Perrone G, Galoppi P, Palaia I, Muzii L, Panici PB, Brunelli R. Cabergoline as an adjuvant to standard heart failure treatment in peripartum cardiomyopathy: A case report and review of the literature. Case Rep Womens Health. 2020 Dec 7;29:e00277. [doi: 10.1016/j.crwh.2020.e00277](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crwh.2020.e00277). [PMID: 33344177](https://pubmed.gov/33344177); [PMCID: PMC7736906](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7736906)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r151d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0241-2020-12-21-409.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0241-2020-12-21-409.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5ecb05a2b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0241-2020-12-21-409.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘St Jeor JD, Reisenauer CJ, Andrews JC, Fleming CJ, Misra S, Takahashi EA. Transjugular Renal Biopsy Bleeding Risk and Diagnostic Yield: A Systematic Review. J Vasc Interv Radiol. 2020 Dec;31(12):2106-2112. [doi: 10.1016/j.jvir.2020.07.016](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvir.2020.07.016). Epub 2020 Oct 3. [PMID: 33023806](https://pubmed.gov/33023806)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r409d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0242-2020-12-21-624.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0242-2020-12-21-624.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..abb00559b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0242-2020-12-21-624.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Böhnlein J, Altegoer L, Muck NK, Roesmann K, Redlich R, Dannlowski U, Leehr EJ. Factors influencing the success of exposure therapy for specific phobia: A systematic review. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:796-820. [doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.009](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.009). Epub 2019 Dec 9. [PMID: 31830494](https://pubmed.gov/31830494)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r624d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0243-2020-12-21-593.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0243-2020-12-21-593.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3d5c511bf --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0243-2020-12-21-593.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Rezar R, Jirak P, Lichtenauer M, Jung C, Lauten A, Hoppe UC, Wernly B. Partial oral antibiotic therapy is non-inferior to intravenous therapy in non- critically ill patients with infective endocarditis : Review and meta-analysis. Wien Klin Wochenschr. 2020 Dec;132(23-24):762-769. [doi: 10.1007/s00508-020-01614-z](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00508-020-01614-z). Epub 2020 Feb 10. [PMID: 32040621](https://pubmed.gov/32040621); [PMCID: PMC7732798](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7732798)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r593d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0244-2020-12-21-61.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0244-2020-12-21-61.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e6e5e392f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0244-2020-12-21-61.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hughes LD, Lum J, Mahfoud Z, Malik RA, Anand A, Charalambous CP. Comparison of Surgical Site Infection Risk Between Warfarin, LMWH, and Aspirin for Venous Thromboprophylaxis in TKA or THA: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. JBJS Rev. 2020 Dec 18;8(12):e20.00021. [doi: 10.2106/JBJS.RVW.20.00021](https://doi.org/10.2106/JBJS.RVW.20.00021). [PMID: 33347014](https://pubmed.gov/33347014)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r61d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0245-2020-12-21-626.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0245-2020-12-21-626.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d90786bbe --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0245-2020-12-21-626.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Yuan C, Zhou Y, Pan Y, Wang J. Curative effect comparison of transforaminal endoscopic spine system and traditional open discectomy: a meta-analysis. ANZ J Surg. 2020 Jan;90(1-2):123-129. [doi: 10.1111/ans.15579](https://doi.org/10.1111/ans.15579). Epub 2019 Dec 11. [PMID: 31828889](https://pubmed.gov/31828889)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r626d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0246-2020-12-21-636.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0246-2020-12-21-636.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e9b8613fb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0246-2020-12-21-636.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Luo L, Fu M, Li Y, Chen Z, Yu J, Luo J, Hu S, Tu L, Xu X. The efficacy and safety of P2Y12 inhibitor monotherapy in patients after percutaneous coronary intervention. Clin Cardiol. 2020 Mar;43(3):235-241. [doi: 10.1002/clc.23305](https://doi.org/10.1002/clc.23305). Epub 2019 Nov 28. [PMID: 31777973](https://pubmed.gov/31777973); [PMCID: PMC7068072](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7068072)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r636d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0247-2020-12-21-387.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0247-2020-12-21-387.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e5f1274df --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0247-2020-12-21-387.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Alshami A, Einav S, Skrifvars MB, Varon J. Administration of inhaled noble and other gases after cardiopulmonary resuscitation: A systematic review. Am J Emerg Med. 2020 Oct;38(10):2179-2184. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajem.2020.06.066](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajem.2020.06.066). Epub 2020 Jul 2. [PMID: 33071073](https://pubmed.gov/33071073)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r387d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0248-2020-12-21-353.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0248-2020-12-21-353.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2bbbd6363 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0248-2020-12-21-353.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Yue JL, Yan W, Sun YK, Yuan K, Su SZ, Han Y, Ravindran AV, Kosten T, Everall I, Davey CG, Bullmore E, Kawakami N, Barbui C, Thornicroft G, Lund C, Lin X, Liu L, Shi L, Shi J, Ran MS, Bao YP, Lu L. Mental health services for infectious disease outbreaks including COVID-19: a rapid systematic review. Psychol Med. 2020 Nov;50(15):2498-2513. [doi: 10.1017/S0033291720003888](https://doi.org/10.1017/S0033291720003888). Epub 2020 Nov 5. [PMID: 33148347](https://pubmed.gov/33148347); [PMCID: PMC7642960](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7642960)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r353d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0249-2020-12-21-209.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0249-2020-12-21-209.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3e5a54fad --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0249-2020-12-21-209.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Dombalis S, Nash A. The Effect of Statins in Children and Adolescents With Familial Hypercholesterolemia: A Systematic Review. J Pediatr Health Care. 2020 Dec 17:S0891-5245(20)30308-4. [doi: 10.1016/j.pedhc.2020.11.007](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pedhc.2020.11.007). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342622](https://pubmed.gov/33342622)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r209d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0250-2020-12-21-212.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0250-2020-12-21-212.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a9b276eea --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0250-2020-12-21-212.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Gibbons AJ, Moss CE. Re: systematic review of lingual nerve retraction during surgical mandibular third molar extractions. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 Nov 28:S0266-4356(20)30904-9. [doi: 10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.11.014](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.11.014). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342589](https://pubmed.gov/33342589)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r212d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0251-2020-12-21-468.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0251-2020-12-21-468.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ebc1a9533 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0251-2020-12-21-468.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Tay EL, Hayashida K, Chen M, Yin WH, Park DW, Seth A, Kao HL, Lin MS, Ho KW, Buddhari W, Chandavimol M, Posas FE, Nguyen QN, Kong W, Rosli MA, Hon J, Firman D, Lee M. Transcatheter aortic valve implantation during the COVID-19 pandemic: Clinical expert opinion and consensus statement for Asia. J Card Surg. 2020 Sep;35(9):2142-2146. [doi: 10.1111/jocs.14722](https://doi.org/10.1111/jocs.14722). Epub 2020 Jul 27. [PMID: 32720374](https://pubmed.gov/32720374)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r468d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0252-2020-12-21-83.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0252-2020-12-21-83.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d8fad498d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0252-2020-12-21-83.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sridharan K, Sivaramakrishnan G. A network meta-analysis of CYP2C9, CYP2C9 with VKORC1 and CYP2C9 with VKORC1 and CYP4F2 genotype-based warfarin dosing strategies compared to traditional. J Clin Pharm Ther. 2020 Dec 21. [doi: 10.1111/jcpt.13334](https://doi.org/10.1111/jcpt.13334). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346393](https://pubmed.gov/33346393)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r83d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0253-2020-12-21-574.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0253-2020-12-21-574.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6a657c7ab --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0253-2020-12-21-574.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chen X, Yang Z, Li H, Zhu S, Wang Y, Qian W. Higher risk of revision in total knee arthroplasty after high tibial osteotomy: a systematic review and updated meta-analysis. BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2020 Mar 6;21(1):153. [doi: 10.1186/s12891-020-3177-9](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12891-020-3177-9). [PMID: 32143608](https://pubmed.gov/32143608); [PMCID: PMC7060637](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7060637)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r574d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0254-2020-12-21-118.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0254-2020-12-21-118.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a29aa1ac7 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0254-2020-12-21-118.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Huang X, Xue J, Gao M, Qin Q, Ma T, Li X, Wang H. Medical Management of Inoperable Malignant Bowel Obstruction. Ann Pharmacother. 2020 Dec 21:1060028020979773. [doi: 10.1177/1060028020979773](https://doi.org/10.1177/1060028020979773). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345552](https://pubmed.gov/33345552)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r118d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0255-2020-12-21-319.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0255-2020-12-21-319.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e9f8ef627 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0255-2020-12-21-319.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Fabrizio V, Trzaski JM, Brownell EA, Esposito P, Lainwala S, Lussier MM, Hagadorn JI. Individualized versus standard diet fortification for growth and development in preterm infants receiving human milk. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 23;11:CD013465. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013465.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD013465.pub2). [PMID: 33226632](https://pubmed.gov/33226632)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r319d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0256-2020-12-21-598.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0256-2020-12-21-598.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d46e3f76d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0256-2020-12-21-598.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Foronda CL, Fernandez-Burgos M, Nadeau C, Kelley CN, Henry MN. Virtual Simulation in Nursing Education: A Systematic Review Spanning 1996 to 2018. Simul Healthc. 2020 Feb;15(1):46-54. [doi: 10.1097/SIH.0000000000000411](https://doi.org/10.1097/SIH.0000000000000411). [PMID: 32028447](https://pubmed.gov/32028447)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r598d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0257-2020-12-21-169.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0257-2020-12-21-169.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d4ccd4bfa --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0257-2020-12-21-169.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Toumi M, Biernikiewicz M, Liang S, Wang Y, Qiu T, Han R. A critical analysis and review of Lancet COVID-19 hydroxychloroquine study. J Mark Access Health Policy. 2020 Sep 10;8(1):1809236. [doi: 10.1080/20016689.2020.1809236](https://doi.org/10.1080/20016689.2020.1809236). [PMID: 33343837](https://pubmed.gov/33343837); [PMCID: PMC7733902](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7733902)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r169d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0258-2020-12-21-199.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0258-2020-12-21-199.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6e8944f69 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0258-2020-12-21-199.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Giuseppe ZR, Silvia C, Eleonora F, Gabriella M, Marica F, Silvia C, Mario B, Francesco D, Savino C, Milly B, Frezza GP, Maurizio Z, Morganti AG. Hippocampal-sparing radiotherapy and neurocognitive impairment: A systematic literature review. J Cancer Res Ther. 2020 Oct-Dec;16(6):1215-1222. [doi: 10.4103/jcrt.JCRT_573_17](https://doi.org/10.4103/jcrt.JCRT_573_17). [PMID: 33342776](https://pubmed.gov/33342776)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r199d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0259-2020-12-21-64.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0259-2020-12-21-64.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..468cc7e21 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0259-2020-12-21-64.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Navas-Blanco JR, Louro J, Reynolds J, Epstein RH, Dudaryk R. Intraoperative Focused Cardiac Ultrasound for Assessment of Hypotension: A Systematic Review. Anesth Analg. 2020 Dec 18. [doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000005336](https://doi.org/10.1213/ANE.0000000000005336). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346986](https://pubmed.gov/33346986)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r64d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0260-2020-12-21-668.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0260-2020-12-21-668.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0f95f688b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0260-2020-12-21-668.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Dimitrov E, Enchev E, Minkov G, Halacheva K, Yovtchev Y. Poor Outcome Could Be Predicted by Lower Monocyte Human Leukocyte Antigen-DR Expression in Patients with Complicated Intra-Abdominal Infections: A Review. Surg Infect (Larchmt). 2020 Mar;21(2):77-80. [doi: 10.1089/sur.2019.050](https://doi.org/10.1089/sur.2019.050). Epub 2019 Sep 4. [PMID: 31483200](https://pubmed.gov/31483200)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r668d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0261-2020-12-21-445.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0261-2020-12-21-445.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..95772f671 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0261-2020-12-21-445.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Migliavaca CB, Stein C, Colpani V, Eibel B, Bgeginski R, Simões MV, Rohde LE, Falavigna M. High-dose versus low-dose angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitors in heart failure: systematic review and meta-analysis. Open Heart. 2020 Aug;7(2):e001228. [doi: 10.1136/openhrt-2019-001228](https://doi.org/10.1136/openhrt-2019-001228). [PMID: 32820054](https://pubmed.gov/32820054); [PMCID: PMC7443275](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7443275)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r445d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0262-2020-12-21-691.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0262-2020-12-21-691.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f89df6470 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0262-2020-12-21-691.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Røsvik J, Michelet M, Engedal K, Bieber A, Broda A, Gonçalves-Pereira M, Hopper L, Irving K, Jelley H, Kerpershoek L, Meyer G, Marques MJ, Portolani E, Sjölund BM, Sköldunger A, Stephan A, Verhey F, de Vugt M, Woods B, Wolfs C, Zanetti O, Selbaek G. Interventions to enhance access to and utilization of formal community care services for home dwelling persons with dementia and their informal carers. A scoping review. Aging Ment Health. 2020 Feb;24(2):200-211. [doi: 10.1080/13607863.2018.1523876](https://doi.org/10.1080/13607863.2018.1523876). Epub 2019 Jan 21. [PMID: 30663890](https://pubmed.gov/30663890)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r691d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0263-2020-12-21-369.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0263-2020-12-21-369.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..889ad10f5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0263-2020-12-21-369.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhu S, Liu L, Xu Y, Yang Y, Shi R. Application of controlled release urea improved grain yield and nitrogen use efficiency: A meta-analysis. PLoS One. 2020 Oct 29;15(10):e0241481. [doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0241481](https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0241481). [PMID: 33119693](https://pubmed.gov/33119693); [PMCID: PMC7595396](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7595396)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r369d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0264-2020-12-21-183.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0264-2020-12-21-183.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..05c837b44 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0264-2020-12-21-183.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Oppong S. Towards a Model of Valued Human Cognitive Abilities: An African Perspective Based on a Systematic Review. Front Psychol. 2020 Dec 4;11:538072. [doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.538072](https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.538072). [PMID: 33343437](https://pubmed.gov/33343437); [PMCID: PMC7746612](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7746612)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r183d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0265-2020-12-21-259.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0265-2020-12-21-259.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..241b6d8b6 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0265-2020-12-21-259.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Wreesmann WW, Lorié ES, van Veenendaal NR, van Kempen AAMW, Ket JCF, Labrie NHM. The functions of adequate communication in the neonatal care unit: A systematic review and meta-synthesis of qualitative research. Patient Educ Couns. 2020 Nov 28:S0738-3991(20)30653-4. [doi: 10.1016/j.pec.2020.11.029](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pec.2020.11.029). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341329](https://pubmed.gov/33341329)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r259d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0266-2020-12-21-590.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0266-2020-12-21-590.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d896e6ca6 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0266-2020-12-21-590.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kabacińska K, Sharma N, Kaye J, Mattek N, Kuzeljevic B, Robillard JM. Investigating the concept of participant burden in aging technology research. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Feb 12;20(1):50. [doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-1441-3](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-020-1441-3). [PMID: 32050910](https://pubmed.gov/32050910); [PMCID: PMC7017624](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7017624)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r590d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0267-2020-12-21-588.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0267-2020-12-21-588.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ccbdd91c9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0267-2020-12-21-588.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Cheon H, Dziewulska KH, Moosic KB, Olson KC, Gru AA, Feith DJ, Loughran TP Jr. Advances in the Diagnosis and Treatment of Large Granular Lymphocytic Leukemia. Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Apr;15(2):103-112. [doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00565-6](https://doi.org/10.1007/s11899-020-00565-6). [PMID: 32062772](https://pubmed.gov/32062772); [PMCID: PMC7234906](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7234906)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r588d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0268-2020-12-21-613.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0268-2020-12-21-613.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b08b37ef0 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0268-2020-12-21-613.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Tully PJ, Yano Y, Launer LJ, Kario K, Nagai M, Mooijaart SP, Claassen JAHR, Lattanzi S, Vincent AD, Tzourio C; Variability in Blood Pressure and Brain Health Consortium †; Variability in Blood Pressure and Brain Health Consortium. Association Between Blood Pressure Variability and Cerebral Small-Vessel Disease: A Systematic Review and Meta- Analysis. J Am Heart Assoc. 2020 Jan 7;9(1):e013841. [doi: 10.1161/JAHA.119.013841](https://doi.org/10.1161/JAHA.119.013841). Epub 2019 Dec 24. [PMID: 31870233](https://pubmed.gov/31870233); [PMCID: PMC6988154](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC6988154)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r613d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0269-2020-12-21-164.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0269-2020-12-21-164.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..99e0c5c93 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0269-2020-12-21-164.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ness BM, Zimney K, Schweinle WE, Cleland JA. DUAL-TASK ASSESSMENT IMPLICATIONS FOR ANTERIOR CRUCIATE LIGAMENT INJURY: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW. Int J Sports Phys Ther. 2020 Dec;15(6):840-855. [doi: 10.26603/ijspt20200840](https://doi.org/10.26603/ijspt20200840). [PMID: 33344002](https://pubmed.gov/33344002); [PMCID: PMC7727432](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7727432)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r164d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0270-2020-12-21-502.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0270-2020-12-21-502.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3a7bf06c8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0270-2020-12-21-502.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Langton S, Cousin GCS, Plüddemann A, Bankhead CR. Comparison of primary care doctors and dentists in the referral of oral cancer: a systematic review. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 Oct;58(8):898-917. [doi: 10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.06.009](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.06.009). Epub 2020 Jun 24. [PMID: 32591210](https://pubmed.gov/32591210)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r502d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0271-2020-12-21-257.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0271-2020-12-21-257.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8d9940608 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0271-2020-12-21-257.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Diedrich L, Dockweiler C. Video-based teleconsultations in pharmaceutical care - A systematic review. Res Social Adm Pharm. 2020 Dec 13:S1551-7411(20)31207-9. [doi: 10.1016/j.sapharm.2020.12.002](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sapharm.2020.12.002). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341405](https://pubmed.gov/33341405)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r257d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0272-2020-12-21-476.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0272-2020-12-21-476.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2f2e55931 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0272-2020-12-21-476.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Twigg JA, Anderson JM, Humphris G, Nixon I, Rogers SN, Kanatas A. Best practice in reducing the suicide risk in head and neck cancer patients: a structured review. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 Nov;58(9):e6-e15. [doi: 10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.06.035](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.06.035). Epub 2020 Jul 15. [PMID: 32682651](https://pubmed.gov/32682651)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r476d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0273-2020-12-21-472.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0273-2020-12-21-472.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..842bc1265 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0273-2020-12-21-472.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Huang M, Li G, Liu J, Li Y, Du P. Is There an Association Between Contraception and Sexual Dysfunction in Women? A Systematic Review and Meta- analysis Based on Female Sexual Function Index. J Sex Med. 2020 Oct;17(10):1942-1955. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.06.008](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.06.008). Epub 2020 Jul 18. [PMID: 32694069](https://pubmed.gov/32694069)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r472d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0274-2020-12-21-481.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0274-2020-12-21-481.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0a8caa24b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0274-2020-12-21-481.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Cong R, Wang Y, Wang Y, Zhang Q, Zhou X, Ji C, Yao L, Song N, Meng X. Comprehensive Analysis of lncRNA Expression Pattern and lncRNA-miRNA-mRNA Network in a Rat Model With Cavernous Nerve Injury Erectile Dysfunction. J Sex Med. 2020 Sep;17(9):1603-1617. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.05.008](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.05.008). Epub 2020 Jul 13. [PMID: 32675050](https://pubmed.gov/32675050)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r481d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0275-2020-12-21-105.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0275-2020-12-21-105.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..52eb5a87c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0275-2020-12-21-105.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Liu B, Yu M, Chen J, Li W. The HIV prevalence in older men who have sex with men in Western & Central Europe and North America-a meta-analysis. Int J STD AIDS. 2020 Dec 20:956462420967576. [doi: 10.1177/0956462420967576](https://doi.org/10.1177/0956462420967576). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345748](https://pubmed.gov/33345748)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r105d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0276-2020-12-21-582.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0276-2020-12-21-582.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..06664cb45 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0276-2020-12-21-582.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lurie F, Passman M, Meisner M, Dalsing M, Masuda E, Welch H, Bush RL, Blebea J, Carpentier PH, De Maeseneer M, Gasparis A, Labropoulos N, Marston WA, Rafetto J, Santiago F, Shortell C, Uhl JF, Urbanek T, van Rij A, Eklof B, Gloviczki P, Kistner R, Lawrence P, Moneta G, Padberg F, Perrin M, Wakefield T. The 2020 update of the CEAP classification system and reporting standards. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2020 May;8(3):342-352. [doi: 10.1016/j.jvsv.2019.12.075](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvsv.2019.12.075). Epub 2020 Feb 27. Erratum in: J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2021 Jan;9(1):288. [PMID: 32113854](https://pubmed.gov/32113854)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r582d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0277-2020-12-21-200.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0277-2020-12-21-200.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..709828bf7 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0277-2020-12-21-200.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Omyan G, Musa AE, Shabeeb D, Akbardoost N, Gholami S. Efficacy and toxicity of FLASH radiotherapy: A systematic review. J Cancer Res Ther. 2020 Oct- Dec;16(6):1203-1209. [doi: 10.4103/jcrt.JCRT_180_20](https://doi.org/10.4103/jcrt.JCRT_180_20). [PMID: 33342774](https://pubmed.gov/33342774)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r200d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0278-2020-12-21-292.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0278-2020-12-21-292.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bb6b8bfd8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0278-2020-12-21-292.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhou Y, Zeng Z, Dong X, Fei J, Li B. Effects of Chaihu-Shugan-San for reflux esophagitis: A protocol for systematic review and meta-analysis. Medicine (Baltimore). 2020 Dec 4;99(49):e23458. [doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000023458](https://doi.org/10.1097/MD.0000000000023458). [PMID: 33285744](https://pubmed.gov/33285744); [PMCID: PMC7717765](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7717765)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r292d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0279-2020-12-21-75.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0279-2020-12-21-75.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5afb81fa5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0279-2020-12-21-75.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Shi J, Shi X, Dai RQ. The prognostic impact of abnormally expressed, long noncoding RNAs in acute myeloid leukemia: a meta-analysis. Hematology. 2020 Dec;25(1):219-228. [doi: 10.1080/16078454.2020.1779480](https://doi.org/10.1080/16078454.2020.1779480). [PMID: 33346694](https://pubmed.gov/33346694)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r75d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0280-2020-12-21-277.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0280-2020-12-21-277.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ad940dee6 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0280-2020-12-21-277.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chi W, Chen Y, Wang L, Luo Z, Zhang Y, Zhu X. Acupuncture for COVID-19 patient after ventilator weaning: A protocol for systematic review and meta- analysis. Medicine (Baltimore). 2020 Dec 11;99(50):e23602. [doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000023602](https://doi.org/10.1097/MD.0000000000023602). [PMID: 33327327](https://pubmed.gov/33327327); [PMCID: PMC7738103](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7738103)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r277d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0281-2020-12-21-384.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0281-2020-12-21-384.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..eceefd7e2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0281-2020-12-21-384.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Mousa A, Al-Taiar A, Anstey NM, Badaut C, Barber BE, Bassat Q, Challenger JD, Cunnington AJ, Datta D, Drakeley C, Ghani AC, Gordeuk VR, Grigg MJ, Hugo P, John CC, Mayor A, Migot-Nabias F, Opoka RO, Pasvol G, Rees C, Reyburn H, Riley EM, Shah BN, Sitoe A, Sutherland CJ, Thuma PE, Unger SA, Viwami F, Walther M, Whitty CJM, William T, Okell LC. The impact of delayed treatment of uncomplicated P. falciparum malaria on progression to severe malaria: A systematic review and a pooled multicentre individual-patient meta-analysis. PLoS Med. 2020 Oct 19;17(10):e1003359. [doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1003359](https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1003359). [PMID: 33075101](https://pubmed.gov/33075101); [PMCID: PMC7571702](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7571702)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r384d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0282-2020-12-21-608.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0282-2020-12-21-608.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..368265979 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0282-2020-12-21-608.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Xu J, Kanagaratnam A, Cao JY, Chaggar GS, Bruce W. A comparison of aspirin against rivaroxaban for venous thromboembolism prophylaxis after hip or knee arthroplasty: A meta-analysis. J Orthop Surg (Hong Kong). 2020 Jan- Apr;28(1):2309499019896024. [doi: 10.1177/2309499019896024](https://doi.org/10.1177/2309499019896024). [PMID: 31908175](https://pubmed.gov/31908175)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r608d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0283-2020-12-21-248.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0283-2020-12-21-248.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fade6d248 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0283-2020-12-21-248.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Martins RARC, Costa FWG, Silva SM, Silva PGB, Carvalho FSR, Fonteles CSR, Ribeiro TR. Salivary immunoglobulins (A, G, and M) in type 1 diabetes mellitus patients: A PROSPERO-registered systematic review and meta-analysis. Arch Oral Biol. 2020 Dec 8;122:105025. [doi: 10.1016/j.archoralbio.2020.105025](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.archoralbio.2020.105025). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341591](https://pubmed.gov/33341591)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r248d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0284-2020-12-21-568.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0284-2020-12-21-568.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..77d94cd15 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0284-2020-12-21-568.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Liang H, Luo S, Chen X, Lu Y, Liu Z, Wei L. Effects of Tai Chi exercise on cardiovascular disease risk factors and quality of life in adults with essential hypertension: A meta-analysis. Heart Lung. 2020 Jul-Aug;49(4):353-363. [doi: 10.1016/j.hrtlng.2020.02.041](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hrtlng.2020.02.041). Epub 2020 Mar 12. [PMID: 32171586](https://pubmed.gov/32171586)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r568d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0285-2020-12-21-444.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0285-2020-12-21-444.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f960b589f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0285-2020-12-21-444.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Huang D, Zhang G, Yi J, Cheng M, Lai C, Xu P, Zhang C, Liu Y, Zhou C, Xue W, Wang R, Li Z, Chen S. Progress and challenges of metal-organic frameworks- based materials for SR-AOPs applications in water treatment. Chemosphere. 2021 Jan;263:127672. [doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.127672](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.127672). Epub 2020 Aug 13. [PMID: 32822945](https://pubmed.gov/32822945)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r444d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0286-2020-12-21-639.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0286-2020-12-21-639.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e8b40cbb5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0286-2020-12-21-639.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bai J, Gao Q, Wang C, Dai J. Diabetes mellitus and risk of low-energy fracture: a meta-analysis. Aging Clin Exp Res. 2020 Nov;32(11):2173-2186. [doi: 10.1007/s40520-019-01417-x](https://doi.org/10.1007/s40520-019-01417-x). Epub 2019 Nov 25. [PMID: 31768878](https://pubmed.gov/31768878)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r639d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0287-2020-12-21-268.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0287-2020-12-21-268.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..15f9464d6 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0287-2020-12-21-268.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Drugs and Lactation Database (LactMed) [Internet]. Bethesda (MD): National Library of Medicine (US); 2006–. Iodine. 2020 Dec 21. [PMID: 30000537](https://pubmed.gov/30000537)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r268d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0288-2020-12-21-53.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0288-2020-12-21-53.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..65ff2d59f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0288-2020-12-21-53.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Marco-Gardoqui M, Eizaguirre A, García-Feijoo M. The impact of service- learning methodology on business schools' students worldwide: A systematic literature review. PLoS One. 2020 Dec 21;15(12):e0244389. [doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0244389](https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0244389). [PMID: 33347503](https://pubmed.gov/33347503)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r53d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0289-2020-12-21-288.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0289-2020-12-21-288.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..712fbcab4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0289-2020-12-21-288.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Haldane V, Zhang Z, Abbas RF, Dodd W, Lau LL, Kidd MR, Rouleau K, Zou G, Chao Z, Upshur REG, Walley J, Wei X. National primary care responses to COVID-19: a rapid review of the literature. BMJ Open. 2020 Dec 8;10(12):e041622. [doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-041622](https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2020-041622). [PMID: 33293398](https://pubmed.gov/33293398); [PMCID: PMC7725079](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7725079)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r288d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0290-2020-12-21-398.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0290-2020-12-21-398.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1ac9192dc --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0290-2020-12-21-398.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Felsenreich DM, Gachabayov M, Rojas A, Latifi R, Bergamaschi R. Meta- analysis of Postoperative Mortality and Morbidity After Total Abdominal Colectomy Versus Loop Ileostomy With Colonic Lavage for Fulminant Clostridium Difficile Colitis. Dis Colon Rectum. 2020 Sep;63(9):1317-1326. [doi: 10.1097/DCR.0000000000001764](https://doi.org/10.1097/DCR.0000000000001764). [PMID: 33044807](https://pubmed.gov/33044807)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r398d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0291-2020-12-21-442.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0291-2020-12-21-442.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..16dc79d34 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0291-2020-12-21-442.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘de Lima AKA, Amorim Dos Santos J, Stefani CM, Almeida de Lima A, Damé- Teixeira N. Diabetes mellitus and poor glycemic control increase the occurrence of coronal and root caries: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3801-3812. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03531-x](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-020-03531-x). Epub 2020 Aug 22. [PMID: 32829477](https://pubmed.gov/32829477)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r442d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0292-2020-12-21-592.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0292-2020-12-21-592.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d6850d97f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0292-2020-12-21-592.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Grgic J, Diaz-Lara FJ, Coso JD, Duncan MJ, Tallis J, Pickering C, Schoenfeld BJ, Mikulic P. The Effects of Caffeine Ingestion on Measures of Rowing Performance: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Nutrients. 2020 Feb 8;12(2):434. [doi: 10.3390/nu12020434](https://doi.org/10.3390/nu12020434). [PMID: 32046330](https://pubmed.gov/32046330); [PMCID: PMC7071243](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7071243)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r592d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0293-2020-12-21-22.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0293-2020-12-21-22.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..387743591 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0293-2020-12-21-22.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Elkommos S, Mula M. A systematic review of neuroimaging studies of depression in adults with epilepsy. Epilepsy Behav. 2020 Dec 18;115:107695. [doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2020.107695](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.yebeh.2020.107695). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348194](https://pubmed.gov/33348194)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r22d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0294-2020-12-21-634.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0294-2020-12-21-634.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d553950d2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0294-2020-12-21-634.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Heard M, Lee YS. Shared neural resources of rhythm and syntax: An ALE meta- analysis. Neuropsychologia. 2020 Feb 3;137:107284. [doi: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2019.107284](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2019.107284). Epub 2019 Nov 26. [PMID: 31783081](https://pubmed.gov/31783081)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r634d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0295-2020-12-21-689.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0295-2020-12-21-689.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8084cafd1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0295-2020-12-21-689.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Vermeulen FM, Gerbens LAA, Bosma AL, Apfelbacher CJ, Irvine AD, Arents BWM, Barbarot S, Deleuran M, Eichenfield LF, Manca A, Schmitt J, Vestergaard C, Wall D, Weidinger S, Middelkamp-Hup MA, Spuls PI, Flohr C; International TREAT Registry Taskforce. TREatment of ATopic eczema (TREAT) Registry Taskforce: consensus on how and when to measure the core dataset for atopic eczema treatment research registries. Br J Dermatol. 2019 Sep;181(3):492-504. [doi: 10.1111/bjd.17715](https://doi.org/10.1111/bjd.17715). Epub 2019 Jun 23. [PMID: 30719709](https://pubmed.gov/30719709); [PMCID: PMC6771812](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC6771812)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r689d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0296-2020-12-21-521.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0296-2020-12-21-521.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0e36c7880 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0296-2020-12-21-521.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Pastoor H, Gregory A. Penile Size Dissatisfaction. J Sex Med. 2020 Jul;17(7):1400-1404. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.03.015](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.03.015). Epub 2020 May 20. [PMID: 32444341](https://pubmed.gov/32444341)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r521d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0297-2020-12-21-167.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0297-2020-12-21-167.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0ca608fdb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0297-2020-12-21-167.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kürzinger ML, Douarin L, Uzun I, El-Haddad C, Hurst W, Juhaeri J, Tcherny- Lessenot S. Structured benefit-risk evaluation for medicinal products: review of quantitative benefit-risk assessment findings in the literature. Ther Adv Drug Saf. 2020 Dec 8;11:2042098620976951. [doi: 10.1177/2042098620976951](https://doi.org/10.1177/2042098620976951). [PMID: 33343857](https://pubmed.gov/33343857); [PMCID: PMC7727082](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7727082)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r167d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0298-2020-12-21-500.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0298-2020-12-21-500.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..dbc29436f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0298-2020-12-21-500.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bateki CA, van Dijk S, Wilkes A, Dickhoefer U, White R. Meta-analysis of the effects of on-farm management strategies on milk yields of dairy cattle on smallholder farms in the Tropics. Animal. 2020 Dec;14(12):2619-2627. [doi: 10.1017/S1751731120001548](https://doi.org/10.1017/S1751731120001548). Epub 2020 Jun 30. [PMID: 32600497](https://pubmed.gov/32600497); [PMCID: PMC7645308](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7645308)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r500d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0299-2020-12-21-30.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0299-2020-12-21-30.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f93cdf507 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0299-2020-12-21-30.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ricci S, Bennett C, Falcone T. Uterine transplantation: evolving data, success, and clinical importance. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2020 Dec 18:S1553-4650(20)31188-2. [doi: 10.1016/j.jmig.2020.12.015](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmig.2020.12.015). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348011](https://pubmed.gov/33348011)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r30d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0300-2020-12-21-198.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0300-2020-12-21-198.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..76e54d18f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0300-2020-12-21-198.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lv X, Zhang Y, Wang J. Systematic Review of Transcatheter Arterial Embolization of AVM: Indications, Bleeding Complications, Cure Rate, and Long- Term Bleeding Risk. Neurol India. 2020 Nov-Dec;68(6):1285-1292. [doi: 10.4103/0028-3886.304101](https://doi.org/10.4103/0028-3886.304101). [PMID: 33342854](https://pubmed.gov/33342854)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r198d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0301-2020-12-21-503.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0301-2020-12-21-503.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6533ff191 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0301-2020-12-21-503.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Tran DTQ, Bradbury MI, Ogtrop FFV, Bozkurt H, Jones BJ, McCONCHIE R. Environmental Drivers for Persistence of Escherichia coli and Salmonella in Manure-Amended Soils: A Meta-Analysis. J Food Prot. 2020 Jul 1;83(7):1268-1277. [doi: 10.4315/0362-028X.JFP-19-460](https://doi.org/10.4315/0362-028X.JFP-19-460). [PMID: 32577760](https://pubmed.gov/32577760)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r503d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0302-2020-12-21-127.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0302-2020-12-21-127.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..32dc50961 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0302-2020-12-21-127.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Fleming C, Le Brocque R, Healy K. How are families included in the treatment of adults affected by eating disorders? A scoping review. Int J Eat Disord. 2020 Dec 20. [doi: 10.1002/eat.23441](https://doi.org/10.1002/eat.23441). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345319](https://pubmed.gov/33345319)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r127d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0303-2020-12-21-289.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0303-2020-12-21-289.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6a0098e8a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0303-2020-12-21-289.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Wang D, Li J, Zhu F, Hong Q, Zhang M, Gao M, Chen W. Protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis of respiratory rehabilitation following intensive care unit discharge for COVID-19 survivors. BMJ Open. 2020 Dec 8;10(12):e041184. [doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-041184](https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2020-041184). [PMID: 33293395](https://pubmed.gov/33293395); [PMCID: PMC7725092](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7725092)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r289d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0304-2020-12-21-258.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0304-2020-12-21-258.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ec101e849 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0304-2020-12-21-258.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Slocum RB, Villano JL. Narrative medicine applications for neuro-oncology patient identity and quality of life. J Clin Neurosci. 2020 Dec 16:S0967-5868(20)31683-0. [doi: 10.1016/j.jocn.2020.11.046](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jocn.2020.11.046). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341368](https://pubmed.gov/33341368)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r258d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0305-2020-12-21-92.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0305-2020-12-21-92.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b5ad352b9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0305-2020-12-21-92.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Al-Hafez L, Chauhan SP, Riegel M, Balogun OA, Hammad IA, Berghella V. Routine third-trimester ultrasound in low-risk pregnancies and perinatal death: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 Nov;2(4):100242. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100242](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100242). Epub 2020 Oct 3. [PMID: 33345941](https://pubmed.gov/33345941)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r92d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0306-2020-12-21-430.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0306-2020-12-21-430.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2bc77d8b8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0306-2020-12-21-430.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Aung Thein MZ, Pereira JV, Nitchingham A, Caplan GA. A call to action for delirium research: Meta-analysis and regression of delirium associated mortality. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Sep 7;20(1):325. [doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01723-4](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-020-01723-4). [PMID: 32894065](https://pubmed.gov/32894065); [PMCID: PMC7487610](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7487610)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r430d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0307-2020-12-21-108.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0307-2020-12-21-108.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..754efecbc --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0307-2020-12-21-108.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Illingworth BJ, Lewis DJ, Lambarth AT, Stocking K, Duffy JM, Jelen LA, Rucker JJ. A comparison of MDMA-assisted psychotherapy to non-assisted psychotherapy in treatment-resistant PTSD: A systematic review and meta- analysis. J Psychopharmacol. 2020 Dec 20:269881120965915. [doi: 10.1177/0269881120965915](https://doi.org/10.1177/0269881120965915). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345689](https://pubmed.gov/33345689)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r108d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0308-2020-12-21-390.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0308-2020-12-21-390.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2326620b9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0308-2020-12-21-390.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zheng JS, Luan J, Sofianopoulou E, Sharp SJ, Day FR, Imamura F, Gundersen TE, Lotta LA, Sluijs I, Stewart ID, Shah RL, van der Schouw YT, Wheeler E, Ardanaz E, Boeing H, Dorronsoro M, Dahm CC, Dimou N, El-Fatouhi D, Franks PW, Fagherazzi G, Grioni S, Huerta JM, Heath AK, Hansen L, Jenab M, Jakszyn P, Kaaks R, Kühn T, Khaw KT, Laouali N, Masala G, Nilsson PM, Overvad K, Olsen A, Panico S, Quirós JR, Rolandsson O, Rodríguez-Barranco M, Sacerdote C, Spijkerman AMW, Tong TYN, Tumino R, Tsilidis KK, Danesh J, Riboli E, Butterworth AS, Langenberg C, Forouhi NG, Wareham NJ. The association between circulating 25-hydroxyvitamin D metabolites and type 2 diabetes in European populations: A meta-analysis and Mendelian randomisation analysis. PLoS Med. 2020 Oct 16;17(10):e1003394. [doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1003394](https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1003394). [PMID: 33064751](https://pubmed.gov/33064751); [PMCID: PMC7567390](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7567390)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r390d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0309-2020-12-21-695.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0309-2020-12-21-695.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..85683c9d0 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0309-2020-12-21-695.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Dhont E, Van Der Heggen T, De Jaeger A, Vande Walle J, De Paepe P, De Cock PA. Augmented renal clearance in pediatric intensive care: are we undertreating our sickest patients? Pediatr Nephrol. 2020 Jan;35(1):25-39. [doi: 10.1007/s00467-018-4120-2](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00467-018-4120-2). Epub 2018 Oct 29. [PMID: 30374606](https://pubmed.gov/30374606)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r695d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0310-2020-12-21-48.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0310-2020-12-21-48.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b99c2283e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0310-2020-12-21-48.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Dong MX, Chen GH, Hu L. Dopaminergic System Alteration in Anxiety and Compulsive Disorders: A Systematic Review of Neuroimaging Studies. Front Neurosci. 2020 Dec 3;14:608520. [doi: 10.3389/fnins.2020.608520](https://doi.org/10.3389/fnins.2020.608520). [PMID: 33343291](https://pubmed.gov/33343291); [PMCID: PMC7744599](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7744599)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r48d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0311-2020-12-21-157.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0311-2020-12-21-157.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9d6acbf9c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0311-2020-12-21-157.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Morales AM, Jones SA, Kliamovich D, Harman G, Nagel BJ. Identifying Early Risk Factors for Addiction Later in Life: A Review of Prospective Longitudinal Studies. Curr Addict Rep. 2020 Mar;7(1):89-98. [doi: 10.1007/s40429-019-00282-y](https://doi.org/10.1007/s40429-019-00282-y). Epub 2019 Dec 12. [PMID: 33344103](https://pubmed.gov/33344103); [PMCID: PMC7747788](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7747788)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r157d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0312-2020-12-21-298.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0312-2020-12-21-298.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2c4357e98 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0312-2020-12-21-298.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhu H, Peng P, Zhao R, Fang KY, Han SQ. Efficacy and safety of antimicrobial de-escalation of treatment for sepsis: A protocol for systematic review and meta-analysis. Medicine (Baltimore). 2020 Dec 4;99(49):e23385. [doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000023385](https://doi.org/10.1097/MD.0000000000023385). [PMID: 33285724](https://pubmed.gov/33285724); [PMCID: PMC7717729](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7717729)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r298d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0313-2020-12-21-129.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0313-2020-12-21-129.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..faa724da1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0313-2020-12-21-129.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Mosher A, Fraser-Thomas J, Baker J. What Defines Early Specialization: A Systematic Review of Literature. Front Sports Act Living. 2020 Oct 27;2:596229. [doi: 10.3389/fspor.2020.596229](https://doi.org/10.3389/fspor.2020.596229). [PMID: 33345176](https://pubmed.gov/33345176); [PMCID: PMC7739675](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7739675)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r129d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0314-2020-12-21-284.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0314-2020-12-21-284.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b44306cda --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0314-2020-12-21-284.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Li Y, Fang R, Liu Z, Jiang L, Zhang J, Li H, Liu C, Li F. The association between toxic pesticide environmental exposure and Alzheimer's disease: A scientometric and visualization analysis. Chemosphere. 2021 Jan;263:128238. [doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128238](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128238). Epub 2020 Sep 4. [PMID: 33297185](https://pubmed.gov/33297185)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r284d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0315-2020-12-21-477.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0315-2020-12-21-477.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4fdb3d9ec --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0315-2020-12-21-477.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘León-Salas B, Trujillo-Martín MM, Del Castillo LPM, García JG, Pérez-Ros P, Ruiz FR, Serrano-Aguilar P. Pharmacologic interventions for prevention of delirium in hospitalized older people: A meta-analysis. Arch Gerontol Geriatr. 2020 Sep-Oct;90:104171. [doi: 10.1016/j.archger.2020.104171](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.archger.2020.104171). Epub 2020 Jul 11. [PMID: 32682169](https://pubmed.gov/32682169)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r477d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0316-2020-12-21-359.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0316-2020-12-21-359.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6b3e6ee71 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0316-2020-12-21-359.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Rueda JR, Mugueta-Aguinaga I, Vilaró J, Rueda-Etxebarria M. Myofunctional therapy (oropharyngeal exercises) for obstructive sleep apnoea. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 3;11:CD013449. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013449.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD013449.pub2). [PMID: 33141943](https://pubmed.gov/33141943)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r359d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0317-2020-12-21-604.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0317-2020-12-21-604.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e8667aed2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0317-2020-12-21-604.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Birdi G, Cooke R, Knibb RC. Impact of atopic dermatitis on quality of life in adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Dermatol. 2020 Apr;59(4):e75-e91. [doi: 10.1111/ijd.14763](https://doi.org/10.1111/ijd.14763). Epub 2020 Jan 13. [PMID: 31930494](https://pubmed.gov/31930494)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r604d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0318-2020-12-21-26.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0318-2020-12-21-26.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3bab3758c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0318-2020-12-21-26.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Mishima RS, Verdicchio CV, Noubiap JJ, Ariyaratnam JP, Gallagher C, Jones D, Malik V, Agbaedeng T, Middeldorp ME, Lau DH, Sanders P, Elliott AD. Self- reported Physical Activity and Atrial Fibrillation Risk: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Heart Rhythm. 2020 Dec 18:S1547-5271(20)31165-6. [doi: 10.1016/j.hrthm.2020.12.017](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hrthm.2020.12.017). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348059](https://pubmed.gov/33348059)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r26d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0319-2020-12-21-215.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0319-2020-12-21-215.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4a34ef1da --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0319-2020-12-21-215.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhao BC, Lei SH, Yang X, Zhang Y, Qiu SD, Liu WF, Li C, Liu KX. Assessment of prognostic value of intraoperative oliguria for postoperative acute kidney injury: a retrospective cohort study. Br J Anaesth. 2020 Dec 17:S0007-0912(20)30939-9. [doi: 10.1016/j.bja.2020.11.018](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bja.2020.11.018). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342539](https://pubmed.gov/33342539)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r215d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0320-2020-12-21-52.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0320-2020-12-21-52.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bad9e0d2b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0320-2020-12-21-52.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Byhamre ML, Araghi M, Alfredsson L, Bellocco R, Engström G, Eriksson M, Galanti MR, Jansson JH, Lager A, Lundberg M, Östergren PO, Pedersen NL, Trolle Lagerros Y, Ye W, Wennberg P, Magnusson C. Swedish snus use is associated with mortality: a pooled analysis of eight prospective studies. Int J Epidemiol. 2020 Dec 21:dyaa197. [doi: 10.1093/ije/dyaa197](https://doi.org/10.1093/ije/dyaa197). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33347584](https://pubmed.gov/33347584)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r52d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0321-2020-12-21-187.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0321-2020-12-21-187.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9e6dbc8cf --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0321-2020-12-21-187.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zou Y, Tuo F, Zhang Z, Guo J, Yuan Y, Zhang H, Xu Z, Pan Z, Tang Y, Deng C, Julie N, Wu W, Guo W, Li C, Huang X, Xu Q, Song J, Wang Q. Safety and Efficacy of Adjunctive Therapy With Artesunate in the Treatment of Severe Malaria: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Front Pharmacol. 2020 Nov 12;11:596697. [doi: 10.3389/fphar.2020.596697](https://doi.org/10.3389/fphar.2020.596697). [PMID: 33343367](https://pubmed.gov/33343367); [PMCID: PMC7748123](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7748123)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r187d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0322-2020-12-21-688.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0322-2020-12-21-688.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9440156fe --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0322-2020-12-21-688.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Mourad A, Straube S, Armijo-Olivo S, Gniadecki R. Factors predicting persistence of biologic drugs in psoriasis: a systematic review and meta- analysis. Br J Dermatol. 2019 Sep;181(3):450-458. [doi: 10.1111/bjd.17738](https://doi.org/10.1111/bjd.17738). Epub 2019 Apr 29. [PMID: 30729500](https://pubmed.gov/30729500)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r688d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0323-2020-12-21-645.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0323-2020-12-21-645.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3ba846f4d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0323-2020-12-21-645.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Foster TJ, Amin AH, Busu T, Patel K, Farjo P, Hallak AA, Ali N, Alkhouli M. Aorto-cardiac fistula etiology, presentation, and management: A systematic review. Heart Lung. 2020 May-Jun;49(3):317-323. [doi: 10.1016/j.hrtlng.2019.11.002](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hrtlng.2019.11.002). Epub 2019 Nov 15. [PMID: 31735456](https://pubmed.gov/31735456)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r645d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0324-2020-12-21-222.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0324-2020-12-21-222.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3534748a3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0324-2020-12-21-222.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Liu B, Li W. Association between education level and HIV-associated neurocognitive disorder: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sex Health. 2020 Dec 21. [doi: 10.1071/SH20057](https://doi.org/10.1071/SH20057). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342460](https://pubmed.gov/33342460)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r222d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0325-2020-12-21-664.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0325-2020-12-21-664.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2bc7b019c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0325-2020-12-21-664.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Simbi CMC, Zhang Y, Wang Z. Early parental loss in childhood and depression in adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis of case-controlled studies. J Affect Disord. 2020 Jan 1;260:272-280. [doi: 10.1016/j.jad.2019.07.087](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2019.07.087). Epub 2019 Jul 30. [PMID: 31521863](https://pubmed.gov/31521863)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r664d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0326-2020-12-21-152.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0326-2020-12-21-152.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6c7105132 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0326-2020-12-21-152.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Choudhary N, Sarode GS, Yuwanati M, Maniyar N, Sarode SC, Gadbail AR, Gondivkar S, Patil S. Tumor associated tissue eosinophilia in oral squamous cell carcinoma: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Oral Biol Craniofac Res. 2021 Jan-Mar;11(1):33-39. [doi: 10.1016/j.jobcr.2020.11.012](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jobcr.2020.11.012). Epub 2020 Nov 23. [PMID: 33344159](https://pubmed.gov/33344159); [PMCID: PMC7736986](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7736986)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r152d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0327-2020-12-21-589.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0327-2020-12-21-589.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cbda2a95c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0327-2020-12-21-589.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Rodríguez-Calero MA, Blanco-Mavillard I, Morales-Asencio JM, Fernández- Fernández I, Castro-Sánchez E, de Pedro-Gómez JE. Defining risk factors associated with difficult peripheral venous Cannulation: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Heart Lung. 2020 May-Jun;49(3):273-286. [doi: 10.1016/j.hrtlng.2020.01.009](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hrtlng.2020.01.009). Epub 2020 Feb 11. [PMID: 32057426](https://pubmed.gov/32057426)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r589d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0328-2020-12-21-107.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0328-2020-12-21-107.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0f87b345f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0328-2020-12-21-107.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Stagg K. Intravenous versus oral paracetamol for postoperative analgesia: A systematic review. J Perioper Pract. 2020 Dec 20:1750458920950652. [doi: 10.1177/1750458920950652](https://doi.org/10.1177/1750458920950652). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345698](https://pubmed.gov/33345698)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r107d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0329-2020-12-21-434.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0329-2020-12-21-434.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5134336a0 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0329-2020-12-21-434.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Neame MT, Sefton G, Roberts M, Harkness D, Sinha IP, Hawcutt DB. Evaluating health information technologies: A systematic review of framework recommendations. Int J Med Inform. 2020 Oct;142:104247. [doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104247](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104247). Epub 2020 Aug 14. [PMID: 32871491](https://pubmed.gov/32871491)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r434d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0330-2020-12-21-619.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0330-2020-12-21-619.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..87f11a334 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0330-2020-12-21-619.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Petrovič M, Locatelli I. Comparative effectiveness of pulmonary arterial hypertension drugs in treatment-naive patients: a network meta-analysis. J Comp Eff Res. 2020 Jan;9(1):7-22. [doi: 10.2217/cer-2019-0037](https://doi.org/10.2217/cer-2019-0037). Epub 2019 Dec 17. [PMID: 31845591](https://pubmed.gov/31845591)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r619d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0331-2020-12-21-637.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0331-2020-12-21-637.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7c1721017 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0331-2020-12-21-637.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Xu G, Fu X, Tian P, Bahat D, Huang Y, Li Z. The lateral and medial approach in total arthroplasty for valgus knee: a meta-analysis of current literature. J Comp Eff Res. 2020 Jan;9(1):35-44. [doi: 10.2217/cer-2019-0111](https://doi.org/10.2217/cer-2019-0111). Epub 2019 Nov 28. [PMID: 31777265](https://pubmed.gov/31777265)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r637d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0332-2020-12-21-133.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0332-2020-12-21-133.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b55dc679d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0332-2020-12-21-133.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Stuart S, Parrington L, Martini D, Peterka R, Chesnutt J, King L. The Measurement of Eye Movements in Mild Traumatic Brain Injury: A Structured Review of an Emerging Area. Front Sports Act Living. 2020 Jan 28;2:5. [doi: 10.3389/fspor.2020.00005](https://doi.org/10.3389/fspor.2020.00005). [PMID: 33345000](https://pubmed.gov/33345000); [PMCID: PMC7739790](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7739790)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r133d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0333-2020-12-21-366.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0333-2020-12-21-366.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..15819db65 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0333-2020-12-21-366.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Puntis S, Minichino A, De Crescenzo F, Cipriani A, Lennox B, Harrison R. Specialised early intervention teams for recent-onset psychosis. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 2;11:CD013288. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013288.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD013288.pub2). [PMID: 33135811](https://pubmed.gov/33135811)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r366d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0334-2020-12-21-491.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0334-2020-12-21-491.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2b8f70d11 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0334-2020-12-21-491.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Xu BC, Fu J, Zhu LY, Li Z, Wang YZ, Jin ML. Overall assessment of antimicrobial peptides in piglets: a set of meta-analyses. Animal. 2020 Dec;14(12):2463-2471. [doi: 10.1017/S1751731120001640](https://doi.org/10.1017/S1751731120001640). Epub 2020 Jul 8. [PMID: 32635952](https://pubmed.gov/32635952)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r491d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0335-2020-12-21-550.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0335-2020-12-21-550.