Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

HLD for aggregate VOQ counters. #1587

Open
wants to merge 35 commits into
base: master
Choose a base branch
from
Open
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from 29 commits
Commits
Show all changes
35 commits
Select commit Hold shift + click to select a range
e0f1129
Added HLD for aggregate VOQ counters
vivekverma-arista Jan 12, 2024
9621b03
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Feb 13, 2024
f4d03c5
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Feb 20, 2024
b8ed520
Merge branch 'sonic-net:master' into aggVoq
vivekverma-arista May 16, 2024
f408549
Delete doc/voq/images/add_voq_seq.png
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
82b925c
Add files via upload
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
6e744b3
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
a194c67
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
bebc9f0
Delete doc/voq/images/add_voq_seq.png
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
1c52f4b
Add files via upload
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
7d38058
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
cbc0322
Add files via upload
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
70664c3
Delete doc/voq/images/add_voq_seq.png
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
8010286
Add files via upload
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
874e2d3
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
889ebc3
Delete doc/voq/images/add_voq_cli.png
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
3910da2
Add files via upload
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
8ed1774
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
8854b6c
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md with the latest approach.
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
5b3592a
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
4353040
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
c5bcbd3
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
cfef7d2
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Aug 23, 2024
b55725b
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Aug 28, 2024
84081cf
Delete doc/voq/images/voq_stats_seq.png
vivekverma-arista Aug 28, 2024
b668edb
Add files via upload
vivekverma-arista Aug 28, 2024
4b27b4f
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Aug 28, 2024
079f037
Delete add_voq_seq.png
vivekverma-arista Aug 28, 2024
cccd69d
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Sep 11, 2024
8918480
Made correction in counter attributes.
vivekverma-arista Sep 12, 2024
a2f2367
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Sep 24, 2024
da9f789
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Sep 24, 2024
82ae143
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Sep 24, 2024
2b47d1b
Update aggregate_voq_counters.md
vivekverma-arista Sep 24, 2024
2bdb431
Merge branch 'sonic-net:master' into aggVoq
vivekverma-arista Nov 11, 2024
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
128 changes: 128 additions & 0 deletions doc/voq/aggregate_voq_counters.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,128 @@



# Aggregate VOQ Counters in SONiC #
#### Rev 1.0

## Table of Content
* [Revision](#revision)
* [Overview](#overview)
* [Requirements](#requirements)
* [Architecture Design](#architecture-design)
* [High-Level Design](#high-level-design)
* [Database changes](#database-changes)
* [SWSS Changes](#swss-changes)
* [Telemetry Changes](#gnmi-changes)
* [Repositories that need to be changed](#repositories-that-need-to-be-changed)
* [SAI API](#sai-api)
* [Configuration and management](#configuration-and-management)
* [CLI](#cli)
* [Testing Requirements/Design](#testing-requirementsdesign)
* [System Test cases](#system-test-cases)

### Revision
| Rev | Date | Author | Change Description |
|:---:|:-----------:|:----------------------------------------------------------------------------------:|-----------------------------------|
| 1.0 | 11-Jan-2024 | Harsis Yadav, Pandurangan R S, Vivek Kumar Verma (Arista Networks) | Initial public version |

### Overview

In a [distributed VOQ architecture](https://github.com/sonic-net/SONiC/blob/master/doc/voq/architecture.md) corresponding to each output VOQ present on an ASIC, there are VOQs present on every ASIC in the system. Each ASIC has its own set of VOQ stats maintained in the linecard that needs to be gathered independently and can be hard to visualize, providing a non-cohesive experience.

### Requirements

Provide aggregate VOQ counters in a distributed VOQ architecture.

### Architecture Design

No new architecture changes are required to SONiC.

A new database `CHASSIS_COUNTERS_DB` will be introduced in `redis_chassis` instance of the supervisor dedicated to aggregate statistics.

Voq stats on linecard are already polled via flex counter for each asic by it's corresponding syncd instance and updated in COUNTER_DB. Swss will be used to synchronise VOQ stats between linecard and supervisor.

### High-Level Design

Figure 1: Gathering the VOQ stats in CHASSIS_COUNTERS_DB
![Sequence Diagram](images/voq_seq_diagram.png "Figure 1: Sequence Diagram")
Figure 2: Aggregation of VOQ stats
![Aggregation of VOQ Stats](images/voq_cli.png "Figure 2: Aggregation of VOQ Stats")


#### Database Changes
A new database called CHASSIS_COUNTERS_DB will be introduced on the redis_chassis instance of supervisor.

```
"CHASSIS_COUNTERS_DB" : {
"id": 21,
"separator": ":",
"instance": "redis_chassis"
}
```

The VOQ stats will be updated in a new table `COUNTERS_VOQ`

The following new VOQ counters should be available for each VOQ entry in the DB:
* `COUNTERS_VOQ : LINECARD | ASIC | EthernetXXX @ LINECARD | ASIC : VOQ_index`
* `SAI_VOQ_STAT_PACKETS`

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

AFAIK, only the following SAI attributes are supported to read the counters for both egress queue and voq. Only the queue id is different for egress queue and voq.
in orchagent:
static const vector<sai_queue_stat_t> queue_stat_ids =
{
SAI_QUEUE_STAT_PACKETS,
SAI_QUEUE_STAT_BYTES,
SAI_QUEUE_STAT_DROPPED_PACKETS,
SAI_QUEUE_STAT_DROPPED_BYTES,
};
static const vector<sai_queue_stat_t> voq_stat_ids =
{
SAI_QUEUE_STAT_CREDIT_WD_DELETED_PACKETS
};
SAI
https://github.com/opencomputeproject/SAI/blob/be523777da96504758d3bb6b3696ae7d1129419d/inc/saiqueue.h#L280
Where are these attributes coming from?

