Add tips for contributing, update State article

[netnef]

For the State article, I made these changes:

• Convert the layout to a table (lmk if you don't like it)
• Update the info to match the latest progress
• Add links/issues to some features for reference

Preview: https://netnef.github.io/wiki/state/

[sharpenedblade]

There is work in progress support for custom graphics on the Touch Bar.

Its not really WIP anymore, it should just say that its supported

Trackpad 🟡 Partially working

It should be marked as working, but leave the note there. Same with audio.

[AdityaGarg8]

Wi-Fi and Bluetooth drivers are upstreamed. Also, Bluetooth is partially working for BCM4377 devices. On other devices too, it's not very stable.

[AdityaGarg8]

See latest comment

[AdityaGarg8]

I added a commit in your pr so that there is no clash.

[Redecorating]

having a table here is much better

[netnef]

I updated the State article to address all of the comments here. I also added "Thunderbolt" to the features list.

Preview: https://netnef.github.io/wiki/state/

There's one last thing I wanted to ask about:

Some models have deadzones on the edges of their trackpads where swipes along the trackpad that start in these deadzones will not be registered.

Is this still an issue? Is there a list of affected models anywhere?

[AdityaGarg8]

I updated the State article to address all of the comments here. I also added "Thunderbolt" to the features list.

Preview: https://netnef.github.io/wiki/state/

There's one last thing I wanted to ask about:

Some models have deadzones on the edges of their trackpads where swipes along the trackpad that start in these deadzones will not be registered.

Is this still an issue? Is there a list of affected models anywhere?

Tbh not enough feedback there by the users. Today only mbp 16,2 got fixed.

[netnef]

Ok, then we can leave the notice there I guess. But I would still leave the status as "working" because for most models it works as well as it possibly can (using libinput, at least). We should probably also add details about how to use the Synaptics driver (with a disclaimer that it's unsupported and requires using deprecated X11 instead of Wayland). smileBeda provided instructions in the Discord for this. We can maybe paste those into a gist or wiki article.

[AdityaGarg8]

The gist is already in the wiki, you can put working as well

[AdityaGarg8]

Also, fix the lint errors please

[netnef]

The gist is already in the wiki, you can put working as well

Do you have a link to that so I can include it here?

[AdityaGarg8]

https://wiki.t2linux.org/#guides-and-similar

I don't think we need to put it here though. But status as working should be put.

[netnef]

The reason I think we should reference it here is because of the note we have added to it:

Works, but isn't as great as on macOS

On the other wiki page you linked, it says that you can obtain this:

Implement macOS-like Keyboard and trackpad experience

I don't think adding a casual mention to it would hurt. Something like this:

Works, but isn't as great as on macOS (no force touch or palm rejection). Some models have deadzones on the edges of their trackpads where swipes along the trackpad that start in these deadzones will not be registered. Using Synaptics + X11 as per this guide could make it feel more like macOS, but comes at the cost of using a legacy display server (X11) instead of Wayland, potentially exposing other issues, like blurry display scaling.

Let me know what you think.

[AdityaGarg8]

The reason I think we should reference it here is because of the note we have added to it:

Works, but isn't as great as on macOS

On the other wiki page you linked, it says that you can obtain this:

Implement macOS-like Keyboard and trackpad experience

I don't think adding a casual mention to it would hurt. Something like this:

Works, but isn't as great as on macOS (no force touch or palm rejection). Some models have deadzones on the edges of their trackpads where swipes along the trackpad that start in these deadzones will not be registered. Using Synaptics + X11 as per this guide could make it feel more like macOS, but comes at the cost of using a legacy display server (X11) instead of Wayland, potentially exposing other issues, like blurry display scaling.

Let me know what you think.

I leave this to other maintainers @Redecorating @sharpenedblade

[sharpenedblade]

https://gist.github.com/smileBeda/f0452f0d7f1f6d8aa772603411f7876f

This config doesnt seem to be doing anything that cant be done with libinput, we should try to get it working on wayland before puting this on the wiki (once its on the wiki people are going to use it and we "have" to support them). touchpad preasure and palm rejection is supported, we just need to set the quirks, the touchpad edge bug is fixed with this commit.

We can merge this now and change it later, or wait for proper libinput support. @Redecorating

[AdityaGarg8]

Let's merge this after addressing all this?

[netnef]

https://gist.github.com/smileBeda/f0452f0d7f1f6d8aa772603411f7876f

This config doesnt seem to be doing anything that cant be done with libinput, we should try to get it working on wayland before puting this on the wiki (once its on the wiki people are going to use it and we "have" to support them). touchpad preasure and palm rejection is supported, we just need to set the quirks, the touchpad edge bug is fixed with this commit.

We can merge this now and change it later, or wait for proper libinput support. @Redecorating

The config is already on the wiki: https://wiki.t2linux.org/#guides-and-similar

Perhaps we should clarify that it's unsupported by the t2linux maintainers there.

[netnef]

I updated two pages to address concerns from @sharpenedblade. Let me know what you think.

• https://netnef.github.io/wiki/#guides-and-similar
• https://netnef.github.io/wiki/state/

[sharpenedblade]

The deadzone problem was fixed a few days ago, we can merge once thats removed from the touchpad section

[netnef]

I removed the deadzones remark. @AdityaGarg8 are we good to merge?

[AdityaGarg8]

Looks like we are

[netnef]

👍 Thank you all for the help. Glad we got these pages updated. Long overdue.