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7f710e1cb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0335-2020-12-21-550.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Cabras M, Carrozzo M, Gambino A, Broccoletti R, Sciascia S, Baldovino S, Arduino PG. Value of colchicine as treatment for recurrent oral ulcers: A systematic review. J Oral Pathol Med. 2020 Sep;49(8):731-740. [doi: 10.1111/jop.13020](https://doi.org/10.1111/jop.13020). Epub 2020 May 12. [PMID: 32281694](https://pubmed.gov/32281694)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r550d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0336-2020-12-21-672.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0336-2020-12-21-672.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..563781527 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0336-2020-12-21-672.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bae JM. Body Mass Index and Risk of Gastric Cancer in Asian Adults: A Meta- Epidemiological Meta-Analysis of Population-Based Cohort Studies. Cancer Res Treat. 2020 Apr;52(2):369-373. [doi: 10.4143/crt.2019.241](https://doi.org/10.4143/crt.2019.241). Epub 2019 Aug 12. [PMID: 31401820](https://pubmed.gov/31401820); [PMCID: PMC7176952](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7176952)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r672d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0337-2020-12-21-79.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0337-2020-12-21-79.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6fec9ed70 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0337-2020-12-21-79.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lin Y, Yang Y, Zhang X, Li W, Li H, Mu D. Postoperative Health-related Quality of Life in Reduction Mammaplasty: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Ann Plast Surg. 2020 Dec 15;Publish Ahead of Print. [doi: 10.1097/SAP.0000000000002609](https://doi.org/10.1097/SAP.0000000000002609). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346564](https://pubmed.gov/33346564)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r79d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0338-2020-12-21-69.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0338-2020-12-21-69.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1a8abc520 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0338-2020-12-21-69.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Aleksovska K, Puggina A, Giraldi L, Buck C, Burns C, Cardon G, Carlin A, Chantal S, Ciarapica D, Colotto M, Condello G, Coppinger T, Cortis C, D'Haese S, De Craemer M, Di Blasio A, Hansen S, Iacoviello L, Issartel J, Izzicupo P, Jaeschke L, Kanning M, Kennedy A, Ling F, Luzak A, Napolitano G, Nazare JA, Perchoux C, Pischon T, Polito A, Sannella A, Schulz H, Sohun R, Steinbrecher A, Schlicht W, Ricciardi W, MacDonncha C, Capranica L, Boccia S. Correction to: Biological determinants of physical activity across the life course: a "Determinants of Diet and Physical Activity" (DEDIPAC) umbrella systematic literature review. Sports Med Open. 2020 Dec 21;6(1):60. [doi: 10.1186/s40798-020-00291-6](https://doi.org/10.1186/s40798-020-00291-6). Erratum for: Sports Med Open. 2019 Jan 8;5(1):2. [PMID: 33346880](https://pubmed.gov/33346880)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r69d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0339-2020-12-21-116.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0339-2020-12-21-116.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5ff2aadf9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0339-2020-12-21-116.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Gogna S, Samson D, Choi J, Con J, Prabhakaran K, Rhee P, Latifi R. The Role of Nutritional Access in Malnourished Elderly Undergoing Major Surgery for Acute Abdomen: A Propensity Score-Matched Analysis. Am Surg. 2020 Dec 19:3134820973719. [doi: 10.1177/0003134820973719](https://doi.org/10.1177/0003134820973719). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345560](https://pubmed.gov/33345560)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r116d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0340-2020-12-21-617.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0340-2020-12-21-617.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d89991aab --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0340-2020-12-21-617.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Giridhar P, Kashyap L, Mallick S, Dutt Upadhyay A, Rath GK. Impact of surgery and adjuvant treatment on the outcome of extraocular sebaceous carcinoma: a systematic review and individual patient's data analysis of 206 cases. Int J Dermatol. 2020 Apr;59(4):494-505. [doi: 10.1111/ijd.14739](https://doi.org/10.1111/ijd.14739). Epub 2019 Dec 18. [PMID: 31850516](https://pubmed.gov/31850516)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r617d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0341-2020-12-21-417.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0341-2020-12-21-417.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2343ee037 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0341-2020-12-21-417.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Guo PP, Fan SL, Li P, Zhang XH, Liu N, Wang J, Chen DD, Sun WJ, Yu L, Yang S, Zhang W. The effectiveness of massage on peri-operative anxiety in adults: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and controlled clinical trials. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101240. [doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101240](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101240). Epub 2020 Sep 17. [PMID: 32977216](https://pubmed.gov/32977216)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r417d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0342-2020-12-21-345.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0342-2020-12-21-345.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fe365f284 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0342-2020-12-21-345.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Juffermans NP, van den Brom CE, Kleinveld DJB. Targeting Endothelial Dysfunction in Acute Critical Illness to Reduce Organ Failure. Anesth Analg. 2020 Dec;131(6):1708-1720. [doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000005023](https://doi.org/10.1213/ANE.0000000000005023). [PMID: 33186159](https://pubmed.gov/33186159)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r345d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0343-2020-12-21-185.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0343-2020-12-21-185.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5ad660ca2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0343-2020-12-21-185.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Li ET, Luyten P, Midgley N. Psychological Mediators of the Association Between Childhood Emotional Abuse and Depression: A Systematic Review. Front Psychiatry. 2020 Dec 4;11:559213. [doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2020.559213](https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2020.559213). [PMID: 33343409](https://pubmed.gov/33343409); [PMCID: PMC7746653](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7746653)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r185d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0344-2020-12-21-62.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0344-2020-12-21-62.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1c43f2041 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0344-2020-12-21-62.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Desiato VM, Byun YJ, Nguyen SA, Thiers BH, Day TA. Sebaceous Carcinoma of the Eyelid: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Dermatol Surg. 2021 Jan 1;47(1):104-110. [doi: 10.1097/DSS.0000000000002660](https://doi.org/10.1097/DSS.0000000000002660). [PMID: 33347004](https://pubmed.gov/33347004)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r62d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0345-2020-12-21-623.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0345-2020-12-21-623.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f2bf03993 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0345-2020-12-21-623.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Irwin C, Khalesi S, Desbrow B, McCartney D. Effects of acute caffeine consumption following sleep loss on cognitive, physical, occupational and driving performance: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:877-888. [doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.008](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.008). Epub 2019 Dec 16. [PMID: 31837359](https://pubmed.gov/31837359)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r623d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0346-2020-12-21-307.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0346-2020-12-21-307.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ef7aaf0d8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0346-2020-12-21-307.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hu BS, -Z Hu M, Jiang LX, Yu J, Chang Y, Cao Y, Dai ZP. Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) in patients with COVID-19: a rapid systematic review of case studies. Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci. 2020 Nov;24(22):11945-11952. [doi: 10.26355/eurrev_202011_23855](https://doi.org/10.26355/eurrev_202011_23855). [PMID: 33275268](https://pubmed.gov/33275268)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r307d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0347-2020-12-21-618.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0347-2020-12-21-618.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f385c0daf --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0347-2020-12-21-618.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Suvarna B, Suvarna A, Phillips R, Juster RP, McDermott B, Sarnyai Z. Health risk behaviours and allostatic load: A systematic review. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:694-711. [doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.020](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.020). Epub 2019 Dec 14. [PMID: 31846655](https://pubmed.gov/31846655)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r618d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0348-2020-12-21-2.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0348-2020-12-21-2.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..eb8db6b47 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0348-2020-12-21-2.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Cresp SJ, Lee SF, Moss C. A framework for nurses working in partnership with substitute decision-makers for people living with advanced dementia: A discursive paper. J Clin Nurs. 2020 Dec 21. [doi: 10.1111/jocn.15618](https://doi.org/10.1111/jocn.15618). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348467](https://pubmed.gov/33348467)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r2d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0349-2020-12-21-642.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0349-2020-12-21-642.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4eb800d32 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0349-2020-12-21-642.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Huang WL, Xu Y, Wan SP. Association of Toll-like 4 receptor gene polymorphism (rs4986790, rs4986791) with the risk of urinary tract infection: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Kaohsiung J Med Sci. 2020 Mar;36(3):206-211. [doi: 10.1002/kjm2.12158](https://doi.org/10.1002/kjm2.12158). Epub 2019 Nov 21. [PMID: 31749314](https://pubmed.gov/31749314)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r642d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0350-2020-12-21-56.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0350-2020-12-21-56.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bfc93814d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0350-2020-12-21-56.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Gu Y, Ji Y, Jiang H, Qiu G. Clinical Effect of Driver Mutations of KRAS, CDKN2A/P16, TP53, and SMAD4 in Pancreatic Cancer: A Meta-Analysis. Genet Test Mol Biomarkers. 2020 Dec;24(12):777-788. [doi: 10.1089/gtmb.2020.0078](https://doi.org/10.1089/gtmb.2020.0078). [PMID: 33347393](https://pubmed.gov/33347393)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r56d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0351-2020-12-21-414.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0351-2020-12-21-414.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bab8c0812 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0351-2020-12-21-414.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Rostami M, Mansouritorghabeh H. D-dimer level in COVID-19 infection: a systematic review. Expert Rev Hematol. 2020 Nov;13(11):1265-1275. [doi: 10.1080/17474086.2020.1831383](https://doi.org/10.1080/17474086.2020.1831383). Epub 2020 Oct 12. [PMID: 32997543](https://pubmed.gov/32997543)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r414d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0352-2020-12-21-296.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0352-2020-12-21-296.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..07bcebdf3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0352-2020-12-21-296.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Li Y, Zheng X, Wang Y, Li Y. Auricular therapy for polycystic ovary syndrome: A protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis. Medicine (Baltimore). 2020 Dec 4;99(49):e23396. [doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000023396](https://doi.org/10.1097/MD.0000000000023396). [PMID: 33285726](https://pubmed.gov/33285726); [PMCID: PMC7717724](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7717724)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r296d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0353-2020-12-21-7.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0353-2020-12-21-7.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e30dad06a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0353-2020-12-21-7.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Dos Santos AP, Cardoso TN, Waisse S, Bonamin LV. Homeopathy in Experimental Cancer Models: A Systematic Review. Homeopathy. 2020 Dec 21. [doi: 10.1055/s-0040-1716369](https://doi.org/10.1055/s-0040-1716369). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348419](https://pubmed.gov/33348419)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r7d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0354-2020-12-21-304.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0354-2020-12-21-304.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0e4d4d744 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0354-2020-12-21-304.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Saraiva F, Moreira R, Cerqueira RJ, Mancio J, Barros AS, Lourenço AP, Leite-Moreira A. Multiple Versus Single Arterial Grafting In The Elderly: A Meta-Analysis Of Randomized Controlled Trials And Propensity Score Studies. Rev Port Cir Cardiotorac Vasc. 2020 Oct-Dec;27(4):258. [PMID: 33280292](https://pubmed.gov/33280292)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r304d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0355-2020-12-21-452.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0355-2020-12-21-452.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a115a5a40 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0355-2020-12-21-452.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Alghamdi SM, Barker RE, Alsulayyim ASS, Alasmari AM, Banya WAS, Polkey MI, Birring SS, Hopkinson NS. Use of oscillatory positive expiratory pressure (OPEP) devices to augment sputum clearance in COPD: a systematic review and meta- analysis. Thorax. 2020 Oct;75(10):855-863. [doi: 10.1136/thoraxjnl-2019-214360](https://doi.org/10.1136/thoraxjnl-2019-214360). Epub 2020 Aug 11. [PMID: 32788259](https://pubmed.gov/32788259)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r452d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0356-2020-12-21-374.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0356-2020-12-21-374.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ffeac907c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0356-2020-12-21-374.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘King MD, Elliott JE, Williams TD. Effects of petroleum exposure on birds: A review. Sci Total Environ. 2021 Feb 10;755(Pt 1):142834. [doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142834](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142834). Epub 2020 Oct 8. [PMID: 33109373](https://pubmed.gov/33109373)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r374d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0357-2020-12-21-86.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0357-2020-12-21-86.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..22b8c0be0 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0357-2020-12-21-86.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Contreras Jofre P, Valenzuela Solís Á, Pinto Soto J, Mendoza Ponce N, López- Alegría F. Violencia en el trabajo hacia los profesionales de enfermería en los servicios de emergencias: revisión integrativa [Workplace violence against emergency service nurses: an integrative reviewViolência no trabalho contra os profissionais de enfermagem em serviços de emergência: revisão integrativa]. Rev Panam Salud Publica. 2020 Dec 17;44:e173. Spanish. [doi: 10.26633/RPSP.2020.173](https://doi.org/10.26633/RPSP.2020.173). [PMID: 33346247](https://pubmed.gov/33346247); [PMCID: PMC7745999](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7745999)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r86d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0358-2020-12-21-44.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0358-2020-12-21-44.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..54d02c69c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0358-2020-12-21-44.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Scollan JP, Bertsch ML, Flanagan CD, Chughtai M, Chepla KJ, Hoyen HA, Bafus BT. Acute compartment syndrome of the deltoid: a case report and systematic review of the literature. JSES Int. 2020 Sep 7;4(4):753-758. [doi: 10.1016/j.jseint.2020.07.016](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jseint.2020.07.016). [PMID: 33345211](https://pubmed.gov/33345211); [PMCID: PMC7738586](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7738586)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r44d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0359-2020-12-21-620.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0359-2020-12-21-620.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..905c06ad3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0359-2020-12-21-620.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Krahe J, Binkofski F, Schulz JB, Reetz K, Romanzetti S. Neurochemical profiles in hereditary ataxias: A meta-analysis of Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy studies. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:854-865. [doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.019](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.019). Epub 2019 Dec 12. [PMID: 31838195](https://pubmed.gov/31838195)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r620d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0360-2020-12-21-138.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0360-2020-12-21-138.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..948a0d5be --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0360-2020-12-21-138.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Rumbut J, Fang H, Wang H. Topic modeling for systematic review of visual analytics in incomplete longitudinal behavioral trial data. Smart Health (Amst). 2020 Nov;18:100142. [doi: 10.1016/j.smhl.2020.100142](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.smhl.2020.100142). Epub 2020 Nov 13. [PMID: 33344744](https://pubmed.gov/33344744); [PMCID: PMC7745978](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7745978)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r138d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0361-2020-12-21-446.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0361-2020-12-21-446.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..009816a7b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0361-2020-12-21-446.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Larson AS, Lehman VT, Lanzino G, Brinjikji W. Lack of Baseline Intracranial Aneurysm Wall Enhancement Predicts Future Stability: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Longitudinal Studies. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2020 Sep;41(9):1606-1610. [doi: 10.3174/ajnr.A6690](https://doi.org/10.3174/ajnr.A6690). Epub 2020 Aug 20. [PMID: 32819901](https://pubmed.gov/32819901); [PMCID: PMC7583099](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7583099)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r446d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0362-2020-12-21-38.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0362-2020-12-21-38.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e4e8b3cf3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0362-2020-12-21-38.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Jan S, Dar MI, Wani R, Sandey J, Mushtaq I, Lateef S, Syed SH. Targeting EHMT2/ G9a for cancer therapy: progress and perspective. Eur J Pharmacol. 2020 Dec 18:173827. [doi: 10.1016/j.ejphar.2020.173827](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejphar.2020.173827). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33347828](https://pubmed.gov/33347828)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r38d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0363-2020-12-21-28.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0363-2020-12-21-28.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..881a6adb3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0363-2020-12-21-28.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Miller KA, Baird J, Lira J, Herrera Eguizabal J, Fei S, Kysh L, Lotstein D. The use of telemedicine for home-based palliative care for children with serious illness: a scoping review. J Pain Symptom Manage. 2020 Dec 18:S0885-3924(20)30942-8. [doi: 10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2020.12.004](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2020.12.004). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348029](https://pubmed.gov/33348029)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r28d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0364-2020-12-21-640.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0364-2020-12-21-640.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..330067830 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0364-2020-12-21-640.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lin J, Sun Y, Chen Q, Liu S, Ding Z, Chen J. Outcome Comparison of Graft Bridging and Superior Capsule Reconstruction for Large to Massive Rotator Cuff Tears: A Systematic Review. Am J Sports Med. 2020 Sep;48(11):2828-2838. [doi: 10.1177/0363546519889040](https://doi.org/10.1177/0363546519889040). Epub 2019 Nov 25. [PMID: 31766858](https://pubmed.gov/31766858)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r640d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0365-2020-12-21-117.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0365-2020-12-21-117.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..665b29772 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0365-2020-12-21-117.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Woodis CB, Ghassemi E, McLendon AN. Bioidentical Oral 17β-Estradiol and Progesterone for the Treatment of Moderate to Severe Vasomotor Symptoms of Menopause. Ann Pharmacother. 2020 Dec 21:1060028020982611. [doi: 10.1177/1060028020982611](https://doi.org/10.1177/1060028020982611). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345556](https://pubmed.gov/33345556)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r117d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0366-2020-12-21-280.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0366-2020-12-21-280.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ad9043608 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0366-2020-12-21-280.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Truppa C, Abo-Shehada MN. Antimicrobial resistance among GLASS pathogens in conflict and non-conflict affected settings in the Middle East: a systematic review. BMC Infect Dis. 2020 Dec 9;20(1):936. [doi: 10.1186/s12879-020-05503-8](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12879-020-05503-8). [PMID: 33297983](https://pubmed.gov/33297983); [PMCID: PMC7724697](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7724697)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r280d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0367-2020-12-21-72.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0367-2020-12-21-72.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..de4cf7ac2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0367-2020-12-21-72.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Mayakonda A, Schönung M, Hey J, Batra RN, Feuerstein-Akgoz C, Köhler K, Lipka DB, Sotillo R, Plass C, Lutsik P, Toth R. Methrix: an R/bioconductor package for systematic aggregation and analysis of bisulfite sequencing data. Bioinformatics. 2020 Dec 21:btaa1048. [doi: 10.1093/bioinformatics/btaa1048](https://doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/btaa1048). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346800](https://pubmed.gov/33346800)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r72d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0368-2020-12-21-46.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0368-2020-12-21-46.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..773cb29b0 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0368-2020-12-21-46.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Tafazoli A, Tafazoli Moghadam E. Camellia Sinensis Mouthwashes in Oral Care: a Systematic Review. J Dent (Shiraz). 2020 Dec;21(4):249-262. [doi: 10.30476/DENTJODS.2020.83204.1045](https://doi.org/10.30476/DENTJODS.2020.83204.1045). [PMID: 33344675](https://pubmed.gov/33344675); [PMCID: PMC7737926](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7737926)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r46d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0369-2020-12-21-290.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0369-2020-12-21-290.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..86706da64 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0369-2020-12-21-290.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Russell JA, Marshall JC, Slutsky A, Murthy S, Sweet D, Lee T, Singer J, Patrick DM, Du B, Peng Z, Cheng M, Burns KD, Harhay MO. Study protocol for a multicentre, prospective cohort study of the association of angiotensin II type 1 receptor blockers on outcomes of coronavirus infection. BMJ Open. 2020 Dec 7;10(12):e040768. [doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-040768](https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2020-040768). [PMID: 33293316](https://pubmed.gov/33293316); [PMCID: PMC7722825](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7722825)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r290d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0370-2020-12-21-686.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0370-2020-12-21-686.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c5661e96a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0370-2020-12-21-686.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Nasioudis D, Kim SW, Schoen C, Levine LD. Maternal and neonatal outcomes with mechanical cervical dilation plus misoprostol compared to misoprostol alone for cervical ripening; a systematic review of literature and metaanalysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2019 May;1(2):101-111. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2019.06.003](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajogmf.2019.06.003). Epub 2019 Jun 11. [PMID: 33345815](https://pubmed.gov/33345815)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r686d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0371-2020-12-21-340.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0371-2020-12-21-340.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..13be71ea9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0371-2020-12-21-340.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Abdel-Rahman O, Elsayed Z. Yttrium-90 microsphere radioembolisation for unresectable hepatocellular carcinoma. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 16;11:CD011313. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011313.pub4](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD011313.pub4). [PMID: 33197051](https://pubmed.gov/33197051)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r340d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0372-2020-12-21-156.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0372-2020-12-21-156.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..94e50de82 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0372-2020-12-21-156.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Gerlach LB, Kales HC. Pharmacological Management of Neuropsychiatric Symptoms of Dementia. Curr Treat Options Psychiatry. 2020 Dec;7(4):489-507. [doi: 10.1007/s40501-020-00233-9](https://doi.org/10.1007/s40501-020-00233-9). Epub 2020 Sep 2. [PMID: 33344107](https://pubmed.gov/33344107); [PMCID: PMC7742723](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7742723)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r156d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0373-2020-12-21-104.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0373-2020-12-21-104.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e1680b2c5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0373-2020-12-21-104.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ciriaco P, Muriana P, Lembo R, Carretta A, Negri G. Treatment of Thoracic Endometriosis Syndrome: A Meta-analysis and Review. Ann Thorac Surg. 2020 Dec 17:S0003-4975(20)32117-2. [doi: 10.1016/j.athoracsur.2020.09.064](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.athoracsur.2020.09.064). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345783](https://pubmed.gov/33345783)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r104d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0374-2020-12-21-540.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0374-2020-12-21-540.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d9e5fb557 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0374-2020-12-21-540.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Edgelow M, Harrison L, Miceli M, Cramm H. Occupational therapy return to work interventions for persons with trauma and stress-related mental health conditions: A scoping review. Work. 2020;65(4):821-836. [doi: 10.3233/WOR-203134](https://doi.org/10.3233/WOR-203134). [PMID: 32310212](https://pubmed.gov/32310212)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r540d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0375-2020-12-21-467.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0375-2020-12-21-467.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..48fa3113d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0375-2020-12-21-467.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lu H, Xie J, Gerido LH, Cheng Y, Chen Y, Sun L. Information Needs of Breast Cancer Patients: Theory-Generating Meta-Synthesis. J Med Internet Res. 2020 Jul 28;22(7):e17907. [doi: 10.2196/17907](https://doi.org/10.2196/17907). [PMID: 32720899](https://pubmed.gov/32720899); [PMCID: PMC7420822](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7420822)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r467d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0376-2020-12-21-439.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0376-2020-12-21-439.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6362f6fef --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0376-2020-12-21-439.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kim Y, Vakula MN, Waller B, Bressel E. A systematic review and meta- analysis comparing the effect of aquatic and land exercise on dynamic balance in older adults. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Aug 25;20(1):302. [doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01702-9](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-020-01702-9). [PMID: 32842967](https://pubmed.gov/32842967); [PMCID: PMC7446104](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7446104)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r439d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0377-2020-12-21-182.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0377-2020-12-21-182.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..232fc8ec4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0377-2020-12-21-182.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhu L, Li L, Wang L, Jin X, Zhang H. Physical Activity for Executive Function and Activities of Daily Living in AD Patients: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Front Psychol. 2020 Dec 3;11:560461. [doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.560461](https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.560461). [PMID: 33343442](https://pubmed.gov/33343442); [PMCID: PMC7744293](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7744293)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r182d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0378-2020-12-21-5.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0378-2020-12-21-5.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..66cc16b24 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0378-2020-12-21-5.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Smith V, Devane D, Nichol A, Roche D. Care bundles for improving outcomes in patients with COVID-19 or related conditions in intensive care - a rapid scoping review. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Dec 21;12:CD013819. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013819](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD013819). [PMID: 33348427](https://pubmed.gov/33348427)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r5d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0379-2020-12-21-270.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0379-2020-12-21-270.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d43da38b0 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0379-2020-12-21-270.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Drugs and Lactation Database (LactMed) [Internet]. Bethesda (MD): National Library of Medicine (US); 2006–. Lithium. 2020 Dec 21. [PMID: 30000212](https://pubmed.gov/30000212)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r270d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0380-2020-12-21-231.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0380-2020-12-21-231.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..60bbb3cca --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0380-2020-12-21-231.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Reges O, Ning H, Wilkins JT, Wu CO, Tian X, Domanski MJ, Lloyd-Jones DM, Allen NB. Association of Cumulative Systolic Blood Pressure With Long-Term Risk of Cardiovascular Disease and Healthy Longevity: Findings From the Lifetime Risk Pooling Project Cohorts. Hypertension. 2020 Dec 21:HYPERTENSIONAHA12015650. [doi: 10.1161/HYPERTENSIONAHA.120.15650](https://doi.org/10.1161/HYPERTENSIONAHA.120.15650). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342241](https://pubmed.gov/33342241)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r231d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0381-2020-12-21-67.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0381-2020-12-21-67.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c1f0979ea --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0381-2020-12-21-67.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ippolito S, Cusini C, Lasalvia P, Gianfagna F, Veronesi G, Gallo D, Masiello E, Premoli P, Sabatino J, Mercuriali A, Lai A, Piantanida E, Tanda ML, Bartalena L. Change in newly diagnosed Graves' disease phenotype between the twentieth and the twenty-first centuries: meta-analysis and meta-regression. J Endocrinol Invest. 2020 Dec 21. [doi: 10.1007/s40618-020-01479-z](https://doi.org/10.1007/s40618-020-01479-z). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346898](https://pubmed.gov/33346898)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r67d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0382-2020-12-21-585.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0382-2020-12-21-585.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..eb14d7c98 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0382-2020-12-21-585.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lopetuso LR, Ianiro G, Allegretti JR, Bibbò S, Gasbarrini A, Scaldaferri F, Cammarota G. Fecal transplantation for ulcerative colitis: current evidence and future applications. Expert Opin Biol Ther. 2020 Apr;20(4):343-351. [doi: 10.1080/14712598.2020.1733964](https://doi.org/10.1080/14712598.2020.1733964). Epub 2020 Feb 26. [PMID: 32083498](https://pubmed.gov/32083498)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r585d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0383-2020-12-21-548.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0383-2020-12-21-548.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e37a3abd1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0383-2020-12-21-548.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ontario Health (Quality). Gene Expression Profiling Tests for Early-Stage Invasive Breast Cancer: A Health Technology Assessment. Ont Health Technol Assess Ser. 2020 Mar 6;20(10):1-234. [PMID: 32284770](https://pubmed.gov/32284770); [PMCID: PMC7143374](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7143374)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r548d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0384-2020-12-21-422.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0384-2020-12-21-422.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..604f8aa1f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0384-2020-12-21-422.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Silva K, Lee WK, Forbes A, Demmer RT, Barton C, Enticott J. Use and performance of machine learning models for type 2 diabetes prediction in community settings: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Med Inform. 2020 Nov;143:104268. [doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104268](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104268). Epub 2020 Sep 7. [PMID: 32950874](https://pubmed.gov/32950874)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r422d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0385-2020-12-21-189.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0385-2020-12-21-189.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9fce8b694 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0385-2020-12-21-189.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Qian H, Chen R, Wang B, Yuan X, Chen S, Liu Y, Shi G. Associations of Platelet Count with Inflammation and Response to Anti-TNF-α Therapy in Patients with Ankylosing Spondylitis. Front Pharmacol. 2020 Nov 6;11:559593. [doi: 10.3389/fphar.2020.559593](https://doi.org/10.3389/fphar.2020.559593). [PMID: 33343345](https://pubmed.gov/33343345); [PMCID: PMC7741170](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7741170)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r189d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0386-2020-12-21-191.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0386-2020-12-21-191.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..997f4eaca --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0386-2020-12-21-191.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Huhn M, Nikolakopoulou A, Schneider-Thoma J, Krause M, Samara M, Peter N, Arndt T, Bäckers L, Rothe P, Cipriani A, Davis J, Salanti G, Leucht S. Comparative Efficacy and Tolerability of 32 Oral Antipsychotics for the Acute Treatment of Adults With Multi-Episode Schizophrenia: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis. Focus (Am Psychiatr Publ). 2020 Oct;18(4):443-455. [doi: 10.1176/appi.focus.18306](https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.focus.18306). Epub 2020 Nov 5. [PMID: 33343258](https://pubmed.gov/33343258); [PMCID: PMC7725155](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7725155)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r191d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0387-2020-12-21-425.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0387-2020-12-21-425.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..90808a08c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0387-2020-12-21-425.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hakimi AA, Armstrong WB. Hand Sanitizer in a Pandemic: Wrong Formulations in the Wrong Hands. J Emerg Med. 2020 Nov;59(5):668-672. [doi: 10.1016/j.jemermed.2020.07.018](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jemermed.2020.07.018). Epub 2020 Sep 10. [PMID: 32921540](https://pubmed.gov/32921540)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r425d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0388-2020-12-21-3.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0388-2020-12-21-3.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b37dc1978 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0388-2020-12-21-3.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Galderisi A, Bruschettini M, Russo C, Hall R, Trevisanuto D. Continuous glucose monitoring for the prevention of morbidity and mortality in preterm infants. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Dec 21;12:CD013309. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013309.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD013309.pub2). [PMID: 33348448](https://pubmed.gov/33348448)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r3d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0389-2020-12-21-320.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0389-2020-12-21-320.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3f1e90564 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0389-2020-12-21-320.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sangkomkamhang US, Lumbiganon P, Pattanittum P. Progestogens or progestogen-releasing intrauterine systems for uterine fibroids (other than preoperative medical therapy). Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 23;11:CD008994. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008994.pub3](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD008994.pub3). [PMID: 33226133](https://pubmed.gov/33226133)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r320d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0390-2020-12-21-575.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0390-2020-12-21-575.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..83609d03b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0390-2020-12-21-575.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Masuda E, Ozsvath K, Vossler J, Woo K, Kistner R, Lurie F, Monahan D, Brown W, Labropoulos N, Dalsing M, Khilnani N, Wakefield T, Gloviczki P. The 2020 appropriate use criteria for chronic lower extremity venous disease of the American Venous Forum, the Society for Vascular Surgery, the American Vein and Lymphatic Society, and the Society of Interventional Radiology. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2020 Jul;8(4):505-525.e4. [doi: 10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.02.001](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.02.001). Epub 2020 Mar 3. [PMID: 32139328](https://pubmed.gov/32139328)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r575d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0391-2020-12-21-15.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0391-2020-12-21-15.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..69527cd44 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0391-2020-12-21-15.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Nabizadeh-Gharghozar Z, Alavi NM, Ajorpaz NM. Clinical competence in nursing: A hybrid concept analysis. Nurse Educ Today. 2020 Dec 16;97:104728. [doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2020.104728](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2020.104728). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348301](https://pubmed.gov/33348301)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r15d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0392-2020-12-21-29.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0392-2020-12-21-29.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c086c88b3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0392-2020-12-21-29.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Uccella S, Zorzato PC, Kho RM. INCIDENCE AND PREVENTION OF VAGINAL CUFF DEHISCENCE FOLLOWING LAPAROSCOPIC AND ROBOTIC HYSTERECTOMY: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND META-ANALYSIS. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2020 Dec 18:S1553-4650(20)31190-0. [doi: 10.1016/j.jmig.2020.12.016](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmig.2020.12.016). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348012](https://pubmed.gov/33348012)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r29d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0393-2020-12-21-678.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0393-2020-12-21-678.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cfe8f4533 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0393-2020-12-21-678.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘McKenzie J, Joy A. Family intervention improves outcomes for patients with delirium: Systematic review and meta-analysis. Australas J Ageing. 2020 Mar;39(1):21-30. [doi: 10.1111/ajag.12688](https://doi.org/10.1111/ajag.12688). Epub 2019 Jun 28. [PMID: 31250961](https://pubmed.gov/31250961)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r678d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0394-2020-12-21-627.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0394-2020-12-21-627.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cfcf11b7f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0394-2020-12-21-627.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Piepoli MF, Abreu A, Albus C, Ambrosetti M, Brotons C, Catapano AL, Corra U, Cosyns B, Deaton C, Graham I, Hoes A, Lochen ML, Matrone B, Redon J, Sattar N, Smulders Y, Tiberi M. Update on cardiovascular prevention in clinical practice: A position paper of the European Association of Preventive Cardiology of the European Society of Cardiology. Eur J Prev Cardiol. 2020 Jan;27(2):181-205. [doi: 10.1177/2047487319893035](https://doi.org/10.1177/2047487319893035). Epub 2019 Dec 12. [PMID: 31826679](https://pubmed.gov/31826679)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r627d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0395-2020-12-21-337.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0395-2020-12-21-337.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b397c6f96 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0395-2020-12-21-337.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Thomson J, Hogan S, Leonardi-Bee J, Williams HC, Bath-Hextall FJ. Interventions for basal cell carcinoma of the skin. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 17;11:CD003412. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003412.pub3](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD003412.pub3). [PMID: 33202063](https://pubmed.gov/33202063)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r337d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0396-2020-12-21-475.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0396-2020-12-21-475.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f48c2a4c6 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0396-2020-12-21-475.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Stockbridge J, Jones AR, Gillanders BM. A meta-analysis of multiple stressors on seagrasses in the context of marine spatial cumulative impacts assessment. Sci Rep. 2020 Jul 20;10(1):11934. [doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-68801-w](https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-68801-w). [PMID: 32686719](https://pubmed.gov/32686719); [PMCID: PMC7371696](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7371696)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r475d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0397-2020-12-21-210.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0397-2020-12-21-210.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d1bdcb0c1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0397-2020-12-21-210.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Licurci CAA, Lins L, Garbossa M, Canabarro A. A comparative study between replica and cementation techniques in the evaluation of internal and marginal misfits of single crowns. J Prosthet Dent. 2020 Dec 17:S0022-3913(20)30692-2. [doi: 10.1016/j.prosdent.2020.11.004](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.prosdent.2020.11.004). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342611](https://pubmed.gov/33342611)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r210d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0398-2020-12-21-647.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0398-2020-12-21-647.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1f3bbb8a9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0398-2020-12-21-647.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sánchez-Ruano L, de la Hoz B, Martínez-Botas J. Clinical utility of microarray B-cell epitope mapping in food allergies: A systematic review. Pediatr Allergy Immunol. 2020 Feb;31(2):175-185. [doi: 10.1111/pai.13141](https://doi.org/10.1111/pai.13141). Epub 2019 Nov 21. [PMID: 31655013](https://pubmed.gov/31655013)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r647d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0399-2020-12-21-57.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0399-2020-12-21-57.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8ee13baf5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0399-2020-12-21-57.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Gabriel A, Camardo M, O'Rorke E, Gold R, Kim PJ. Effects of Negative- Pressure Wound Therapy With Instillation versus Standard of Care in Multiple Wound Types: Systematic Literature Review and Meta-Analysis. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2021 Jan 1;147(1S-1):68S-76S. [doi: 10.1097/PRS.0000000000007614](https://doi.org/10.1097/PRS.0000000000007614). [PMID: 33347065](https://pubmed.gov/33347065)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r57d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0400-2020-12-21-303.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0400-2020-12-21-303.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f4325184f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0400-2020-12-21-303.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Cabral D, Nawojowska A, Antunes M, Calado T, Torres C, Alvoeiro M, Mendes S, Rodrigues C, Félix F. Lymph Node Upstaging After Surgery In Patients With Negative Mediastinal Staging By Ebus. Rev Port Cir Cardiotorac Vasc. 2020 Oct- Dec;27(4):264. [PMID: 33280296](https://pubmed.gov/33280296)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r303d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0401-2020-12-21-363.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0401-2020-12-21-363.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..921d395c1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0401-2020-12-21-363.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Mrzljak A, Novak R, Mikulic D. Publication Activity on Liver Transplantation from Southeastern European Countries: A Bibliometric Analysis. Chirurgia (Bucur). 2020 Sept-Oct;115(5):635-642. [doi: 10.21614/chirurgia.115.5.635](https://doi.org/10.21614/chirurgia.115.5.635). [PMID: 33138901](https://pubmed.gov/33138901)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r363d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0402-2020-12-21-606.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0402-2020-12-21-606.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2178d3db6 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0402-2020-12-21-606.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Gupta D, Potter T, Disher T, Eaton K, Goldstein L, Patel L, Grima D, Velleca M, Costa G. Comparative effectiveness of catheter ablation devices in the treatment of atrial fibrillation: a network meta-analysis. J Comp Eff Res. 2020 Jan;9(2):115-126. [doi: 10.2217/cer-2019-0165](https://doi.org/10.2217/cer-2019-0165). Epub 2020 Jan 8. [PMID: 31913063](https://pubmed.gov/31913063)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r606d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0403-2020-12-21-237.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0403-2020-12-21-237.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..db87f7f82 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0403-2020-12-21-237.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Martin CL, Bakker CJ, Breth MS, Gao G, Lee K, Lee MA, Tiase VL, Tunby LJ, Wyatt TH, Janeway LM. The efficacy of mobile health interventions used to manage acute or chronic pain: A systematic review. Res Nurs Health. 2020 Dec 20. [doi: 10.1002/nur.22097](https://doi.org/10.1002/nur.22097). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341989](https://pubmed.gov/33341989)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r237d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0404-2020-12-21-405.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0404-2020-12-21-405.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e40122aa4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0404-2020-12-21-405.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Emadzadeh M, Rashidmayvan M, Sahebi R, Sadeghi R, Ferns GA, Ghayour- Mobarhan M. The effect of vitamin D fortified products on anthropometric indices: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101242. [doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101242](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101242). Epub 2020 Sep 23. [PMID: 33035745](https://pubmed.gov/33035745)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r405d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0405-2020-12-21-204.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0405-2020-12-21-204.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7d58da423 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0405-2020-12-21-204.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Jiang C, Huang DG, Yan L, Hao DJ. The efficacy of triclosan coated sutures for preventing surgical site infections in orthopedic surgery: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Asian J Surg. 2020 Dec 17:S1015-9584(20)30378-X. [doi: 10.1016/j.asjsur.2020.11.019](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.asjsur.2020.11.019). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342701](https://pubmed.gov/33342701)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r204d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0406-2020-12-21-629.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0406-2020-12-21-629.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..03e58e9e4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0406-2020-12-21-629.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Domínguez-Borràs J, Moyne M, Saj A, Guex R, Vuilleumier P. Impaired emotional biases in visual attention after bilateral amygdala lesion. Neuropsychologia. 2020 Feb 3;137:107292. [doi: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2019.107292](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2019.107292). Epub 2019 Dec 4. [PMID: 31811846](https://pubmed.gov/31811846)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r629d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0407-2020-12-21-287.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0407-2020-12-21-287.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fb8244bad --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0407-2020-12-21-287.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ansari M, Sharifian M, Ehrampoush MH, Mahvi AH, Salmani MH, Fallahzadeh H. Dielectric barrier discharge plasma with photocatalysts as a hybrid emerging technology for degradation of synthetic organic compounds in aqueous environments: A critical review. Chemosphere. 2021 Jan;263:128065. [doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128065](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128065). Epub 2020 Aug 23. [PMID: 33297070](https://pubmed.gov/33297070)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r287d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0408-2020-12-21-496.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0408-2020-12-21-496.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2206dba86 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0408-2020-12-21-496.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Rezaee ME, Gross MS. Are We Overstating the Risk of Priapism With Oral Phosphodiesterase Type 5 Inhibitors? J Sex Med. 2020 Aug;17(8):1579-1582. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.05.019](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.05.019). Epub 2020 Jul 2. [PMID: 32622767](https://pubmed.gov/32622767)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r496d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0409-2020-12-21-493.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0409-2020-12-21-493.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..58991a5e3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0409-2020-12-21-493.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Haddad R, Monaghan TF, Joussain C, Phé V, Bower W, Roggeman S, Robain G, Everaert K. Nocturia in patients with cognitive dysfunction: a systematic review of the literature. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Jul 6;20(1):230. [doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01622-8](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-020-01622-8). [PMID: 32631237](https://pubmed.gov/32631237); [PMCID: PMC7336631](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7336631)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r493d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0410-2020-12-21-471.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0410-2020-12-21-471.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..607d1373c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0410-2020-12-21-471.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kåks P, Målqvist M. Peer support for disadvantaged parents: a narrative review of strategies used in home visiting health interventions in high-income countries. BMC Health Serv Res. 2020 Jul 23;20(1):682. [doi: 10.1186/s12913-020-05540-8](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-020-05540-8). [PMID: 32703302](https://pubmed.gov/32703302); [PMCID: PMC7376883](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7376883)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r471d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0411-2020-12-21-429.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0411-2020-12-21-429.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..10d91d58d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0411-2020-12-21-429.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lenihan D, Carver J, Porter C, Liu JE, Dent S, Thavendiranathan P, Mitchell JD, Nohria A, Fradley MG, Pusic I, Stockerl-Goldstein K, Blaes A, Lyon AR, Ganatra S, López-Fernández T, O'Quinn R, Minotti G, Szmit S, Cardinale D, Alvarez-Cardona J, Curigliano G, Neilan TG, Herrmann J. Cardio-oncology care in the era of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic: An International Cardio-Oncology Society (ICOS) statement. CA Cancer J Clin. 2020 Nov;70(6):480-504. [doi: 10.3322/caac.21635](https://doi.org/10.3322/caac.21635). Epub 2020 Sep 10. [PMID: 32910493](https://pubmed.gov/32910493)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r429d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0412-2020-12-21-679.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0412-2020-12-21-679.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fbde08657 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0412-2020-12-21-679.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Romanos GE, Romanos EB, Alqahtani F, Alqahtani M, Javed F. "Religious Belief": An Undervalued Ethical Inclusion Criterion for Clinical Trials on Bone Grafting Procedures. J Relig Health. 2020 Dec;59(6):2928-2934. [doi: 10.1007/s10943-019-00851-5](https://doi.org/10.1007/s10943-019-00851-5). [PMID: 31154591](https://pubmed.gov/31154591)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r679d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0413-2020-12-21-448.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0413-2020-12-21-448.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..342bf2453 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0413-2020-12-21-448.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Towe M, Huynh LM, Osman MM, El-Khatib FM, Andrianne R, Barton G, Broderick G, Burnett AL, Campbell JD, Clavell-Hernandez J, Connor J, Gross M, Guillum R, Guise AI, Hatzichristodoulou G, Henry GD, Hsieh TC, Jenkins LC, Koprowski C, Lee KB, Lentz A, Munarriz RM, Osmonov D, Pan S, Parikh K, Park SH, Patel AS, Perito P, Sadeghi-Nejad H, Sempels M, Simhan J, Wang R, Yafi FA. Impact of Antimicrobial Dipping Solutions on Postoperative Infection Rates in Patients With Diabetes Undergoing Primary Insertion of a Coloplast Titan Inflatable Penile Prosthesis. J Sex Med. 2020 Oct;17(10):2077-2083. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.07.009](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.07.009). Epub 2020 Aug 15. [PMID: 32807707](https://pubmed.gov/32807707)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r448d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0414-2020-12-21-269.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0414-2020-12-21-269.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8125ead53 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0414-2020-12-21-269.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Drugs and Lactation Database (LactMed) [Internet]. Bethesda (MD): National Library of Medicine (US); 2006–. Domperidone. 2020 Dec 21. [PMID: 30000430](https://pubmed.gov/30000430)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r269d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0415-2020-12-21-160.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0415-2020-12-21-160.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e358f4320 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0415-2020-12-21-160.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Cuenca-Martínez F, Zapardiel-Sánchez E, Carrasco-González E, La Touche R, Suso-Martí L. Assessing anxiety, depression and quality of life in patients with peripheral facial palsy: a systematic review. PeerJ. 2020 Dec 1;8:e10449. [doi: 10.7717/peerj.10449](https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.10449). [PMID: 33344085](https://pubmed.gov/33344085); [PMCID: PMC7718791](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7718791)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r160d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0416-2020-12-21-80.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0416-2020-12-21-80.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4d519d804 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0416-2020-12-21-80.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lai YW, Huang SH, Lee Y, Chen FM, Lai CS. Personal Approach to Optimizing Inframammary Fold Incision for Asian Augmentation Mammoplasty. Ann Plast Surg. 2020 Dec 15;Publish Ahead of Print. [doi: 10.1097/SAP.0000000000002616](https://doi.org/10.1097/SAP.0000000000002616). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346556](https://pubmed.gov/33346556)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r80d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0417-2020-12-21-450.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0417-2020-12-21-450.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d25ea8744 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0417-2020-12-21-450.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Yao LQ, Tan JY, Turner C, Wang T, Liu XL. Traditional Chinese exercise for cancer-related sleep disturbance: A systematic review and descriptive analysis of randomized controlled trials. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Aug;40:101197. [doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101197](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101197). Epub 2020 May 14. [PMID: 32791319](https://pubmed.gov/32791319)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r450d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0418-2020-12-21-10.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0418-2020-12-21-10.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ceea3a0d4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0418-2020-12-21-10.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bernasconi A, Canakoglu A, Masseroli M, Pinoli P, Ceri S. A review on viral data sources and search systems for perspective mitigation of COVID-19. Brief Bioinform. 2020 Dec 22:bbaa359. [doi: 10.1093/bib/bbaa359](https://doi.org/10.1093/bib/bbaa359). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348368](https://pubmed.gov/33348368)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r10d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0419-2020-12-21-535.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0419-2020-12-21-535.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3e9164c06 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0419-2020-12-21-535.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘O'Donnell TF Jr, Allison GM, Melikian R, Iafrati MD. A systematic review of the quality of clinical practice guidelines for lymphedema, as assessed using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II instrument. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2020 Jul;8(4):685-692. [doi: 10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.04.008](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.04.008). Epub 2020 Apr 23. [PMID: 32335331](https://pubmed.gov/32335331)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r535d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0420-2020-12-21-87.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0420-2020-12-21-87.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d89b22b7e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0420-2020-12-21-87.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bizhani N, Hashemi Hafshejani S, Mohammadi N, Rezaei M, Rokni MB. Human Cysticercosis in Asia: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Iran J Public Health. 2020 Oct;49(10):1839-1847. [doi: 10.18502/ijph.v49i10.4683](https://doi.org/10.18502/ijph.v49i10.4683). [PMID: 33346233](https://pubmed.gov/33346233); [PMCID: PMC7719645](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7719645)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r87d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0421-2020-12-21-594.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0421-2020-12-21-594.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..772238fd5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0421-2020-12-21-594.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhang X, Yang P, Guo C, Li S, Zhang Y. Effects of volume-assured pressure support noninvasive ventilation in stable COPD with chronic respiratory failure: Meta-analysis and literature review. Heart Lung. 2020 May-Jun;49(3):287-295. [doi: 10.1016/j.hrtlng.2020.01.007](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hrtlng.2020.01.007). Epub 2020 Feb 5. [PMID: 32035642](https://pubmed.gov/32035642)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r594d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0422-2020-12-21-348.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0422-2020-12-21-348.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c58af4b77 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0422-2020-12-21-348.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Oladapo OT, Okusanya BO, Abalos E, Gallos ID, Papadopoulou A. Intravenous versus intramuscular prophylactic oxytocin for the third stage of labour. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 9;11:CD009332. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009332.pub4](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD009332.pub4). [PMID: 33169839](https://pubmed.gov/33169839)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r348d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0423-2020-12-21-536.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0423-2020-12-21-536.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2fa333e5f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0423-2020-12-21-536.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Dai Y, Cook OY, Yeganeh L, Huang C, Ding J, Johnson CE. Patient-Reported Barriers and Facilitators to Seeking and Accessing Support in Gynecologic and Breast Cancer Survivors With Sexual Problems: A Systematic Review of Qualitative and Quantitative Studies. J Sex Med. 2020 Jul;17(7):1326-1358. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.03.004](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.03.004). Epub 2020 Apr 21. [PMID: 32331967](https://pubmed.gov/32331967)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r536d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0424-2020-12-21-51.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0424-2020-12-21-51.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..06a686cbf --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0424-2020-12-21-51.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Tso LO, Costello MF, Albuquerque LET, Andriolo RB, Macedo CR. Metformin treatment before and during IVF or ICSI in women with polycystic ovary syndrome. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Dec 21;12:CD006105. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD006105.pub4](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD006105.pub4). [PMID: 33347618](https://pubmed.gov/33347618)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r51d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0425-2020-12-21-370.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0425-2020-12-21-370.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7935178a4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0425-2020-12-21-370.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Abed Al Ahad M, Sullivan F, Demšar U, Melhem M, Kulu H. The effect of air- pollution and weather exposure on mortality and hospital admission and implications for further research: A systematic scoping review. PLoS One. 2020 Oct 29;15(10):e0241415. [doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0241415](https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0241415). [PMID: 33119678](https://pubmed.gov/33119678); [PMCID: PMC7595412](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7595412)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r370d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0426-2020-12-21-302.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0426-2020-12-21-302.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..baf696683 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0426-2020-12-21-302.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Duarte-Gamas L, Pereira-Neves A, Jácome F, Sousa-Pinto B, Rocha-Neves J. The Diagnostic Accuracy Of Nearinfrared Spectroscopy In Carotid Artery Endarterectomy Under Regional Anesthesia - Systematic Review And Meta-Analysis. Rev Port Cir Cardiotorac Vasc. 2020 Oct-Dec;27(4):277-278. [PMID: 33280306](https://pubmed.gov/33280306)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r302d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0427-2020-12-21-42.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0427-2020-12-21-42.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..681eb6a3a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0427-2020-12-21-42.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Shah SS, Gaal BT, Roche AM, Namdari S, Grawe BM, Lawler M, Dalton S, King JJ, Helmkamp J, Garrigues GE, Wright TW, Schoch BS, Flik K, Otto RJ, Jones R, Jawa A, McCann P, Abboud J, Horneff G, Ross G, Friedman R, Ricchetti ET, Boardman D, Tashjian RZ, Gulotta LV. The modern reverse shoulder arthroplasty and an updated systematic review for each complication: part I. JSES Int. 2020 Sep 7;4(4):929-943. [doi: 10.1016/j.jseint.2020.07.017](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jseint.2020.07.017). [PMID: 33345237](https://pubmed.gov/33345237); [PMCID: PMC7738599](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7738599)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r42d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0428-2020-12-21-227.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0428-2020-12-21-227.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..18fd668a1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0428-2020-12-21-227.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sun K, Sun F, Yao H, Zhang D, Wu G, Wang T, Wang J, Wu J. Efficacy and Safety of Combination Comprising Tamsulosin and PDE5-Is, Relative to Monotherapies, in Treating Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms and Erectile Dysfunction Associated With Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia: A Meta-Analysis. Am J Mens Health. 2020 Nov-Dec;14(6):1557988320980180. [doi: 10.1177/1557988320980180](https://doi.org/10.1177/1557988320980180). [PMID: 33342335](https://pubmed.gov/33342335)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r227d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0429-2020-12-21-214.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0429-2020-12-21-214.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..567f3cc59 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0429-2020-12-21-214.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Şık AS, Aydınoğlu AU, Aydın Son Y. Assessing the readiness of Turkish health information systems for integrating genetic/genomic patient data: System architecture and available terminologies, legislative, and protection of personal data. Health Policy. 2020 Dec 8:S0168-8510(20)30303-1. [doi: 10.1016/j.healthpol.2020.12.004](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.healthpol.2020.12.004). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342546](https://pubmed.gov/33342546)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r214d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0430-2020-12-21-331.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0430-2020-12-21-331.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4d59398e9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0430-2020-12-21-331.