Collaborator Guidelines

This guide is for collaborators. These special people have write access to mxcl’s repository and help merge the contributions of others. You may find what is written here interesting, but it’s definitely not a beginner’s guide.

Maybe you were looking for the Formula Cookbook?

Quick Checklist

This is all that really matters:

• Ensure the name is correct. This cannot be changed later, so it must be right the first time!
• Add aliases
• Ensure it is not a dupe of anything that comes with OS X
• Ensure it is not a dupe of anything that can be installed with gem, cpan or pip.
• Ensure the name is not in Ruby’s stdlib (Try Formula.factory('readline') in the brew irb shell)
• Ensure that any dependencies are accurate

You should test the build process. But you’re really pressed for time, just get it in there and let someone else test the build.

Checking deps is important, because they will probably stick around forever. Nobody really checks if they are necessary or not. Use the :optional and :recommended modifiers as appropriate.

Depend on as little stuff as possible. Avoid X11 functionality unless it is required. For example, we build Wireshark, but not the monolithic GUI. If users want that, they should just grab the DMG that Wireshark themselves provide.

Homebrew is about UNIX software. Stuff that builds to an .app should be accepted frugally. That is, rarely.

Naming

The name is the strictest item, because we can’t change it afterwards.

Choose a name that’s the colloquial (most common) name for the project. For example, we chose objective-caml, but we should have chosen ocaml. Choose what people say to each other when talking about the project.

Add other names as aliases with the aka class function. Ensure the name referenced on the homepage is one of these, as it may be different and have underscores and hyphens and so on.

We don’t allow versions in formula names (e.g. bash4.rb). This is sometimes frustrating, but we’re trying to solve this properly. (python3.rb is the only exception, because it’s basically a “new” language and installs no conflicting executables.)

For now, if someone submits a formula like this, we’ll leave them in their own tree.

Merging, rebasing, cherry-picking

Merging is mainly useful when new work is being done. Feel free to rebase or cherry-pick contributions rather than fill our tree up with noisy merge commits.

Don’t rebase until you finally push. Once pushed, you can’t rebase : you’re a collaborator now!

Cherry-picking changes the date of the commit, which kind of sucks.

Don’t merge unclean branches. So if someone is still learning git their branch is filled with nonsensical merges, then rebase and squash the commits. Our main branch history should be useful to other people, not confusing.

Testing

We need to at least check it builds.

In order to test the formula specifies its dependencies properly try to have as little installed into /usr/local as possible. Ideally, we’d create some kind of brew sandbox…

Check the formula builds. Check on 10.5 and 10.6 if possible. If it won’t build, comment on the issue.

Verify the formula works if possible. If you can’t tell—for example, if it’s a library—trust the original contributor, it worked for them, so chances are it is fine. If you aren’t an expert in the tool in question, you can’t really gauge if the formula installed the program correctly. At some point an expert will come along, cry blue murder that it doesn’t work, and fix it. This is how open source works.

If the formula uses a repository, then the url parameter should have a tag or revision. url s have versions and are stable (not yet implemented!).

Testing in /usr/local and somewhere else

If not completely annoying, test in both /usr/local and somewhere else. Preferably on different machines to ensure the /usr/local install doesn’t effect the other one.

The reason for this is some build systems suck, and fail if deps aren’t installed in /usr/local, even though Homebrew goes to some lengths to try to make this work.

Common “Gotchas”

1. Ensure you have set your username and email address properly
2. Sign off cherry-picks if you amended them (GitX can do this, otherwise there is a command line flag for it)
3. If the commit fixes a bug, use “Fixes #104” syntax to close the bug report and link to the commit

Build “Gotchas”

Often parallel builds work with 2-core systems, but fail on 4-core systems.

Dupes

The main branch avoids dupes as much as possible. The exception is libraries that OS X provides but have bugs, and the bugs are fixed in a newer version. Or libraries that OS X provides, but they are too old for some other formula.

Still determine if it possible to avoid the dupe. Be thorough. Duped libs and tools cause bugs that are tricky to solve. Once the formula is pulled, we can’t go back on that willy-nilly.

If it dupes anything ask mxcl first. Some dupes are okay, some can cause subtle issues we don’t want to have to deal with in the future.

Dupes we have allowed:

• libxml <— OS X version is old and buggy
• libpng <— Ditto

Add comments!

It may be enough to refer to an issue ticket, but make sure changes that if you came to them unaware of the surrounding issues would make sense to you. Many times on other projects I’ve seen code removed because the new guy didn’t know why it was there. Regressions suck.

Don’t allow bloated diffs

Amend a cherry-pick to remove commits that are only changes in whitespace. They are not acceptable because our history is important and git blame should be useful.

Whitespace corrections (to ruby standard etc.) are allowed (in fact this is a good opportunity to do it) provided the line itself has some kind of modification that is not whitespace in it. But be careful about making changes to inline patches—make sure they still apply.

This rule is why the case statement in the brew tool is a mess. We’ll fix such things up for v2.

Working with the network

The network is huge, you can get an idea for that by doing:

gem install drnic-github
cd `brew --prefix`
gh network fetch

The github gem helps. I wouldn’t fetch the whole network into your actual Homebrew that you use though.

Other useful github gem commands include fetch (makes a branch too) and fetch_all (just allows you to view the remote branches with gitx/gitk --all).

Moving formulae from one tap to another

And preserving the history. I made a [gist](https://gist.github.com/samueljohn/5280700) about this, based on Jack’s initial version.