Ledger "unexpected application error!" after clicking the account to connect with "No LedgerRequestKeysContext found"

[314159265359879]

Reproduce with these steps

1. Sign out wallet
2. Connect wallet to Stacks with Ledger, so account balance shows in the extension
3. Then disconnect the ledger device from computer
4. Sign in to a dapp for example lockstacks.com
5. Select account to connect with
6. See error:

To fix issue: connect Ledger Device to your computer again, start the Stacks app on the Ledger device then try again.

I think instead of this error the wallet should show better guidance for the user.

[wizard1786]

How about for edge browser?

[wizard1786]

Did not work with edge browser got the same error message
Any help on transferring stx out of leather wallet ?

[edgarkhanzadian]

@314159265359879 I've tried reproducing the error but i didn't get any result. What version did you get this error on? Can you, please, try reproducing it on the dev branch now?

Note: you won't be able to see it in the video, but i disconnected the ledger device right after signing in into leather with stacks app.

reproductionAttemptLedgerError.mov

[wizard1786]

???? Dev branch Sent from my iPhoneOn Jan 24, 2024, at 5:12 AM, Edgar Khanzadian ***@***.***> wrote: @314159265359879 I've tried reproducing the error but i didn't get any result. What version did you get this error on? Can you, please, try reproducing it on the dev branch now? Note: you won't be able to see it in the video, but i disconnected the ledger device right after signing in into leather with stacks app. https://github.com/leather-wallet/extension/assets/22010816/74ceb7b4-9449-4ce7-85a8-98f6d9f82f22 —Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[wizard1786]

I give up If I used a different ledger device would that make a difference? Sent from my iPhoneOn Jan 24, 2024, at 5:12 AM, Edgar Khanzadian ***@***.***> wrote: @314159265359879 I've tried reproducing the error but i didn't get any result. What version did you get this error on? Can you, please, try reproducing it on the dev branch now? Note: you won't be able to see it in the video, but i disconnected the ledger device right after signing in into leather with stacks app. https://github.com/leather-wallet/extension/assets/22010816/74ceb7b4-9449-4ce7-85a8-98f6d9f82f22 —Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[edgarkhanzadian]

@wizard1786 using a different ledger device shouldn't make a difference in theory, but let me know if you are able to reproduce it on another type of device. I was unable to repro it on ledger nano X

[314159265359879]

@edgarkhanzadian I first tested this with version 6.22.0 of the wallet and a Nano S plus, it is still the same for me today with version 6.24.0.
Testing on Chrome version 120.0.6099.227
firmware version 1.1.1

You're video isn't playing for me (looks like an issue with github).

2024-01-25_15-40-03.mp4

[wizard1786]

Nothing seems to make a difference Sent from my iPhoneOn Jan 25, 2024, at 9:42 AM, Werner ***@***.***> wrote: @edgarkhanzadian I first tested this with version 6.22.0 of the wallet and a Nano S plus, it is still the same for me today with version 6.24.0. Testing on Chrome version 120.0.6099.227 firmware version 1.1.1 You're video isn't playing for me (looks like an issue with github). https://github.com/leather-wallet/extension/assets/33360391/bc4c87b4-c159-491d-b630-401a463c7143 —Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[wizard1786]

Tried to send an mp4 file of video , says it is too large ? how to get it to you Connected to a different stacks website got the same error message From: Edgar Khanzadian ***@***.***> Sent: Thursday, January 25, 2024 4:19 AM To: leather-wallet/extension ***@***.***> Cc: wizard1786 ***@***.***>; Mention ***@***.***> Subject: Re: [leather-wallet/extension] Ledger "unexpected application error!" after clicking the account to connect with "No LedgerRequestKeysContext found" (Issue #4786) @wizard1786 <https://github.com/wizard1786> using a different ledger device shouldn't make a difference in theory, but let me know if you are able to reproduce it on another type of device. I was unable to repro it on ledger nano X — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#4786 (comment)> , or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AIXAWLXBMJBFL4ATSBBCDHDYQIPPPAVCNFSM6AAAAABBS35VKWVHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMYTSMBZG4ZDINRUGA> . You are receiving this because you were mentioned. <https://github.com/notifications/beacon/AIXAWLVNZ7UI34XG4XJWBSTYQIPPPA5CNFSM6AAAAABBS35VKWWGG33NNVSW45C7OR4XAZNMJFZXG5LFINXW23LFNZ2KUY3PNVWWK3TUL5UWJTTR2QK6A.gif> Message ID: ***@***.***>

[314159265359879]

@wizard1786 We have enough video material, thanks for the effort though.