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Panin SI, Postolov MP, Kovalenko NV, Beburishvili AG, Fedorov AV, Bykov AV. Sravnitel'naya otsenka subtotal'noi distal'noi rezektsii i gastrektomii v khirurgicheskom lechenie bol'nykh rakom zheludka [Distal subtotal gastrectomy and gastreectomy in surgical treatment of patients with gastric cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis]. Khirurgiia (Mosk). 2020;(11):93-100. Russian. [doi: 10.17116/hirurgia202011193](https://doi.org/10.17116/hirurgia202011193). [PMID: 33210514](https://pubmed.gov/33210514)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r331d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0431-2020-12-21-418.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0431-2020-12-21-418.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2a6bcd6a0 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0431-2020-12-21-418.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘da Costa RMB, Poluha RL, De la Torre Canales G, Junior JFS, Conti PCR, Neppelenbroek KH, Porto VC. The effectiveness of microwave disinfection in treating Candida-associated denture stomatitis: a systematic review and metaanalysis. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3821-3832. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03599-5](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-020-03599-5). Epub 2020 Sep 24. [PMID: 32974776](https://pubmed.gov/32974776)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r418d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0432-2020-12-21-21.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0432-2020-12-21-21.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0721c8dac --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0432-2020-12-21-21.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chambergo-Michilot D, Brañez-Condorena A, Falvy-Bockos I, Pacheco-Mendoza J, Benites-Zapata VA. Efficacy of omega-3 supplementation on sertraline continuous therapy to reduce depression or anxiety symptoms: A systematic review and meta- analysis. Psychiatry Res. 2020 Dec 15;296:113652. [doi: 10.1016/j.psychres.2020.113652](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychres.2020.113652). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348198](https://pubmed.gov/33348198)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r21d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0433-2020-12-21-512.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0433-2020-12-21-512.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0dce9fbd7 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0433-2020-12-21-512.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Poletto AG, Mello FW, Melo G, Rivero ERC. Prevalence of mucoepidermoid carcinoma among intraoral minor salivary gland tumors: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Oral Pathol Med. 2020 Sep;49(8):720-726. [doi: 10.1111/jop.13073](https://doi.org/10.1111/jop.13073). Epub 2020 Jul 4. [PMID: 32531838](https://pubmed.gov/32531838)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r512d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0434-2020-12-21-279.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0434-2020-12-21-279.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..50718ecd7 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0434-2020-12-21-279.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Reichert M, Sartelli M, Weigand MA, Doppstadt C, Hecker M, Reinisch-Liese A, Bender F, Askevold I, Padberg W, Coccolini F, Catena F, Hecker A; WSES COVID-19 emergency surgery survey collaboration group. Impact of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic on emergency surgery services-a multi-national survey among WSES members. World J Emerg Surg. 2020 Dec 9;15(1):64. [doi: 10.1186/s13017-020-00341-0](https://doi.org/10.1186/s13017-020-00341-0). [PMID: 33298131](https://pubmed.gov/33298131); [PMCID: PMC7724441](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7724441)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r279d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0435-2020-12-21-383.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0435-2020-12-21-383.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..65b27d869 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0435-2020-12-21-383.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Leisman DE, Ronner L, Pinotti R, Taylor MD, Sinha P, Calfee CS, Hirayama AV, Mastroiani F, Turtle CJ, Harhay MO, Legrand M, Deutschman CS. Cytokine elevation in severe and critical COVID-19: a rapid systematic review, meta- analysis, and comparison with other inflammatory syndromes. Lancet Respir Med. 2020 Dec;8(12):1233-1244. [doi: 10.1016/S2213-2600(20)30404-5](https://doi.org/10.1016/S2213-2600(20)30404-5). Epub 2020 Oct 16. [PMID: 33075298](https://pubmed.gov/33075298); [PMCID: PMC7567529](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7567529)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r383d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0436-2020-12-21-379.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0436-2020-12-21-379.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..69cabfee2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0436-2020-12-21-379.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Escontrías OA, Istrate E, Stewart DCL. Curricular and clinical approaches to addressing the opioid epidemic: Results from the 2019 ADEA opioid dental school survey. J Dent Educ. 2020 Dec;84(12):1359-1367. [doi: 10.1002/jdd.12452](https://doi.org/10.1002/jdd.12452). Epub 2020 Oct 22. [PMID: 33089898](https://pubmed.gov/33089898)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r379d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0437-2020-12-21-662.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0437-2020-12-21-662.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..54bc06e9c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0437-2020-12-21-662.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lu HT, Shen QY, Xie D, Zhao QZ, Xu YM. Lack of association between appendectomy and Parkinson's disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Aging Clin Exp Res. 2020 Nov;32(11):2201-2209. [doi: 10.1007/s40520-019-01354-9](https://doi.org/10.1007/s40520-019-01354-9). Epub 2019 Sep 19. [PMID: 31538320](https://pubmed.gov/31538320)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r662d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0438-2020-12-21-517.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0438-2020-12-21-517.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6e052b5a9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0438-2020-12-21-517.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘de Buck van Overstraeten A, Brar MS, Khorasani S, Dossa F, Myrelid P. Ileorectal Anastomosis Versus IPAA for the Surgical Treatment of Ulcerative Colitis: A Markov Decision Analysis. Dis Colon Rectum. 2020 Sep;63(9):1276-1284. [doi: 10.1097/DCR.0000000000001686](https://doi.org/10.1097/DCR.0000000000001686). [PMID: 32472777](https://pubmed.gov/32472777)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r517d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0439-2020-12-21-242.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0439-2020-12-21-242.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d705cad10 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0439-2020-12-21-242.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Baijens LWJ, Walshe M, Aaltonen LM, Arens C, Cordier R, Cras P, Crevier- Buchman L, Curtis C, Golusinski W, Govender R, Eriksen JG, Hansen K, Heathcote K, Hess MM, Hosal S, Klussmann JP, Leemans CR, MacCarthy D, Manduchi B, Marie JP, Nouraei R, Parkes C, Pflug C, Pilz W, Regan J, Rommel N, Schindler A, Schols AMWJ, Speyer R, Succo G, Wessel I, Willemsen ACH, Yilmaz T, Clavé P. European white paper: oropharyngeal dysphagia in head and neck cancer. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2020 Dec 19. [doi: 10.1007/s00405-020-06507-5](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00405-020-06507-5). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341909](https://pubmed.gov/33341909)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r242d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0440-2020-12-21-82.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0440-2020-12-21-82.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a560d8e2d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0440-2020-12-21-82.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hauch A, McKee R, Li WY, Crowley JS, Ramamoorthy S, Dobke M. Rectovaginal Fistula Repair 1 Year Later: Lessons Learned. Ann Plast Surg. 2020 Dec 15;Publish Ahead of Print. [doi: 10.1097/SAP.0000000000002626](https://doi.org/10.1097/SAP.0000000000002626). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346534](https://pubmed.gov/33346534)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r82d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0441-2020-12-21-671.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0441-2020-12-21-671.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f10e0b18b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0441-2020-12-21-671.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chirewa B, Wakhisi A. Emergency hormonal contraceptive service provision via community pharmacies in the UK: a systematic review of pharmacists' and young women's views, perspectives and experiences. Perspect Public Health. 2020 Mar;140(2):108-116. [doi: 10.1177/1757913919867356](https://doi.org/10.1177/1757913919867356). Epub 2019 Aug 12. [PMID: 31402746](https://pubmed.gov/31402746)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r671d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0442-2020-12-21-643.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0442-2020-12-21-643.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..acfce11f9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0442-2020-12-21-643.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chen CF, Gao XF, Liu MJ, Jin CL, Xu YZ. Safety and efficacy of the ThermoCool SmartTouch SurroundFlow catheter for atrial fibrillation ablation: A meta-analysis. Clin Cardiol. 2020 Mar;43(3):267-274. [doi: 10.1002/clc.23297](https://doi.org/10.1002/clc.23297). Epub 2019 Nov 19. [PMID: 31743474](https://pubmed.gov/31743474); [PMCID: PMC7068067](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7068067)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r643d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0443-2020-12-21-66.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0443-2020-12-21-66.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..30c20d264 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0443-2020-12-21-66.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lorkowski J, Jugowicz A. Shortage of Physicians: A Critical Review. Adv Exp Med Biol. 2020 Dec 22. [doi: 10.1007/5584_2020_601](https://doi.org/10.1007/5584_2020_601). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346901](https://pubmed.gov/33346901)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r66d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0444-2020-12-21-578.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0444-2020-12-21-578.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b0b014f53 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0444-2020-12-21-578.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Fakhri G, Al Assaad M, Tfayli A. Association of various dietary habits and risk of lung cancer: an updated comprehensive literature review. Tumori. 2020 Dec;106(6):445-456. [doi: 10.1177/0300891619900675](https://doi.org/10.1177/0300891619900675). Epub 2020 Mar 4. [PMID: 32129158](https://pubmed.gov/32129158)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r578d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0445-2020-12-21-224.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0445-2020-12-21-224.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5acac20d4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0445-2020-12-21-224.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Warren C, Barsky A, McGraw AP. What Makes Things Funny? An Integrative Review of the Antecedents of Laughter and Amusement. Pers Soc Psychol Rev. 2020 Dec 21:1088868320961909. [doi: 10.1177/1088868320961909](https://doi.org/10.1177/1088868320961909). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342368](https://pubmed.gov/33342368)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r224d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0446-2020-12-21-140.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0446-2020-12-21-140.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8c7331764 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0446-2020-12-21-140.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Liu G, Deng Y, Zhang S, Lin T, Guo H. Robot-Assisted versus Conventional Open Kidney Transplantation: A Meta-Analysis. Biomed Res Int. 2020 Dec 3;2020:2358028. [doi: 10.1155/2020/2358028](https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/2358028). [PMID: 33344632](https://pubmed.gov/33344632); [PMCID: PMC7732374](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7732374)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r140d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0447-2020-12-21-600.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0447-2020-12-21-600.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1c2643e75 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0447-2020-12-21-600.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Birgin E, Yang C, Hetjens S, Reissfelder C, Hohenberger P, Rahbari NN. Core needle biopsy versus incisional biopsy for differentiation of soft-tissue sarcomas: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Cancer. 2020 Jan 1;126(9):1917-1928. [doi: 10.1002/cncr.32735](https://doi.org/10.1002/cncr.32735). Epub 2020 Feb 5. [PMID: 32022262](https://pubmed.gov/32022262)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r600d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0448-2020-12-21-203.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0448-2020-12-21-203.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ce1dbb48e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0448-2020-12-21-203.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kubota T, Gajera PK, Kuroda N. Meta-analysis of EEG findings in patients with COVID-19. Epilepsy Behav. 2020 Dec 4:107682. [doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2020.107682](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.yebeh.2020.107682). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342709](https://pubmed.gov/33342709)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r203d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0449-2020-12-21-322.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0449-2020-12-21-322.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..67b4583bb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0449-2020-12-21-322.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kuru Alici N, Arikan Dönmez A. A systematic review of the effect of laughter yoga on physical function and psychosocial outcomes in older adults. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101252. [doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101252](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101252). Epub 2020 Oct 28. [PMID: 33217706](https://pubmed.gov/33217706)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r322d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0450-2020-12-21-93.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0450-2020-12-21-93.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..51896881e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0450-2020-12-21-93.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘O'Shea LE, Lord J, Fletcher J, Hasler E, Cameron S. Cervical priming before surgical abortion up to 13+6 weeks' gestation: a systematic review and metaanalyses for the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence-new clinical guidelines for England. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 Nov;2(4):100220. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100220](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100220). Epub 2020 Sep 2. [PMID: 33345928](https://pubmed.gov/33345928)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r93d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0451-2020-12-21-121.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0451-2020-12-21-121.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e3f4492d5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0451-2020-12-21-121.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘McKinney A, Fitzsimons D, Blackwood B, McGaughey J. Patient and family involvement in escalating concerns about clinical deterioration in acute adult wards: A qualitative systematic review. Nurs Crit Care. 2020 Dec 20. [doi: 10.1111/nicc.12582](https://doi.org/10.1111/nicc.12582). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345386](https://pubmed.gov/33345386)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r121d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0452-2020-12-21-541.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0452-2020-12-21-541.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b9598add9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0452-2020-12-21-541.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhao S, Wang X, Qiang X, Wang H, He J, Shen M, Zheng C, Kang R. Is There an Association Between Schizophrenia and Sexual Dysfunction in Both Sexes? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Sex Med. 2020 Aug;17(8):1476-1488. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.03.005](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.03.005). Epub 2020 Apr 14. [PMID: 32299716](https://pubmed.gov/32299716)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r541d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0453-2020-12-21-462.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0453-2020-12-21-462.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c6a497cf2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0453-2020-12-21-462.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lai S, Diao T, Zhang W, Seery S, Zhang Z, Hu M, Meng L, Ma T, Liu X, Wang J, Zhang Y. Sexual Functions in Women With Stress Urinary Incontinence After Mid-Urethral Sling Surgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Prospective Randomized and Non-Randomized Studies. J Sex Med. 2020 Oct;17(10):1956-1970. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.07.003](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.07.003). Epub 2020 Jul 30. [PMID: 32741744](https://pubmed.gov/32741744)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r462d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0454-2020-12-21-264.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0454-2020-12-21-264.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..305b2133e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0454-2020-12-21-264.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hu MC, Yang YL, Chen TT, Lee CI, Tam KW. Recruitment maneuvers to reduce pulmonary atelectasis after cardiac surgery: A meta-analysis of randomized trials. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2020 Nov 26:S0022-5223(20)33105-6. [doi: 10.1016/j.jtcvs.2020.10.142](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtcvs.2020.10.142). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341273](https://pubmed.gov/33341273)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r264d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0455-2020-12-21-644.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0455-2020-12-21-644.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..afc625c3d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0455-2020-12-21-644.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Haltaufderheide J, Nadolny S, Gysels M, Bausewein C, Vollmann J, Schildmann J. Outcomes of clinical ethics support near the end of life: A systematic review. Nurs Ethics. 2020 May;27(3):838-854. [doi: 10.1177/0969733019878840](https://doi.org/10.1177/0969733019878840). Epub 2019 Nov 19. [PMID: 31742473](https://pubmed.gov/31742473)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r644d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0456-2020-12-21-163.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0456-2020-12-21-163.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..026455af9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0456-2020-12-21-163.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Moore D, Semciw AI, Pizzari T. A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND META-ANALYSIS OF COMMON THERAPEUTIC EXERCISES THAT GENERATE HIGHEST MUSCLE ACTIVITY IN THE GLUTEUS MEDIUS AND GLUTEUS MINIMUS SEGMENTS. Int J Sports Phys Ther. 2020 Dec;15(6):856-881. [doi: 10.26603/ijspt20200856](https://doi.org/10.26603/ijspt20200856). [PMID: 33344003](https://pubmed.gov/33344003); [PMCID: PMC7727410](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7727410)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r163d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0457-2020-12-21-146.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0457-2020-12-21-146.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..02719cdf7 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0457-2020-12-21-146.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sokol-Borrelli SL, Coombs RS, Boyle JP. A Comparison of Stage Conversion in the Coccidian Apicomplexans Toxoplasma gondii, Hammondia hammondi, and Neospora caninum. Front Cell Infect Microbiol. 2020 Dec 3;10:608283. [doi: 10.3389/fcimb.2020.608283](https://doi.org/10.3389/fcimb.2020.608283). [PMID: 33344268](https://pubmed.gov/33344268); [PMCID: PMC7744739](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7744739)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r146d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0458-2020-12-21-631.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0458-2020-12-21-631.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..455d2ff85 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0458-2020-12-21-631.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Herrero Babiloni A, Nixdorf DR, Moana-Filho EJ. Persistent dentoalveolar pain disorder: A putative intraoral chronic overlapping pain condition. Oral Dis. 2020 Nov;26(8):1601-1609. [doi: 10.1111/odi.13248](https://doi.org/10.1111/odi.13248). Epub 2019 Dec 17. [PMID: 31797486](https://pubmed.gov/31797486); [PMCID: PMC7269821](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7269821)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r631d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0459-2020-12-21-447.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0459-2020-12-21-447.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ea7603424 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0459-2020-12-21-447.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Turan O, Hakim A, Dashraath P, Jeslyn WJL, Wright A, Abdul-Kadir R. Clinical characteristics, prognostic factors, and maternal and neonatal outcomes of SARS-CoV-2 infection among hospitalized pregnant women: A systematic review. Int J Gynaecol Obstet. 2020 Oct;151(1):7-16. [doi: 10.1002/ijgo.13329](https://doi.org/10.1002/ijgo.13329). Epub 2020 Aug 30. [PMID: 32816307](https://pubmed.gov/32816307)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r447d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0460-2020-12-21-17.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0460-2020-12-21-17.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..382bed680 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0460-2020-12-21-17.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Anderson A, Hartley S, Bucci S. A Systematic Review of the experimental induction of auditory perceptual experiences. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry. 2020 Dec 10;71:101635. [doi: 10.1016/j.jbtep.2020.101635](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbtep.2020.101635). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348277](https://pubmed.gov/33348277)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r17d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0461-2020-12-21-294.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0461-2020-12-21-294.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d5129d2ca --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0461-2020-12-21-294.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Liang S, Zhang G, Li J, Zhong L, Zhang C. Wrist ankle acupuncture in the treatment of acute lumbar sprain: A protocol for systematic review and meta- analysis. Medicine (Baltimore). 2020 Dec 4;99(49):e23420. [doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000023420](https://doi.org/10.1097/MD.0000000000023420). [PMID: 33285734](https://pubmed.gov/33285734); [PMCID: PMC7717768](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7717768)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r294d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0462-2020-12-21-399.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0462-2020-12-21-399.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..678cf6fbb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0462-2020-12-21-399.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Trentino KM, Farmer SL, Isbister JP, Sanfilippo FM, Leahy MF, Hofmann A, Shander A, Murray K. Restrictive Versus Liberal Transfusion Trials: Are They Asking the Right Question? Anesth Analg. 2020 Dec;131(6):1950-1955. [doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000005227](https://doi.org/10.1213/ANE.0000000000005227). [PMID: 33044262](https://pubmed.gov/33044262)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r399d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0463-2020-12-21-673.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0463-2020-12-21-673.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9f4d2be36 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0463-2020-12-21-673.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Neumann DL. A Systematic Review of Attentional Focus Strategies in Weightlifting. Front Sports Act Living. 2019 Aug 9;1:7. [doi: 10.3389/fspor.2019.00007](https://doi.org/10.3389/fspor.2019.00007). [PMID: 33344931](https://pubmed.gov/33344931); [PMCID: PMC7739707](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7739707)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r673d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0464-2020-12-21-553.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0464-2020-12-21-553.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..89e5d063d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0464-2020-12-21-553.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kerr D, Ostaszkiewicz J, Dunning T, Martin P. The effectiveness of training interventions on nurses' communication skills: A systematic review. Nurse Educ Today. 2020 Jun;89:104405. [doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2020.104405](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2020.104405). Epub 2020 Mar 20. [PMID: 32244125](https://pubmed.gov/32244125)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r553d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0465-2020-12-21-100.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0465-2020-12-21-100.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..aa007b35d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0465-2020-12-21-100.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Park K, Gupta NK, Olweny EO, Schlesinger N. BEYOND ARTHRITIS: UNDERSTANDING THE INFLUENCE OF GOUT ON ERECTILE FUNCTION: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW. Urology. 2020 Dec 17:S0090-4295(20)31492-8. [doi: 10.1016/j.urology.2020.12.005](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.urology.2020.12.005). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345860](https://pubmed.gov/33345860)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r100d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0466-2020-12-21-428.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0466-2020-12-21-428.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c4e379508 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0466-2020-12-21-428.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hasan SS, Kow CS, Hadi MA, Zaidi STR, Merchant HA. Mortality and Disease Severity Among COVID-19 Patients Receiving Renin-Angiotensin System Inhibitors: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Am J Cardiovasc Drugs. 2020 Dec;20(6):571-590. [doi: 10.1007/s40256-020-00439-5](https://doi.org/10.1007/s40256-020-00439-5). Epub 2020 Sep 12. [PMID: 32918209](https://pubmed.gov/32918209); [PMCID: PMC7486167](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7486167)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r428d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0467-2020-12-21-103.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0467-2020-12-21-103.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ef16fe197 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0467-2020-12-21-103.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘D'Souza R, Horyn I, Pavalagantharajah S, Zaffar N, Jacob CE. Maternal body mass index and pregnancy outcomes: a systematic review and metaanalysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2019 Nov;1(4):100041. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2019.100041](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajogmf.2019.100041). Epub 2019 Aug 30. [PMID: 33345836](https://pubmed.gov/33345836)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r103d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0468-2020-12-21-659.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0468-2020-12-21-659.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..92a8de080 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0468-2020-12-21-659.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Leonardi-Bee J, Flohr C, van Zuuren EJ, Le Cleach L, Hollestein LM. Common methodological pitfalls and new developments in systematic review meta-analyses. Br J Dermatol. 2019 Oct;181(4):649-651. [doi: 10.1111/bjd.18336](https://doi.org/10.1111/bjd.18336). [PMID: 31576568](https://pubmed.gov/31576568)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r659d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0469-2020-12-21-508.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0469-2020-12-21-508.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..31fcd19fc --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0469-2020-12-21-508.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Watt JA, Goodarzi Z, Veroniki AA, Nincic V, Khan PA, Ghassemi M, Thompson Y, Lai Y, Treister V, Tricco AC, Straus SE. Safety of pharmacologic interventions for neuropsychiatric symptoms in dementia: a systematic review and network meta-analysis. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Jun 16;20(1):212. [doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01607-7](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-020-01607-7). [PMID: 32546202](https://pubmed.gov/32546202); [PMCID: PMC7298771](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7298771)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r508d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0470-2020-12-21-147.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0470-2020-12-21-147.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..69b72256c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0470-2020-12-21-147.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zheng Q, Li J, Zhang H, Wang Y, Zhang S. Immune Checkpoint Inhibitors in Advanced Acral Melanoma: A Systematic Review. Front Oncol. 2020 Dec 3;10:602705. [doi: 10.3389/fonc.2020.602705](https://doi.org/10.3389/fonc.2020.602705). [PMID: 33344255](https://pubmed.gov/33344255); [PMCID: PMC7744720](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7744720)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r147d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0471-2020-12-21-556.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0471-2020-12-21-556.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..32f9de1f0 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0471-2020-12-21-556.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Giuliani M, Frambach J, Broadhurst M, Papadakos J, Fazelad R, Driessen E, Martimianakis MAT. A critical review of representation in the development of global oncology curricula and the influence of neocolonialism. BMC Med Educ. 2020 Mar 30;20(1):93. [doi: 10.1186/s12909-020-1989-9](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-020-1989-9). [PMID: 32228538](https://pubmed.gov/32228538); [PMCID: PMC7106787](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7106787)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r556d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0472-2020-12-21-529.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0472-2020-12-21-529.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bb55066d4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0472-2020-12-21-529.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Soldati L, Bianchi-Demicheli F, Schockaert P, Köhl J, Bolmont M, Hasler R, Perroud N. Sexual Function, Sexual Dysfunctions, and ADHD: A Systematic Literature Review. J Sex Med. 2020 Sep;17(9):1653-1664. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.03.019](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.03.019). Epub 2020 May 10. [PMID: 32402814](https://pubmed.gov/32402814)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r529d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0473-2020-12-21-194.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0473-2020-12-21-194.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8729678bb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0473-2020-12-21-194.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Campanelli S, Tort ABL, Lobão-Soares B. Pranayamas and Their Neurophysiological Effects. Int J Yoga. 2020 Sep-Dec;13(3):183-192. [doi: 10.4103/ijoy.IJOY_91_19](https://doi.org/10.4103/ijoy.IJOY_91_19). Epub 2020 Sep 13. [PMID: 33343147](https://pubmed.gov/33343147); [PMCID: PMC7735501](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7735501)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r194d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0474-2020-12-21-395.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0474-2020-12-21-395.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..51e292a46 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0474-2020-12-21-395.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Mytton OT, Boyland E, Adams J, Collins B, O'Connell M, Russell SJ, Smith K, Stroud R, Viner RM, Cobiac LJ. The potential health impact of restricting less- healthy food and beverage advertising on UK television between 05.30 and 21.00 hours: A modelling study. PLoS Med. 2020 Oct 13;17(10):e1003212. [doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1003212](https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1003212). [PMID: 33048922](https://pubmed.gov/33048922); [PMCID: PMC7553286](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7553286)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r395d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0475-2020-12-21-65.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0475-2020-12-21-65.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f88589032 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0475-2020-12-21-65.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Islam N, Furuya-Kanamori L, Mahmood S, Thalib L. Prophylactic antibiotics for preventing genital tract infection in women undergoing surgical procedures for incomplete abortion: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. BJOG. 2020 Dec 21. [doi: 10.1111/1471-0528.16637](https://doi.org/10.1111/1471-0528.16637). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346920](https://pubmed.gov/33346920)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r65d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0476-2020-12-21-441.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0476-2020-12-21-441.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0839257bf --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0476-2020-12-21-441.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Yang F, Gao Y, Zhang L, Zheng B, Wang L, Sun H, Huang D. Local anaesthesia for surgical extraction of mandibular third molars: a systematic review and network meta-analysis. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3781-3800. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03490-3](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-020-03490-3). Epub 2020 Aug 24. [PMID: 32833132](https://pubmed.gov/32833132)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r441d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0477-2020-12-21-1.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0477-2020-12-21-1.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8dc51379d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0477-2020-12-21-1.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Nujić D, Musić Milanović S, Milas V, Miškulin I, Ivić V, Milas J. Association between child/adolescent overweight/obesity and conduct disorder: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Pediatr Obes. 2020 Dec 21:e12742. [doi: 10.1111/ijpo.12742](https://doi.org/10.1111/ijpo.12742). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348469](https://pubmed.gov/33348469)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r1d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0478-2020-12-21-171.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0478-2020-12-21-171.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..234ba3a7f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0478-2020-12-21-171.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Almoajil H, Theologis T, Dawes H, Parsonage J, Pierce J, Hopewell S, Toye F. Patients' and parents' views about lower limb orthopaedic surgery for ambulant children and young people with cerebral palsy: a qualitative evidence synthesis. J Child Orthop. 2020 Dec 1;14(6):562-573. [doi: 10.1302/1863-2548.14.200139](https://doi.org/10.1302/1863-2548.14.200139). [PMID: 33343752](https://pubmed.gov/33343752); [PMCID: PMC7740689](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7740689)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r171d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0479-2020-12-21-635.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0479-2020-12-21-635.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..dd68f9772 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0479-2020-12-21-635.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kluwe-Schiavon B, Viola TW, Sanvicente-Vieira B, Lumertz FS, Salum GA, Grassi-Oliveira R, Quednow BB. Substance related disorders are associated with impaired valuation of delayed gratification and feedback processing: A multilevel meta-analysis and meta-regression. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:295-307. [doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.11.016](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.11.016). Epub 2019 Nov 25. [PMID: 31778679](https://pubmed.gov/31778679)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r635d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0480-2020-12-21-652.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0480-2020-12-21-652.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6bcbefab3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0480-2020-12-21-652.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Wright DK, Gastmans C, Vandyk A, de Casterlé BD. Moral identity and palliative sedation: A systematic review of normative nursing literature. Nurs Ethics. 2020 May;27(3):868-886. [doi: 10.1177/0969733019876312](https://doi.org/10.1177/0969733019876312). Epub 2019 Oct 21. [PMID: 31635514](https://pubmed.gov/31635514)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r652d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0481-2020-12-21-364.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0481-2020-12-21-364.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b976f3eaa --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0481-2020-12-21-364.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Rosendahl K, Lundestad A, Bjørlykke JA, Lein RK, Angenete O, Augdal TA, Müller LO, Jaramillo D. Revisiting the radiographic assessment of osteoporosis- Osteopenia in children 0-2 years of age. A systematic review. PLoS One. 2020 Nov 2;15(11):e0241635. [doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0241635](https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0241635). [PMID: 33137162](https://pubmed.gov/33137162); [PMCID: PMC7605664](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7605664)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r364d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0482-2020-12-21-158.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0482-2020-12-21-158.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ee7a1d1e4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0482-2020-12-21-158.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Finch AJ, Jurinsky J, Anderson BM. Recovery and Youth: An Integrative Review. Alcohol Res. 2020 Dec 17;40(3):06. [doi: 10.35946/arcr.v40.3.06](https://doi.org/10.35946/arcr.v40.3.06). [PMID: 33344101](https://pubmed.gov/33344101); [PMCID: PMC7732345](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7732345)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r158d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0483-2020-12-21-241.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0483-2020-12-21-241.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2751f53cf --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0483-2020-12-21-241.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hussein AAA, Bloem E, Fodor I, Baz ES, Tadros MM, Soliman MFM, El-Shenawy NS, Koene JM. Slowly seeing the light: an integrative review on ecological light pollution as a potential threat for mollusks. Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2020 Dec 19. [doi: 10.1007/s11356-020-11824-7](https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-020-11824-7). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341922](https://pubmed.gov/33341922)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r241d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0484-2020-12-21-154.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0484-2020-12-21-154.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fe2599547 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0484-2020-12-21-154.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Werneck AO, Winpenny EM, Foubister C, Guagliano JM, Monnickendam AG, van Sluijs EMF, Corder K. Cohabitation and marriage during the transition between adolescence and emerging adulthood: A systematic review of changes in weight- related outcomes, diet and physical activity. Prev Med Rep. 2020 Nov 28;20:101261. [doi: 10.1016/j.pmedr.2020.101261](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pmedr.2020.101261). [PMID: 33344148](https://pubmed.gov/33344148); [PMCID: PMC7736988](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7736988)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r154d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0485-2020-12-21-524.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0485-2020-12-21-524.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3991d6a37 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0485-2020-12-21-524.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kunnumakkara AB, Shabnam B, Girisa S, Harsha C, Banik K, Devi TB, Choudhury R, Sahu H, Parama D, Sailo BL, Thakur KK, Gupta SC, Aggarwal BB. Inflammation, NF-κB, and Chronic Diseases: How are They Linked? Crit Rev Immunol. 2020;40(1):1-39. [doi: 10.1615/CritRevImmunol.2020033210](https://doi.org/10.1615/CritRevImmunol.2020033210). [PMID: 32421977](https://pubmed.gov/32421977)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r524d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0486-2020-12-21-687.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0486-2020-12-21-687.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b31e6e702 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0486-2020-12-21-687.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Gaviola MA, Inder KJ, Dilworth S, Holliday EG, Higgins I. Impact of individualised music listening intervention on persons with dementia: A systematic review of randomised controlled trials. Australas J Ageing. 2020 Mar;39(1):10-20. [doi: 10.1111/ajag.12642](https://doi.org/10.1111/ajag.12642). Epub 2019 Mar 26. [PMID: 30912616](https://pubmed.gov/30912616)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r687d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0487-2020-12-21-520.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0487-2020-12-21-520.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f69c122b4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0487-2020-12-21-520.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Quasie-Woode DP, Cunningham-Erves J, Mayo-Gamble TL. The Use of Religion in the Management of Depression in Sickle Cell Disease: A Systematic Review. J Relig Health. 2020 Dec;59(6):3110-3125. [doi: 10.1007/s10943-020-01039-y](https://doi.org/10.1007/s10943-020-01039-y). [PMID: 32447507](https://pubmed.gov/32447507)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r520d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0488-2020-12-21-172.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0488-2020-12-21-172.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..67f752ce9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0488-2020-12-21-172.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Landre T, Chouahnia K, Des Guetz G, Duchemann B, Assié JB, Chouaïd C. First-line immune-checkpoint inhibitor plus chemotherapy versus chemotherapy alone for extensive-stage small-cell lung cancer: a meta-analysis. Ther Adv Med Oncol. 2020 Dec 9;12:1758835920977137. [doi: 10.1177/1758835920977137](https://doi.org/10.1177/1758835920977137). [PMID: 33343721](https://pubmed.gov/33343721); [PMCID: PMC7731693](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7731693)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r172d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0489-2020-12-21-297.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0489-2020-12-21-297.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2bdb8d9e1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0489-2020-12-21-297.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhang J, Feng J, Liu Y. Preventive effect and safety of Chinese herbal medicine mouthwash in chemotherapy-induced oral mucositis: A protocol for systematic review and meta analysis. Medicine (Baltimore). 2020 Dec 4;99(49):e23387. [doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000023387](https://doi.org/10.1097/MD.0000000000023387). [PMID: 33285725](https://pubmed.gov/33285725); [PMCID: PMC7717741](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7717741)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r297d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0490-2020-12-21-454.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0490-2020-12-21-454.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4e6bfd1c2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0490-2020-12-21-454.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Martínez-Jiménez F, Muiños F, Sentís I, Deu-Pons J, Reyes-Salazar I, Arnedo-Pac C, Mularoni L, Pich O, Bonet J, Kranas H, Gonzalez-Perez A, Lopez- Bigas N. A compendium of mutational cancer driver genes. Nat Rev Cancer. 2020 Oct;20(10):555-572. [doi: 10.1038/s41568-020-0290-x](https://doi.org/10.1038/s41568-020-0290-x). Epub 2020 Aug 10. [PMID: 32778778](https://pubmed.gov/32778778)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r454d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0491-2020-12-21-487.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0491-2020-12-21-487.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..74abdd534 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0491-2020-12-21-487.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Crayton E, Richardson M, Fuller C, Smith C, Liu S, Forbes G, Anderson N, Shallcross L, Michie S, Hayward A, Lorencatto F. Interventions to improve appropriate antibiotic prescribing in long-term care facilities: a systematic review. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Jul 9;20(1):237. [doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01564-1](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-020-01564-1). [PMID: 32646382](https://pubmed.gov/32646382); [PMCID: PMC7350746](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7350746)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r487d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0492-2020-12-21-463.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0492-2020-12-21-463.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3eaddd33f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0492-2020-12-21-463.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Campbell RE, McGhee AN, Freedman KB, Tjoumakaris FP. Diagnostic Imaging of Ulnar Collateral Ligament Injury: A Systematic Review. Am J Sports Med. 2020 Sep;48(11):2819-2827. [doi: 10.1177/0363546520937302](https://doi.org/10.1177/0363546520937302). Epub 2020 Jul 31. [PMID: 32735456](https://pubmed.gov/32735456)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r463d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0493-2020-12-21-557.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0493-2020-12-21-557.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cf2001da9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0493-2020-12-21-557.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Gouin T. Toward an Improved Understanding of the Ingestion and Trophic Transfer of Microplastic Particles: Critical Review and Implications for Future Research. Environ Toxicol Chem. 2020 May;39(6):1119-1137. [doi: 10.1002/etc.4718](https://doi.org/10.1002/etc.4718). [PMID: 32223000](https://pubmed.gov/32223000); [PMCID: PMC7383496](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7383496)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r557d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0494-2020-12-21-166.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0494-2020-12-21-166.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..92f587240 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0494-2020-12-21-166.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Dolan J, Mandras S, Mehta JP, Navas V, Tarver J, Chakinala M, Rahaghi F. Reducing rates of readmission and development of an outpatient management plan in pulmonary hypertension: lessons from congestive heart failure management. Pulm Circ. 2020 Dec 7;10(4):2045894020968471. [doi: 10.1177/2045894020968471](https://doi.org/10.1177/2045894020968471). [PMID: 33343880](https://pubmed.gov/33343880); [PMCID: PMC7727062](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7727062)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r166d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0495-2020-12-21-670.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0495-2020-12-21-670.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8cce703f4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0495-2020-12-21-670.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Henry BM, Pękala PA, Frączek PA, Pękala JR, Natsis K, Piagkou M, Tomaszewski KA, Tomaszewska IM. Prevalence, morphology, and morphometry of the pterygospinous bar: a meta-analysis. Surg Radiol Anat. 2020 May;42(5):497-507. [doi: 10.1007/s00276-019-02305-9](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00276-019-02305-9). Epub 2019 Aug 28. [PMID: 31463681](https://pubmed.gov/31463681); [PMCID: PMC7096365](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7096365)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r670d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0496-2020-12-21-415.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0496-2020-12-21-415.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f0ec8c905 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0496-2020-12-21-415.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sanchez C, Grzenda A, Varias A, Widge AS, Carpenter LL, McDonald WM, Nemeroff CB, Kalin NH, Martin G, Tohen M, Filippou-Frye M, Ramsey D, Linos E, Mangurian C, Rodriguez CI. Social media recruitment for mental health research: A systematic review. Compr Psychiatry. 2020 Nov;103:152197. [doi: 10.1016/j.comppsych.2020.152197](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.comppsych.2020.152197). Epub 2020 Aug 12. [PMID: 32992073](https://pubmed.gov/32992073); [PMCID: PMC7704547](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7704547)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r415d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0497-2020-12-21-99.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0497-2020-12-21-99.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..61d4544e3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0497-2020-12-21-99.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Link HM, Jones H, Miller L, Kaltenbach K, Seligman N. Buprenorphine-naloxone use in pregnancy: a systematic review and metaanalysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 Aug;2(3):100179. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100179](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100179). Epub 2020 Jul 3. [PMID: 33345863](https://pubmed.gov/33345863)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r99d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0498-2020-12-21-543.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0498-2020-12-21-543.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..882bf327c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0498-2020-12-21-543.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhu J, Ji P, Pang J, Zhong Z, Li H, He C, Zhang J, Zhao C. Clinical characteristics of 3062 COVID-19 patients: A meta-analysis. J Med Virol. 2020 Oct;92(10):1902-1914. [doi: 10.1002/jmv.25884](https://doi.org/10.1002/jmv.25884). Epub 2020 Jun 24. [PMID: 32293716](https://pubmed.gov/32293716); [PMCID: PMC7262119](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7262119)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r543d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0499-2020-12-21-71.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0499-2020-12-21-71.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ea7980894 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0499-2020-12-21-71.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hawkridge K, Ahmed I, Ahmed Z. Evidence for the use of spinal collars in stabilising spinal injuries in the pre-hospital setting in trauma patients: a systematic review. Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg. 2020 Dec 21. [doi: 10.1007/s00068-020-01576-x](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00068-020-01576-x). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346863](https://pubmed.gov/33346863)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r71d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0500-2020-12-21-531.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0500-2020-12-21-531.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4045daa73 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0500-2020-12-21-531.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Opie E, Brooks S, Greenberg N, Rubin GJ. The usefulness of pre-employment and pre-deployment psychological screening for disaster relief workers: a systematic review. BMC Psychiatry. 2020 May 11;20(1):211. [doi: 10.1186/s12888-020-02593-1](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12888-020-02593-1). [PMID: 32393208](https://pubmed.gov/32393208); [PMCID: PMC7216600](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7216600)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r531d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0501-2020-12-21-225.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0501-2020-12-21-225.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ab81345fb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0501-2020-12-21-225.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Karanikas N, Jani BD. Frequency of examination and perceived contribution of factors relating to work-related musculoskeletal disorders of physiotherapists. Int J Occup Saf Ergon. 2020 Dec 21:1-33. [doi: 10.1080/10803548.2020.1867337](https://doi.org/10.1080/10803548.2020.1867337). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342365](https://pubmed.gov/33342365)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r225d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0502-2020-12-21-565.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0502-2020-12-21-565.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e5817b7b3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0502-2020-12-21-565.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Altintas B, Scheidt M, Kremser V, Boykin R, Bhatia S, Sajadi KR, Mair S, Millett PJ. Superior Capsule Reconstruction for Irreparable Massive Rotator Cuff Tears: Does It Make Sense? A Systematic Review of Early Clinical Evidence. Am J Sports Med. 2020 Nov;48(13):3365-3375. [doi: 10.1177/0363546520904378](https://doi.org/10.1177/0363546520904378). Epub 2020 Mar 19. [PMID: 32191494](https://pubmed.gov/32191494)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r565d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0503-2020-12-21-115.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0503-2020-12-21-115.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fe42188b5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0503-2020-12-21-115.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bastos RM, Carvalho Júnior JG, Silva SAMD, Campos SF, Rosa MV, Prianti BM. Answer letter for: "Now you see it - Now you don't: A letter to the editor concerning "Surgery is no more effective than conservative treatment for femoroacetabular impingement syndrome: Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials". Clin Rehabil. 2020 Dec 21:269215520981605. [doi: 10.1177/0269215520981605](https://doi.org/10.1177/0269215520981605). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345596](https://pubmed.gov/33345596)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r115d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0504-2020-12-21-507.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0504-2020-12-21-507.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cff0f218f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0504-2020-12-21-507.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Askar H, Misch J, Chen Z, Chadha S, Wang HL. Capnography monitoring in procedural intravenous sedation: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3761-3770. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03395-1](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-020-03395-1). Epub 2020 Jun 16. [PMID: 32556657](https://pubmed.gov/32556657)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r507d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0505-2020-12-21-396.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0505-2020-12-21-396.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fd5b3227e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0505-2020-12-21-396.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Martin JM, Goldstein LJ. In Support of CDK4/6 Inhibitors-A Meta-analysis of Available Randomized Data. JAMA Netw Open. 2020 Oct 1;3(10):e2021062. [doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.21062](https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.21062). [PMID: 33048125](https://pubmed.gov/33048125)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r396d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0506-2020-12-21-314.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0506-2020-12-21-314.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b73ca38cc --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0506-2020-12-21-314.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Xiang Y, Huang Y, He H, Xu Q. [Phylogenetic and expression analysis of SEPALLATA-like gene in Brassica oleracea L. var. acephala]. Sheng Wu Gong Cheng Xue Bao. 2020 Nov 25;36(11):2398-2412. Chinese. [doi: 10.13345/j.cjb.200422](https://doi.org/10.13345/j.cjb.200422). [PMID: 33244934](https://pubmed.gov/33244934)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r314d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0507-2020-12-21-675.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0507-2020-12-21-675.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..faecfee09 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0507-2020-12-21-675.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘He Y, Li K, Chen Q, Yin J, Bai D. Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation on Motor Recovery for Patients With Stroke: A PRISMA Compliant Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 2020 Feb;99(2):99-108. [doi: 10.1097/PHM.0000000000001277](https://doi.org/10.1097/PHM.0000000000001277). [PMID: 31361620](https://pubmed.gov/31361620)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r675d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0508-2020-12-21-112.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0508-2020-12-21-112.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6b56fdb47 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0508-2020-12-21-112.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sebastian NA, Spence AR, Bouhadoun S, Abenhaim HA. Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation in pregnant and postpartum patients: a systematic review. J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med. 2020 Dec 20:1-11. [doi: 10.1080/14767058.2020.1860932](https://doi.org/10.1080/14767058.2020.1860932). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345652](https://pubmed.gov/33345652)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r112d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0509-2020-12-21-685.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0509-2020-12-21-685.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2680ef831 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0509-2020-12-21-685.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Yeroushalmi S, Maloni H, Costello K, Wallin MT. Telemedicine and multiple sclerosis: A comprehensive literature review. J Telemed Telecare. 2020 Aug- Sep;26(7-8):400-413. [doi: 10.1177/1357633X19840097](https://doi.org/10.1177/1357633X19840097). Epub 2019 May 1. [PMID: 31042118](https://pubmed.gov/31042118)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r685d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0510-2020-12-21-464.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0510-2020-12-21-464.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6bd000be5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0510-2020-12-21-464.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Wang Y, Zhou Q, Xu M, Kang J, Chen Y. Characteristics of Clinical Trials relating to COVID-19 registered at ClinicalTrials.gov. J Clin Pharm Ther. 2020 Dec;45(6):1357-1362. [doi: 10.1111/jcpt.13222](https://doi.org/10.1111/jcpt.13222). Epub 2020 Jul 30. [PMID: 32734670](https://pubmed.gov/32734670)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r464d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0511-2020-12-21-179.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0511-2020-12-21-179.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a66fc6bf4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0511-2020-12-21-179.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Yang J, Yu SY, Yang J, Kong J, Liang FR, Lv ZT. No Association Between G1246A Polymorphism in HCRTR2 Gene and Risk of Cluster Headache: Evidence From an Updated Meta-Analysis of Observational Studies. Front Genet. 2020 Dec 3;11:560517. [doi: 10.3389/fgene.2020.560517](https://doi.org/10.3389/fgene.2020.560517). [PMID: 33343621](https://pubmed.gov/33343621); [PMCID: PMC7744679](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7744679)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r179d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0512-2020-12-21-551.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0512-2020-12-21-551.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bd1597bda --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0512-2020-12-21-551.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Stulz A, Lamore K, Montalescot L, Favez N, Flahault C. Sexual health in colon cancer patients: A systematic review. Psychooncology. 2020 Jul;29(7):1095-1104. [doi: 10.1002/pon.5391](https://doi.org/10.1002/pon.5391). Epub 2020 Apr 20. [PMID: 32281129](https://pubmed.gov/32281129)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r551d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0513-2020-12-21-421.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0513-2020-12-21-421.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..89a958f6b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0513-2020-12-21-421.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Pedersen V. Die (schwer) verletzte schwangere Patientin aus Sicht der Unfallchirurgie [The (severely) injured pregnant patient from the perspective of trauma surgery]. Unfallchirurg. 2020 Dec;123(12):911-921. German. [doi: 10.1007/s00113-020-00868-6](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00113-020-00868-6). [PMID: 32955671](https://pubmed.gov/32955671)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r421d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0514-2020-12-21-311.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0514-2020-12-21-311.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..20cc8963f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0514-2020-12-21-311.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kuno G. The Absence of Yellow Fever in Asia: History, Hypotheses, Vector Dispersal, Possibility of YF in Asia, and Other Enigmas. Viruses. 2020 Nov 25;12(12):E1349. [doi: 10.3390/v12121349](https://doi.org/10.3390/v12121349). [PMID: 33255615](https://pubmed.gov/33255615)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r311d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0515-2020-12-21-562.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0515-2020-12-21-562.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..81bdb1ccd --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0515-2020-12-21-562.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Shaeer O, Skakke D, Giraldi A, Shaeer E, Shaeer K. Female Orgasm and Overall Sexual Function and Habits: A Descriptive Study of a Cohort of U.S. Women. J Sex Med. 2020 Jun;17(6):1133-1143. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.01.029](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.01.029). Epub 2020 Mar 20. [PMID: 32201145](https://pubmed.gov/32201145)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r562d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0516-2020-12-21-649.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0516-2020-12-21-649.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b0c3188d8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0516-2020-12-21-649.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lotufo MA, Tempestini Horliana ACR, Santana T, de Queiroz AC, Gomes AO, Motta LJ, Ferrari RAM, Dos Santos Fernandes KP, Bussadori SK. "Efficacy of photodynamic therapy on the treatment of herpes labialis: A systematic review". Photodiagnosis Photodyn Ther. 2020 Mar;29:101536. [doi: 10.1016/j.pdpdt.2019.08.018](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pdpdt.2019.08.018). Epub 2019 Oct 21. [PMID: 31648056](https://pubmed.gov/31648056)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r649d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0517-2020-12-21-351.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0517-2020-12-21-351.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1c94d1fa1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0517-2020-12-21-351.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Gana JC, Cifuentes LI, Gattini D, Torres-Robles R. Band ligation versus sclerotherapy for primary prophylaxis of oesophageal variceal bleeding in children with chronic liver disease or portal vein thrombosis. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 6;11:CD011803. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011803.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD011803.pub2). [PMID: 33164205](https://pubmed.gov/33164205)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r351d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0518-2020-12-21-486.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0518-2020-12-21-486.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e3f21b435 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0518-2020-12-21-486.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Liang X, Huang L, Ou Y, He Y, Tang S. Association between MAFB rs17820943 and rs6072081 polymorphism and risk of nonsyndromic cleft lip with or without cleft palate: a meta-analysis. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 Nov;58(9):1065-1072. [doi: 10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.05.034](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.05.034). Epub 2020 Jul 6. [PMID: 32646788](https://pubmed.gov/32646788)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r486d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0519-2020-12-21-377.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0519-2020-12-21-377.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b518d68ca --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0519-2020-12-21-377.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Liu JH, Xiong Y, Hu ZY, Jiang DF. [Systematic review of the qualitative researches on care experience of caregivers of burn children]. Zhonghua Shao Shang Za Zhi. 2020 Oct 20;36(10):959-965. Chinese. [doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn501120-20200108-00013](https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.cn501120-20200108-00013). [PMID: 33105949](https://pubmed.gov/33105949)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r377d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0520-2020-12-21-437.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0520-2020-12-21-437.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..07ee4d324 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0520-2020-12-21-437.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Soni N, Ora M, Mohindra N, Menda Y, Bathla G. Diagnostic Performance of PET and Perfusion-Weighted Imaging in Differentiating Tumor Recurrence or Progression from Radiation Necrosis in Posttreatment Gliomas: A Review of Literature. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2020 Sep;41(9):1550-1557. [doi: 10.3174/ajnr.A6685](https://doi.org/10.3174/ajnr.A6685). Epub 2020 Aug 27. [PMID: 32855194](https://pubmed.gov/32855194); [PMCID: PMC7583093](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7583093)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r437d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0521-2020-12-21-217.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0521-2020-12-21-217.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f76e5188c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0521-2020-12-21-217.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Gleason PM, Kleinman R, Chojnacki GJ, Briefel RR, Forrestal SG. Measuring the Effects of a Demonstration to Reduce Childhood Food Insecurity: A Randomized Controlled Trial of the Nevada Healthy, Hunger Free Kids Project. J Acad Nutr Diet. 2021 Jan;121(1S):S22-S33. [doi: 10.1016/j.jand.2020.03.002](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jand.2020.03.002). [PMID: 33342522](https://pubmed.gov/33342522)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r217d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0522-2020-12-21-651.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0522-2020-12-21-651.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9f27fe451 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0522-2020-12-21-651.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Nunez NA, Singh B, Romo-Nava F, Joseph B, Veldic M, Cuellar-Barboza A, Cabello Arreola A, Vande Voort JL, Croarkin P, Moore KM, Biernacka J, McElroy SL, Frye MA. Efficacy and tolerability of adjunctive modafinil/armodafinil in bipolar depression: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Bipolar Disord. 2020 Mar;22(2):109-120. [doi: 10.1111/bdi.12859](https://doi.org/10.1111/bdi.12859). Epub 2020 Jan 7. [PMID: 31643130](https://pubmed.gov/31643130)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r651d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0523-2020-12-21-186.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0523-2020-12-21-186.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4a9fbf9a9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0523-2020-12-21-186.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Monti M, Vertogen B, Masini C, Donati C, Lilli C, Zingaretti C, Musuraca G, De Giorgi U, Cerchione C, Farolfi A, Cortesi P, Viale P, Martinelli G, Nanni O. Hydroxychloroquine as Prophylaxis for COVID-19: A Review. Front Pharmacol. 2020 Dec 3;11:605185. [doi: 10.3389/fphar.2020.605185](https://doi.org/10.3389/fphar.2020.605185). [PMID: 33343376](https://pubmed.gov/33343376); [PMCID: PMC7744418](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7744418)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r186d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0524-2020-12-21-59.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0524-2020-12-21-59.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..787e42295 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0524-2020-12-21-59.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Yin LX, Barnes JH, Saoji AA, Carlson ML. Clinical Utility of Intraoperative Electrocochleography (ECochG) During Cochlear Implantation: A Systematic Review and Quantitative Analysis. Otol Neurotol. 2020 Dec 17;Publish Ahead of Print. [doi: 10.1097/MAO.0000000000002996](https://doi.org/10.1097/MAO.0000000000002996). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33347054](https://pubmed.gov/33347054)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r59d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0525-2020-12-21-544.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0525-2020-12-21-544.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..251b45d86 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0525-2020-12-21-544.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Leerssen J, Foster-Dingley JC, Lakbila-Kamal O, Dekkers LMS, Albers ACW, Ikelaar SLC, Maksimovic T, Wassing R, Houtman SJ, Bresser T, Blanken TF, Te Lindert B, Ramautar JR, Van Someren EJW. Internet-guided cognitive, behavioral and chronobiological interventions in depression-prone insomnia subtypes: protocol of a randomized controlled prevention trial. BMC Psychiatry. 2020 Apr 15;20(1):163. [doi: 10.1186/s12888-020-02554-8](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12888-020-02554-8). [PMID: 32293363](https://pubmed.gov/32293363); [PMCID: PMC7160982](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7160982)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r544d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0526-2020-12-21-469.