Parsed authorship properties #239
Comments
nielsklazenga
added
class:TaxonName
|
Although ICZN article 51.2.1. (Recommendation 51E. Citation of contributors) could be read to allow for joint authorship using "ex" (substituting ex for in); article 50.1.1 makes it clear that an ascribed author is responsible for the name and an optional citation acknowledging both the ascribed and publishing authors will take the form "ascribedAuthor ex publishingAuthor". This looks the same as the botanical form, except the publishing author is optional, not v.v. |
|
To help with a common code base, along with 'combination*', I have been replacing 'basionym' with 'primary' ( PrimaryUsage, primaryName, primaryAuthor ). It allows for lists mixing codes and does not create confusion. ICZN recommendation 51G permits (if desired) usage of the botanical form, |
|
Thanks @ghwhitbread, that makes it really clear. Maybe we should add 'Publishing' into the other terms? In any case, I will fix up those notes. |
|
Actually, @ghwhitbread , it looks like you are confounding 'ascription' and 'attribution'. From the '...both for the name or act and for satisfying the criteria of availability...' it is clear the Art. 50.1.1 is talking about the author to whom a name is attributed, so the The definition in Hawkesworth (2010) seems to indicate that it is not:
From Googling and ChatGPT-ing it seems to me that 'ex' in zoological names is used in the same sense that we use 'sec.' or 'sensu'. |
|
Edit: I'm too quick (or late), seeing that Greg beat me to the part of combination author in zoology. |
|
Yes, @nielsklazenga, I'm just making noise (but not confusing ascription). It seems that both codes are in agreement when it comes to the identity of authors (attribution), and only the botanical code accommodates (albeit optionally) the acknowledgement of partial ascription using "ex" authorship. Very few zoologists have read the biocode. |
|
Thanks @ghwhitbread, all good, I think your noise has improved the notes. I think that, even though the draft Biocode was published in a botanical journal, there will also be very few botanists who have read it. What is important is that it exists and was agreed on by nomenclature experts from all groups of organisms. And it has been very helpful for this exercise (not so much for the authorship, as that is not in there). |
|
It just occurred to me that the only thing we need to do for
There is nothing like this in TCS 1 and I am not sure it is something we want to exchange, so I have just updated the notes. |
Just putting the four existing properties together in a single issue, so we can concentrate the discussion and do not need to have four more issues.
tcs:basionymAuthor
Author of the basionym of the name
basionymAuthoris an IRI property. It can be a Person or a Group, or multiple Person IRIs or objects.basionymAuthor(or its literal counterpart) is the bit in parentheses in thedwc:scientificNameAuthorship.tcs:basionymAuthorLiteral
Author of the basionym of the name
basionymAuthorLiteralis a Literal property.basionymAuthorLiteralis the bit in parentheses in thedwc:scientificNameAuthorship.tcs:combinationAuthor
Author of the combination
combinationAuthoris an IRI property. It can be a Person or a Group, or multiple Person IRIs or objects.'combination' is taken here to be a different name with the same nomenclatural type.
tcs:combinationAuthorLiteral
Author of the combination
combinationAuthorLiteralis a Literal property.'combination' is taken here to be a different name with the same nomenclatural type.
tcs:basionymAscribedAuthor
Ascribed author of the basionym of the name
basionymAscribedAuthoris an IRI property. It can be a Person or a Group, or multiple Person IRIs or objects.'Ascribed author' is a person (or group of people) who a name is ascribed to in a publication, but who is not the author of the name according to the rules of the nomenclatural codes, because they did not contribute to the validating description of the name. In the
dwc:scientificNameAuthorshipthese authors are indicated with 'ex', the ascribed author coming before the 'ex' and the author the name is attributed to after. Note that the 'ex' construction that is sometimes used with zoological names has got nothing to do with attribution or ascription, but is used to indicate a concept, much like we do here with 'sec.' or 'sensu' in taxon concept labels.tcs:basionymAscribedAuthorLiteral
Ascribed author of the basionym of the name
basionymAscribedAuthorLiteralis a Literal property.'Ascribed author' is a person (or group of people) who a name is ascribed to in a publication, but who is not the author of the name according to the rules of the nomenclatural codes, because they did not contribute to the validating description of the name. In the
dwc:scientificNameAuthorshipthese authors are indicated with 'ex', the ascribed author coming before the 'ex' and the author the name is attributed to after. Note that the 'ex' construction that is sometimes used with zoological names has got nothing to do with attribution or ascription, but is used to indicate a concept, much like we do here with 'sec.' or 'sensu' in taxon concept labels.tcs:combinationAscribedAuthor
Ascribed author of the present name
combinationAscibedAuthoris an IRI property. It can be a Person or a Group, or multiple Person IRIs or objects.'Ascribed author' is a person (or group of people) who a name is ascribed to in a publication, but who is not the author of the name according to the rules of the nomenclatural codes, because they did not contribute to the validating description of the name. In the
dwc:scientificNameAuthorshipthese authors are indicated with 'ex', the ascribed author coming before the 'ex' and the author the name is attributed to after. Note that the 'ex' construction that is sometimes used with zoological names has got nothing to do with attribution or ascription, but is used to indicate a concept, much like we do here with 'sec.' or 'sensu' in taxon concept labels.tcs:combinationAscribedAuthorLiteral
Ascribed author of the present name
combinationAscribedAuthorLiteralis a Literal property.'Ascribed author' is a person (or group of people) who a name is ascribed to in a publication, but who is not the author of the name according to the rules of the nomenclatural codes, because they did not contribute to the validating description of the name. In the
dwc:scientificNameAuthorshipthese authors are indicated with 'ex', the ascribed author coming before the 'ex' and the author the name is attributed to after. Note that the 'ex' construction that is sometimes used with zoological names has got nothing to do with attribution or ascription, but is used to indicate a concept, much like we do here with 'sec.' or 'sensu' in taxon concept labels.The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: