feat: pixi diff

[benmoss]

I love @pavelzw 's https://github.com/pavelzw/pixi-diff-to-markdown/ tool but the problem is that you can only get these diffs from pixi update --json right now.

This is a POC to introduce a new pixi diff command that will diff the current pixi.toml & pixi.lock to a different pixi.lock to generate the same diff.

[benmoss]

Example:

pixi diff --old-lockfile <(git show HEAD~100:pixi.lock) | pixi-diff-to-markdown

---

Explicit dependencies

Dependency1	Before	After	Change	Environments
filelock		3.16.0	Added	{default, schema} on all platforms
pytest-rerunfailures		14.0	Added	{default, schema} on all platforms
rich		13.7.1	Added	{default, schema} on all platforms
tomli-w		1.0.0	Added	{default, schema} on all platforms
rust	1.80.1	1.81.0	Minor Upgrade	default on all platforms
taplo	h823019e_0	ha073cba_1	Only build string	lint on win-64

Implicit dependencies

Dependency1	Before	After	Change	Environments
markdown-it-py		3.0.0	Added	{default, schema} on all platforms
mdurl		0.1.2	Added	{default, schema} on all platforms
pygments		2.18.0	Added	{default, schema} on all platforms
filelock	3.15.4	3.16.0	Minor Upgrade	lint on all platforms
rust-std-aarch64-apple-darwin	1.80.1	1.81.0	Minor Upgrade	default on osx-arm64
rust-std-x86_64-apple-darwin	1.80.1	1.81.0	Minor Upgrade	default on osx-64
rust-std-x86_64-pc-windows-msvc	1.80.1	1.81.0	Minor Upgrade	default on win-64
rust-std-x86_64-unknown-linux-gnu	1.80.1	1.81.0	Minor Upgrade	default on linux-64

Footnotes

1. Bold means explicit dependency. ↩ ↩²

[ruben-arts]

Hey @benmoss, Thanks for the idea. I would like to discuss the cli command a little more. Especially the location. I believe there are more requests around some interaction with the lockfile. There is also the request for a pixi lock maybe diff could be a subcommand of that. or do you see a different future for this command? e.g. pixi diff --old-manifest etc.

[pavelzw]

There is also the request for a pixi lock

what should pixi lock do?

As mentioned in https://discord.com/channels/1082332781146800168/1298438329788010556/1298935042680029226, i think we are all on the same page that we should split this into a separate executable pixi-diff that you could call using pixi exec pixi-diff

[ruben-arts]

what should pixi lock do?

My braindump
We could introduce some more introspection to that command but also the actual ability to lock on request. Where you would now need to do a pixi list --no-install or some other hacks.

• pixi lock generates the lock-file and only installs the minimal requirements for that. e.g. the conda environment to solve pypi.
• pixi lock diff would do what this pr does
• pixi lock --platform linux-64 would lock only a single platform, which I would find useful when I'm testing some complex setups. And would allow me to test in CLI which platforms would work with this project without modifying the manifest.
• pixi lock --environment cuda12.1 test locking for a single env, same as platform.
• pixi lock export could be a way to do the pixi project export but a little more clearly that the lock is being exported and not the "project".

I don't think it's going to deliver a lot more features but just a more ergonomic interaction.

What do you think?

ps. this is not the right location to discuss but putting it here as there isn't a issue or discussion yet and not sure it's going to be useful yet.

[ruben-arts]

Closing this for now as stale, idea is great we need to think on it some more

[pavelzw]

Maybe I'll find some time during the holidays 😁

[pavelzw]

i'm currently working on this, should have a separate tool very soon available

[pavelzw]

for people subscribed to this: i created https://github.com/pavelzw/pixi-diff which solves this issue