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0526-2020-12-21-469.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a5635fb64 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0526-2020-12-21-469.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Spearman AD, Ginde S, Goot BH, Schaal AM, Feng M, Pan AY, Frommelt MA, Frommelt PC. Echocardiographic Identification of Pulmonary Artery Flow Reversal: An Indicator of Adverse Outcomes in Single Ventricle Physiology. Pediatr Cardiol. 2020 Dec;41(8):1632-1638. [doi: 10.1007/s00246-020-02421-z](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00246-020-02421-z). Epub 2020 Jul 24. [PMID: 32710282](https://pubmed.gov/32710282)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r469d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0527-2020-12-21-492.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0527-2020-12-21-492.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..57a98c44f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0527-2020-12-21-492.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Nascimento B, Miranda EP, Terrier JE, Carneiro F, Mulhall JP. A Critical Analysis of Methodology Pitfalls in Duplex Doppler Ultrasound in the Evaluation of Patients With Erectile Dysfunction: Technical and Interpretation Deficiencies. J Sex Med. 2020 Aug;17(8):1416-1422. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.05.023](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.05.023). Epub 2020 Jul 3. [PMID: 32631763](https://pubmed.gov/32631763)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r492d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0528-2020-12-21-68.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0528-2020-12-21-68.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..46a0292bf --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0528-2020-12-21-68.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chen LJ, Zhou YJ, Wen ZH, Tian F, Li JY. Efficacy and safety of iguratimod combined with methotrexate vs. methotrexate alone in rheumatoid arthritis : A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Z Rheumatol. 2020 Dec 21. English. [doi: 10.1007/s00393-020-00944-7](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00393-020-00944-7). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346891](https://pubmed.gov/33346891)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r68d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0529-2020-12-21-580.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0529-2020-12-21-580.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..07b72c960 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0529-2020-12-21-580.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sun L, An H, Feng Y. Intravenous Tranexamic Acid Decreases Blood Transfusion in Off-Pump Coronary Artery Bypass Surgery: A Meta-analysis. Heart Surg Forum. 2020 Feb 25;23(1):E039-E049. [doi: 10.1532/hsf.2797](https://doi.org/10.1532/hsf.2797). [PMID: 32118541](https://pubmed.gov/32118541)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r580d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0530-2020-12-21-682.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0530-2020-12-21-682.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..470e3f03d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0530-2020-12-21-682.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Yan WS, Cao WL, Sun M, Ma DY, Zhang P. Distal locked or unlocked nailing for stable intertrochanteric fractures? A meta-analysis. ANZ J Surg. 2020 Jan;90(1-2):27-33. [doi: 10.1111/ans.15232](https://doi.org/10.1111/ans.15232). Epub 2019 May 13. [PMID: 31083793](https://pubmed.gov/31083793)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r682d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0531-2020-12-21-27.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0531-2020-12-21-27.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7aba85aa5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0531-2020-12-21-27.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kaye EC, Weaver MS, DeWitt LH, Byers E, Stevens SE, Lukowski J, Shih B, Zalud K, Applegarth J, Wong HN, Baker JN, Ullrich CK; AAHPM Research Committee. The impact of specialty palliative care in pediatric oncology: a systematic review. J Pain Symptom Manage. 2020 Dec 18:S0885-3924(20)30939-8. [doi: 10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2020.12.003](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2020.12.003). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348034](https://pubmed.gov/33348034)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r27d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0532-2020-12-21-669.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0532-2020-12-21-669.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..905019e39 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0532-2020-12-21-669.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Cushman DM, Strenn Q, Elmer A, Yang AJ, Onofrei L. Complications Associated With Electromyography: A Systematic Review. Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 2020 Feb;99(2):149-155. [doi: 10.1097/PHM.0000000000001304](https://doi.org/10.1097/PHM.0000000000001304). [PMID: 31469680](https://pubmed.gov/31469680)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r669d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0533-2020-12-21-60.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0533-2020-12-21-60.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..65fedf721 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0533-2020-12-21-60.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Joseph B, Parsaik AK, Ahmed AT, Erwin PJ, Singh B. A Systematic Review on the Efficacy of Intravenous Racemic Ketamine for Bipolar Depression. J Clin Psychopharmacol. 2021 Jan/Feb 01;41(1):71-75. [doi: 10.1097/JCP.0000000000001317](https://doi.org/10.1097/JCP.0000000000001317). [PMID: 33347027](https://pubmed.gov/33347027)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r60d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0534-2020-12-21-13.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0534-2020-12-21-13.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..44bcdf1fb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0534-2020-12-21-13.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Baroni F, Ruffini N, D'Alessandro G, Consorti G, Lunghi C. The role of touch in osteopathic practice: A narrative review and integrative hypothesis. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Dec 1;42:101277. [doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101277](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101277). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348305](https://pubmed.gov/33348305)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r13d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0535-2020-12-21-234.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0535-2020-12-21-234.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a3f968631 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0535-2020-12-21-234.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Molena E, King E, Davies-Husband C. Octreotide versus oral dietary modification for the treatment of chylous fistula following neck dissection: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Otolaryngol. 2020 Dec 20. [doi: 10.1111/coa.13700](https://doi.org/10.1111/coa.13700). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342047](https://pubmed.gov/33342047)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r234d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0536-2020-12-21-597.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0536-2020-12-21-597.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9b72c8c32 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0536-2020-12-21-597.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lin P, Zhang J, Shi F, Liang ZA. Can haloperidol prophylaxis reduce the incidence of delirium in critically ill patients in intensive care units? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Heart Lung. 2020 May-Jun;49(3):265-272. [doi: 10.1016/j.hrtlng.2020.01.010](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hrtlng.2020.01.010). Epub 2020 Feb 5. [PMID: 32033776](https://pubmed.gov/32033776)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r597d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0537-2020-12-21-488.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0537-2020-12-21-488.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1b36cce05 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0537-2020-12-21-488.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Shao JM, Ayuso SA, Deerenberg EB, Elhage SA, Augenstein VA, Heniford BT. A systematic review of CT chest in COVID-19 diagnosis and its potential application in a surgical setting. Colorectal Dis. 2020 Sep;22(9):993-1001. [doi: 10.1111/codi.15252](https://doi.org/10.1111/codi.15252). Epub 2020 Aug 5. [PMID: 32644268](https://pubmed.gov/32644268); [PMCID: PMC7361755](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7361755)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r488d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0538-2020-12-21-84.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0538-2020-12-21-84.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7b6f1a7d0 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0538-2020-12-21-84.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Coyle M, Sandover S, Poobalan A, Bullen J, Cleland J. Meritocratic and Fair? The discourse of UK and Australia's widening participation policies. Med Educ. 2020 Dec 21. [doi: 10.1111/medu.14442](https://doi.org/10.1111/medu.14442). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346380](https://pubmed.gov/33346380)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r84d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0539-2020-12-21-385.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0539-2020-12-21-385.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..69ab1e612 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0539-2020-12-21-385.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sanchez C, Jaguan D, Shaikh S, McKenney M, Elkbuli A. A systematic review of the causes and prevention strategies in reducing gun violence in the United States. Am J Emerg Med. 2020 Oct;38(10):2169-2178. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajem.2020.06.062](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajem.2020.06.062). Epub 2020 Jun 27. [PMID: 33071102](https://pubmed.gov/33071102)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r385d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0540-2020-12-21-690.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0540-2020-12-21-690.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9197feee1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0540-2020-12-21-690.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sach TH, McManus E, Levell NJ. Understanding economic evidence for the prevention and treatment of atopic eczema. Br J Dermatol. 2019 Oct;181(4):707-716. [doi: 10.1111/bjd.17696](https://doi.org/10.1111/bjd.17696). Epub 2019 Apr 11. [PMID: 30693473](https://pubmed.gov/30693473); [PMCID: PMC6790711](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC6790711)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r690d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0541-2020-12-21-692.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0541-2020-12-21-692.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1b4b613f9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0541-2020-12-21-692.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Howie AJ. Genetic studies of focal segmental glomerulosclerosis: a waste of scientific time? Pediatr Nephrol. 2020 Jan;35(1):9-16. [doi: 10.1007/s00467-018-4161-6](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00467-018-4161-6). Epub 2018 Dec 27. [PMID: 30591974](https://pubmed.gov/30591974); [PMCID: PMC6901409](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC6901409)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r692d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0542-2020-12-21-55.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0542-2020-12-21-55.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..22cf1cdda --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0542-2020-12-21-55.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bach P, Wallisch C, Klein N, Hafermann L, Sauerbrei W, Steyerberg EW, Heinze G, Rauch G; for topic group 2 of the STRATOS initiative. Systematic review of education and practical guidance on regression modeling for medical researchers who lack a strong statistical background: Study protocol. PLoS One. 2020 Dec 21;15(12):e0241427. [doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0241427](https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0241427). [PMID: 33347441](https://pubmed.gov/33347441)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r55d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0543-2020-12-21-587.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0543-2020-12-21-587.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2757e0470 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0543-2020-12-21-587.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kolluri R, Chung J, Kim S, Nath N, Bhalla BB, Jain T, Zygmunt J, Davies A. Network meta-analysis to compare VenaSeal with other superficial venous therapies for chronic venous insufficiency. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2020 May;8(3):472-481.e3. [doi: 10.1016/j.jvsv.2019.12.061](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvsv.2019.12.061). Epub 2020 Feb 14. [PMID: 32063522](https://pubmed.gov/32063522)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r587d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0544-2020-12-21-253.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0544-2020-12-21-253.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6fa96df67 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0544-2020-12-21-253.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sutar R, Atlani MK, Chaudhary P. Antipsychotics and hemodialysis: A systematic review. Asian J Psychiatr. 2020 Dec 3;55:102484. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajp.2020.102484](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajp.2020.102484). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341539](https://pubmed.gov/33341539)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r253d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0545-2020-12-21-663.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0545-2020-12-21-663.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..318656e99 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0545-2020-12-21-663.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Delaplain PT, Phillips JL, Lundeberg M, Nahmias J, Kuza CM, Sheehan BM, Murphy LS, Pejcinovska M, Grigorian A, Gabriel V, Barie PS, Schubl SD. No Reduction in Surgical Site Infection Obtained with Post-Operative Antibiotics in Facial Fractures, Regardless of Duration or Anatomic Location: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Surg Infect (Larchmt). 2020 Mar;21(2):112-121. [doi: 10.1089/sur.2019.149](https://doi.org/10.1089/sur.2019.149). Epub 2019 Sep 17. [PMID: 31526317](https://pubmed.gov/31526317)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r663d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0546-2020-12-21-526.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0546-2020-12-21-526.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..538d1155d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0546-2020-12-21-526.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Rhoten BA, Davis AJ, Baraff BN, Holler KH, Dietrich MS. Priorities and Preferences of Patients With Head and Neck Cancer for Discussing and Receiving Information About Sexuality and Perception of Self-Report Measures. J Sex Med. 2020 Aug;17(8):1529-1537. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.04.001](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.04.001). Epub 2020 May 13. [PMID: 32417203](https://pubmed.gov/32417203); [PMCID: PMC7664992](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7664992)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r526d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0547-2020-12-21-262.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0547-2020-12-21-262.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..00c46346b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0547-2020-12-21-262.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Fei Q, Lin Y, Yuan TM. Lung Ultrasound, a Better Choice for Neonatal Pneumothorax: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2020 Dec 16:S0301-5629(20)30519-6. [doi: 10.1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2020.11.011](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2020.11.011). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341304](https://pubmed.gov/33341304)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r262d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0548-2020-12-21-142.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0548-2020-12-21-142.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..acaf41d4d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0548-2020-12-21-142.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Li J, Chen M, Wang ZJ, Li SG, Jiang M, Shi L, Cao CL, Sang T, Cui XW, Dietrich CF. Interobserver agreement for contrast-enhanced ultrasound of liver imaging reporting and data system: A systematic review and meta-analysis. World J Clin Cases. 2020 Nov 26;8(22):5589-5602. [doi: 10.12998/wjcc.v8.i22.5589](https://doi.org/10.12998/wjcc.v8.i22.5589). [PMID: 33344549](https://pubmed.gov/33344549); [PMCID: PMC7716336](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7716336)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r142d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0549-2020-12-21-37.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0549-2020-12-21-37.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..014bbd120 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0549-2020-12-21-37.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bardou MLD, Henriques MT, Grumach AS. Inborn errors of immunity associated with characteristic phenotypesϯ. J Pediatr (Rio J). 2020 Dec 18:S0021-7557(20)30245-X. [doi: 10.1016/j.jped.2020.10.015](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jped.2020.10.015). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33347837](https://pubmed.gov/33347837)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r37d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0550-2020-12-21-397.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0550-2020-12-21-397.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1ed96b4bd --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0550-2020-12-21-397.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Clark HA, Martin PK, Okut H, Schroeder RW. A Systematic Review and Meta- Analysis of the Utility of the Test of Memory Malingering in Pediatric Examinees. Arch Clin Neuropsychol. 2020 Nov 19;35(8):1312-1322. [doi: 10.1093/arclin/acaa075](https://doi.org/10.1093/arclin/acaa075). [PMID: 33047780](https://pubmed.gov/33047780)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r397d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0551-2020-12-21-427.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0551-2020-12-21-427.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b45085217 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0551-2020-12-21-427.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Jimenez G, Spinazze P, Matchar D, Koh Choon Huat G, van der Kleij RMJJ, Chavannes NH, Car J. Digital health competencies for primary healthcare professionals: A scoping review. Int J Med Inform. 2020 Nov;143:104260. [doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104260](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104260). Epub 2020 Aug 27. [PMID: 32919345](https://pubmed.gov/32919345)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r427d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0552-2020-12-21-656.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0552-2020-12-21-656.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..853e13996 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0552-2020-12-21-656.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Russo V, Ottaviani C, Spitoni GF. Affective touch: A meta-analysis on sex differences. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:445-452. [doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.09.037](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.09.037). Epub 2019 Oct 12. [PMID: 31614152](https://pubmed.gov/31614152)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r656d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0553-2020-12-21-312.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0553-2020-12-21-312.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1b31fbc89 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0553-2020-12-21-312.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Haupt C, Henke M, Kutschmar A, Hauser B, Baldinger S, Saenz SR, Schreiber G. Antiandrogen or estradiol treatment or both during hormone therapy in transitioning transgender women. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 28;11:CD013138. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013138.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD013138.pub2). [PMID: 33251587](https://pubmed.gov/33251587)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r312d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0554-2020-12-21-638.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0554-2020-12-21-638.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d8b3daa0d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0554-2020-12-21-638.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Eusebio-Alpapara KMV, Castillo RL, Dofitas BL. Gabapentin for uremic pruritus: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Int J Dermatol. 2020 Apr;59(4):412-422. [doi: 10.1111/ijd.14708](https://doi.org/10.1111/ijd.14708). Epub 2019 Nov 28. [PMID: 31777066](https://pubmed.gov/31777066)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r638d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0555-2020-12-21-128.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0555-2020-12-21-128.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6b1dfcc3e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0555-2020-12-21-128.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘van Hoorn JF, Schoemaker MM, Stuive I, Dijkstra PU, Rodrigues Trigo Pereira F, van der Sluis CK, Hadders-Algra M. Risk factors in early life for developmental coordination disorder: a scoping review. Dev Med Child Neurol. 2020 Dec 20. [doi: 10.1111/dmcn.14781](https://doi.org/10.1111/dmcn.14781). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345317](https://pubmed.gov/33345317)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r128d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0556-2020-12-21-386.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0556-2020-12-21-386.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f918b1196 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0556-2020-12-21-386.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhao H, Fan K, Feng G. Amiodarone and/or lidocaine for cardiac arrest: A Bayesian network meta-analysis. Am J Emerg Med. 2020 Oct;38(10):2185-2193. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajem.2020.06.074](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajem.2020.06.074). Epub 2020 Jul 5. [PMID: 33071078](https://pubmed.gov/33071078)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r386d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0557-2020-12-21-360.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0557-2020-12-21-360.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..577463c55 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0557-2020-12-21-360.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Martinez-Zapata MJ, Vernooij RW, Simancas-Racines D, Uriona Tuma SM, Stein AT, Moreno Carriles RMM, Vargas E, Bonfill Cosp X. Phlebotonics for venous insufficiency. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 3;11:CD003229. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003229.pub4](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD003229.pub4). [PMID: 33141449](https://pubmed.gov/33141449)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r360d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0558-2020-12-21-85.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0558-2020-12-21-85.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6b4c3e9b4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0558-2020-12-21-85.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘McLaughlin JM, Khan F, Schmitt HJ, Agosti Y, Jodar L, Simões EAF, Swerdlow DL. Respiratory Syncytial Virus-Associated Hospitalization Rates among US Infants: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Infect Dis. 2020 Dec 21:jiaa752. [doi: 10.1093/infdis/jiaa752](https://doi.org/10.1093/infdis/jiaa752). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346360](https://pubmed.gov/33346360)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r85d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0559-2020-12-21-149.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0559-2020-12-21-149.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e1f99c276 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0559-2020-12-21-149.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Cheng G, Li M, Ma X, Nan F, Zhang L, Yan Z, Li H, Zhang G, Han Y, Xie L, Guo X. Systematic Analysis of microRNA Biomarkers for Diagnosis, Prognosis, and Therapy in Patients With Clear Cell Renal Cell Carcinoma. Front Oncol. 2020 Dec 4;10:543817. [doi: 10.3389/fonc.2020.543817](https://doi.org/10.3389/fonc.2020.543817). [PMID: 33344224](https://pubmed.gov/33344224); [PMCID: PMC7746831](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7746831)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r149d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0560-2020-12-21-223.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0560-2020-12-21-223.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2814a30cf --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0560-2020-12-21-223.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Prendki V, Tau N, Avni T, Falcone M, Huttner A, Kaiser L, Paul M, Leibovici-Weissmann Y, Yahav D; ESCMID Study Group for Infections in the Elderly (ESGIE). A systematic review assessing the under-representation of elderly adults in COVID-19 trials. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Dec 20;20(1):538. [doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01954-5](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-020-01954-5). [PMID: 33342426](https://pubmed.gov/33342426); [PMCID: PMC7749979](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7749979)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r223d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0561-2020-12-21-558.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0561-2020-12-21-558.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6d2115cce --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0561-2020-12-21-558.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Vukkadala N, Qian ZJ, Holsinger FC, Patel ZM, Rosenthal E. COVID-19 and the Otolaryngologist: Preliminary Evidence-Based Review. Laryngoscope. 2020 Nov;130(11):2537-2543. [doi: 10.1002/lary.28672](https://doi.org/10.1002/lary.28672). Epub 2020 Apr 24. [PMID: 32219846](https://pubmed.gov/32219846)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r558d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0562-2020-12-21-438.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0562-2020-12-21-438.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..401bf1504 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0562-2020-12-21-438.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lindt N, van Berkel J, Mulder BC. Determinants of overburdening among informal carers: a systematic review. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Aug 26;20(1):304. [doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01708-3](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-020-01708-3). [PMID: 32847493](https://pubmed.gov/32847493); [PMCID: PMC7448315](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7448315)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r438d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0563-2020-12-21-518.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0563-2020-12-21-518.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d35a14211 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0563-2020-12-21-518.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Leenen JPL, Leerentveld C, van Dijk JD, van Westreenen HL, Schoonhoven L, Patijn GA. Current Evidence for Continuous Vital Signs Monitoring by Wearable Wireless Devices in Hospitalized Adults: Systematic Review. J Med Internet Res. 2020 Jun 17;22(6):e18636. [doi: 10.2196/18636](https://doi.org/10.2196/18636). [PMID: 32469323](https://pubmed.gov/32469323); [PMCID: PMC7351263](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7351263)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r518d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0564-2020-12-21-602.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0564-2020-12-21-602.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8d5af1ea6 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0564-2020-12-21-602.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Carder SL, Giusti NE, Vopat LM, Tarakemeh A, Baker J, Vopat BG, Mulcahey MK. The Concept of Sport Sampling Versus Sport Specialization: Preventing Youth Athlete Injury: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2020 Sep;48(11):2850-2857. [doi: 10.1177/0363546519899380](https://doi.org/10.1177/0363546519899380). Epub 2020 Jan 21. [PMID: 31961703](https://pubmed.gov/31961703)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r602d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0565-2020-12-21-45.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0565-2020-12-21-45.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d8bd1683b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0565-2020-12-21-45.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Narvaez Linares NF, Charron V, Ouimet AJ, Labelle PR, Plamondon H. A systematic review of the Trier Social Stress Test methodology: Issues in promoting study comparison and replicable research. Neurobiol Stress. 2020 Jun 15;13:100235. [doi: 10.1016/j.ynstr.2020.100235](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ynstr.2020.100235). [PMID: 33344691](https://pubmed.gov/33344691); [PMCID: PMC7739033](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7739033)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r45d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0566-2020-12-21-346.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0566-2020-12-21-346.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4c68974a3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0566-2020-12-21-346.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Elsner B, Kugler J, Pohl M, Mehrholz J. Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) for improving activities of daily living, and physical and cognitive functioning, in people after stroke. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 11;11:CD009645. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009645.pub4](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD009645.pub4). [PMID: 33175411](https://pubmed.gov/33175411)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r346d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0567-2020-12-21-136.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0567-2020-12-21-136.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b1635f2dd --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0567-2020-12-21-136.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Barek MA, Aziz MA, Islam MS. Impact of age, sex, comorbidities and clinical symptoms on the severity of COVID-19 cases: A meta-analysis with 55 studies and 10014 cases. Heliyon. 2020 Dec;6(12):e05684. [doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2020.e05684](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2020.e05684). Epub 2020 Dec 15. [PMID: 33344791](https://pubmed.gov/33344791); [PMCID: PMC7737518](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7737518)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r136d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0568-2020-12-21-453.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0568-2020-12-21-453.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2abe2a3cb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0568-2020-12-21-453.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Can A, Coskun H. The rationale of using mesenchymal stem cells in patients with COVID-19-related acute respiratory distress syndrome: What to expect. Stem Cells Transl Med. 2020 Nov;9(11):1287-1302. [doi: 10.1002/sctm.20-0164](https://doi.org/10.1002/sctm.20-0164). Epub 2020 Jul 21. [PMID: 32779878](https://pubmed.gov/32779878); [PMCID: PMC7404450](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7404450)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r453d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0569-2020-12-21-33.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0569-2020-12-21-33.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..40babfeb1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0569-2020-12-21-33.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Li Y, Liang M, Gao L, Ahmed MA, Uy JP, Cheng C, Zhou Q, Sun C. Face masks to prevent transmission of COVID-19: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J Infect Control. 2020 Dec 18:S0196-6553(20)31043-9. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajic.2020.12.007](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajic.2020.12.007). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33347937](https://pubmed.gov/33347937); [PMCID: PMC7748970](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7748970)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r33d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0570-2020-12-21-176.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0570-2020-12-21-176.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1517aa5af --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0570-2020-12-21-176.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Aung NM, Myint KK. Evidence of Second Canal between Permanent Mandibular Central and Lateral Incisors in China; a Systematic Review on CBCT Studies. Int J Dent. 2020 Dec 3;2020:8849609. [doi: 10.1155/2020/8849609](https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/8849609). [PMID: 33343667](https://pubmed.gov/33343667); [PMCID: PMC7728484](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7728484)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r176d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0571-2020-12-21-96.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0571-2020-12-21-96.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6a94126c3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0571-2020-12-21-96.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Schuster HJ, de Jonghe BA, Limpens J, Budding AE, Painter RC. Asymptomatic vaginal Candida colonization and adverse pregnancy outcomes including preterm birth: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 Aug;2(3):100163. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100163](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100163). Epub 2020 Jun 23. [PMID: 33345884](https://pubmed.gov/33345884)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r96d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0572-2020-12-21-443.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0572-2020-12-21-443.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ef65c129c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0572-2020-12-21-443.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Abu-Elezz I, Hassan A, Nazeemudeen A, Househ M, Abd-Alrazaq A. The benefits and threats of blockchain technology in healthcare: A scoping review. Int J Med Inform. 2020 Oct;142:104246. [doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104246](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104246). Epub 2020 Aug 14. [PMID: 32828033](https://pubmed.gov/32828033)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r443d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0573-2020-12-21-615.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0573-2020-12-21-615.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bbc0ed84c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0573-2020-12-21-615.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Cuspidi C, Tadic M, Sala C, Gherbesi E, Grassi G, Mancia G. Targeting Concentric Left Ventricular Hypertrophy in Obstructive Sleep Apnea Syndrome. A Meta-analysis of Echocardiographic Studies. Am J Hypertens. 2020 Apr 1;33(4):310-315. [doi: 10.1093/ajh/hpz198](https://doi.org/10.1093/ajh/hpz198). [PMID: 31863113](https://pubmed.gov/31863113)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r615d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0574-2020-12-21-327.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0574-2020-12-21-327.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3092dccfa --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0574-2020-12-21-327.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Duarte GS, Rodrigues FB, Castelão M, Marques RE, Ferreira J, Sampaio C, Moore AP, Costa J. Botulinum toxin type A therapy for hemifacial spasm. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 19;11:CD004899. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004899.pub3](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD004899.pub3). [PMID: 33211908](https://pubmed.gov/33211908)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r327d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0575-2020-12-21-451.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0575-2020-12-21-451.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d46cebe6b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0575-2020-12-21-451.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Pellino G, Vaizey CJ, Maeda Y; European Society of Coloproctology (ESCP) Guideline Committee. The COVID-19 pandemic: considerations for resuming normal colorectal services. Colorectal Dis. 2020 Sep;22(9):1006-1014. [doi: 10.1111/codi.15313](https://doi.org/10.1111/codi.15313). Epub 2020 Aug 28. [PMID: 32790095](https://pubmed.gov/32790095); [PMCID: PMC7436303](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7436303)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r451d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0576-2020-12-21-576.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0576-2020-12-21-576.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4d6b90c22 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0576-2020-12-21-576.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Mooney-Doyle K, Ulrich CM. Parent moral distress in serious pediatric illness: A dimensional analysis. Nurs Ethics. 2020 May;27(3):821-837. [doi: 10.1177/0969733019878838](https://doi.org/10.1177/0969733019878838). Epub 2020 Mar 5. [PMID: 32138577](https://pubmed.gov/32138577)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r576d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0577-2020-12-21-516.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0577-2020-12-21-516.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..35d7c911d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0577-2020-12-21-516.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Pescia R, Kiliaridis S, Antonarakis GS. Spontaneous eruption of impacted maxillary incisors after surgical extraction of supernumerary teeth: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3749-3759. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03369-3](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-020-03369-3). Epub 2020 Jun 2. [PMID: 32488485](https://pubmed.gov/32488485)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r516d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0578-2020-12-21-371.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0578-2020-12-21-371.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bd063baf5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0578-2020-12-21-371.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Stresman G, Whittaker C, Slater HC, Bousema T, Cook J. Quantifying Plasmodium falciparum infections clustering within households to inform household-based intervention strategies for malaria control programs: An observational study and meta-analysis from 41 malaria-endemic countries. PLoS Med. 2020 Oct 29;17(10):e1003370. [doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1003370](https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1003370). [PMID: 33119589](https://pubmed.gov/33119589); [PMCID: PMC7595326](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7595326)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r371d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0579-2020-12-21-455.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0579-2020-12-21-455.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a1f328142 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0579-2020-12-21-455.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Fuentes-Abolafio IJ, Stubbs B, Pérez-Belmonte LM, Bernal-López MR, Gómez- Huelgas R, Cuesta-Vargas A. Functional parameters indicative of mild cognitive impairment: a systematic review using instrumented kinematic assessment. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Aug 10;20(1):282. [doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01678-6](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-020-01678-6). [PMID: 32778071](https://pubmed.gov/32778071); [PMCID: PMC7418187](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7418187)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r455d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0580-2020-12-21-361.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0580-2020-12-21-361.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ed3b08194 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0580-2020-12-21-361.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ni WW, Leong S, Irani F, Patel A, Damodharan K, Venkataranasimha N, Chandramohan S, Kumar P, Chua J, Gogna A, Da Zhuang K, Chong TT, Tang TY, Chng SP, Tay KH. "Angioplasty-First" Approach for Limb Salvage in Asian Patients with Critical Limb Ischemia: Outcomes from 3,303 Angioplasties on 2,402 Limbs in a Single Tertiary Hospital. J Vasc Interv Radiol. 2020 Dec;31(12):1969-1977.e1. [doi: 10.1016/j.jvir.2020.08.008](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvir.2020.08.008). Epub 2020 Nov 1. [PMID: 33139186](https://pubmed.gov/33139186)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r361d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0581-2020-12-21-461.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0581-2020-12-21-461.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a5aff97b2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0581-2020-12-21-461.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ashraf S, Al-Maweri SA, Alaizari N, Umair A, Ariffin Z, Alhajj MN, Kassim S, Awan KH. The association between Epstein-Barr virus and oral lichen planus: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Oral Pathol Med. 2020 Nov;49(10):969-976. [doi: 10.1111/jop.13093](https://doi.org/10.1111/jop.13093). Epub 2020 Aug 24. [PMID: 32746493](https://pubmed.gov/32746493)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r461d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0582-2020-12-21-459.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0582-2020-12-21-459.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..da61d5d9e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0582-2020-12-21-459.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bai T, Fang F, Li F, Ren Y, Hu J, Cao J. Sarcopenia is associated with hypertension in older adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Aug 6;20(1):279. [doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01672-y](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-020-01672-y). [PMID: 32762638](https://pubmed.gov/32762638); [PMCID: PMC7409686](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7409686)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r459d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0583-2020-12-21-655.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0583-2020-12-21-655.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ee43b6ca0 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0583-2020-12-21-655.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Maurage P, Masson N, Bollen Z, D'Hondt F. Eye tracking correlates of acute alcohol consumption: A systematic and critical review. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:400-422. [doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.10.001](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.10.001). Epub 2019 Oct 12. [PMID: 31614153](https://pubmed.gov/31614153)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r655d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0584-2020-12-21-23.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0584-2020-12-21-23.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bc78c8e32 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0584-2020-12-21-23.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Saconi B, Polomano RC, Compton PC, McPhillips MV, Kuna ST, Sawyer AM. The influence of sleep disturbances and sleep disorders on pain outcomes among veterans: A systematic scoping review. Sleep Med Rev. 2020 Nov 30;56:101411. [doi: 10.1016/j.smrv.2020.101411](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.smrv.2020.101411). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348172](https://pubmed.gov/33348172)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r23d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0585-2020-12-21-181.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0585-2020-12-21-181.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d70b5157c --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0585-2020-12-21-181.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Fahr A, Keller JW, van Hedel HJA. A Systematic Review of Training Methods That May Improve Selective Voluntary Motor Control in Children With Spastic Cerebral Palsy. Front Neurol. 2020 Dec 4;11:572038. [doi: 10.3389/fneur.2020.572038](https://doi.org/10.3389/fneur.2020.572038). [PMID: 33343485](https://pubmed.gov/33343485); [PMCID: PMC7746811](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7746811)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r181d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0586-2020-12-21-122.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0586-2020-12-21-122.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..07c87dbae --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0586-2020-12-21-122.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bowie J, Brunckhorst O, Stewart R, Dasgupta P, Ahmed K. A systematic review of tools used to assess body image, masculinity and self-esteem in men with prostate cancer. Psychooncology. 2020 Nov;29(11):1761-1771. [doi: 10.1002/pon.5518](https://doi.org/10.1002/pon.5518). Epub 2020 Sep 1. [PMID: 33345371](https://pubmed.gov/33345371)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r122d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0587-2020-12-21-677.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0587-2020-12-21-677.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1c8e7de65 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0587-2020-12-21-677.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Dudi-Venkata NN, Kroon HM, Bedrikovetski S, Moore JW, Sammour T. Systematic scoping review of enhanced recovery protocol recommendations targeting return of gastrointestinal function after colorectal surgery. ANZ J Surg. 2020 Jan;90(1-2):41-47. [doi: 10.1111/ans.15319](https://doi.org/10.1111/ans.15319). Epub 2019 Jul 4. [PMID: 31272135](https://pubmed.gov/31272135)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r677d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0588-2020-12-21-41.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0588-2020-12-21-41.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fb5db3fa8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0588-2020-12-21-41.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lu B, Zhang X, Wen J. Real World Effectiveness of Information and Communication Technologies in Disaster Relief: A Systematic Review. Iran J Public Health. 2020 Oct;49(10):1813-1826. [doi: 10.18502/ijph.v49i10.4678](https://doi.org/10.18502/ijph.v49i10.4678). [PMID: 33346227](https://pubmed.gov/33346227); [PMCID: PMC7719660](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7719660)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r41d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0589-2020-12-21-533.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0589-2020-12-21-533.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..76515b4d3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0589-2020-12-21-533.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ronaghy A, Yang RK, Khoury JD, Kanagal-Shamanna R. Clinical Applications of Chromosomal Microarray Testing in Myeloid Malignancies. Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Jun;15(3):194-202. [doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00578-1](https://doi.org/10.1007/s11899-020-00578-1). [PMID: 32382988](https://pubmed.gov/32382988)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r533d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0590-2020-12-21-407.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0590-2020-12-21-407.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fecdcff07 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0590-2020-12-21-407.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Wang H, Lu F, Guo M, Fan W, Ji W, Dong Z. Associations between PM1 exposure and daily emergency department visits in 19 hospitals, Beijing. Sci Total Environ. 2021 Feb 10;755(Pt 1):142507. [doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142507](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142507). Epub 2020 Sep 25. [PMID: 33032134](https://pubmed.gov/33032134)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r407d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0591-2020-12-21-380.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0591-2020-12-21-380.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..146cdaeea --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0591-2020-12-21-380.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘de França AJB, Costa RTF, Monteiro JLGC, Rocha NS, do Egito Vasconcelos BC, de Moraes SLD. Comparison of three anesthetic techniques for the removal of posterior mandibular teeth with 2% lidocaine: a systematic review. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Dec;24(12):4143-4152. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03580-2](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-020-03580-2). Epub 2020 Oct 22. [PMID: 33089877](https://pubmed.gov/33089877)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r380d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0592-2020-12-21-559.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0592-2020-12-21-559.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1954209e2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0592-2020-12-21-559.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Li XK, Zhou H, Xu Y, Cong ZZ, Wu WJ, Luo J, Jiang ZS, Shen Y. Enteral immunonutrition versus enteral nutrition for patients undergoing oesophagectomy: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg. 2020 Jun 1;30(6):854-862. [doi: 10.1093/icvts/ivaa022](https://doi.org/10.1093/icvts/ivaa022). [PMID: 32206808](https://pubmed.gov/32206808)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r559d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0593-2020-12-21-501.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0593-2020-12-21-501.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4b24dcb31 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0593-2020-12-21-501.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Leung YY, Wu FHW, Chan HH. Ultrasonography-guided arthrocentesis versus conventional arthrocentesis in treating internal derangement of temporomandibular joint: a systematic review. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3771-3780. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03408-z](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-020-03408-z). Epub 2020 Jun 27. [PMID: 32594307](https://pubmed.gov/32594307)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r501d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0594-2020-12-21-532.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0594-2020-12-21-532.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..879fe21a2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0594-2020-12-21-532.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhao H, Hu J, Zhao L. Histological analysis of socket preservation using DBBM. A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Stomatol Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 Dec;121(6):729-735. [doi: 10.1016/j.jormas.2020.04.011](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jormas.2020.04.011). Epub 2020 May 6. [PMID: 32387688](https://pubmed.gov/32387688)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r532d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0595-2020-12-21-94.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0595-2020-12-21-94.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..15659b3d8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0595-2020-12-21-94.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Blankenship SA, Brown KE, Simon LE, Stout MJ, Tuuli MG. Antenatal corticosteroids in preterm small-for-gestational age infants: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 Nov;2(4):100215. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100215](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100215). Epub 2020 Aug 17. [PMID: 33345924](https://pubmed.gov/33345924)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r94d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0596-2020-12-21-299.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0596-2020-12-21-299.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..71ce0ecb7 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0596-2020-12-21-299.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Shamshirian A, Hessami A, Heydari K, Navaei RA, Ebrahimzadeh MA, Yip GW, Ghasemian R, Sedaghat M, Baradaran H, Yazdi SM, Aboufazeli E, Jafarpour H, Dadgostar E, Tirandazi B, Sadeghnezhad R, Karimifar K, Eftekhari A, Shamshirian D. The Role of Hydroxychloroquine in COVID-19: A Systematic Review and Meta- Analysis. Ann Acad Med Singap. 2020 Oct;49(10):789-800. [PMID: 33283842](https://pubmed.gov/33283842)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r299d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0597-2020-12-21-506.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0597-2020-12-21-506.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..86e514cb2 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0597-2020-12-21-506.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Peraza A, Gómez R, Beltran J, Amarista FJ. Mucoepidermoid carcinoma. An update and review of the literature. J Stomatol Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 Dec;121(6):713-720. [doi: 10.1016/j.jormas.2020.06.003](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jormas.2020.06.003). Epub 2020 Jun 18. [PMID: 32565266](https://pubmed.gov/32565266)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r506d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0598-2020-12-21-192.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0598-2020-12-21-192.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..24657cd18 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0598-2020-12-21-192.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Furukawa TA, Cipriani A, Cowen PJ, Leucht S, Egger M, Salanti G. Optimal Dose of Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors, Venlafaxine, and Mirtazapine in Major Depression: A Systematic Review and Dose-Response Meta-Analysis. Focus (Am Psychiatr Publ). 2020 Apr;18(2):211-219. [doi: 10.1176/appi.focus.18204](https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.focus.18204). Epub 2020 Apr 23. [PMID: 33343239](https://pubmed.gov/33343239); [PMCID: PMC7587875](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7587875)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r192d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0599-2020-12-21-528.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0599-2020-12-21-528.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b3914f4cb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0599-2020-12-21-528.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lasica M, Tam CS. Management of Ibrutinib Toxicities: a Practical Guide. Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Jun;15(3):177-186. [doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00576-3](https://doi.org/10.1007/s11899-020-00576-3). [PMID: 32415406](https://pubmed.gov/32415406)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r528d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0600-2020-12-21-498.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0600-2020-12-21-498.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..35d6708d8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0600-2020-12-21-498.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Novara G, Checcucci E, Crestani A, Abrate A, Esperto F, Pavan N, De Nunzio C, Galfano A, Giannarini G, Gregori A, Liguori G, Bartoletti R, Porpiglia F, Scarpa RM, Simonato A, Trombetta C, Tubaro A, Ficarra V; Research Urology Network (RUN). Telehealth in Urology: A Systematic Review of the Literature. How Much Can Telemedicine Be Useful During and After the COVID-19 Pandemic? Eur Urol. 2020 Dec;78(6):786-811. [doi: 10.1016/j.eururo.2020.06.025](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eururo.2020.06.025). Epub 2020 Jun 18. [PMID: 32616405](https://pubmed.gov/32616405); [PMCID: PMC7301090](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7301090)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r498d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0601-2020-12-21-545.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0601-2020-12-21-545.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bcd9d9768 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0601-2020-12-21-545.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Abdulla A, Davis WM, Ratnaweera N, Szefer E, Ballantyne Scott B, Lee AYY. A Meta-Analysis of Case Fatality Rates of Recurrent Venous Thromboembolism and Major Bleeding in Patients with Cancer. Thromb Haemost. 2020 Apr;120(4):702-713. [doi: 10.1055/s-0040-1708481](https://doi.org/10.1055/s-0040-1708481). Epub 2020 Apr 14. [PMID: 32289865](https://pubmed.gov/32289865)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r545d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0602-2020-12-21-236.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0602-2020-12-21-236.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b1b6c3fef --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0602-2020-12-21-236.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Diriba DC, Leung DYP, Suen LKP. The Effects of Diabetes Self-management Interventions on Physiological Outcomes in People Living with Diabetes in Africa: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Diabet Med. 2020 Dec 20:e14501. [doi: 10.1111/dme.14501](https://doi.org/10.1111/dme.14501). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341999](https://pubmed.gov/33341999)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r236d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0603-2020-12-21-291.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0603-2020-12-21-291.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4ffa9eb90 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0603-2020-12-21-291.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Misset B, Hoste E, Donneau AF, Grimaldi D, Meyfroidt G, Moutschen M, Compernolle V, Gothot A, Desmecht D, Garigliany M, Najdovski T, Laterre PF. A multicenter randomized trial to assess the efficacy of CONvalescent plasma therapy in patients with Invasive COVID-19 and acute respiratory failure treated with mechanical ventilation: the CONFIDENT trial protocol. BMC Pulm Med. 2020 Dec 7;20(1):317. [doi: 10.1186/s12890-020-01361-x](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12890-020-01361-x). [PMID: 33287790](https://pubmed.gov/33287790); [PMCID: PMC7719725](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7719725)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r291d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0604-2020-12-21-235.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0604-2020-12-21-235.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c6d898c8e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0604-2020-12-21-235.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Langton K, Tufton N, Akker S, Deinum J, Eisenhofer G, Timmers HJLM, Spaanderman MEA, Lenders JWM. Pregnancy and pheochromocytoma / paraganglioma: clinical clues affecting diagnosis and outcome: a systematic review. BJOG. 2020 Dec 20. [doi: 10.1111/1471-0528.16635](https://doi.org/10.1111/1471-0528.16635). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342020](https://pubmed.gov/33342020)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r235d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0605-2020-12-21-123.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0605-2020-12-21-123.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..08f8b56ea --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0605-2020-12-21-123.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Finlay J, Dela Cruz AM, Lind C. Concept analysis: Resilience in young women with chronic pain. Nurs Forum. 2020 Dec 20. [doi: 10.1111/nuf.12543](https://doi.org/10.1111/nuf.12543). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345367](https://pubmed.gov/33345367)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r123d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0606-2020-12-21-300.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0606-2020-12-21-300.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..45b190431 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0606-2020-12-21-300.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Castelbranco O, Nasc C, Castro E Sousa L, Ferreira T, Medeiros D. Infected Evar Endograft - A Lesson To Be Learned. Rev Port Cir Cardiotorac Vasc. 2020 Oct-Dec;27(4):298. [PMID: 33280322](https://pubmed.gov/33280322)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r300d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0607-2020-12-21-356.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0607-2020-12-21-356.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f65bb9e94 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0607-2020-12-21-356.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Agarwal R, Choi L, Johnson S, Takwoingi Y. Rapid diagnostic tests for Plasmodium vivax malaria in endemic countries. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 4;11:CD013218. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013218.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD013218.pub2). [PMID: 33146932](https://pubmed.gov/33146932)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r356d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0608-2020-12-21-230.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0608-2020-12-21-230.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..79cbb5c52 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0608-2020-12-21-230.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Feliciano DV. A Review of "Changes in the Management of Injuries to the Liver and Spleen" (2005). Am Surg. 2020 Dec 21:3134820979587. [doi: 10.1177/0003134820979587](https://doi.org/10.1177/0003134820979587). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342252](https://pubmed.gov/33342252)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r230d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0609-2020-12-21-324.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0609-2020-12-21-324.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cb4d8df5e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0609-2020-12-21-324.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Gao C, Miller J, Collins CT, Rumbold AR. Comparison of different protein concentrations of human milk fortifier for promoting growth and neurological development in preterm infants. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 20;11:CD007090. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007090.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD007090.pub2). [PMID: 33215474](https://pubmed.gov/33215474)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r324d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0610-2020-12-21-432.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0610-2020-12-21-432.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9e4020561 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0610-2020-12-21-432.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Yaqi H, Nan J, Ying C, Xiaojun Z, Lijuan Z, Yulu W, Siqi W, Shixiang C, Yue Z. Foot reflexology in the management of functional constipation: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Aug;40:101198. [doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101198](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101198). Epub 2020 May 8. [PMID: 32891277](https://pubmed.gov/32891277)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r432d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0611-2020-12-21-569.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0611-2020-12-21-569.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4fd139a9e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0611-2020-12-21-569.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘AACN Practice Alert: Pulmonary Artery/Central Venous Pressure Monitoring in Adults. AACN Adv Crit Care. 2020 Mar 15;31(1):41-48. [doi: 10.4037/aacnacc2020328](https://doi.org/10.4037/aacnacc2020328). [PMID: 32168513](https://pubmed.gov/32168513)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r569d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0612-2020-12-21-19.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0612-2020-12-21-19.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c69441017 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0612-2020-12-21-19.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Badal S, Thapa Bajgain K, Badal S, Thapa R, Bajgain BB, Santana MJ. Prevalence, clinical characteristics, and outcomes of pediatric COVID-19: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Clin Virol. 2020 Dec 8;135:104715. [doi: 10.1016/j.jcv.2020.104715](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcv.2020.104715). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348220](https://pubmed.gov/33348220); [PMCID: PMC7723460](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7723460)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r19d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0613-2020-12-21-293.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0613-2020-12-21-293.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..91a24794d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0613-2020-12-21-293.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hu Y, Cheng X, Su X, Fu Y. Auricular therapy improves gastrointestinal function in patients with gynecological laparoscopic surgery: A protocol for systematic review and meta analysis. Medicine (Baltimore). 2020 Dec 4;99(49):e23421. [doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000023421](https://doi.org/10.1097/MD.0000000000023421). [PMID: 33285735](https://pubmed.gov/33285735); [PMCID: PMC7717805](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7717805)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r293d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0614-2020-12-21-95.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0614-2020-12-21-95.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8a4edebae --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0614-2020-12-21-95.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bennett C, Chambers LM, Al-Hafez L, Michener CM, Falcone T, Yao M, Berghella V. Retracted articles in the obstetrics literature: lessons from the past to change the future. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 Nov;2(4):100201. [doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100201](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100201). Epub 2020 Aug 19. [PMID: 33345918](https://pubmed.gov/33345918)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r95d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0615-2020-12-21-50.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0615-2020-12-21-50.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8240eca66 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0615-2020-12-21-50.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Tan J, Ning T, Zhang W, Qian Z, Jiang X, Sun L, Wu B. Heparin locks with low and high concentration in haemodialysis patients: A systematic review and meta- analysis. Int J Nurs Pract. 2020 Dec 21:e12907. [doi: 10.1111/ijn.12907](https://doi.org/10.1111/ijn.12907). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33347670](https://pubmed.gov/33347670)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r50d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0616-2020-12-21-570.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0616-2020-12-21-570.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..39fc43471 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0616-2020-12-21-570.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘de Oliveira L, Carvalho J. The Link Between Boredom and Hypersexuality: A Systematic Review. J Sex Med. 2020 May;17(5):994-1004. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.02.007](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.02.007). Epub 2020 Mar 9. [PMID: 32165100](https://pubmed.gov/32165100)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r570d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0617-2020-12-21-326.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0617-2020-12-21-326.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7d5b089b1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0617-2020-12-21-326.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Liang WQ, Xi HQ, Qiao S, Cui JX, Zhang KC, Gao YH, Song YN, Zhang L, Luo H, Wei B, Xue WG, Chen L. [Analysis of clinicopathologic characteristics of gastric cancer patients undergoing gastrectomy based on a single-center gastric cancer database with above 10 000 cases]. Zhonghua Wei Chang Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2020 Nov 25;23(11):1051-1058. Chinese. [doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn.441530-20200117-00031](https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.cn.441530-20200117-00031). [PMID: 33212553](https://pubmed.gov/33212553)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r326d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0618-2020-12-21-499.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0618-2020-12-21-499.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..421b7f3f3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0618-2020-12-21-499.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Levine SL, Webb EG, Saltmiras DA. Review and analysis of the potential for glyphosate to interact with the estrogen, androgen and thyroid pathways. Pest Manag Sci. 2020 Sep;76(9):2886-2906. [doi: 10.1002/ps.5983](https://doi.org/10.1002/ps.5983). Epub 2020 Jul 17. [PMID: 32608552](https://pubmed.gov/32608552)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r499d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0619-2020-12-21-6.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0619-2020-12-21-6.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..05feed327 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0619-2020-12-21-6.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Pahl A, Young L, Buus-Frank ME, Marcellus L, Soll R. Non-pharmacological care for opioid withdrawal in newborns. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Dec 21;12:CD013217. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013217.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD013217.pub2). [PMID: 33348423](https://pubmed.gov/33348423)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r6d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0620-2020-12-21-333.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0620-2020-12-21-333.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f0e41af24 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0620-2020-12-21-333.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Rittiphairoj T, Mir TA, Li T, Virgili G. Intravitreal steroids for macular edema in diabetes. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 17;11:CD005656. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD005656.pub3](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD005656.pub3). [PMID: 33206392](https://pubmed.gov/33206392)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r333d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0621-2020-12-21-563.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0621-2020-12-21-563.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..387629219 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0621-2020-12-21-563.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ardizzone CA, Houck DA, McCartney DW, Vidal AF, Frank RM. All-Inside Repair of Bucket-Handle Meniscal Tears: Clinical Outcomes and Prognostic Factors. Am J Sports Med. 2020 Nov;48(13):3386-3393. [doi: 10.1177/0363546520906141](https://doi.org/10.1177/0363546520906141). Epub 2020 Mar 20. [PMID: 32195594](https://pubmed.gov/32195594)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r563d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0622-2020-12-21-410.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0622-2020-12-21-410.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8085c58ff --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0622-2020-12-21-410.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Francisco Mora C, Ibáñez A, Balcells-Balcells A. State of the Art of Family Quality of Life in Early Care and Disability: A Systematic Review. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020 Oct 2;17(19):7220. [doi: 10.3390/ijerph17197220](https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph17197220). [PMID: 33023172](https://pubmed.gov/33023172); [PMCID: PMC7578947](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7578947)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r410d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0623-2020-12-21-247.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0623-2020-12-21-247.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..934d94f3d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0623-2020-12-21-247.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Khanagar SB, Vishwanathaiah S, Naik S, A Al-Kheraif A, Devang Divakar D, Sarode SC, Bhandi S, Patil S. Application and performance of artificial intelligence technology in forensic odontology - A systematic review. Leg Med (Tokyo). 2020 Dec 10;48:101826. [doi: 10.1016/j.legalmed.2020.101826](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.legalmed.2020.101826). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341601](https://pubmed.gov/33341601)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r247d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0624-2020-12-21-657.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0624-2020-12-21-657.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1b06d6f2f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0624-2020-12-21-657.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Spaaij R, Broerse J, Oxford S, Luguetti C, McLachlan F, McDonald B, Klepac B, Lymbery L, Bishara J, Pankowiak A. Sport, Refugees, and Forced Migration: A Critical Review of the Literature. Front Sports Act Living. 2019 Oct 11;1:47. [doi: 10.3389/fspor.2019.00047](https://doi.org/10.3389/fspor.2019.00047). [PMID: 33344970](https://pubmed.gov/33344970); [PMCID: PMC7739661](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7739661)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r657d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0625-2020-12-21-403.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0625-2020-12-21-403.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..72b02b9b0 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0625-2020-12-21-403.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhang X, Song J, Wang Y, Deng W, Liu Y. Effects of land use on slope runoff and soil loss in the Loess Plateau of China: A meta-analysis. Sci Total Environ. 2021 Feb 10;755(Pt 1):142418. [doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142418](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142418). Epub 2020 Sep 22. [PMID: 33035990](https://pubmed.gov/33035990)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r403d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0626-2020-12-21-497.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0626-2020-12-21-497.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9290760a4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0626-2020-12-21-497.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chen Z, Han D, Wang Q, Li L. Four interventions for pediatric femoral shaft fractures: Network meta-analysis of randomized trials. Int J Surg. 2020 Aug;80:53-60. [doi: 10.1016/j.ijsu.2020.06.032](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsu.2020.06.032). Epub 2020 Jul 1. [PMID: 32622056](https://pubmed.gov/32622056)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r497d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0627-2020-12-21-420.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0627-2020-12-21-420.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d5b7a3018 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0627-2020-12-21-420.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Shao DD, Achkar CM, Lai A, Srivastava S, Doan RN, Rodan LH, Chen AY; Brain Development Study Group, Poduri A, Yang E, Walsh CA. Polymicrogyria is Associated With Pathogenic Variants in PTEN. Ann Neurol. 2020 Dec;88(6):1153-1164. [doi: 10.1002/ana.25904](https://doi.org/10.1002/ana.25904). Epub 2020 Oct 8. [PMID: 32959437](https://pubmed.gov/32959437)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r420d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0628-2020-12-21-490.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0628-2020-12-21-490.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..47295ed53 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0628-2020-12-21-490.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Almutairi H, Stafford A, Etherton-Beer C, Flicker L. Optimisation of medications used in residential aged care facilities: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Jul 8;20(1):236. [doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01634-4](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-020-01634-4). [PMID: 32641005](https://pubmed.gov/32641005); [PMCID: PMC7346508](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7346508)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r490d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0629-2020-12-21-243.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0629-2020-12-21-243.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0b509336e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0629-2020-12-21-243.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Alvarado CE, Worrell SG, Bachman KC, Gray K, Perry Y, Linden PA, Towe CW. Surgery following neoadjuvant chemoradiation therapy in clinical N3 esophageal cancer results in improved survival: a propensity-matched analysis. Dis Esophagus. 2020 Dec 21:doaa118. [doi: 10.1093/dote/doaa118](https://doi.org/10.1093/dote/doaa118). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341903](https://pubmed.gov/33341903)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r243d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0630-2020-12-21-135.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0630-2020-12-21-135.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c7edc1a46 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0630-2020-12-21-135.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Muneer R, Hashmet MR, Pourafshary P. Fine Migration Control in Sandstones: Surface Force Analysis and Application of DLVO Theory. ACS Omega. 2020 Dec 2;5(49):31624-31639. [doi: 10.1021/acsomega.0c03943](https://doi.org/10.1021/acsomega.0c03943). [PMID: 33344814](https://pubmed.gov/33344814); [PMCID: PMC7745222](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7745222)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r135d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0631-2020-12-21-527.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0631-2020-12-21-527.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4d8067d9e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0631-2020-12-21-527.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Miseré RML, Wolfs JAGN, Lobbes MBI, van der Hulst RRWJ, Qiu SS. A systematic review of magnetic resonance lymphography for the evaluation of peripheral lymphedema. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2020 Sep;8(5):882-892.e2. [doi: 10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.03.007](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.03.007). Epub 2020 May 13. [PMID: 32417145](https://pubmed.gov/32417145)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r527d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0632-2020-12-21-376.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0632-2020-12-21-376.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..73e950b4b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0632-2020-12-21-376.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Shauly O, Stone G, Gould D. The Public's Perception of the Severity and Global Impact at the Start of the SARS-CoV-2 Pandemic: A Crowdsourcing-Based Cross-Sectional Analysis. J Med Internet Res. 2020 Nov 26;22(11):e19768. [doi: 10.2196/19768](https://doi.org/10.2196/19768). [PMID: 33108314](https://pubmed.gov/33108314); [PMCID: PMC7695545](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7695545)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r376d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0633-2020-12-21-510.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0633-2020-12-21-510.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2ad9a0329 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0633-2020-12-21-510.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sengar M, Jain H, Rajendra A, Rengaraj K, Thorat J. Frontline Therapy of Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia: Changing Treatment Paradigm. Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Jun;15(3):168-176. [doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00580-7](https://doi.org/10.1007/s11899-020-00580-7). [PMID: 32542586](https://pubmed.gov/32542586)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r510d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0634-2020-12-21-549.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0634-2020-12-21-549.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..548cc3e12 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0634-2020-12-21-549.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hao Q, Hu Y, Zhang L, Ross J, Robishaw S, Noble C, Wu X, Zhang X. A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Clinical Trials of Neuraxial, Intravenous, and Inhalational Anesthesia for External Cephalic Version. Anesth Analg. 2020 Dec;131(6):1800-1811. [doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000004795](https://doi.org/10.1213/ANE.0000000000004795). [PMID: 32282385](https://pubmed.gov/32282385); [PMCID: PMC7643798](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7643798)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r549d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0635-2020-12-21-365.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0635-2020-12-21-365.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fa5acf148 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0635-2020-12-21-365.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Puntis S, Minichino A, De Crescenzo F, Cipriani A, Lennox B, Harrison R. Specialised early intervention teams (extended time) for recent-onset psychosis. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 2;11:CD013287. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013287.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD013287.pub2). [PMID: 33135812](https://pubmed.gov/33135812)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r365d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0636-2020-12-21-411.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0636-2020-12-21-411.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3a78704d0 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0636-2020-12-21-411.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ogonowska-Slodownik A, Richley Geigle P, Morgulec-Adamowicz N. Head-Out Water-Based Protocols to Assess Cardiorespiratory Fitness-Systematic Review. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020 Oct 2;17(19):7215. [doi: 10.3390/ijerph17197215](https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph17197215). [PMID: 33023128](https://pubmed.gov/33023128); [PMCID: PMC7579306](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7579306)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r411d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0637-2020-12-21-165.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0637-2020-12-21-165.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5aa4932d5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0637-2020-12-21-165.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Cao Z, Yang Z, Liang Z, Cen Q, Zhang Z, Liang H, Liu R, Zeng L, Xie Y, Wang Y. Prone versus Supine Position Ventilation in Adult Patients with Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Emerg Med Int. 2020 Nov 30;2020:4973878. [doi: 10.1155/2020/4973878](https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/4973878). [PMID: 33343939](https://pubmed.gov/33343939); [PMCID: PMC7732410](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7732410)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r165d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0638-2020-12-21-175.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0638-2020-12-21-175.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d914effc9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0638-2020-12-21-175.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Erdrich S, Hawrelak JA, Myers SP, Harnett JE. A systematic review of the association between fibromyalgia and functional gastrointestinal disorders. Therap Adv Gastroenterol. 2020 Dec 8;13:1756284820977402. [doi: 10.1177/1756284820977402](https://doi.org/10.1177/1756284820977402). [PMID: 33343707](https://pubmed.gov/33343707); [PMCID: PMC7727037](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7727037)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r175d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0639-2020-12-21-254.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0639-2020-12-21-254.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4b8faa007 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0639-2020-12-21-254.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Le Tertre M, Ka C, Raud L, Berlivet I, Gourlaouen I, Richard G, Uguen K, Chen JM, Férec C, Fichou Y, Le Gac G. Splicing analysis of SLC40A1 missense variations and contribution to hemochromatosis type 4 phenotypes. Blood Cells Mol Dis. 2020 Dec 8;87:102527. [doi: 10.1016/j.bcmd.2020.102527](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bcmd.2020.102527). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341511](https://pubmed.gov/33341511)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r254d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0640-2020-12-21-295.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0640-2020-12-21-295.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0d7e17f37 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0640-2020-12-21-295.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zhang J, Mei L, Wang F, Li Y. Ten years' disease-free survival of advanced epithelial ovarian cancer treated by cytoreductive surgery plus hyperthermic intraperitoneal chemotherapy: A case report and literature review. Medicine (Baltimore). 2020 Dec 4;99(49):e23404. [doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000023404](https://doi.org/10.1097/MD.0000000000023404). [PMID: 33285729](https://pubmed.gov/33285729); [PMCID: PMC7717790](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7717790)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r295d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0641-2020-12-21-24.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0641-2020-12-21-24.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b0abecb49 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0641-2020-12-21-24.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Wolfsegger T, Hauser A, Wimmer S, Neuwirth K, Assar H, Topakian R. A comprehensive clinico-radiological, neuropsychological and biomechanical analysis approach to patients with idiopathic normal pressure hydrocephalus. Clin Neurol Neurosurg. 2020 Dec 4;201:106402. [doi: 10.1016/j.clineuro.2020.106402](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clineuro.2020.106402). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348122](https://pubmed.gov/33348122)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r24d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0642-2020-12-21-130.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0642-2020-12-21-130.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e4cb76696 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0642-2020-12-21-130.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Marzi I, Emmerling S, Demetriou Y, Bucksch J, Schulze C, Brindley C, Reimers AK. Interventions Aiming to Promote Active Commuting in Children and Adolescents: An Evaluation From a Sex/Gender Perspective. Front Sports Act Living. 2020 Nov 26;2:590857. [doi: 10.3389/fspor.2020.590857](https://doi.org/10.3389/fspor.2020.590857). [PMID: 33345167](https://pubmed.gov/33345167); [PMCID: PMC7739596](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7739596)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r130d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0643-2020-12-21-213.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0643-2020-12-21-213.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e94d1469f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0643-2020-12-21-213.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Reas DL, Grilo CM. Psychotherapy and Medications for Eating Disorders: Better Together? Clin Ther. 2020 Dec 17:S0149-2918(20)30474-4. [doi: 10.1016/j.clinthera.2020.10.006](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clinthera.2020.10.006). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342555](https://pubmed.gov/33342555)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r213d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0644-2020-12-21-552.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0644-2020-12-21-552.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..77a8cf3b1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0644-2020-12-21-552.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Campello CP, Pellizzer EP, Vasconcelos BCDE, Moraes SLD, Lemos CAA, Muniz MTC. Evaluation of IL-6 levels and +3954 polymorphism of IL-1β in burning mouth syndrome: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Oral Pathol Med. 2020 Nov;49(10):961-968. [doi: 10.1111/jop.13018](https://doi.org/10.1111/jop.13018). Epub 2020 May 30. [PMID: 32274841](https://pubmed.gov/32274841)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r552d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0645-2020-12-21-32.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0645-2020-12-21-32.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f5dab1e60 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0645-2020-12-21-32.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Noori A, Mezlini AM, Hyman BT, Serrano-Pozo A, Das S. Systematic review and meta-analysis of human Transcriptomics reveals Neuroinflammation, deficient energy metabolism, and Proteostasis failure across Neurodegeneration. Neurobiol Dis. 2020 Dec 18:105225. [doi: 10.1016/j.nbd.2020.105225](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nbd.2020.105225). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33347974](https://pubmed.gov/33347974)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r32d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0646-2020-12-21-49.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0646-2020-12-21-49.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..866080637 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0646-2020-12-21-49.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Romanelli JP, Meli P, Naves RP, Alves MC, Rodrigues RR. Reliability of evidence-review methods in restoration ecology. Conserv Biol. 2020 Dec 21. [doi: 10.1111/cobi.13661](https://doi.org/10.1111/cobi.13661). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33347737](https://pubmed.gov/33347737)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r49d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0647-2020-12-21-373.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0647-2020-12-21-373.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..53ebf76ef --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0647-2020-12-21-373.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sterzenbach T, Helbig R, Hannig C, Hannig M. Bioadhesion in the oral cavity and approaches for biofilm management by surface modifications. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Dec;24(12):4237-4260. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03646-1](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-020-03646-1). Epub 2020 Oct 27. [PMID: 33111157](https://pubmed.gov/33111157); [PMCID: PMC7666681](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7666681)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r373d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0648-2020-12-21-308.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0648-2020-12-21-308.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0c90b0be9 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0648-2020-12-21-308.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kim JS, Lee KH, Kim GE, Kim S, Yang JW, Li H, Hong SH, Ghayda RA, Kronbichler A, Koyanagi A, Jacob L, Shin JI, Smith L. Clinical characteristics and mortality of patients with hematologic malignancies and COVID-19: a systematic review. Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci. 2020 Nov;24(22):11926-11933. [doi: 10.26355/eurrev_202011_23852](https://doi.org/10.26355/eurrev_202011_23852). [PMID: 33275265](https://pubmed.gov/33275265)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r308d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0649-2020-12-21-271.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0649-2020-12-21-271.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..63d65cbbd --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0649-2020-12-21-271.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Onwuchekwa C, Edem B, Williams V, Oga E. Estimating the impact of pneumococcal conjugate vaccines on childhood pneumonia in sub-Saharan Africa: A systematic review. F1000Res. 2020 Jul 23;9:765. [doi: 10.12688/f1000research.25227.2](https://doi.org/10.12688/f1000research.25227.2). [PMID: 33335713](https://pubmed.gov/33335713); [PMCID: PMC7713889](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7713889)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r271d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0650-2020-12-21-681.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0650-2020-12-21-681.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..abd78cf4b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0650-2020-12-21-681.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lassaletta L, Morales-Puebla JM, Altuna X, Arbizu Á, Arístegui M, Batuecas Á, Cenjor C, Espinosa-Sánchez JM, García-Iza L, García-Raya P, González-Otero T, Mañós M, Martín C, Moraleda S, Roda JM, Santiago S, Benítez J, Cavallé L, Correia V, Estévez JM, Gómez J, González R, Jiménez J, Lacosta JL, Lavilla MJ, Peñarrocha J, Polo R, García-Purriños F, Ramos F, Tomás M, Uzcanga M, Vallejo LÁ, Gavilán J. Facial paralysis: Clinical practice guideline of the Spanish Society of Otolaryngology. Acta Otorrinolaringol Esp. 2020 Mar-Apr;71(2):99-118. English, Spanish. [doi: 10.1016/j.otorri.2018.12.004](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.otorri.2018.12.004). Epub 2019 May 13. [PMID: 31097197](https://pubmed.gov/31097197)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r681d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0651-2020-12-21-196.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0651-2020-12-21-196.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0c7cd15f5 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0651-2020-12-21-196.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Huynh T. Clinical and Laboratory Aspects of Insulin Autoantibody-Mediated Glycaemic Dysregulation and Hyperinsulinaemic Hypoglycaemia: Insulin Autoimmune Syndrome and Exogenous Insulin Antibody Syndrome. Clin Biochem Rev. 2020 Dec;41(3):93-102. [doi: 10.33176/AACB-20-00008](https://doi.org/10.33176/AACB-20-00008). [PMID: 33343044](https://pubmed.gov/33343044); [PMCID: PMC7731936](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7731936)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r196d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0652-2020-12-21-180.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0652-2020-12-21-180.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b67da1b7a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0652-2020-12-21-180.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sun YF, Zhang J, Xu YM, Cao ZY, Wang YZ, Hao GM, Gao BL. High BMI and Insulin Resistance Are Risk Factors for Spontaneous Abortion in Patients With Polycystic Ovary Syndrome Undergoing Assisted Reproductive Treatment: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Front Endocrinol (Lausanne). 2020 Dec 3;11:592495. [doi: 10.3389/fendo.2020.592495](https://doi.org/10.3389/fendo.2020.592495). [PMID: 33343510](https://pubmed.gov/33343510); [PMCID: PMC7744738](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7744738)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r180d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0653-2020-12-21-309.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0653-2020-12-21-309.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..019da26b3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0653-2020-12-21-309.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Yap M, Debenham L, Kew T, Chatterjee SR, Allotey J, Stallings E, Coomar D, Lee SI, Qiu X, Yuan M, Clavé Llavall A, Dixit A, Zhou D, Balaji R, van Wely M, Kostova E, van Leeuwen E, Mofenson L, Kunst H, Khalil A, Tiberi S, Thomas J, Brizuela V, Broutet N, Kara E, Kim C, Thorson A, Rayco-Solon P, Pardo-Hernandez H, Oladapo OT, Zamora J, Bonet M, Thangaratinam S; PregCOV-19 Consortium. Clinical manifestations, prevalence, risk factors, outcomes, transmission, diagnosis and treatment of COVID-19 in pregnancy and postpartum: a living systematic review protocol. BMJ Open. 2020 Dec 2;10(12):e041868. [doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-041868](https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2020-041868). [PMID: 33268430](https://pubmed.gov/33268430); [PMCID: PMC7712931](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7712931)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r309d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0654-2020-12-21-416.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0654-2020-12-21-416.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..05772fa92 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0654-2020-12-21-416.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Skelton E, Drey N, Rutherford M, Ayers S, Malamateniou C. Electronic consenting for conducting research remotely: A review of current practice and key recommendations for using e-consenting. Int J Med Inform. 2020 Nov;143:104271. [doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104271](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104271). Epub 2020 Sep 13. [PMID: 32979650](https://pubmed.gov/32979650); [PMCID: PMC7487205](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7487205)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r416d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0655-2020-12-21-676.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0655-2020-12-21-676.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c94665d5d --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0655-2020-12-21-676.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Nilsson C, Berthold M, Mascialino B, Orme M, Sjölander S, Hamilton R. Allergen components in diagnosing childhood hazelnut allergy: Systematic literature review and meta-analysis. Pediatr Allergy Immunol. 2020 Feb;31(2):186-196. [doi: 10.1111/pai.13110](https://doi.org/10.1111/pai.13110). Epub 2020 Jan 1. [PMID: 31301691](https://pubmed.gov/31301691)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r676d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0656-2020-12-21-77.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0656-2020-12-21-77.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..43df1f2b4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0656-2020-12-21-77.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kim YI. Salvage peptide receptor radionuclide therapy in patients with progressive neuroendocrine tumors: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Nucl Med Commun. 2020 Dec 18;Publish Ahead of Print. [doi: 10.1097/MNM.0000000000001350](https://doi.org/10.1097/MNM.0000000000001350). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346603](https://pubmed.gov/33346603)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r77d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0657-2020-12-21-522.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0657-2020-12-21-522.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f9bbcd3cb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0657-2020-12-21-522.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘O'Donnell TF Jr, Allison GM, Iafrati MD. A systematic review of guidelines for lymphedema and the need for contemporary intersocietal guidelines for the management of lymphedema. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2020 Jul;8(4):676-684. [doi: 10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.03.006](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.03.006). Epub 2020 May 20. [PMID: 32444277](https://pubmed.gov/32444277)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r522d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0658-2020-12-21-285.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0658-2020-12-21-285.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..766fb15a7 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0658-2020-12-21-285.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Dhote L, Kumar S, Singh L, Kumar R. A systematic review on options for sustainable treatment and resource recovery of distillery sludge. Chemosphere. 2021 Jan;263:128225. [doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128225](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128225). Epub 2020 Sep 3. [PMID: 33297181](https://pubmed.gov/33297181)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r285d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0659-2020-12-21-266.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0659-2020-12-21-266.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..90ce47730 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0659-2020-12-21-266.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Jacob V, Chattopadhyay SK, Reynolds JA, Hopkins DP, Morgan JA, Brown DR, Kochtitzky CS, Cuellar AE, Kumanyika SK; Community Preventive Services Task Force. Economics of Interventions to Increase Active Travel to School: A Community Guide Systematic Review. Am J Prev Med. 2021 Jan;60(1):e27-e40. [doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2020.08.002](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amepre.2020.08.002). [PMID: 33341185](https://pubmed.gov/33341185)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r266d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0660-2020-12-21-573.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0660-2020-12-21-573.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..51d7be8be --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0660-2020-12-21-573.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Yafi FA, Huynh LM, Ahlering T, Rosen R. What Is a "Validated Questionnaire"? A Critical Review of Erectile Function Assessment. J Sex Med. 2020 May;17(5):849-860. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.02.005](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.02.005). Epub 2020 Mar 5. [PMID: 32146130](https://pubmed.gov/32146130)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r573d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0661-2020-12-21-595.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0661-2020-12-21-595.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f3971df11 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0661-2020-12-21-595.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Braun T, von Jan J, Wahnschaffe L, Herling M. Advances and Perspectives in the Treatment of T-PLL. Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Apr;15(2):113-124. [doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00566-5](https://doi.org/10.1007/s11899-020-00566-5). [PMID: 32034661](https://pubmed.gov/32034661); [PMCID: PMC7230055](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7230055)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r595d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0662-2020-12-21-350.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0662-2020-12-21-350.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d5194f31b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0662-2020-12-21-350.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Minozzi S, Amato L, Jahanfar S, Bellisario C, Ferri M, Davoli M. Maintenance agonist treatments for opiate-dependent pregnant women. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 9;11:CD006318. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD006318.pub4](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD006318.pub4). [PMID: 33165953](https://pubmed.gov/33165953)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r350d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0663-2020-12-21-419.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0663-2020-12-21-419.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cade8256a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0663-2020-12-21-419.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Aminoshariae A, Kulild J, Fouad AF. The impact of cardiovascular disease and endodontic outcome: a systematic review of longitudinal studies. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3813-3819. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03596-8](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-020-03596-8). Epub 2020 Sep 23. [PMID: 32965589](https://pubmed.gov/32965589)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r419d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0664-2020-12-21-393.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0664-2020-12-21-393.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cc3d5ecde --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0664-2020-12-21-393.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hong DW, Lin XJ, Wiegand A, Yu H. Does delayed toothbrushing after the consumption of erosive foodstuffs or beverages decrease erosive tooth wear? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Dec;24(12):4169-4183. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03614-9](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-020-03614-9). Epub 2020 Oct 14. [PMID: 33052542](https://pubmed.gov/33052542)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r393d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0665-2020-12-21-263.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0665-2020-12-21-263.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..eea33c552 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0665-2020-12-21-263.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Cheng C, Cheng GY, Denas G, Pengo V. Arterial thrombosis in antiphospholipid syndrome (APS): Clinical approach and treatment. A systematic review. Blood Rev. 2020 Dec 13:100788. [doi: 10.1016/j.blre.2020.100788](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.blre.2020.100788). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341301](https://pubmed.gov/33341301)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r263d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0666-2020-12-21-126.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0666-2020-12-21-126.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a1fd767bf --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0666-2020-12-21-126.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Dragičević P, Bielen A, Petrić I, Hudina S. Microbial pathogens of freshwater crayfish: A critical review and systematization of the existing data with directions for future research. J Fish Dis. 2020 Dec 20. [doi: 10.1111/jfd.13314](https://doi.org/10.1111/jfd.13314). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33345337](https://pubmed.gov/33345337)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r126d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0667-2020-12-21-554.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0667-2020-12-21-554.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cbbc12c55 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0667-2020-12-21-554.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Hebditch M, Daley S, Wright J, Sherlock G, Scott J, Banerjee S. Preferences of nursing and medical students for working with older adults and people with dementia: a systematic review. BMC Med Educ. 2020 Mar 30;20(1):92. [doi: 10.1186/s12909-020-02000-z](https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-020-02000-z). [PMID: 32228571](https://pubmed.gov/32228571); [PMCID: PMC7106576](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7106576)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r554d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0668-2020-12-21-12.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0668-2020-12-21-12.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7e23a3643 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0668-2020-12-21-12.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sun B, Zhang H, Zhang Y, Wu Z, Bao B, Hu Y, Li T. Compressed sensing of large-scale local field potentials using adaptive sparsity analysis and Non- convex Optimization. J Neural Eng. 2020 Dec 21. [doi: 10.1088/1741-2552/abd578](https://doi.org/10.1088/1741-2552/abd578). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348334](https://pubmed.gov/33348334)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r12d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0669-2020-12-21-305.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0669-2020-12-21-305.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d1fa050c0 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0669-2020-12-21-305.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Saraiva F, Leite-Moreira JP, Barros AS, Leite-Moreira A, Lourenço AP. Multiple Vs Single Arterial Grafting In Coronary Surgery Among Diabetic Patients: A Meta-Analysis. Rev Port Cir Cardiotorac Vasc. 2020 Oct- Dec;27(4):248. [PMID: 33280282](https://pubmed.gov/33280282)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r305d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0670-2020-12-21-431.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0670-2020-12-21-431.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6cac2d933 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0670-2020-12-21-431.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Walshaw EG, Smith M, Kanatas A, Rogers SN. Handle-On-QOL: a dedicated quality of life resource following the diagnosis and treatment of head and neck cancer. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 Nov;58(9):e25-e32. [doi: 10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.05.013](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.05.013). Epub 2020 Sep 2. [PMID: 32891434](https://pubmed.gov/32891434)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r431d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0671-2020-12-21-579.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0671-2020-12-21-579.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4079425a4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0671-2020-12-21-579.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Li Q, Yang J, Zhang J, Yang C, Fan Z, Yang Y, Zheng T, Yang J. Effect of Perioperative Glucose-Insulin-Potassium Therapy in Patients Undergoing On-Pump Cardiac Surgery: A Meta-Analysis. Heart Surg Forum. 2020 Feb 25;23(1):E063-E069. [doi: 10.1532/hsf.2735](https://doi.org/10.1532/hsf.2735). [PMID: 32118546](https://pubmed.gov/32118546)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r579d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0672-2020-12-21-88.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0672-2020-12-21-88.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0e5b74a79 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0672-2020-12-21-88.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Sobhani SR, Babashahi M. Determinants of Household Food Basket Composition: A Systematic Review. Iran J Public Health. 2020 Oct;49(10):1827-1838. [doi: 10.18502/ijph.v49i10.4681](https://doi.org/10.18502/ijph.v49i10.4681). [PMID: 33346207](https://pubmed.gov/33346207); [PMCID: PMC7719639](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7719639)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r88d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0673-2020-12-21-76.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0673-2020-12-21-76.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..90bef4866 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0673-2020-12-21-76.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bolia R, Goel A, Srivastava A. Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Thiopurine Metabolite Levels and Biochemical Remission in Autoimmune Hepatitis. Ther Drug Monit. 2020 Dec 17;Publish Ahead of Print. [doi: 10.1097/FTD.0000000000000848](https://doi.org/10.1097/FTD.0000000000000848). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33346628](https://pubmed.gov/33346628)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r76d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0674-2020-12-21-413.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0674-2020-12-21-413.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c1a0425e8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0674-2020-12-21-413.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Patil S, Warnakulasuriya S. Blood-based circulating microRNAs as potential biomarkers for predicting the prognosis of head and neck cancer-a systematic review. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3833-3841. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03608-7](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-020-03608-7). Epub 2020 Oct 3. [PMID: 33009627](https://pubmed.gov/33009627)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r413d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0675-2020-12-21-8.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0675-2020-12-21-8.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b592df207 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0675-2020-12-21-8.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Taksøe-Vester C, Dyre L, Schroll J, Tabor A, Tolsgaard M. Simulation-Based Ultrasound Training in Obstetrics and Gynecology: A Systematic Review and Meta- Analysis. Ultraschall Med. 2020 Dec 21. English. [doi: 10.1055/a-1300-1680](https://doi.org/10.1055/a-1300-1680). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348415](https://pubmed.gov/33348415)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r8d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0676-2020-12-21-378.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0676-2020-12-21-378.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ddc25a5de --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0676-2020-12-21-378.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Alemu AY, Endalamaw A, Belay DM, Mekonen DK, Birhan BM, Bayih WA. Healthcare-associated infection and its determinants in Ethiopia: A systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One. 2020 Oct 23;15(10):e0241073. [doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0241073](https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0241073). [PMID: 33095807](https://pubmed.gov/33095807); [PMCID: PMC7584210](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7584210)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r378d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0677-2020-12-21-58.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0677-2020-12-21-58.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..243a6977f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0677-2020-12-21-58.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Diehm YF, Fischer S, Wirth GA, Haug V, Orgill DP, Momeni A, Horch RE, Lehner B, Kneser U, Hirche C. Management of Acute and Traumatic Wounds With Negative- Pressure Wound Therapy With Instillation and Dwell Time. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2021 Jan 1;147(1S-1):43S-53S. [doi: 10.1097/PRS.0000000000007610](https://doi.org/10.1097/PRS.0000000000007610). [PMID: 33347062](https://pubmed.gov/33347062)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r58d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0678-2020-12-21-539.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0678-2020-12-21-539.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e9073adc8 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0678-2020-12-21-539.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Nukala V, Incrocci L, Hunt AA, Ballas L, Koontz BF. Challenges in Reporting the Effect of Radiotherapy on Erectile Function. J Sex Med. 2020 Jun;17(6):1053-1059. [doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.03.008](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.03.008). Epub 2020 Apr 17. [PMID: 32312661](https://pubmed.gov/32312661)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r539d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0679-2020-12-21-207.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0679-2020-12-21-207.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d5ca6f065 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0679-2020-12-21-207.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bhuiyan MU, Stiboy E, Hassan MZ, Chan M, Islam MS, Haider N, Jaffe A, Homaira N. Epidemiology of COVID-19 infection in young children under five years: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Vaccine. 2020 Dec 5:S0264-410X(20)31570-X. [doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.11.078](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.11.078). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33342635](https://pubmed.gov/33342635)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r207d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0680-2020-12-21-388.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0680-2020-12-21-388.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a0d9be0bb --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0680-2020-12-21-388.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Gomes EWB, Casarin M, Martins TM, da Silva AF. Local delivery therapies as adjuvants to non-surgical periodontal treatment of periodontitis grade C: a systematic review. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Dec;24(12):4213-4224. [doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03631-8](https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-020-03631-8). Epub 2020 Oct 17. [PMID: 33070281](https://pubmed.gov/33070281)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r388d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0681-2020-12-21-349.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0681-2020-12-21-349.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..66622ebfd --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0681-2020-12-21-349.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Semlitsch T, Engler J, Siebenhofer A, Jeitler K, Berghold A, Horvath K. (Ultra-)long-acting insulin analogues versus NPH insulin (human isophane insulin) for adults with type 2 diabetes mellitus. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 9;11:CD005613. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD005613.pub4](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD005613.pub4). [PMID: 33166419](https://pubmed.gov/33166419)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r349d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0682-2020-12-21-547.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0682-2020-12-21-547.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e5c30634a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0682-2020-12-21-547.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Ontario Health (Quality). Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation for Cardiac Indications in Adults: A Health Technology Assessment. Ont Health Technol Assess Ser. 2020 Mar 6;20(8):1-121. [PMID: 32284771](https://pubmed.gov/32284771); [PMCID: PMC7143364](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7143364)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r547d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0683-2020-12-21-260.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0683-2020-12-21-260.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c99da5ad6 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0683-2020-12-21-260.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Magalhães GM, Vieira ÉC, Garcia LC, De Carvalho-Leite MLR, Guedes ACM, Araújo MG. Update on human papilloma virus - part I: epidemiology, pathogenesis, and clinical spectrum. An Bras Dermatol. 2020 Dec 10:S0365-0596(20)30662-0. [doi: 10.1016/j.abd.2020.11.003](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.abd.2020.11.003). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341319](https://pubmed.gov/33341319)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r260d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0684-2020-12-21-328.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0684-2020-12-21-328.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c3b790b44 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0684-2020-12-21-328.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Duarte GS, Rodrigues FB, Marques RE, Castelão M, Ferreira J, Sampaio C, Moore AP, Costa J. Botulinum toxin type A therapy for blepharospasm. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 19;11:CD004900. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004900.pub3](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD004900.pub3). [PMID: 33211907](https://pubmed.gov/33211907)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r328d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0685-2020-12-21-401.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0685-2020-12-21-401.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7641163f1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0685-2020-12-21-401.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Li Y, Xia G, Tan Y, Shuai J. Acupoint stimulation and Chinese herbal medicines for the treatment of premature ovarian insufficiency: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101244. [doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101244](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101244). Epub 2020 Oct 7. [PMID: 33039750](https://pubmed.gov/33039750)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r401d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0686-2020-12-21-478.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0686-2020-12-21-478.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bfd917954 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0686-2020-12-21-478.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Amaral LKB, Souza MB, Campos MGM, Mendonça VA, Bastone A, Pereira LSM, Mascarenhas RO, Oliveira VC. Efficacy of conservative therapy in older people with nonspecific low back pain: A systematic review with meta-analysis and GRADE recommendations. Arch Gerontol Geriatr. 2020 Sep-Oct;90:104177. [doi: 10.1016/j.archger.2020.104177](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.archger.2020.104177). Epub 2020 Jul 11. [PMID: 32682168](https://pubmed.gov/32682168)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r478d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0687-2020-12-21-334.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0687-2020-12-21-334.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..65f9af8b4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0687-2020-12-21-334.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Chen I, Veth VB, Choudhry AJ, Murji A, Zakhari A, Black AY, Agarpao C, Maas JW. Pre- and postsurgical medical therapy for endometriosis surgery. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 18;11:CD003678. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003678.pub3](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD003678.pub3). [PMID: 33206374](https://pubmed.gov/33206374)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r334d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0688-2020-12-21-34.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0688-2020-12-21-34.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fb26326c1 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0688-2020-12-21-34.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Kirk AG, Behm KJ, Ksimmel LA, Ekegren CL. Levels of physical activity and sedentary behaviour during and after hospitalisation: a systematic review. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2020 Dec 18:S0003-9993(20)31320-4. [doi: 10.1016/j.apmr.2020.11.012](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apmr.2020.11.012). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33347891](https://pubmed.gov/33347891)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r34d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0689-2020-12-21-240.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0689-2020-12-21-240.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..094d1b35f --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0689-2020-12-21-240.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Lorentzen AK, Davis C, Penninga L. Interventions for frostbite injuries. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Dec 20;12:CD012980. [doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012980.pub2](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD012980.pub2). [PMID: 33341943](https://pubmed.gov/33341943)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r240d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0690-2020-12-21-426.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0690-2020-12-21-426.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1b88a005e --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0690-2020-12-21-426.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Tehrani BN, Basir MB, Kapur NK. Acute myocardial infarction and cardiogenic shock: Should we unload the ventricle before percutaneous coronary intervention? Prog Cardiovasc Dis. 2020 Sep-Oct;63(5):607-622. [doi: 10.1016/j.pcad.2020.09.001](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pcad.2020.09.001). Epub 2020 Sep 11. [PMID: 32920027](https://pubmed.gov/32920027)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r426d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0691-2020-12-21-16.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0691-2020-12-21-16.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d7c09c49a --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0691-2020-12-21-16.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Guo J, Pei L, Chen L, Chen H, Gu D, Peng Y, Sun J. Bidirectional association between irritable bowel syndrome and restless legs syndrome: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sleep Med. 2020 Dec 4;77:104-111. [doi: 10.1016/j.sleep.2020.12.002](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sleep.2020.12.002). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33348297](https://pubmed.gov/33348297)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r16d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0692-2020-12-21-406.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0692-2020-12-21-406.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3a013df34 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0692-2020-12-21-406.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Banothu KK, Bhat JI, Das RR, Dhochak N, Ghimire JJ, Goyal JP, Gulla KM, Gupta S, Jat KR, Kabra SK, Kalyan P, Kumar A, Kumar P, Kumar V, Lodha R, Mathew JL, Pathania A, Ratageri VH, Singh V, Warankar S. Expert Opinion on Restoration of Pediatric Pulmonology Services During the SARS-CoV-2 Pandemic. Indian Pediatr. 2020 Nov 15;57(11):1055-1059. [doi: 10.1007/s13312-020-2035-z](https://doi.org/10.1007/s13312-020-2035-z). Epub 2020 Sep 16. [PMID: 33034302](https://pubmed.gov/33034302); [PMCID: PMC7678585](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7678585)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r406d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0693-2020-12-21-321.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0693-2020-12-21-321.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..19cd31f19 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0693-2020-12-21-321.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Marotta N, Demeco A, Moggio L, Marinaro C, Pino I, Barletta M, Petraroli A, Pepe D, Lavano F, Ammendolia A. Comparative effectiveness of breathing exercises in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101260. [doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101260](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101260). Epub 2020 Nov 17. [PMID: 33221632](https://pubmed.gov/33221632)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r321d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0694-2020-12-21-667.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0694-2020-12-21-667.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a145e10b4 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0694-2020-12-21-667.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Zheng L, Li G, Wang X, Yin H, Jia Y, Leng M, Li H, Chen L. Effect of exergames on physical outcomes in frail elderly: a systematic review. Aging Clin Exp Res. 2020 Nov;32(11):2187-2200. [doi: 10.1007/s40520-019-01344-x](https://doi.org/10.1007/s40520-019-01344-x). Epub 2019 Sep 13. [PMID: 31520334](https://pubmed.gov/31520334)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r667d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0695-2020-12-21-170.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0695-2020-12-21-170.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2b002ff83 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0695-2020-12-21-170.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Salas RL, Eslava-Schmalbach J, Vaca-González C, Rodríguez D, Figueras A. Development of a stepwise tool to aide primary health care professionals in the process of deprescribing in older persons. Pharm Pract (Granada). 2020 Oct- Dec;18(4):2033. [doi: 10.18549/PharmPract.2020.4.2033](https://doi.org/10.18549/PharmPract.2020.4.2033). Epub 2020 Dec 4. [PMID: 33343769](https://pubmed.gov/33343769); [PMCID: PMC7732213](https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/PMC7732213)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r170d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0696-2020-12-21-261.md b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0696-2020-12-21-261.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5e64d168b --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/posts-edit/2020/12/21/0696-2020-12-21-261.md @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ + + + + +title: "Record Awaiting Appraisal" + +summary: "A Zheln appraisal record downloaded from the PubMed Systematic Subset daily updates." + +thumbnail: journal-whills + +Zhelnov P. A critical appraisal of _‘Bakaloudi DR, Halloran A, Rippin HL, Oikonomidou AC, Dardavesis TI, Williams J, Wickramasinghe K, Breda J, Chourdakis M. Intake and adequacy of the vegan diet. A systematic review of the evidence. Clin Nutr. 2020 Dec 7:S0261-5614(20)30656-7. [doi: 10.1016/j.clnu.2020.11.035](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clnu.2020.11.035). Epub ahead of print. [PMID: 33341313](https://pubmed.gov/33341313)’._ Zheln. 2020 Dec 23;52(1):r261d21. URI: {{ page.url | absolute_url }}. + + + + + + + + + +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Title +- [ ] 2. ✅ Meets [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Abstract +- [ ] 2. ❌ Does Not Meet [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/11820967_Taking_Advantage_of_the_Explosion_of_Systematic_Reviews_An_Efficient_MEDLINE_Search_Strategy) True Positive Criteria for Systematic Reviews by Neither Title nor Abstract + +medicine: + - [ ] cardiovascular diseases + - [ ] chemical pathology + - [ ] clinical informatics + - [ ] clinical laboratory dermatological immunology + - [ ] clinical laboratory immunology + - [ ] clinical neurophysiology + - [ ] clinical pathology + - [ ] clinical pharmacology + - [ ] dermatology + - [ ] diabetes + - [ ] emergency medical services + - [ ] endocrinology + - [ ] epidemiology + - [ ] epilepsy + - [ ] family medicine + - [ ] family practice + - [ ] gastroenterology + - [ ] general practice + - [ ] general preventive medicine + - [ ] hematology + - [ ] hepatology + - [ ] hospice medicine + - [ ] hospitalist + - [ ] internal medicine + - [ ] medical management + - [ ] medical physics + - [ ] nephrology + - [ ] neurology + - [ ] neuromuscular medicine + - [ ] nutrition + - [ ] osteopathic manipulative medicine + - [ ] osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine + - [ ] palliative medicine + - [ ] pharmaceutical medicine + - [ ] physical medicine rehabilitation + - [ ] public health + - [ ] pulmonary disease + - [ ] radiological physics + - [ ] rheumatology + - [ ] sleep medicine + - [ ] vascular medicine + - [ ] vascular neurology + +psychiatry: + - [ ] neuropsychiatry + - [ ] psychiatry + - [ ] psychoanalysis + - [ ] psychosomatic medicine + +surgery: + - [ ] abdominal radiology + - [ ] abdominal surgery + - [ ] acute pain medicine + - [ ] adult reconstructive orthopedics + - [ ] adult cardiothoracic anesthesiology + - [ ] advanced heart failure + - [ ] anatomic pathology + - [ ] anesthesiology + - [ ] ankle orthopedics + - [ ] blood banking + - [ ] brain injury medicine + - [ ] cardiac electrophysiology + - [ ] cardiothoracic radiology + - [ ] colon surgery + - [ ] cosmetic surgery + - [ ] craniofacial surgery + - [ ] critical care medicine + - [ ] dermatologic surgery + - [ ] dermatopathology + - [ ] diagnostic radiology + - [ ] endovascular surgical neuroradiology + - [ ] facial plastic surgery + - [ ] foot orthopedics + - [ ] general surgery + - [ ] hand surgery + - [ ] infertility + - [ ] interventional cardiology + - [ ] interventional radiology + - [ ] maxillofacial surgery + - [ ] musculoskeletal radiology + - [ ] neurological surgery + - [ ] neuropathology + - [ ] neuroradiology + - [ ] neurotology + - [ ] nuclear cardiology + - [ ] ophthalmic plastic surgery + - [ ] ophthalmic reconstructive surgery + - [ ] ophthalmology + - [ ] oral surgery + - [ ] orthopedic spine surgery + - [ ] orthopedic surgery + - [ ] otolaryngology + - [ ] pain management + - [ ] pain medicine + - [ ] phlebology + - [ ] plastic head and neck surgery + - [ ] plastic surgery + - [ ] procedural dermatology + - [ ] proctology + - [ ] pulmonary critical care medicine + - [ ] radiology + - [ ] rectal surgery + - [ ] regional anesthesiology + - [ ] reproductive endocrinology + - [ ] selective pathology + - [ ] spinal cord injury + - [ ] surgical critical care + - [ ] thoracic surgery + - [ ] transfusion medicine + - [ ] transplant cardiology + - [ ] transplant hepatology + - [ ] transplant surgery + - [ ] urology + - [ ] vascular radiology + - [ ] vascular surgery + +injury: + - [ ] emergency medicine + - [ ] orthopedic trauma + - [ ] trauma surgery + - [ ] urgent care medicine + +infection: + - [ ] allergy + - [ ] immunology + - [ ] infectious disease + - [ ] medical microbiology + +tumor: + - [ ] advanced surgical oncology + - [ ] clinical cytogenetics + - [ ] clinical molecular genetics + - [ ] cytopathology + - [ ] head and neck surgery + - [ ] hematology-oncology + - [ ] medical oncology + - [ ] molecular genetic pathology + - [ ] musculoskeletal oncology + - [ ] nuclear medicine + - [ ] nuclear radiology + - [ ] radiation oncology + - [ ] surgical oncology + +special: + - [ ] adolescent medicine + - [ ] adolescent psychiatry + - [ ] adult congenital heart disease + - [ ] aerospace medicine + - [ ] child neurology + - [ ] child psychiatry + - [ ] clinical biochemical genetics + - [ ] clinical genetics + - [ ] congenital cardiac surgery + - [ ] developmental-behavioral pediatrics + - [ ] female pelvic medicine + - [ ] female reconstructive surgery + - [ ] geriatric medicine + - [ ] geriatric psychiatry + - [ ] gynecological oncology + - [ ] gynecology + - [ ] hyperbaric medicine + - [ ] maternal-fetal medicine + - [ ] medical biochemical genetics + - [ ] medical genetics + - [ ] neonatal-perinatal medicine + - [ ] neurodevelopmental disabilities + - [ ] obstetric anesthesiology + - [ ] obstetrics + - [ ] occupational medicine + - [ ] pediatric allergy + - [ ] pediatric anesthesiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiology + - [ ] pediatric cardiothoracic surgery + - [ ] pediatric critical care medicine + - [ ] pediatric dermatology + - [ ] pediatric emergency medicine + - [ ] pediatric endocrinology + - [ ] pediatric gastroenterology + - [ ] pediatric hematology oncology + - [ ] pediatric hospital medicine + - [ ] pediatric infectious diseases + - [ ] pediatric nephrology + - [ ] pediatric ophthalmology + - [ ] pediatric orthopedics + - [ ] pediatric otolaryngology + - [ ] pediatric pathology + - [ ] pediatric pulmonology + - [ ] pediatric radiology + - [ ] pediatric rehabilitation medicine + - [ ] pediatric rheumatology + - [ ] pediatric surgery + - [ ] pediatric transplant hepatology + - [ ] pediatric urology + - [ ] pediatrics + - [ ] sports medicine + - [ ] undersea medicine + +illegal: + - [ ] addiction medicine + - [ ] addiction psychiatry + - [ ] child abuse pediatrics + - [ ] forensic pathology + - [ ] forensic psychiatry + - [ ] legal medicine + - [ ] medical toxicology + +full appraisal: +- [ ] 3. ❌ No Full Text Available to **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 3. ✅ Full Text & Other Reports Collected by **Zheln** +- [ ] 4. ❌ Does Not Generate Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 4. ✅ Generates Pragmatic Evidence Directly Relevant to Evidence-Based Practice +- [ ] 5. ❌ Is Duplicate +- [ ] 5. ✅ Not Found Duplicate by **Zheln** +- [ ] 6. ❌ Failed Replication +- [ ] 6. ✅ Passed Replication +- [ ] 7. ❌ Has Critical Conduct Flaws +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Critical Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 7. ✅ No Conduct Flaws Identified by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👎 Disliked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 8. 👍 Liked by **Zheln** +- [ ] 9. ✅ Practical Implications Summarized by **Zheln** +- [ ] 10. ✅ Appraisal Published & Call for Crowdfunding diff --git a/zheln/rnd/2020/12/rnd_2020-12-21_696.lst b/zheln/rnd/2020/12/rnd_2020-12-21_696.lst new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1b66505a3 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/rnd/2020/12/rnd_2020-12-21_696.lst @@ -0,0 +1,696 @@ +392 +110 +343 +221 +18 +625 +514 +342 +98 +281 +537 +621 +632 +661 +511 +368 +560 +505 +382 +479 +423 +132 +272 +530 +159 +145 +286 +641 +591 +73 +357 +358 +546 +81 +628 +137 +256 +504 +188 +485 +564 +660 +318 +402 +251 +329 +567 +648 +609 +11 +144 +542 +9 +153 +355 +178 +583 +20 +252 +336 +206 +466 +389 +238 +275 +54 +335 +274 +525 +607 +317 +106 +205 +555 +193 +124 +362 +484 +195 +177 +561 +202 +141 +584 +489 +233 +190 +283 +483 +276 +596 +603 +352 +630 +70 +610 +456 +339 +457 +239 +313 +228 +482 +572 +244 +436 +255 +35 +148 +208 +74 +694 +408 +40 +534 +614 +372 +394 +229 +63 +523 +653 +375 +155 +338 +646 +265 +102 +125 +412 +78 +538 +90 +119 +139 +666 +218 +566 +433 +494 +622 +495 +25 +513 +219 +480 +658 +400 +232 +332 +354 +599 +330 +273 +109 +650 +519 +571 +674 +168 +14 +515 +150 +47 +43 +39 +161 +315 +201 +36 +680 +601 +89 +654 +101 +301 +509 +31 +278 +424 +577 +114 +367 +474 +684 +249 +696 +173 +435 +184 +113 +91 +605 +267 +4 +470 +616 +612 +347 +693 +97 +111 +216 +220 +586 +143 +581 +611 +226 +391 +323 +245 +120 +465 +404 +211 +458 +325 +633 +683 +449 +665 +473 +341 +250 +440 +306 +131 +246 +344 +460 +134 +310 +197 +174 +162 +316 +282 +381 +151 +409 +624 +593 +61 +626 +636 +387 +353 +209 +212 +468 +83 +574 +118 +319 +598 +169 +199 +64 +668 +445 +691 +369 +183 +259 +590 +588 +613 +164 +502 +257 +476 +472 +481 +105 +582 +200 +292 +75 +277 +384 +608 +248 +568 +444 +639 +268 +53 +288 +398 +442 +592 +22 +634 +689 +521 +167 +500 +30 +198 +503 +127 +289 +258 +92 +430 +108 +390 +695 +48 +157 +298 +129 +284 +477 +359 +604 +26 +215 +52 +187 +688 +645 +222 +664 +152 +589 +107 +434 +619 +637 +133 +366 +491 +550 +672 +79 +69 +116 +617 +417 +345 +185 +62 +623 +307 +618 +2 +642 +56 +414 +296 +7 +304 +452 +374 +86 +44 +620 +138 +446 +38 +28 +640 +117 +280 +72 +46 +290 +686 +340 +156 +104 +540 +467 +439 +182 +5 +270 +231 +67 +585 +548 +422 +189 +191 +425 +3 +320 +575 +15 +29 +678 +627 +337 +475 +210 +647 +57 +303 +363 +606 +237 +405 +204 +629 +287 +496 +493 +471 +429 +679 +448 +269 +160 +80 +450 +10 +535 +87 +594 +348 +536 +51 +370 +302 +42 +227 +214 +331 +418 +21 +512 +279 +383 +379 +662 +517 +242 +82 +671 +643 +66 +578 +224 +140 +600 +203 +322 +93 +121 +541 +462 +264 +644 +163 +146 +631 +447 +17 +294 +399 +673 +553 +100 +428 +103 +659 +508 +147 +556 +529 +194 +395 +65 +441 +1 +171 +635 +652 +364 +158 +241 +154 +524 +687 +520 +172 +297 +454 +487 +463 +557 +166 +670 +415 +99 +543 +71 +531 +225 +565 +115 +507 +396 +314 +675 +112 +685 +464 +179 +551 +421 +311 +562 +649 +351 +486 +377 +437 +217 +651 +186 +59 +544 +469 +492 +68 +580 +682 +27 +669 +60 +13 +234 +597 +488 +84 +385 +690 +692 +55 +587 +253 +663 +526 +262 +142 +37 +397 +427 +656 +312 +638 +128 +386 +360 +85 +149 +223 +558 +438 +518 +602 +45 +346 +136 +453 +33 +176 +96 +443 +615 +327 +451 +576 +516 +371 +455 +361 +461 +459 +655 +23 +181 +122 +677 +41 +533 +407 +380 +559 +501 +532 +94 +299 +506 +192 +528 +498 +545 +236 +291 +235 +123 +300 +356 +230 +324 +432 +569 +19 +293 +95 +50 +570 +326 +499 +6 +333 +563 +410 +247 +657 +403 +497 +420 +490 +243 +135 +527 +376 +510 +549 +365 +411 +165 +175 +254 +295 +24 +130 +213 +552 +32 +49 +373 +308 +271 +681 +196 +180 +309 +416 +676 +77 +522 +285 +266 +573 +595 +350 +419 +393 +263 +126 +554 +12 +305 +431 +579 +88 +76 +413 +8 +378 +58 +539 +207 +388 +349 +547 +260 +328 +401 +478 +334 +34 +240 +426 +16 +406 +321 +667 +170 +261 diff --git a/zheln/ssb-replicated-ae408b9/ssb-replicated-ae408b9_2020-12-21.md b/zheln/ssb-replicated-ae408b9/ssb-replicated-ae408b9_2020-12-21.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..efb141c18 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/ssb-replicated-ae408b9/ssb-replicated-ae408b9_2020-12-21.md @@ -0,0 +1,451 @@ +# Zheln Search + +## PubMed + +### Replicated Systematic Review Subset + +* This query ultimately represents the [Search Strategy Used to Create the Systematic Reviews Subset on PubMed](https://www.nlm.nih.gov/bsd/pubmed_subsets/sysreviews_strategy.html) as joined from the two versions: [February 2017](http://web.archive.org/web/20181023065423/https://www.nlm.nih.gov/bsd/pubmed_subsets/sysreviews_strategy.html) and [December 2018](http://web.archive.org/web/20190711085949/https://www.nlm.nih.gov/bsd/pubmed_subsets/sysreviews_strategy.html). +* The February 2017 version is [based](https://wayback.archive-it.org/org-350/20180406175620/https://www.nlm.nih.gov/bsd/pubmed_subsets/sysreviews_sources.html) on the study by [Shojania & Bero 2001](https://pubmed.gov/11525102). I don’t know what the December 2018 version is based on, it’s not been written there. +* The Replicated version produces a replicable set of records for a certain date. In other words, if the query still works, you will get a consistent set of records each time on whatever date you run the query. Notice: There is [evidence PubMed index is sometimes updated retrospectively](https://github.com/p1m-ortho/qs-global-ortho-search-queries/commit/29c9a7cfba51dc06390672971eb69d248b91cf35); therefore, in these cases, count mismatches may still occur. +* See a detailed account of development of the Replicated Systematic Review Subset and its testing reports in the [commit history of the Zheln methods repository](https://github.com/p1m-ortho/qs-global-ortho-search-queries/commits/global-sr-query). While lurking through the commit history, be sure to inspect [both the diff _and_ the body of the commits](https://git-scm.com/book/en/v2/Git-Basics-Recording-Changes-to-the-Repository). +* When run on Dec 23, 2020, this query returned [696 records](https://github.com/p1m-ortho/qs-global-ortho-search-queries/blob/global-sr-query/zheln/summary-systematic-set/summary-systematic-set_2020-12-21_696.txt). + +``` +( + ( + ( + ( + ( + ( + "systematic review"[ti] OR "systematic literature review"[ti] OR "systematic scoping review"[ti] OR "systematic narrative review"[ti] OR "systematic qualitative review"[ti] OR "systematic evidence review"[ti] OR "systematic quantitative review"[ti] OR "systematic meta review"[ti] OR "systematic critical review"[ti] OR "systematic mixed studies review"[ti] OR "systematic mapping review"[ti] OR "systematic cochrane review"[ti] OR "systematic search and review"[ti] OR "systematic integrative review"[ti] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + NOT + ( + "comment"[pt] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + ) + NOT + ( + ( + "protocol"[ti] OR "protocols"[ti] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + ) + NOT + ( + "medline"[sb] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + ) + ) + OR + ( + ( + "cochrane database syst rev"[ta] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + AND + ( + "review"[pt] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + ) + ) + OR + ( + "systematic review"[pt] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + ) + ) + OR + ( + ( + ( + "systematic review"[ti] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + OR + ( + "meta-analysis"[pt] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + ) + OR + ( + ( + "meta analysis"[ti] OR "systematic literature review"[ti] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + OR + ( + ( + "this systematic review"[tw] OR "pooling project"[tw] + ) + AND + ( + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + OR + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[mhda] + ) + ) + OR + ( + ( + "this systematic review"[tiab] OR "pooling project"[tiab] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + OR + ( + ( + "systematic review"[tiab] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + AND + ( + "review"[pt] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + ) + ) + OR + ( + ( + "meta synthesis"[ti] OR "meta analy*"[ti] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + OR + ( + ( + "integrative review"[tw] OR "integrative research review"[tw] OR "rapid review"[tw] OR "umbrella review"[tw] + ) + AND + ( + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + OR + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[mhda] + ) + ) + OR + ( + ( + "integrative review"[tiab] OR "integrative research review"[tiab] OR "rapid review"[tiab] OR "umbrella review"[tiab] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + OR + ( + ( + "consensus development conference"[pt] OR "practice guideline"[pt] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + ) + OR + ( + ( + "drug class reviews"[ti] OR "cochrane database syst rev"[ta] OR "acp journal club"[ta] OR "health technol assess"[ta] OR "evid rep technol assess summ"[ta] OR "jbi database system rev implement rep"[ta] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + OR + ( + "clinical guideline"[tw] + AND + "management"[tw] + AND + ( + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + OR + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[mhda] + ) + ) + OR + ( + "clinical guideline"[tiab] + AND + "management"[tiab] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + OR + ( + ( + ( + "evidence based"[ti] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + OR + ( + "evidence-based medicine"[mh] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[mhda] + ) + OR + ( + ( + "best practice*"[ti] OR "evidence synthesis"[tiab] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + ) + AND + ( + ( + ( + "review"[pt] OR "evaluation study"[pt] OR "validation study"[pt] OR "guideline"[pt] OR "pmcbook"[all] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + ) + OR + ( + ( + "diseases category"[mh] OR "behavior and behavior mechanisms"[mh] OR "therapeutics"[mh] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[mhda] + ) + ) + ) + OR + ( + ( + ( + ( + "systematic"[tw] OR "systematically"[tw] OR "study selection"[tw] + OR + ( + ( + "predetermined"[tw] OR "inclusion"[tw] + ) + AND + "criteri*"[tw] + ) + OR + "exclusion criteri*"[tw] OR "main outcome measures"[tw] OR "standard of care"[tw] OR "standards of care"[tw] + ) + AND + ( + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + OR + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[mhda] + ) + ) + OR + ( + ( + "systematic"[tiab] OR "systematically"[tiab] OR "study selection"[tiab] + OR + ( + ( + "predetermined"[tiab] OR "inclusion"[tiab] + ) + AND + "criteri*"[tiab] + ) + OR + "exclusion criteri*"[tiab] OR "main outcome measures"[tiab] OR "standard of care"[tiab] OR "standards of care"[tiab] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + OR + ( + "critical"[tiab] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + ) + AND + ( + ( + ( + "survey"[tiab] OR "surveys"[tiab] OR "review"[tiab] OR "reviews"[tiab] OR "analysis"[ti] OR "critique"[tiab] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + OR + ( + ( + "overview*"[tw] OR "search*"[tw] OR "handsearch"[tw] OR "appraisal"[tw] + ) + AND + ( + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + OR + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[mhda] + ) + ) + OR + ( + ( + "overview*"[tiab] OR "search*"[tiab] OR "handsearch"[tiab] OR "appraisal"[tiab] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + OR + ( + ( + ( + "reduction"[tw] + AND + ( + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + OR + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[mhda] + ) + ) + OR + ( + "reduction"[tiab] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + ) + AND + ( + ( + "risk"[mh] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[mhda] + ) + OR + ( + ( + "risk"[tw] + AND + ( + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + OR + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[mhda] + ) + ) + OR + ( + "risk"[tiab] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + ) + ) + AND + ( + ( + ( + "death"[mh] OR "recurrence"[mh] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[mhda] + ) + OR + ( + ( + "death"[all] OR "recurrence"[all] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + ) + ) + ) + ) + AND + ( + ( + ( + "literature"[tiab] OR "articles"[tiab] OR "publications"[tiab] OR "publication"[tiab] OR "bibliography"[tiab] OR "bibliographies"[tiab] OR "published"[tiab] OR "database"[tiab] OR "internet"[tiab] OR "textbooks"[tiab] OR "trials"[tiab] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + OR + ( + ( + "pooled data"[tw] OR "unpublished"[tw] OR "citation"[tw] OR "citations"[tw] OR "references"[tw] OR "scales"[tw] OR "papers"[tw] OR "datasets"[tw] OR "meta analy*"[tw] + ) + AND + ( + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + OR + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[mhda] + ) + ) + OR + ( + ( + "pooled data"[tiab] OR "unpublished"[tiab] OR "citation"[tiab] OR "citations"[tiab] OR "references"[tiab] OR "scales"[tiab] OR "papers"[tiab] OR "datasets"[tiab] OR "meta analy*"[tiab] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + OR + ( + "clinical"[tiab] + AND + "studies"[tiab] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + OR + ( + "treatment outcome"[mh] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[mhda] + ) + OR + ( + "treatment outcome"[tw] + AND + ( + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + OR + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[mhda] + ) + ) + OR + ( + "treatment outcome"[tiab] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[crdt] + ) + OR + ( + "pmcbook"[all] + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + ) + ) + ) + ) + NOT + ( + ( + "letter"[pt] OR "newspaper article"[pt] + ) + AND + 1865/01/01:2020/12/21[dcom] + ) + ) +) AND (2020/12/21:2020/12/21[crdt] OR 2020/12/21:2020/12/21[dcom] OR 2020/12/21:2020/12/21[mhda]) +``` diff --git a/zheln/summary-systematic-set/summary-systematic-set_2020-12-21_696.txt b/zheln/summary-systematic-set/summary-systematic-set_2020-12-21_696.txt new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c35c16924 --- /dev/null +++ b/zheln/summary-systematic-set/summary-systematic-set_2020-12-21_696.txt @@ -0,0 +1,3766 @@ +1: Nujić D, Musić Milanović S, Milas V, Miškulin I, Ivić V, Milas J. Association +between child/adolescent overweight/obesity and conduct disorder: A systematic +review and meta-analysis. Pediatr Obes. 2020 Dec 21:e12742. doi: +10.1111/ijpo.12742. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348469. + +2: Cresp SJ, Lee SF, Moss C. A framework for nurses working in partnership with +substitute decision-makers for people living with advanced dementia: A +discursive paper. J Clin Nurs. 2020 Dec 21. doi: 10.1111/jocn.15618. Epub ahead +of print. PMID: 33348467. + +3: Galderisi A, Bruschettini M, Russo C, Hall R, Trevisanuto D. Continuous +glucose monitoring for the prevention of morbidity and mortality in preterm +infants. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Dec 21;12:CD013309. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD013309.pub2. PMID: 33348448. + +4: Romero SA, Young K, Hickey M, Su HI. Levonorgestrel intrauterine system for +endometrial protection in women with breast cancer on adjuvant tamoxifen. +Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Dec 21;12:CD007245. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD007245.pub4. PMID: 33348436. + +5: Smith V, Devane D, Nichol A, Roche D. Care bundles for improving outcomes in +patients with COVID-19 or related conditions in intensive care - a rapid scoping +review. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Dec 21;12:CD013819. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD013819. PMID: 33348427. + +6: Pahl A, Young L, Buus-Frank ME, Marcellus L, Soll R. Non-pharmacological care +for opioid withdrawal in newborns. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Dec +21;12:CD013217. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013217.pub2. PMID: 33348423. + +7: Dos Santos AP, Cardoso TN, Waisse S, Bonamin LV. Homeopathy in Experimental +Cancer Models: A Systematic Review. Homeopathy. 2020 Dec 21. doi: +10.1055/s-0040-1716369. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348419. + +8: Taksøe-Vester C, Dyre L, Schroll J, Tabor A, Tolsgaard M. Simulation-Based +Ultrasound Training in Obstetrics and Gynecology: A Systematic Review and Meta- +Analysis. Ultraschall Med. 2020 Dec 21. English. doi: 10.1055/a-1300-1680. Epub +ahead of print. PMID: 33348415. + +9: Welle R, Seufferlein T, Kratzer W. Die Forschungssituation der +Abdomensonografie an den deutschen Universitätskliniken. Eine Längsschnittstudie +über 20 Jahre [Current state of research in abdominal ultrasonography at German +university hospitals. A panel study over 20 years]. Z Gastroenterol. 2020 Dec +21. German. doi: 10.1055/a-1332-2589. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348406. + +10: Bernasconi A, Canakoglu A, Masseroli M, Pinoli P, Ceri S. A review on viral +data sources and search systems for perspective mitigation of COVID-19. Brief +Bioinform. 2020 Dec 22:bbaa359. doi: 10.1093/bib/bbaa359. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33348368. + +11: Huang J, Yue N, Wu J, Shi N, Wang Q, Cui T, Zheng M, Sun S, Jin H. Screening +rate and influential factors of lung cancer with low-dose computed tomography in +Asian population: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Public Health (Oxf). +2020 Dec 22:fdaa225. doi: 10.1093/pubmed/fdaa225. Epub ahead of print. PMID: +33348356. + +12: Sun B, Zhang H, Zhang Y, Wu Z, Bao B, Hu Y, Li T. Compressed sensing of +large-scale local field potentials using adaptive sparsity analysis and Non- +convex Optimization. J Neural Eng. 2020 Dec 21. doi: 10.1088/1741-2552/abd578. +Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348334. + +13: Baroni F, Ruffini N, D'Alessandro G, Consorti G, Lunghi C. The role of touch +in osteopathic practice: A narrative review and integrative hypothesis. +Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Dec 1;42:101277. doi: +10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101277. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348305. + +14: Wei XY, Gong QL, Zeng A, Wang W, Wang Q, Zhang XX. Seroprevalence and risk +factors of Toxoplasma gondii infection in goats in China from 2010 to 2020: A +systematic review and meta-analysis. Prev Vet Med. 2020 Dec 5;186:105230. doi: +10.1016/j.prevetmed.2020.105230. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348304. + +15: Nabizadeh-Gharghozar Z, Alavi NM, Ajorpaz NM. Clinical competence in +nursing: A hybrid concept analysis. Nurse Educ Today. 2020 Dec 16;97:104728. +doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2020.104728. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348301. + +16: Guo J, Pei L, Chen L, Chen H, Gu D, Peng Y, Sun J. Bidirectional association +between irritable bowel syndrome and restless legs syndrome: a systematic review +and meta-analysis. Sleep Med. 2020 Dec 4;77:104-111. doi: +10.1016/j.sleep.2020.12.002. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348297. + +17: Anderson A, Hartley S, Bucci S. A Systematic Review of the experimental +induction of auditory perceptual experiences. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry. 2020 +Dec 10;71:101635. doi: 10.1016/j.jbtep.2020.101635. Epub ahead of print. PMID: +33348277. + +18: Khaing K, Nair BR. Melatonin for delirium prevention in hospitalized +patients: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Psychiatr Res. 2020 Dec +13;133:181-190. doi: 10.1016/j.jpsychires.2020.12.020. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33348252. + +19: Badal S, Thapa Bajgain K, Badal S, Thapa R, Bajgain BB, Santana MJ. +Prevalence, clinical characteristics, and outcomes of pediatric COVID-19: A +systematic review and meta-analysis. J Clin Virol. 2020 Dec 8;135:104715. doi: +10.1016/j.jcv.2020.104715. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348220; PMCID: +PMC7723460. + +20: Omraninava M, Mehranfar S, Vahedi P, Razi B, Imani D, Aslani S, Feyzinia S. +Association between IL7 Receptor Alpha (Il7ra) gene rs6897932 polymorphism and +the risk of Multiple Sclerosis: A meta-regression and meta-analysis. Mult Scler +Relat Disord. 2020 Dec 15;48:102687. doi: 10.1016/j.msard.2020.102687. Epub +ahead of print. PMID: 33348212. + +21: Chambergo-Michilot D, Brañez-Condorena A, Falvy-Bockos I, Pacheco-Mendoza J, +Benites-Zapata VA. Efficacy of omega-3 supplementation on sertraline continuous +therapy to reduce depression or anxiety symptoms: A systematic review and meta- +analysis. Psychiatry Res. 2020 Dec 15;296:113652. doi: +10.1016/j.psychres.2020.113652. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348198. + +22: Elkommos S, Mula M. A systematic review of neuroimaging studies of +depression in adults with epilepsy. Epilepsy Behav. 2020 Dec 18;115:107695. doi: +10.1016/j.yebeh.2020.107695. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348194. + +23: Saconi B, Polomano RC, Compton PC, McPhillips MV, Kuna ST, Sawyer AM. The +influence of sleep disturbances and sleep disorders on pain outcomes among +veterans: A systematic scoping review. Sleep Med Rev. 2020 Nov 30;56:101411. +doi: 10.1016/j.smrv.2020.101411. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348172. + +24: Wolfsegger T, Hauser A, Wimmer S, Neuwirth K, Assar H, Topakian R. A +comprehensive clinico-radiological, neuropsychological and biomechanical +analysis approach to patients with idiopathic normal pressure hydrocephalus. +Clin Neurol Neurosurg. 2020 Dec 4;201:106402. doi: +10.1016/j.clineuro.2020.106402. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348122. + +25: Aghdam ZN, Rahmani AM, Hosseinzadeh M. The Role of the Internet of Things in +Healthcare: Future Trends and Challenges. Comput Methods Programs Biomed. 2020 +Dec 13;199:105903. doi: 10.1016/j.cmpb.2020.105903. Epub ahead of print. PMID: +33348073. + +26: Mishima RS, Verdicchio CV, Noubiap JJ, Ariyaratnam JP, Gallagher C, Jones D, +Malik V, Agbaedeng T, Middeldorp ME, Lau DH, Sanders P, Elliott AD. Self- +reported Physical Activity and Atrial Fibrillation Risk: A Systematic Review and +Meta-analysis. Heart Rhythm. 2020 Dec 18:S1547-5271(20)31165-6. doi: +10.1016/j.hrthm.2020.12.017. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348059. + +27: Kaye EC, Weaver MS, DeWitt LH, Byers E, Stevens SE, Lukowski J, Shih B, +Zalud K, Applegarth J, Wong HN, Baker JN, Ullrich CK; AAHPM Research Committee. +The impact of specialty palliative care in pediatric oncology: a systematic +review. J Pain Symptom Manage. 2020 Dec 18:S0885-3924(20)30939-8. doi: +10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2020.12.003. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348034. + +28: Miller KA, Baird J, Lira J, Herrera Eguizabal J, Fei S, Kysh L, Lotstein D. +The use of telemedicine for home-based palliative care for children with serious +illness: a scoping review. J Pain Symptom Manage. 2020 Dec +18:S0885-3924(20)30942-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2020.12.004. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33348029. + +29: Uccella S, Zorzato PC, Kho RM. INCIDENCE AND PREVENTION OF VAGINAL CUFF +DEHISCENCE FOLLOWING LAPAROSCOPIC AND ROBOTIC HYSTERECTOMY: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW +AND META-ANALYSIS. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2020 Dec 18:S1553-4650(20)31190-0. +doi: 10.1016/j.jmig.2020.12.016. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33348012. + +30: Ricci S, Bennett C, Falcone T. Uterine transplantation: evolving data, +success, and clinical importance. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2020 Dec +18:S1553-4650(20)31188-2. doi: 10.1016/j.jmig.2020.12.015. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33348011. + +31: Göbölös L, Rácz I, Hogan M, Remsey-Semmelweis E, Atallah B, AlMahmeed W, +AlSindi F, Suri RM, Bhatnagar G, Tuzcu EM. The role of renin-angiotensin system +activated phagocytes in the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus infection. J Vasc Surg. 2020 +Dec 18:S0741-5214(20)32605-7. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2020.12.056. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33348007; PMCID: PMC7748976. + +32: Noori A, Mezlini AM, Hyman BT, Serrano-Pozo A, Das S. Systematic review and +meta-analysis of human Transcriptomics reveals Neuroinflammation, deficient +energy metabolism, and Proteostasis failure across Neurodegeneration. Neurobiol +Dis. 2020 Dec 18:105225. doi: 10.1016/j.nbd.2020.105225. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33347974. + +33: Li Y, Liang M, Gao L, Ahmed MA, Uy JP, Cheng C, Zhou Q, Sun C. Face masks to +prevent transmission of COVID-19: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J +Infect Control. 2020 Dec 18:S0196-6553(20)31043-9. doi: +10.1016/j.ajic.2020.12.007. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33347937; PMCID: +PMC7748970. + +34: Kirk AG, Behm KJ, Ksimmel LA, Ekegren CL. Levels of physical activity and +sedentary behaviour during and after hospitalisation: a systematic review. Arch +Phys Med Rehabil. 2020 Dec 18:S0003-9993(20)31320-4. doi: +10.1016/j.apmr.2020.11.012. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33347891. + +35: Luo H, Xiao X, Li S, Sun W, Yi Z, Wang P, Zhang Q. Spectrum-frequency and +genotype-phenotype analysis of rhodopsin variants. Exp Eye Res. 2020 Dec +18:108405. doi: 10.1016/j.exer.2020.108405. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33347869. + +36: Sadeghi AH, Mathari SE, Abjigitova D, Maat APWM, Taverne YJHJ, Bogers AJJC, +Mahtab EAF. Current and Future Applications of Virtual, Augmented, and Mixed +Reality in Cardiothoracic Surgery. Ann Thorac Surg. 2020 Dec +18:S0003-4975(20)32127-5. doi: 10.1016/j.athoracsur.2020.11.030. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33347848. + +37: Bardou MLD, Henriques MT, Grumach AS. Inborn errors of immunity associated +with characteristic phenotypesϯ. J Pediatr (Rio J). 2020 Dec +18:S0021-7557(20)30245-X. doi: 10.1016/j.jped.2020.10.015. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33347837. + +38: Jan S, Dar MI, Wani R, Sandey J, Mushtaq I, Lateef S, Syed SH. Targeting +EHMT2/ G9a for cancer therapy: progress and perspective. Eur J Pharmacol. 2020 +Dec 18:173827. doi: 10.1016/j.ejphar.2020.173827. Epub ahead of print. PMID: +33347828. + +39: Morice PM, Leary A, Dolladille C, Chrétien B, Poulain L, González-Martín A, +Moore K, O'Reilly EM, Ray-Coquard I, Alexandre J. Myelodysplastic syndrome and +acute myeloid leukaemia in patients treated with PARP inhibitors: a safety meta- +analysis of randomised controlled trials and a retrospective study of the WHO +pharmacovigilance database. Lancet Haematol. 2020 Dec 18:S2352-3026(20)30360-4. +doi: 10.1016/S2352-3026(20)30360-4. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33347814. + +40: Rausa E, Manfredi R, Kelly ME, Bianco F, Aiolfi A, Bonitta G, Lucianetti A, +Zappa MA. Magnetic Sphincter Augmentation Placement for Recalcitrant +Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease Following Bariatric Procedures: A Systematic +Review and Bayesian Meta-Analysis. J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A. 2020 Dec 21. +doi: 10.1089/lap.2020.0763. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33347784. + +41: Lu B, Zhang X, Wen J. Real World Effectiveness of Information and +Communication Technologies in Disaster Relief: A Systematic Review. Iran J +Public Health. 2020 Oct;49(10):1813-1826. doi: 10.18502/ijph.v49i10.4678. PMID: +33346227; PMCID: PMC7719660. + +42: Shah SS, Gaal BT, Roche AM, Namdari S, Grawe BM, Lawler M, Dalton S, King +JJ, Helmkamp J, Garrigues GE, Wright TW, Schoch BS, Flik K, Otto RJ, Jones R, +Jawa A, McCann P, Abboud J, Horneff G, Ross G, Friedman R, Ricchetti ET, +Boardman D, Tashjian RZ, Gulotta LV. The modern reverse shoulder arthroplasty +and an updated systematic review for each complication: part I. JSES Int. 2020 +Sep 7;4(4):929-943. doi: 10.1016/j.jseint.2020.07.017. PMID: 33345237; PMCID: +PMC7738599. + +43: Matar RN, Shah NS, Gardner TJ, Grawe BM. Return to sport after surgical +treatment for posterior shoulder instability: a systematic review. JSES Int. +2020 Sep 11;4(4):797-802. doi: 10.1016/j.jseint.2020.08.002. PMID: 33345218; +PMCID: PMC7738578. + +44: Scollan JP, Bertsch ML, Flanagan CD, Chughtai M, Chepla KJ, Hoyen HA, Bafus +BT. Acute compartment syndrome of the deltoid: a case report and systematic +review of the literature. JSES Int. 2020 Sep 7;4(4):753-758. doi: +10.1016/j.jseint.2020.07.016. PMID: 33345211; PMCID: PMC7738586. + +45: Narvaez Linares NF, Charron V, Ouimet AJ, Labelle PR, Plamondon H. A +systematic review of the Trier Social Stress Test methodology: Issues in +promoting study comparison and replicable research. Neurobiol Stress. 2020 Jun +15;13:100235. doi: 10.1016/j.ynstr.2020.100235. PMID: 33344691; PMCID: +PMC7739033. + +46: Tafazoli A, Tafazoli Moghadam E. Camellia Sinensis Mouthwashes in Oral Care: +a Systematic Review. J Dent (Shiraz). 2020 Dec;21(4):249-262. doi: +10.30476/DENTJODS.2020.83204.1045. PMID: 33344675; PMCID: PMC7737926. + +47: Romero-Franco N, Ortego-Mate MDC, Molina-Mula J. Knee Kinematics During +Landing: Is It Really a Predictor of Acute Noncontact Knee Injuries in Athletes? +A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Orthop J Sports Med. 2020 Dec +9;8(12):2325967120966952. doi: 10.1177/2325967120966952. PMID: 33344669; PMCID: +PMC7731707. + +48: Dong MX, Chen GH, Hu L. Dopaminergic System Alteration in Anxiety and +Compulsive Disorders: A Systematic Review of Neuroimaging Studies. Front +Neurosci. 2020 Dec 3;14:608520. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2020.608520. PMID: 33343291; +PMCID: PMC7744599. + +49: Romanelli JP, Meli P, Naves RP, Alves MC, Rodrigues RR. Reliability of +evidence-review methods in restoration ecology. Conserv Biol. 2020 Dec 21. doi: +10.1111/cobi.13661. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33347737. + +50: Tan J, Ning T, Zhang W, Qian Z, Jiang X, Sun L, Wu B. Heparin locks with low +and high concentration in haemodialysis patients: A systematic review and meta- +analysis. Int J Nurs Pract. 2020 Dec 21:e12907. doi: 10.1111/ijn.12907. Epub +ahead of print. PMID: 33347670. + +51: Tso LO, Costello MF, Albuquerque LET, Andriolo RB, Macedo CR. Metformin +treatment before and during IVF or ICSI in women with polycystic ovary syndrome. +Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Dec 21;12:CD006105. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD006105.pub4. PMID: 33347618. + +52: Byhamre ML, Araghi M, Alfredsson L, Bellocco R, Engström G, Eriksson M, +Galanti MR, Jansson JH, Lager A, Lundberg M, Östergren PO, Pedersen NL, Trolle +Lagerros Y, Ye W, Wennberg P, Magnusson C. Swedish snus use is associated with +mortality: a pooled analysis of eight prospective studies. Int J Epidemiol. 2020 +Dec 21:dyaa197. doi: 10.1093/ije/dyaa197. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33347584. + +53: Marco-Gardoqui M, Eizaguirre A, García-Feijoo M. The impact of service- +learning methodology on business schools' students worldwide: A systematic +literature review. PLoS One. 2020 Dec 21;15(12):e0244389. doi: +10.1371/journal.pone.0244389. PMID: 33347503. + +54: Bédard A, Lamarche PO, Grégoire LM, Trudel-Guy C, Provencher V, Desroches S, +Lemieux S. Can eating pleasure be a lever for healthy eating? A systematic +scoping review of eating pleasure and its links with dietary behaviors and +health. PLoS One. 2020 Dec 21;15(12):e0244292. doi: +10.1371/journal.pone.0244292. PMID: 33347469. + +55: Bach P, Wallisch C, Klein N, Hafermann L, Sauerbrei W, Steyerberg EW, Heinze +G, Rauch G; for topic group 2 of the STRATOS initiative. Systematic review of +education and practical guidance on regression modeling for medical researchers +who lack a strong statistical background: Study protocol. PLoS One. 2020 Dec +21;15(12):e0241427. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0241427. PMID: 33347441. + +56: Gu Y, Ji Y, Jiang H, Qiu G. Clinical Effect of Driver Mutations of KRAS, +CDKN2A/P16, TP53, and SMAD4 in Pancreatic Cancer: A Meta-Analysis. +Genet Test Mol Biomarkers. 2020 Dec;24(12):777-788. doi: 10.1089/gtmb.2020.0078. +PMID: 33347393. + +57: Gabriel A, Camardo M, O'Rorke E, Gold R, Kim PJ. Effects of Negative- +Pressure Wound Therapy With Instillation versus Standard of Care in Multiple +Wound Types: Systematic Literature Review and Meta-Analysis. Plast Reconstr +Surg. 2021 Jan 1;147(1S-1):68S-76S. doi: 10.1097/PRS.0000000000007614. PMID: +33347065. + +58: Diehm YF, Fischer S, Wirth GA, Haug V, Orgill DP, Momeni A, Horch RE, Lehner +B, Kneser U, Hirche C. Management of Acute and Traumatic Wounds With Negative- +Pressure Wound Therapy With Instillation and Dwell Time. Plast Reconstr Surg. +2021 Jan 1;147(1S-1):43S-53S. doi: 10.1097/PRS.0000000000007610. PMID: 33347062. + +59: Yin LX, Barnes JH, Saoji AA, Carlson ML. Clinical Utility of Intraoperative +Electrocochleography (ECochG) During Cochlear Implantation: A Systematic Review +and Quantitative Analysis. Otol Neurotol. 2020 Dec 17;Publish Ahead of Print. +doi: 10.1097/MAO.0000000000002996. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33347054. + +60: Joseph B, Parsaik AK, Ahmed AT, Erwin PJ, Singh B. A Systematic Review on +the Efficacy of Intravenous Racemic Ketamine for Bipolar Depression. J Clin +Psychopharmacol. 2021 Jan/Feb 01;41(1):71-75. doi: 10.1097/JCP.0000000000001317. +PMID: 33347027. + +61: Hughes LD, Lum J, Mahfoud Z, Malik RA, Anand A, Charalambous CP. Comparison +of Surgical Site Infection Risk Between Warfarin, LMWH, and Aspirin for Venous +Thromboprophylaxis in TKA or THA: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. JBJS +Rev. 2020 Dec 18;8(12):e20.00021. doi: 10.2106/JBJS.RVW.20.00021. PMID: +33347014. + +62: Desiato VM, Byun YJ, Nguyen SA, Thiers BH, Day TA. Sebaceous Carcinoma of +the Eyelid: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Dermatol Surg. 2021 Jan +1;47(1):104-110. doi: 10.1097/DSS.0000000000002660. PMID: 33347004. + +63: Sadowski A, Dunlap C, Lacombe A, Hanes D. Alterations in Heart Rate +Variability Associated With Irritable Bowel Syndrome or Inflammatory Bowel +Disease: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Clin Transl Gastroenterol. 2020 +Dec 18;12(1):e00275. doi: 10.14309/ctg.0000000000000275. PMID: 33346998; PMCID: +PMC7752679. + +64: Navas-Blanco JR, Louro J, Reynolds J, Epstein RH, Dudaryk R. Intraoperative +Focused Cardiac Ultrasound for Assessment of Hypotension: A Systematic Review. +Anesth Analg. 2020 Dec 18. doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000005336. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33346986. + +65: Islam N, Furuya-Kanamori L, Mahmood S, Thalib L. Prophylactic antibiotics +for preventing genital tract infection in women undergoing surgical procedures +for incomplete abortion: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized +controlled trials. BJOG. 2020 Dec 21. doi: 10.1111/1471-0528.16637. Epub ahead +of print. PMID: 33346920. + +66: Lorkowski J, Jugowicz A. Shortage of Physicians: A Critical Review. Adv Exp +Med Biol. 2020 Dec 22. doi: 10.1007/5584_2020_601. Epub ahead of print. PMID: +33346901. + +67: Ippolito S, Cusini C, Lasalvia P, Gianfagna F, Veronesi G, Gallo D, Masiello +E, Premoli P, Sabatino J, Mercuriali A, Lai A, Piantanida E, Tanda ML, Bartalena +L. Change in newly diagnosed Graves' disease phenotype between the twentieth and +the twenty-first centuries: meta-analysis and meta-regression. J Endocrinol +Invest. 2020 Dec 21. doi: 10.1007/s40618-020-01479-z. Epub ahead of print. PMID: +33346898. + +68: Chen LJ, Zhou YJ, Wen ZH, Tian F, Li JY. Efficacy and safety of iguratimod +combined with methotrexate vs. methotrexate alone in rheumatoid arthritis : +A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Z +Rheumatol. 2020 Dec 21. English. doi: 10.1007/s00393-020-00944-7. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33346891. + +69: Aleksovska K, Puggina A, Giraldi L, Buck C, Burns C, Cardon G, Carlin A, +Chantal S, Ciarapica D, Colotto M, Condello G, Coppinger T, Cortis C, D'Haese S, +De Craemer M, Di Blasio A, Hansen S, Iacoviello L, Issartel J, Izzicupo P, +Jaeschke L, Kanning M, Kennedy A, Ling F, Luzak A, Napolitano G, Nazare JA, +Perchoux C, Pischon T, Polito A, Sannella A, Schulz H, Sohun R, Steinbrecher A, +Schlicht W, Ricciardi W, MacDonncha C, Capranica L, Boccia S. Correction to: +Biological determinants of physical activity across the life course: a +"Determinants of Diet and Physical Activity" (DEDIPAC) umbrella systematic +literature review. Sports Med Open. 2020 Dec 21;6(1):60. doi: +10.1186/s40798-020-00291-6. Erratum for: Sports Med Open. 2019 Jan 8;5(1):2. +PMID: 33346880. + +70: Wirries N, Budde S. Der Oberflächenteilersatz an der Hüfte – eine kritische +Analyse [Partial hip resurfacing-a critical analysis]. Orthopade. 2020 Dec 21. +German. doi: 10.1007/s00132-020-04056-7. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33346866. + +71: Hawkridge K, Ahmed I, Ahmed Z. Evidence for the use of spinal collars in +stabilising spinal injuries in the pre-hospital setting in trauma patients: a +systematic review. Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg. 2020 Dec 21. doi: +10.1007/s00068-020-01576-x. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33346863. + +72: Mayakonda A, Schönung M, Hey J, Batra RN, Feuerstein-Akgoz C, Köhler K, +Lipka DB, Sotillo R, Plass C, Lutsik P, Toth R. Methrix: an R/bioconductor +package for systematic aggregation and analysis of bisulfite sequencing data. +Bioinformatics. 2020 Dec 21:btaa1048. doi: 10.1093/bioinformatics/btaa1048. Epub +ahead of print. PMID: 33346800. + +73: Shi M, Gette JA, Gissandaner TD, Cooke JT, Littlefield AK. E-cigarette use +among Asian Americans: a systematic review. J Ethn Subst Abuse. 2020 Dec +21:1-34. doi: 10.1080/15332640.2020.1861495. Epub ahead of print. PMID: +33346722. + +74: González-Castro TB, Tovilla-Zárate CA, López-Narvaez ML, Juárez-Rojop IE, +Calderón-Colmenero J, Sandoval JP, García-Montes JA, Blachman-Braun R, Castillo- +Avila RG, García-Flores E, Cazarín-Santos BG, Borgonio-Cuadra VM, Posadas- +Sánchez R, Vargas-Alarcón G, Rodríguez-Pérez JM, Pérez-Hernández N. Association +between congenital heart disease and NKX2.5 gene polymorphisms: +systematic review and meta-analysis. Biomark Med. 2020 Dec;14(18):1747-1757. +doi: 10.2217/bmm-2020-0190. PMID: 33346701. + +75: Shi J, Shi X, Dai RQ. The prognostic impact of abnormally expressed, long +noncoding RNAs in acute myeloid leukemia: a meta-analysis. Hematology. 2020 +Dec;25(1):219-228. doi: 10.1080/16078454.2020.1779480. PMID: 33346694. + +76: Bolia R, Goel A, Srivastava A. Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of +Thiopurine Metabolite Levels and Biochemical Remission in Autoimmune Hepatitis. +Ther Drug Monit. 2020 Dec 17;Publish Ahead of Print. doi: +10.1097/FTD.0000000000000848. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33346628. + +77: Kim YI. Salvage peptide receptor radionuclide therapy in patients with +progressive neuroendocrine tumors: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Nucl +Med Commun. 2020 Dec 18;Publish Ahead of Print. doi: +10.1097/MNM.0000000000001350. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33346603. + +78: Uhlig HH, Charbit-Henrion F, Kotlarz D, Shouval DS, Schwerd T, Strisciuglio +C, de Ridder L, van Limbergen J, Macchi M, Snapper SB, Ruemmele FM, Wilson DC, +Travis SPL, Griffiths AM, Turner D, Klein C, Muise AM, Russell RK; Paediatric +IBD Porto group of ESPGHAN. Clinical Genomics for the Diagnosis of Monogenic +forms of Inflammatory Bowel Disease: A Position Paper from The Paediatric IBD +Porto Group of ESPGHAN. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr. 2020 Dec 16;Publish Ahead +of Print. doi: 10.1097/MPG.0000000000003017. Epub ahead of print. PMID: +33346580. + +79: Lin Y, Yang Y, Zhang X, Li W, Li H, Mu D. Postoperative Health-related +Quality of Life in Reduction Mammaplasty: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. +Ann Plast Surg. 2020 Dec 15;Publish Ahead of Print. doi: +10.1097/SAP.0000000000002609. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33346564. + +80: Lai YW, Huang SH, Lee Y, Chen FM, Lai CS. Personal Approach to Optimizing +Inframammary Fold Incision for Asian Augmentation Mammoplasty. Ann Plast Surg. +2020 Dec 15;Publish Ahead of Print. doi: 10.1097/SAP.0000000000002616. Epub +ahead of print. PMID: 33346556. + +81: Parmeshwar N, Sultan SM, Kim EA, Piper ML. A Systematic Review of the +Utility of Indocyanine Angiography in Autologous Breast Reconstruction. Ann +Plast Surg. 2020 Dec 15;Publish Ahead of Print. doi: +10.1097/SAP.0000000000002576. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33346549. + +82: Hauch A, McKee R, Li WY, Crowley JS, Ramamoorthy S, Dobke M. Rectovaginal +Fistula Repair 1 Year Later: Lessons Learned. Ann Plast Surg. 2020 Dec +15;Publish Ahead of Print. doi: 10.1097/SAP.0000000000002626. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33346534. + +83: Sridharan K, Sivaramakrishnan G. A network meta-analysis of CYP2C9, CYP2C9 +with VKORC1 and CYP2C9 with VKORC1 and CYP4F2 genotype-based warfarin dosing +strategies compared to traditional. J Clin Pharm Ther. 2020 Dec 21. doi: +10.1111/jcpt.13334. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33346393. + +84: Coyle M, Sandover S, Poobalan A, Bullen J, Cleland J. Meritocratic and Fair? +The discourse of UK and Australia's widening participation policies. Med Educ. +2020 Dec 21. doi: 10.1111/medu.14442. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33346380. + +85: McLaughlin JM, Khan F, Schmitt HJ, Agosti Y, Jodar L, Simões EAF, Swerdlow +DL. Respiratory Syncytial Virus-Associated Hospitalization Rates among US +Infants: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Infect Dis. 2020 Dec +21:jiaa752. doi: 10.1093/infdis/jiaa752. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33346360. + +86: Contreras Jofre P, Valenzuela Solís Á, Pinto Soto J, Mendoza Ponce N, López- +Alegría F. Violencia en el trabajo hacia los profesionales de enfermería en los +servicios de emergencias: revisión integrativa [Workplace violence against +emergency service nurses: an integrative reviewViolência no trabalho contra os +profissionais de enfermagem em serviços de emergência: revisão integrativa]. Rev +Panam Salud Publica. 2020 Dec 17;44:e173. Spanish. doi: 10.26633/RPSP.2020.173. +PMID: 33346247; PMCID: PMC7745999. + +87: Bizhani N, Hashemi Hafshejani S, Mohammadi N, Rezaei M, Rokni MB. Human +Cysticercosis in Asia: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Iran J Public +Health. 2020 Oct;49(10):1839-1847. doi: 10.18502/ijph.v49i10.4683. PMID: +33346233; PMCID: PMC7719645. + +88: Sobhani SR, Babashahi M. Determinants of Household Food Basket Composition: +A Systematic Review. Iran J Public Health. 2020 Oct;49(10):1827-1838. doi: +10.18502/ijph.v49i10.4681. PMID: 33346207; PMCID: PMC7719639. + +89: Varkaneh HK, Rinaldi G, Hekmatdoost A, Fatahi S, Tan SC, Shadnoush M, Khni +V, Mousavi SM, Zarezadeh M, Salamat S, Bawadi H, Rahmani J. Reply to "Double- +counting of effect sizes and inappropriate exclusion of studies in "The +influence of vitamin D supplementation on IGF-1 levels in humans: A systematic +review and meta_analysis". Ageing Res Rev. 2020 Dec 17:101239. doi: +10.1016/j.arr.2020.101239. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33346153. + +90: Michener CM, Lampert E, Yao M, Harnegie MP, Chalif J, Chambers LM. Meta- +analysis of laparo-endoscopic single site and vaginal natural orifice +transluminal endoscopic hysterectomy compared to multi-port hysterectomy: real +benefits or diminishing returns? J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2020 Dec +17:S1553-4650(20)31189-4. doi: 10.1016/j.jmig.2020.11.029. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33346073. + +91: Loggini A, Tangonan R, El Ammar F, Mansour A, Kramer CL, Lazaridis C, +Goldenberg FD. Neuroendocrine dysfunction in the acute setting of penetrating +brain injury: a systematic review. World Neurosurg. 2020 Dec +17:S1878-8750(20)32624-3. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2020.12.058. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33346052. + +92: Al-Hafez L, Chauhan SP, Riegel M, Balogun OA, Hammad IA, Berghella V. +Routine third-trimester ultrasound in low-risk pregnancies and perinatal death: +a systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 +Nov;2(4):100242. doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100242. Epub 2020 Oct 3. PMID: +33345941. + +93: O'Shea LE, Lord J, Fletcher J, Hasler E, Cameron S. Cervical priming before +surgical abortion up to 13+6 weeks' gestation: a systematic review +and metaanalyses for the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence-new +clinical guidelines for England. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 Nov;2(4):100220. +doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100220. Epub 2020 Sep 2. PMID: 33345928. + +94: Blankenship SA, Brown KE, Simon LE, Stout MJ, Tuuli MG. Antenatal +corticosteroids in preterm small-for-gestational age infants: a systematic +review and meta-analysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 Nov;2(4):100215. doi: +10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100215. Epub 2020 Aug 17. PMID: 33345924. + +95: Bennett C, Chambers LM, Al-Hafez L, Michener CM, Falcone T, Yao M, Berghella +V. Retracted articles in the obstetrics literature: lessons from the past to +change the future. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 Nov;2(4):100201. doi: +10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100201. Epub 2020 Aug 19. PMID: 33345918. + +96: Schuster HJ, de Jonghe BA, Limpens J, Budding AE, Painter RC. Asymptomatic +vaginal Candida colonization and adverse pregnancy outcomes including preterm +birth: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 +Aug;2(3):100163. doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100163. Epub 2020 Jun 23. PMID: +33345884. + +97: Pavalagantharajah S, Villani LA, D'Souza R. Vasa previa and associated risk +factors: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 +Aug;2(3):100117. doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100117. Epub 2020 Apr 15. PMID: +33345868. + +98: Villani LA, Pavalagantharajah S, D'Souza R. Variations in reported outcomes +in studies on vasa previa: a systematic review. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 +Aug;2(3):100116. doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100116. Epub 2020 Apr 16. PMID: +33345867. + +99: Link HM, Jones H, Miller L, Kaltenbach K, Seligman N. Buprenorphine-naloxone +use in pregnancy: a systematic review and metaanalysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. +2020 Aug;2(3):100179. doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100179. Epub 2020 Jul 3. PMID: +33345863. + +100: Park K, Gupta NK, Olweny EO, Schlesinger N. BEYOND ARTHRITIS: UNDERSTANDING +THE INFLUENCE OF GOUT ON ERECTILE FUNCTION: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW. Urology. 2020 +Dec 17:S0090-4295(20)31492-8. doi: 10.1016/j.urology.2020.12.005. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33345860. + +101: Kim SW, Nasioudis D, Levine LD. Role of early amniotomy with induced labor: +a systematic review of literature and meta-analysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. +2019 Nov;1(4):100052. doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2019.100052. Epub 2019 Sep 28. PMID: +33345842. + +102: Higgins MF, Pollard L, McGuinness SK, Kingdom JC. Fetal heart rate +monitoring in nonobstetric surgery: a systematic review of the evidence. Am J +Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2019 Nov;1(4):100048. doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2019.100048. +Epub 2019 Sep 27. PMID: 33345838. + +103: D'Souza R, Horyn I, Pavalagantharajah S, Zaffar N, Jacob CE. Maternal body +mass index and pregnancy outcomes: a systematic review and metaanalysis. Am J +Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2019 Nov;1(4):100041. doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2019.100041. +Epub 2019 Aug 30. PMID: 33345836. + +104: Ciriaco P, Muriana P, Lembo R, Carretta A, Negri G. Treatment of Thoracic +Endometriosis Syndrome: A Meta-analysis and Review. Ann Thorac Surg. 2020 Dec +17:S0003-4975(20)32117-2. doi: 10.1016/j.athoracsur.2020.09.064. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33345783. + +105: Liu B, Yu M, Chen J, Li W. The HIV prevalence in older men who have sex +with men in Western & Central Europe and North America-a meta-analysis. Int J +STD AIDS. 2020 Dec 20:956462420967576. doi: 10.1177/0956462420967576. Epub ahead +of print. PMID: 33345748. + +106: Green JE, Davis JA, Berk M, Hair C, Loughman A, Castle D, Athan E, +Nierenberg AA, Cryan JF, Jacka F, Marx W. Efficacy and safety of fecal +microbiota transplantation for the treatment of diseases other than +Clostridium difficile infection: a systematic review and meta-analysis. +Gut Microbes. 2020 Nov 9;12(1):1-25. doi: 10.1080/19490976.2020.1854640. PMID: +33345703. + +107: Stagg K. Intravenous versus oral paracetamol for postoperative analgesia: A +systematic review. J Perioper Pract. 2020 Dec 20:1750458920950652. doi: +10.1177/1750458920950652. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33345698. + +108: Illingworth BJ, Lewis DJ, Lambarth AT, Stocking K, Duffy JM, Jelen LA, +Rucker JJ. A comparison of MDMA-assisted psychotherapy to non-assisted +psychotherapy in treatment-resistant PTSD: A systematic review and meta- +analysis. J Psychopharmacol. 2020 Dec 20:269881120965915. doi: +10.1177/0269881120965915. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33345689. + +109: Zelig R, Goldstein S, Touger-Decker R, Firestone E, Golden A, Johnson Z, +Kaseta A, Sackey J, Tomesko J, Parrott JS. Tooth Loss and Nutritional Status in +Older Adults: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. JDR Clin Trans Res. 2020 +Dec 21:2380084420981016. doi: 10.1177/2380084420981016. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33345687. + +110: Herman JP, Nawreen N, Smail MA, Cotella EM. Brain mechanisms of HPA axis +regulation: neurocircuitry and feedback in context Richard Kvetnansky lecture. +Stress. 2020 Dec 21:1-16. doi: 10.1080/10253890.2020.1859475. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33345670. + +111: Di Tucci C, Galati G, Mattei G, Bonanni V, Capri O, D'Amelio R, Muzii L, +Benedetti Panici P. The role of alpha lipoic acid in female and male +infertility: a systematic review. Gynecol Endocrinol. 2020 Dec 21:1-9. doi: +10.1080/09513590.2020.1843619. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33345661. + +112: Sebastian NA, Spence AR, Bouhadoun S, Abenhaim HA. Extracorporeal membrane +oxygenation in pregnant and postpartum patients: a systematic review. J Matern +Fetal Neonatal Med. 2020 Dec 20:1-11. doi: 10.1080/14767058.2020.1860932. Epub +ahead of print. PMID: 33345652. + +113: Bellera CL, Llanos M, Gantner ME, Rodriguez S, Gavernet L, Comini M, Talevi +A. Can drug repurposing strategies be the solution to the COVID-19 crisis? +Expert Opin Drug Discov. 2020 Dec 23:1-8. doi: 10.1080/17460441.2021.1863943. +Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33345645. + +114: Nussbaum ES, Mikoff N, Paranjape GS. Cognitive deficits among patients +surviving aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage. A contemporary systematic review. +Br J Neurosurg. 2020 Dec 21:1-18. doi: 10.1080/02688697.2020.1859462. Epub ahead +of print. PMID: 33345644. + +115: Bastos RM, Carvalho Júnior JG, Silva SAMD, Campos SF, Rosa MV, Prianti BM. +Answer letter for: "Now you see it - Now you don't: A letter to the editor +concerning "Surgery is no more effective than conservative treatment for +femoroacetabular impingement syndrome: Systematic review and meta-analysis of +randomized controlled trials". Clin Rehabil. 2020 Dec 21:269215520981605. doi: +10.1177/0269215520981605. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33345596. + +116: Gogna S, Samson D, Choi J, Con J, Prabhakaran K, Rhee P, Latifi R. The Role +of Nutritional Access in Malnourished Elderly Undergoing Major Surgery for Acute +Abdomen: A Propensity Score-Matched Analysis. Am Surg. 2020 Dec +19:3134820973719. doi: 10.1177/0003134820973719. Epub ahead of print. PMID: +33345560. + +117: Woodis CB, Ghassemi E, McLendon AN. Bioidentical Oral 17β-Estradiol and +Progesterone for the Treatment of Moderate to Severe Vasomotor Symptoms of +Menopause. Ann Pharmacother. 2020 Dec 21:1060028020982611. doi: +10.1177/1060028020982611. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33345556. + +118: Huang X, Xue J, Gao M, Qin Q, Ma T, Li X, Wang H. Medical Management of +Inoperable Malignant Bowel Obstruction. Ann Pharmacother. 2020 Dec +21:1060028020979773. doi: 10.1177/1060028020979773. Epub ahead of print. PMID: +33345552. + +119: Lee YC, Fang TJ, Kuo IC, Tsai YT, Hsin LJ. Stapler Closure versus Manual +Closure in Total Laryngectomy for Laryngeal Cancer: A Systematic Review and +Meta-Analysis. Clin Otolaryngol. 2020 Dec 21. doi: 10.1111/coa.13702. Epub ahead +of print. PMID: 33345446. + +120: Melazzini L, Vitali P, Olivieri E, Bolchini M, Zanardo M, Savoldi F, Di Leo +G, Griffanti L, Baselli G, Sardanelli F, Codari M. White Matter Hyperintensities +Quantification in Healthy Adults: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Magn +Reson Imaging. 2020 Dec 20. doi: 10.1002/jmri.27479. Epub ahead of print. PMID: +33345393. + +121: McKinney A, Fitzsimons D, Blackwood B, McGaughey J. Patient and family +involvement in escalating concerns about clinical deterioration in acute adult +wards: A qualitative systematic review. Nurs Crit Care. 2020 Dec 20. doi: +10.1111/nicc.12582. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33345386. + +122: Bowie J, Brunckhorst O, Stewart R, Dasgupta P, Ahmed K. A systematic review +of tools used to assess body image, masculinity and self-esteem in men with +prostate cancer. Psychooncology. 2020 Nov;29(11):1761-1771. doi: +10.1002/pon.5518. Epub 2020 Sep 1. PMID: 33345371. + +123: Finlay J, Dela Cruz AM, Lind C. Concept analysis: Resilience in young women +with chronic pain. Nurs Forum. 2020 Dec 20. doi: 10.1111/nuf.12543. Epub ahead +of print. PMID: 33345367. + +124: Kostopoulou E, Dastamani A, Güemes M, Clement E, Caiulo S, Shanmugananda P, +Dattani M, Gilbert C, Hurst JA, Shah P. Syndromic Forms of Hyperinsulinaemic +Hypoglycaemia A 15-year follow-up Study. Clin Endocrinol (Oxf). 2020 Dec 20. +doi: 10.1111/cen.14393. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33345357. + +125: Yang Y, Liu J, Yang K, Ma Y, Fu S, Tang X, Wang Y, Zhou L. Endocrine +Adverse Events Caused By Different Types and Different Doses of Immune +Checkpoint Inhibitors in the Treatment of solid Tumors: A Meta-Analysis and +Systematic Review. J Clin Pharmacol. 2020 Dec 20. doi: 10.1002/jcph.1804. Epub +ahead of print. PMID: 33345342. + +126: Dragičević P, Bielen A, Petrić I, Hudina S. Microbial pathogens of +freshwater crayfish: A critical review and systematization of the existing data +with directions for future research. J Fish Dis. 2020 Dec 20. doi: +10.1111/jfd.13314. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33345337. + +127: Fleming C, Le Brocque R, Healy K. How are families included in the +treatment of adults affected by eating disorders? A scoping review. Int J Eat +Disord. 2020 Dec 20. doi: 10.1002/eat.23441. Epub ahead of print. PMID: +33345319. + +128: van Hoorn JF, Schoemaker MM, Stuive I, Dijkstra PU, Rodrigues Trigo Pereira +F, van der Sluis CK, Hadders-Algra M. Risk factors in early life for +developmental coordination disorder: a scoping review. Dev Med Child Neurol. +2020 Dec 20. doi: 10.1111/dmcn.14781. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33345317. + +129: Mosher A, Fraser-Thomas J, Baker J. What Defines Early Specialization: A +Systematic Review of Literature. Front Sports Act Living. 2020 Oct 27;2:596229. +doi: 10.3389/fspor.2020.596229. PMID: 33345176; PMCID: PMC7739675. + +130: Marzi I, Emmerling S, Demetriou Y, Bucksch J, Schulze C, Brindley C, +Reimers AK. Interventions Aiming to Promote Active Commuting in Children and +Adolescents: An Evaluation From a Sex/Gender Perspective. Front Sports Act +Living. 2020 Nov 26;2:590857. doi: 10.3389/fspor.2020.590857. PMID: 33345167; +PMCID: PMC7739596. + +131: Geurin AN, Naraine ML. 20 Years of Olympic Media Research: Trends and +Future Directions. Front Sports Act Living. 2020 Sep 29;2:572495. doi: +10.3389/fspor.2020.572495. PMID: 33345133; PMCID: PMC7739588. + +132: Altan E, Seide S, Bayram I, Gizzi L, Ertan H, Röhrle O. A Systematic Review +and Meta-Analysis on the Longitudinal Effects of Unilateral Knee Extension +Exercise on Muscle Strength. Front Sports Act Living. 2020 Nov 16;2:518148. doi: +10.3389/fspor.2020.518148. PMID: 33345109; PMCID: PMC7739592. + +133: Stuart S, Parrington L, Martini D, Peterka R, Chesnutt J, King L. The +Measurement of Eye Movements in Mild Traumatic Brain Injury: A Structured Review +of an Emerging Area. Front Sports Act Living. 2020 Jan 28;2:5. doi: +10.3389/fspor.2020.00005. PMID: 33345000; PMCID: PMC7739790. + +134: Conforti F, Pala L, Bagnardi V, Specchia C, Oriecuia C, Marra A, Zagami P, +Morganti S, Tarantino P, Catania C, De Marinis F, Queirolo P, De Pas T. EGFR-TKI +Plus Anti-Angiogenic Drugs in EGFR-Mutated Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer: A Meta- +Analysis of Randomized Clinical Trials. JNCI Cancer Spectr. 2020 Jul +29;4(6):pkaa064. doi: 10.1093/jncics/pkaa064. PMID: 33344882; PMCID: PMC7737478. + +135: Muneer R, Hashmet MR, Pourafshary P. Fine Migration Control in Sandstones: +Surface Force Analysis and Application of DLVO Theory. ACS Omega. 2020 Dec +2;5(49):31624-31639. doi: 10.1021/acsomega.0c03943. PMID: 33344814; PMCID: +PMC7745222. + +136: Barek MA, Aziz MA, Islam MS. Impact of age, sex, comorbidities and clinical +symptoms on the severity of COVID-19 cases: A meta-analysis with 55 studies and +10014 cases. Heliyon. 2020 Dec;6(12):e05684. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2020.e05684. +Epub 2020 Dec 15. PMID: 33344791; PMCID: PMC7737518. + +137: Hughes RC, Kitsao-Wekulo P, Bhopal S, Kimani-Murage EW, Hill Z, Kirkwood +BR. Nairobi Early Childcare in Slums (NECS) Study Protocol: a mixed-methods +exploration of paid early childcare in Mukuru slum, Nairobi. BMJ Paediatr Open. +2020 Dec 3;4(1):e000822. doi: 10.1136/bmjpo-2020-000822. PMID: 33344785; PMCID: +PMC7716665. + +138: Rumbut J, Fang H, Wang H. Topic modeling for systematic review of visual +analytics in incomplete longitudinal behavioral trial data. Smart Health (Amst). +2020 Nov;18:100142. doi: 10.1016/j.smhl.2020.100142. Epub 2020 Nov 13. PMID: +33344744; PMCID: PMC7745978. + +139: Ma F, Fan Y, Zhang L, Zhao Z, Nie Y, Chen M, Wang C. Roux-en-Y and Billroth +II Reconstruction after Pancreaticoduodenectomy: A Meta-Analysis of +Complications. Biomed Res Int. 2020 Dec 3;2020:6131968. doi: +10.1155/2020/6131968. PMID: 33344644; PMCID: PMC7732384. + +140: Liu G, Deng Y, Zhang S, Lin T, Guo H. Robot-Assisted versus Conventional +Open Kidney Transplantation: A Meta-Analysis. Biomed Res Int. 2020 Dec +3;2020:2358028. doi: 10.1155/2020/2358028. PMID: 33344632; PMCID: PMC7732374. + +141: Pang QL, He WC, Li JX, Huang L. Symptomatic and optimal supportive care of +critical COVID-19: A case report and literature review. World J Clin Cases. 2020 +Dec 6;8(23):6181-6189. doi: 10.12998/wjcc.v8.i23.6181. PMID: 33344621; PMCID: +PMC7723689. + +142: Li J, Chen M, Wang ZJ, Li SG, Jiang M, Shi L, Cao CL, Sang T, Cui XW, +Dietrich CF. Interobserver agreement for contrast-enhanced ultrasound of liver +imaging reporting and data system: A systematic review and meta-analysis. World +J Clin Cases. 2020 Nov 26;8(22):5589-5602. doi: 10.12998/wjcc.v8.i22.5589. PMID: +33344549; PMCID: PMC7716336. + +143: Fausak ED. A Mapping Study of Veterinary Literature on Perceptions and +Attitudes of Female Canine Spaying. Front Vet Sci. 2020 Dec 4;7:559659. doi: +10.3389/fvets.2020.559659. PMID: 33344522; PMCID: PMC7746841. + +144: He R, Wang L, Li J, Ma L, Wang F, Wang Y. Integrated Analysis of a +Competing Endogenous RNA Network Reveals a Prognostic Signature in Kidney Renal +Papillary Cell Carcinoma. Front Cell Dev Biol. 2020 Dec 3;8:612924. doi: +10.3389/fcell.2020.612924. PMID: 33344459; PMCID: PMC7744790. + +145: Chinen K. Sudden death caused by Clostridium perfringens sepsis +presenting as massive intravascular hemolysis. Autops Case Rep. 2020 Jul +30;10(3):e2020185. doi: 10.4322/acr.2020.185. PMID: 33344302; PMCID: PMC7703123. + +146: Sokol-Borrelli SL, Coombs RS, Boyle JP. A Comparison of Stage Conversion in +the Coccidian Apicomplexans Toxoplasma gondii, Hammondia hammondi, +and Neospora caninum. Front Cell Infect Microbiol. 2020 Dec 3;10:608283. +doi: 10.3389/fcimb.2020.608283. PMID: 33344268; PMCID: PMC7744739. + +147: Zheng Q, Li J, Zhang H, Wang Y, Zhang S. Immune Checkpoint Inhibitors in +Advanced Acral Melanoma: A Systematic Review. Front Oncol. 2020 Dec 3;10:602705. +doi: 10.3389/fonc.2020.602705. PMID: 33344255; PMCID: PMC7744720. + +148: Peng L, Li J, Meng C, Li J, Tang D, Guan F, Xu P, Wei T, Li Y. Diagnostic +Value of Telomerase Activity in Patients With Bladder Cancer: A Meta-Analysis of +Diagnostic Test. Front Oncol. 2020 Dec 3;10:570127. doi: +10.3389/fonc.2020.570127. PMID: 33344230; PMCID: PMC7744937. + +149: Cheng G, Li M, Ma X, Nan F, Zhang L, Yan Z, Li H, Zhang G, Han Y, Xie L, +Guo X. Systematic Analysis of microRNA Biomarkers for Diagnosis, Prognosis, and +Therapy in Patients With Clear Cell Renal Cell Carcinoma. Front Oncol. 2020 Dec +4;10:543817. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2020.543817. PMID: 33344224; PMCID: PMC7746831. + +150: Saeid Y, Salaree MM, Ebadi A, Moradian ST. Family Intensive Care Unit +Syndrome: An Integrative Review. Iran J Nurs Midwifery Res. 2020 Sep +1;25(5):361-368. doi: 10.4103/ijnmr.IJNMR_243_19. PMID: 33344205; PMCID: +PMC7737832. + +151: Caruso G, Scopelliti A, Scaramuzzino S, Perrone G, Galoppi P, Palaia I, +Muzii L, Panici PB, Brunelli R. Cabergoline as an adjuvant to standard heart +failure treatment in peripartum cardiomyopathy: A case report and review of the +literature. Case Rep Womens Health. 2020 Dec 7;29:e00277. doi: +10.1016/j.crwh.2020.e00277. PMID: 33344177; PMCID: PMC7736906. + +152: Choudhary N, Sarode GS, Yuwanati M, Maniyar N, Sarode SC, Gadbail AR, +Gondivkar S, Patil S. Tumor associated tissue eosinophilia in oral squamous cell +carcinoma: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Oral Biol Craniofac Res. +2021 Jan-Mar;11(1):33-39. doi: 10.1016/j.jobcr.2020.11.012. Epub 2020 Nov 23. +PMID: 33344159; PMCID: PMC7736986. + +153: Patil S, Hedad IA, Jafer AA, Abutaleb GK, Arishi TM, Arishi SA, Arishi HA, +Jafer M, Gujar AN, Khan S, Raj AT. Effectiveness of mobile phone applications in +improving oral hygiene care and outcomes in orthodontic patients. J Oral Biol +Craniofac Res. 2021 Jan-Mar;11(1):26-32. doi: 10.1016/j.jobcr.2020.11.004. Epub +2020 Nov 17. PMID: 33344158; PMCID: PMC7736984. + +154: Werneck AO, Winpenny EM, Foubister C, Guagliano JM, Monnickendam AG, van +Sluijs EMF, Corder K. Cohabitation and marriage during the transition between +adolescence and emerging adulthood: A systematic review of changes in weight- +related outcomes, diet and physical activity. Prev Med Rep. 2020 Nov +28;20:101261. doi: 10.1016/j.pmedr.2020.101261. PMID: 33344148; PMCID: +PMC7736988. + +155: Almeida GJ, Khoja SS, Zelle BA. Effect of prehabilitation in older adults +undergoing total joint replacement: An Overview of Systematic Reviews. Curr +Geriatr Rep. 2020 Dec;9(4):280-287. doi: 10.1007/s13670-020-00342-6. Epub 2020 +Nov 24. PMID: 33344110; PMCID: PMC7745772. + +156: Gerlach LB, Kales HC. Pharmacological Management of Neuropsychiatric +Symptoms of Dementia. Curr Treat Options Psychiatry. 2020 Dec;7(4):489-507. doi: +10.1007/s40501-020-00233-9. Epub 2020 Sep 2. PMID: 33344107; PMCID: PMC7742723. + +157: Morales AM, Jones SA, Kliamovich D, Harman G, Nagel BJ. Identifying Early +Risk Factors for Addiction Later in Life: A Review of Prospective Longitudinal +Studies. Curr Addict Rep. 2020 Mar;7(1):89-98. doi: 10.1007/s40429-019-00282-y. +Epub 2019 Dec 12. PMID: 33344103; PMCID: PMC7747788. + +158: Finch AJ, Jurinsky J, Anderson BM. Recovery and Youth: An Integrative +Review. Alcohol Res. 2020 Dec 17;40(3):06. doi: 10.35946/arcr.v40.3.06. PMID: +33344101; PMCID: PMC7732345. + +159: Demrozi F, Pravadelli G, Bihorac A, Rashidi P. Human Activity Recognition +using Inertial, Physiological and Environmental Sensors: A Comprehensive Survey. +IEEE Access. 2020;8:210816-210836. doi: 10.1109/access.2020.3037715. Epub 2020 +Nov 16. PMID: 33344100; PMCID: PMC7748247. + +160: Cuenca-Martínez F, Zapardiel-Sánchez E, Carrasco-González E, La Touche R, +Suso-Martí L. Assessing anxiety, depression and quality of life in patients with +peripheral facial palsy: a systematic review. PeerJ. 2020 Dec 1;8:e10449. doi: +10.7717/peerj.10449. PMID: 33344085; PMCID: PMC7718791. + +161: Huang Q, Xiong H, Shuai T, Zhang M, Zhang C, Wang Y, Zhu L, Lu J, Liu J. +Risk factors for new-onset atrial fibrillation in patients with chronic +obstructive pulmonary disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PeerJ. +2020 Dec 2;8:e10376. doi: 10.7717/peerj.10376. PMID: 33344074; PMCID: +PMC7718784. + +162: Charles D, White R, Reyes C, Palmer D. A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF THE EFFECTS +OF BLOOD FLOW RESTRICTION TRAINING ON QUADRICEPS MUSCLE ATROPHY AND +CIRCUMFERENCE POST ACL RECONSTRUCTION. Int J Sports Phys Ther. 2020 +Dec;15(6):882-891. doi: 10.26603/ijspt20200882. PMID: 33344004; PMCID: +PMC7727417. + +163: Moore D, Semciw AI, Pizzari T. A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND META-ANALYSIS OF +COMMON THERAPEUTIC EXERCISES THAT GENERATE HIGHEST MUSCLE ACTIVITY IN THE +GLUTEUS MEDIUS AND GLUTEUS MINIMUS SEGMENTS. Int J Sports Phys Ther. 2020 +Dec;15(6):856-881. doi: 10.26603/ijspt20200856. PMID: 33344003; PMCID: +PMC7727410. + +164: Ness BM, Zimney K, Schweinle WE, Cleland JA. DUAL-TASK ASSESSMENT +IMPLICATIONS FOR ANTERIOR CRUCIATE LIGAMENT INJURY: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW. Int J +Sports Phys Ther. 2020 Dec;15(6):840-855. doi: 10.26603/ijspt20200840. PMID: +33344002; PMCID: PMC7727432. + +165: Cao Z, Yang Z, Liang Z, Cen Q, Zhang Z, Liang H, Liu R, Zeng L, Xie Y, Wang +Y. Prone versus Supine Position Ventilation in Adult Patients with Acute +Respiratory Distress Syndrome: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. +Emerg Med Int. 2020 Nov 30;2020:4973878. doi: 10.1155/2020/4973878. PMID: +33343939; PMCID: PMC7732410. + +166: Dolan J, Mandras S, Mehta JP, Navas V, Tarver J, Chakinala M, Rahaghi F. +Reducing rates of readmission and development of an outpatient management plan +in pulmonary hypertension: lessons from congestive heart failure management. +Pulm Circ. 2020 Dec 7;10(4):2045894020968471. doi: 10.1177/2045894020968471. +PMID: 33343880; PMCID: PMC7727062. + +167: Kürzinger ML, Douarin L, Uzun I, El-Haddad C, Hurst W, Juhaeri J, Tcherny- +Lessenot S. Structured benefit-risk evaluation for medicinal products: review of +quantitative benefit-risk assessment findings in the literature. Ther Adv Drug +Saf. 2020 Dec 8;11:2042098620976951. doi: 10.1177/2042098620976951. PMID: +33343857; PMCID: PMC7727082. + +168: Velickovic VM, McIlwaine E, Zhang R, Spelman T. Adverse events in second- +and third-line treatments for acute and chronic graft-versus-host +disease: systematic review. Ther Adv Hematol. 2020 Dec 8;11:2040620720977039. +doi: 10.1177/2040620720977039. PMID: 33343855; PMCID: PMC7727084. + +169: Toumi M, Biernikiewicz M, Liang S, Wang Y, Qiu T, Han R. A critical +analysis and review of Lancet COVID-19 hydroxychloroquine study. J Mark Access +Health Policy. 2020 Sep 10;8(1):1809236. doi: 10.1080/20016689.2020.1809236. +PMID: 33343837; PMCID: PMC7733902. + +170: Salas RL, Eslava-Schmalbach J, Vaca-González C, Rodríguez D, Figueras A. +Development of a stepwise tool to aide primary health care professionals in the +process of deprescribing in older persons. Pharm Pract (Granada). 2020 Oct- +Dec;18(4):2033. doi: 10.18549/PharmPract.2020.4.2033. Epub 2020 Dec 4. PMID: +33343769; PMCID: PMC7732213. + +171: Almoajil H, Theologis T, Dawes H, Parsonage J, Pierce J, Hopewell S, Toye +F. Patients' and parents' views about lower limb orthopaedic surgery for +ambulant children and young people with cerebral palsy: a qualitative evidence +synthesis. J Child Orthop. 2020 Dec 1;14(6):562-573. doi: +10.1302/1863-2548.14.200139. PMID: 33343752; PMCID: PMC7740689. + +172: Landre T, Chouahnia K, Des Guetz G, Duchemann B, Assié JB, Chouaïd C. +First-line immune-checkpoint inhibitor plus chemotherapy versus +chemotherapy alone for extensive-stage small-cell lung cancer: a meta-analysis. +Ther Adv Med Oncol. 2020 Dec 9;12:1758835920977137. doi: +10.1177/1758835920977137. PMID: 33343721; PMCID: PMC7731693. + +173: Mei M, Chen YH, Meng T, Qu LH, Zhang ZY, Zhang X. Comparative efficacy and +safety of radiotherapy/cetuximab versus radiotherapy/chemotherapy for +locally advanced head and neck squamous cell carcinoma patients: a systematic +review of published, primarily non-randomized, data. Ther Adv Med Oncol. 2020 +Dec 8;12:1758835920975355. doi: 10.1177/1758835920975355. PMID: 33343720; PMCID: +PMC7727048. + +174: Tsivgoulis G, Palaiodimou L, Zand R, Lioutas VA, Krogias C, Katsanos AH, +Shoamanesh A, Sharma VK, Shahjouei S, Baracchini C, Vlachopoulos C, Gournellis +R, Sfikakis PP, Sandset EC, Alexandrov AV, Tsiodras S. COVID-19 and +cerebrovascular diseases: a comprehensive overview. Ther Adv Neurol Disord. 2020 +Dec 8;13:1756286420978004. doi: 10.1177/1756286420978004. PMID: 33343709; PMCID: +PMC7727052. + +175: Erdrich S, Hawrelak JA, Myers SP, Harnett JE. A systematic review of the +association between fibromyalgia and functional gastrointestinal disorders. +Therap Adv Gastroenterol. 2020 Dec 8;13:1756284820977402. doi: +10.1177/1756284820977402. PMID: 33343707; PMCID: PMC7727037. + +176: Aung NM, Myint KK. Evidence of Second Canal between Permanent Mandibular +Central and Lateral Incisors in China; a Systematic Review on CBCT Studies. Int +J Dent. 2020 Dec 3;2020:8849609. doi: 10.1155/2020/8849609. PMID: 33343667; +PMCID: PMC7728484. + +177: Senbekov M, Saliev T, Bukeyeva Z, Almabayeva A, Zhanaliyeva M, Aitenova N, +Toishibekov Y, Fakhradiyev I. The Recent Progress and Applications of Digital +Technologies in Healthcare: A Review. Int J Telemed Appl. 2020 Dec +3;2020:8830200. doi: 10.1155/2020/8830200. PMID: 33343657; PMCID: PMC7732404. + +178: Shen LS, Liu LM, Zheng LH, Hu F, Hu ZC, Liu SY, Guo JR, Bhagat KK, Yao Y. +Ablation strategies for arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy: a +systematic review and meta-analysis. J Geriatr Cardiol. 2020 Nov +28;17(11):694-703. doi: 10.11909/j.issn.1671-5411.2020.11.001. PMID: 33343648; +PMCID: PMC7729178. + +179: Yang J, Yu SY, Yang J, Kong J, Liang FR, Lv ZT. No Association Between +G1246A Polymorphism in HCRTR2 Gene and Risk of Cluster Headache: Evidence +From an Updated Meta-Analysis of Observational Studies. Front Genet. 2020 Dec +3;11:560517. doi: 10.3389/fgene.2020.560517. PMID: 33343621; PMCID: PMC7744679. + +180: Sun YF, Zhang J, Xu YM, Cao ZY, Wang YZ, Hao GM, Gao BL. High BMI and +Insulin Resistance Are Risk Factors for Spontaneous Abortion in Patients With +Polycystic Ovary Syndrome Undergoing Assisted Reproductive Treatment: A +Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Front Endocrinol (Lausanne). 2020 Dec +3;11:592495. doi: 10.3389/fendo.2020.592495. PMID: 33343510; PMCID: PMC7744738. + +181: Fahr A, Keller JW, van Hedel HJA. A Systematic Review of Training Methods +That May Improve Selective Voluntary Motor Control in Children With Spastic +Cerebral Palsy. Front Neurol. 2020 Dec 4;11:572038. doi: +10.3389/fneur.2020.572038. PMID: 33343485; PMCID: PMC7746811. + +182: Zhu L, Li L, Wang L, Jin X, Zhang H. Physical Activity for Executive +Function and Activities of Daily Living in AD Patients: A Systematic Review and +Meta-Analysis. Front Psychol. 2020 Dec 3;11:560461. doi: +10.3389/fpsyg.2020.560461. PMID: 33343442; PMCID: PMC7744293. + +183: Oppong S. Towards a Model of Valued Human Cognitive Abilities: An African +Perspective Based on a Systematic Review. Front Psychol. 2020 Dec 4;11:538072. +doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.538072. PMID: 33343437; PMCID: PMC7746612. + +184: Qian H, Shao F, Lenahan C, Shao A, Li Y. Efficacy and Safety of Botulinum +Toxin vs. Placebo in Depression: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of +Randomized Controlled Trials. Front Psychiatry. 2020 Dec 4;11:603087. doi: +10.3389/fpsyt.2020.603087. PMID: 33343429; PMCID: PMC7746677. + +185: Li ET, Luyten P, Midgley N. Psychological Mediators of the Association +Between Childhood Emotional Abuse and Depression: A Systematic Review. Front +Psychiatry. 2020 Dec 4;11:559213. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2020.559213. PMID: +33343409; PMCID: PMC7746653. + +186: Monti M, Vertogen B, Masini C, Donati C, Lilli C, Zingaretti C, Musuraca G, +De Giorgi U, Cerchione C, Farolfi A, Cortesi P, Viale P, Martinelli G, Nanni O. +Hydroxychloroquine as Prophylaxis for COVID-19: A Review. Front Pharmacol. 2020 +Dec 3;11:605185. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2020.605185. PMID: 33343376; PMCID: +PMC7744418. + +187: Zou Y, Tuo F, Zhang Z, Guo J, Yuan Y, Zhang H, Xu Z, Pan Z, Tang Y, Deng C, +Julie N, Wu W, Guo W, Li C, Huang X, Xu Q, Song J, Wang Q. Safety and Efficacy +of Adjunctive Therapy With Artesunate in the Treatment of Severe Malaria: A +Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Front Pharmacol. 2020 Nov 12;11:596697. +doi: 10.3389/fphar.2020.596697. PMID: 33343367; PMCID: PMC7748123. + +188: Kong W, Deng H, Wan J, Zhou Y, Zhou Y, Song B, Wang X. Comparative +Remission Rates and Tolerability of Drugs for Generalised Anxiety Disorder: A +Systematic Review and Network Meta-analysis of Double-Blind Randomized +Controlled Trials. Front Pharmacol. 2020 Nov 11;11:580858. doi: +10.3389/fphar.2020.580858. PMID: 33343351; PMCID: PMC7741609. + +189: Qian H, Chen R, Wang B, Yuan X, Chen S, Liu Y, Shi G. Associations of +Platelet Count with Inflammation and Response to Anti-TNF-α Therapy in Patients +with Ankylosing Spondylitis. Front Pharmacol. 2020 Nov 6;11:559593. doi: +10.3389/fphar.2020.559593. PMID: 33343345; PMCID: PMC7741170. + +190: Xiang X, He Q, Ou Y, Wang W, Wu Y. Efficacy and Safety of CAR-Modified T +Cell Therapy in Patients with Relapsed or Refractory Multiple Myeloma: A Meta- +Analysis of Prospective Clinical Trials. Front Pharmacol. 2020 Dec 3;11:544754. +doi: 10.3389/fphar.2020.544754. PMID: 33343342; PMCID: PMC7744881. + +191: Huhn M, Nikolakopoulou A, Schneider-Thoma J, Krause M, Samara M, Peter N, +Arndt T, Bäckers L, Rothe P, Cipriani A, Davis J, Salanti G, Leucht S. +Comparative Efficacy and Tolerability of 32 Oral Antipsychotics for the Acute +Treatment of Adults With Multi-Episode Schizophrenia: A Systematic Review and +Network Meta-Analysis. Focus (Am Psychiatr Publ). 2020 Oct;18(4):443-455. doi: +10.1176/appi.focus.18306. Epub 2020 Nov 5. PMID: 33343258; PMCID: PMC7725155. + +192: Furukawa TA, Cipriani A, Cowen PJ, Leucht S, Egger M, Salanti G. Optimal +Dose of Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors, Venlafaxine, and Mirtazapine in +Major Depression: A Systematic Review and Dose-Response Meta-Analysis. Focus (Am +Psychiatr Publ). 2020 Apr;18(2):211-219. doi: 10.1176/appi.focus.18204. Epub +2020 Apr 23. PMID: 33343239; PMCID: PMC7587875. + +193: Weinmann A, Galle PR. Role of immunotherapy in the management of +hepatocellular carcinoma: current standards and future directions. Curr Oncol. +2020 Nov;27(Suppl 3):S152-S164. doi: 10.3747/co.27.7315. Epub 2020 Nov 1. PMID: +33343209; PMCID: PMC7739523. + +194: Campanelli S, Tort ABL, Lobão-Soares B. Pranayamas and Their +Neurophysiological Effects. Int J Yoga. 2020 Sep-Dec;13(3):183-192. doi: +10.4103/ijoy.IJOY_91_19. Epub 2020 Sep 13. PMID: 33343147; PMCID: PMC7735501. + +195: Smith SL, Langen WH. A Systematic Review of Mindfulness Practices for +Improving Outcomes in Chronic Low Back Pain. Int J Yoga. 2020 Sep- +Dec;13(3):177-182. doi: 10.4103/ijoy.IJOY_4_20. Epub 2020 Sep 13. PMID: +33343146; PMCID: PMC7735497. + +196: Huynh T. Clinical and Laboratory Aspects of Insulin Autoantibody-Mediated +Glycaemic Dysregulation and Hyperinsulinaemic Hypoglycaemia: Insulin Autoimmune +Syndrome and Exogenous Insulin Antibody Syndrome. Clin Biochem Rev. 2020 +Dec;41(3):93-102. doi: 10.33176/AACB-20-00008. PMID: 33343044; PMCID: +PMC7731936. + +197: Chen CX, Liu ML, Cao K, Yusufu M, Wang JD. Diagnostic value of optical +coherence tomography angiography for choroidal neovascularization in age-related +macular degeneration: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Ophthalmic Res. +2020 Dec 16. doi: 10.1159/000511265. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342974. + +198: Lv X, Zhang Y, Wang J. Systematic Review of Transcatheter Arterial +Embolization of AVM: Indications, Bleeding Complications, Cure Rate, and Long- +Term Bleeding Risk. Neurol India. 2020 Nov-Dec;68(6):1285-1292. doi: +10.4103/0028-3886.304101. PMID: 33342854. + +199: Giuseppe ZR, Silvia C, Eleonora F, Gabriella M, Marica F, Silvia C, Mario +B, Francesco D, Savino C, Milly B, Frezza GP, Maurizio Z, Morganti AG. +Hippocampal-sparing radiotherapy and neurocognitive impairment: A systematic +literature review. J Cancer Res Ther. 2020 Oct-Dec;16(6):1215-1222. doi: +10.4103/jcrt.JCRT_573_17. PMID: 33342776. + +200: Omyan G, Musa AE, Shabeeb D, Akbardoost N, Gholami S. Efficacy and toxicity +of FLASH radiotherapy: A systematic review. J Cancer Res Ther. 2020 Oct- +Dec;16(6):1203-1209. doi: 10.4103/jcrt.JCRT_180_20. PMID: 33342774. + +201: Kim D, Ki Y, Kim W, Park D, Joo J, Jeon H, Nam J. Comparison of local +recurrence after mastectomy for pure ductal carcinoma in situ with close +or positive margins: A meta-analysis. J Cancer Res Ther. 2020 Oct- +Dec;16(6):1197-1202. doi: 10.4103/jcrt.JCRT_160_19. PMID: 33342773. + +202: Kiely J, Kumar M, Wade RG. The accuracy of different modalities of +perforator mapping for unilateral DIEP flap breast reconstruction: A systematic +review and meta-analysis. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2020 Dec +10:S1748-6815(20)30670-7. doi: 10.1016/j.bjps.2020.12.005. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33342741. + +203: Kubota T, Gajera PK, Kuroda N. Meta-analysis of EEG findings in patients +with COVID-19. Epilepsy Behav. 2020 Dec 4:107682. doi: +10.1016/j.yebeh.2020.107682. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342709. + +204: Jiang C, Huang DG, Yan L, Hao DJ. The efficacy of triclosan coated sutures +for preventing surgical site infections in orthopedic surgery: A systematic +review and meta-analysis. Asian J Surg. 2020 Dec 17:S1015-9584(20)30378-X. doi: +10.1016/j.asjsur.2020.11.019. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342701. + +205: Borges ALF, Duarte PLES, Almeida RBS, Ledesma ALL, Azevedo YJ, Pereira LV, +Bahmad F Jr. Cochlear implant and tinnitus-a meta-analysis. Braz J +Otorhinolaryngol. 2020 Dec 8:S1808-8694(20)30215-9. doi: +10.1016/j.bjorl.2020.11.006. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342697. + +206: Siag K, Mazzawi S, Paker M, Biener R, Ghanayim R, Lumelsky D. Acute longus +colli tendinitis and otolaryngology. Braz J Otorhinolaryngol. 2020 Dec +5:S1808-8694(20)30214-7. doi: 10.1016/j.bjorl.2020.10.018. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33342696. + +207: Bhuiyan MU, Stiboy E, Hassan MZ, Chan M, Islam MS, Haider N, Jaffe A, +Homaira N. Epidemiology of COVID-19 infection in young children under five +years: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Vaccine. 2020 Dec +5:S0264-410X(20)31570-X. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.11.078. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33342635. + +208: Celdrán-Vivancos D, Noval-Martín S, González-Manrique M, Negoita A, Porto- +Castro S. Eye oscilations with neurological implications in pediatric age. Arch +Soc Esp Oftalmol. 2020 Dec 17:S0365-6691(20)30416-0. English, Spanish. doi: +10.1016/j.oftal.2020.09.015. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342629. + +209: Dombalis S, Nash A. The Effect of Statins in Children and Adolescents With +Familial Hypercholesterolemia: A Systematic Review. J Pediatr Health Care. 2020 +Dec 17:S0891-5245(20)30308-4. doi: 10.1016/j.pedhc.2020.11.007. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33342622. + +210: Licurci CAA, Lins L, Garbossa M, Canabarro A. A comparative study between +replica and cementation techniques in the evaluation of internal and marginal +misfits of single crowns. J Prosthet Dent. 2020 Dec 17:S0022-3913(20)30692-2. +doi: 10.1016/j.prosdent.2020.11.004. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342611. + +211: van Ommen-Nijhof A, Steenbruggen TG, Schats W, Wiersma T, Horlings HM, Mann +R, Koppert L, van Werkhoven E, Sonke GS, Jager A. Erratum to "Prognostic factors +in patients with oligometastatic breast cancer - A systematic review". [Cancer +treatment Rev. 91 (2020) 102114]. Cancer Treat Rev. 2020 Dec 17:102138. doi: +10.1016/j.ctrv.2020.102138. Epub ahead of print. Erratum for: Cancer Treat Rev. +2020 Dec;91:102114. PMID: 33342599. + +212: Gibbons AJ, Moss CE. Re: systematic review of lingual nerve retraction +during surgical mandibular third molar extractions. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. +2020 Nov 28:S0266-4356(20)30904-9. doi: 10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.11.014. Epub ahead +of print. PMID: 33342589. + +213: Reas DL, Grilo CM. Psychotherapy and Medications for Eating Disorders: +Better Together? Clin Ther. 2020 Dec 17:S0149-2918(20)30474-4. doi: +10.1016/j.clinthera.2020.10.006. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342555. + +214: Şık AS, Aydınoğlu AU, Aydın Son Y. Assessing the readiness of Turkish +health information systems for integrating genetic/genomic patient data: System +architecture and available terminologies, legislative, and protection of +personal data. Health Policy. 2020 Dec 8:S0168-8510(20)30303-1. doi: +10.1016/j.healthpol.2020.12.004. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342546. + +215: Zhao BC, Lei SH, Yang X, Zhang Y, Qiu SD, Liu WF, Li C, Liu KX. Assessment +of prognostic value of intraoperative oliguria for postoperative acute kidney +injury: a retrospective cohort study. Br J Anaesth. 2020 Dec +17:S0007-0912(20)30939-9. doi: 10.1016/j.bja.2020.11.018. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33342539. + +216: Chojnacki GJ, Gothro AG, Gleason PM, Forrestal SG. A Randomized Controlled +Trial Measuring Effects of Extra Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program +(SNAP) Benefits on Child Food Security in Low-Income Families in Rural Kentucky. +J Acad Nutr Diet. 2021 Jan;121(1S):S9-S21. doi: 10.1016/j.jand.2020.05.017. +PMID: 33342530. + +217: Gleason PM, Kleinman R, Chojnacki GJ, Briefel RR, Forrestal SG. Measuring +the Effects of a Demonstration to Reduce Childhood Food Insecurity: A Randomized +Controlled Trial of the Nevada Healthy, Hunger Free Kids Project. J Acad Nutr +Diet. 2021 Jan;121(1S):S22-S33. doi: 10.1016/j.jand.2020.03.002. PMID: 33342522. + +218: Smith CH, Mahil SK, Yiu ZZN, Bale T, Burden AD, Coates LC, McGuire A, +Murphy R, Owen CM, Parslew R, Uthman OA, Woolf RT, Manounah L, Ezejimofor MC, +Exton LS, Mohd Mustapa MF. Quantitative Evaluation of Biologic Therapy Options +for Psoriasis: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis-Correction. J +Invest Dermatol. 2021 Jan;141(1):177-181. doi: 10.1016/j.jid.2020.02.048. PMID: +33342507. + +219: Nesami MB, Moosazadeh M, Goudarzian AH, Jafari-Koulaee A. Erratum to: +"Effect of Cryotherapy on Arteriovenous Fistula Puncture-Related Pain in +Hemodialysis Patients: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis" [Complementary +Therapies in Medicine 49C (2020) 102326]. Complement Ther Med. 2020 +Mar;49:102363. doi: 10.1016/j.ctim.2020.102363. Epub 2020 Mar 5. Erratum for: +Complement Ther Med. 2020 Mar;49:102326. PMID: 33342485. + +220: Mack SA. Eliminating the stigma: A systematic review of the health effects +of low-dose radiation within the diagnostic imaging department and its +implications for the future of medical radiation. J Med Imaging Radiat Sci. 2020 +Dec;51(4):662-670. doi: 10.1016/j.jmir.2020.07.052. Epub 2020 Oct 21. PMID: +33342484. + +221: Conte F, Morava E, Bakar NA, Wortmann SB, Poerink AJ, Grunewald S, Crushell +E, Al-Gazali L, de Vries MC, Mørkrid L, Hertecant J, Brocke Holmefjord KS, Kronn +D, Feigenbaum A, Fingerhut R, Wong SY, van Scherpenzeel M, Voermans NC, Lefeber +DJ. Phosphoglucomutase-1 deficiency: Early presentation, metabolic management +and detection in neonatal blood spots. Mol Genet Metab. 2020 Sep- +Oct;131(1-2):135-146. doi: 10.1016/j.ymgme.2020.08.003. Epub 2020 Sep 17. PMID: +33342467. + +222: Liu B, Li W. Association between education level and HIV-associated +neurocognitive disorder: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sex Health. 2020 +Dec 21. doi: 10.1071/SH20057. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342460. + +223: Prendki V, Tau N, Avni T, Falcone M, Huttner A, Kaiser L, Paul M, +Leibovici-Weissmann Y, Yahav D; ESCMID Study Group for Infections in the Elderly +(ESGIE). A systematic review assessing the under-representation of elderly +adults in COVID-19 trials. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Dec 20;20(1):538. doi: +10.1186/s12877-020-01954-5. PMID: 33342426; PMCID: PMC7749979. + +224: Warren C, Barsky A, McGraw AP. What Makes Things Funny? An Integrative +Review of the Antecedents of Laughter and Amusement. Pers Soc Psychol Rev. 2020 +Dec 21:1088868320961909. doi: 10.1177/1088868320961909. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33342368. + +225: Karanikas N, Jani BD. Frequency of examination and perceived contribution +of factors relating to work-related musculoskeletal disorders of +physiotherapists. Int J Occup Saf Ergon. 2020 Dec 21:1-33. doi: +10.1080/10803548.2020.1867337. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342365. + +226: Bills SE, Johnston JD, Shi D, Bradshaw J. Social-environmental moderators +of neurodevelopmental outcomes in youth born preterm: A systematic review. Child +Neuropsychol. 2020 Dec 21:1-20. doi: 10.1080/09297049.2020.1861229. Epub ahead +of print. PMID: 33342364. + +227: Sun K, Sun F, Yao H, Zhang D, Wu G, Wang T, Wang J, Wu J. Efficacy and +Safety of Combination Comprising Tamsulosin and PDE5-Is, Relative to +Monotherapies, in Treating Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms and Erectile Dysfunction +Associated With Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia: A Meta-Analysis. Am J Mens Health. +2020 Nov-Dec;14(6):1557988320980180. doi: 10.1177/1557988320980180. PMID: +33342335. + +228: Schizas D, Mastoraki A, Giannakodimos I, Giannakodimos A, Ziogou A, +Katsaros I, Frountzas M, Koutelidakis I, Vassiliu P, Pikoulis E. Primary +Angiosarcoma of the Gastrointestinal Tract: A Systematic Review of the +Literature. J Invest Surg. 2020 Dec 21:1-9. doi: 10.1080/08941939.2020.1853283. +Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342318. + +229: Ishøi L, Nielsen MF, Hölmich P, Thorborg K. Now you see it - Now you don't: +A letter to the editor concerning "Surgery is no more effective than +conservative treatment for femoroacetabular impingement syndrome: Systematic +review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials". Clin Rehabil. 2020 +Dec 21:269215520981695. doi: 10.1177/0269215520981695. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33342271. + +230: Feliciano DV. A Review of "Changes in the Management of Injuries to the +Liver and Spleen" (2005). Am Surg. 2020 Dec 21:3134820979587. doi: +10.1177/0003134820979587. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342252. + +231: Reges O, Ning H, Wilkins JT, Wu CO, Tian X, Domanski MJ, Lloyd-Jones DM, +Allen NB. Association of Cumulative Systolic Blood Pressure With Long-Term Risk +of Cardiovascular Disease and Healthy Longevity: Findings From the Lifetime Risk +Pooling Project Cohorts. Hypertension. 2020 Dec 21:HYPERTENSIONAHA12015650. doi: +10.1161/HYPERTENSIONAHA.120.15650. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342241. + +232: Clark CE, Warren FC, Boddy K, McDonagh STJ, Moore SF, Goddard J, Reed N, +Turner M, Alzamora MT, Ramos Blanes R, Chuang SY, Criqui M, Dahl M, Engström G, +Erbel R, Espeland M, Ferrucci L, Guerchet M, Hattersley A, Lahoz C, McClelland +RL, McDermott MM, Price J, Stoffers HE, Wang JG, Westerink J, White J, Cloutier +L, Taylor RS, Shore AC, McManus RJ, Aboyans V, Campbell JL. Associations Between +Systolic Interarm Differences in Blood Pressure and Cardiovascular Disease +Outcomes and Mortality: Individual Participant Data Meta-Analysis, Development +and Validation of a Prognostic Algorithm: The INTERPRESS-IPD Collaboration. +Hypertension. 2020 Dec 21:HYPERTENSIONAHA12015997. doi: +10.1161/HYPERTENSIONAHA.120.15997. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342236. + +233: Zhou YP, Yang M, Yao PT, Ge YB, Tang W, Wen Y, Lyu ZY, Tan FW, Sun X, Li F, +Li J, Li N. [Quality assessment of guidelines and consensus in lung cancer +chemotherapy]. Zhonghua Zhong Liu Za Zhi. 2020 Dec 23;42(12):1025-1033. Chinese. +doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn112152-20190508-00293. PMID: 33342159. + +234: Molena E, King E, Davies-Husband C. Octreotide versus oral dietary +modification for the treatment of chylous fistula following neck dissection: a +systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Otolaryngol. 2020 Dec 20. doi: +10.1111/coa.13700. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342047. + +235: Langton K, Tufton N, Akker S, Deinum J, Eisenhofer G, Timmers HJLM, +Spaanderman MEA, Lenders JWM. Pregnancy and pheochromocytoma / paraganglioma: +clinical clues affecting diagnosis and outcome: a systematic review. BJOG. 2020 +Dec 20. doi: 10.1111/1471-0528.16635. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33342020. + +236: Diriba DC, Leung DYP, Suen LKP. The Effects of Diabetes Self-management +Interventions on Physiological Outcomes in People Living with Diabetes in +Africa: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Diabet Med. 2020 Dec 20:e14501. +doi: 10.1111/dme.14501. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33341999. + +237: Martin CL, Bakker CJ, Breth MS, Gao G, Lee K, Lee MA, Tiase VL, Tunby LJ, +Wyatt TH, Janeway LM. The efficacy of mobile health interventions used to manage +acute or chronic pain: A systematic review. Res Nurs Health. 2020 Dec 20. doi: +10.1002/nur.22097. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33341989. + +238: Urabe F. Editorial Comment from Dr Urabe to Diagnostic performance of +prostate cancer antigen 3 and the Prostate Health Index in detecting overall and +clinically significant prostate cancer in men at first biopsy: A meta-analysis. +Int J Urol. 2020 Dec 19. doi: 10.1111/iju.14467. Epub ahead of print. PMID: +33341976. + +239: Lobo EH, Frølich A, Kensing F, Rasmussen LJ, Livingston PM, Grundy J, +Abdelrazek M. mHealth applications to support caregiver needs and engagement +during stroke recovery: A content review. Res Nurs Health. 2020 Dec 20. doi: +10.1002/nur.22096. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33341958. + +240: Lorentzen AK, Davis C, Penninga L. Interventions for frostbite injuries. +Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Dec 20;12:CD012980. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD012980.pub2. PMID: 33341943. + +241: Hussein AAA, Bloem E, Fodor I, Baz ES, Tadros MM, Soliman MFM, El-Shenawy +NS, Koene JM. Slowly seeing the light: an integrative review on ecological light +pollution as a potential threat for mollusks. Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2020 +Dec 19. doi: 10.1007/s11356-020-11824-7. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33341922. + +242: Baijens LWJ, Walshe M, Aaltonen LM, Arens C, Cordier R, Cras P, Crevier- +Buchman L, Curtis C, Golusinski W, Govender R, Eriksen JG, Hansen K, Heathcote +K, Hess MM, Hosal S, Klussmann JP, Leemans CR, MacCarthy D, Manduchi B, Marie +JP, Nouraei R, Parkes C, Pflug C, Pilz W, Regan J, Rommel N, Schindler A, Schols +AMWJ, Speyer R, Succo G, Wessel I, Willemsen ACH, Yilmaz T, Clavé P. European +white paper: oropharyngeal dysphagia in head and neck cancer. Eur Arch +Otorhinolaryngol. 2020 Dec 19. doi: 10.1007/s00405-020-06507-5. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33341909. + +243: Alvarado CE, Worrell SG, Bachman KC, Gray K, Perry Y, Linden PA, Towe CW. +Surgery following neoadjuvant chemoradiation therapy in clinical N3 esophageal +cancer results in improved survival: a propensity-matched analysis. Dis +Esophagus. 2020 Dec 21:doaa118. doi: 10.1093/dote/doaa118. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33341903. + +244: Asghar A, Talha KM, Amanullah M, Shahabuddin S. Comparison of figure of +eight and traditional simple wire closure method to prevent dehiscence after +sternal closure. J Pak Med Assoc. 2020 Nov;70(11):2001-2006. doi: +10.5455/JPMA.20135. PMID: 33341848. + +245: Ribeiro RAB, Soeiro CBBM. Analysing criminal profiling validity: Underlying +problems and future directions. Int J Law Psychiatry. 2020 Dec 17;74:101670. +doi: 10.1016/j.ijlp.2020.101670. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33341721. + +246: Varghese J, Gohari SS, Rizki H, Faheem I, Langridge B, Kümmel S, Johnson L, +Schmid P. A systematic review and meta-analysis on the effect of neoadjuvant +chemotherapy on complications following immediate breast reconstruction. Breast. +2020 Dec 3;55:55-62. doi: 10.1016/j.breast.2020.11.023. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33341706. + +247: Khanagar SB, Vishwanathaiah S, Naik S, A Al-Kheraif A, Devang Divakar D, +Sarode SC, Bhandi S, Patil S. Application and performance of artificial +intelligence technology in forensic odontology - A systematic review. Leg Med +(Tokyo). 2020 Dec 10;48:101826. doi: 10.1016/j.legalmed.2020.101826. Epub ahead +of print. PMID: 33341601. + +248: Martins RARC, Costa FWG, Silva SM, Silva PGB, Carvalho FSR, Fonteles CSR, +Ribeiro TR. Salivary immunoglobulins (A, G, and M) in type 1 diabetes mellitus +patients: A PROSPERO-registered systematic review and meta-analysis. Arch Oral +Biol. 2020 Dec 8;122:105025. doi: 10.1016/j.archoralbio.2020.105025. Epub ahead +of print. PMID: 33341591. + +249: Hu Y, Kattan C, Kontos D, Zhu W, Hernandez ME. Benefits of tai ji quan +practice on neuromuscular functions in older adults: A Systematic Review and +meta-analysis. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Dec 16;42:101295. doi: +10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101295. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33341582. + +250: Adam MG, Tran PTM, Bolan N, Balasubramanian R. Biomass burning-derived +airborne particulate matter in Southeast Asia: A critical review. J Hazard +Mater. 2020 Dec 3;407:124760. doi: 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2020.124760. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33341572. + +251: Siow I, Lee KS, Zhang JJY, Saffari SE, Ng A, Young B. Stroke as a +Neurological Complication of COVID-19: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of +Incidence, Outcomes and Predictors. J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis. 2020 Dec +15;30(3):105549. doi: 10.1016/j.jstrokecerebrovasdis.2020.105549. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33341565. + +252: Alfattni G, Peek N, Nenadic G. Corrigendum to "Extraction of temporal +relations from clinical free text: A systematic review of current approaches" +[J. Biomed. Inf. 108 (2020) 103488]. J Biomed Inform. 2020 Dec 18;113:103663. +doi: 10.1016/j.jbi.2020.103663. Epub ahead of print. Erratum for: J Biomed +Inform. 2020 Aug;108:103488. PMID: 33341543. + +253: Sutar R, Atlani MK, Chaudhary P. Antipsychotics and hemodialysis: A +systematic review. Asian J Psychiatr. 2020 Dec 3;55:102484. doi: +10.1016/j.ajp.2020.102484. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33341539. + +254: Le Tertre M, Ka C, Raud L, Berlivet I, Gourlaouen I, Richard G, Uguen K, +Chen JM, Férec C, Fichou Y, Le Gac G. Splicing analysis of SLC40A1 missense +variations and contribution to hemochromatosis type 4 phenotypes. Blood Cells +Mol Dis. 2020 Dec 8;87:102527. doi: 10.1016/j.bcmd.2020.102527. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33341511. + +255: Keshavarz P, Rafiee F, Kavandi H, Goudarzi S, Heidari F, Gholamrezanezhad +A. Ischemic gastrointestinal complications of COVID-19: a systematic review on +imaging presentation. Clin Imaging. 2020 Dec 8;73:86-95. doi: +10.1016/j.clinimag.2020.11.054. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33341452. + +256: DelRosso LM, Picchietti DL, Spruyt K, Bruni O, Garcia-Borreguero D, Kotagal +S, Owens JA, Simakajornboon N, Ferri R; International Restless Legs Syndrome +Study Group (IRLSSG). Restless sleep in children: A systematic review. Sleep Med +Rev. 2020 Dec 1;56:101406. doi: 10.1016/j.smrv.2020.101406. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33341437. + +257: Diedrich L, Dockweiler C. Video-based teleconsultations in pharmaceutical +care - A systematic review. Res Social Adm Pharm. 2020 Dec +13:S1551-7411(20)31207-9. doi: 10.1016/j.sapharm.2020.12.002. Epub ahead of +print. PMID: 33341405. + +258: Slocum RB, Villano JL. Narrative medicine applications for neuro-oncology +patient identity and quality of life. J Clin Neurosci. 2020 Dec +16:S0967-5868(20)31683-0. doi: 10.1016/j.jocn.2020.11.046. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33341368. + +259: Wreesmann WW, Lorié ES, van Veenendaal NR, van Kempen AAMW, Ket JCF, Labrie +NHM. The functions of adequate communication in the neonatal care unit: A +systematic review and meta-synthesis of qualitative research. Patient Educ +Couns. 2020 Nov 28:S0738-3991(20)30653-4. doi: 10.1016/j.pec.2020.11.029. Epub +ahead of print. PMID: 33341329. + +260: Magalhães GM, Vieira ÉC, Garcia LC, De Carvalho-Leite MLR, Guedes ACM, +Araújo MG. Update on human papilloma virus - part I: epidemiology, pathogenesis, +and clinical spectrum. An Bras Dermatol. 2020 Dec 10:S0365-0596(20)30662-0. doi: +10.1016/j.abd.2020.11.003. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33341319. + +261: Bakaloudi DR, Halloran A, Rippin HL, Oikonomidou AC, Dardavesis TI, +Williams J, Wickramasinghe K, Breda J, Chourdakis M. Intake and adequacy of the +vegan diet. A systematic review of the evidence. Clin Nutr. 2020 Dec +7:S0261-5614(20)30656-7. doi: 10.1016/j.clnu.2020.11.035. Epub ahead of print. +PMID: 33341313. + +262: Fei Q, Lin Y, Yuan TM. Lung Ultrasound, a Better Choice for Neonatal +Pneumothorax: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2020 +Dec 16:S0301-5629(20)30519-6. doi: 10.1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2020.11.011. Epub +ahead of print. PMID: 33341304. + +263: Cheng C, Cheng GY, Denas G, Pengo V. Arterial thrombosis in +antiphospholipid syndrome (APS): Clinical approach and treatment. A systematic +review. Blood Rev. 2020 Dec 13:100788. doi: 10.1016/j.blre.2020.100788. Epub +ahead of print. PMID: 33341301. + +264: Hu MC, Yang YL, Chen TT, Lee CI, Tam KW. Recruitment maneuvers to reduce +pulmonary atelectasis after cardiac surgery: A meta-analysis of randomized +trials. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2020 Nov 26:S0022-5223(20)33105-6. doi: +10.1016/j.jtcvs.2020.10.142. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33341273. + +265: Ma C, Peng Y, Li H, Chen W. Organ-on-a-Chip: A New Paradigm for Drug +Development. Trends Pharmacol Sci. 2020 Dec 16:S0165-6147(20)30264-9. doi: +10.1016/j.tips.2020.11.009. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 33341248. + +266: Jacob V, Chattopadhyay SK, Reynolds JA, Hopkins DP, Morgan JA, Brown DR, +Kochtitzky CS, Cuellar AE, Kumanyika SK; Community Preventive Services Task +Force. Economics of Interventions to Increase Active Travel to School: A +Community Guide Systematic Review. Am J Prev Med. 2021 Jan;60(1):e27-e40. doi: +10.1016/j.amepre.2020.08.002. PMID: 33341185. + +267: Dunn CG, Wilcox S, Saunders RP, Kaczynski AT, Blake CE, Turner-McGrievy GM. +Healthy Eating and Physical Activity Interventions in Faith-Based Settings: A +Systematic Review Using the Reach, Effectiveness/Efficacy, Adoption, +Implementation, Maintenance Framework. Am J Prev Med. 2021 Jan;60(1):127-135. +doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2020.05.014. PMID: 33341177. + +268: Drugs and Lactation Database (LactMed) [Internet]. Bethesda (MD): National +Library of Medicine (US); 2006–. Iodine. 2020 Dec 21. PMID: 30000537. + +269: Drugs and Lactation Database (LactMed) [Internet]. Bethesda (MD): National +Library of Medicine (US); 2006–. Domperidone. 2020 Dec 21. PMID: 30000430. + +270: Drugs and Lactation Database (LactMed) [Internet]. Bethesda (MD): National +Library of Medicine (US); 2006–. Lithium. 2020 Dec 21. PMID: 30000212. + +271: Onwuchekwa C, Edem B, Williams V, Oga E. Estimating the impact of +pneumococcal conjugate vaccines on childhood pneumonia in sub-Saharan Africa: A +systematic review. F1000Res. 2020 Jul 23;9:765. doi: +10.12688/f1000research.25227.2. PMID: 33335713; PMCID: PMC7713889. + +272: Fernández-Jané C, Solà-Madurell M, Yu M, Liang C, Fei Y, Sitjà-Rabert M, +Úrrutia G. Completeness of reporting acupuncture interventions for chronic +obstructive pulmonary disease: Review of adherence to the STRICTA statement. +F1000Res. 2020 Apr 2;9:226. doi: 10.12688/f1000research.22843.3. PMID: 33335712; +PMCID: PMC7713895. + +273: Yuan X, Xue N, Han Z. A meta-analysis of heavy metals pollution in farmland +and urban soils in China over the past 20 years. J Environ Sci (China). 2021 +Mar;101:217-226. doi: 10.1016/j.jes.2020.08.013. Epub 2020 Sep 3. PMID: +33334517. + +274: Deng FC, Wang C, Gu W, Chen YY, Han JJ, Du HM, Peng H, Tang S. [Research +advances in the adverse effects of azo dyes]. Zhonghua Yu Fang Yi Xue Za Zhi. +2020 Dec 6;54(12):1478-1483. Chinese. doi: +10.3760/cma.j.cn112150-20200114-00020. PMID: 33333672. + +275: Shevchenko IL, Stoĭko IM, Gudymovich VG, Cherniago TI. Glikokaliks – +opredeliaiushchiĭ faktor v razvitii éndotelial'noĭ venoznoĭ disfunktsii i +vozmozhnosti ee korrektsii [Glycocalyx as a determining factor in development of +endothelial venous dysfunction and possibilities of correction thereof]. Angiol +Sosud Khir. 2020;26(4):71-77. Russian. doi: 10.33529/ANGIO2020404. PMID: +33332308. + +276: Melo CFCAE, Vasconcelos PFDC, Alcantara LCJ, Araujo WN. The obscurance of +the greatest sylvatic yellow fever epidemic and the cooperation of the Pan +American Health Organization during the COVID-19 pandemic. Rev Soc Bras Med +Trop. 2020 Dec 11;53:e20200787. doi: 10.1590/0037-8682-0787-2020. PMID: +33331614; PMCID: PMC7747828. + +277: Chi W, Chen Y, Wang L, Luo Z, Zhang Y, Zhu X. Acupuncture for COVID-19 +patient after ventilator weaning: A protocol for systematic review and meta- +analysis. Medicine (Baltimore). 2020 Dec 11;99(50):e23602. doi: +10.1097/MD.0000000000023602. PMID: 33327327; PMCID: PMC7738103. + +278: Moisset X, Pereira B, Ciampi de Andrade D, Fontaine D, Lantéri-Minet M, +Mawet J. Neuromodulation techniques for acute and preventive migraine treatment: +a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. J +Headache Pain. 2020 Dec 10;21(1):142. doi: 10.1186/s10194-020-01204-4. PMID: +33302882; PMCID: PMC7726868. + +279: Reichert M, Sartelli M, Weigand MA, Doppstadt C, Hecker M, Reinisch-Liese +A, Bender F, Askevold I, Padberg W, Coccolini F, Catena F, Hecker A; WSES +COVID-19 emergency surgery survey collaboration group. Impact of the SARS-CoV-2 +pandemic on emergency surgery services-a multi-national survey among WSES +members. World J Emerg Surg. 2020 Dec 9;15(1):64. doi: +10.1186/s13017-020-00341-0. PMID: 33298131; PMCID: PMC7724441. + +280: Truppa C, Abo-Shehada MN. Antimicrobial resistance among GLASS pathogens in +conflict and non-conflict affected settings in the Middle East: a systematic +review. BMC Infect Dis. 2020 Dec 9;20(1):936. doi: 10.1186/s12879-020-05503-8. +PMID: 33297983; PMCID: PMC7724697. + +281: Menon S, Rossi R, Dusabimana A, Zdraveska N, Bhattacharyya S, Francis J. +The epidemiology of tuberculosis-associated hyperglycemia in individuals newly +screened for type 2 diabetes mellitus: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC +Infect Dis. 2020 Dec 9;20(1):937. doi: 10.1186/s12879-020-05512-7. PMID: +33297969; PMCID: PMC7724718. + +282: Holford P, Carr AC, Jovic TH, Ali SR, Whitaker IS, Marik PE, Smith AD. +Vitamin C-An Adjunctive Therapy for Respiratory Infection, Sepsis and COVID-19. +Nutrients. 2020 Dec 7;12(12):E3760. doi: 10.3390/nu12123760. PMID: 33297491. + +283: Lai SY, Ng KH, Cheng CK, Nur H, Nurhadi M, Arumugam M. Photocatalytic +remediation of organic waste over Keggin-based polyoxometalate materials: A +review. Chemosphere. 2021 Jan;263:128244. doi: +10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128244. Epub 2020 Sep 6. PMID: 33297191. + +284: Li Y, Fang R, Liu Z, Jiang L, Zhang J, Li H, Liu C, Li F. The association +between toxic pesticide environmental exposure and Alzheimer's disease: A +scientometric and visualization analysis. Chemosphere. 2021 Jan;263:128238. doi: +10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128238. Epub 2020 Sep 4. PMID: 33297185. + +285: Dhote L, Kumar S, Singh L, Kumar R. A systematic review on options for +sustainable treatment and resource recovery of distillery sludge. Chemosphere. +2021 Jan;263:128225. doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128225. Epub 2020 Sep 3. +PMID: 33297181. + +286: De Silva S, Ball AS, Indrapala DV, Reichman SM. Review of the interactions +between vehicular emitted potentially toxic elements, roadside soils, and +associated biota. Chemosphere. 2021 Jan;263:128135. doi: +10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128135. Epub 2020 Aug 31. PMID: 33297123. + +287: Ansari M, Sharifian M, Ehrampoush MH, Mahvi AH, Salmani MH, Fallahzadeh H. +Dielectric barrier discharge plasma with photocatalysts as a hybrid emerging +technology for degradation of synthetic organic compounds in aqueous +environments: A critical review. Chemosphere. 2021 Jan;263:128065. doi: +10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128065. Epub 2020 Aug 23. PMID: 33297070. + +288: Haldane V, Zhang Z, Abbas RF, Dodd W, Lau LL, Kidd MR, Rouleau K, Zou G, +Chao Z, Upshur REG, Walley J, Wei X. National primary care responses to +COVID-19: a rapid review of the literature. BMJ Open. 2020 Dec 8;10(12):e041622. +doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-041622. PMID: 33293398; PMCID: PMC7725079. + +289: Wang D, Li J, Zhu F, Hong Q, Zhang M, Gao M, Chen W. Protocol for a +systematic review and meta-analysis of respiratory rehabilitation following +intensive care unit discharge for COVID-19 survivors. BMJ Open. 2020 Dec +8;10(12):e041184. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-041184. PMID: 33293395; PMCID: +PMC7725092. + +290: Russell JA, Marshall JC, Slutsky A, Murthy S, Sweet D, Lee T, Singer J, +Patrick DM, Du B, Peng Z, Cheng M, Burns KD, Harhay MO. Study protocol for a +multicentre, prospective cohort study of the association of angiotensin II type +1 receptor blockers on outcomes of coronavirus infection. BMJ Open. 2020 Dec +7;10(12):e040768. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-040768. PMID: 33293316; PMCID: +PMC7722825. + +291: Misset B, Hoste E, Donneau AF, Grimaldi D, Meyfroidt G, Moutschen M, +Compernolle V, Gothot A, Desmecht D, Garigliany M, Najdovski T, Laterre PF. A +multicenter randomized trial to assess the efficacy of CONvalescent plasma +therapy in patients with Invasive COVID-19 and acute respiratory failure treated +with mechanical ventilation: the CONFIDENT trial protocol. BMC Pulm Med. 2020 +Dec 7;20(1):317. doi: 10.1186/s12890-020-01361-x. PMID: 33287790; PMCID: +PMC7719725. + +292: Zhou Y, Zeng Z, Dong X, Fei J, Li B. Effects of Chaihu-Shugan-San for +reflux esophagitis: A protocol for systematic review and meta-analysis. Medicine +(Baltimore). 2020 Dec 4;99(49):e23458. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000023458. PMID: +33285744; PMCID: PMC7717765. + +293: Hu Y, Cheng X, Su X, Fu Y. Auricular therapy improves gastrointestinal +function in patients with gynecological laparoscopic surgery: A protocol for +systematic review and meta analysis. Medicine (Baltimore). 2020 Dec +4;99(49):e23421. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000023421. PMID: 33285735; PMCID: +PMC7717805. + +294: Liang S, Zhang G, Li J, Zhong L, Zhang C. Wrist ankle acupuncture in the +treatment of acute lumbar sprain: A protocol for systematic review and meta- +analysis. Medicine (Baltimore). 2020 Dec 4;99(49):e23420. doi: +10.1097/MD.0000000000023420. PMID: 33285734; PMCID: PMC7717768. + +295: Zhang J, Mei L, Wang F, Li Y. Ten years' disease-free survival of advanced +epithelial ovarian cancer treated by cytoreductive surgery plus hyperthermic +intraperitoneal chemotherapy: A case report and literature review. Medicine +(Baltimore). 2020 Dec 4;99(49):e23404. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000023404. PMID: +33285729; PMCID: PMC7717790. + +296: Li Y, Zheng X, Wang Y, Li Y. Auricular therapy for polycystic ovary +syndrome: A protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis. Medicine +(Baltimore). 2020 Dec 4;99(49):e23396. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000023396. PMID: +33285726; PMCID: PMC7717724. + +297: Zhang J, Feng J, Liu Y. Preventive effect and safety of Chinese herbal +medicine mouthwash in chemotherapy-induced oral mucositis: A protocol for +systematic review and meta analysis. Medicine (Baltimore). 2020 Dec +4;99(49):e23387. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000023387. PMID: 33285725; PMCID: +PMC7717741. + +298: Zhu H, Peng P, Zhao R, Fang KY, Han SQ. Efficacy and safety of +antimicrobial de-escalation of treatment for sepsis: A protocol for systematic +review and meta-analysis. Medicine (Baltimore). 2020 Dec 4;99(49):e23385. doi: +10.1097/MD.0000000000023385. PMID: 33285724; PMCID: PMC7717729. + +299: Shamshirian A, Hessami A, Heydari K, Navaei RA, Ebrahimzadeh MA, Yip GW, +Ghasemian R, Sedaghat M, Baradaran H, Yazdi SM, Aboufazeli E, Jafarpour H, +Dadgostar E, Tirandazi B, Sadeghnezhad R, Karimifar K, Eftekhari A, Shamshirian +D. The Role of Hydroxychloroquine in COVID-19: A Systematic Review and Meta- +Analysis. Ann Acad Med Singap. 2020 Oct;49(10):789-800. PMID: 33283842. + +300: Castelbranco O, Nasc C, Castro E Sousa L, Ferreira T, Medeiros D. Infected +Evar Endograft - A Lesson To Be Learned. Rev Port Cir Cardiotorac Vasc. 2020 +Oct-Dec;27(4):298. PMID: 33280322. + +301: Sousa PP, O'sullivan GJ. Iliocaval Endovascular Reconstruction - Clinical +Cases Presentation And Systematic Review Publication. Rev Port Cir Cardiotorac +Vasc. 2020 Oct-Dec;27(4):288. PMID: 33280314. + +302: Duarte-Gamas L, Pereira-Neves A, Jácome F, Sousa-Pinto B, Rocha-Neves J. +The Diagnostic Accuracy Of Nearinfrared Spectroscopy In Carotid Artery +Endarterectomy Under Regional Anesthesia - Systematic Review And Meta-Analysis. +Rev Port Cir Cardiotorac Vasc. 2020 Oct-Dec;27(4):277-278. PMID: 33280306. + +303: Cabral D, Nawojowska A, Antunes M, Calado T, Torres C, Alvoeiro M, Mendes +S, Rodrigues C, Félix F. Lymph Node Upstaging After Surgery In Patients With +Negative Mediastinal Staging By Ebus. Rev Port Cir Cardiotorac Vasc. 2020 Oct- +Dec;27(4):264. PMID: 33280296. + +304: Saraiva F, Moreira R, Cerqueira RJ, Mancio J, Barros AS, Lourenço AP, +Leite-Moreira A. Multiple Versus Single Arterial Grafting In The Elderly: A +Meta-Analysis Of Randomized Controlled Trials And Propensity Score Studies. Rev +Port Cir Cardiotorac Vasc. 2020 Oct-Dec;27(4):258. PMID: 33280292. + +305: Saraiva F, Leite-Moreira JP, Barros AS, Leite-Moreira A, Lourenço AP. +Multiple Vs Single Arterial Grafting In Coronary Surgery Among Diabetic +Patients: A Meta-Analysis. Rev Port Cir Cardiotorac Vasc. 2020 Oct- +Dec;27(4):248. PMID: 33280282. + +306: Radcliffe C, Lier A, Doilicho N, Parikh S, Kaddouh F. Bordetella +bronchiseptica: a rare cause of meningitis. BMC Infect Dis. 2020 Dec +3;20(1):922. doi: 10.1186/s12879-020-05668-2. PMID: 33272197; PMCID: PMC7713019. + +307: Hu BS, -Z Hu M, Jiang LX, Yu J, Chang Y, Cao Y, Dai ZP. Extracorporeal +membrane oxygenation (ECMO) in patients with COVID-19: a rapid systematic review +of case studies. Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci. 2020 Nov;24(22):11945-11952. doi: +10.26355/eurrev_202011_23855. PMID: 33275268. + +308: Kim JS, Lee KH, Kim GE, Kim S, Yang JW, Li H, Hong SH, Ghayda RA, +Kronbichler A, Koyanagi A, Jacob L, Shin JI, Smith L. Clinical characteristics +and mortality of patients with hematologic malignancies and COVID-19: a +systematic review. Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci. 2020 Nov;24(22):11926-11933. doi: +10.26355/eurrev_202011_23852. PMID: 33275265. + +309: Yap M, Debenham L, Kew T, Chatterjee SR, Allotey J, Stallings E, Coomar D, +Lee SI, Qiu X, Yuan M, Clavé Llavall A, Dixit A, Zhou D, Balaji R, van Wely M, +Kostova E, van Leeuwen E, Mofenson L, Kunst H, Khalil A, Tiberi S, Thomas J, +Brizuela V, Broutet N, Kara E, Kim C, Thorson A, Rayco-Solon P, Pardo-Hernandez +H, Oladapo OT, Zamora J, Bonet M, Thangaratinam S; PregCOV-19 Consortium. +Clinical manifestations, prevalence, risk factors, outcomes, transmission, +diagnosis and treatment of COVID-19 in pregnancy and postpartum: a living +systematic review protocol. BMJ Open. 2020 Dec 2;10(12):e041868. doi: +10.1136/bmjopen-2020-041868. PMID: 33268430; PMCID: PMC7712931. + +310: Zhang L, Silva TC, Young JI, Gomez L, Schmidt MA, Hamilton-Nelson KL, +Kunkle BW, Chen X, Martin ER, Wang L. Epigenome-wide meta-analysis of DNA +methylation differences in prefrontal cortex implicates the immune processes in +Alzheimer's disease. Nat Commun. 2020 Nov 30;11(1):6114. doi: +10.1038/s41467-020-19791-w. PMID: 33257653; PMCID: PMC7704686. + +311: Kuno G. The Absence of Yellow Fever in Asia: History, Hypotheses, Vector +Dispersal, Possibility of YF in Asia, and Other Enigmas. Viruses. 2020 Nov +25;12(12):E1349. doi: 10.3390/v12121349. PMID: 33255615. + +312: Haupt C, Henke M, Kutschmar A, Hauser B, Baldinger S, Saenz SR, Schreiber +G. Antiandrogen or estradiol treatment or both during hormone therapy in +transitioning transgender women. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov +28;11:CD013138. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013138.pub2. PMID: 33251587. + +313: Olowoyeye A, Okwundu CI. Gene therapy for sickle cell disease. Cochrane +Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 30;11:CD007652. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007652.pub7. +PMID: 33251574. + +314: Xiang Y, Huang Y, He H, Xu Q. [Phylogenetic and expression analysis of +SEPALLATA-like gene in Brassica oleracea L. var. acephala]. Sheng Wu Gong Cheng +Xue Bao. 2020 Nov 25;36(11):2398-2412. Chinese. doi: 10.13345/j.cjb.200422. +PMID: 33244934. + +315: Guay J, Kopp S. Peripheral nerve blocks for hip fractures in adults. +Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 25;11:CD001159. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD001159.pub3. PMID: 33238043. + +316: Van der Loo LE, Aquarius R, Teernstra O, Klijn K, Menovsky T, van Dijk JMC, +Bartels R, Boogaarts HD. Iron chelators for acute stroke. Cochrane Database Syst +Rev. 2020 Nov 24;11:CD009280. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009280.pub3. PMID: +33236783. + +317: Parry Smith WR, Papadopoulou A, Thomas E, Tobias A, Price MJ, Meher S, +Alfirevic Z, Weeks AD, Hofmeyr GJ, Gülmezoglu AM, Widmer M, Oladapo OT, Vogel +JP, Althabe F, Coomarasamy A, Gallos ID. Uterotonic agents for first-line +treatment of postpartum haemorrhage: a network meta-analysis. Cochrane Database +Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 24;11:CD012754. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012754.pub2. PMID: +33232518. + +318: de Sévaux JL, Venekamp RP, Lutje V, Hak E, Schilder AG, Sanders EA, +Damoiseaux RA. Pneumococcal conjugate vaccines for preventing acute otitis media +in children. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 24;11:CD001480. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD001480.pub6. PMID: 33231293. + +319: Fabrizio V, Trzaski JM, Brownell EA, Esposito P, Lainwala S, Lussier MM, +Hagadorn JI. Individualized versus standard diet fortification for growth and +development in preterm infants receiving human milk. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. +2020 Nov 23;11:CD013465. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013465.pub2. PMID: 33226632. + +320: Sangkomkamhang US, Lumbiganon P, Pattanittum P. Progestogens or +progestogen-releasing intrauterine systems for uterine fibroids (other than +preoperative medical therapy). Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov +23;11:CD008994. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008994.pub3. PMID: 33226133. + +321: Marotta N, Demeco A, Moggio L, Marinaro C, Pino I, Barletta M, Petraroli A, +Pepe D, Lavano F, Ammendolia A. Comparative effectiveness of breathing exercises +in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Complement Ther Clin +Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101260. doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101260. Epub 2020 Nov 17. +PMID: 33221632. + +322: Kuru Alici N, Arikan Dönmez A. A systematic review of the effect of +laughter yoga on physical function and psychosocial outcomes in older adults. +Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101252. doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101252. +Epub 2020 Oct 28. PMID: 33217706. + +323: You YN, Hardiman KM, Bafford A, Poylin V, Francone TD, Davis K, Paquette +IM, Steele SR, Feingold DL; Clinical Practice Guidelines Committee of the +American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons. The American Society of Colon and +Rectal Surgeons Clinical Practice Guidelines for the Management of Rectal +Cancer. Dis Colon Rectum. 2020 Sep;63(9):1191-1222. doi: +10.1097/DCR.0000000000001762. PMID: 33216491. + +324: Gao C, Miller J, Collins CT, Rumbold AR. Comparison of different protein +concentrations of human milk fortifier for promoting growth and neurological +development in preterm infants. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov +20;11:CD007090. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007090.pub2. PMID: 33215474. + +325: Du Y, Li WP, Xiong H, Zhang S, Zhou ZY, Deng JP, Zhang JN. [Efficacy and +safety of pylorus-preserving gastrectomy for early gastric cancer located in the +middle third of the stomach: a meta-analysis]. Zhonghua Wei Chang Wai Ke Za Zhi. +2020 Nov 25;23(11):1088-1096. Chinese. doi: +10.3760/cma.j.cn.441530-20200228-00098. PMID: 33212558. + +326: Liang WQ, Xi HQ, Qiao S, Cui JX, Zhang KC, Gao YH, Song YN, Zhang L, Luo H, +Wei B, Xue WG, Chen L. [Analysis of clinicopathologic characteristics of gastric +cancer patients undergoing gastrectomy based on a single-center gastric cancer +database with above 10 000 cases]. Zhonghua Wei Chang Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2020 Nov +25;23(11):1051-1058. Chinese. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn.441530-20200117-00031. PMID: +33212553. + +327: Duarte GS, Rodrigues FB, Castelão M, Marques RE, Ferreira J, Sampaio C, +Moore AP, Costa J. Botulinum toxin type A therapy for hemifacial spasm. Cochrane +Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 19;11:CD004899. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004899.pub3. +PMID: 33211908. + +328: Duarte GS, Rodrigues FB, Marques RE, Castelão M, Ferreira J, Sampaio C, +Moore AP, Costa J. Botulinum toxin type A therapy for blepharospasm. Cochrane +Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 19;11:CD004900. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004900.pub3. +PMID: 33211907. + +329: Ipsen EØ, Madsen KS, Chi Y, Pedersen-Bjergaard U, Richter B, Metzendorf MI, +Hemmingsen B. Pioglitazone for prevention or delay of type 2 diabetes mellitus +and its associated complications in people at risk for the development of type 2 +diabetes mellitus. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 19;11:CD013516. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD013516.pub2. PMID: 33210751. + +330: Tomita Y, Moldovan M, Chang Lee R, Hsieh AH, Townsend A, Price T. Salvage +systemic therapy for advanced gastric and oesophago-gastric junction +adenocarcinoma. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 19;11:CD012078. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD012078.pub2. PMID: 33210731. + +331: Panin SI, Postolov MP, Kovalenko NV, Beburishvili AG, Fedorov AV, Bykov AV. +Sravnitel'naya otsenka subtotal'noi distal'noi rezektsii i gastrektomii v +khirurgicheskom lechenie bol'nykh rakom zheludka [Distal subtotal gastrectomy +and gastreectomy in surgical treatment of patients with gastric cancer: a +systematic review and meta-analysis]. Khirurgiia (Mosk). 2020;(11):93-100. +Russian. doi: 10.17116/hirurgia202011193. PMID: 33210514. + +332: Bugge C, Adams EJ, Gopinath D, Stewart F, Dembinsky M, Sobiesuo P, Kearney +R. Pessaries (mechanical devices) for managing pelvic organ prolapse in women. +Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 18;11:CD004010. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD004010.pub4. PMID: 33207004. + +333: Rittiphairoj T, Mir TA, Li T, Virgili G. Intravitreal steroids for macular +edema in diabetes. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 17;11:CD005656. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD005656.pub3. PMID: 33206392. + +334: Chen I, Veth VB, Choudhry AJ, Murji A, Zakhari A, Black AY, Agarpao C, Maas +JW. Pre- and postsurgical medical therapy for endometriosis surgery. Cochrane +Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 18;11:CD003678. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003678.pub3. +PMID: 33206374. + +335: Chiu HC, Ada L, Bania TA. Mechanically assisted walking training for +walking, participation, and quality of life in children with cerebral palsy. +Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 18;11:CD013114. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD013114.pub2. PMID: 33202482. + +336: Li H, Hu Y, Tang H, Li S, Ding H, Zhai S, Zhao R. The Potential of +Glycyrrhizinate in the Management of COVID-19: A Systematic Review of the +Efficacy and Safety of Glycyrrhizin Preparations in the Treatment of SARS and +MERS. Am J Chin Med. 2020;48(7):1539-1552. doi: 10.1142/S0192415X20500767. Epub +2020 Nov 13. PMID: 33202150. + +337: Thomson J, Hogan S, Leonardi-Bee J, Williams HC, Bath-Hextall FJ. +Interventions for basal cell carcinoma of the skin. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. +2020 Nov 17;11:CD003412. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003412.pub3. PMID: 33202063. + +338: Khattri S, Kumbargere Nagraj S, Arora A, Eachempati P, Kusum CK, Bhat KG, +Johnson TM, Lodi G. Adjunctive systemic antimicrobials for the non-surgical +treatment of periodontitis. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 16;11:CD012568. +doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012568.pub2. PMID: 33197289. + +339: Lazarus JV, Palayew A, Rasmussen LN, Andersen TH, Nicholson J, Norgaard O. +Searching PubMed to Retrieve Publications on the COVID-19 Pandemic: Comparative +Analysis of Search Strings. J Med Internet Res. 2020 Nov 26;22(11):e23449. doi: +10.2196/23449. PMID: 33197230; PMCID: PMC7695541. + +340: Abdel-Rahman O, Elsayed Z. Yttrium-90 microsphere radioembolisation for +unresectable hepatocellular carcinoma. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov +16;11:CD011313. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011313.pub4. PMID: 33197051. + +341: Zhao J, Chen M, Zhuo C, Huang Y, Zheng L, Wang Q. The Effect of Renin- +Angiotensin System Inhibitors on the Recurrence of Atrial Fibrillation After +Catheter Ablation. Int Heart J. 2020 Nov 28;61(6):1174-1182. doi: +10.1536/ihj.20-346. Epub 2020 Nov 13. PMID: 33191354. + +342: Shinohara H, Kodera S, Kiyosue A, Ando J, Morita H, Komuro I. Efficacy of +Fractional Flow Reserve-Guided Percutaneous Cornary Intervention for Patients +with Angina Pectoris. Int Heart J. 2020 Nov 28;61(6):1097-1106. doi: +10.1536/ihj.20-023. Epub 2020 Nov 13. PMID: 33191337. + +343: Zhang J, He Y, Huang X, Liu Y, Yu H. The effects of acupuncture versus +sham/placebo acupuncture for insomnia: A systematic review and meta-analysis of +randomized controlled trials. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101253. +doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101253. Epub 2020 Nov 1. PMID: 33186824. + +344: Ball L, Almondo C, Pelosi P. Perioperative Lung Protection: General +Mechanisms and Protective Approaches. Anesth Analg. 2020 Dec;131(6):1789-1798. +doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000005246. PMID: 33186165. + +345: Juffermans NP, van den Brom CE, Kleinveld DJB. Targeting Endothelial +Dysfunction in Acute Critical Illness to Reduce Organ Failure. Anesth Analg. +2020 Dec;131(6):1708-1720. doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000005023. PMID: 33186159. + +346: Elsner B, Kugler J, Pohl M, Mehrholz J. Transcranial direct current +stimulation (tDCS) for improving activities of daily living, and physical and +cognitive functioning, in people after stroke. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 +Nov 11;11:CD009645. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009645.pub4. PMID: 33175411. + +347: Moresco L, Bruschettini M, Calevo MG, Siri L. Pharmacological treatment for +continuous spike-wave during slow wave sleep syndrome and Landau-Kleffner +Syndrome. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 6;11:CD013132. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD013132.pub2. PMID: 33174224. + +348: Oladapo OT, Okusanya BO, Abalos E, Gallos ID, Papadopoulou A. Intravenous +versus intramuscular prophylactic oxytocin for the third stage of labour. +Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 9;11:CD009332. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD009332.pub4. PMID: 33169839. + +349: Semlitsch T, Engler J, Siebenhofer A, Jeitler K, Berghold A, Horvath K. +(Ultra-)long-acting insulin analogues versus NPH insulin (human isophane +insulin) for adults with type 2 diabetes mellitus. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. +2020 Nov 9;11:CD005613. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD005613.pub4. PMID: 33166419. + +350: Minozzi S, Amato L, Jahanfar S, Bellisario C, Ferri M, Davoli M. +Maintenance agonist treatments for opiate-dependent pregnant women. Cochrane +Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 9;11:CD006318. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD006318.pub4. +PMID: 33165953. + +351: Gana JC, Cifuentes LI, Gattini D, Torres-Robles R. Band ligation versus +sclerotherapy for primary prophylaxis of oesophageal variceal bleeding in +children with chronic liver disease or portal vein thrombosis. Cochrane Database +Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 6;11:CD011803. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011803.pub2. PMID: +33164205. + +352: Uhlig K, Efremov L, Tongers J, Frantz S, Mikolajczyk R, Sedding D, Schumann +J. Inotropic agents and vasodilator strategies for the treatment of cardiogenic +shock or low cardiac output syndrome. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov +5;11:CD009669. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009669.pub4. PMID: 33152122. + +353: Yue JL, Yan W, Sun YK, Yuan K, Su SZ, Han Y, Ravindran AV, Kosten T, +Everall I, Davey CG, Bullmore E, Kawakami N, Barbui C, Thornicroft G, Lund C, +Lin X, Liu L, Shi L, Shi J, Ran MS, Bao YP, Lu L. Mental health services for +infectious disease outbreaks including COVID-19: a rapid systematic review. +Psychol Med. 2020 Nov;50(15):2498-2513. doi: 10.1017/S0033291720003888. Epub +2020 Nov 5. PMID: 33148347; PMCID: PMC7642960. + +354: Liang N, Li H, Wang J, Jiao L, Ma Y, Wang X, Liu B, Luo X, Zhao S, Lv M, +Cao J, Hu W, Zhang H, Xiong Y, Tian Y, Chen Y, Wang Y, Shi N. Development of +Rapid Advice Guidelines for the Treatment of Coronavirus Disease 2019 with +Traditional Chinese Medicine. Am J Chin Med. 2020;48(7):1511-1521. doi: +10.1142/S0192415X20500743. Epub 2020 Nov 5. PMID: 33148006. + +355: Benstoem C, Kalvelage C, Breuer T, Heussen N, Marx G, Stoppe C, Brandenburg +V. Ivabradine as adjuvant treatment for chronic heart failure. Cochrane Database +Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 4;11:CD013004. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013004.pub2. PMID: +33147368. + +356: Agarwal R, Choi L, Johnson S, Takwoingi Y. Rapid diagnostic tests for +Plasmodium vivax malaria in endemic countries. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 +Nov 4;11:CD013218. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013218.pub2. PMID: 33146932. + +357: Kashbour W, Gupta P, Worthington HV, Boyers D. Pit and fissure sealants +versus fluoride varnishes for preventing dental decay in the permanent teeth of +children and adolescents. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 4;11:CD003067. +doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003067.pub5. PMID: 33142363. + +358: Baugh JJ, White BA, Biddinger PD, Raja AS, Wittbold KA, Sonis JD, Yun BJ. +To solve our new emergency care crisis, let's start with the old one. Am J Emerg +Med. 2020 Oct;38(10):2000-2001. doi: 10.1016/j.ajem.2020.06.036. Epub 2020 Jun +25. PMID: 33142164; PMCID: PMC7315955. + +359: Rueda JR, Mugueta-Aguinaga I, Vilaró J, Rueda-Etxebarria M. Myofunctional +therapy (oropharyngeal exercises) for obstructive sleep apnoea. Cochrane +Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 3;11:CD013449. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013449.pub2. +PMID: 33141943. + +360: Martinez-Zapata MJ, Vernooij RW, Simancas-Racines D, Uriona Tuma SM, Stein +AT, Moreno Carriles RMM, Vargas E, Bonfill Cosp X. Phlebotonics for venous +insufficiency. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 3;11:CD003229. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD003229.pub4. PMID: 33141449. + +361: Ni WW, Leong S, Irani F, Patel A, Damodharan K, Venkataranasimha N, +Chandramohan S, Kumar P, Chua J, Gogna A, Da Zhuang K, Chong TT, Tang TY, Chng +SP, Tay KH. "Angioplasty-First" Approach for Limb Salvage in Asian Patients with +Critical Limb Ischemia: Outcomes from 3,303 Angioplasties on 2,402 Limbs in a +Single Tertiary Hospital. J Vasc Interv Radiol. 2020 Dec;31(12):1969-1977.e1. +doi: 10.1016/j.jvir.2020.08.008. Epub 2020 Nov 1. PMID: 33139186. + +362: Bardac OD, Baciu AB, Bogdan-Duică IS. Anal Metastasis from Lung Cancer: +Report of a Case and Systematic Review of the Literature. Chirurgia (Bucur). +2020 Sept-Oct;115(5):681-689. doi: 10.21614/chirurgia.115.5.681. PMID: 33138907. + +363: Mrzljak A, Novak R, Mikulic D. Publication Activity on Liver +Transplantation from Southeastern European Countries: A Bibliometric Analysis. +Chirurgia (Bucur). 2020 Sept-Oct;115(5):635-642. doi: +10.21614/chirurgia.115.5.635. PMID: 33138901. + +364: Rosendahl K, Lundestad A, Bjørlykke JA, Lein RK, Angenete O, Augdal TA, +Müller LO, Jaramillo D. Revisiting the radiographic assessment of osteoporosis- +Osteopenia in children 0-2 years of age. A systematic review. PLoS One. 2020 Nov +2;15(11):e0241635. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0241635. PMID: 33137162; PMCID: +PMC7605664. + +365: Puntis S, Minichino A, De Crescenzo F, Cipriani A, Lennox B, Harrison R. +Specialised early intervention teams (extended time) for recent-onset psychosis. +Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 2;11:CD013287. doi: +10.1002/14651858.CD013287.pub2. PMID: 33135812. + +366: Puntis S, Minichino A, De Crescenzo F, Cipriani A, Lennox B, Harrison R. +Specialised early intervention teams for recent-onset psychosis. Cochrane +Database Syst Rev. 2020 Nov 2;11:CD013288. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013288.pub2. +PMID: 33135811. + +367: Talebi F, Malchi F, Abedi P, Jahanfar S. Effect of dill (Anethum Graveolens +Linn) seed on the duration of labor: A systematic review. Complement Ther Clin +Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101251. doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101251. Epub 2020 Oct 28. +PMID: 33130423. + +368: McNerney NA, Losensky MJ, Lash MM, Rozaieski KR, Ortiz D, Garcia AN, +Rethorn ZD. Low theoretical fidelity hinders the research on health coaching for +opioid reduction: A systematic review of randomized controlled trials. PLoS One. +2020 Oct 29;15(10):e0241434. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0241434. PMID: 33119705; +PMCID: PMC7595321. + +369: Zhu S, Liu L, Xu Y, Yang Y, Shi R. Application of controlled release urea +improved grain yield and nitrogen use efficiency: A meta-analysis. PLoS One. +2020 Oct 29;15(10):e0241481. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0241481. PMID: 33119693; +PMCID: PMC7595396. + +370: Abed Al Ahad M, Sullivan F, Demšar U, Melhem M, Kulu H. The effect of air- +pollution and weather exposure on mortality and hospital admission and +implications for further research: A systematic scoping review. PLoS One. 2020 +Oct 29;15(10):e0241415. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0241415. PMID: 33119678; +PMCID: PMC7595412. + +371: Stresman G, Whittaker C, Slater HC, Bousema T, Cook J. Quantifying +Plasmodium falciparum infections clustering within households to inform +household-based intervention strategies for malaria control programs: An +observational study and meta-analysis from 41 malaria-endemic countries. PLoS +Med. 2020 Oct 29;17(10):e1003370. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1003370. PMID: +33119589; PMCID: PMC7595326. + +372: Captieux M, Prigge R, Wild S, Guthrie B. Defining remission of type 2 +diabetes in research studies: A systematic scoping review. PLoS Med. 2020 Oct +28;17(10):e1003396. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1003396. PMID: 33112845; PMCID: +PMC7592769. + +373: Sterzenbach T, Helbig R, Hannig C, Hannig M. Bioadhesion in the oral cavity +and approaches for biofilm management by surface modifications. Clin Oral +Investig. 2020 Dec;24(12):4237-4260. doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03646-1. Epub 2020 +Oct 27. PMID: 33111157; PMCID: PMC7666681. + +374: King MD, Elliott JE, Williams TD. Effects of petroleum exposure on birds: A +review. Sci Total Environ. 2021 Feb 10;755(Pt 1):142834. doi: +10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142834. Epub 2020 Oct 8. PMID: 33109373. + +375: Tiseo C, Vacca A, Felbush A, Filimonova T, Gai A, Glazyrina T, Hubalek IA, +Marchenko Y, Overeem LH, Piroso S, Tkachev A, Martelletti P, Sacco S; European +Headache Federation School of Advanced Studies (EHF-SAS). Migraine and sleep +disorders: a systematic review. J Headache Pain. 2020 Oct 27;21(1):126. doi: +10.1186/s10194-020-01192-5. PMID: 33109076; PMCID: PMC7590682. + +376: Shauly O, Stone G, Gould D. The Public's Perception of the Severity and +Global Impact at the Start of the SARS-CoV-2 Pandemic: A Crowdsourcing-Based +Cross-Sectional Analysis. J Med Internet Res. 2020 Nov 26;22(11):e19768. doi: +10.2196/19768. PMID: 33108314; PMCID: PMC7695545. + +377: Liu JH, Xiong Y, Hu ZY, Jiang DF. [Systematic review of the qualitative +researches on care experience of caregivers of burn children]. Zhonghua Shao +Shang Za Zhi. 2020 Oct 20;36(10):959-965. Chinese. doi: +10.3760/cma.j.cn501120-20200108-00013. PMID: 33105949. + +378: Alemu AY, Endalamaw A, Belay DM, Mekonen DK, Birhan BM, Bayih WA. +Healthcare-associated infection and its determinants in Ethiopia: A systematic +review and meta-analysis. PLoS One. 2020 Oct 23;15(10):e0241073. doi: +10.1371/journal.pone.0241073. PMID: 33095807; PMCID: PMC7584210. + +379: Escontrías OA, Istrate E, Stewart DCL. Curricular and clinical approaches +to addressing the opioid epidemic: Results from the 2019 ADEA opioid dental +school survey. J Dent Educ. 2020 Dec;84(12):1359-1367. doi: 10.1002/jdd.12452. +Epub 2020 Oct 22. PMID: 33089898. + +380: de França AJB, Costa RTF, Monteiro JLGC, Rocha NS, do Egito Vasconcelos BC, +de Moraes SLD. Comparison of three anesthetic techniques for the removal of +posterior mandibular teeth with 2% lidocaine: a systematic review. Clin Oral +Investig. 2020 Dec;24(12):4143-4152. doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03580-2. Epub 2020 +Oct 22. PMID: 33089877. + +381: Lopes LCP, Terada RSS, Tsuzuki FM, Giannini M, Hirata R. Heating and +preheating of dental restorative materials-a systematic review. Clin Oral +Investig. 2020 Dec;24(12):4225-4235. doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03637-2. Epub 2020 +Oct 20. PMID: 33083851. + +382: Newland P, Bettencourt BA. Effectiveness of mindfulness-based art therapy +for symptoms of anxiety, depression, and fatigue: A systematic review and meta- +analysis. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101246. doi: +10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101246. Epub 2020 Oct 13. PMID: 33075726. + +383: Leisman DE, Ronner L, Pinotti R, Taylor MD, Sinha P, Calfee CS, Hirayama +AV, Mastroiani F, Turtle CJ, Harhay MO, Legrand M, Deutschman CS. Cytokine +elevation in severe and critical COVID-19: a rapid systematic review, meta- +analysis, and comparison with other inflammatory syndromes. Lancet Respir Med. +2020 Dec;8(12):1233-1244. doi: 10.1016/S2213-2600(20)30404-5. Epub 2020 Oct 16. +PMID: 33075298; PMCID: PMC7567529. + +384: Mousa A, Al-Taiar A, Anstey NM, Badaut C, Barber BE, Bassat Q, Challenger +JD, Cunnington AJ, Datta D, Drakeley C, Ghani AC, Gordeuk VR, Grigg MJ, Hugo P, +John CC, Mayor A, Migot-Nabias F, Opoka RO, Pasvol G, Rees C, Reyburn H, Riley +EM, Shah BN, Sitoe A, Sutherland CJ, Thuma PE, Unger SA, Viwami F, Walther M, +Whitty CJM, William T, Okell LC. The impact of delayed treatment of +uncomplicated P. falciparum malaria on progression to severe malaria: A +systematic review and a pooled multicentre individual-patient meta-analysis. +PLoS Med. 2020 Oct 19;17(10):e1003359. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1003359. PMID: +33075101; PMCID: PMC7571702. + +385: Sanchez C, Jaguan D, Shaikh S, McKenney M, Elkbuli A. A systematic review +of the causes and prevention strategies in reducing gun violence in the United +States. Am J Emerg Med. 2020 Oct;38(10):2169-2178. doi: +10.1016/j.ajem.2020.06.062. Epub 2020 Jun 27. PMID: 33071102. + +386: Zhao H, Fan K, Feng G. Amiodarone and/or lidocaine for cardiac arrest: A +Bayesian network meta-analysis. Am J Emerg Med. 2020 Oct;38(10):2185-2193. doi: +10.1016/j.ajem.2020.06.074. Epub 2020 Jul 5. PMID: 33071078. + +387: Alshami A, Einav S, Skrifvars MB, Varon J. Administration of inhaled noble +and other gases after cardiopulmonary resuscitation: A systematic review. Am J +Emerg Med. 2020 Oct;38(10):2179-2184. doi: 10.1016/j.ajem.2020.06.066. Epub 2020 +Jul 2. PMID: 33071073. + +388: Gomes EWB, Casarin M, Martins TM, da Silva AF. Local delivery therapies as +adjuvants to non-surgical periodontal treatment of periodontitis grade C: a +systematic review. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Dec;24(12):4213-4224. doi: +10.1007/s00784-020-03631-8. Epub 2020 Oct 17. PMID: 33070281. + +389: Cantini F, Goletti D, Petrone L, Najafi Fard S, Niccoli L, Foti R. Immune +Therapy, or Antiviral Therapy, or Both for COVID-19: A Systematic Review. Drugs. +2020 Dec;80(18):1929-1946. doi: 10.1007/s40265-020-01421-w. PMID: 33068263; +PMCID: PMC7568461. + +390: Zheng JS, Luan J, Sofianopoulou E, Sharp SJ, Day FR, Imamura F, Gundersen +TE, Lotta LA, Sluijs I, Stewart ID, Shah RL, van der Schouw YT, Wheeler E, +Ardanaz E, Boeing H, Dorronsoro M, Dahm CC, Dimou N, El-Fatouhi D, Franks PW, +Fagherazzi G, Grioni S, Huerta JM, Heath AK, Hansen L, Jenab M, Jakszyn P, Kaaks +R, Kühn T, Khaw KT, Laouali N, Masala G, Nilsson PM, Overvad K, Olsen A, Panico +S, Quirós JR, Rolandsson O, Rodríguez-Barranco M, Sacerdote C, Spijkerman AMW, +Tong TYN, Tumino R, Tsilidis KK, Danesh J, Riboli E, Butterworth AS, Langenberg +C, Forouhi NG, Wareham NJ. The association between circulating 25-hydroxyvitamin +D metabolites and type 2 diabetes in European populations: A meta-analysis and +Mendelian randomisation analysis. PLoS Med. 2020 Oct 16;17(10):e1003394. doi: +10.1371/journal.pmed.1003394. PMID: 33064751; PMCID: PMC7567390. + +391: Heckwolf MJ, Peterson A, Jänes H, Horne P, Künne J, Liversage K, Sajeva M, +Reusch TBH, Kotta J. From ecosystems to socio-economic benefits: A systematic +review of coastal ecosystem services in the Baltic Sea. Sci Total Environ. 2021 +Feb 10;755(Pt 2):142565. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142565. Epub 2020 Sep 30. +PMID: 33059139. + +392: Hu H, Feng C, Jiang Z, Wang L, Shrestha S, Yan J, Shu Y, Ge L, Lai W, Hua +F, Long H. Effectiveness of remineralizing agents in the prevention and reversal +of orthodontically induced white spot lesions: a systematic review and network +meta-analysis. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Dec;24(12):4153-4167. doi: +10.1007/s00784-020-03610-z. Epub 2020 Oct 15. PMID: 33057826. + +393: Hong DW, Lin XJ, Wiegand A, Yu H. Does delayed toothbrushing after the +consumption of erosive foodstuffs or beverages decrease erosive tooth wear? A +systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 +Dec;24(12):4169-4183. doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03614-9. Epub 2020 Oct 14. PMID: +33052542. + +394: Moraitis AA, Shreeve N, Sovio U, Brocklehurst P, Heazell AEP, Thornton JG, +Robson SC, Papageorghiou A, Smith GC. Universal third-trimester ultrasonic +screening using fetal macrosomia in the prediction of adverse perinatal outcome: +A systematic review and meta-analysis of diagnostic test accuracy. PLoS Med. +2020 Oct 13;17(10):e1003190. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1003190. PMID: 33048935; +PMCID: PMC7553291. + +395: Mytton OT, Boyland E, Adams J, Collins B, O'Connell M, Russell SJ, Smith K, +Stroud R, Viner RM, Cobiac LJ. The potential health impact of restricting less- +healthy food and beverage advertising on UK television between 05.30 and 21.00 +hours: A modelling study. PLoS Med. 2020 Oct 13;17(10):e1003212. doi: +10.1371/journal.pmed.1003212. PMID: 33048922; PMCID: PMC7553286. + +396: Martin JM, Goldstein LJ. In Support of CDK4/6 Inhibitors-A Meta-analysis of +Available Randomized Data. JAMA Netw Open. 2020 Oct 1;3(10):e2021062. doi: +10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.21062. PMID: 33048125. + +397: Clark HA, Martin PK, Okut H, Schroeder RW. A Systematic Review and Meta- +Analysis of the Utility of the Test of Memory Malingering in Pediatric +Examinees. Arch Clin Neuropsychol. 2020 Nov 19;35(8):1312-1322. doi: +10.1093/arclin/acaa075. PMID: 33047780. + +398: Felsenreich DM, Gachabayov M, Rojas A, Latifi R, Bergamaschi R. Meta- +analysis of Postoperative Mortality and Morbidity After Total Abdominal +Colectomy Versus Loop Ileostomy With Colonic Lavage for Fulminant Clostridium +Difficile Colitis. Dis Colon Rectum. 2020 Sep;63(9):1317-1326. doi: +10.1097/DCR.0000000000001764. PMID: 33044807. + +399: Trentino KM, Farmer SL, Isbister JP, Sanfilippo FM, Leahy MF, Hofmann A, +Shander A, Murray K. Restrictive Versus Liberal Transfusion Trials: Are They +Asking the Right Question? Anesth Analg. 2020 Dec;131(6):1950-1955. doi: +10.1213/ANE.0000000000005227. PMID: 33044262. + +400: Bansal A, Singh AD, Jain V, Aggarwal M, Gupta S, Padappayil RP, Nadeem M, +Joshi S, Mian A, Greathouse T, Wells D, Gupta M, Khan MZ. The association of +D-dimers with mortality, intensive care unit admission or acute respiratory +distress syndrome in patients hospitalized with coronavirus disease 2019 +(COVID-19): A systematic review and meta-analysis. Heart Lung. 2021 Jan- +Feb;50(1):9-12. doi: 10.1016/j.hrtlng.2020.08.024. Epub 2020 Sep 18. PMID: +33041057; PMCID: PMC7500895. + +401: Li Y, Xia G, Tan Y, Shuai J. Acupoint stimulation and Chinese herbal +medicines for the treatment of premature ovarian insufficiency: A systematic +review and meta-analysis. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101244. doi: +10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101244. Epub 2020 Oct 7. PMID: 33039750. + +402: Santiago-Colón A, Daniels R, Reissman D, Anderson K, Calvert G, Caplan A, +Carreón T, Katruska A, Kubale T, Liu R, Nembhard R, Robison WA, Yiin J, Howard +J. World Trade Center Health Program: First Decade of Research. Int J Environ +Res Public Health. 2020 Oct 6;17(19):7290. doi: 10.3390/ijerph17197290. PMID: +33036199; PMCID: PMC7579473. + +403: Zhang X, Song J, Wang Y, Deng W, Liu Y. Effects of land use on slope runoff +and soil loss in the Loess Plateau of China: A meta-analysis. Sci Total Environ. +2021 Feb 10;755(Pt 1):142418. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142418. Epub 2020 +Sep 22. PMID: 33035990. + +404: Gissi E, Manea E, Mazaris AD, Fraschetti S, Almpanidou V, Bevilacqua S, +Coll M, Guarnieri G, Lloret-Lloret E, Pascual M, Petza D, Rilov G, Schonwald M, +Stelzenmüller V, Katsanevakis S. A review of the combined effects of climate +change and other local human stressors on the marine environment. Sci Total +Environ. 2021 Feb 10;755(Pt 1):142564. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142564. +Epub 2020 Sep 29. PMID: 33035971. + +405: Emadzadeh M, Rashidmayvan M, Sahebi R, Sadeghi R, Ferns GA, Ghayour- +Mobarhan M. The effect of vitamin D fortified products on anthropometric +indices: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 +Nov;41:101242. doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101242. Epub 2020 Sep 23. PMID: +33035745. + +406: Banothu KK, Bhat JI, Das RR, Dhochak N, Ghimire JJ, Goyal JP, Gulla KM, +Gupta S, Jat KR, Kabra SK, Kalyan P, Kumar A, Kumar P, Kumar V, Lodha R, Mathew +JL, Pathania A, Ratageri VH, Singh V, Warankar S. Expert Opinion on Restoration +of Pediatric Pulmonology Services During the SARS-CoV-2 Pandemic. Indian +Pediatr. 2020 Nov 15;57(11):1055-1059. doi: 10.1007/s13312-020-2035-z. Epub 2020 +Sep 16. PMID: 33034302; PMCID: PMC7678585. + +407: Wang H, Lu F, Guo M, Fan W, Ji W, Dong Z. Associations between +PM1 exposure and daily emergency department visits in 19 hospitals, +Beijing. Sci Total Environ. 2021 Feb 10;755(Pt 1):142507. doi: +10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142507. Epub 2020 Sep 25. PMID: 33032134. + +408: Luo L, Fu M, Li Y, Hu S, Luo J, Chen Z, Yu J, Li W, Dong R, Yang Y, Tu L, +Xu X. The potential association between common comorbidities and severity and +mortality of coronavirus disease 2019: A pooled analysis. Clin Cardiol. 2020 +Dec;43(12):1478-1493. doi: 10.1002/clc.23465. Epub 2020 Oct 7. PMID: 33026120; +PMCID: PMC7675427. + +409: St Jeor JD, Reisenauer CJ, Andrews JC, Fleming CJ, Misra S, Takahashi EA. +Transjugular Renal Biopsy Bleeding Risk and Diagnostic Yield: A Systematic +Review. J Vasc Interv Radiol. 2020 Dec;31(12):2106-2112. doi: +10.1016/j.jvir.2020.07.016. Epub 2020 Oct 3. PMID: 33023806. + +410: Francisco Mora C, Ibáñez A, Balcells-Balcells A. State of the Art of Family +Quality of Life in Early Care and Disability: A Systematic Review. Int J Environ +Res Public Health. 2020 Oct 2;17(19):7220. doi: 10.3390/ijerph17197220. PMID: +33023172; PMCID: PMC7578947. + +411: Ogonowska-Slodownik A, Richley Geigle P, Morgulec-Adamowicz N. Head-Out +Water-Based Protocols to Assess Cardiorespiratory Fitness-Systematic Review. Int +J Environ Res Public Health. 2020 Oct 2;17(19):7215. doi: +10.3390/ijerph17197215. PMID: 33023128; PMCID: PMC7579306. + +412: Guercio V, Pojum IC, Leonardi GS, Shrubsole C, Gowers AM, Dimitroulopoulou +S, Exley KS. Exposure to indoor and outdoor air pollution from solid fuel +combustion and respiratory outcomes in children in developed countries: a +systematic review and meta-analysis. Sci Total Environ. 2021 Feb 10;755(Pt +1):142187. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142187. Epub 2020 Sep 12. PMID: +33017761. + +413: Patil S, Warnakulasuriya S. Blood-based circulating microRNAs as potential +biomarkers for predicting the prognosis of head and neck cancer-a systematic +review. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3833-3841. doi: +10.1007/s00784-020-03608-7. Epub 2020 Oct 3. PMID: 33009627. + +414: Rostami M, Mansouritorghabeh H. D-dimer level in COVID-19 infection: a +systematic review. Expert Rev Hematol. 2020 Nov;13(11):1265-1275. doi: +10.1080/17474086.2020.1831383. Epub 2020 Oct 12. PMID: 32997543. + +415: Sanchez C, Grzenda A, Varias A, Widge AS, Carpenter LL, McDonald WM, +Nemeroff CB, Kalin NH, Martin G, Tohen M, Filippou-Frye M, Ramsey D, Linos E, +Mangurian C, Rodriguez CI. Social media recruitment for mental health research: +A systematic review. Compr Psychiatry. 2020 Nov;103:152197. doi: +10.1016/j.comppsych.2020.152197. Epub 2020 Aug 12. PMID: 32992073; PMCID: +PMC7704547. + +416: Skelton E, Drey N, Rutherford M, Ayers S, Malamateniou C. Electronic +consenting for conducting research remotely: A review of current practice and +key recommendations for using e-consenting. Int J Med Inform. 2020 +Nov;143:104271. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104271. Epub 2020 Sep 13. PMID: +32979650; PMCID: PMC7487205. + +417: Guo PP, Fan SL, Li P, Zhang XH, Liu N, Wang J, Chen DD, Sun WJ, Yu L, Yang +S, Zhang W. The effectiveness of massage on peri-operative anxiety in adults: A +meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and controlled clinical trials. +Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Nov;41:101240. doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101240. +Epub 2020 Sep 17. PMID: 32977216. + +418: da Costa RMB, Poluha RL, De la Torre Canales G, Junior JFS, Conti PCR, +Neppelenbroek KH, Porto VC. The effectiveness of microwave disinfection in +treating Candida-associated denture stomatitis: a systematic review and +metaanalysis. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3821-3832. doi: +10.1007/s00784-020-03599-5. Epub 2020 Sep 24. PMID: 32974776. + +419: Aminoshariae A, Kulild J, Fouad AF. The impact of cardiovascular disease +and endodontic outcome: a systematic review of longitudinal studies. Clin Oral +Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3813-3819. doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03596-8. Epub 2020 +Sep 23. PMID: 32965589. + +420: Shao DD, Achkar CM, Lai A, Srivastava S, Doan RN, Rodan LH, Chen AY; Brain +Development Study Group, Poduri A, Yang E, Walsh CA. Polymicrogyria is +Associated With Pathogenic Variants in PTEN. Ann Neurol. 2020 +Dec;88(6):1153-1164. doi: 10.1002/ana.25904. Epub 2020 Oct 8. PMID: 32959437. + +421: Pedersen V. Die (schwer) verletzte schwangere Patientin aus Sicht der +Unfallchirurgie [The (severely) injured pregnant patient from the perspective of +trauma surgery]. Unfallchirurg. 2020 Dec;123(12):911-921. German. doi: +10.1007/s00113-020-00868-6. PMID: 32955671. + +422: Silva K, Lee WK, Forbes A, Demmer RT, Barton C, Enticott J. Use and +performance of machine learning models for type 2 diabetes prediction in +community settings: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Med Inform. +2020 Nov;143:104268. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104268. Epub 2020 Sep 7. PMID: +32950874. + +423: Chisini LA, Cademartori MG, Conde MCM, Tovo-Rodrigues L, Correa MB. Genes +in the pathway of tooth mineral tissues and dental caries risk: a systematic +review and meta-analysis. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3723-3738. doi: +10.1007/s00784-019-03146-x. Epub 2020 Sep 18. PMID: 32945961. + +424: Bai L, Gao S, Burstein F, Kerr D, Buntine P, Law N. A systematic literature +review on unnecessary diagnostic testing: The role of ICT use. Int J Med Inform. +2020 Nov;143:104269. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104269. Epub 2020 Sep 8. PMID: +32927268. + +425: Hakimi AA, Armstrong WB. Hand Sanitizer in a Pandemic: Wrong Formulations +in the Wrong Hands. J Emerg Med. 2020 Nov;59(5):668-672. doi: +10.1016/j.jemermed.2020.07.018. Epub 2020 Sep 10. PMID: 32921540. + +426: Tehrani BN, Basir MB, Kapur NK. Acute myocardial infarction and cardiogenic +shock: Should we unload the ventricle before percutaneous coronary intervention? +Prog Cardiovasc Dis. 2020 Sep-Oct;63(5):607-622. doi: +10.1016/j.pcad.2020.09.001. Epub 2020 Sep 11. PMID: 32920027. + +427: Jimenez G, Spinazze P, Matchar D, Koh Choon Huat G, van der Kleij RMJJ, +Chavannes NH, Car J. Digital health competencies for primary healthcare +professionals: A scoping review. Int J Med Inform. 2020 Nov;143:104260. doi: +10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104260. Epub 2020 Aug 27. PMID: 32919345. + +428: Hasan SS, Kow CS, Hadi MA, Zaidi STR, Merchant HA. Mortality and Disease +Severity Among COVID-19 Patients Receiving Renin-Angiotensin System Inhibitors: +A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Am J Cardiovasc Drugs. 2020 +Dec;20(6):571-590. doi: 10.1007/s40256-020-00439-5. Epub 2020 Sep 12. PMID: +32918209; PMCID: PMC7486167. + +429: Lenihan D, Carver J, Porter C, Liu JE, Dent S, Thavendiranathan P, Mitchell +JD, Nohria A, Fradley MG, Pusic I, Stockerl-Goldstein K, Blaes A, Lyon AR, +Ganatra S, López-Fernández T, O'Quinn R, Minotti G, Szmit S, Cardinale D, +Alvarez-Cardona J, Curigliano G, Neilan TG, Herrmann J. Cardio-oncology care in +the era of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic: An International +Cardio-Oncology Society (ICOS) statement. CA Cancer J Clin. 2020 +Nov;70(6):480-504. doi: 10.3322/caac.21635. Epub 2020 Sep 10. PMID: 32910493. + +430: Aung Thein MZ, Pereira JV, Nitchingham A, Caplan GA. A call to action for +delirium research: Meta-analysis and regression of delirium associated +mortality. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Sep 7;20(1):325. doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01723-4. +PMID: 32894065; PMCID: PMC7487610. + +431: Walshaw EG, Smith M, Kanatas A, Rogers SN. Handle-On-QOL: a dedicated +quality of life resource following the diagnosis and treatment of head and neck +cancer. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 Nov;58(9):e25-e32. doi: +10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.05.013. Epub 2020 Sep 2. PMID: 32891434. + +432: Yaqi H, Nan J, Ying C, Xiaojun Z, Lijuan Z, Yulu W, Siqi W, Shixiang C, Yue +Z. Foot reflexology in the management of functional constipation: A systematic +review and meta-analysis. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Aug;40:101198. doi: +10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101198. Epub 2020 May 8. PMID: 32891277. + +433: Wang Q, Jiang X, Shen Y, Yao P, Chen J, Zhou Y, Gu Y, Qian Z, Cao X. +Effectiveness of exercise intervention on fall-related fractures in older +adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. +BMC Geriatr. 2020 Sep 4;20(1):322. doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01721-6. PMID: +32887571; PMCID: PMC7650290. + +434: Neame MT, Sefton G, Roberts M, Harkness D, Sinha IP, Hawcutt DB. Evaluating +health information technologies: A systematic review of framework +recommendations. Int J Med Inform. 2020 Oct;142:104247. doi: +10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104247. Epub 2020 Aug 14. PMID: 32871491. + +435: Chadalawada S, Sillau S, Archuleta S, Mundo W, Bandali M, Parra-Henao G, +Rodriguez-Morales AJ, Villamil-Gomez WE, Suárez JA, Shapiro L, Hotez PJ, Woc- +Colburn L, DeSanto K, Rassi A Jr, Franco-Paredes C, Henao-Martínez AF. Risk of +Chronic Cardiomyopathy Among Patients With the Acute Phase or Indeterminate Form +of Chagas Disease: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. JAMA Netw Open. 2020 +Aug 3;3(8):e2015072. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.15072. PMID: 32865573; +PMCID: PMC7489816. + +436: Godinho MA, Jonnagaddala J, Gudi N, Islam R, Narasimhan P, Liaw ST. mHealth +for Integrated People-Centred Health Services in the Western Pacific: A +Systematic Review. Int J Med Inform. 2020 Oct;142:104259. doi: +10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104259. Epub 2020 Aug 19. PMID: 32858339. + +437: Soni N, Ora M, Mohindra N, Menda Y, Bathla G. Diagnostic Performance of PET +and Perfusion-Weighted Imaging in Differentiating Tumor Recurrence or +Progression from Radiation Necrosis in Posttreatment Gliomas: A Review of +Literature. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2020 Sep;41(9):1550-1557. doi: +10.3174/ajnr.A6685. Epub 2020 Aug 27. PMID: 32855194; PMCID: PMC7583093. + +438: Lindt N, van Berkel J, Mulder BC. Determinants of overburdening among +informal carers: a systematic review. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Aug 26;20(1):304. doi: +10.1186/s12877-020-01708-3. PMID: 32847493; PMCID: PMC7448315. + +439: Kim Y, Vakula MN, Waller B, Bressel E. A systematic review and meta- +analysis comparing the effect of aquatic and land exercise on dynamic balance in +older adults. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Aug 25;20(1):302. doi: +10.1186/s12877-020-01702-9. PMID: 32842967; PMCID: PMC7446104. + +440: Davis SP, Bolin LP, Crane PB, Wei H, Crandell J. Non-pharmacological +interventions to manage fatigue in adults with inflammatory bowel disease: A +systematic review and meta-analysis. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 +Nov;41:101229. doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101229. Epub 2020 Aug 13. PMID: +32836107. + +441: Yang F, Gao Y, Zhang L, Zheng B, Wang L, Sun H, Huang D. Local anaesthesia +for surgical extraction of mandibular third molars: a systematic review and +network meta-analysis. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3781-3800. doi: +10.1007/s00784-020-03490-3. Epub 2020 Aug 24. PMID: 32833132. + +442: de Lima AKA, Amorim Dos Santos J, Stefani CM, Almeida de Lima A, Damé- +Teixeira N. Diabetes mellitus and poor glycemic control increase the occurrence +of coronal and root caries: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Oral +Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3801-3812. doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03531-x. Epub 2020 +Aug 22. PMID: 32829477. + +443: Abu-Elezz I, Hassan A, Nazeemudeen A, Househ M, Abd-Alrazaq A. The benefits +and threats of blockchain technology in healthcare: A scoping review. Int J Med +Inform. 2020 Oct;142:104246. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104246. Epub 2020 Aug +14. PMID: 32828033. + +444: Huang D, Zhang G, Yi J, Cheng M, Lai C, Xu P, Zhang C, Liu Y, Zhou C, Xue +W, Wang R, Li Z, Chen S. Progress and challenges of metal-organic frameworks- +based materials for SR-AOPs applications in water treatment. Chemosphere. 2021 +Jan;263:127672. doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.127672. Epub 2020 Aug 13. PMID: +32822945. + +445: Migliavaca CB, Stein C, Colpani V, Eibel B, Bgeginski R, Simões MV, Rohde +LE, Falavigna M. High-dose versus low-dose angiotensin converting enzyme +inhibitors in heart failure: systematic review and meta-analysis. Open Heart. +2020 Aug;7(2):e001228. doi: 10.1136/openhrt-2019-001228. PMID: 32820054; PMCID: +PMC7443275. + +446: Larson AS, Lehman VT, Lanzino G, Brinjikji W. Lack of Baseline Intracranial +Aneurysm Wall Enhancement Predicts Future Stability: A Systematic Review and +Meta-Analysis of Longitudinal Studies. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2020 +Sep;41(9):1606-1610. doi: 10.3174/ajnr.A6690. Epub 2020 Aug 20. PMID: 32819901; +PMCID: PMC7583099. + +447: Turan O, Hakim A, Dashraath P, Jeslyn WJL, Wright A, Abdul-Kadir R. +Clinical characteristics, prognostic factors, and maternal and neonatal outcomes +of SARS-CoV-2 infection among hospitalized pregnant women: A systematic review. +Int J Gynaecol Obstet. 2020 Oct;151(1):7-16. doi: 10.1002/ijgo.13329. Epub 2020 +Aug 30. PMID: 32816307. + +448: Towe M, Huynh LM, Osman MM, El-Khatib FM, Andrianne R, Barton G, Broderick +G, Burnett AL, Campbell JD, Clavell-Hernandez J, Connor J, Gross M, Guillum R, +Guise AI, Hatzichristodoulou G, Henry GD, Hsieh TC, Jenkins LC, Koprowski C, Lee +KB, Lentz A, Munarriz RM, Osmonov D, Pan S, Parikh K, Park SH, Patel AS, Perito +P, Sadeghi-Nejad H, Sempels M, Simhan J, Wang R, Yafi FA. Impact of +Antimicrobial Dipping Solutions on Postoperative Infection Rates in Patients +With Diabetes Undergoing Primary Insertion of a Coloplast Titan Inflatable +Penile Prosthesis. J Sex Med. 2020 Oct;17(10):2077-2083. doi: +10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.07.009. Epub 2020 Aug 15. PMID: 32807707. + +449: Pitros P, O'Connor N, Tryfonos A, Lopes V. A systematic review of the +complications of high-risk third molar removal and coronectomy: development of a +decision tree model and preliminary health economic analysis to assist in +treatment planning. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 Nov;58(9):e16-e24. doi: +10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.07.015. Epub 2020 Aug 14. PMID: 32800608. + +450: Yao LQ, Tan JY, Turner C, Wang T, Liu XL. Traditional Chinese exercise for +cancer-related sleep disturbance: A systematic review and descriptive analysis +of randomized controlled trials. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2020 Aug;40:101197. +doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2020.101197. Epub 2020 May 14. PMID: 32791319. + +451: Pellino G, Vaizey CJ, Maeda Y; European Society of Coloproctology (ESCP) +Guideline Committee. The COVID-19 pandemic: considerations for resuming normal +colorectal services. Colorectal Dis. 2020 Sep;22(9):1006-1014. doi: +10.1111/codi.15313. Epub 2020 Aug 28. PMID: 32790095; PMCID: PMC7436303. + +452: Alghamdi SM, Barker RE, Alsulayyim ASS, Alasmari AM, Banya WAS, Polkey MI, +Birring SS, Hopkinson NS. Use of oscillatory positive expiratory pressure (OPEP) +devices to augment sputum clearance in COPD: a systematic review and meta- +analysis. Thorax. 2020 Oct;75(10):855-863. doi: 10.1136/thoraxjnl-2019-214360. +Epub 2020 Aug 11. PMID: 32788259. + +453: Can A, Coskun H. The rationale of using mesenchymal stem cells in patients +with COVID-19-related acute respiratory distress syndrome: What to expect. Stem +Cells Transl Med. 2020 Nov;9(11):1287-1302. doi: 10.1002/sctm.20-0164. Epub 2020 +Jul 21. PMID: 32779878; PMCID: PMC7404450. + +454: Martínez-Jiménez F, Muiños F, Sentís I, Deu-Pons J, Reyes-Salazar I, +Arnedo-Pac C, Mularoni L, Pich O, Bonet J, Kranas H, Gonzalez-Perez A, Lopez- +Bigas N. A compendium of mutational cancer driver genes. Nat Rev Cancer. 