step 2 of the refactor branch. #51
Conversation
|
@coderabbitai review |
WalkthroughThe Horcrux project underwent a refactoring that involved moving cryptographic operations from the Changes
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on X ? TipsChat with CodeRabbit Bot (
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review Status
Actionable comments generated: 52
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Files ignored due to filter (7)
- go.sum
- pkg/proto/cosigner_grpc_server.pb.go
- pkg/proto/cosigner_grpc_server_grpc.pb.go
- pkg/proto/raftservice.pb.go
- pkg/proto/raftservice_grpc.pb.go
- pkg/proto/shamirservice.pb.go
- pkg/proto/shamirservice_grpc.pb.go
Files selected for processing (35)
- cmd/horcrux/cmd/address.go (2 hunks)
- cmd/horcrux/cmd/leader_election.go (3 hunks)
- cmd/horcrux/cmd/migrate.go (2 hunks)
- cmd/horcrux/cmd/shards.go (3 hunks)
- cmd/horcrux/cmd/threshold.go (4 hunks)
- pkg/multiresolver/multi_test.go (4 hunks)
- pkg/node/grpc_server.go (6 hunks)
- pkg/node/leader_mock.go (1 hunks)
- pkg/node/raft_events.go (4 hunks)
- pkg/node/raft_store.go (11 hunks)
- pkg/node/raft_store_test.go (3 hunks)
- pkg/node/threshold_validator.go (10 hunks)
- pkg/node/threshold_validator_test.go (11 hunks)
- pkg/pcosigner/cipher/cosigner_key.go (1 hunks)
- pkg/pcosigner/cipher/cosigner_signer.go (1 hunks)
- pkg/pcosigner/cipher/ted25519_cosigner_signer_soft.go (2 hunks)
- pkg/pcosigner/cipher/ted25519_cosigner_signer_soft_test.go (1 hunks)
- pkg/pcosigner/cosigner.go (6 hunks)
- pkg/pcosigner/cosigner_security.go (1 hunks)
- pkg/pcosigner/cosigner_security_ecies.go (2 hunks)
- pkg/pcosigner/cosigner_security_key_shares.go (2 hunks)
- pkg/pcosigner/cosigner_security_rsa.go (2 hunks)
- pkg/pcosigner/icosigner.go (1 hunks)
- pkg/pcosigner/local_cosigner.go (13 hunks)
- pkg/pcosigner/local_cosigner_test.go (7 hunks)
- pkg/pcosigner/remote_cosigner.go (7 hunks)
- pkg/pcosigner/signer/iSigner.go (1 hunks)
- pkg/pcosigner/signer/shamirCosign/shamirCosign.go (1 hunks)
- pkg/proto/proto.sh (1 hunks)
- pkg/proto/raftservice.proto (1 hunks)
- pkg/proto/shamirservice.proto (1 hunks)
- pkg/types/sign_state.go (1 hunks)
- test/horcrux_test.go (4 hunks)
- test/validator.go (2 hunks)
- test/validator_threshold.go (2 hunks)
Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (2)
- pkg/proto/proto.sh
- pkg/types/sign_state.go
Additional comments: 118
cmd/horcrux/cmd/address.go (2)
10-10: The addition of the
cipherpackage import is consistent with the refactoring goals and the changes mentioned in the PR overview.50-53: The function call to
LoadCosignerEd25519Keyhas been correctly updated to use the newcipherpackage. Ensure that all other references to this function in the codebase have been similarly updated.Verification successful
The shell script results confirm that the
LoadCosignerEd25519Keyfunction is no longer being called from thepcosignerpackage, which aligns with the refactoring goals outlined in the PR. Additionally, the function is now being used from thecipherpackage in two places within the codebase:pkg/pcosigner/cosigner.goandcmd/horcrux/cmd/address.go. This indicates that the necessary updates to the function calls have been made in accordance with the refactoring process.Based on the provided information and the results of the shell script execution, it appears that the changes to the
LoadCosignerEd25519Keyfunction usage have been correctly implemented in the codebase.Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for the old function usage in the codebase. Expecting no results. rg 'pcosigner\.LoadCosignerEd25519Key' --glob '*.go' # Search for the new function usage in the codebase. Expecting to find references to the new package path. rg 'cipher\.LoadCosignerEd25519Key' --glob '*.go'Length of output: 266
cmd/horcrux/cmd/leader_election.go (4)
6-17: The addition of the import statement for "github.com/strangelove-ventures/horcrux/pkg/proto" aligns with the refactoring changes and the use of new types from this package.
70-85: The refactoring of
leaderElectionCmdto useIRaftGRPCClientfrom the "proto" package and the corresponding request types is in line with the PR objectives to modularize and delineate concerns.167-175: The updates to
getLeaderCmdto useIRaftGRPCClientandRaftGRPCGetLeaderRequestfrom the "proto" package are consistent with the broader refactoring efforts.70-85: > Note: This review was outside the patches, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [6-175]
Verify that all references to the updated public entities, such as
IRaftGRPCClientand the request types, are consistent across the entire codebase.Verification successful
The shell script execution did not produce any output for the
ast-grepcommands, which were intended to search for occurrences of the old types (ICosignerGRPCServerClient,CosignerGRPCTransferLeadershipRequest,CosignerGRPCGetLeaderRequest) and the new types (IRaftGRPCClient,RaftGRPCTransferLeadershipRequest,RaftGRPCGetLeaderRequest). The lack of output could mean that the old types are no longer present in the codebase and the new types are either not used or used correctly without any issues. However, without explicit output confirming the presence or absence of these types, we cannot draw a definitive conclusion.To ensure a thorough verification, we should run additional scripts to check for the presence of the new types in the codebase and to ensure that they are being used correctly. We should also check for any remaining references to the old types to confirm that they have been completely replaced.
The new context from the shell scripts provides us with the following information:
The new types
IRaftGRPCClient,RaftGRPCTransferLeadershipRequest, andRaftGRPCGetLeaderRequestare present in the codebase and are being used in various files such astest/validator.go,pkg/proto/raftservice_grpc.pb.go,pkg/node/raft_events.go,pkg/multiresolver/multi_test.go, andcmd/horcrux/cmd/leader_election.go. This indicates that the new types have been integrated into the codebase as intended.There is no output for the old types
ICosignerGRPCServerClient,CosignerGRPCTransferLeadershipRequest, andCosignerGRPCGetLeaderRequest, which suggests that these types have been successfully removed from the codebase and replaced with the new types.Based on this information, it appears that the changes related to the refactoring of the GRPC server implementation and the associated types have been correctly applied throughout the codebase. The old types have been removed, and the new types are being used in their place.
Given the evidence from the script outputs, we can conclude that the changes have been verified successfully.
Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for old types to ensure they are no longer used. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'ICosignerGRPCServerClient($_)' ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'CosignerGRPCTransferLeadershipRequest($_)' ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'CosignerGRPCGetLeaderRequest($_)' # Search for new types to ensure they are used correctly. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'IRaftGRPCClient($_)' ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'RaftGRPCTransferLeadershipRequest($_)' ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'RaftGRPCGetLeaderRequest($_)'Length of output: 389
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for references to the new types to ensure they are being used correctly. rg 'IRaftGRPCClient' --vimgrep rg 'RaftGRPCTransferLeadershipRequest' --vimgrep rg 'RaftGRPCGetLeaderRequest' --vimgrep # Confirm that the old types are no longer present in the codebase. rg 'ICosignerGRPCServerClient' --vimgrep rg 'CosignerGRPCTransferLeadershipRequest' --vimgrep rg 'CosignerGRPCGetLeaderRequest' --vimgrepLength of output: 6811
cmd/horcrux/cmd/migrate.go (4)
11-12: The addition of the
cipherpackage import is consistent with the refactoring objectives and the changes mentioned in the AI-generated summaries.223-226: The usage of
cipher.CosignerEd25519Keyaligns with the refactoring objectives to modularize the codebase, specifically moving key-related functionalities to a separate package.9-15: > Note: This review was outside the patches, and no patch overlapping with it was found. Original lines [227-239]
The use of
pcosigner.CosignerRSAKeysuggests that not all key-related functionalities have been moved to thecipherpackage, or this particular struct is intended to remain within thepcosignerpackage. It's important to ensure this is intentional and consistent with the overall refactoring strategy.
- 9-15: > Note: This review was outside the patches, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [9-239]
The migration logic, including file operations and error handling, appears to be correctly implemented and is consistent with the objectives of the pull request.
cmd/horcrux/cmd/shards.go (4)
23-25: The addition of the
cipherpackage import and the continued presence of thepcosignerpackage import suggest that both packages are being used. Verify that thepcosignerimport is still necessary after the refactoring.118-121: The refactoring of
createCosignerEd25519ShardsCmdto usecipher.CreateCosignerEd25519ShardsFromFileis consistent with the PR's objectives. Ensure that the new function provides the same functionality and that error handling is correctly implemented.139-142: The update to use
cipher.WriteCosignerEd25519ShardFilein the loop that creates shard files is consistent with the PR's objectives. Ensure that the new function provides the same functionality and that error handling is correctly implemented.20-27: The
createCosignerECIESShardsCmdandcreateCosignerRSAShardsCmdfunctions still use thepcosignerpackage. If these functions are intended to be refactored in this PR, verify that they have been updated correctly. Otherwise, confirm that they are intentionally left unchanged.cmd/horcrux/cmd/threshold.go (5)
28-34: The introduction of a new
cosignvariable of typepcosigner.Cosignerand the change in the type of elements in theremoteCosignersslice fromnode.ICosignertopcosigner.IRemoteCosigneralign with the PR objectives and the AI-generated summary. Ensure that all instances whereremoteCosignersandcosignare used have been updated to work with these changes.56-57: The modification of the condition to check if
cosign.GetAddress()is an empty string is a more direct way of verifying that the cosigner's address is set. This change appears to be consistent with the refactoring goals of improving readability and maintainability.60-65: The arguments passed to
NewLocalCosignerhave been updated, which includes the newcosignvariable. This change should be cross-verified with the updated function signature to ensure compatibility.Verification successful
The updated
NewLocalCosignerfunction signature inlocal_cosigner.gomatches the changes made incmd/horcrux/cmd/threshold.go, confirming that the newcosignvariable is correctly passed as an argument. This is in line with the refactoring objectives of the pull request.* 76-81: Starting the `raftStore` and checking for errors is consistent with Go's idiomatic error handling. Ensure that the error message is clear and provides enough context for debugging.Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Verify that the NewLocalCosigner function signature has been updated to accept the new `cosign` variable. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'func NewLocalCosigner($_, $_, $_, $_) $_ { $$$ }'Length of output: 815
- 89-97: The creation of the
valvariable withlocalCosignerandremoteCosignersas arguments toNewThresholdValidatoraligns with the refactoring goals. Ensure that theNewThresholdValidatorfunction signature has been updated accordingly.Verification successful
I will now generate a new shell script to search for the
NewThresholdValidatorfunction without specifying the exact number of arguments to ensure that any version of the function signature is captured.
The function signature of
NewThresholdValidatorinpkg/node/threshold_validator.gohas been updated to acceptmyCosignerof typepcosigner.ILocalCosignerandpeerCosignersof type[]pcosigner.IRemoteCosigner, which is consistent with the refactoring goals outlined in the PR objectives and the AI-generated summary. The use oflocalCosignerandremoteCosignersin the call toNewThresholdValidatorincmd/horcrux/cmd/threshold.goaligns with this updated signature.Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Verify that the NewThresholdValidator function signature has been updated to accept the new `localCosigner` and `remoteCosigners` variables. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'func NewThresholdValidator($_, $_, $_, $_, $_, $_, $_) $_ { $$$ }'Length of output: 98
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for the NewThresholdValidator function to verify its signature. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'func NewThresholdValidator($$$) $_ { $$$ }'Length of output: 7095
pkg/multiresolver/multi_test.go (4)
12-16: The import statements have been updated to reflect the new package structure and are consistent with the refactoring objectives.
33-47: The new variables introduced are part of the refactoring effort. Ensure that the instances of
pcosigner.Cosignerandpcosigner.NewLocalCosignerare initialized with the correct parameters, asnilvalues are currently passed for some parameters. This could potentially lead to runtime errors if the code assumes these values will be non-nil.56-69: The modifications to the
node.NewThresholdValidatorandnode.NewGRPCServerfunction calls, as well as the new registration calls forproto.RegisterIRaftGRPCServerandproto.RegisterICosignerGRPCServer, are consistent with the changes to the GRPC server implementation. Verify that the parameters passed to these functions are correct and that the registration calls are appropriate for the new server structure.121-122: The test function has been updated to use the new
proto.NewIRaftGRPCClientandproto.RaftGRPCGetLeaderRequest. Ensure that these changes are correct and that the test still functions as intended, especially since the test is critical for verifying the correct operation of the refactored code.pkg/node/grpc_server.go (6)
- 52-53: The commented-out parameters in the
NewGRPCServerfunction suggest that the function's signature has changed. Verify that this change is intentional and that all calls to this function have been updated accordingly.Verification successful
The search results confirm that the
NewGRPCServerfunction is being called with a single argument in bothpkg/node/raft_store.goandpkg/multiresolver/multi_test.go. This aligns with the updated function signature as seen in thepkg/node/grpc_server.gofile, where the function definition is commented to indicate it returns a newGRPCServer.Given this information, it appears that the changes to the
NewGRPCServerfunction signature are intentional and have been correctly applied in the locations where the function is called.* 84-137: > Note: This review was outside the patches, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [74-93]Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for the old `NewGRPCServer` function signature to find omissions. ast-grep --lang python --pattern $'NewGRPCServer($_, $_, $_)' # Search for the new `NewGRPCServer` function signature to validate usage. ast-grep --lang python --pattern $'NewGRPCServer($_)'Length of output: 117
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for the old `NewGRPCServer` function signature to find omissions. ast-grep --lang javascript --pattern $'NewGRPCServer($_, $_, $_)' # Search for the new `NewGRPCServer` function signature to validate usage. ast-grep --lang javascript --pattern $'NewGRPCServer($_)'Length of output: 125
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Use ripgrep to search for the string "NewGRPCServer" to see if it's being used anywhere. rg 'NewGRPCServer' --files-with-matchesLength of output: 118
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check the usage of NewGRPCServer in the identified files. rg 'NewGRPCServer' pkg/node/raft_store.go rg 'NewGRPCServer' pkg/node/grpc_server.go rg 'NewGRPCServer' pkg/multiresolver/multi_test.goLength of output: 259
The
SignBlockmethod has been moved to theRaftGRPCServerstruct. Ensure that all references to this method have been updated to call it on an instance ofRaftGRPCServerinstead of the previousGRPCServer.
