Add nom.tr #832
Add nom.tr #832
Conversation
|
It looks like there are .nom.tr domains since 1998 https://nic.tr/index.php?USRACTN=STATICHTML&PAGE=about_history Google search results https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3A.nom.tr |
|
For Registry-reserved domains, we only accept PRs from the Registry / that can be established via Registry-provided information. As such, I attempted to verify this request by going through https://www.iana.org/domains/root/db/tr.html to http://www.nic.tr and attempting to find a registry-policy reserving these domains. As best I can tell, https://www.nic.tr/forms/eng/policies.pdf is the registry policy, dated Version 5.1.0, and does not reserve .nom.tr. As such, closing this as WONTFIX. |
|
@sleevi have you read https://nic.tr/index.php?USRACTN=STATICHTML&PAGE=about_history ?
|
|
@weppos @sleevi these example domains have different owners according to whois data: erkan.nom.tr koc.nom.tr You can use this whois or your own whois https://nic.tr/index.php?USRACTN=DOMAINSRCH |
|
Differing WHOIS information is not in and of itself sufficient. Thanks for providing that link to the history, but I can't find any supporting data in the policies. It appears to be describing historic registration policies, not current. Indeed, this change conflicts with that documentation. Even under their FAQ, Do you happen to have a contact at the registry you could point to this issue? |
|
@sleevi unfortunatly https://www.nic.tr/forms/eng/policies.pdf is outdated. For example that document doesn't have .kep.tr and tsk.tr but these are 2 are on the list. nc.tr and gov.nc.tr are not on that document too. May be we should remove kep.tr, tsk.tr, nc.tr and gov.nc.tr.? |
|
It is okay to add nonsense domains but it is a problem for nom.tr https://github.com/publicsuffix/list/blob/master/public_suffix_list.dat#L12344 okay |
|
@sleevi there are currently registered 51 nom.tr domains https://nic.tr/index.php?USRACTN=STATISTICS for yesterday 30/06/2019. And the source is nic.tr. |
Probably because they no longer sell .nom.tr domains but retain existing .nom.tr customers. |
|
We do not add domains without the domain holder requesting or with clear documentation of registry policies. Domains which have been validated using such policies remain, until we have evidence otherwise. As such, absent that, we will not be adding |
|
@sleevi you can validate by calling +903129880060 https://nic.tr/index.php?USRACTN=CNTINFO |
There are 51 .nom.tr domains https://nic.tr/index.php?USRACTN=STATISTICS