feat(exercise): Support exercise.pipe option (#804)

NEWS.md

@@ -8,6 +8,8 @@
 
 -   Added a new quick restore option that restores both the last submitted exercise code and the output of that submission, if the output is available to be restored. This option is enabled by setting the global option `tutorial.quick_restore = 2` or the environment variable `TUTORIAL_QUICK_RESTORE=2`. This option augments the quick restore value when `TRUE` or `1`, wherein only the last submitted **code** is restored, such that users will need to click the "Submit" button to evaluate and see the output. (#794)
 
+-   A new `exercise.pipe` tutorial or exercise chunk option can now be used to determine which pipe operator is used for interactive exercises. The default is `"|>"` (the native R pipe) when the tutorial is rendered with R >= 4.1.0, or `"%>%"` otherwise (the magrittr pipe). You can set the pipe used for the tutorial using `tutorial_options()`, or you can use `exercise.pipe` as a knitr chunk option on an individual exercise chunk. (#804)
+
 # learnr 0.11.4
 
 -   Moved curl from Imports to Suggests. curl is only required when using an external evaluator (#776).

R/knitr-hooks.R

@@ -374,12 +374,16 @@ tutorial_knitr_options <- function() {
         completion  <- as.numeric(options$exercise.completion %||% 1 > 0)
         diagnostics <- as.numeric(options$exercise.diagnostics %||% 1 > 0)
         startover <- as.numeric(options$exercise.startover %||% 1 > 0)
-        paste0('<div class="tutorial-', class,
-               '" data-label="', options$label,
-               '" data-completion="', completion,
-               '" data-diagnostics="', diagnostics,
-               '" data-startover="', startover,
-               '" data-lines="', lines, '">')
+        paste0(
+          '<div class="tutorial-', class,
+          '" data-label="', options$label,
+          '" data-completion="', completion,
+          '" data-diagnostics="', diagnostics,
+          '" data-startover="', startover,
+          '" data-lines="', lines,
+          '" data-pipe="', htmltools::htmlEscape(exercise_option_pipe(options)),
+          '">'
+        )
       }
       # after exercise
       else {
@@ -575,3 +579,11 @@ verify_tutorial_chunk_label <- function() {
     )
   }
 }
+
+exercise_option_pipe <- function(options = knitr::opts_chunk$get()) {
+  if (!is.null(options[["exercise.pipe"]])) {
+    return(options[["exercise.pipe"]])
+  }
+
+  if (getRversion() < "4.1.0") "%>%" else "|>"
+}

R/options.R

@@ -16,6 +16,12 @@
 #'   (defaults to \code{30}).
 #' @param exercise.lines Lines of code for exercise editor (defaults to the
 #'   number of lines in the code chunk).
+#' @param exercise.pipe The characters to enter when the user presses the
+#'   "Insert Pipe" keyboard shortcut in the exercise editor
+#'   (`Ctrl/Cmd + Shift + M`). This can be set at the tutorial level or for an
+#'   individual exercise. If `NULL` (default), the base R pipe (`|>`) is used
+#'   when the tutorial is rendered in R >= 4.1.0, otherwise the \pkg{magrittr}
+#'   pipe (`%>%`) is used.
 #' @param exercise.blanks A regular expression to be used to identify blanks in
 #'   submitted code that the user should fill in. If `TRUE` (default), blanks
 #'   are three or more underscores in a row. If `FALSE`, blank checking is not
@@ -37,6 +43,7 @@ tutorial_options <- function(exercise.cap = NULL,
                              exercise.eval = FALSE,
                              exercise.timelimit = 30,
                              exercise.lines = NULL,
+                             exercise.pipe = NULL,
                              exercise.blanks = NULL,
                              exercise.checker = NULL,
                              exercise.error.check.code = NULL,
@@ -53,6 +60,7 @@ tutorial_options <- function(exercise.cap = NULL,
   eval(parse(text = sprintf(set_option_code, "exercise.eval")))
   eval(parse(text = sprintf(set_option_code, "exercise.timelimit")))
   eval(parse(text = sprintf(set_option_code, "exercise.lines")))
+  eval(parse(text = sprintf(set_option_code, "exercise.pipe")))
   eval(parse(text = sprintf(set_option_code, "exercise.blanks")))
   eval(parse(text = sprintf(set_option_code, "exercise.checker")))
   eval(parse(text = sprintf(set_option_code, "exercise.error.check.code")))

learnr-js/tutorial/tutorial.js

@@ -1087,7 +1087,9 @@ Tutorial.prototype.$initializeExerciseEditors = function () {
         }
       })
     }
-    bindInsertKey('insertPipe', 'Ctrl+Shift+M', { r: ' %>% ' })
+
+    const pipeCode = exercise.attr('data-pipe') || '%>%'
+    bindInsertKey('insertPipe', 'Ctrl+Shift+M', { r: ' ' + pipeCode })
     bindInsertKey('insertArrow', 'Alt+-', { r: ' <- ', fallback: ' = ' })
 
     // re-focus the editor on run button click

tests/manual/pipe-option/pipe-option.Rmd

@@ -0,0 +1,56 @@
+---
+title: "Exercise Pipe Option"
+output: learnr::tutorial
+runtime: shiny_prerendered
+---
+
+```{r setup, include=FALSE}
+library(learnr)
+library(dplyr)
+knitr::opts_chunk$set(echo = FALSE)
+```
+
+
+## Ceci n'est pas une pipe
+
+Qu'est-ce qu'une pipe, sinon l'idée d'une pipe?
+
+You can set the characters used for the pipe shortcut at the tutorial level with
+
+```r
+knitr::opts_chunk$set(exercise.pipe = "%>%")
+```
+
+Or you can set the pipe option at the individual level using the `exercise.pipe` chunk option.
+
+````{verbatim echo = TRUE}
+```{r base-pipe, exercise=TRUE, exercise.pipe="|>"}
+mtcars count(cyl)
+```
+````
+
+By default, if not set otherwise set, learnr will use the base R pipe (`|>`) when the tutorial is rendered in R >= 4.1.0.
+
+### Old school
+
+In this next chunk, pressing `Ctrl/Cmd + Shift + M` enters the magrittr pipe: `%>%`.
+
+```{r magrittr, exercise=TRUE, exercise.pipe="%>%"}
+mtcars count(cyl)
+```
+
+### New school
+
+In this next chunk, pressing `Ctrl/Cmd + Shift + M` enters the base R pipe: `|>`.
+
+```{r pipe, exercise=TRUE, exercise.pipe="|>"}
+mtcars count(cyl)
+```
+
+### Night school
+
+In this next chunk, pressing `Ctrl/Cmd + Shift + M` enters the pipe that matches your R version. It's the base R pipe for R >= 4.1.
+
+```{r auto, exercise=TRUE}
+mtcars count(cyl)
+```

vignettes/articles/exercises.Rmd

@@ -22,6 +22,8 @@ There are many options associated with tutorial exercises (all of which are desc
 +-----------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
 | `exercise.lines`            | Lines of code for exercise editor (default to size of code chunk).                                                                  |
 +-----------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
+| `exercise.pipe`             | The code to insert when the user presses `Ctrl/Cmd + Shift + M` (defaults to `|>` for R >= 4.1.0, otherwise `%>%`).                 |
++-----------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
 | `exercise.timelimit`        | Number of seconds to limit execution time to (defaults to 30).                                                                      |
 +-----------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
 | `exercise.checker`          | Function used to check exercise answers (e.g., `gradethis::grade_learnr()`).                                                        |