Copy link
Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Correction made.

* `SAI_VOQ_STAT_BYTES`
* `SAI_VOQ_STAT_DROPPED_PACKETS`
* `SAI_VOQ_STAT_DROPPED_BYTES`
* `SAI_QUEUE_STAT_CREDIT_WD_DELETED_PACKETS`

* `COUNTERS_VOQ` is the table name.
* The first part of the key ( before `@` ) `LINECARD | ASIC | EthernetXXX` denotes the physical location of the interface ( or full system port name )
* The second part of the key ( after `@` ) `LINECARD | ASIC` denotes the location of the VOQ.
* VOQ_index is the index of the VOQ in question.

#### SWSS Changes
##### New VoqStatsOrch module
A new module called VoqStatsOrch will be introduced which will be initialised by orchdaemon.

VoqStatsOrch will synchronise the VOQ counters between each ASIC's COUNTERS_DB on linecards and CHASSIS_COUNTERS_DB running on the supervisor.

#### gNMI changes
New virtual paths will be introduced to retrieve VOQ counters from linecard and aggregated VOQ counter stats from supervisor

| DB target| Virtual Path | Supported On? | Description|
| ---- |:----:| :-:| ----|
|COUNTERS_DB | "COUNTERS/``<asic id>``/``<system port>``/Voq"| Linecard | All VOQ counters for a sytem port on an ASIC on linecard
|COUNTERS_DB | "COUNTERS/``<asic id>``/``*``/Voq"| Linecard | All VOQ counters for all sytem ports on an ASIC on linecard
|COUNTERS_DB | "COUNTERS/``<system port>``/Voq"| Supervisor | Aggregated VOQ counters for a system port from supervisor
|COUNTERS_DB | "COUNTERS/``*``/Voq"| Supervisor | Aggregated VOQ counters for all system ports from supervisor

Note: For the sake of uniformity the virtual path for supervisor says target as `COUNTERS_DB` and table as `COUNTERS` but it will be internally mapped to `CHASSIS_COUNTERS_DB` and `COUNTERS_VOQ`.

#### Repositories that need to be changed
* sonic-buildimage
* sonic-swss-common
* sonic-swss
* sonic-utilities
* sonic-gnmi
* sonic-mgmt

### SAI API
No new SAI API is being added.

### Configuration and management
#### CLI
CLI (queuestat.py) aggregates the VOQ stats for a VOQ across ASICS and present a consolidated view. No new CLI command is being introduced for this rather the following CLI command is leveraged to provide this output on an SSI.

$ show VOQ counters [interface] --voq
```
admin@cmp217:~$ show queue counters "cmp217-5|asic0|Ethernet24" --voq
Port Voq Counter/pkts Counter/bytes Drop/pkts Drop/bytes Credit-WD-Del/pkts
------------------------- ----- -------------- --------------- ----------- ------------ --------------------
cmp217-5|asic0|Ethernet24 VOQ0 54 2700 0 0 0

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

What are the other filters we can apply for this show command?. Can we filter the output for a Line card or asic in Linecard?

Copy link
Author

@vivekverma-arista vivekverma-arista Sep 12, 2024

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

No other filter can be applied as of now. We can only aggregate counters as per system port.

cmp217-5|asic0|Ethernet24 VOQ1 51 2550 0 0 0
cmp217-5|asic0|Ethernet24 VOQ2 4 200 0 0 0
cmp217-5|asic0|Ethernet24 VOQ3 45 2250 0 0 0
cmp217-5|asic0|Ethernet24 VOQ4 7 350 0 0 0
cmp217-5|asic0|Ethernet24 VOQ5 16 800 0 0 0
cmp217-5|asic0|Ethernet24 VOQ6 23 1150 0 0 0
cmp217-5|asic0|Ethernet24 VOQ7 47 13792 0 0 0
```

### Testing Requirements/Design
#### System Test cases
Send traffic across different ASICs and ensure aggregate counters are correctly displayed.
Binary file added doc/voq/images/voq_cli.png
Loading
Sorry, something went wrong. Reload?
Sorry, we cannot display this file.
Sorry, this file is invalid so it cannot be displayed.
Binary file added doc/voq/images/voq_seq_diagram.png
Loading
Sorry, something went wrong. Reload?
Sorry, we cannot display this file.
Sorry, this file is invalid so it cannot be displayed.