2020 +Oct;20(10):555-572. doi: 10.1038/s41568-020-0290-x. Epub 2020 Aug 10. PMID: +32778778. + +455: Fuentes-Abolafio IJ, Stubbs B, Pérez-Belmonte LM, Bernal-López MR, Gómez- +Huelgas R, Cuesta-Vargas A. Functional parameters indicative of mild cognitive +impairment: a systematic review using instrumented kinematic assessment. BMC +Geriatr. 2020 Aug 10;20(1):282. doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01678-6. PMID: 32778071; +PMCID: PMC7418187. + +456: Davies A, Mueller J, Moulton G. Core competencies for clinical +informaticians: A systematic review. Int J Med Inform. 2020 Sep;141:104237. doi: +10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104237. Epub 2020 Jul 24. PMID: 32771960. + +457: Conover ZR, Talai A, Klockau KS, Ing RJ, Chatterjee D. Perioperative +Management of Children on Ketogenic Dietary Therapies. Anesth Analg. 2020 +Dec;131(6):1872-1882. doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000005018. PMID: 32769381. + +458: Barochiner J, Martínez R. Use of inhibitors of the renin-angiotensin system +in hypertensive patients and COVID-19 severity: A systematic review and meta- +analysis. J Clin Pharm Ther. 2020 Dec;45(6):1244-1252. doi: 10.1111/jcpt.13246. +Epub 2020 Aug 7. PMID: 32767823; PMCID: PMC7436708. + +459: Bai T, Fang F, Li F, Ren Y, Hu J, Cao J. Sarcopenia is associated with +hypertension in older adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC +Geriatr. 2020 Aug 6;20(1):279. doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01672-y. PMID: 32762638; +PMCID: PMC7409686. + +460: Crick M, Devey-Burry R, Hu J, Angus DE, Backman C. The role of regulation +in the care of older people with depression living in long-term care: a +systematic scoping review. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Aug 5;20(1):273. doi: +10.1186/s12877-020-01675-9. PMID: 32758157; PMCID: PMC7409447. + +461: Ashraf S, Al-Maweri SA, Alaizari N, Umair A, Ariffin Z, Alhajj MN, Kassim +S, Awan KH. The association between Epstein-Barr virus and oral lichen planus: A +systematic review and meta-analysis. J Oral Pathol Med. 2020 Nov;49(10):969-976. +doi: 10.1111/jop.13093. Epub 2020 Aug 24. PMID: 32746493. + +462: Lai S, Diao T, Zhang W, Seery S, Zhang Z, Hu M, Meng L, Ma T, Liu X, Wang +J, Zhang Y. Sexual Functions in Women With Stress Urinary Incontinence After +Mid-Urethral Sling Surgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Prospective +Randomized and Non-Randomized Studies. J Sex Med. 2020 Oct;17(10):1956-1970. +doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.07.003. Epub 2020 Jul 30. PMID: 32741744. + +463: Campbell RE, McGhee AN, Freedman KB, Tjoumakaris FP. Diagnostic Imaging of +Ulnar Collateral Ligament Injury: A Systematic Review. Am J Sports Med. 2020 +Sep;48(11):2819-2827. doi: 10.1177/0363546520937302. Epub 2020 Jul 31. PMID: +32735456. + +464: Wang Y, Zhou Q, Xu M, Kang J, Chen Y. Characteristics of Clinical Trials +relating to COVID-19 registered at ClinicalTrials.gov. J Clin Pharm Ther. 2020 +Dec;45(6):1357-1362. doi: 10.1111/jcpt.13222. Epub 2020 Jul 30. PMID: 32734670. + +465: Ostaszkiewicz J, Dickson-Swift V, Hutchinson A, Wagg A. A concept analysis +of dignity-protective continence care for care dependent older people in long- +term care settings. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Jul 29;20(1):266. doi: +10.1186/s12877-020-01673-x. PMID: 32727481; PMCID: PMC7392826. + +466: Veronese V, Ryan KE, Hughes C, Lim MS, Pedrana A, Stoové M. Using Digital +Communication Technology to Increase HIV Testing Among Men Who Have Sex With Men +and Transgender Women: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Med Internet Res. +2020 Jul 28;22(7):e14230. doi: 10.2196/14230. PMID: 32720902; PMCID: PMC7420634. + +467: Lu H, Xie J, Gerido LH, Cheng Y, Chen Y, Sun L. Information Needs of Breast +Cancer Patients: Theory-Generating Meta-Synthesis. J Med Internet Res. 2020 Jul +28;22(7):e17907. doi: 10.2196/17907. PMID: 32720899; PMCID: PMC7420822. + +468: Tay EL, Hayashida K, Chen M, Yin WH, Park DW, Seth A, Kao HL, Lin MS, Ho +KW, Buddhari W, Chandavimol M, Posas FE, Nguyen QN, Kong W, Rosli MA, Hon J, +Firman D, Lee M. Transcatheter aortic valve implantation during the COVID-19 +pandemic: Clinical expert opinion and consensus statement for Asia. J Card Surg. +2020 Sep;35(9):2142-2146. doi: 10.1111/jocs.14722. Epub 2020 Jul 27. PMID: +32720374. + +469: Spearman AD, Ginde S, Goot BH, Schaal AM, Feng M, Pan AY, Frommelt MA, +Frommelt PC. Echocardiographic Identification of Pulmonary Artery Flow Reversal: +An Indicator of Adverse Outcomes in Single Ventricle Physiology. Pediatr +Cardiol. 2020 Dec;41(8):1632-1638. doi: 10.1007/s00246-020-02421-z. Epub 2020 +Jul 24. PMID: 32710282. + +470: Al-Samarraie H, Ghazal S, Alzahrani AI, Moody L. Telemedicine in Middle +Eastern countries: Progress, barriers, and policy recommendations. Int J Med +Inform. 2020 Sep;141:104232. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104232. Epub 2020 Jul +15. PMID: 32707430. + +471: Kåks P, Målqvist M. Peer support for disadvantaged parents: a narrative +review of strategies used in home visiting health interventions in high-income +countries. BMC Health Serv Res. 2020 Jul 23;20(1):682. doi: +10.1186/s12913-020-05540-8. PMID: 32703302; PMCID: PMC7376883. + +472: Huang M, Li G, Liu J, Li Y, Du P. Is There an Association Between +Contraception and Sexual Dysfunction in Women? A Systematic Review and Meta- +analysis Based on Female Sexual Function Index. J Sex Med. 2020 +Oct;17(10):1942-1955. doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.06.008. Epub 2020 Jul 18. PMID: +32694069. + +473: Pool J, Akhlaghpour S, Fatehi F. Towards a contextual theory of Mobile +Health Data Protection (MHDP): A realist perspective. Int J Med Inform. 2020 +Sep;141:104229. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104229. Epub 2020 Jul 11. PMID: +32693246. + +474: Vargas KG, Jäger B, Kaufmann CC, Biagioli A, Watremez S, Gatto F, Özbek C, +Razouk A, Geppert A, Huber K. Impella in cardiogenic shock following acute +myocardial infarction: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Wien Klin +Wochenschr. 2020 Dec;132(23-24):716-725. doi: 10.1007/s00508-020-01712-y. Epub +2020 Jul 20. PMID: 32691215. + +475: Stockbridge J, Jones AR, Gillanders BM. A meta-analysis of multiple +stressors on seagrasses in the context of marine spatial cumulative impacts +assessment. Sci Rep. 2020 Jul 20;10(1):11934. doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-68801-w. +PMID: 32686719; PMCID: PMC7371696. + +476: Twigg JA, Anderson JM, Humphris G, Nixon I, Rogers SN, Kanatas A. Best +practice in reducing the suicide risk in head and neck cancer patients: a +structured review. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 Nov;58(9):e6-e15. doi: +10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.06.035. Epub 2020 Jul 15. PMID: 32682651. + +477: León-Salas B, Trujillo-Martín MM, Del Castillo LPM, García JG, Pérez-Ros P, +Ruiz FR, Serrano-Aguilar P. Pharmacologic interventions for prevention of +delirium in hospitalized older people: A meta-analysis. Arch Gerontol Geriatr. +2020 Sep-Oct;90:104171. doi: 10.1016/j.archger.2020.104171. Epub 2020 Jul 11. +PMID: 32682169. + +478: Amaral LKB, Souza MB, Campos MGM, Mendonça VA, Bastone A, Pereira LSM, +Mascarenhas RO, Oliveira VC. Efficacy of conservative therapy in older people +with nonspecific low back pain: A systematic review with meta-analysis and GRADE +recommendations. Arch Gerontol Geriatr. 2020 Sep-Oct;90:104177. doi: +10.1016/j.archger.2020.104177. Epub 2020 Jul 11. PMID: 32682168. + +479: Kocsis T, Molnár B, Németh D, Hegyi P, Szakács Z, Bálint A, Garami A, Soós +A, Márta K, Solymár M. Probiotics have beneficial metabolic effects in patients +with type 2 diabetes mellitus: a meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials. +Sci Rep. 2020 Jul 16;10(1):11787. doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-68440-1. PMID: +32678128; PMCID: PMC7366719. + +480: Ebrahimpour-Koujan S, Milajerdi A, Larijani B, Esmaillzadeh A. Effects of +probiotics on salivary cytokines and immunoglobulines: a systematic review and +meta-analysis on clinical trials. Sci Rep. 2020 Jul 16;10(1):11800. doi: +10.1038/s41598-020-67037-y. PMID: 32678117; PMCID: PMC7366729. + +481: Cong R, Wang Y, Wang Y, Zhang Q, Zhou X, Ji C, Yao L, Song N, Meng X. +Comprehensive Analysis of lncRNA Expression Pattern and lncRNA-miRNA-mRNA +Network in a Rat Model With Cavernous Nerve Injury Erectile Dysfunction. J Sex +Med. 2020 Sep;17(9):1603-1617. doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.05.008. Epub 2020 Jul +13. PMID: 32675050. + +482: Sumida K, Nadkarni GN, Grams ME, Sang Y, Ballew SH, Coresh J, Matsushita K, +Surapaneni A, Brunskill N, Chadban SJ, Chang AR, Cirillo M, Daratha KB, +Gansevoort RT, Garg AX, Iacoviello L, Kayama T, Konta T, Kovesdy CP, Lash J, Lee +BJ, Major RW, Metzger M, Miura K, Naimark DMJ, Nelson RG, Sawhney S, +Stempniewicz N, Tang M, Townsend RR, Traynor JP, Valdivielso JM, Wetzels J, +Polkinghorne KR, Heerspink HJL; Chronic Kidney Disease Prognosis Consortium. +Conversion of Urine Protein-Creatinine Ratio or Urine Dipstick Protein to Urine +Albumin-Creatinine Ratio for Use in Chronic Kidney Disease Screening and +Prognosis : An Individual Participant-Based Meta-analysis. Ann Intern Med. 2020 +Sep 15;173(6):426-435. doi: 10.7326/M20-0529. Epub 2020 Jul 14. PMID: 32658569. + +483: Rodriguez Socarrás M, Loeb S, Teoh JY, Ribal MJ, Bloemberg J, Catto J, +N'Dow J, Van Poppel H, Gómez Rivas J. Telemedicine and Smart Working: +Recommendations of the European Association of Urology. Eur Urol. 2020 +Dec;78(6):812-819. doi: 10.1016/j.eururo.2020.06.031. Epub 2020 Jul 10. PMID: +32654801; PMCID: PMC7347487. + +484: Smith TO, Sreekanta A, Walkeden S, Penhale B, Hanson S. Interventions for +reducing hospital-associated deconditioning: A systematic review and meta- +analysis. Arch Gerontol Geriatr. 2020 Sep-Oct;90:104176. doi: +10.1016/j.archger.2020.104176. Epub 2020 Jul 6. PMID: 32652367. + +485: Arca KN, Smith JH, Chiang CC, Starling AJ, Robertson CE, Halker Singh RB, +Schwedt TJ, Kissoon NR, Garza I, Rozen TD, Boes CJ, Whealy MA, VanderPluym JH. +COVID-19 and Headache Medicine: A Narrative Review of Non-Steroidal Anti- +Inflammatory Drug (NSAID) and Corticosteroid Use. Headache. 2020 +Sep;60(8):1558-1568. doi: 10.1111/head.13903. Epub 2020 Jul 10. PMID: 32648592; +PMCID: PMC7404408. + +486: Liang X, Huang L, Ou Y, He Y, Tang S. Association between MAFB rs17820943 +and rs6072081 polymorphism and risk of nonsyndromic cleft lip with or without +cleft palate: a meta-analysis. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 +Nov;58(9):1065-1072. doi: 10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.05.034. Epub 2020 Jul 6. PMID: +32646788. + +487: Crayton E, Richardson M, Fuller C, Smith C, Liu S, Forbes G, Anderson N, +Shallcross L, Michie S, Hayward A, Lorencatto F. Interventions to improve +appropriate antibiotic prescribing in long-term care facilities: a systematic +review. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Jul 9;20(1):237. doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01564-1. +PMID: 32646382; PMCID: PMC7350746. + +488: Shao JM, Ayuso SA, Deerenberg EB, Elhage SA, Augenstein VA, Heniford BT. A +systematic review of CT chest in COVID-19 diagnosis and its potential +application in a surgical setting. Colorectal Dis. 2020 Sep;22(9):993-1001. doi: +10.1111/codi.15252. Epub 2020 Aug 5. PMID: 32644268; PMCID: PMC7361755. + +489: Morales J, Shubrook JH, Skolnik N. Practical guidance for use of oral +semaglutide in primary care: a narrative review. Postgrad Med. 2020 +Nov;132(8):687-696. doi: 10.1080/00325481.2020.1788340. Epub 2020 Jul 9. PMID: +32643514. + +490: Almutairi H, Stafford A, Etherton-Beer C, Flicker L. Optimisation of +medications used in residential aged care facilities: a systematic review and +meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Jul +8;20(1):236. doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-01634-4. PMID: 32641005; PMCID: PMC7346508. + +491: Xu BC, Fu J, Zhu LY, Li Z, Wang YZ, Jin ML. Overall assessment of +antimicrobial peptides in piglets: a set of meta-analyses. Animal. 2020 +Dec;14(12):2463-2471. doi: 10.1017/S1751731120001640. Epub 2020 Jul 8. PMID: +32635952. + +492: Nascimento B, Miranda EP, Terrier JE, Carneiro F, Mulhall JP. A Critical +Analysis of Methodology Pitfalls in Duplex Doppler Ultrasound in the Evaluation +of Patients With Erectile Dysfunction: Technical and Interpretation +Deficiencies. J Sex Med. 2020 Aug;17(8):1416-1422. doi: +10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.05.023. Epub 2020 Jul 3. PMID: 32631763. + +493: Haddad R, Monaghan TF, Joussain C, Phé V, Bower W, Roggeman S, Robain G, +Everaert K. Nocturia in patients with cognitive dysfunction: a systematic review +of the literature. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Jul 6;20(1):230. doi: +10.1186/s12877-020-01622-8. PMID: 32631237; PMCID: PMC7336631. + +494: Kraiss JT, Ten Klooster PM, Moskowitz JT, Bohlmeijer ET. The relationship +between emotion regulation and well-being in patients with mental disorders: A +meta-analysis. Compr Psychiatry. 2020 Oct;102:152189. doi: +10.1016/j.comppsych.2020.152189. Epub 2020 Jun 18. PMID: 32629064. + +495: Carvalho LC, Nogueira HS, Minussi ART, Lima MB, Munari DP, Peruzzi NJ, +Silva EP. Genetic growth potential characterization in the Japanese quail: a +meta-analysis. Animal. 2020 Aug;14(S2):s341-s347. doi: +10.1017/S1751731120001202. Epub 2020 Jun 22. PMID: 32624080. + +496: Rezaee ME, Gross MS. Are We Overstating the Risk of Priapism With Oral +Phosphodiesterase Type 5 Inhibitors? J Sex Med. 2020 Aug;17(8):1579-1582. doi: +10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.05.019. Epub 2020 Jul 2. PMID: 32622767. + +497: Chen Z, Han D, Wang Q, Li L. Four interventions for pediatric femoral shaft +fractures: Network meta-analysis of randomized trials. Int J Surg. 2020 +Aug;80:53-60. doi: 10.1016/j.ijsu.2020.06.032. Epub 2020 Jul 1. PMID: 32622056. + +498: Novara G, Checcucci E, Crestani A, Abrate A, Esperto F, Pavan N, De Nunzio +C, Galfano A, Giannarini G, Gregori A, Liguori G, Bartoletti R, Porpiglia F, +Scarpa RM, Simonato A, Trombetta C, Tubaro A, Ficarra V; Research Urology +Network (RUN). Telehealth in Urology: A Systematic Review of the Literature. How +Much Can Telemedicine Be Useful During and After the COVID-19 Pandemic? Eur +Urol. 2020 Dec;78(6):786-811. doi: 10.1016/j.eururo.2020.06.025. Epub 2020 Jun +18. PMID: 32616405; PMCID: PMC7301090. + +499: Levine SL, Webb EG, Saltmiras DA. Review and analysis of the potential for +glyphosate to interact with the estrogen, androgen and thyroid pathways. Pest +Manag Sci. 2020 Sep;76(9):2886-2906. doi: 10.1002/ps.5983. Epub 2020 Jul 17. +PMID: 32608552. + +500: Bateki CA, van Dijk S, Wilkes A, Dickhoefer U, White R. Meta-analysis of +the effects of on-farm management strategies on milk yields of dairy cattle on +smallholder farms in the Tropics. Animal. 2020 Dec;14(12):2619-2627. doi: +10.1017/S1751731120001548. Epub 2020 Jun 30. PMID: 32600497; PMCID: PMC7645308. + +501: Leung YY, Wu FHW, Chan HH. Ultrasonography-guided arthrocentesis versus +conventional arthrocentesis in treating internal derangement of +temporomandibular joint: a systematic review. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 +Nov;24(11):3771-3780. doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03408-z. Epub 2020 Jun 27. PMID: +32594307. + +502: Langton S, Cousin GCS, Plüddemann A, Bankhead CR. Comparison of primary +care doctors and dentists in the referral of oral cancer: a systematic review. +Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 Oct;58(8):898-917. doi: +10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.06.009. Epub 2020 Jun 24. PMID: 32591210. + +503: Tran DTQ, Bradbury MI, Ogtrop FFV, Bozkurt H, Jones BJ, McCONCHIE R. +Environmental Drivers for Persistence of Escherichia coli and Salmonella in +Manure-Amended Soils: A Meta-Analysis. J Food Prot. 2020 Jul 1;83(7):1268-1277. +doi: 10.4315/0362-028X.JFP-19-460. PMID: 32577760. + +504: Rezende Oliveira S, Fernandes Araújo Almeida T, Aparecida da Silva T, Alves +Mesquita R, Guimarães Abreu L. Comparison of tissue artifacts in punch and +scalpel biopsies of oral and maxillofacial lesions: A systematic review and +meta-analysis. J Stomatol Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 Dec;121(6):704-712. doi: +10.1016/j.jormas.2020.06.005. Epub 2020 Jun 20. PMID: 32574868. + +505: Furness K, Sarkies MN, Huggins CE, Croagh D, Haines TP. Impact of the +Method of Delivering Electronic Health Behavior Change Interventions in +Survivors of Cancer on Engagement, Health Behaviors, and Health Outcomes: +Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Med Internet Res. 2020 Jun +23;22(6):e16112. doi: 10.2196/16112. PMID: 32574147; PMCID: PMC7381039. + +506: Peraza A, Gómez R, Beltran J, Amarista FJ. Mucoepidermoid carcinoma. An +update and review of the literature. J Stomatol Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 +Dec;121(6):713-720. doi: 10.1016/j.jormas.2020.06.003. Epub 2020 Jun 18. PMID: +32565266. + +507: Askar H, Misch J, Chen Z, Chadha S, Wang HL. Capnography monitoring in +procedural intravenous sedation: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin +Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3761-3770. doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03395-1. Epub +2020 Jun 16. PMID: 32556657. + +508: Watt JA, Goodarzi Z, Veroniki AA, Nincic V, Khan PA, Ghassemi M, Thompson +Y, Lai Y, Treister V, Tricco AC, Straus SE. Safety of pharmacologic +interventions for neuropsychiatric symptoms in dementia: a systematic review and +network meta-analysis. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Jun 16;20(1):212. doi: +10.1186/s12877-020-01607-7. PMID: 32546202; PMCID: PMC7298771. + +509: Carpenter CR, Mudd PA, West CP, Wilber E, Wilber ST. Diagnosing COVID-19 in +the Emergency Department: A Scoping Review of Clinical Examinations, Laboratory +Tests, Imaging Accuracy, and Biases. Acad Emerg Med. 2020 Aug;27(8):653-670. +doi: 10.1111/acem.14048. Epub 2020 Jul 26. PMID: 32542934; PMCID: PMC7323136. + +510: Sengar M, Jain H, Rajendra A, Rengaraj K, Thorat J. Frontline Therapy of +Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia: Changing Treatment Paradigm. Curr Hematol Malig +Rep. 2020 Jun;15(3):168-176. doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00580-7. PMID: 32542586. + +511: Chinna Meyyappan A, Forth E, Wallace CJK, Milev R. Effect of fecal +microbiota transplant on symptoms of psychiatric disorders: a systematic review. +BMC Psychiatry. 2020 Jun 15;20(1):299. doi: 10.1186/s12888-020-02654-5. PMID: +32539741; PMCID: PMC7294648. + +512: Poletto AG, Mello FW, Melo G, Rivero ERC. Prevalence of mucoepidermoid +carcinoma among intraoral minor salivary gland tumors: A systematic review and +meta-analysis. J Oral Pathol Med. 2020 Sep;49(8):720-726. doi: +10.1111/jop.13073. Epub 2020 Jul 4. PMID: 32531838. + +513: de Oliveira Gondim ITG, de Souza CCB, Rodrigues MAB, Azevedo IM, de Sales +Coriolano MDGW, Lins OG. Portable accelerometers for the evaluation of spatio- +temporal gait parameters in people with Parkinson's disease: an integrative +review. Arch Gerontol Geriatr. 2020 Sep-Oct;90:104097. doi: +10.1016/j.archger.2020.104097. Epub 2020 May 13. PMID: 32531644. + +514: Rogers AM, Brammer JE. Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation and Adoptive Cell +Therapy in Peripheral T Cell Lymphoma. Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 +Aug;15(4):316-332. doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00590-5. PMID: 32529515; PMCID: +PMC7415649. + +515: Côté-Léger P, Rowland DL. Estimations of Typical, Ideal, Premature +Ejaculation, and Actual Latencies by Men and Female Sexual Partners of Men +During Partnered Sex. J Sex Med. 2020 Aug;17(8):1448-1456. doi: +10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.04.317. Epub 2020 Jun 5. PMID: 32507609. + +516: Pescia R, Kiliaridis S, Antonarakis GS. Spontaneous eruption of impacted +maxillary incisors after surgical extraction of supernumerary teeth: a +systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 +Nov;24(11):3749-3759. doi: 10.1007/s00784-020-03369-3. Epub 2020 Jun 2. PMID: +32488485. + +517: de Buck van Overstraeten A, Brar MS, Khorasani S, Dossa F, Myrelid P. +Ileorectal Anastomosis Versus IPAA for the Surgical Treatment of Ulcerative +Colitis: A Markov Decision Analysis. Dis Colon Rectum. 2020 Sep;63(9):1276-1284. +doi: 10.1097/DCR.0000000000001686. PMID: 32472777. + +518: Leenen JPL, Leerentveld C, van Dijk JD, van Westreenen HL, Schoonhoven L, +Patijn GA. Current Evidence for Continuous Vital Signs Monitoring by Wearable +Wireless Devices in Hospitalized Adults: Systematic Review. J Med Internet Res. +2020 Jun 17;22(6):e18636. doi: 10.2196/18636. PMID: 32469323; PMCID: PMC7351263. + +519: Harteveld LM, Blom NA, Hazekamp MG, Ten Harkel ADJ. Treatment and outcome +of plastic bronchitis in single ventricle patients: a systematic review. +Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg. 2020 Jun 1;30(6):846-853. doi: +10.1093/icvts/ivaa032. PMID: 32451550. + +520: Quasie-Woode DP, Cunningham-Erves J, Mayo-Gamble TL. The Use of Religion in +the Management of Depression in Sickle Cell Disease: A Systematic Review. J +Relig Health. 2020 Dec;59(6):3110-3125. doi: 10.1007/s10943-020-01039-y. PMID: +32447507. + +521: Pastoor H, Gregory A. Penile Size Dissatisfaction. J Sex Med. 2020 +Jul;17(7):1400-1404. doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.03.015. Epub 2020 May 20. PMID: +32444341. + +522: O'Donnell TF Jr, Allison GM, Iafrati MD. A systematic review of guidelines +for lymphedema and the need for contemporary intersocietal guidelines for the +management of lymphedema. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2020 +Jul;8(4):676-684. doi: 10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.03.006. Epub 2020 May 20. PMID: +32444277. + +523: Liverpool S, Mota CP, Sales CMD, Čuš A, Carletto S, Hancheva C, Sousa S, +Cerón SC, Moreno-Peral P, Pietrabissa G, Moltrecht B, Ulberg R, Ferreira N, +Edbrooke-Childs J. Engaging Children and Young People in Digital Mental Health +Interventions: Systematic Review of Modes of Delivery, Facilitators, and +Barriers. J Med Internet Res. 2020 Jun 23;22(6):e16317. doi: 10.2196/16317. +PMID: 32442160; PMCID: PMC7381028. + +524: Kunnumakkara AB, Shabnam B, Girisa S, Harsha C, Banik K, Devi TB, Choudhury +R, Sahu H, Parama D, Sailo BL, Thakur KK, Gupta SC, Aggarwal BB. Inflammation, +NF-κB, and Chronic Diseases: How are They Linked? Crit Rev Immunol. +2020;40(1):1-39. doi: 10.1615/CritRevImmunol.2020033210. PMID: 32421977. + +525: Davide M, Hagay S, Michela B, Claudia D, Elisabetta C. The effectiveness of +ultrasound examination to assess the healing process of bone lesions of the +jaws: a systematic review. Clin Oral Investig. 2020 Nov;24(11):3739-3747. doi: +10.1007/s00784-020-03339-9. Epub 2020 May 16. Erratum in: Clin Oral Investig. +2020 Dec;24(12):4663. PMID: 32418014. + +526: Rhoten BA, Davis AJ, Baraff BN, Holler KH, Dietrich MS. Priorities and +Preferences of Patients With Head and Neck Cancer for Discussing and Receiving +Information About Sexuality and Perception of Self-Report Measures. J Sex Med. +2020 Aug;17(8):1529-1537. doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.04.001. Epub 2020 May 13. +PMID: 32417203; PMCID: PMC7664992. + +527: Miseré RML, Wolfs JAGN, Lobbes MBI, van der Hulst RRWJ, Qiu SS. A +systematic review of magnetic resonance lymphography for the evaluation of +peripheral lymphedema. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2020 +Sep;8(5):882-892.e2. doi: 10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.03.007. Epub 2020 May 13. PMID: +32417145. + +528: Lasica M, Tam CS. Management of Ibrutinib Toxicities: a Practical Guide. +Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Jun;15(3):177-186. doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00576-3. +PMID: 32415406. + +529: Soldati L, Bianchi-Demicheli F, Schockaert P, Köhl J, Bolmont M, Hasler R, +Perroud N. Sexual Function, Sexual Dysfunctions, and ADHD: A Systematic +Literature Review. J Sex Med. 2020 Sep;17(9):1653-1664. doi: +10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.03.019. Epub 2020 May 10. PMID: 32402814. + +530: Cook J, Muchtar E, Warsame R. Updates in the Diagnosis and Management of AL +Amyloidosis. Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Jun;15(3):155-167. doi: +10.1007/s11899-020-00574-5. PMID: 32394186. + +531: Opie E, Brooks S, Greenberg N, Rubin GJ. The usefulness of pre-employment +and pre-deployment psychological screening for disaster relief workers: a +systematic review. BMC Psychiatry. 2020 May 11;20(1):211. doi: +10.1186/s12888-020-02593-1. PMID: 32393208; PMCID: PMC7216600. + +532: Zhao H, Hu J, Zhao L. Histological analysis of socket preservation using +DBBM. A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Stomatol Oral Maxillofac Surg. +2020 Dec;121(6):729-735. doi: 10.1016/j.jormas.2020.04.011. Epub 2020 May 6. +PMID: 32387688. + +533: Ronaghy A, Yang RK, Khoury JD, Kanagal-Shamanna R. Clinical Applications of +Chromosomal Microarray Testing in Myeloid Malignancies. Curr Hematol Malig Rep. +2020 Jun;15(3):194-202. doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00578-1. PMID: 32382988. + +534: French HP, Deasy M, Gallagher R, O'Grady A, Doyle F. Prevalence of Hip or +Groin Pain in Adolescents: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Pain Pract. +2020 Sep;20(7):792-811. doi: 10.1111/papr.12907. Epub 2020 Jun 15. PMID: +32362057. + +535: O'Donnell TF Jr, Allison GM, Melikian R, Iafrati MD. A systematic review of +the quality of clinical practice guidelines for lymphedema, as assessed using +the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II instrument. J Vasc +Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2020 Jul;8(4):685-692. doi: +10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.04.008. Epub 2020 Apr 23. PMID: 32335331. + +536: Dai Y, Cook OY, Yeganeh L, Huang C, Ding J, Johnson CE. Patient-Reported +Barriers and Facilitators to Seeking and Accessing Support in Gynecologic and +Breast Cancer Survivors With Sexual Problems: A Systematic Review of Qualitative +and Quantitative Studies. J Sex Med. 2020 Jul;17(7):1326-1358. doi: +10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.03.004. Epub 2020 Apr 21. PMID: 32331967. + +537: Toth S, Flohr TR, Schubart J, Knehans A, Castello MC, Aziz F. A meta- +analysis and systematic review of venous thromboembolism prophylaxis in patients +undergoing vascular surgery procedures. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2020 +Sep;8(5):869-881.e2. doi: 10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.03.017. Epub 2020 Apr 21. PMID: +32330639. + +538: Drakos P, Ford BC, Labropoulos N. A systematic review on internal jugular +vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2020 +Jul;8(4):662-666. doi: 10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.03.003. Epub 2020 Apr 19. PMID: +32321692. + +539: Nukala V, Incrocci L, Hunt AA, Ballas L, Koontz BF. Challenges in Reporting +the Effect of Radiotherapy on Erectile Function. J Sex Med. 2020 +Jun;17(6):1053-1059. doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.03.008. Epub 2020 Apr 17. PMID: +32312661. + +540: Edgelow M, Harrison L, Miceli M, Cramm H. Occupational therapy return to +work interventions for persons with trauma and stress-related mental health +conditions: A scoping review. Work. 2020;65(4):821-836. doi: 10.3233/WOR-203134. +PMID: 32310212. + +541: Zhao S, Wang X, Qiang X, Wang H, He J, Shen M, Zheng C, Kang R. Is There an +Association Between Schizophrenia and Sexual Dysfunction in Both Sexes? A +Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Sex Med. 2020 Aug;17(8):1476-1488. doi: +10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.03.005. Epub 2020 Apr 14. PMID: 32299716. + +542: Golden CE, Mishra A. Prevalence of Salmonella and Campylobacter spp. in +Alternative and Conventionally Produced Chicken in the United States: A +Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Food Prot. 2020 Jul 1;83(7):1181-1197. +doi: 10.4315/JFP-19-538. PMID: 32294168. + +543: Zhu J, Ji P, Pang J, Zhong Z, Li H, He C, Zhang J, Zhao C. Clinical +characteristics of 3062 COVID-19 patients: A meta-analysis. J Med Virol. 2020 +Oct;92(10):1902-1914. doi: 10.1002/jmv.25884. Epub 2020 Jun 24. PMID: 32293716; +PMCID: PMC7262119. + +544: Leerssen J, Foster-Dingley JC, Lakbila-Kamal O, Dekkers LMS, Albers ACW, +Ikelaar SLC, Maksimovic T, Wassing R, Houtman SJ, Bresser T, Blanken TF, Te +Lindert B, Ramautar JR, Van Someren EJW. Internet-guided cognitive, behavioral +and chronobiological interventions in depression-prone insomnia subtypes: +protocol of a randomized controlled prevention trial. BMC Psychiatry. 2020 Apr +15;20(1):163. doi: 10.1186/s12888-020-02554-8. PMID: 32293363; PMCID: +PMC7160982. + +545: Abdulla A, Davis WM, Ratnaweera N, Szefer E, Ballantyne Scott B, Lee AYY. A +Meta-Analysis of Case Fatality Rates of Recurrent Venous Thromboembolism and +Major Bleeding in Patients with Cancer. Thromb Haemost. 2020 Apr;120(4):702-713. +doi: 10.1055/s-0040-1708481. Epub 2020 Apr 14. PMID: 32289865. + +546: d'Alessandro E, Becker C, Bergmeier W, Bode C, Bourne JH, Brown H, Buller +HR, Ten Cate-Hoek AJ, Ten Cate V, van Cauteren YJM, Cheung YFH, Cleuren A, +Coenen D, Crijns HJGM, de Simone I, Dolleman SC, Klein CE, Fernandez DI, +Granneman L, van T Hof A, Henke P, Henskens YMC, Huang J, Jennings LK, Jooss N, +Karel M, van den Kerkhof D, Klok FA, Kremers B, Lämmle B, Leader A, Lundstrom A, +Mackman N, Mannucci PM, Maqsood Z, van der Meijden PEJ, van Moorsel M, Moran LA, +Morser J, van Mourik M, Navarro S, Neagoe RAI, Olie RH, van Paridon P, Posma J, +Provenzale I, Reitsma PH, Scaf B, Schurgers L, Seelig J, Siegbahn A, Siegerink +B, Soehnlein O, Soriano EM, Sowa MA, Spronk HMH, Storey RF, Tantiwong C, Veninga +A, Wang X, Watson SP, Weitz J, Zeerleder SS, Ten Cate H; Scientific Reviewer +Committee. Thrombo-Inflammation in Cardiovascular Disease: An Expert Consensus +Document from the Third Maastricht Consensus Conference on Thrombosis. Thromb +Haemost. 2020 Apr;120(4):538-564. doi: 10.1055/s-0040-1708035. Epub 2020 Apr 14. +PMID: 32289858. + +547: Ontario Health (Quality). Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation for Cardiac +Indications in Adults: A Health Technology Assessment. Ont Health Technol Assess +Ser. 2020 Mar 6;20(8):1-121. PMID: 32284771; PMCID: PMC7143364. + +548: Ontario Health (Quality). Gene Expression Profiling Tests for Early-Stage +Invasive Breast Cancer: A Health Technology Assessment. Ont Health Technol +Assess Ser. 2020 Mar 6;20(10):1-234. PMID: 32284770; PMCID: PMC7143374. + +549: Hao Q, Hu Y, Zhang L, Ross J, Robishaw S, Noble C, Wu X, Zhang X. A +Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Clinical Trials of Neuraxial, +Intravenous, and Inhalational Anesthesia for External Cephalic Version. Anesth +Analg. 2020 Dec;131(6):1800-1811. doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000004795. PMID: +32282385; PMCID: PMC7643798. + +550: Cabras M, Carrozzo M, Gambino A, Broccoletti R, Sciascia S, Baldovino S, +Arduino PG. Value of colchicine as treatment for recurrent oral ulcers: A +systematic review. J Oral Pathol Med. 2020 Sep;49(8):731-740. doi: +10.1111/jop.13020. Epub 2020 May 12. PMID: 32281694. + +551: Stulz A, Lamore K, Montalescot L, Favez N, Flahault C. Sexual health in +colon cancer patients: A systematic review. Psychooncology. 2020 +Jul;29(7):1095-1104. doi: 10.1002/pon.5391. Epub 2020 Apr 20. PMID: 32281129. + +552: Campello CP, Pellizzer EP, Vasconcelos BCDE, Moraes SLD, Lemos CAA, Muniz +MTC. Evaluation of IL-6 levels and +3954 polymorphism of IL-1β in burning mouth +syndrome: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Oral Pathol Med. 2020 +Nov;49(10):961-968. doi: 10.1111/jop.13018. Epub 2020 May 30. PMID: 32274841. + +553: Kerr D, Ostaszkiewicz J, Dunning T, Martin P. The effectiveness of training +interventions on nurses' communication skills: A systematic review. Nurse Educ +Today. 2020 Jun;89:104405. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2020.104405. Epub 2020 Mar 20. +PMID: 32244125. + +554: Hebditch M, Daley S, Wright J, Sherlock G, Scott J, Banerjee S. Preferences +of nursing and medical students for working with older adults and people with +dementia: a systematic review. BMC Med Educ. 2020 Mar 30;20(1):92. doi: +10.1186/s12909-020-02000-z. PMID: 32228571; PMCID: PMC7106576. + +555: Regmi K, Jones L. A systematic review of the factors - enablers and +barriers - affecting e-learning in health sciences education. BMC Med Educ. 2020 +Mar 30;20(1):91. doi: 10.1186/s12909-020-02007-6. PMID: 32228560; PMCID: +PMC7106784. + +556: Giuliani M, Frambach J, Broadhurst M, Papadakos J, Fazelad R, Driessen E, +Martimianakis MAT. A critical review of representation in the development of +global oncology curricula and the influence of neocolonialism. BMC Med Educ. +2020 Mar 30;20(1):93. doi: 10.1186/s12909-020-1989-9. PMID: 32228538; PMCID: +PMC7106787. + +557: Gouin T. Toward an Improved Understanding of the Ingestion and Trophic +Transfer of Microplastic Particles: Critical Review and Implications for Future +Research. Environ Toxicol Chem. 2020 May;39(6):1119-1137. doi: 10.1002/etc.4718. +PMID: 32223000; PMCID: PMC7383496. + +558: Vukkadala N, Qian ZJ, Holsinger FC, Patel ZM, Rosenthal E. COVID-19 and the +Otolaryngologist: Preliminary Evidence-Based Review. Laryngoscope. 2020 +Nov;130(11):2537-2543. doi: 10.1002/lary.28672. Epub 2020 Apr 24. PMID: +32219846. + +559: Li XK, Zhou H, Xu Y, Cong ZZ, Wu WJ, Luo J, Jiang ZS, Shen Y. Enteral +immunonutrition versus enteral nutrition for patients undergoing oesophagectomy: +a systematic review and meta-analysis. Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg. 2020 Jun +1;30(6):854-862. doi: 10.1093/icvts/ivaa022. PMID: 32206808. + +560: Ontario Health (Quality). Cell-Free Circulating Tumour DNA Blood Testing to +Detect EGFR T790M Mutation in People With Advanced Non-Small Cell Lung +Cancer: A Health Technology Assessment. Ont Health Technol Assess Ser. 2020 Mar +6;20(5):1-176. PMID: 32206157; PMCID: PMC7082730. + +561: Muraraneza C, Mtshali N, Bvumbwe T. Challenges in postgraduate research +supervision in nursing education: Integrative review. Nurse Educ Today. 2020 +Jun;89:104376. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2020.104376. Epub 2020 Feb 21. PMID: +32203748. + +562: Shaeer O, Skakke D, Giraldi A, Shaeer E, Shaeer K. Female Orgasm and +Overall Sexual Function and Habits: A Descriptive Study of a Cohort of U.S. +Women. J Sex Med. 2020 Jun;17(6):1133-1143. doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.01.029. +Epub 2020 Mar 20. PMID: 32201145. + +563: Ardizzone CA, Houck DA, McCartney DW, Vidal AF, Frank RM. All-Inside Repair +of Bucket-Handle Meniscal Tears: Clinical Outcomes and Prognostic Factors. Am J +Sports Med. 2020 Nov;48(13):3386-3393. doi: 10.1177/0363546520906141. Epub 2020 +Mar 20. PMID: 32195594. + +564: Ontario Health (Quality). 5-Aminolevulinic Acid Hydrochloride +(5-ALA)-Guided Surgical Resection of High-Grade Gliomas: A Health Technology +Assessment. Ont Health Technol Assess Ser. 2020 Mar 6;20(9):1-92. PMID: +32194883; PMCID: PMC7077938. + +565: Altintas B, Scheidt M, Kremser V, Boykin R, Bhatia S, Sajadi KR, Mair S, +Millett PJ. Superior Capsule Reconstruction for Irreparable Massive Rotator Cuff +Tears: Does It Make Sense? A Systematic Review of Early Clinical Evidence. Am J +Sports Med. 2020 Nov;48(13):3365-3375. doi: 10.1177/0363546520904378. Epub 2020 +Mar 19. PMID: 32191494. + +566: Radin M, Foddai SG, Cecchi I, Rubini E, Schreiber K, Roccatello D, +Bertolaccini ML, Sciascia S. Antiphosphatidylserine/Prothrombin Antibodies: An +Update on Their Association with Clinical Manifestations of Antiphospholipid +Syndrome. Thromb Haemost. 2020 Apr;120(4):592-598. doi: 10.1055/s-0040-1705115. +Epub 2020 Mar 17. PMID: 32185783. + +567: Guzdar A, Costello C. Supportive Care in Multiple Myeloma. Curr Hematol +Malig Rep. 2020 Apr;15(2):56-61. doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00570-9. PMID: +32172361. + +568: Liang H, Luo S, Chen X, Lu Y, Liu Z, Wei L. Effects of Tai Chi exercise on +cardiovascular disease risk factors and quality of life in adults with essential +hypertension: A meta-analysis. Heart Lung. 2020 Jul-Aug;49(4):353-363. doi: +10.1016/j.hrtlng.2020.02.041. Epub 2020 Mar 12. PMID: 32171586. + +569: AACN Practice Alert: Pulmonary Artery/Central Venous Pressure Monitoring in +Adults. AACN Adv Crit Care. 2020 Mar 15;31(1):41-48. doi: +10.4037/aacnacc2020328. PMID: 32168513. + +570: de Oliveira L, Carvalho J. The Link Between Boredom and Hypersexuality: A +Systematic Review. J Sex Med. 2020 May;17(5):994-1004. doi: +10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.02.007. Epub 2020 Mar 9. PMID: 32165100. + +571: Dvoretskiy S, Lieblein-Boff JC, Jonnalagadda S, Atherton PJ, Phillips BE, +Pereira SL. Exploring the Association between Vascular Dysfunction and Skeletal +Muscle Mass, Strength and Function in Healthy Adults: A Systematic Review. +Nutrients. 2020 Mar 7;12(3):715. doi: 10.3390/nu12030715. PMID: 32156061; PMCID: +PMC7146456. + +572: Klimova B, Novotny M, Valis M. The Impact of Nutrition and Intestinal +Microbiome on Elderly Depression-A Systematic Review. Nutrients. 2020 Mar +7;12(3):710. doi: 10.3390/nu12030710. PMID: 32156003; PMCID: PMC7146624. + +573: Yafi FA, Huynh LM, Ahlering T, Rosen R. What Is a "Validated +Questionnaire"? A Critical Review of Erectile Function Assessment. J Sex Med. +2020 May;17(5):849-860. doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.02.005. Epub 2020 Mar 5. PMID: +32146130. + +574: Chen X, Yang Z, Li H, Zhu S, Wang Y, Qian W. Higher risk of revision in +total knee arthroplasty after high tibial osteotomy: a systematic review and +updated meta-analysis. BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2020 Mar 6;21(1):153. doi: +10.1186/s12891-020-3177-9. PMID: 32143608; PMCID: PMC7060637. + +575: Masuda E, Ozsvath K, Vossler J, Woo K, Kistner R, Lurie F, Monahan D, Brown +W, Labropoulos N, Dalsing M, Khilnani N, Wakefield T, Gloviczki P. The 2020 +appropriate use criteria for chronic lower extremity venous disease of the +American Venous Forum, the Society for Vascular Surgery, the American Vein and +Lymphatic Society, and the Society of Interventional Radiology. J Vasc Surg +Venous Lymphat Disord. 2020 Jul;8(4):505-525.e4. doi: +10.1016/j.jvsv.2020.02.001. Epub 2020 Mar 3. PMID: 32139328. + +576: Mooney-Doyle K, Ulrich CM. Parent moral distress in serious pediatric +illness: A dimensional analysis. Nurs Ethics. 2020 May;27(3):821-837. doi: +10.1177/0969733019878838. Epub 2020 Mar 5. PMID: 32138577. + +577: Gutsmiedl K, Krause M, Bighelli I, Schneider-Thoma J, Leucht S. How well do +elderly patients with major depressive disorder respond to antidepressants: a +systematic review and single-group meta-analysis. BMC Psychiatry. 2020 Mar +4;20(1):102. doi: 10.1186/s12888-020-02514-2. PMID: 32131786; PMCID: PMC7057600. + +578: Fakhri G, Al Assaad M, Tfayli A. Association of various dietary habits and +risk of lung cancer: an updated comprehensive literature review. Tumori. 2020 +Dec;106(6):445-456. doi: 10.1177/0300891619900675. Epub 2020 Mar 4. PMID: +32129158. + +579: Li Q, Yang J, Zhang J, Yang C, Fan Z, Yang Y, Zheng T, Yang J. Effect of +Perioperative Glucose-Insulin-Potassium Therapy in Patients Undergoing On-Pump +Cardiac Surgery: A Meta-Analysis. Heart Surg Forum. 2020 Feb 25;23(1):E063-E069. +doi: 10.1532/hsf.2735. PMID: 32118546. + +580: Sun L, An H, Feng Y. Intravenous Tranexamic Acid Decreases Blood +Transfusion in Off-Pump Coronary Artery Bypass Surgery: A Meta-analysis. Heart +Surg Forum. 2020 Feb 25;23(1):E039-E049. doi: 10.1532/hsf.2797. PMID: 32118541. + +581: Wan Y, Wu X, Kou Y. The Impact of Text Message On Self-Management for +Coronary Heart Disease: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Heart +Surg Forum. 2020 Feb 10;23(1):E018-E024. doi: 10.1532/hsf.2519. PMID: 32118537. + +582: Lurie F, Passman M, Meisner M, Dalsing M, Masuda E, Welch H, Bush RL, +Blebea J, Carpentier PH, De Maeseneer M, Gasparis A, Labropoulos N, Marston WA, +Rafetto J, Santiago F, Shortell C, Uhl JF, Urbanek T, van Rij A, Eklof B, +Gloviczki P, Kistner R, Lawrence P, Moneta G, Padberg F, Perrin M, Wakefield T. +The 2020 update of the CEAP classification system and reporting standards. J +Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2020 May;8(3):342-352. doi: +10.1016/j.jvsv.2019.12.075. Epub 2020 Feb 27. Erratum in: J Vasc Surg Venous +Lymphat Disord. 2021 Jan;9(1):288. PMID: 32113854. + +583: Bodendorfer BM, Wang DX, McCormick BP, Looney AM, Conroy CM, Fryar CM, +Kotler JA, Ferris WJ, Postma WF, Chang ES. Treatment of Pectoralis Major Tendon +Tears: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Repair Timing and Fixation +Methods. Am J Sports Med. 2020 Nov;48(13):3376-3385. doi: +10.1177/0363546520904402. Epub 2020 Feb 28. PMID: 32109153. + +584: Lee JC, Lamanna N. Is There a Role for Chemotherapy in the Era of Targeted +Therapies? Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Apr;15(2):72-82. doi: +10.1007/s11899-020-00563-8. PMID: 32107713. + +585: Lopetuso LR, Ianiro G, Allegretti JR, Bibbò S, Gasbarrini A, Scaldaferri F, +Cammarota G. Fecal transplantation for ulcerative colitis: current evidence and +future applications. Expert Opin Biol Ther. 2020 Apr;20(4):343-351. doi: +10.1080/14712598.2020.1733964. Epub 2020 Feb 26. PMID: 32083498. + +586: Ma F, Zhi C, Wang M, Li T, Khan SA, Ma Z, Jing Z, Bo C, Zhou Q, Xia S, +Huang S, Huang S, Zhang Z, Jia H, Cui X, Yao M, Ji T. Dysregulated NF-κB signal +promotes the hub gene PCLAF expression to facilitate nasopharyngeal carcinoma +proliferation and metastasis. Biomed Pharmacother. 2020 May;125:109905. doi: +10.1016/j.biopha.2020.109905. Epub 2020 Feb 25. PMID: 32070873. + +587: Kolluri R, Chung J, Kim S, Nath N, Bhalla BB, Jain T, Zygmunt J, Davies A. +Network meta-analysis to compare VenaSeal with other superficial venous +therapies for chronic venous insufficiency. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. +2020 May;8(3):472-481.e3. doi: 10.1016/j.jvsv.2019.12.061. Epub 2020 Feb 14. +PMID: 32063522. + +588: Cheon H, Dziewulska KH, Moosic KB, Olson KC, Gru AA, Feith DJ, Loughran TP +Jr. Advances in the Diagnosis and Treatment of Large Granular Lymphocytic +Leukemia. Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Apr;15(2):103-112. doi: +10.1007/s11899-020-00565-6. PMID: 32062772; PMCID: PMC7234906. + +589: Rodríguez-Calero MA, Blanco-Mavillard I, Morales-Asencio JM, Fernández- +Fernández I, Castro-Sánchez E, de Pedro-Gómez JE. Defining risk factors +associated with difficult peripheral venous Cannulation: A systematic review and +meta-analysis. Heart Lung. 2020 May-Jun;49(3):273-286. doi: +10.1016/j.hrtlng.2020.01.009. Epub 2020 Feb 11. PMID: 32057426. + +590: Kabacińska K, Sharma N, Kaye J, Mattek N, Kuzeljevic B, Robillard JM. +Investigating the concept of participant burden in aging technology research. +BMC Geriatr. 2020 Feb 12;20(1):50. doi: 10.1186/s12877-020-1441-3. PMID: +32050910; PMCID: PMC7017624. + +591: Janmohamed A, Sohani N, Lassi ZS, Bhutta ZA. The Effects of Community Home +Visit and Peer Group Nutrition Intervention Delivery Platforms on Nutrition +Outcomes in Low and Middle-Income Countries: A Systematic Review and Meta- +Analysis. Nutrients. 2020 Feb 10;12(2):440. doi: 10.3390/nu12020440. PMID: +32050577; PMCID: PMC7071285. + +592: Grgic J, Diaz-Lara FJ, Coso JD, Duncan MJ, Tallis J, Pickering C, +Schoenfeld BJ, Mikulic P. The Effects of Caffeine Ingestion on Measures of +Rowing Performance: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Nutrients. 2020 Feb +8;12(2):434. doi: 10.3390/nu12020434. PMID: 32046330; PMCID: PMC7071243. + +593: Rezar R, Jirak P, Lichtenauer M, Jung C, Lauten A, Hoppe UC, Wernly B. +Partial oral antibiotic therapy is non-inferior to intravenous therapy in non- +critically ill patients with infective endocarditis : Review and meta-analysis. +Wien Klin Wochenschr. 2020 Dec;132(23-24):762-769. doi: +10.1007/s00508-020-01614-z. Epub 2020 Feb 10. PMID: 32040621; PMCID: PMC7732798. + +594: Zhang X, Yang P, Guo C, Li S, Zhang Y. Effects of volume-assured pressure +support noninvasive ventilation in stable COPD with chronic respiratory failure: +Meta-analysis and literature review. Heart Lung. 2020 May-Jun;49(3):287-295. +doi: 10.1016/j.hrtlng.2020.01.007. Epub 2020 Feb 5. PMID: 32035642. + +595: Braun T, von Jan J, Wahnschaffe L, Herling M. Advances and Perspectives in +the Treatment of T-PLL. Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Apr;15(2):113-124. doi: +10.1007/s11899-020-00566-5. PMID: 32034661; PMCID: PMC7230055. + +596: Hunter BD, Chen YB. Current Approaches to Transplantation for FLT3-ITD AML. +Curr Hematol Malig Rep. 2020 Feb;15(1):1-8. doi: 10.1007/s11899-020-00558-5. +PMID: 32034660. + +597: Lin P, Zhang J, Shi F, Liang ZA. Can haloperidol prophylaxis reduce the +incidence of delirium in critically ill patients in intensive care units? A +systematic review and meta-analysis. Heart Lung. 2020 May-Jun;49(3):265-272. +doi: 10.1016/j.hrtlng.2020.01.010. Epub 2020 Feb 5. PMID: 32033776. + +598: Foronda CL, Fernandez-Burgos M, Nadeau C, Kelley CN, Henry MN. Virtual +Simulation in Nursing Education: A Systematic Review Spanning 1996 to 2018. +Simul Healthc. 2020 Feb;15(1):46-54. doi: 10.1097/SIH.0000000000000411. PMID: +32028447. + +599: de Medeiros MMD, Carletti TM, Magno MB, Maia LC, Cavalcanti YW, Rodrigues- +Garcia RCM. Does the institutionalization influence elderly's quality of life? A +systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Geriatr. 2020 Feb 5;20(1):44. doi: +10.1186/s12877-020-1452-0. PMID: 32024479; PMCID: PMC7003363. + +600: Birgin E, Yang C, Hetjens S, Reissfelder C, Hohenberger P, Rahbari NN. Core +needle biopsy versus incisional biopsy for differentiation of soft-tissue +sarcomas: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Cancer. 2020 Jan +1;126(9):1917-1928. doi: 10.1002/cncr.32735. Epub 2020 Feb 5. PMID: 32022262. + +601: Arnott C, Li Q, Kang A, Neuen BL, Bompoint S, Lam CSP, Rodgers A, Mahaffey +KW, Cannon CP, Perkovic V, Jardine MJ, Neal B. Sodium-Glucose Cotransporter 2 +Inhibition for the Prevention of Cardiovascular Events in Patients With Type 2 +Diabetes Mellitus: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Am Heart Assoc. 2020 +Feb 4;9(3):e014908. doi: 10.1161/JAHA.119.014908. Epub 2020 Jan 29. PMID: +31992158; PMCID: PMC7033896. + +602: Carder SL, Giusti NE, Vopat LM, Tarakemeh A, Baker J, Vopat BG, Mulcahey +MK. The Concept of Sport Sampling Versus Sport Specialization: Preventing Youth +Athlete Injury: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2020 +Sep;48(11):2850-2857. doi: 10.1177/0363546519899380. Epub 2020 Jan 21. PMID: +31961703. + +603: Sarris J, Sinclair J, Karamacoska D, Davidson M, Firth J. Medicinal +cannabis for psychiatric disorders: a clinically-focused systematic review. BMC +Psychiatry. 2020 Jan 16;20(1):24. doi: 10.1186/s12888-019-2409-8. PMID: +31948424; PMCID: PMC6966847. + +604: Birdi G, Cooke R, Knibb RC. Impact of atopic dermatitis on quality of life +in adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Dermatol. 2020 +Apr;59(4):e75-e91. doi: 10.1111/ijd.14763. Epub 2020 Jan 13. PMID: 31930494. + +605: British Orthopaedic Association Trauma Committee. Electronic address: +william.eardley@nhs.net. British Orthopaedic Association Standard for Trauma +(BOAST): Open fracture management. Injury. 2020 Feb;51(2):174-177. doi: +10.1016/j.injury.2019.12.034. Epub 2019 Dec 24. PMID: 31926613. + +606: Gupta D, Potter T, Disher T, Eaton K, Goldstein L, Patel L, Grima D, +Velleca M, Costa G. Comparative effectiveness of catheter ablation devices in +the treatment of atrial fibrillation: a network meta-analysis. J Comp Eff Res. +2020 Jan;9(2):115-126. doi: 10.2217/cer-2019-0165. Epub 2020 Jan 8. PMID: +31913063. + +607: Magri MC, Nunes AKDS, Dantas BP, Manchiero C, Prata TVG, Alves GM, Tengan +FM. Meta-Analysis of the Prevalence of HBV Infection Among Alcohol Users +Worldwide. Alcohol Alcohol. 2020 Mar 19;55(2):136-143. doi: +10.1093/alcalc/agz102. PMID: 31912149. + +608: Xu J, Kanagaratnam A, Cao JY, Chaggar GS, Bruce W. A comparison of aspirin +against rivaroxaban for venous thromboembolism prophylaxis after hip or knee +arthroplasty: A meta-analysis. J Orthop Surg (Hong Kong). 2020 Jan- +Apr;28(1):2309499019896024. doi: 10.1177/2309499019896024. PMID: 31908175. + +609: Puciło M, Lipski M, Sroczyk-Jaszczyńska M, Puciło A, Nowicka A. The +anatomical relationship between the roots of erupted permanent teeth and the +mandibular canal: a systematic review. Surg Radiol Anat. 2020 May;42(5):529-542. +doi: 10.1007/s00276-019-02404-7. Epub 2020 Jan 3. PMID: 31900577. + +610: Acharya P, Mathur MC. Oxidative stress in alopecia areata: a systematic +review and meta-analysis. Int J Dermatol. 2020 Apr;59(4):434-440. doi: +10.1111/ijd.14753. Epub 2019 Dec 26. PMID: 31875951. + +611: Kim SH, Djaja YP, Park YB, Park JG, Ko YB, Ha CW. Intra-articular Injection +of Culture-Expanded Mesenchymal Stem Cells Without Adjuvant Surgery in Knee +Osteoarthritis: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2020 +Sep;48(11):2839-2849. doi: 10.1177/0363546519892278. Epub 2019 Dec 24. PMID: +31874044. + +612: Mergenhagen KA, Wattengel BA, Skelly MK, Clark CM, Russo TA. Fact versus +Fiction: a Review of the Evidence behind Alcohol and Antibiotic Interactions. +Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 2020 Feb 21;64(3):e02167-19. doi: +10.1128/AAC.02167-19. PMID: 31871085; PMCID: PMC7038249. + +613: Tully PJ, Yano Y, Launer LJ, Kario K, Nagai M, Mooijaart SP, Claassen JAHR, +Lattanzi S, Vincent AD, Tzourio C; Variability in Blood Pressure and Brain +Health Consortium †; Variability in Blood Pressure and Brain Health +Consortium. Association Between Blood Pressure +Variability and Cerebral Small-Vessel Disease: A Systematic Review and Meta- +Analysis. J Am Heart Assoc. 2020 Jan 7;9(1):e013841. doi: +10.1161/JAHA.119.013841. Epub 2019 Dec 24. PMID: 31870233; PMCID: PMC6988154. + +614: Chahal CAA, Salloum MN, Alahdab F, Gottwald JA, Tester DJ, Anwer LA, So EL, +Murad MH, St Louis EK, Ackerman MJ, Somers VK. Systematic Review of the Genetics +of Sudden Unexpected Death in Epilepsy: Potential Overlap With Sudden Cardiac +Death and Arrhythmia-Related Genes. J Am Heart Assoc. 2020 Jan 7;9(1):e012264. +doi: 10.1161/JAHA.119.012264. Epub 2019 Dec 21. PMID: 31865891; PMCID: +PMC6988156. + +615: Cuspidi C, Tadic M, Sala C, Gherbesi E, Grassi G, Mancia G. Targeting +Concentric Left Ventricular Hypertrophy in Obstructive Sleep Apnea Syndrome. A +Meta-analysis of Echocardiographic Studies. Am J Hypertens. 2020 Apr +1;33(4):310-315. doi: 10.1093/ajh/hpz198. PMID: 31863113. + +616: Wang Z, Liu BS, Wang XY, Peng JL, Huang XQ, Tian H, Wei QH, Wang LQ. +Effects of fixed-time artificial insemination using triptorelin on the +reproductive performance of pigs: a meta-analysis. Animal. 2020 +Jul;14(7):1481-1492. doi: 10.1017/S1751731119003008. Epub 2019 Dec 20. PMID: +31858952. + +617: Giridhar P, Kashyap L, Mallick S, Dutt Upadhyay A, Rath GK. Impact of +surgery and adjuvant treatment on the outcome of extraocular sebaceous +carcinoma: a systematic review and individual patient's data analysis of 206 +cases. Int J Dermatol. 2020 Apr;59(4):494-505. doi: 10.1111/ijd.14739. Epub 2019 +Dec 18. PMID: 31850516. + +618: Suvarna B, Suvarna A, Phillips R, Juster RP, McDermott B, Sarnyai Z. Health +risk behaviours and allostatic load: A systematic review. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. +2020 Jan;108:694-711. doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.020. Epub 2019 Dec 14. +PMID: 31846655. + +619: Petrovič M, Locatelli I. Comparative effectiveness of pulmonary arterial +hypertension drugs in treatment-naive patients: a network meta-analysis. J Comp +Eff Res. 2020 Jan;9(1):7-22. doi: 10.2217/cer-2019-0037. Epub 2019 Dec 17. PMID: +31845591. + +620: Krahe J, Binkofski F, Schulz JB, Reetz K, Romanzetti S. Neurochemical +profiles in hereditary ataxias: A meta-analysis of Magnetic Resonance +Spectroscopy studies. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:854-865. doi: +10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.019. Epub 2019 Dec 12. PMID: 31838195. + +621: Sulpizio S, Del Maschio N, Fedeli D, Abutalebi J. Bilingual language +processing: A meta-analysis of functional neuroimaging studies. Neurosci +Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:834-853. doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.014. Epub +2019 Dec 12. PMID: 31838193. + +622: Palandi J, Bobinski F, de Oliveira GM, Ilha J. Neuropathic pain after +spinal cord injury and physical exercise in animal models: A systematic review +and meta-analysis. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:781-795. doi: +10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.016. Epub 2019 Dec 16. PMID: 31837360. + +623: Irwin C, Khalesi S, Desbrow B, McCartney D. Effects of acute caffeine +consumption following sleep loss on cognitive, physical, occupational and +driving performance: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Neurosci Biobehav +Rev. 2020 Jan;108:877-888. doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.008. Epub 2019 Dec +16. PMID: 31837359. + +624: Böhnlein J, Altegoer L, Muck NK, Roesmann K, Redlich R, Dannlowski U, Leehr +EJ. Factors influencing the success of exposure therapy for specific phobia: A +systematic review. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:796-820. doi: +10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.009. Epub 2019 Dec 9. PMID: 31830494. + +625: Cavanagh N, Cockett G, Heinrich C, Doig L, Fiest K, Guichon JR, Page S, +Mitchell I, Doig CJ. Compassion fatigue in healthcare providers: A systematic +review and meta-analysis. Nurs Ethics. 2020 May;27(3):639-665. doi: +10.1177/0969733019889400. Epub 2019 Dec 12. PMID: 31829113. + +626: Yuan C, Zhou Y, Pan Y, Wang J. Curative effect comparison of transforaminal +endoscopic spine system and traditional open discectomy: a meta-analysis. ANZ J +Surg. 2020 Jan;90(1-2):123-129. doi: 10.1111/ans.15579. Epub 2019 Dec 11. PMID: +31828889. + +627: Piepoli MF, Abreu A, Albus C, Ambrosetti M, Brotons C, Catapano AL, Corra +U, Cosyns B, Deaton C, Graham I, Hoes A, Lochen ML, Matrone B, Redon J, Sattar +N, Smulders Y, Tiberi M. Update on cardiovascular prevention in clinical +practice: A position paper of the European Association of Preventive Cardiology +of the European Society of Cardiology. Eur J Prev Cardiol. 2020 +Jan;27(2):181-205. doi: 10.1177/2047487319893035. Epub 2019 Dec 12. PMID: +31826679. + +628: Marzuki AA, Pereira de Souza AMFL, Sahakian BJ, Robbins TW. Are candidate +neurocognitive endophenotypes of OCD present in paediatric patients? A +systematic review. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:617-645. doi: +10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.010. Epub 2019 Dec 9. PMID: 31821834. + +629: Domínguez-Borràs J, Moyne M, Saj A, Guex R, Vuilleumier P. Impaired +emotional biases in visual attention after bilateral amygdala lesion. +Neuropsychologia. 2020 Feb 3;137:107292. doi: +10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2019.107292. Epub 2019 Dec 4. PMID: 31811846. + +630: Cotelli M, Manenti R, Ferrari C, Gobbi E, Macis A, Cappa SF. Effectiveness +of language training and non-invasive brain stimulation on oral and written +naming performance in Primary Progressive Aphasia: A meta-analysis and +systematic review. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:498-525. doi: +10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.12.003. Epub 2019 Dec 4. PMID: 31811834. + +631: Herrero Babiloni A, Nixdorf DR, Moana-Filho EJ. Persistent dentoalveolar +pain disorder: A putative intraoral chronic overlapping pain condition. Oral +Dis. 2020 Nov;26(8):1601-1609. doi: 10.1111/odi.13248. Epub 2019 Dec 17. PMID: +31797486; PMCID: PMC7269821. + +632: Ding R, Ren J, Li S, Zhu X, Zhang K, Luo W. Domain-general and domain- +preferential neural correlates underlying empathy towards physical pain, +emotional situation and emotional faces: An ALE meta-analysis. Neuropsychologia. +2020 Feb 3;137:107286. doi: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2019.107286. Epub 2019 +Nov 28. PMID: 31786222. + +633: Babiker A, Hassan M, Muhammed S, Taylor G, Poonia B, Shah A, Bagchi S. +Inflammatory and cardiovascular diseases biomarkers in chronic hepatitis C virus +infection: A review. Clin Cardiol. 2020 Mar;43(3):222-234. doi: +10.1002/clc.23299. Epub 2019 Nov 30. PMID: 31785111; PMCID: PMC7068107. + +634: Heard M, Lee YS. Shared neural resources of rhythm and syntax: An ALE meta- +analysis. Neuropsychologia. 2020 Feb 3;137:107284. doi: +10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2019.107284. Epub 2019 Nov 26. PMID: 31783081. + +635: Kluwe-Schiavon B, Viola TW, Sanvicente-Vieira B, Lumertz FS, Salum GA, +Grassi-Oliveira R, Quednow BB. Substance related disorders are associated with +impaired valuation of delayed gratification and feedback processing: A +multilevel meta-analysis and meta-regression. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 +Jan;108:295-307. doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.11.016. Epub 2019 Nov 25. PMID: +31778679. + +636: Luo L, Fu M, Li Y, Chen Z, Yu J, Luo J, Hu S, Tu L, Xu X. The efficacy and +safety of P2Y12 inhibitor monotherapy in patients after percutaneous coronary +intervention. Clin Cardiol. 2020 Mar;43(3):235-241. doi: 10.1002/clc.23305. Epub +2019 Nov 28. PMID: 31777973; PMCID: PMC7068072. + +637: Xu G, Fu X, Tian P, Bahat D, Huang Y, Li Z. The lateral and medial approach +in total arthroplasty for valgus knee: a meta-analysis of current literature. J +Comp Eff Res. 2020 Jan;9(1):35-44. doi: 10.2217/cer-2019-0111. Epub 2019 Nov 28. +PMID: 31777265. + +638: Eusebio-Alpapara KMV, Castillo RL, Dofitas BL. Gabapentin for uremic +pruritus: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Int J Dermatol. +2020 Apr;59(4):412-422. doi: 10.1111/ijd.14708. Epub 2019 Nov 28. PMID: +31777066. + +639: Bai J, Gao Q, Wang C, Dai J. Diabetes mellitus and risk of low-energy +fracture: a meta-analysis. Aging Clin Exp Res. 2020 Nov;32(11):2173-2186. doi: +10.1007/s40520-019-01417-x. Epub 2019 Nov 25. PMID: 31768878. + +640: Lin J, Sun Y, Chen Q, Liu S, Ding Z, Chen J. Outcome Comparison of Graft +Bridging and Superior Capsule Reconstruction for Large to Massive Rotator Cuff +Tears: A Systematic Review. Am J Sports Med. 2020 Sep;48(11):2828-2838. doi: +10.1177/0363546519889040. Epub 2019 Nov 25. PMID: 31766858. + +641: Prompahakul C, Epstein EG. Moral distress experienced by non-Western +nurses: An integrative review. Nurs Ethics. 2020 May;27(3):778-795. doi: +10.1177/0969733019880241. Epub 2019 Nov 21. PMID: 31750780. + +642: Huang WL, Xu Y, Wan SP. Association of Toll-like 4 receptor gene +polymorphism (rs4986790, rs4986791) with the risk of urinary tract infection: A +systematic review and meta-analysis. Kaohsiung J Med Sci. 2020 +Mar;36(3):206-211. doi: 10.1002/kjm2.12158. Epub 2019 Nov 21. PMID: 31749314. + +643: Chen CF, Gao XF, Liu MJ, Jin CL, Xu YZ. Safety and efficacy of the +ThermoCool SmartTouch SurroundFlow catheter for atrial fibrillation ablation: A +meta-analysis. Clin Cardiol. 2020 Mar;43(3):267-274. doi: 10.1002/clc.23297. +Epub 2019 Nov 19. PMID: 31743474; PMCID: PMC7068067. + +644: Haltaufderheide J, Nadolny S, Gysels M, Bausewein C, Vollmann J, Schildmann +J. Outcomes of clinical ethics support near the end of life: A systematic +review. Nurs Ethics. 2020 May;27(3):838-854. doi: 10.1177/0969733019878840. Epub +2019 Nov 19. PMID: 31742473. + +645: Foster TJ, Amin AH, Busu T, Patel K, Farjo P, Hallak AA, Ali N, Alkhouli M. +Aorto-cardiac fistula etiology, presentation, and management: A systematic +review. Heart Lung. 2020 May-Jun;49(3):317-323. doi: +10.1016/j.hrtlng.2019.11.002. Epub 2019 Nov 15. PMID: 31735456. + +646: Figueiredo PR, Tolomeo S, Steele JD, Baldacchino A. Neurocognitive +consequences of chronic cannabis use: a systematic review and meta-analysis. +Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:358-369. doi: +10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.10.014. Epub 2019 Nov 9. PMID: 31715191. + +647: Sánchez-Ruano L, de la Hoz B, Martínez-Botas J. Clinical utility of +microarray B-cell epitope mapping in food allergies: A systematic review. +Pediatr Allergy Immunol. 2020 Feb;31(2):175-185. doi: 10.1111/pai.13141. Epub +2019 Nov 21. PMID: 31655013. + +648: Jerger L, Hyams JS. Special considerations for biologic medications in +pediatric ulcerative colitis. Expert Opin Biol Ther. 2020 Apr;20(4):429-435. +doi: 10.1080/14712598.2020.1685492. Epub 2019 Oct 29. PMID: 31652087. + +649: Lotufo MA, Tempestini Horliana ACR, Santana T, de Queiroz AC, Gomes AO, +Motta LJ, Ferrari RAM, Dos Santos Fernandes KP, Bussadori SK. "Efficacy of +photodynamic therapy on the treatment of herpes labialis: A systematic review". +Photodiagnosis Photodyn Ther. 2020 Mar;29:101536. doi: +10.1016/j.pdpdt.2019.08.018. Epub 2019 Oct 21. PMID: 31648056. + +650: Zhao E, Lowres N, Woolaston A, Naismith SL, Gallagher R. Prevalence and +patterns of cognitive impairment in acute coronary syndrome patients: A +systematic review. Eur J Prev Cardiol. 2020 Feb;27(3):284-293. doi: +10.1177/2047487319878945. Epub 2019 Oct 24. PMID: 31645116. + +651: Nunez NA, Singh B, Romo-Nava F, Joseph B, Veldic M, Cuellar-Barboza A, +Cabello Arreola A, Vande Voort JL, Croarkin P, Moore KM, Biernacka J, McElroy +SL, Frye MA. Efficacy and tolerability of adjunctive modafinil/armodafinil in +bipolar depression: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Bipolar +Disord. 2020 Mar;22(2):109-120. doi: 10.1111/bdi.12859. Epub 2020 Jan 7. PMID: +31643130. + +652: Wright DK, Gastmans C, Vandyk A, de Casterlé BD. Moral identity and +palliative sedation: A systematic review of normative nursing literature. Nurs +Ethics. 2020 May;27(3):868-886. doi: 10.1177/0969733019876312. Epub 2019 Oct 21. +PMID: 31635514. + +653: Bahls M, Lorenz MW, Dörr M, Gao L, Kitagawa K, Tuomainen TP, Agewall S, +Berenson G, Catapano AL, Norata GD, Bots ML, van Gilst W, Asselbergs FW, +Brouwers FP, Uthoff H, Sander D, Poppert H, Hecht Olsen M, Empana JP, Schminke +U, Baldassarre D, Veglia F, Franco OH, Kavousi M, de Groot E, Mathiesen EB, +Grigore L, Polak JF, Rundek T, Stehouwer CD, Skilton MR, Hatzitolios AI, +Savopoulos C, Ntaios G, Plichart M, McLachlan S, Lind L, Willeit P, Steinmetz H, +Desvarieux M, Ikram MA, Johnsen SH, Schmidt C, Willeit J, Ducimetiere P, Price +JF, Bergström G, Kauhanen J, Kiechl S, Sitzer M, Bickel H, Sacco RL, Hofman A, +Völzke H, Thompson SG; PROG-IMT Study Group. Progression of conventional +cardiovascular risk factors and vascular disease risk in individuals: insights +from the PROG-IMT consortium. Eur J Prev Cardiol. 2020 Feb;27(3):234-243. doi: +10.1177/2047487319877078. Epub 2019 Oct 16. PMID: 31619084; PMCID: PMC7008553. + +654: Noone C, Leahy J, Morrissey EC, Newell J, Newell M, Dwyer CP, Murphy J, +Doyle F, Murphy AW, Molloy GJ. Comparative efficacy of exercise and anti- +hypertensive pharmacological interventions in reducing blood pressure in people +with hypertension: A network meta-analysis. Eur J Prev Cardiol. 2020 +Feb;27(3):247-255. doi: 10.1177/2047487319879786. Epub 2019 Oct 15. PMID: +31615283. + +655: Maurage P, Masson N, Bollen Z, D'Hondt F. Eye tracking correlates of acute +alcohol consumption: A systematic and critical review. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. +2020 Jan;108:400-422. doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.10.001. Epub 2019 Oct 12. +PMID: 31614153. + +656: Russo V, Ottaviani C, Spitoni GF. Affective touch: A meta-analysis on sex +differences. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020 Jan;108:445-452. doi: +10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.09.037. Epub 2019 Oct 12. PMID: 31614152. + +657: Spaaij R, Broerse J, Oxford S, Luguetti C, McLachlan F, McDonald B, Klepac +B, Lymbery L, Bishara J, Pankowiak A. Sport, Refugees, and Forced Migration: A +Critical Review of the Literature. Front Sports Act Living. 2019 Oct 11;1:47. +doi: 10.3389/fspor.2019.00047. PMID: 33344970; PMCID: PMC7739661. + +658: Tessier JM, Sanders J, Sartelli M, Ulrych J, De Simone B, Grabowski J, +Buckman S, Duane TM. Necrotizing Soft Tissue Infections: A Focused Review of +Pathophysiology, Diagnosis, Operative Management, Antimicrobial Therapy, and +Pediatrics. Surg Infect (Larchmt). 2020 Mar;21(2):81-93. doi: +10.1089/sur.2019.219. Epub 2019 Oct 4. PMID: 31584343. + +659: Leonardi-Bee J, Flohr C, van Zuuren EJ, Le Cleach L, Hollestein LM. Common +methodological pitfalls and new developments in systematic review meta-analyses. +Br J Dermatol. 2019 Oct;181(4):649-651. doi: 10.1111/bjd.18336. PMID: 31576568. + +660: Halmai LA, Neilson AR, Kilonzo M. Economic evaluation of interventions for +the treatment of asthma in children: A systematic review. Pediatr Allergy +Immunol. 2020 Feb;31(2):150-157. doi: 10.1111/pai.13129. Epub 2019 Dec 3. PMID: +31571263. + +661: European Association for the Study of the Liver. Electronic address: +easloffice@easloffice.eu; Clinical Practice Guideline Panel: Chair:; Panel +members:; EASL Governing Board representative:. EASL Clinical Practice +Guideline: Occupational liver diseases. J Hepatol. 2019 Nov;71(5):1022-1037. +doi: 10.1016/j.jhep.2019.08.008. Epub 2019 Sep 17. PMID: 31540728. + +662: Lu HT, Shen QY, Xie D, Zhao QZ, Xu YM. Lack of association between +appendectomy and Parkinson's disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis. +Aging Clin Exp Res. 2020 Nov;32(11):2201-2209. doi: 10.1007/s40520-019-01354-9. +Epub 2019 Sep 19. PMID: 31538320. + +663: Delaplain PT, Phillips JL, Lundeberg M, Nahmias J, Kuza CM, Sheehan BM, +Murphy LS, Pejcinovska M, Grigorian A, Gabriel V, Barie PS, Schubl SD. No +Reduction in Surgical Site Infection Obtained with Post-Operative Antibiotics in +Facial Fractures, Regardless of Duration or Anatomic Location: A Systematic +Review and Meta-Analysis. Surg Infect (Larchmt). 2020 Mar;21(2):112-121. doi: +10.1089/sur.2019.149. Epub 2019 Sep 17. PMID: 31526317. + +664: Simbi CMC, Zhang Y, Wang Z. Early parental loss in childhood and depression +in adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis of case-controlled studies. J +Affect Disord. 2020 Jan 1;260:272-280. doi: 10.1016/j.jad.2019.07.087. Epub 2019 +Jul 30. PMID: 31521863. + +665: Andrade-González N, Hernández-Gómez A, Álvarez-Sesmero S, Gutiérrez-Rojas +L, Vieta E, Reinares M, Lahera G. The influence of the working alliance on the +treatment and outcomes of patients with bipolar disorder: A systematic review. J +Affect Disord. 2020 Jan 1;260:263-271. doi: 10.1016/j.jad.2019.09.014. Epub 2019 +Sep 3. PMID: 31521862. + +666: Caldeira PC, Soto AML, de Aguiar MCF, Martins CC. Tumor depth of invasion +and prognosis of early-stage oral squamous cell carcinoma: A meta-analysis. Oral +Dis. 2020 Oct;26(7):1357-1365. doi: 10.1111/odi.13194. Epub 2019 Oct 9. PMID: +31520552. + +667: Zheng L, Li G, Wang X, Yin H, Jia Y, Leng M, Li H, Chen L. Effect of +exergames on physical outcomes in frail elderly: a systematic review. Aging Clin +Exp Res. 2020 Nov;32(11):2187-2200. doi: 10.1007/s40520-019-01344-x. Epub 2019 +Sep 13. PMID: 31520334. + +668: Dimitrov E, Enchev E, Minkov G, Halacheva K, Yovtchev Y. Poor Outcome Could +Be Predicted by Lower Monocyte Human Leukocyte Antigen-DR Expression in Patients +with Complicated Intra-Abdominal Infections: A Review. Surg Infect (Larchmt). +2020 Mar;21(2):77-80. doi: 10.1089/sur.2019.050. Epub 2019 Sep 4. PMID: +31483200. + +669: Cushman DM, Strenn Q, Elmer A, Yang AJ, Onofrei L. Complications Associated +With Electromyography: A Systematic Review. Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 2020 +Feb;99(2):149-155. doi: 10.1097/PHM.0000000000001304. PMID: 31469680. + +670: Henry BM, Pękala PA, Frączek PA, Pękala JR, Natsis K, Piagkou M, +Tomaszewski KA, Tomaszewska IM. Prevalence, morphology, and morphometry of the +pterygospinous bar: a meta-analysis. Surg Radiol Anat. 2020 May;42(5):497-507. +doi: 10.1007/s00276-019-02305-9. Epub 2019 Aug 28. PMID: 31463681; PMCID: +PMC7096365. + +671: Chirewa B, Wakhisi A. Emergency hormonal contraceptive service provision +via community pharmacies in the UK: a systematic review of pharmacists' and +young women's views, perspectives and experiences. Perspect Public Health. 2020 +Mar;140(2):108-116. doi: 10.1177/1757913919867356. Epub 2019 Aug 12. PMID: +31402746. + +672: Bae JM. Body Mass Index and Risk of Gastric Cancer in Asian Adults: A Meta- +Epidemiological Meta-Analysis of Population-Based Cohort Studies. Cancer Res +Treat. 2020 Apr;52(2):369-373. doi: 10.4143/crt.2019.241. Epub 2019 Aug 12. +PMID: 31401820; PMCID: PMC7176952. + +673: Neumann DL. A Systematic Review of Attentional Focus Strategies in +Weightlifting. Front Sports Act Living. 2019 Aug 9;1:7. doi: +10.3389/fspor.2019.00007. PMID: 33344931; PMCID: PMC7739707. + +674: Bahraini S, Gifford W, Graham ID, Wazni L, Brémault-Phillips S, Hackbusch +R, Demers C, Egan M. The accuracy of measures in screening adults for spiritual +suffering in health care settings: A systematic review. Palliat Support Care. +2020 Feb;18(1):89-102. doi: 10.1017/S1478951519000506. PMID: 31387655. + +675: He Y, Li K, Chen Q, Yin J, Bai D. Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic +Stimulation on Motor Recovery for Patients With Stroke: A PRISMA Compliant +Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 2020 +Feb;99(2):99-108. doi: 10.1097/PHM.0000000000001277. PMID: 31361620. + +676: Nilsson C, Berthold M, Mascialino B, Orme M, Sjölander S, Hamilton R. +Allergen components in diagnosing childhood hazelnut allergy: Systematic +literature review and meta-analysis. Pediatr Allergy Immunol. 2020 +Feb;31(2):186-196. doi: 10.1111/pai.13110. Epub 2020 Jan 1. PMID: 31301691. + +677: Dudi-Venkata NN, Kroon HM, Bedrikovetski S, Moore JW, Sammour T. Systematic +scoping review of enhanced recovery protocol recommendations targeting return of +gastrointestinal function after colorectal surgery. ANZ J Surg. 2020 +Jan;90(1-2):41-47. doi: 10.1111/ans.15319. Epub 2019 Jul 4. PMID: 31272135. + +678: McKenzie J, Joy A. Family intervention improves outcomes for patients with +delirium: Systematic review and meta-analysis. Australas J Ageing. 2020 +Mar;39(1):21-30. doi: 10.1111/ajag.12688. Epub 2019 Jun 28. PMID: 31250961. + +679: Romanos GE, Romanos EB, Alqahtani F, Alqahtani M, Javed F. "Religious +Belief": An Undervalued Ethical Inclusion Criterion for Clinical Trials on Bone +Grafting Procedures. J Relig Health. 2020 Dec;59(6):2928-2934. doi: +10.1007/s10943-019-00851-5. PMID: 31154591. + +680: Di Tella S, Pagliari C, Blasi V, Mendozzi L, Rovaris M, Baglio F. +Integrated telerehabilitation approach in multiple sclerosis: A systematic +review and meta-analysis. J Telemed Telecare. 2020 Aug-Sep;26(7-8):385-399. doi: +10.1177/1357633X19850381. Epub 2019 May 27. PMID: 31132909. + +681: Lassaletta L, Morales-Puebla JM, Altuna X, Arbizu Á, Arístegui M, Batuecas +Á, Cenjor C, Espinosa-Sánchez JM, García-Iza L, García-Raya P, González-Otero T, +Mañós M, Martín C, Moraleda S, Roda JM, Santiago S, Benítez J, Cavallé L, +Correia V, Estévez JM, Gómez J, González R, Jiménez J, Lacosta JL, Lavilla MJ, +Peñarrocha J, Polo R, García-Purriños F, Ramos F, Tomás M, Uzcanga M, Vallejo +LÁ, Gavilán J. Facial paralysis: Clinical practice guideline of the Spanish +Society of Otolaryngology. Acta Otorrinolaringol Esp. 2020 Mar-Apr;71(2):99-118. +English, Spanish. doi: 10.1016/j.otorri.2018.12.004. Epub 2019 May 13. PMID: +31097197. + +682: Yan WS, Cao WL, Sun M, Ma DY, Zhang P. Distal locked or unlocked nailing +for stable intertrochanteric fractures? A meta-analysis. ANZ J Surg. 2020 +Jan;90(1-2):27-33. doi: 10.1111/ans.15232. Epub 2019 May 13. PMID: 31083793. + +683: Drosatos G, Kaldoudi E. A probabilistic semantic analysis of eHealth +scientific literature. J Telemed Telecare. 2020 Aug-Sep;26(7-8):414-432. doi: +10.1177/1357633X19846252. Epub 2019 May 12. Erratum in: J Telemed Telecare. 2020 +Apr;26(3):NP1. PMID: 31081450. + +684: Matterne U, Baumeister SE, Apfelbacher CJ. Suicidality and risk of +suicidality in psoriasis: a critical appraisal of two systematic reviews and +meta-analyses. Br J Dermatol. 2019 Oct;181(4):717-721. doi: 10.1111/bjd.18108. +Epub 2019 Aug 1. PMID: 31074832. + +685: Yeroushalmi S, Maloni H, Costello K, Wallin MT. Telemedicine and multiple +sclerosis: A comprehensive literature review. J Telemed Telecare. 2020 Aug- +Sep;26(7-8):400-413. doi: 10.1177/1357633X19840097. Epub 2019 May 1. PMID: +31042118. + +686: Nasioudis D, Kim SW, Schoen C, Levine LD. Maternal and neonatal outcomes +with mechanical cervical dilation plus misoprostol compared to misoprostol alone +for cervical ripening; a systematic review of literature and metaanalysis. Am J +Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2019 May;1(2):101-111. doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2019.06.003. +Epub 2019 Jun 11. PMID: 33345815. + +687: Gaviola MA, Inder KJ, Dilworth S, Holliday EG, Higgins I. Impact of +individualised music listening intervention on persons with dementia: A +systematic review of randomised controlled trials. Australas J Ageing. 2020 +Mar;39(1):10-20. doi: 10.1111/ajag.12642. Epub 2019 Mar 26. PMID: 30912616. + +688: Mourad A, Straube S, Armijo-Olivo S, Gniadecki R. Factors predicting +persistence of biologic drugs in psoriasis: a systematic review and meta- +analysis. Br J Dermatol. 2019 Sep;181(3):450-458. doi: 10.1111/bjd.17738. Epub +2019 Apr 29. PMID: 30729500. + +689: Vermeulen FM, Gerbens LAA, Bosma AL, Apfelbacher CJ, Irvine AD, Arents BWM, +Barbarot S, Deleuran M, Eichenfield LF, Manca A, Schmitt J, Vestergaard C, Wall +D, Weidinger S, Middelkamp-Hup MA, Spuls PI, Flohr C; International TREAT +Registry Taskforce. TREatment of ATopic eczema (TREAT) Registry Taskforce: +consensus on how and when to measure the core dataset for atopic eczema +treatment research registries. Br J Dermatol. 2019 Sep;181(3):492-504. doi: +10.1111/bjd.17715. Epub 2019 Jun 23. PMID: 30719709; PMCID: PMC6771812. + +690: Sach TH, McManus E, Levell NJ. Understanding economic evidence for the +prevention and treatment of atopic eczema. Br J Dermatol. 2019 +Oct;181(4):707-716. doi: 10.1111/bjd.17696. Epub 2019 Apr 11. PMID: 30693473; +PMCID: PMC6790711. + +691: Røsvik J, Michelet M, Engedal K, Bieber A, Broda A, Gonçalves-Pereira M, +Hopper L, Irving K, Jelley H, Kerpershoek L, Meyer G, Marques MJ, Portolani E, +Sjölund BM, Sköldunger A, Stephan A, Verhey F, de Vugt M, Woods B, Wolfs C, +Zanetti O, Selbaek G. Interventions to enhance access to and utilization of +formal community care services for home dwelling persons with dementia and their +informal carers. A scoping review. Aging Ment Health. 2020 Feb;24(2):200-211. +doi: 10.1080/13607863.2018.1523876. Epub 2019 Jan 21. PMID: 30663890. + +692: Howie AJ. Genetic studies of focal segmental glomerulosclerosis: a waste of +scientific time? Pediatr Nephrol. 2020 Jan;35(1):9-16. doi: +10.1007/s00467-018-4161-6. Epub 2018 Dec 27. PMID: 30591974; PMCID: PMC6901409. + +693: Romero-Martínez Á, Hidalgo-Moreno G, Moya-Albiol L. Neuropsychological +consequences of chronic stress: the case of informal caregivers. Aging Ment +Health. 2020 Feb;24(2):259-271. doi: 10.1080/13607863.2018.1537360. Epub 2018 +Nov 18. PMID: 30450952. + +694: Khan MS, Siddiqi TJ, Khan SU, Shah SJ, VanWagner LB, Khan SS. Association +of liver stiffness and cardiovascular outcomes in patients with heart failure: A +systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur J Prev Cardiol. 2020 Feb;27(3):331-334. +doi: 10.1177/2047487318810013. Epub 2018 Oct 30. PMID: 30376368; PMCID: +PMC7319230. + +695: Dhont E, Van Der Heggen T, De Jaeger A, Vande Walle J, De Paepe P, De Cock +PA. Augmented renal clearance in pediatric intensive care: are we undertreating +our sickest patients? Pediatr Nephrol. 2020 Jan;35(1):25-39. doi: +10.1007/s00467-018-4120-2. Epub 2018 Oct 29. PMID: 30374606. + +696: Droege JR, Robinson WL, Jason LA. Suicidality Protective Factors for +African American Adolescents: A Systematic Review of the Research Literature. +SOJ Nurs Health Care. 2017;3(2):10.15226/2471-6529/3/2/00130. doi: +10.15226/2471-6529/3/2/00130. Epub 2017 May 31. PMID: 33344874; PMCID: +PMC7747935. \ No newline at end of file