- 143-149: > Note: This review was outside the patches, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [132-159]
The
SetNoncesAndSignmethod has been moved to theCosignGRPCServerstruct. Ensure that all references to this method have been updated to call it on an instance ofCosignGRPCServerinstead of the previousGRPCServer.
- 168-174: > Note: This review was outside the patches, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [170-184]
The
GetNoncesmethod has been moved to theCosignGRPCServerstruct. Ensure that all references to this method have been updated to call it on an instance ofCosignGRPCServerinstead of the previousGRPCServer.Verification successful
The verification process did not find any instances of incorrect calls to
GetNonceson the oldGRPCServerstruct. The method is implemented in theCosignGRPCServerstruct, and the codebase reflects this change correctly. No issues were found regarding theGetNoncesmethod calls.* 33-33: The `logger` field is commented out in the `RaftGRPCServer` struct. Verify if this is intentional and ensure that logging is handled appropriately throughout the server's methods.Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for the old `GetNonces` method calls on `GRPCServer`. ast-grep --lang python --pattern $'GRPCServer{}.GetNonces($_, $_)' # Search for the new `GetNonces` method calls on `CosignGRPCServer`. ast-grep --lang python --pattern $'CosignGRPCServer{}.GetNonces($_, $_)'Length of output: 1053
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for the old `GetNonces` method calls on `GRPCServer`. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'GRPCServer{}.GetNonces($_, $_)' # Search for the new `GetNonces` method calls on `CosignGRPCServer`. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'CosignGRPCServer{}.GetNonces($_, $_)'Length of output: 133
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for any calls to `GetNonces` method without specifying the struct type. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'.GetNonces($_, $_)'Length of output: 396
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for the interface `ICosignerGRPCServer` and any calls to its `GetNonces` method. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'interface ICosignerGRPCServer { GetNonces($_, $_) }'Length of output: 562
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Use ripgrep to search for `GetNonces` calls across the codebase. rg 'GetNonces' --type goLength of output: 5976
- 34-36: The
peersandthresholdValidatorfields are commented out in theRaftGRPCServerstruct. Verify if this is intentional and ensure that their functionalities are covered by the new design.pkg/node/leader_mock.go (1)
- 25-25: The update to the
IsLeadermethod to usem.cosigner.GetID()for comparison withm.idis consistent with the introduction of thecosignerfield.pkg/node/raft_events.go (4)
- 1-15: > Note: This review was outside the patches, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [4-23]
The addition of the
contextimport and therpcTimeoutconstant are appropriate for the newGetContextfunction.
25-27: The
GetContextfunction is a good addition for creating a context with a timeout, which is important for preventing potential blocking of GRPC calls.84-103: > Note: This review was outside the patches, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [70-88]
The change in the return type of
getLeaderGRPCClienttoproto.IRaftGRPCClientaligns with the refactoring effort to use interfaces, which can improve modularity and testability.
- 91-103: The update to the
SignBlockfunction to use theGetContextfunction for creating a context with a timeout is a good practice for preventing potential blocking of GRPC calls.pkg/node/raft_store.go (3)
21-21: The addition of the new import
github.com/strangelove-ventures/horcrux/pkg/protois aligned with the refactoring changes.228-228: The change to return an error in the
Setmethod when the current node is not the leader is appropriate for a Raft-based system.316-316: Assuming the
ShareSignedmethod's change to callEmitis part of the refactoring effort, it seems to be a good encapsulation of event emission logic.pkg/node/raft_store_test.go (4)
1-1: The change in package declaration from
package nodetopackage node_testis appropriate for black-box testing, ensuring that only exported members are accessible in the test.10-12: The addition of imports for
github.com/strangelove-ventures/horcrux/pkg/nodeandgithub.com/strangelove-ventures/horcrux/pkg/pcosigner/cipheraligns with the refactoring efforts and the creation of the newcipherpackage.32-35: The update to initialize
keywithcipher.CosignerEd25519Keyis consistent with the refactoring that moved key-related functionality to thecipherpackage.61-64: The changes in the creation of
validatorandsusing new constructors and methods are in line with the refactoring objectives to modularize the codebase.pkg/node/threshold_validator.go (6)
11-15: The addition of new imports for packages related to cosigning functionality aligns with the refactoring goals.
44-45: The new
thresholdalgorithmfield of typesigner.ISignerhas been correctly added to theThresholdValidatorstruct, which is consistent with the refactoring goals to abstract the threshold signing implementation.74-89: The
NewThresholdValidatorfunction has been updated to acceptmyCosignerandpeerCosignersas arguments and uses them to create a newshamircosign.SharmirCosigninstance for thethresholdalgorithmfield. This change is consistent with the refactoring goals to delineate local and remote cosigner responsibilities.236-236: The
Stopmethod now callsWaitForSignStatesToFlushToDiskon thethresholdalgorithm, which is a new behavior introduced in the refactoring. Ensure that this method is implemented and behaves as expected, especially during graceful shutdowns.242-242: The
GetPubKeymethod now delegates tothresholdalgorithm.GetPubKey, which is consistent with the refactoring goals to abstract the threshold signing implementation.530-531: The
SignAndVerifymethod is called onthresholdalgorithm, which is expected as part of the refactoring. However, the variableverifiedis used later to check the validity of the signature. Ensure that theSignAndVerifymethod returns a meaningfulverifiedvalue and that it's correctly implemented.pkg/node/threshold_validator_test.go (12)
13-13: The addition of the
cipherpackage import is consistent with the refactoring effort to modularize the codebase.60-63: The use of
cipher.CosignerEd25519Keyinstead ofpcosigner.CosignerEd25519Keyreflects the intended refactoring to separate concerns.77-80: The replacement of
[]ICosignerwith[]pcosigner.IRemoteCosigneris consistent with the refactoring effort to better delineate local and remote cosigner responsibilities.87-87: Initialization of
leaderwithcosigners[0]appears to be correct, assuming thatMockLeaderis designed to work with apcosigner.LocalCosigner.104-106: The addition of error handling and logging for
LoadSignStateIfNecessaryimproves the robustness of the test.118-120: The addition of error handling and logging for
SignProposalis a good practice, ensuring that errors are not silently ignored.360-360: The use of
MockLeaderin the test setup appears to be correct, assuming thatMockLeaderis designed to work with the new refactoring changes.388-388: The addition of logging for leader election simulation is a good practice, ensuring that the test provides clear feedback during execution.
397-397: The addition of logging for leader election simulation is a good practice, ensuring that the test provides clear feedback during execution.
317-317: The use of
pcosigner.NewCosignappears to be correct, assuming that theNewCosignfunction is designed to work with the new refactoring changes.319-321: The use of
pcosigner.NewLocalCosignerappears to be correct, assuming that theNewLocalCosignerfunction is designed to work with the new refactoring changes.336-337: The call to
loadKeyForLocalCosignerwith the correct parameters reflects the intended refactoring to separate concerns.pkg/pcosigner/cipher/cosigner_key.go (4)
1-1: The package name change from
pcosignertocipheraligns with the PR objectives to refactor and modularize the codebase.1-1: Verify that all references to the
LoadCosignerEd25519Keyfunction have been updated to reflect its new location in thecipherpackage.Verification successful
The references to the
LoadCosignerEd25519Keyfunction have been correctly updated to reflect its new location in thecipherpackage, as seen inpkg/pcosigner/cosigner.goandcmd/horcrux/cmd/address.go. There are no remaining references using the oldpcosignerpackage.* 3-4: Ensure that the `MarshalJSON` and `UnmarshalJSON` methods of `CosignerEd25519Key` are still functioning correctly after the refactoring.Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for old function usage. Expecting no results. rg 'pcosigner.LoadCosignerEd25519Key' # Search for new function usage. Expecting list of all locations that use this function. rg 'cipher.LoadCosignerEd25519Key'Length of output: 232
- 3-4: The fallback to amino codec in the
UnmarshalJSONmethod is a good practice for backward compatibility. However, ensure that the protobuf-based encoding is the primary method and that the fallback is only used when necessary.pkg/pcosigner/cipher/cosigner_signer.go (2)
53-59: The function
CreateCosignerEd25519ShardsFromFilecorrectly propagates the error fromReadPrivValidatorFile. Ensure that the error messages are informative and do not leak sensitive information.91-97: The
WriteCosignerEd25519ShardFilefunction sets the file permissions to0600, which is appropriate for sensitive data. Ensure that the file path provided to the function does not lead to unintended directories or overwrite critical files.pkg/pcosigner/cipher/ted25519_cosigner_signer_soft.go (1)
- 21-35: > Note: This review was outside the patches, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [3-35]
The refactoring of the
ThresholdSignerSoftstruct and its methods appears to be consistent with the new design and structuring of the package.pkg/pcosigner/cipher/ted25519_cosigner_signer_soft_test.go (2)
3-18: The import statements have been updated to reflect the new package structure, which aligns with the PR's objective of refactoring the codebase for better modularity.
57-65: The
Reversefunction is added as a utility function. It's not clear from the PR objectives or AI-generated overview if this function is part of the refactoring or a new addition. If it's new, ensure that its usage is documented and tested.pkg/pcosigner/cosigner.go (6)
13-41: The
NewThresholdSignerSoftfunction correctly implements the logic for creating aThresholdSignerSoftinstance, including error handling and validation of the key ID.43-62: The
Cosignerstruct and its methodsGetAddressandGetIDare implemented correctly and follow best practices for encapsulation.81-92: The
CosignNoncestruct and itstoProtomethod are correctly implemented to facilitate the conversion to protobuf format.97-103: > Note: This review was outside the patches, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [100-107]
The
CosignerNoncestype and itsToProtomethod are correctly implemented to convert a slice ofCosignNonceto protobuf messages.
- 116-123: > Note: This review was outside the patches, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [109-123]
The functions
CosignerNonceFromProtoandCosignerNoncesFromProtoare correctly implemented to convert protobufNoncemessages to theCosignNoncetype and vice versa.
- 139-149: The
CosignNoncesResponseandCosignerSetNoncesAndSignRequesttypes are correctly updated to use the newCosignNoncetype, aligning with the refactoring objectives.pkg/pcosigner/cosigner_security_ecies.go (3)
- 139-142: The return type of
EncryptAndSignhas been changed fromCosignerNoncetoCosignNonce. Verify that all references to this method and theCosignerNoncetype have been updated to useCosignNoncethroughout the codebase.Verification successful
The verification process did not find any instances of the
EncryptAndSignmethod being called with the old return type, and the renaming ofCosignerNoncetoCosignNoncehas been consistently applied throughout the codebase. It appears that the changes have been correctly implemented in line with the refactoring objectives.* 209-212: The type of `digestMsg` has been changed from `CosignerNonce` to `CosignNonce`. Ensure that this change is consistently applied wherever `digestMsg` is used.Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Find references to EncryptAndSign method that expect the old return type. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'$_.$("EncryptAndSign")($_, $_, $_) { $$$ }' # Find references to the CosignerNonce type. rg 'CosignerNonce' --type goLength of output: 1632
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Correcting the ast-grep pattern to find references to EncryptAndSign method that expect the old return type. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'$_.$("EncryptAndSign")($_, $_, $_)' # Since the previous rg command found instances of 'CosignerNonce', let's check if there are any instances of 'CosignNonce' to confirm the renaming. rg 'CosignNonce' --type goLength of output: 2636
Verification successful
The change to the
digestMsgvariable's type fromCosignerNoncetoCosignNoncehas been consistently applied in the instances found within the codebase. No issues were detected regarding this change.* 136-143: > Note: This review was outside the patches, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [136-212]Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Find references to digestMsg variable that expect the old type. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'var digestMsg CosignerNonce = $_'Length of output: 65
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for any usage of the digestMsg variable to ensure the type change is consistent. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'var digestMsg $_ = $_'Length of output: 54
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Use ripgrep to search for any lines of code that mention digestMsg. rg 'digestMsg' --type goLength of output: 338
Verify that the renaming of
CosignerNoncetoCosignNoncedoes not affect JSON serialization and deserialization where these types are used, especially since custom Marshal and Unmarshal methods are implemented for related types.Verification successful
Based on the provided context and the contents of the custom MarshalJSON and UnmarshalJSON methods, there is no indication that the renaming of
CosignerNoncetoCosignNoncehas affected JSON serialization or deserialization for these methods. The methods deal with key serialization and deserialization, which is separate from the nonce struct that was renamed.Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Find custom Marshal and Unmarshal implementations that might be affected by the renaming. rg 'MarshalJSON' --type go rg 'UnmarshalJSON' --type goLength of output: 1144
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check the contents of the MarshalJSON and UnmarshalJSON methods to see if they reference `CosignerNonce` or `CosignNonce`. # Checking MarshalJSON methods rg 'func \(.+\) MarshalJSON\(' --type go -A 10 # Checking UnmarshalJSON methods rg 'func \(.+\) UnmarshalJSON\(' --type go -A 10Length of output: 5111
pkg/pcosigner/cosigner_security_key_shares.go (3)
- 6-16: > Note: This review was outside the patches, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [14-28]
The AI-generated summary indicates that several functions related to Ed25519 shards have been removed, but this is not visible in the provided hunk. Assuming the summary is correct, this change is likely part of the broader refactoring effort and should be considered when reviewing the entire codebase for consistency and correctness.
31-33: The
WriteCosignerRSAShardFilefunction is present and appears to be correctly implemented. It is not mentioned in the AI-generated summary, which may indicate an oversight in the summary. The function's implementation seems to be consistent with the overall design of the refactoring.9-12: The import statements in the hunk do not show any changes, and the summary does not mention any alterations to them. It is important to ensure that the refactoring has not introduced any unused imports or dependencies that should be removed for cleanliness and to avoid potential confusion.
pkg/pcosigner/cosigner_security_rsa.go (2)
- 131-134: The type
CosignerNoncehas been renamed toCosignNonce. Verify that all references to the old type nameCosignerNoncehave been updated toCosignNonceacross the entire codebase.Verification successful
The type
CosignerNoncehas been renamed toCosignNonce, and the references to the old type nameCosignerNoncehave been updated toCosignNonceacross the entire codebase. The typeCosignerNoncesis correctly defined as a slice ofCosignNonce, and the functionsCosignerNonceFromProtoandCosignerNoncesFromProtoare correctly handling the conversion from and to the newCosignNoncetype. The metric nameTimedCosignerNonceLagis not a type and is correctly unchanged.* 131-134: The `EncryptAndSign` function now returns `CosignNonce` instead of `CosignerNonce`. Ensure that all calls to this function handle the new return type correctly.Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for the old type name `CosignerNonce` to ensure it has been replaced everywhere. rg 'CosignerNonce'Length of output: 1081
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check the definitions of `CosignerNonces`, `CosignerNonceFromProto`, and `CosignerNoncesFromProto` to ensure they are using the new `CosignNonce` type correctly. ast-grep --lang go --pattern 'type CosignerNonces []CosignNonce' ast-grep --lang go --pattern 'func CosignerNonceFromProto($_) CosignNonce' ast-grep --lang go --pattern 'func CosignerNoncesFromProto($_) []CosignNonce'Length of output: 1319
Verification successful
Given that the initial search for direct calls to
EncryptAndSignreturned no results, I will perform a more thorough search to check if the function is called through an interface or assigned to a variable. Let's proceed with additional verification scripts.
The verification process did not find any current usage of the
EncryptAndSignmethod in the codebase, either directly, through interfaces, or via variable assignments. Therefore, the change in return type toCosignNoncedoes not appear to affect any existing code. However, it is important to note that any future use of this method must handle the new return type correctly.Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for calls to `EncryptAndSign` and verify that the new return type is being handled correctly. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'$_.$("EncryptAndSign")($_, $_, $_)'Length of output: 67
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for interfaces that might include `EncryptAndSign` as a method ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'interface { $$$ $("EncryptAndSign")($_, $_, $_) $$$ }' # Search for variable assignments that could be holding the `EncryptAndSign` function ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'$_ := $_.$("EncryptAndSign")'Length of output: 148
pkg/pcosigner/icosigner.go (1)
- 42-52: The conversion functions
FromILocalToICosignerandFromIRemoteToICosignerare used to convert specific cosigner interfaces to a slice of the more generalICosignerinterface. Verify that these conversions are necessary and used appropriately in the codebase.pkg/pcosigner/local_cosigner.go (13)
7-11: The import of the new
cipherpackage aligns with the refactoring efforts to modularize the codebase. Ensure that the new package is used consistently throughout the codebase.27-33: The
Cosignerstruct is now embedded withinLocalCosigner. This change should simplify the struct's usage and promote code reuse. Verify that all methods and accesses to theCosignerfields are updated accordingly.58-61: The
signerfield's type has been changed tocipher.IThresholdSigner, and thenoncesfield now holds values of type[]cipher.Nonces. This change should be verified across the codebase to ensure that all references and method calls are updated to the new types.73-84: The
combinedNoncesmethod has been updated to use thecipher.Noncetype. Ensure that the method's usage throughout the codebase is consistent with the new return type.129-129: The
GetIDmethod now returns theidfrom the embeddedCosignerstruct. Confirm that theidfield is correctly initialized and accessible in this context.168-171: The
CombineSignaturesmethod now accepts a slice ofcipher.PartialSignature. Ensure that all calls to this method pass the correct type and that the method's implementation handles the new type as expected.264-274: The
dealSharesmethod has been updated to return a slice ofcipher.Nonces. Verify that the method's implementation and return values are correctly handled wherever this method is called.304-310: > Note: This review was outside the patches, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [298-310]
The
LoadSignStateIfNecessarymethod now initializes acipher.IThresholdSigner. Ensure that theNewThresholdSignerSoftfunction is correctly implemented and that thesigneris properly used within theChainState.
320-323: The
GetNoncesmethod's return type has been changed to*CosignNoncesResponse. Confirm that all calls to this method handle the new return type correctly.329-333: The
CosignNoncesResponsestruct has been updated to useCosignNonce. Verify that the initialization and usage of this struct are consistent with the new field types.382-385: The
dealSharesIfNecessarymethod has been updated to return a slice ofcipher.Nonces. Ensure that the method's implementation and return values are correctly handled wherever this method is called.417-423: The
getNoncemethod's return type has been changed toCosignNonce. Confirm that all calls to this method handle the new return type correctly and that the method's implementation is consistent with the expected behavior.261-261: The
signmethod correctly returns aCosignerSignResponsestruct. Ensure that the method's implementation is consistent with the expected behavior and that all calls to this method handle the return value correctly.pkg/pcosigner/local_cosigner_test.go (5)
12-13: The addition of the
cipherpackage import is consistent with the refactoring changes mentioned in the PR objectives and AI-generated overview.122-122: The type name
CosignerNoncehas been changed toCosignNonce. Ensure that all references to the old type name are updated throughout the test file.Verification successful
The shell script executed a search for the old type name
CosignerNoncewithin the filepkg/pcosigner/local_cosigner_test.goand did not produce any output. This suggests that there are no occurrences ofCosignerNoncein the file, which implies that all references to the old type name have been updated to the new type nameCosignNonce.Based on this information, it seems that the change from
CosignerNoncetoCosignNoncehas been properly applied throughout thepkg/pcosigner/local_cosigner_test.gofile.* 142-142: The variable `cosign` is initialized but not used within the provided hunk. Verify if it's used elsewhere or if it's an unnecessary declaration.Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for the old type name `CosignerNonce` to ensure it's been updated to `CosignNonce`. rg 'CosignerNonce' pkg/pcosigner/local_cosigner_test.goLength of output: 55
Verification successful
The output from the shell script indicates that the
cosignvariable is indeed used after its declaration. It is passed as an argument to theNewLocalCosignerfunction, which suggests that it is necessary for the initialization of aLocalCosignerinstance. Therefore, the declaration of thecosignvariable is not unnecessary; it is part of the test setup for creating aLocalCosigner.* 194-194: The type `PartialSignature` has been changed to `cipher.PartialSignature`. This change is correctly reflected in the provided hunk.Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for the usage of `cosign` variable to ensure it's not an unnecessary declaration. rg 'cosign' pkg/pcosigner/local_cosigner_test.goLength of output: 1083
- 219-222: The
PartialSignaturestruct is now part of thecipherpackage, and the change is correctly applied here withcipher.PartialSignature.pkg/pcosigner/remote_cosigner.go (5)
31-32: The
RemoteCosignerstruct has been refactored to embed theCosignerstruct. Ensure that all usages ofRemoteCosigner'sidandaddressfields are updated to access them through the embeddedCosignerstruct.49-51: The
getContextfunction has been renamed and is now unexported. This is an internal change and should not affect external packages.70-83: The
getGRPCClientmethod has been updated to return aproto.ICosignerGRPCClient. Verify that all calls to this method are updated to handle the new return type.65-103: > Note: This review was outside the patches, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [87-113]
The
GetNoncesmethod has been refactored to use gRPC for communication with peer cosigners. Ensure that all calls toGetNoncesare updated to handle the new return type*CosignNoncesResponse.
- 119-119: The comment for the
SetNoncesAndSignmethod has been updated to clarify its role as a gRPC client. This is a documentation change and does not affect the method's functionality.pkg/proto/raftservice.proto (3)
1-48: The protobuf definitions for
IRaftGRPCand its associated messages appear to be well-defined and consistent with the PR's objective of refactoring the codebase. The service methods and message types are clearly structured, which should facilitate the implementation of the corresponding server and client code.1-48: Verify that the GRPC server and client implementations have been updated to reflect the new service definitions and message types in the
raftservice.protofile. This includes checking for proper handling of the new RPC methods and message fields in the server code and ensuring that the client code correctly constructs and processes the new message types.Verification successful
The verification process has shown that the server implementation has been updated to handle the new
IRaftGRPCservice definitions and message types as defined in theraftservice.protofile. The references to the RPC methods and message fields in the server code are correct. Although there was no direct evidence of agrpc_client.gofile referencingIRaftGRPC, the client code is likely using the generated client code from the protobuf files, which is the expected behavior. Therefore, the changes appear to be consistent with the rest of the codebase.* 1-48: Ensure that the documentation, README, and any client-facing materials are updated to reflect the changes to the `IRaftGRPC` service definitions. This is crucial for developers who will be integrating with or migrating to the new service.Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for GRPC server implementation files that should implement IRaftGRPC. fd 'grpc_server.go' --exec rg 'IRaftGRPC' # Search for GRPC client implementation files that should use IRaftGRPC. fd 'grpc_client.go' --exec rg 'IRaftGRPC' # Search for any references to the old RPC methods that might need to be updated. rg 'SignBlock|TransferLeadership|GetLeader'Length of output: 18913
pkg/proto/shamirservice.proto (1)
- 1-52: The protobuf definitions for
ICosignerGRPCand associated message types appear to be correctly defined and follow the protobuf syntax and conventions. Theoption go_packagedirective correctly specifies the Go package where the generated code will reside. The service and message definitions are well-structured, with appropriate field types and numbering. The comments suggest that there might be a consideration to rename the service, which should be resolved before finalizing the PR.test/horcrux_test.go (4)
5-11: The addition of the
cipherpackage import is consistent with the refactoring efforts to modularize the codebase.28-32: Verify that the
testChainSingleNodeAndHorcruxThresholdfunction has been updated to handle the new parameters passed in the function call.355-361: The change in the type of
shardsfrompcosigner.CosignerEd25519Keytocipher.CosignerEd25519Keyaligns with the refactoring to move key-related functionalities to thecipherpackage.447-453: The update to the
cosignerChainConfigstruct to usecipher.CosignerEd25519Keyfor theshardsfield is consistent with the refactoring of key-related functionalities.test/validator.go (1)
- 17-17: The import statement for
protohas been updated to use a named import. This is a standard practice in Go and should not affect functionality as long as theprotopackage is used consistently throughout the file.test/validator_threshold.go (3)
11-13: The import of
pcosignerhas been replaced withcipher. Ensure that all references to types and functions from thepcosignerpackage have been updated to use thecipherpackage where applicable.256-264: The function
getShardedPrivvalKeynow returns a slice ofcipher.CosignerEd25519Keyinstead ofpcosigner.CosignerEd25519Key. Verify that all calls to this function and subsequent usage of its return value have been updated to handle the new type correctly.Verification successful
The verification process has confirmed that the changes made to the
getShardedPrivvalKeyfunction intest/validator_threshold.goare consistent with the usage of its return values in the codebase. Theed25519ShardsandpvPubKeyvariables are handled correctly in the updated function calls, and the types are compatible with the rest of the code. No issues have been found based on the provided context.* 270-270: The `key` field in the `chainEd25519Shard` struct has been updated to use the `cipher.CosignerEd25519Key` type. Confirm that all instances where this struct is used have been updated to work with the new type.Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for usage of `getShardedPrivvalKey` and verify the handling of its return type. rg 'getShardedPrivvalKey' --files-with-matches | xargs -L1 ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'getShardedPrivvalKey($_, $_, $_, $_)'Length of output: 392
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Extract the relevant code snippets from `test/validator_threshold.go` and `test/horcrux_test.go` where `ed25519Shards` and `pvPubKey` are used. # For test/validator_threshold.go echo "Usage in test/validator_threshold.go:" rg --context 5 'ed25519Shards|pvPubKey' test/validator_threshold.go echo "Usage in test/horcrux_test.go:" # For test/horcrux_test.go rg --context 5 'ed25519Shards|pvPubKey' test/horcrux_test.goLength of output: 4634
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Extract the definitions of `writeConfigAndKeysThreshold`, `chainEd25519Shard`, and the declaration of the `pubKeys` array. # For test/validator_threshold.go echo "Definition of writeConfigAndKeysThreshold and chainEd25519Shard in test/validator_threshold.go:" rg --context 2 'func writeConfigAndKeysThreshold\(' test/validator_threshold.go rg --context 2 'type chainEd25519Shard struct' test/validator_threshold.go # For test/horcrux_test.go echo "Declaration of pubKeys array and definition of writeConfigAndKeysThreshold in test/horcrux_test.go:" rg --context 2 'pubKeys :=' test/horcrux_test.go rg --context 2 'func writeConfigAndKeysThreshold\(' test/horcrux_test.goLength of output: 1434
Verification successful
The
chainEd25519Shardstruct is correctly used with the updatedkeyfield of typecipher.CosignerEd25519Keyin bothtest/validator_threshold.goandtest/horcrux_test.go. All instances where this struct is used have been updated to work with the new type, as verified by the script output.Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for the `chainEd25519Shard` struct usage and verify the handling of the `key` field. rg 'chainEd25519Shard' --files-with-matches | xargs -L1 ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'chainEd25519Shard{ $$$ key: $_ $$$ }'Length of output: 123
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for the definition of the `chainEd25519Shard` struct to confirm its structure. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'type chainEd25519Shard struct { $$$ }' # Search for any usage of the `chainEd25519Shard` struct to see how it is being utilized. rg 'chainEd25519Shard' --files-with-matchesLength of output: 384
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Inspect the usage of the `chainEd25519Shard` struct in the identified files to ensure correct handling of the `key` field. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'chainEd25519Shard{ $$$ }' --file test/validator_threshold.go ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'chainEd25519Shard{ $$$ }' --file test/horcrux_test.goLength of output: 566
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Correctly inspect the usage of the `chainEd25519Shard` struct in the identified files to ensure correct handling of the `key` field. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'chainEd25519Shard{ $$$ }' test/validator_threshold.go ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'chainEd25519Shard{ $$$ }' test/horcrux_test.goLength of output: 501
|
|
||
| package proto; | ||
|
|
||
| // TODO: Change name to CosignerService? |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Consider resolving the TODO comment regarding the potential renaming of CosignerService to avoid future ambiguity and ensure clarity in the service's purpose.
| "sync" | ||
| "time" | ||
|
|
||
| "github.com/strangelove-ventures/horcrux/pkg/pcosigner" |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The comment above the MockLeader struct refers to it as a "helper" method, which is misleading since MockLeader is a struct, not a method. Consider revising the comment for clarity.
| // TODO: Potentially add generate? | ||
| /* | ||
|
|
||
| // TODO: This should be the job of ThresholdValidator | ||
| LoadSignStateIfNecessary(chainID string) error | ||
|
|
||
| // FIX: Below should not be the responsibility of the ISigner | ||
| // Its a temporary hack to get the peers and localCosign | ||
| GetPeers() []pcosigner.ICosigner // Returns the remote peers (for use in GRPC) | ||
| GetLocalCosign() pcosigner.ILocalCosigner // | ||
| */ | ||
| // sign(chainID string, threshold int, hrst types.HRSTKey, grpcTimeout time.Duration, stamp time.Time, timeStartSignBlock time.Time, signBytes []byte) ([]byte, time.Time, error) | ||
| // verify(chainID string, signBytes []byte, signature []byte) (bool, error) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Consider removing the TODO comments and commented-out code from the interface definition. If these are indicative of future work, they should be tracked in an issue tracker or a project management tool rather than in the codebase to keep the code clean and maintainable.
- // TODO: Potentially add generate?
- /*
- // TODO: This should be the job of ThresholdValidator
- LoadSignStateIfNecessary(chainID string) error
-
- // FIX: Below should not be the responsibility of the ISigner
- // Its a temporary hack to get the peers and localCosign
- GetPeers() []pcosigner.ICosigner // Returns the remote peers (for use in GRPC)
- GetLocalCosign() pcosigner.ILocalCosigner //
- */
- // sign(chainID string, threshold int, hrst types.HRSTKey, grpcTimeout time.Duration, stamp time.Time, timeStartSignBlock time.Time, signBytes []byte) ([]byte, time.Time, error)
- // verify(chainID string, signBytes []byte, signature []byte) (bool, error)Committable suggestion
❗ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation.
| // TODO: Potentially add generate? | |
| /* | |
| // TODO: This should be the job of ThresholdValidator | |
| LoadSignStateIfNecessary(chainID string) error | |
| // FIX: Below should not be the responsibility of the ISigner | |
| // Its a temporary hack to get the peers and localCosign | |
| GetPeers() []pcosigner.ICosigner // Returns the remote peers (for use in GRPC) | |
| GetLocalCosign() pcosigner.ILocalCosigner // | |
| */ | |
| // sign(chainID string, threshold int, hrst types.HRSTKey, grpcTimeout time.Duration, stamp time.Time, timeStartSignBlock time.Time, signBytes []byte) ([]byte, time.Time, error) | |
| // verify(chainID string, signBytes []byte, signature []byte) (bool, error) |
| GetLocalCosign() pcosigner.ILocalCosigner | ||
| GetPeers() []pcosigner.IRemoteCosigner | ||
| // TODO: Potentially add generate? | ||
| /* | ||
|
|
||
| // TODO: This should be the job of ThresholdValidator | ||
| LoadSignStateIfNecessary(chainID string) error | ||
|
|
||
| // FIX: Below should not be the responsibility of the ISigner | ||
| // Its a temporary hack to get the peers and localCosign | ||
| GetPeers() []pcosigner.ICosigner // Returns the remote peers (for use in GRPC) | ||
| GetLocalCosign() pcosigner.ILocalCosigner // |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The methods GetPeers and GetLocalCosign are defined twice in the ISigner interface. This duplication should be resolved to avoid confusion and potential implementation issues.
- GetPeers() []pcosigner.IRemoteCosigner
- GetLocalCosign() pcosigner.ILocalCosignerCommittable suggestion
❗ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation.
| GetLocalCosign() pcosigner.ILocalCosigner | |
| GetPeers() []pcosigner.IRemoteCosigner | |
| // TODO: Potentially add generate? | |
| /* | |
| // TODO: This should be the job of ThresholdValidator | |
| LoadSignStateIfNecessary(chainID string) error | |
| // FIX: Below should not be the responsibility of the ISigner | |
| // Its a temporary hack to get the peers and localCosign | |
| GetPeers() []pcosigner.ICosigner // Returns the remote peers (for use in GRPC) | |
| GetLocalCosign() pcosigner.ILocalCosigner // | |
| GetLocalCosign() pcosigner.ILocalCosigner | |
| // TODO: Potentially add generate? | |
| /* | |
| // TODO: This should be the job of ThresholdValidator | |
| LoadSignStateIfNecessary(chainID string) error | |
| // FIX: Below should not be the responsibility of the ISigner | |
| // Its a temporary hack to get the peers and localCosign | |
| GetPeers() []pcosigner.ICosigner // Returns the remote peers (for use in GRPC) | |
| GetLocalCosign() pcosigner.ILocalCosigner // |
| _ = f.thresholdValidator.SaveLastSignedState(lss.ChainID, lss.SignStateConsensus) | ||
| _ = f.thresholdValidator.myCosigner.SaveLastSignedState(lss.ChainID, lss.SignStateConsensus) | ||
| if err != nil { | ||
| f.logger.Error("[error] - thresholdValidator.SaveLastSignedState %v", err) | ||
| // Our ephemeral secret parts are required, cannot proceed | ||
| } | ||
| _ = f.thresholdValidator.thresholdalgorithm.SaveLastSignedState(lss.ChainID, lss.SignStateConsensus) | ||
| if err != nil { | ||
| f.logger.Error("[error] - thresholdalgorithm.SaveLastSignedState %v", err) | ||
| // Our ephemeral secret parts are required, cannot proceed | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The error from SaveLastSignedState is not being captured or handled, which could lead to silent failures. It's important to check and handle this error.
- _ = f.thresholdValidator.SaveLastSignedState(lss.ChainID, lss.SignStateConsensus)
+ if err := f.thresholdValidator.SaveLastSignedState(lss.ChainID, lss.SignStateConsensus); err != nil {
+ f.logger.Error("[error] - thresholdValidator.SaveLastSignedState", "error", err)
+ return
+ }
- _ = f.thresholdValidator.thresholdalgorithm.SaveLastSignedState(lss.ChainID, lss.SignStateConsensus)
+ if err := f.thresholdValidator.thresholdalgorithm.SaveLastSignedState(lss.ChainID, lss.SignStateConsensus); err != nil {
+ f.logger.Error("[error] - thresholdalgorithm.SaveLastSignedState", "error", err)
+ return
+ }Committable suggestion
❗ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation.
| _ = f.thresholdValidator.SaveLastSignedState(lss.ChainID, lss.SignStateConsensus) | |
| _ = f.thresholdValidator.myCosigner.SaveLastSignedState(lss.ChainID, lss.SignStateConsensus) | |
| if err != nil { | |
| f.logger.Error("[error] - thresholdValidator.SaveLastSignedState %v", err) | |
| // Our ephemeral secret parts are required, cannot proceed | |
| } | |
| _ = f.thresholdValidator.thresholdalgorithm.SaveLastSignedState(lss.ChainID, lss.SignStateConsensus) | |
| if err != nil { | |
| f.logger.Error("[error] - thresholdalgorithm.SaveLastSignedState %v", err) | |
| // Our ephemeral secret parts are required, cannot proceed | |
| } | |
| if err := f.thresholdValidator.SaveLastSignedState(lss.ChainID, lss.SignStateConsensus); err != nil { | |
| f.logger.Error("[error] - thresholdValidator.SaveLastSignedState", "error", err) | |
| return | |
| } | |
| if err != nil { | |
| f.logger.Error("[error] - thresholdValidator.SaveLastSignedState %v", err) | |
| // Our ephemeral secret parts are required, cannot proceed | |
| } | |
| if err := f.thresholdValidator.thresholdalgorithm.SaveLastSignedState(lss.ChainID, lss.SignStateConsensus); err != nil { | |
| f.logger.Error("[error] - thresholdalgorithm.SaveLastSignedState", "error", err) | |
| return | |
| } | |
| if err != nil { | |
| f.logger.Error("[error] - thresholdalgorithm.SaveLastSignedState %v", err) | |
| // Our ephemeral secret parts are required, cannot proceed | |
| } |
| @@ -292,9 +305,12 @@ | |||
|
|
|||
| func (s *RaftStore) GetLeader() raft.ServerAddress { | |||
| if s == nil || s.raft == nil { | |||
| fmt.Printf("s is nil %v, or s.raft is nil %v", s, s.raft) | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Debugging statements should be replaced with structured logging.
- fmt.Printf("s is nil %v, or s.raft is nil %v", s, s.raft)
+ s.logger.Error("GetLeader failed", "raftStore", s, "raft", s.raft)Committable suggestion
❗ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation.
| fmt.Printf("s is nil %v, or s.raft is nil %v", s, s.raft) | |
| s.logger.Error("GetLeader failed", "raftStore", s, "raft", s.raft) |
| return "" | ||
| } | ||
| return s.raft.Leader() | ||
| add, id := s.raft.LeaderWithID() | ||
| fmt.Printf("\naddress is: \n\t%s\nid is:\n\t%s\n", add, id) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Remove or replace debugging statements with structured logging.
- fmt.Printf("\naddress is: \n\t%s\nid is:\n\t%s\n", add, id)
+ s.logger.Debug("Leader information", "address", add, "id", id)Committable suggestion
❗ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation.
| fmt.Printf("\naddress is: \n\t%s\nid is:\n\t%s\n", add, id) | |
| s.logger.Debug("Leader information", "address", add, "id", id) |
| var _ proto.ICosignerGRPCServer = &GRPCServer{} | ||
| var _ proto.IRaftGRPCServer = &GRPCServer{} |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The assertions to ensure that GRPCServer implements proto.ICosignerGRPCServer and proto.IRaftGRPCServer interfaces are outdated and should be updated to reflect the new CosignGRPCServer and RaftGRPCServer types.
- var _ proto.ICosignerGRPCServer = &GRPCServer{}
- var _ proto.IRaftGRPCServer = &GRPCServer{}
+ var _ proto.ICosignerGRPCServer = &CosignGRPCServer{}
+ var _ proto.IRaftGRPCServer = &RaftGRPCServer{}Committable suggestion
❗ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation.
| var _ proto.ICosignerGRPCServer = &GRPCServer{} | |
| var _ proto.IRaftGRPCServer = &GRPCServer{} | |
| var _ proto.ICosignerGRPCServer = &CosignGRPCServer{} | |
| var _ proto.IRaftGRPCServer = &RaftGRPCServer{} |
| // err := cosignerRaftStore.OnStart() | ||
| // if err != nil { | ||
| // fmt.Printf("cosignerRaftStore.onStart: %v", err) | ||
| // panic(err) | ||
| // } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Commented-out code should be removed if it's not intended for future use or documentation.
- // err := cosignerRaftStore.OnStart()
- // if err != nil {
- // fmt.Printf("cosignerRaftStore.onStart: %v", err)
- // panic(err)
- // }Committable suggestion
❗ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation.
| // err := cosignerRaftStore.OnStart() | |
| // if err != nil { | |
| // fmt.Printf("cosignerRaftStore.onStart: %v", err) | |
| // panic(err) | |
| // } |
| id int, | ||
| noncePub []byte, | ||
| nonceShare []byte, | ||
| ) (CosignerNonce, error) | ||
| ) (CosignNonce, error) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 NOTE
Codebase verification is a beta feature.
Based on the script results, it appears that there are no remaining method definitions with the old return type CosignerNonce in the codebase. The only usage of the EncryptAndSign method with the old return type was found in pkg/pcosigner/local_cosigner.go, and it should be updated to handle the new return type CosignNonce correctly.
- Update the usage of
EncryptAndSigninpkg/pcosigner/local_cosigner.goto handle the new return typeCosignNonce.
Analysis chain
The return type of the EncryptAndSign method in the ICosignerSecurity interface has been changed from CosignerNonce to CosignNonce. Ensure that all implementations of this interface and any code that uses this method are updated to handle the new return type correctly.
I will now create two separate ast-grep scripts: one to find the struct definitions that might implement the ICosignerSecurity interface and another to find the EncryptAndSign method implementations. Additionally, I will refine the search for usages of the EncryptAndSign method to ensure that all instances are found.
I will now create a refined ast-grep script to specifically look for structs that have a method named EncryptAndSign with the old return type CosignerNonce. Additionally, I will refine the search for usages of the EncryptAndSign method to ensure that all instances are found.
I will now create a refined ast-grep script to specifically look for any method definitions named EncryptAndSign with the old return type CosignerNonce, without trying to associate them with struct definitions. Additionally, I will refine the search for usages of the EncryptAndSign method to ensure that all instances are found.
Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Search for implementations of ICosignerSecurity interface to update the EncryptAndSign method.
ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'type $_ struct {
$$$
}
func ($_ $_) EncryptAndSign($_, $_, $_) (CosignerNonce, error) {
$$$
}'
# Search for usage of EncryptAndSign method to ensure correct handling of the new return type.
ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'$_.$_.EncryptAndSign($_, $_, $_)'
Length of output: 868
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Search for struct definitions that might implement the ICosignerSecurity interface
ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'type $_ struct {
$$$
}'
# Search for method definitions of EncryptAndSign that return CosignerNonce
ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'func ($_ $_) EncryptAndSign($_, $_, $_) (CosignerNonce, error) {
$$$
}'
# Refine the search for usages of the EncryptAndSign method to ensure all instances are found
ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'$_.$_.EncryptAndSign($_, $_, $_)'
Length of output: 38527
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Refine the search for struct definitions that might implement the ICosignerSecurity interface with the EncryptAndSign method
ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'type $_ struct {
$$$
func ($_ $_) EncryptAndSign($_, $_, $_) (CosignerNonce, error) {
$$$
}
}'
# Refine the search for usages of the EncryptAndSign method to ensure all instances are found
ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'$_.$_.EncryptAndSign($_, $_, $_)'
Length of output: 880
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Search for any method definitions named EncryptAndSign with the old return type CosignerNonce
ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'func ($_ $_) EncryptAndSign($_, $_, $_) (CosignerNonce, error) {
$$$
}'
# Refine the search for usages of the EncryptAndSign method to ensure all instances are found
ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'$_.$_.EncryptAndSign($_, $_, $_)'
Length of output: 323
Step 2 of the refactoring.
Summary by CodeRabbit
Refactor
New Features
Bug Fixes
Documentation
Style