If you keep hitting this error even when the Ledger device is connected to your computer and it is the same device used to setup your Leather wallet. I assume there is an issue with connection or cable. Try it on another device, another browser and/or with another cable to exclude any issues with those.

Before signing in on a dapp, make sure your Leather wallet is on the same account you want to sign in with. Then sign in on the page. Please connect via [email protected] for further assistance if you see this persist.

[kyranjamie]

Reopening this issue, saw it happen.

When trying to sign a transaction with Ledger, and the device isn't able to connect, we route to an error page (that isn't within the context so we see this error).

[pete-watters]

I've been investigating this but as yet unable to reproduce. Once signed in to a DAPP with ledger, if I then disconnect, when I try and perform an action it prompts me to connect the Ledger again.

• I signed in to Gamma
• initiated a purchase of a BTC collectible
• disconnected the ledger
• observed that the popup prompts me to connect my Ledger and doesn't error

I'll keep investigating and try with a Stacks interaction instead in case there is some bug there.

@kyranjamie do you remember exactly what you were doing to cause the error? Maybe its different than the device not being connected and it's an issue with communicating with a connected device?

[kyranjamie]

This was a routing issue I think, where you get routed somewhere outside the context. Try with lockstacks.com

[pete-watters]

I could be missing something here but if my Ledger is not connected, I consistently get a prompt to ask me to connect it rather than hitting any kind of uncaught error.

No LedgerRequestKeysContext found is an error we throw in useLedgerRequestKeysContext and I cannot find any instances of it in Sentry, albeit it for the past 90 days.

If I try with lockstacks.com to:

• connect my wallet - with a disconnected Ledger
  https://github.com/leather-wallet/extension/assets/2938440/69f1e9c7-d66b-4c1e-a8f5-5d0d0d56049e

• join a staking pool - with a disconnected Ledger
  https://github.com/leather-wallet/extension/assets/2938440/a6cf0bb3-163d-430a-a24c-62ea8e2d9f2c

In both cases, the Leather popup handles the lack of Ledger connection gracefully and shows the We're unable to connect to your Ledger device warning.

Looking at the code and two places where we use useLedgerRequestKeysContext and could potentially hit this error are in:

• ConnectLedgerRequestKeys
• AddMoreKeysLayout

If I am testing ConnectLedgerRequestKeys AKA the initial Route - ConnectLedger - connect-your-ledger it seems to be handled well.

If it is still a bug it seems likely related to AddMoreKeysLayout but when I look deeper into that, it seems like dead code no longer used. In our code we only have:

• a reference to only the route RouteUrls.LedgerAddMoreKeys in route-urls
• Handling of that route in ledgerRequestKeysRoutes with component AddMoreKeysLayout

@kyranjamie : do you know what the LedgerAddMoreKeys route is for? Does it relate to #2502? It was added in this PR - #4042

@314159265359879 : I can't play your repro video linked in #4786 (comment). When you have time can you please help me try and reproduce this?

[kyranjamie]

Thanks for the investigation @pete-watters. Could be that it's been fixed 👍🏼

RE: RouteUrls.LedgerAddMoreKey. At one point, we had a route that would allow you to add more keys, after you'd added the first, but I think this has been removed as we show the connect button on homepage. As such, think we can remove it.

[pete-watters]

OK thanks. I will remove that route and when Werner is back I will double check with him and if he cannot reproduce I will close.

[pete-watters]

@314159265359879 when you have a chance can you please help test if this is still a problem? I was unable to reproduce so I think it is fixed but if you can still reproduce it please let me know

[314159265359879]

@pete-watters I retested this too, and it looks resolved indeed. It is handled gracefully now.

[pete-watters]

OK that's great, thanks for confirming 👍