Edit request for the source localization tutorial

[deepagupta]

Hello,

Please note my comments below:

Suggestions for implementation:

1.    Please consider adding somewhere that Fieldtrip-lite extension must be installed. If not, go to File-> manage EEGLAB extensions and install Fieldtrip-lite.
2.    Please note that while executing the code for figure “5:ft_sourceplot: sourceProj”, I get the following error message:

could not reshape "time" to the dimensions of the volume
Warning: functional data is complex, taking absolute value
Check for incorrect argument data type or missing argument in call to function 'abs'.

Error in ft_sourceplot (line 455)
 fun = abs(fun);

Error in dipfit_example_tutorialtest20230823 (line 89)
figure; ft_sourceplot(cfg, sourceProj);

3.    Please note that while executing the code for the section:
%% Prepare leadfield surface
In the section ‘Performing source reconstruction:’
I get the warning:

Warning: adding C:\Users\d2gupta\Documents\eeglab2022.1\plugins\Fieldtrip-lite20230613\external\gifti toolbox to your MATLAB path
Warning: use cfg.sourcemodel instead of cfg.grid

Cosmetic changes’ suggestions to descriptive for clarity to the reader:

1.    Please consider changing the heading from "Equivalent dipole source localization of EEG data" to "Equivalent dipole source localization of EEG or ERP data"
2.    Positive affirmation first: Please consider changing first line to "EEGLAB provides a command-line implementation of the DIPFIT plugin to fit dipoles to raw ERP or EEG scalp maps that has otherwise not been expressly designed anywhere else including the plugin itself" from "Though the implementation of the DIPFIT plugin has not been expressly designed to fit dipoles to raw ERP or EEG scalp maps, EEGLAB provides a command-line function allowing DIPFIT to do so. "
3.    For giving the beginner an idea about what is DIPFIT as a starter, please consider hyperlinking DIPFIT plugin in the first line to: https://github.com/sccn/dipfit AND https://sccn.ucsd.edu/eeglab/dipfittut/dipfit.htmlold AND https://eeglab.org/tutorials/09_source/DIPFIT.html
4.    Please correct this: The “here” in “Click here to download the script above” is leading to an error message “Notice: Undefined variable: baseurl2 in /var/local/www/html/eeglab/locatefile.php on line 80
File not found”.
5.    Please include the eeglab_data_epochs_ica.set file or the instructions for how to fetch this sample dataset.
6.    In the section “Advanced source reconstruction using DIPFIT/Fieldtrip”:
a.    please make a subsection “History” or “Background” and then in that include the first paragrpah “DIPFIT relies on Fieldtrip, though in fact, DIPFIT was also an ancestor of Fieldtrip: when Robert Oostenveld, the first Fieldtrip developer, decided to release source imaging functions he had developed during his dissertation work, he first packaged them in EEGLAB as DIPFIT. A few years later, when he and his collaborators released Fieldtrip (also running on MATLAB), we reworked DIPFIT so it would use the Fieldtrip functions that Robert and colleagues planned to and have since maintained for use in Fieldtrip. Below is a short tutorial on how to perform source modeling using Fieldtrip applied to data in an EEGLAB dataset.”
b.    Also, one may consider hyperlinking here DIPFIT to the earlier links as highlighted in the above point#3 in this first paragraph of history.
c.    Subsection “Implementation” or “Performing source reconstruction in a volume” could include text from “First, use DIPFIT to align the electrode locations with a head model of choice (menu item Tools → Locate dipoles using DIPFIT → Head model and settings). The resulting DIPFIT information … and so on”
7.    Please correct this: script download link in the section ‘Performing source reconstruction on a surface’ is giving the error: “Notice: Undefined variable: baseurl2 in /var/local/www/html/eeglab/locatefile.php on line 80
File not found”
8.    Please consider perhaps specifying the following tutorial additionally in the relevant section: https://eeglab.org/tutorials/09_source/Model_Settings.html and https://eeglab.org/tutorials/09_source/Custom_head_model.html

I hope the above is helpful
Thanking you
Sincerely
Deepa Gupta

[arnodelorme]

Hi Deepa, this is the EEGLAB code. For the tutorial please change this repo https://github.com/sccn/sccn.github.io

[deepagupta]

Dear Arnaud, Thank you for your kind guidance. I have corrected it now. Please let me know if this is better now: sccn/sccn.github.io#88 Truly hope that's better now, Thanking you, Sincerely Deepa Gupta <https://www.linkedin.com/in/deepaguptaresearcher/> Postdoc Scholar, SCCN <https://sccn.ucsd.edu/>, SDSC <https://www.sdsc.edu/> , INC <https://inc.ucsd.edu/index.php>, UCSD <https://ucsd.edu/> Ph.D. , Dr. Choa's Lab <https://blogs.cs.umbc.edu/choalab/>, CSEE <https://www.csee.umbc.edu/>, UMBC <https://www.umbc.edu/>

…

On Wed, Jun 28, 2023 at 10:53 PM Arnaud Delorme ***@***.***> wrote: Closed #643 <#643>. — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#643 (comment)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAFPLK3U35RQZL5WCQ4KLOTXNUJ6BANCNFSM6AAAAAAZXVOOLY> . You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: ***@***.***>